I didn't record I was just going through some stuff on my computer, found this, and thought some might be interested. Even tho there are like 10 other posts of it already.
Idina Menzel is a queen, 100% my favorite Broadway Actress, I've only seen/heard one other person (Donna Vivino) do Elphaba better than her...Maureen however? No one even comes close to Idina! just my opinion 🤗🤗❤️
LV ANIMATIONS Idina was in Aida a few years before Wicked, and this was the original costume worn by Sherie René Scott as well. Has nothing to do with Wicked.
Sorry, I just don't see Idina's appeal. I think she's a decent performer in certain roles, but she just doesn't do it for me here. When I was younger, I was a big fan mainly due to her work in Rent and Wicked. But there's not a single role she's played that someone else hasn't done much better, and that includes Maureen and Elphaba. Don't get me wrong, I'm glad she's been so successful, I just don't quite understand it.
Arlo I think it’s because of her presence and how she really puts herself into the role and makes it something so unique. I do think that some people have done better than her but that’s just personal preference. But no matter what she always stands out in the role🙂
her best role is Kate from Andrew lippa's wild party. i agree with what you said about the fact that someone always plays her roles better. thats not the case in that show. look up "idina menzel life of the party"
I think it's because she has an appeal that's interesting... Like it's that whole 'will she fail' kinda thing.. Like you watch just to see how she'll do. When she's great... She's magic and when she's not it's really not.
Idina is the perfect example of someone who just has that "it" factor. Yes, there are others who may be able to technically sing better, and others who may make stronger acting choices, but there's just something about Idina. When she's on stage, you can't take your eyes off of her. That's what makes a star.
아이다는 흑인배우들, 암네리스는 백인 배우들이 해왔죠. 한국에서처럼 같은 인종만 사는 나라에서 하는 공연이 아니니, 보통 일반적으로 초연에서 정해진 식으로 이어지는 경우가 대다수고요. 정선아씨가 잘한 건 동의하나, 브웨 암네리스는 워낙 세계적인 배우들이 했으니, 안보시고 함부로 누가 탑이네 아니네 하실 말씀은 아닐 듯.
Orsy Godri No I don't have the link to this. Just type Aida Broadway full musical show in here (youtube). The results will pop up Aida OBC that's the original Broadway cast not with Idina Menzel. But there's another one with full show with Idina Menzel the youtube user is Havana Kaba, but the person uploaded in parts.
Everything is off, there´s even a missing girl at the runway at 4:39. The one in red has to come back to replace her. And Idina is horrible in this. If I had paid for this ticket I would have been really pissed.
@Xavier D Allen loves Toiley and Loofah Why do you feel the need to comment how much you dislike her all over this comment section, you’re being really rude
![อาจารย์ยอด : ลุงแว่วเล่าเรื่องผี [ผี]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Fd2Qsy4dqpM/mqdefault.jpg)
lol Idina Menzel replaced Sherie Rene Scott in Aida and Sherie replaced Idina in Rent. Loving the coincidence.
Sherrie was never in Rent
elphbwckd *Sherie quite literally replaced Idina in Rent on Broadway
elphbwckd th-cam.com/video/-zydo9iknpQ/w-d-xo.html
elphbwckd th-cam.com/video/No8YMv3R214/w-d-xo.html
Ha! Ha! Good point. Kinda thot I wish I had first. In its' own way Broadway is a small town.
Idina's blue dress is foreshadowing her future role as Elsa.
Idina's pointy hat is foreshadowing her future role as Elphaba.
That Already Happened..
@@theaveryandnorashow1295 no...this was 2001 (right after 9/11)
As expected of Idina, she dominates the role. This is why Idina is my idol. Her role as Elphaba from Wicked is why I got into musicals.
Same. she got me into theatre
You don't hear she's out of tune many many times?
Idina's first step into the Magical World of Disney!!!! AIDA and HERCULES: THE SERIES in 1 whole year before the ENCHANTED and FROZEN film series.
i completely forgot she was in Aida. One of my all time favorite broadway shows
No idea she was in Aida and I was pleasantly surprised!
she was in Aida?!?! what!!?
Literally just had the same reaction.
Fletcher - Raymond same lol! It's GREAT!
Yes it’s true
I had no idea either hahah feels so random buuut I love it!
Idina Menzel is a queen, 100% my favorite Broadway Actress, I've only seen/heard one other person (Donna Vivino) do Elphaba better than her...Maureen however? No one even comes close to Idina! just my opinion 🤗🤗❤️
IMO, I wish they casted Shoshana Bean as Amneris. That would've been AMAZING.
Shoshana Bean though!
Completely and utterly agree! Donna and Idina are the best Elphabas for suuuuuure!! None of the others hit the spot for me
Pointy hat? DEFYING GRAVITY IN 2001
Edit: That dress makes Idina look even 100% attractive
QUEEN!
queen of swords
wow idina killin it here
Idina Menzel has a very unique singing voice I always thought which I like
Wow, her voice really cuts through all the background, and she gets the comedy of this number. Outstanding.
OMG I had no idea she was on aida 😮 OMG!
왜 우리나라 사람들은 외국영상까지 들어와서 비교질을 해대냐 진짜..
쪽팔린다
대공감이요ㅋㅋㅋ쪽팔려 죽겠음...
ㅇㅈ
Jacob Kemezys your right
I love Idina but this role didn't do anything for her. Sherie Scott was made for this role..
Taste is subjective. I much prefer Idina to Sherie.
I love how her dress transformation was a nod to her role in wicked!
LV ANIMATIONS Idina was in Aida a few years before Wicked, and this was the original costume worn by Sherie René Scott as well. Has nothing to do with Wicked.
Also as Elsa through the pale blue dress, hehe
No lol
It was during her run in AIDA she got the WICKED audition, the F BOMB incident, and boom..... she got Elphaba!!!
All I see and hear is Elsa
이분 렛잇고 부른분입니다….
전세계사람들 정선아 암네리스 못본사람 없게해주세요 (쩌렁쩌렁)
외국은 몬가 그냥 극을 보러가는 것 같고 우리나라는 배우에 더 집중하는 거 같은 느낌. 우리나라사람이 확실히 완벽주의성향이 강한듯
자기자신에게도 남에게도
그래서 솔직히 이 넘버도 우리나라 배우가 훨 잘함
ㅇㄱㄹㅇ이다 진짜 이게 답이고 이게 맞지,,, 저쪽이 언더스터디나 스윙 배우들이 더 활약할 수 있는 환경이 괜히 조성이 되는게 아님,,, 영상 속 이디나도 암네 언더였고... 괜히 씁쓸해지는 느낌 분명 둘 다 장단점이 있겠지만...
buried in her role character
huh?
Sorry, I just don't see Idina's appeal. I think she's a decent performer in certain roles, but she just doesn't do it for me here. When I was younger, I was a big fan mainly due to her work in Rent and Wicked. But there's not a single role she's played that someone else hasn't done much better, and that includes Maureen and Elphaba. Don't get me wrong, I'm glad she's been so successful, I just don't quite understand it.
Arlo
I think it’s because of her presence and how she really puts herself into the role and makes it something so unique. I do think that some people have done better than her but that’s just personal preference. But no matter what she always stands out in the role🙂
her best role is Kate from Andrew lippa's wild party. i agree with what you said about the fact that someone always plays her roles better. thats not the case in that show. look up "idina menzel life of the party"
I think it's because she has an appeal that's interesting... Like it's that whole 'will she fail' kinda thing.. Like you watch just to see how she'll do. When she's great... She's magic and when she's not it's really not.
Idina is the perfect example of someone who just has that "it" factor. Yes, there are others who may be able to technically sing better, and others who may make stronger acting choices, but there's just something about Idina. When she's on stage, you can't take your eyes off of her. That's what makes a star.
That might be why she only did this role for about 4 months or so. Considering that this show was on for 4 1/2 yrs, that's pretty short.
love her but this is a far cry from SRS ! 4 of out 10 ...
that’s because she’s not Sherie.
아이다 역할하지 차라리 암네리스 안어울리는 데.. 정암네는 전세계탑이네...
아이다는 흑인배우들, 암네리스는 백인 배우들이 해왔죠. 한국에서처럼 같은 인종만 사는 나라에서 하는 공연이 아니니, 보통 일반적으로 초연에서 정해진 식으로 이어지는 경우가 대다수고요. 정선아씨가 잘한 건 동의하나, 브웨 암네리스는 워낙 세계적인 배우들이 했으니, 안보시고 함부로 누가 탑이네 아니네 하실 말씀은 아닐 듯.
CRI Innn 그리고 이디나는 암네리스 언더스터디였죠. 이때 암네리스에 정식으로 이름을 걸고 연기했던 배우가 누구인지는 모르겠네요
where is this from?
This from Disney on Broadway musical called Aida. There is a full musical on youtube with her in it. If you're interested.
@@entertainmentstarz1 Hello. Do you have the link?
Orsy Godri No I don't have the link to this. Just type Aida Broadway full musical show in here (youtube). The results will pop up Aida OBC that's the original Broadway cast not with Idina Menzel. But there's another one with full show with Idina Menzel the youtube user is Havana Kaba, but the person uploaded in parts.
She's screaming too much
James Netusil She always does.
It’s called belting 😂😂😂
not really. To belt (healthily, at least) you must develop a technique Idina unfortunately didn’t... Screaming is just screaming.
poor Idina..😭
@@jihoyeom3939 Idina needs some vocal improvement, just saying.
This looks so half-assed compared to SRS
Well, no one's perfect.
She really struggles with the high notes
Why doesn't she have a blonde wig on?
For Amneris? I don’t know why they ever did that in the first place…
정선아가 훨잘함;;; 이거 완전 애드립 대잔치;;;
비교 ㄴㄴ
That was awkward
이디나는 참 실력의 굴곡이 심하네..
she has awful technique and can't hold a candle to SRS
Facts!!!
Everything is off, there´s even a missing girl at the runway at 4:39. The one in red has to come back to replace her. And Idina is horrible in this. If I had paid for this ticket I would have been really pissed.
Yes, something went wrong, and like real professionals they improv'd to keep the number going.
정선아 압승
I dont like her voice.
@Xavier D Allen loves Toiley and Loofah Why do you feel the need to comment how much you dislike her all over this comment section, you’re being really rude
She sounded terrible here
Terrible