ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 31 พ.ค. 2016
- On Questionable, it's not about having the most popular answer: it's about changing the most minds. Originally broadcast live!
Playing were:
JAY FOREMAN: jayforeman.co.uk - / jayforeman
SARAH BREESE: sarahbreese.com - / sarahbreese
WILL SEAWARD: / willseaward
I'm at tomscott.com
on Twitter at / tomscott
on Facebook at / tomscott
and on Instagram as @tomscottgo
Thanks to:
All the team at TH-cam Space London for all their production support: they're the reason this looks so good!
Grant Stevens, our sound engineer
Our LIVE STUDIO AUDIENCE who were wonderful
Our CHAT MODERATORS who kept things relatively clean
And everyone who voted, commented, and watched the live broadcast!
![ช้างศึกสู้ต่อไป!! พาเปียโน ดูบอลไทยครั้งแรก ตกรอบแบบโคตรเสียดาย!! l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4WloIH645Lg/mqdefault.jpg)
Imagine how freaked out the telepathy person would be if they read the mind of the invisible person.
This is one of the most underrated comments I have ever seen
this is astounding
This. Needs. To be Seen.
@@euanirvine5471 but they're invisible...
alan smithee 🤦♂️
I like the subtle lighting of the colors on the people matching the letters.
That was the TH-cam Space team at work! They're wonderful :)
Though Jay looks like he has a red Mohawk. Also Jay is the most like me (I was really paranoid as a child and STILL REALLY PARANOID) and actually tried to telepathically tell my friends stuff during the spelling bee...
I like Tom's subtle joke about giant crabs and having to get a cream for that
Ooh. I didn't even notice that! :)
@@TomScottGo Tom replied to a comment and it didn't get swarmed by thousands of replies?
Amazing places episode n+1
I feel like Will had the distinct advantage of being Will
tbh I found him completely annoying :/
@@brettonjohansen1619 pirate hater.
@@brettonjohansen1619 pirate hater.
@@brettonjohansen1619 pirate hater.
unfair advantage of being himself
"Vehicularness is in the eye of the transported"
@@DragonFanngg agreed
"Gnocchi is the hovercraft of carbohydrates" - Jay Foreman 2016
Matt Robinson still the best injoke with some friends
how so
ajajajsjajaj english speaking people writing gniocchi and not ñoqui, ajsjajaj
@@santiagoorgeira9142 because they come from italy, and they use the _real_ spelling?
@@santiagoorgeira9142 bro how do u even type that n character what u on about
If we (hashtag) ban legs, then only pirates will have legs-in a rather charming reversal of the status quo.
Not a reversal - Pirates always have had plenty of bootlegs.
i read that in will's voice
@@gayMath Yeah, like that mario 7 thing for the famicom. What with the flintstones and such.
@@neilisbored2177 GRANDDAD
@@koohikoo I read it in Tom's and I did a better impression than you
I love how jay gives a serious argument and then Sarah just said everyone looks good in goggles
Jay: semi - reasonable arguments
Will: creative and unexpected ones
Sarah: goggles idk
Will: PIRATES!
@@witherschat PANTHERS?!?!?!?
it's exactly why all her arguments were absolutely boring and forgettable. Who cares if short people can reach things? chairs and ladders are a thing. who cares about effing goggles?
@@Vengetuen_Wraithy u mad bro
It's funny how Jay is making actual arguments and the other two are just like "hey wouldn't it be funny if I scared this person"
Will is a Scooby Doo villain and everyone on stage, Will included, is okay with that.
"It's completely fine to be naked if you're ethereal."
You'd still be cold. There was a re-write of The Invisible Man. A good book became a predictably awful Chevy Chase movie. But the book drills down into the concept. Can't eat, cuz your food shows...digesting. Can't wear clothes, so what do you do when you re-appear. etc.
You would also not be able to see.
Enrico Piazza
Well, if we're gonna get into the "actually not possible" stuff...gotta put "be invisible" at the top of the list. Once you say "yeah, but somehow you are"...some corners must be cut.
In the book, the clothes he was in (and other clothes from the Inviliblizing Incident site) were ALSO invisible. So he could wear stuff.
If you can turn invisible the clothes you are wearing, you should also be able to make just some parts of your body invisible. Like your hand or head. Or skin. That last one might actually be dangerous, as it makes your inner parts exposed to sun. I think you would get cancer pretty damn easily if doing so.
Partial invisibility is also cool for medical purposes. Depending on how you could control it, you might be able to show for example just your heart or brains and different layers of them. You wouldn't need x-ray, you could show a full HD crosscut of your bones if needed. Wow, this is actually like the coolest one of the superpowers.
Jay Foreman and Tom Scott in the same room at the same time?!?!
It's a dream come true!
And even a bonus Will Seaward
Tom Scott had a cameo in a jay foreman video as well
@@pistashio_lord8918 ooh
Isabelle Wolvetang which one?
@@plebjames jay appeared in the Tom Scott video about copyright, and Tom appeared in the jay Foreman video why cyclists should want cycle lanes I believe.
I think the most disturbing thing about intensely thinking, "If telepaths exist, get out of my head!!!" would be if a random passerby just said quietly in your ear as they walked next to you, _"Don't be silly. Telepaths aren't real,"_ and just carried on walking...
I'm noticing, Tom, that you have a particularly unique and fluid definition of "seconds."
John Maddock time is a social construct.
Time is in the eye of the clock holder.
Time is relative
time is a relative term
is relative. Time
I'm sorry, this isn't a proper Tom Scott video if you aren't wearing a red shirt.
#redshirt dominated the chat
he was wearing a red shirt under it
It's the Red Shirt on the inside that matters
or atleast a red suit
I knew something was off!! :p
“This isn’t live! . . . Please don’t try to vote.”
*This sign can’t stop me ‘cause I can’t read*
A
C
B
D
C
Do *panthers* count as land vehicles?
It's a reference to when Will Seaward appeared on Citation Needed (another show run by Tom Scott).
Timothy McLean P A N T H E R S ? ? ?
Imagine if Will became invisible and came up to you (cloaked) and said "*panthers??*"
Paaaanthaas???
The bold made me read this in Will's voice. It was a little spooky
“To clarify everyone I am in no way Jack the Ripper” is something Jack the Ripper would say.
What are you hiding Will?
I was thinking "of course he's not Jack the Ripper, he'd be Will the Ripper."
@@ashtonhoward5582 Will the Ripper what?
@@IHateUniqueUsernames Will the Ripper? I hardly know 'er!
I'm terrified by Angela the Rippon
Jay's watercraft argument is completely correct..
Greta would be proud
I was going to say land, but that argument swayed me to water
agkl steampunk style airships
agkl Cargo planes exist
Remember when the USSR cut off shipments to West Berlin?
You think we got supplies there through water?
@@ultimatedude5686 All though that was hugely expensive, impractical and a logistics nightmare.
"WE ARE NOT BANNING LEGS" and "Gnocchi is the hovercraft of carbohydrates", haha. That was amazing, I love the format and they were all hilarious.
Ngl, will’s argument for land vehicles was VERY convincing.
the pirates argument won the crowd.
Land land land land land!
P I R A T E S H I P S ! ! !
*_SKY PIRATES_*
Will Seaward is what you get when you combine Matt Gray, Gary Brannan, and Chris Joel into a single person.
And add a very large speaker.
@@j.simons9374 or perhaps brian blessed
@@j.simons9374 So, Brian Blessed?
@@oz_jones Well, he is, in fact, a large speaker...
*panthers?*
So if there were only land vehicles allowed, and you illegally got in a boat, how would anyone stop you? Law enforcement wouldn't be allowed to use boats/planes.
That's a bit like saying "if speed limits existed how are any police going to catch you"... I'd assume in this hypothetical law enforcement/military are exempt from the general populice's ban, much like real life....
@@frowlinian8175 there is a speed limit police isn't excepted from.
~299 792 458 m/s
@@antonf.9278 I c what you did there
A horse in SCUBA gear.
They could just launch missiles at you ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
ngl, this is the best live video feed I've seen on TH-cam. It's not full of awkward pauses or technical difficulties. Even for a show it's interesting and grabbing the whole way.
I mean there's one of the Technical Difficulties
The audience was a bit meh for what they were putting on, I can't believe there wasn't more laughter.
If I look up the word "jolly" in the dictionary, I'm sure it's just a picture of Will.
"In order to get to the space you've gotta go through the air... or something has gone very wrong." -- Tom Scott
"That has been questionable" I see what you did there
There is a fundamental flaw in this concept. The person with the option which gets the highest initial vote is a disadvantage while the person with the least popular category has an advantage due to regression towards the mean. Basically the higher an initial stat is the greater the chance that it decreases on a second measurement- intuitively, there are fewer people eligible to change their mind to your category if it is initially popular! Imaging if someone got 100% of the votes to start with- they'd be guaranteed to lose (or at best tie 3 ways with 0 mind changes).
Now I've watched it I note: The initial leader did not win a single round.
The choice with the second most initial votes won 1 round.
The least popular initial choice won 3 rounds.
Sorry to break it you Tom, your game is broken.
Assuming each of these categories should win 4/3 of the rounds if my hypothesis is false the chi-squared statistic is ((4/3-0)^2+(4/3-1)^2+(4/3-3)^2)/(4/3)=3.5 with 2 degrees of freedom. This null hypothesis is rejected at the 20% significance level but not at the 15% level. There's still hope!
I noticed that too. Maybe total percentage + changed percentage would be a decent balance. If you start at 90% and end up at 80%, your score would still be 70%. Plus, the three scores would still be guaranteed to add up to 100%, so that's kinda nice.
The one flaw in your analysis is, this is a panel comedy show, not a game show. It's not particularly meant to be fair. (:
I feel like this sort of nerdy analysis is the kind of thing Tom would appreciate. I'm happy to continue watching this show, it was very enjoyable but I just think it was interesting to note the problems. As he releases more episodes I'll probably keep the analysis going as the sample size increases to see if we can really see the regression towards the mean effect in action.
The real question in my opinion is... are wheelchairs land vehicles?
MoD366 obviously it is.
Good question! ♿👍
So if legs are banned, I would have a "leg up" so to speak!
But if land vehicles were banned, I would need a Hover Rocket instead of my wheelchair. I'm on it, Dystopian Universe 🦸♀️
@@joshcanonasipi9990 Only if you can walk. Otherwise, they are leg replacements, and therefore not land vehicles. Obviously. :p
@@bodyofhope legs wouldn't be banned if land vehicles aren't banned.
nah
I was with Jay, from a logical standpoint, until Will opened his mouth.
This goes for every question equally.
Fun idea for a show! This is something I could consider watching once a week!
The first time is always the most difficult. I'm sure that if they are going to continue, it will become easier every time.
It would probably get easier to set up, as they have already got the code and the ideas and everything. But during the show it'd still be difficult.
Actually, I'd love to see another one :)
Its different but if you havent heard it the debators by the cbc is good
Will seaward as a ghost would be just going "ooOOoo Panthers"
Kram Ballinger oh god. I’m never going to sleep again
Paanthers?
I can never go to the cinema!
of the three guests, Will is definitely the most likely to be a sky/sea pirate
"Vehicularness is in the eye of the transported" will now be my yearbook quote
map men, map men, map map map! men men men
Gideon Bellamy map map map map map map map map map map map map map map map map map map map map map map map map map map
I drew a wizard
Men
@@Shronkistan NEVER DRAW ON A MAP!
I can hear this comment
I was expecting Will to say "So you could pretend to be a ghost and say "These people have a terrible curse, they must come with me..." and then fight everyone with swords" because Citation Needed
You know you live in 2020/21 when you thought the disclaimer "this isn't live" was meant to not freak out people that there were spectators and live guests without masks and not to prevent people from trying to vote.
Truly. Reminds me of all of the noticed added to things near the beginning of this to let people know they filmed it before the outbreak.
To be fair, I still feel freaked by that, in 2022
Only flaw in your logic is that this was in 2016
Will has mastered the Appeal to Awesome fallacy...
This is hands down Tom Scott's finest work. Gripped for 45 minutes solid.
hello from 7 years later
he has toppled himself so many times
Gnochi is the hovercraft of the carbohydrates
I have been struggling to figure out a fun activity for my class (speech and debate) to do remotely for the persuasive speech unit... this is wonderful! Thank you so much! Zoom has a poll feature I can use with it and everything. You've saved my planning period for tomorrow! Happy dance!
How did it go?
I hope it worked out well. How'd your class take to it?
I love the passive-aggressiveness in “Please don’t try to vote”
This is so bloody good. I love that style of British panel shows, this is like all of my favourite ones collapsed into one. Hope there's more of this coming?
Sorry mate.
Excellent stuff!
Agreed! And hello there, wasn't expecting to find you here xD I'm a big fan of your random tweets about cereal (and magic! of course)
Lucas Snowball_Cathug Come for the magic. Stay for the cereal tweets. ;D
Gnocchi: the hovercraft of carbohydrates™
I like how Sara single handedly forced the applications of carbohydrates in art to be a major talking point of each other player's argument.
Fake vid, no red shirt.
He had a red shirt underneath
It was filmed in Bielefeld
Mysterious, Tom 🕵😕🤔🤔🤔.
Red Shirt is Invisible
He has a gray jacket though.
Will is like a mixture of Brian blessed and the go compare man
That is a very apt comparison
Might I add that he's what Hagrid would look like if he were a bird.
I know it's been 5 years, but god do we need a part 2, Even if it's just online like the disconnected one
29:58 Faloodeh a persian dessert is actually made with rice noodles so technically not pasta
I love this, please make this around once very week!!!!
I've had a few comments and tweets about this: I'd love to, but it is massively time-consuming (and a bit expensive) to prep and arrange everything for this. Maybe as a one-off occasionally! Glad you like it, though, thank you :)
+Tom Scott I agree, really liked this as I do all of your videos.
+Tom Scott Maybe once every two or three months. That balances difficulty with demand.
+Tom Scott Really loved it, this is the kind of things you pay for watching on tv, very entertaining and very very professional, I can understand that it is expensive, you could add commercials or something in between, I wouldn't care at all and I think most of the people either. Seriously, this was a greeeeeat video, looking forward to watch some more,keep up the good work!
+Tom Scott Really loved it, this is the kind of things you pay for watching on tv, very entertaining and very very professional, I can understand that it is expensive, you could add commercials or something in between, I wouldn't care at all and I think most of the people either. Seriously, this was a greeeeeat video, looking forward to watch some more,keep up the good work!
Tom: 'There are places in America where they use planes as cropdusters!'
Me: That's literally the entire plot of 'Planes'.
Wait, Planes has a plot...
invisibility has been ruined for me ever since i learned that physics would make you blind and dirty.
Why dirty?
@@schlimmbotg472 I'm guessing because the dirt on you wouldn't disappear?
Good point
ignore physics and just use the conventional idea of invisibility
horses are not land vehicles but the carriage/cart/wagon they pull is definitely a land vehicle
"[...] emergency Welsh speaker [...]"
Already lost it right there.
Will reminds me of Hagrid
6:18 Tom went through the 5 stages of grief in 5 seconds
pov: you're looking for all the commenters who think they can vote
You could still mow lawns if only aircraft were allowed - hover mowers are basically hovercraft with a blade attached to the bottom of the fan...
This is an amazing concept for a game-show type show. I hope there are many more to come.
Is anyone going to point out that the initial results from 3 of the four rounds are exactly the same??
"Rice is really good if I'm hungry and wanna eat 2000 of something"
- Mitch Hedberg
nice, but I just googled: 2000 isn't close to making a hungry guy full
@@jankisi no reason to stop there...
Eating 2000 of something was just a desire to be quenched, not a fulfilment goal XD
Am I the only one who immediately thought of trying a Space Hopper on a pool filled with custard?
Is ooblek land?
"Land land land land land" is a valid sentence :P
Hi, I'm from Land.
so is "Will Will Smith smith Will Smith?"
So is 'How many bears would Bear Grylls grill if Bear Grylls could grill bears?'
Who else came here from Map Men?
Was it from that comment?
And regretted it...
My choices for the superpower question kinda invert if you have control:
1: Controlled Telepathy
2: Controlled Flight
3: Controlled Invisibility
4: Uncontrolled Invisibility
5: Uncontrolled Flight
6: Uncontrolled Telepathy.
My reasoning is as follows:
I don't really like having lots of attention on me, so being the guy who hovers down the street would be awful. I'd much rather be permanently invisible, thank you. And uncontrolled telepathy would probably drive you mad. There's a character in an anime called Code Geass who has exactly that issue and the guy is among the looniest characters I've seen in media.
Conversely, controlled flight would be nice because I could get where I want to go quickly and cheaply, so it's better than the controlled invisibility because the only uses for that are pranking people, espionage, or crime, none of which I find particularly appealing. Controlled telepathy, on the other hand, would be immensely beneficial because I'd actually be able to know what to say to people (with practice, anyway).
And control is innately better than lack of control.
Nice bit of political ordering for the graphics, what with red on the left, blue on the right, and yellow in the middle…
And also, is Will Seaward what happens if Gary Brannan and Chris Joel met going opposite directions around the LHC?
#banlegs
#banwheelchairs
ohhhh noooo xD .-.
#banspacehoppers
Love your crazy game show ideas, Tom Scott! A game show that ends in a 3 way tie between 3 contestants would never get aired on traditional TV, yet here we are enjoying a laugh at such a zany and funny idea! What a fortunate generation we are.
I can definitely believe thst Will is an alchemist
"Gnocchi is the Hovercraft of the carbohydrates."
Beautiful quote.
This is fantastic!
Are we having the same people next episode, because they were hilarious!
also #banlegs #SkyPirates
#Skyrates
XD
I love Jay Foreman, pressed this video without even noticing him.
"Instead of being impressed, they're thinking 'how did you do that?!'"
DO you know another definition of being impressed?
Is Will the long lost son of Brian Blessed?
I think Brian Blessed has around 143 biological children.
Yes
well that was eminently watchable! more like this please!
"Zeppelins, that's very you"; and here I am watching just shortly after the release of Tom's indoor personal airship video...
Jay was the only one who focused on the culinary possibilities of his carbohydrate. I don't care about what art you can make with food. I care about having a wide variety of tasty and interesting meals to be able to create
Will sounds like Gary putting on his "pretentious scholar" voice.
I thought he sounded like the offspring of Brian Blessed.
will is the combination of chris, matt and gary - but only the goofy characteristics
His "Gosh, aren't they diverse?" at 31:25 sounded like an Ashens line to me
For the potatoes, there was a 7 week period where for every single meal I had some form of potato. They are much more versatile than any of the other two, and all of their varieties are much more tasty than rice and pasta.
Plus, if you eat them with the skins on, there's a surprising number of vitamins an minerals in them.
@@OrigamiMarie and antinutrients to stop you absorbing them
Rice on its own isn't great, but add some beans and you now have an extremely versatile, tasty, and healthy food.
how on earth did the argument for potatoes not include fries/chips or chips/crisps?
We need this again.
You know that mistake that did in 40:32? You did the same thing at 27:03. They are exactly the same as the vehicle ones at 14:28. The whole 3rd round was wrong!
Very well spotted!
actually it wasn't botched, because since it was how many convinced, it didn't really matter, since the change percentages were accurate.
Also I'm sleeping with B.K.Y.D-
JN Baker no they werent the change was calculated based on the wrong results
They changed it on the third round after Jay noticed.
@@officialteaincorporated243 The initial numbers for round 3 were not correct. Instead it was the initial numbers for round 2, and this wasn't spotted. The final numbers for round 3 started off as the final numbers for round 2, which was spotted and corrected. But those were compared to round 2 initial instead of round 3 initial.
Tom, this was excellent! Please, please, please do more of these.
Wow I love every game Tom comes up with ! It's always fun, the competitors are so fair play and enjoying themselves, and the concepts are always awesome ! Keep it up !
WE NEED ANOTHER QUESTIONABLE
thanks from 2017
Aww, you didn't include all the hilarious pre-show stuff. Maybe a separate upload for that?
25:27 technical difficulties? :D
I'll go home now
We neeed more!
Aha! Tom! I had a variation on that thought, most certainly. It usually is, in fact, along the lines of:
"If there are any telepaths listening; my apologies. I do try to keep on top of the mess in here."
SPOILER!!
I knew it, if the internet has a chance to f**k things up at the end, they'll take it every time!
Amazingly, the lack of red shirt really threw me for a couple seconds!
Naw. He said on his Matt And Tom channel that he's got a suit
„Please don't try to vote.“
You can‘t tell me what to do! A it is!!!
I've gone back and watched this several time I would love to see you revive this idea and do more of it.
Someone call the BBC, I'd definitely watch this on TV.
_Hey, that rhymed, too_
This is pure entertainment, with a bit of knowledge and other things that can really tickle your brain into happiness.
Pasta is 32bit, Rice is 64bit, and Potatoes are vector art.
I would like to note that Bruce Willis has detective skills and can sing.
I would LOVE to see more of these
30:41 gnocchi is the hovercraft of the carbohydrates
best line of the whole video
Whoever you are that finally made CC for this video, thank you very much!
Thanks Jake Roosenbloom, Oliver Platt, Siren, Ivan The Space Biker, Voxy!
William Seaward even sounds like a pirate's name.