Thank you Faizaan sahab. It was such a pleasure to listen with great zeal anf the renewed interest till end on this important burning topic. God bless you
I would love to see a discussion on this topic between Shri Arif Mohammad Khan and Professor Faizan Mustafa. If moderated by Ravish Kumar, I am sure, it will be a very high-level intellectual discussion which will inform us common folks so much.
With your due respect sir, theology isn't based on blind belief,as you said. Our existence itself is a poof of a Creator. I highly appreciate your other insights on contemporary laws.
Faizan Sahib is smart , knowledgeable , articulate , entertaining and somewhat pompous. All Good. Now... 1. 96 minutes and FM did not say He had opposed TTT on many many occasions past 30 years. Did he ever file a PIL ? Why not ? 2. FM never suggests his recommendation on a path forward on TTT. ( Gutless ) 3. Faizan Sahib skirts Uniform Civil Law and his opinion on UCL. 4. Agreed , Society mindset will take several generations to change. Dahej is Down. Child marriage is down Sati is down in 20 years, it is likely TTT will also be down... If in Year 2040 , It is clear TTT criminalization has produced Great suffering , no real benefits , Law on Criminal Punishment for TTT can be changed. 5. Faizal sahib... make a recommendation. Just dont toss everything to Uleema. What things progressive has Uleema done in past 100 years ...zilch. 6. Nikah Halala is in the courts ? Your opinion ? तर्क छोड़िये ....कुछ तो बोलिये If AMU throws you out .... so be it.
Mr. String(dore).. You have no argument but even you still parroting... Why? He is Law teacher not an activist... And he just a law teacher not an islamic scholar... If you face any Islamic scholar in live debate when you won't find any shelter to hide... You will have no argument.... If you want to test then debate with me on any topic...
Faizan Saheb, Very eloquent lecture. Legalities apart, the dichotomy between Sharia and constitution are too many. If the Muslim population has to progress, it should be the duty of eminent and learned men like you to impress upon the population to allow discussions and bring in the reforms. The triple talaq is banned in many progressive Muslim countries. And any divorce has to be agreed between the partners only in the court of law. You have talked about the better examples of Muslims laws prevalent in Medical period, such as Slave Girls which is in very poor taste. Proposing examples of Medieval versions of Sharia will never allow the Muslim population to come out of ignorance and allow them to be stuck in the ideas propagated by the clerics. You give examples of western jurisprudence and legal greats but still talk about the sharia or muslim personal law. These two things are totally contradictory and only way to progress is to follow a clear cut common civil law without any ifs and buts. Otherwise let there be imposition of a harshest sharia law on all Muslims without any exception. Simple fact is that every citizen of the country has to follow one law and that too passed by the parliament. There should be no other escape. A common civil law which allows for compensation to wives and children and protects then against all kind of domestic violence, allows honourable settlement and divorce is always welcome. But this should be done not by a Kazi, but only front of a Judge or a registrar. It is time that people like find courage and come in forefront to create an atmosphere of change and progress in the Muslim society which is still shackled in medieval ages.
Criminalization is a necessity even though it is not the full solution. All types of laws dealing with violence need to be criminalized. Dowry related violence was criminalized. You are conveniently talking that it is not a solution but I am saying - it is a necessity. The social solution of course is the social awareness & enlightenment but the legal solution is a criminalized law. Having both is good for the society. People like you can spread social awareness and the criminalized triple talaq law will ensure the end of this evil practice. The Indian justice has a book in one hand (teachings) and a whip in another hand (punishment). You need both salt (teachings) and pepper (punishment) to make a good cuisine.
Dr. Faizan Mustafa SB, Triple Talaq bill is the only achievement of India after independence. It is a great bill, punishment should be increased like 10-15 years because you don't know that ass holes get married with full festival mood and try divorce on WhatsApp.
Faizan Mustafa Forget that Article 13(3) definition of law is not exclusive but inclusive hence many other things may fall in this definition which is law of the land this is also clear by 13 (3). Moreover like any other fanatic Muslim, he is putting arguments against making Tripple talaq crime. and for this, he puts an argument that raises questions on the existence of law itself according to him law doesn't bring change in society.
thanx prof sab mujhe lagta hai islam mein her problem ka solution hai unke triple talaq bill ke pass hone ke bawajood koi aisa rasta nikaliye jis se hamein shariyat ke against na jana pade allah helps you insha Allah
Abrar...you did a great job. but do you really need other's certificate on your great work... ..great work is always great work.I hope a lots of men will be inspired by your work.
Muslim Personel Law is law though it is uncodified because it has Divine Authority. The whole universe is governed by divine law. All the schools of Islamic Thought not independent they are bound to follow the Quranic Law / principles. Islam has both under its fold the criminal law & civil law.
My name is Sk Ezaz Ahmed, I'm a CA ipcc student sir I respect you also your knowledge but sir I'm not Agree with you some speech like that "blind believer" , I'm and also we are(Muslim) true believer ,so pls watch islam and Science lecture by Dr.zakir Naik. It's a man who most knowledgeable person about Islam. Most few people are this type of person in the world, So I respect you and also your lecture. (Allah) God bless you thx you.
Janab Faizan sahab you have talked excellently but recently the courts delivering judgements are totally incontrast with your views and facts of the laws. Be it the case of Triple Talaq or of awarding of death punishments to Yakub Memon in the case of owning a vehicle in his name in the blast case while Pragya Thakur and others in same type of offences registered against them are being allowed to got Scott free, Which law is governing here and what is status of its implementation.
faizan mustafa sir why are you saying that the peoples should do the law beacouse we need a lot of docter and engineer that is the health system in india is poor
Thank you Faizaan sahab. It was such a pleasure to listen with great zeal anf the renewed interest till end on this important burning topic.
God bless you
Sir thank you soo much...apke is video ko dekh ke mene apne Viva me bohot acha perform kiya.... thank soo soo much sir
If there is Faizan Mustafa, I won't sleep with my wife, rather I would like to prefer myself to listen him mindfully and carefully
Extremely thoughtful to faizan Mustafa sir for your efforts towards nation,
I would love to see a discussion on this topic between Shri Arif Mohammad Khan and Professor Faizan Mustafa. If moderated by Ravish Kumar, I am sure, it will be a very high-level intellectual discussion which will inform us common folks so much.
We must include Taarik Fateh in this
With your due respect sir, theology isn't based on blind belief,as you said. Our existence itself is a poof of a Creator. I highly appreciate your other insights on contemporary laws.
Such a wonderful gentleman...god bless you sir amidst good health happiness and success forever
What a lecture professor Mustapha was my lecturer at AMU
Love to hear you sir always..
th-cam.com/video/r4-ZF1SdzNU/w-d-xo.html
Dekho pura vdo
lot of information and knowledge it has....
Faizan Sahib is smart , knowledgeable , articulate , entertaining and somewhat pompous.
All Good.
Now...
1. 96 minutes and FM did not say He had opposed TTT on many many occasions past 30 years.
Did he ever file a PIL ? Why not ?
2. FM never suggests his recommendation on a path forward on TTT. ( Gutless )
3. Faizan Sahib skirts Uniform Civil Law and his opinion on UCL.
4. Agreed , Society mindset will take several generations to change.
Dahej is Down.
Child marriage is down
Sati is down
in 20 years, it is likely TTT will also be down...
If in Year 2040 , It is clear TTT criminalization has produced Great suffering , no real benefits ,
Law on Criminal Punishment for TTT can be changed.
5. Faizal sahib... make a recommendation. Just dont toss everything to Uleema. What
things progressive has Uleema done in past 100 years ...zilch.
6. Nikah Halala is in the courts ? Your opinion ?
तर्क छोड़िये ....कुछ तो बोलिये
If AMU throws you out .... so be it.
Mr. String(dore)..
You have no argument but even you still parroting... Why?
He is Law teacher not an activist...
And he just a law teacher not an islamic scholar...
If you face any Islamic scholar in live debate when you won't find any shelter to hide...
You will have no argument....
If you want to test then debate with me on any topic...
@Eric sam wow... And it will change his opinion....
What an idiocy.. 😂😂
You got the crux of speech. 😎
A great legal mind indeed well done prof
many a time the greatest challenge is what is in book and what is in practice.
Faizan Saheb, Very eloquent lecture. Legalities apart, the dichotomy between Sharia and constitution are too many. If the Muslim population has to progress, it should be the duty of eminent and learned men like you to impress upon the population to allow discussions and bring in the reforms. The triple talaq is banned in many progressive Muslim countries. And any divorce has to be agreed between the partners only in the court of law.
You have talked about the better examples of Muslims laws prevalent in Medical period, such as Slave Girls which is in very poor taste. Proposing examples of Medieval versions of Sharia will never allow the Muslim population to come out of ignorance and allow them to be stuck in the ideas propagated by the clerics. You give examples of western jurisprudence and legal greats but still talk about the sharia or muslim personal law. These two things are totally contradictory and only way to progress is to follow a clear cut common civil law without any ifs and buts. Otherwise let there be imposition of a harshest sharia law on all Muslims without any exception.
Simple fact is that every citizen of the country has to follow one law and that too passed by the parliament. There should be no other escape. A common civil law which allows for compensation to wives and children and protects then against all kind of domestic violence, allows honourable settlement and divorce is always welcome. But this should be done not by a Kazi, but only front of a Judge or a registrar. It is time that people like find courage and come in forefront to create an atmosphere of change and progress in the Muslim society which is still shackled in medieval ages.
Prof Mustafa sir is a out standing VC
th-cam.com/video/r4-ZF1SdzNU/w-d-xo.html
Jra dekho
Ji. 😀Super video👍 🌹
Ji. 🌹Faizan Mustafa. Ji. Shukriya. 👍🇮🇳
Brilliant lecture by Prof. Faizan Mustafa
Wonderful Speech... ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Every Indian should watch this ..
Excellent class!
really its a great lecture
Enlightening
Criminalization is a necessity even though it is not the full solution. All types of laws dealing with violence need to be criminalized. Dowry related violence was criminalized. You are conveniently talking that it is not a solution but I am saying - it is a necessity. The social solution of course is the social awareness & enlightenment but the legal solution is a criminalized law. Having both is good for the society. People like you can spread social awareness and the criminalized triple talaq law will ensure the end of this evil practice.
The Indian justice has a book in one hand (teachings) and a whip in another hand (punishment). You need both salt (teachings) and pepper (punishment) to make a good cuisine.
सर सैयद साब का भारत की आजादी
मै देश को पहला तोहफा दीया
सर सैयद का ऐक सपना जो आजतक
दैश का बचा वलड पे नामना कमाताहै
What a speech... I like it.. thank you sir
That reference to Kurian Joseph's remark in Shayara Bano Judgment was the highlight of the whole lecture
th-cam.com/video/pqZVbGRVejE/w-d-xo.html
you get my point
Hanfi law draws jurisdiction from Quran and Sunnah.
Same goes with other Mazhab(Shafi,Malik ,Hanbali).
Faijan bhai, it is Alig, s culture never say no
Great 👍👍👍
Very informative
Dr. Faizan Mustafa SB, Triple Talaq bill is the only achievement of India after independence. It is a great bill, punishment should be increased like 10-15 years because you don't know that ass holes get married with full festival mood and try divorce on WhatsApp.
Great
Interesting watch
th-cam.com/video/r4-ZF1SdzNU/w-d-xo.html
Dekho ab
Great speaker
th-cam.com/video/r4-ZF1SdzNU/w-d-xo.html
Dekho pura vdo
In bengal no one hue and cry ,hindu to muslim tribal to hindu and muslim ,vice-versa. Example ali of lucknow ,naidu andhra
Excellent
Hazrat MD and Macron me keya mil hai.
Faizan Mustafa Forget that Article 13(3) definition of law is not exclusive but inclusive hence many other things may fall in this definition which is law of the land this is also clear by 13 (3). Moreover like any other fanatic Muslim, he is putting arguments against making Tripple talaq crime. and for this, he puts an argument that raises questions on the existence of law itself according to him law doesn't bring change in society.
शानदार
great job
thanx prof sab mujhe lagta hai islam mein her problem ka solution hai unke triple talaq bill ke pass hone ke bawajood koi aisa rasta nikaliye jis se hamein shariyat ke against na jana pade allah helps you insha Allah
اسلام پے مضبوطی سے قائم رہے الگ راستہ تلاش کرنے سے کچھ نہیں ہونے والا الگ راستہ تلاش کرنے سے ایمان ڈگمگاتا ہے
Shabnum Parveen मैंने ऐक मरीज लड़की से शादी की आज ठीक है कोई खातुन नहीं कहती आदमी अच्छे है ।
Please do justify SHAH BANO CASE on the ground of your personal law...
Abrar...you did a great job. but do you really need other's certificate on your great work... ..great work is always great work.I hope a lots of men will be inspired by your work.
Good 👌
Sir is sooo innocent......
Muslim Personel Law is law though it is uncodified because it has Divine Authority. The whole universe is governed by divine law. All the schools of Islamic Thought not independent they are bound to follow the Quranic Law / principles. Islam has both under its fold the criminal law & civil law.
My name is Sk Ezaz Ahmed, I'm a CA ipcc student sir I respect you also your knowledge but sir I'm not Agree with you some speech like that "blind believer" , I'm and also we are(Muslim) true believer ,so pls watch islam and Science lecture by Dr.zakir Naik. It's a man who most knowledgeable person about Islam. Most few people are this type of person in the world, So I respect you and also your lecture. (Allah) God bless you thx you.
Great lectures sir
You cannot delete your child or children on triple talaq. Constitional right
Legend
Faizanji namaste namaste namaste
Can so called Modren law .
End suffering of human .
No
Only law made by creater can solve our problem.
Then try to implement it but except making derogatory points,you won't do a shit about it.
😢😢❤❤❤❤✊✊
sir you are awesome
Ambedkar by virtue encouraged for inter caste marriage.
Camaraderie vs comrade , BJP VS CPIM
Bhaaii i so want to get into nalsar 😭😭😭
i would love to see the 'research' which says hindus are more bigamous than muslims. if anyone could help me, it would be highly appreciative.
Bheed Mein chor hi Chor Chor Chilla kar nikal jata hai
@@jagdishgirigoswami9819 😂😂🤣🤣 ye nhi sudhrenge
Janab Faizan sahab you have talked excellently but recently the courts delivering judgements are totally incontrast with your views and facts of the laws. Be it the case of Triple Talaq or of awarding of death punishments to Yakub Memon in the case of owning a vehicle in his name in the blast case while Pragya Thakur and others in same type of offences registered against them are being allowed to got Scott free, Which law is governing here and what is status of its implementation.
Pragya Thakur may have sold that motor cycle years before incident. Inconvenient facts can cloud judgement jab " dil men virodh hai ".
@@ganeshdore hahha
पर jabalpur में IPC देख कर करते हैं
Liquar policy vs keriwal
वीडियो बीच में कटा है
26:30
1:25:08
Md.Aijaz Akhtar
me apko rajya sabha me dekhna chahta hu faizan sahab
faizan mustafa sir why are you saying that the peoples should do the law beacouse we need a lot of docter and engineer that is the health system in india is poor
Because the law decides who will be eligible to live... Who will have right to get treated by doctor...
O to na use liye keya keya badya yantra laya..almost 15.
what about kashmir?
what about the muslim dress code?
بہت خوب فیضان سر
Markhande Katju Law Sir
CAA NRC NPR
E chhote mote nahi hai ,real.
madrasa chap log khooch sikho isse!! be intellectual not parrot, and help india to make great.
.... Muslim personal law... Should bring real shariat which is divine
🤣🤣🤣🤣 jao Pakistan me mile ga jo chahiye
@@CD-123 sorry Pakistan main bi nahi hai I am Pakistani so don’t come and it will be waste of time
Vd
UR misleading?
Pakistan ki rupaiya India se print hota tha. Ab to goandagol.
Magrib ki taraf gao gae.
Too dub gao gae.
Illogical law
th-cam.com/video/r4-ZF1SdzNU/w-d-xo.html
Ye vdo dekho aakhe khulegi
Rss ka bhaqat hai bow 😂😂😂 in ur link
Sariyat me dakhal na do madi ji
*Shariyat
Ghaznabi betha
YOUR CONSTITUTION IS ABOVE SHAR'IA, ABOVE GOD???
1:18:00