I don't understand how some peopel can't get this simple logic that the one whonis not created how his speech can be created. Whoever Allah misguides none can guide. Even though they have mind they don't have ability tonuse this faculty.
Brother , first look for the truth before using logic, Torah and the book of Issa bin Maryam were also speech of Allah , now do you say they are attributes of Allah ? Now use logic, can attributes of Allah be tampered? Hopefully Allah will open your Eyes.
@@fuadseif2199speech of Allah swt can't be tampered.what he actually said in previous scriptures is an attribute of allah.the false speech that people attribute to Allah swt is not an attribute of him.also about tampering the speech of Allah lah.no one can change or tamper the speech of Allah unless Allah allows it and the speech of Allah was allowed by Allah to be tampered or changed due to his infinite wisdom which we might not fully grasp.Also,God changing what he said earlier is not tampering.its just saying things which are appropriate for people of different times.like how allah changed his command of commanding muslims to pray towards Mecca rather than Jerusalem.
The principle is that the one who denies a siffah of Allah is a kafir because it's an act of kufr. However, takfir on a specific individual who has been seen or is known for doing this, that job is left for a scholar and we stay silent.
Firstly, our country doesn’t matter in terms of knowledge.but to answer your question. No, Ustadh Abdurrahman hasan is British, his parents are Somali.
No one is saying Arabic isn't created. But the Quran is the speech of Allah which is not created. “And if anyone of the Mushrikoon (polytheists, idolaters, pagans, disbelievers in the Oneness of Allah) seeks your protection then grant him protection, so that he may hear the Word of Allah (the Quran), and then escort him to where he can be secure” [at-Tawbah 9:6]. An-Nisa 4:164 "And Allāh spoke to Moses with [direct] speech."
8 หลายเดือนก่อน
@@AdnanAsSylheti thank you brother but me as muslims things that I don't get is how we human specially Muslim even come with the question there things that shouldn't be questioned to begging with. I have seen two arguing where is Allah. One says Allah is above the Arsh which as Allah mentioned in the quran. And the other says Allah is everywhere and soon as he said Allah is everyone the other said a question that I hate to see someone say he said " is Allah in bathroom" ? I was around I said both of you are right so the one that that's said Allah is above the Arsh told me I was wrong. I asked him brother do you believe that Allah created the moon and the Sun to be a sign for those are ulul albab and also beneficial for us to get a light and guidance? he said yes I said is it not right above us right now? he said yes I said can please go and out run the Sun ? He said what do you mean I said if i give you 20 minute to run away till you reach where you see not the sun right above you, can you do that he said no it always be above unless it is sets or moves it is own. I said Allah is much more higher than the Sun and moon he is everywhere and can't out run so he is right and you are right both of you are right.. My entire point is some questions should never come because they are the gateway for Shaytan.. Jazaka Allah Kair for your explanation
Wa iyyak. Akhi, the question "where is Allah?" was asked by the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم himself when he asked the slave girl, "where is Allah?" She said, "above the heaven." The Prophet asked "and who am I?" She said, "You are the messenger of Allah." The Prophet said to Muawiyyah, "free her, for she is a believer" (Muslim 537 a, Abu Dawud 3282). This shows that this belief is also one of the fundamental things that makes one a believer.
8 หลายเดือนก่อน +2
@@AdnanAsSylheti @AdnanAsSylheti yes you are right I have seen that hadith إعتقيها فإنها مؤمنة .. Jazaka Allah Khair ya shiikh. والذي فلق الحب وبرأ النسمة احبكم في الله
JazakAllahu khairan brother, May Allah reward you.
I don't understand how some peopel can't get this simple logic that the one whonis not created how his speech can be created. Whoever Allah misguides none can guide. Even though they have mind they don't have ability tonuse this faculty.
Unfortunately, ahlul hawa Will always mislead unlearned (about tauhid & sunnah) people go astray
Brother , first look for the truth before using logic, Torah and the book of Issa bin Maryam were also speech of Allah , now do you say they are attributes of Allah ?
Now use logic, can attributes of Allah be tampered? Hopefully Allah will open your Eyes.
@@fuadseif2199speech of Allah swt can't be tampered.what he actually said in previous scriptures is an attribute of allah.the false speech that people attribute to Allah swt is not an attribute of him.also about tampering the speech of Allah lah.no one can change or tamper the speech of Allah unless Allah allows it and the speech of Allah was allowed by Allah to be tampered or changed due to his infinite wisdom which we might not fully grasp.Also,God changing what he said earlier is not tampering.its just saying things which are appropriate for people of different times.like how allah changed his command of commanding muslims to pray towards Mecca rather than Jerusalem.
What is the verdict on someone who disagrees that Qur'an is a sifat of Allah ? Is this person making an error of ijtihad or still considered a kafir ?
The principle is that the one who denies a siffah of Allah is a kafir because it's an act of kufr. However, takfir on a specific individual who has been seen or is known for doing this, that job is left for a scholar and we stay silent.
Are you from any chance from Bangladesh akhi?
That is irrelevant question, when it comes to our deen , we look for answers not country.
Firstly, our country doesn’t matter in terms of knowledge.but to answer your question. No, Ustadh Abdurrahman hasan is British, his parents are Somali.
@@fuadseif2199 I was jus curious. Nationalism is a disease
Each and everything other than Allah is created.. how Allah teach Adam every name and language if Arabic is not created .
No one is saying Arabic isn't created. But the Quran is the speech of Allah which is not created.
“And if anyone of the Mushrikoon (polytheists, idolaters, pagans, disbelievers in the Oneness of Allah) seeks your protection then grant him protection, so that he may hear the Word of Allah (the Quran), and then escort him to where he can be secure” [at-Tawbah 9:6].
An-Nisa 4:164 "And Allāh spoke to Moses with [direct] speech."
@@AdnanAsSylheti thank you brother but me as muslims things that I don't get is how we human specially Muslim even come with the question there things that shouldn't be questioned to begging with. I have seen two arguing where is Allah. One says Allah is above the Arsh which as Allah mentioned in the quran. And the other says Allah is everywhere and soon as he said Allah is everyone the other said a question that I hate to see someone say he said " is Allah in bathroom" ?
I was around I said both of you are right so the one that that's said Allah is above the Arsh told me I was wrong.
I asked him brother do you believe that Allah created the moon and the Sun to be a sign for those are ulul albab and also beneficial for us to get a light and guidance? he said yes
I said is it not right above us right now? he said yes
I said can please go and out run the Sun ? He said what do you mean I said if i give you 20 minute to run away till you reach where you see not the sun right above you, can you do that he said no it always be above unless it is sets or moves it is own.
I said Allah is much more higher than the Sun and moon he is everywhere and can't out run so he is right and you are right both of you are right..
My entire point is some questions should never come because they are the gateway for Shaytan..
Jazaka Allah Kair for your explanation
Wa iyyak. Akhi, the question "where is Allah?" was asked by the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم himself when he asked the slave girl, "where is Allah?" She said, "above the heaven." The Prophet asked "and who am I?" She said, "You are the messenger of Allah." The Prophet said to Muawiyyah, "free her, for she is a believer" (Muslim 537 a, Abu Dawud 3282). This shows that this belief is also one of the fundamental things that makes one a believer.
@@AdnanAsSylheti @AdnanAsSylheti
yes you are right I have seen that hadith إعتقيها فإنها مؤمنة .. Jazaka Allah Khair ya shiikh.
والذي فلق الحب وبرأ النسمة احبكم في الله
أحبك الذي أحببتني له