What impresses me of Andre Sensei is that he is one the the few western people who moves like a Japanese with a very light touch of his own. We should emulate the moves of people like him. I always refer to Japanese praticioner's moves to improve my technique, never to western. Thanks for sharing! Vielen Dank! God Bless
Your A "TOP OF THE LINE INSTRUCTER"so proud to be one of your old students and to be still continuing you and sensei asi training. Look forward to be a similar example of you one day! Osu
Wenn ich Andre Bertel zu meiner aktiven Zeit gekannt hätte, wäre ich 2x im Jahr bei seinen Seminaren gewesen!!! Selten so konsquente und effektive Techniken gesehen und dabei fast alles auf Kata aufgebaut!!!
I've enjoyed watching Bertel Sensei seminars over the years. I am a student of karate and he has a great mindset in training and the fine points of movement. Thank you for sharing.
Why not, maybe he was rude ahead in the emails or booked a crappy hotel room and deserved it? 😂 or just fat and untrained and need to understand he does not deserve a black belt falling around like rag doll fat like a pig 🤣 How the hell can we know the reasons for why he hit him so many times!! You go figure and come back tell us all! Everyone got different ways of teaching and disciplining students! Is not about need, is about his way to teach!
In his own right, Andre's technical ability, is head & shoulders above many other Karate Instructors. However, there is absolutely no need to continually hit & kick his students as regularly as he does.
Quando si fanno esempi applicando le tecniche su un allievo per dimostrare la loro efficacia, ebbene mettere una protezione tipo uno scudo paracolpi all'addome, nel massimo rispetto di chi subisce il colpo! Un colpo senza contatto o scarso contatto ha un effetto un colpo a pieno contatto ne ha un'altro...Non ci si deve mai dimenticare che chi abbiamo di fronte è un essere umano passivo che spalleggia il maestro, e si presuppone che stia lì per imparare, e non per fare il sacco...Oss!
@Sensei Andre Berthel can you ask the organizer of the Seminar to bring punching and kicking bags. Hitting people is not the budo way. I am sorry it is not.
You're wrong. Stop lying to yourself about the fundaments of matrial of war you little elm person. You even say you're sorry when you're truly not sorry.
This guy is great, reminds me a training with Enoeda and also Kawasoe when they were young. Both would call you out the front and bash you to demonstrate. Enoeda would say sorry ‘Before’ he hit you, LOL.
This improvised master, who says he was a pupil of not knowing how many masters, did not understand that the power of techniques must not be demonstrated in all movements, but only when necessary. one day he will hurt someone and then he will understand the stupidity of his way of teaching.
Me gusta mirar estos vídeos de karate mi hijo tomo clases empezó de 7 años y paro alos 16 me sentí triste cuando paro asta donde sabe no lo sé pero si sabe
More than just a theory, why not fight with a moving opponent or free opponent with a variety of punches and kicks, even difficult to find in a variety of demo videos that are closer to reality, yes all more just a theory but ordinary students don't realize, whereas it is not effective if it is intended as a martial arts.
As a shotokan karate practitioner. I find it amazing how people actually believe kata is something practical in real life threatening situations. Don't get me wrong I love kata, but I've always considered it a form of physical training rather than an actual combat drill
Whee he said the body is slow but the hands are fast. That philosophy is also in the art I practice. The four true times and the four false times, the true times are the fastest way to move, Time of the hand, Time of the hand and body, time of the hand body and foot and time of the hand body and feet. The false times are the slowest way to move, Time of the foot, time of the foot and body, time of the foot body and hand and time of the feet body and hand.
It's a class of black belts - they can take it and enjoy taking it.... i've seem Sensei's hammer brown belts to make them ready to take Dan gradings... The guy is good. End of.
Never seen Andre fight anybody in who was descent let alone really good.Only seen him fight very mediocre karate men..He definitely is not a top class competeter..
Puede ser y es muy bueno pero no debería golpear a sus alumnos, no entiendo a los “Sensei” que golpean a alguien que está colaborando quieto. Que mal, Oss.
Antonio Atilio Acosta . eso es loque iba a desir en todos sus videos veo como goloea a otros cinturones negros nc es muy rraro mi shihan no acostumbra eso
Got a video? Show the link please, I admit that I was wrong. It's not about fighting for a belt and a degree. I think his level will be evaluated in the MMA cage. About the fool...I'm talking about the attitude to apponents. He gets high when he hits people. I can see it.
You dumb.. this is a teacher, not an opponent of these guys. He teaches them the right techniques and is not there, to have some big fights. You don't have the right attitude towards this martial art.
sockenkuchen98 yuo dumd...This teacher teaches martial arts, not singing, music, or drawing. I see this teacher hitting students, but I don't see him taking the hit himself. If you want to hit, go to sparring. I think he gets high if he hits people who don't hit back. It's more of a showman who makes money from seminars. A coach is someone who has trained a good student fighter.
@@_N.A.L_ you don't understand the Point of few i try to explain. He shows his techniques on a "enemy" or an example. Then the students there, which mostly have a Dan grade, try to perfect these techniques, which they already know. And they do this with partners. In fact, Sensei Bertel only shows how to perfect the hits, kicks, grabs and so on. A teacher is a human, who knows more things than you. So he have to show how these techniques works on a human.
Did I mention how I despise him hitting the solar plexus while demonstrating techniques? He is an excellent Karateka but this behaviour is just unfair and beneath his dignity. Worst of all, he seems to take pleasure in it :-/
Well, I see it from another view. Bevor I started with Karate (21 years ago) I practiced JuJitsu. There was a phrase: The best teacher is pain. If you feel how the technique works, you will get a better understanding how to execute this technique. I was participant at this seminar and I haven't had a feeling, that André Sensei have a pleasure to hurt somebody. I see his enthusiasm on Bûdô-Karate (in doing and teaching). My feeling was, that he had a lot of respect to all participants.
@@dirkzeuge8785 Dear Dirk, I agree that pain can be a good teacher. You definitely need to know what you can take as well as the impact of your techniques. The fact remains that I find his actions at least questionable.
@@antoniapowers8878 Dear Antonia, thank you for your expertise. I'm sure you are one of these Karateka with an iron hard solar plexus. You probably also mastered the art of training your throat, eyes and crouch. You clearly missed my point.
Dear Martin. He clearly asked for someone with a strong stomach to demonstrate on. No disrespect shown by executing the techniques with a good degree of force to show the difference in impact. For student seeing is believing. Here in South Africa all decent dojos ensure proper body conditioning of our students so that hard hits are accepted without question. The streets won't show respect with soft blows. Rather get used to it in the dojo than landing up in ER.
A coach who beats athletes with his techniques without respect...is not a successful coach...the Japanese respect their opponent and do not use their strength because they are confident in their techniques
Ian Mercredi sorry for not cutting my hair. It’s my Japanese wife’s fault. I begged her but she didn’t let me. Maybe you can cut my hair at a seminar? Thank you for your kind observations
@@andrebertel Don.t listen anybody. You have a remarkable haircut, that very suitable for you. Thank you very much for your technique demonstration. Your karate lessons to supply of energy and inspire me for my training. I wish you every success!
@@animaterob maybe,but mostly a ploy to look tough,like look at my belt I've been training a really long time,just like the pop of your gi,means your strikes are powerful,even if your an 80yr old master,just buy a new belt,
I’m an aikido practitioner since 22 years now and my black belt looks terrible really bad. Do there is no explication for that. I’ll ask my Master if I can change it. Oss🥋
What impresses me of Andre Sensei is that he is one the the few western people who moves like a Japanese with a very light touch of his own. We should emulate the moves of people like him. I always refer to Japanese praticioner's moves to improve my technique, never to western. Thanks for sharing! Vielen Dank! God Bless
Your A "TOP OF THE LINE INSTRUCTER"so proud to be one of your old students and to be still continuing you and sensei asi training. Look forward to be a similar example of you one day! Osu
Wenn ich Andre Bertel zu meiner aktiven Zeit gekannt hätte, wäre ich 2x im Jahr bei seinen Seminaren gewesen!!!
Selten so konsquente und effektive Techniken gesehen und dabei fast alles auf Kata aufgebaut!!!
Thank you for posting! Bertel Sensei’s karate always inspires, and his teaching points are gold!! Oss!! 👊👍🏽🙏
Cool
I want to join your school
I've enjoyed watching Bertel Sensei seminars over the years. I am a student of karate and he has a great mindset in training and the fine points of movement. Thank you for sharing.
Wow what an incredible teacher What a beautiful human being
Am feeling very well coz of you Andy
His Oi Zuki is truly a piece of art.
Do you really need to hit the guy 11 times
No, he doesn't.
I've practiced Shotokan for over 10 years with numerous instructors and never had a Sensei hit a student that hard intentionally.
Why not, maybe he was rude ahead in the emails or booked a crappy hotel room and deserved it? 😂 or just fat and untrained and need to understand he does not deserve a black belt falling around like rag doll fat like a pig 🤣
How the hell can we know the reasons for why he hit him so many times!!
You go figure and come back tell us all!
Everyone got different ways of teaching and disciplining students!
Is not about need, is about his way to teach!
Man this is a practice. A good practice have a good results bat Bad consequencess. 😂
Querido maestro es un honor poder observa su enseñanza que mejorara en gran manera mi karate ....oss
Oss!! I would love to train with this guy!!!
Danke für dieses Video.
In his own right, Andre's technical ability, is head & shoulders above many other Karate Instructors. However, there is absolutely no need to continually hit & kick his students as regularly as he does.
osh... I wish you may visit us in Lombok Island - Indonesia someday , to teach and expand our insight about Karate, thanks
Awesome technique shown... Very nice..really Great!
E um esporte que da gosto de se ver e um professor genial
amazing to say the least.
Thanks for sharing Oss..
he is very energetic sensei ...
Pratiquei karatê cheguei até faixa vermelha, eu gosto muito de lutar karatê mande mais vídeos para mim por favor obrigado.
❤❤❤
Quando si fanno esempi applicando le tecniche su un allievo per dimostrare la loro efficacia, ebbene mettere una protezione tipo uno scudo paracolpi all'addome, nel massimo rispetto di chi subisce il colpo! Un colpo senza contatto o scarso contatto ha un effetto un colpo a pieno contatto ne ha un'altro...Non ci si deve mai dimenticare che chi abbiamo di fronte è un essere umano passivo che spalleggia il maestro, e si presuppone che stia lì per imparare, e non per fare il sacco...Oss!
Hi master am asking that how can be the best
awsome videos great job Great Sensei!
how it is possible that many cn symbols of knowledge and mastery need to learn from another cn. what kind of cn are they?
👍👍oss sensei👍👍
@Sensei Andre Berthel can you ask the organizer of the Seminar to bring punching and kicking bags. Hitting people is not the budo way. I am sorry it is not.
Agreed
You're wrong. Stop lying to yourself about the fundaments of matrial of war you little elm person. You even say you're sorry when you're truly not sorry.
What's his karategi brand?
The only mistake you made when recording…there isn’t enough of this great guy
I understand the worn belt thing, but when theres no black left maybe its time for a new one. Excellent technique.
Great technique
Super ❤
This guy is great, reminds me a training with Enoeda and also Kawasoe when they were young.
Both would call you out the front and bash you to demonstrate. Enoeda would say sorry ‘Before’ he hit you, LOL.
Very good sensei
Thanks sir
Something to consider, kata has very few closed fist jodan strikes. This is important to understand. Oss
karate masters are famous for hurting their students but you know the limit , you are very good Sensei , can I join you .
Your big master oss
Good.
v.good👍👍🌸🌸🌸
This improvised master, who says he was a pupil of not knowing how many masters, did not understand that the power of techniques must not be demonstrated in all movements, but only when necessary. one day he will hurt someone and then he will understand the stupidity of his way of teaching.
Couldn't agree more...
Fights???,🤔🤔🤔
Poor guy! I was always the punching bag when I was training.
Me gusta mirar estos vídeos de karate mi hijo tomo clases empezó de 7 años y paro alos 16 me sentí triste cuando paro asta donde sabe no lo sé pero si sabe
le recomiendo los videos del canal kuro-obi world, allí se mantiene la esencia del karate.
More than just a theory, why not fight with a moving opponent or free opponent with a variety of punches and kicks, even difficult to find in a variety of demo videos that are closer to reality, yes all more just a theory but ordinary students don't realize, whereas it is not effective if it is intended as a martial arts.
As a shotokan karate practitioner. I find it amazing how people actually believe kata is something practical in real life threatening situations. Don't get me wrong I love kata, but I've always considered it a form of physical training rather than an actual combat drill
@@Askld precisely
La classe made in Japon le karaté qu' on aime
Muito bom gostei
oss
Very Good
Whee he said the body is slow but the hands are fast. That philosophy is also in the art I practice. The four true times and the four false times, the true times are the fastest way to move, Time of the hand, Time of the hand and body, time of the hand body and foot and time of the hand body and feet. The false times are the slowest way to move, Time of the foot, time of the foot and body, time of the foot body and hand and time of the feet body and hand.
Shotokan
I want to practice karate from you master.
Takes too many liberties with the students.Obviously likes to show off.But he is very good,no doubt about that..
It's a class of black belts - they can take it and enjoy taking it.... i've seem Sensei's hammer brown belts to make them ready to take Dan gradings... The guy is good. End of.
@@stevosd60 regardless of accidentally injuring someone..Yep that's real cool
@@shellyad100 when your a black belt of his caliber. There are no accondents. They are failures
Never seen Andre fight anybody in who was descent let alone really good.Only seen him fight very mediocre karate men..He definitely is not a top class competeter..
All black belts, they are supposed to be able to take a few punches to their tummies
Good sensei
yaaaaawn
Good
Karate indonesia ossu
رائع
確かに空手の基本は上手い。
しかし動かない弟子に技を力一杯当てすぎだろ😔
理解します。私の考えも。
Rikai shimasu. Watashi no kangae mo.
Puede ser y es muy bueno pero no debería golpear a sus alumnos, no entiendo a los “Sensei” que golpean a alguien que está colaborando quieto. Que mal, Oss.
Antonio Atilio Acosta . eso es loque iba a desir en todos sus videos veo como goloea a otros cinturones negros nc es muy rraro mi shihan no acostumbra eso
i rest my case
Simulasi boleh lh tp kl benaran bkm tentu yg jd fathner nya itu kalah
What that fool. He takes pleasure in hitting people, but knows that he will not be hit back. He needs to go to the net, to MMA
Got a video? Show the link please, I admit that I was wrong. It's not about fighting for a belt and a degree. I think his level will be evaluated in the MMA cage. About the fool...I'm talking about the attitude to apponents. He gets high when he hits people. I can see it.
You dumb.. this is a teacher, not an opponent of these guys. He teaches them the right techniques and is not there, to have some big fights. You don't have the right attitude towards this martial art.
sockenkuchen98 yuo dumd...This teacher teaches martial arts, not singing, music, or drawing. I see this teacher hitting students, but I don't see him taking the hit himself. If you want to hit, go to sparring. I think he gets high if he hits people who don't hit back. It's more of a showman who makes money from seminars. A coach is someone who has trained a good student fighter.
@@_N.A.L_ you don't understand the Point of few i try to explain.
He shows his techniques on a "enemy" or an example. Then the students there, which mostly have a Dan grade, try to perfect these techniques, which they already know. And they do this with partners. In fact, Sensei Bertel only shows how to perfect the hits, kicks, grabs and so on. A teacher is a human, who knows more things than you. So he have to show how these techniques works on a human.
Benny Jet That's what I'm talking about.
9🤛👍👍👍👍
What is up with that hair Helmut he is wearing? Looks like a wig...
its not his hair, its his hat 'cos its cold at the gym
@Ronin6575 Hmmmm... samuraj without a master means less than a scoundrel
"You're body moves slowly...your hands are fast."
Did I mention how I despise him hitting the solar plexus while demonstrating techniques? He is an excellent Karateka but this behaviour is just unfair and beneath his dignity. Worst of all, he seems to take pleasure in it :-/
Well, I see it from another view. Bevor I started with Karate (21 years ago) I practiced JuJitsu. There was a phrase: The best teacher is pain. If you feel how the technique works, you will get a better understanding how to execute this technique. I was participant at this seminar and I haven't had a feeling, that André Sensei have a pleasure to hurt somebody. I see his enthusiasm on Bûdô-Karate (in doing and teaching). My feeling was, that he had a lot of respect to all participants.
@@dirkzeuge8785 Dear Dirk, I agree that pain can be a good teacher. You definitely need to know what you can take as well as the impact of your techniques. The fact remains that I find his actions at least questionable.
I agree with you Martin. He should be striking the eyes, throat or groin. There's no point hitting well-trained karateka in their solar plexus.
@@antoniapowers8878 Dear Antonia, thank you for your expertise. I'm sure you are one of these Karateka with an iron hard solar plexus. You probably also mastered the art of training your throat, eyes and crouch. You clearly missed my point.
Dear Martin. He clearly asked for someone with a strong stomach to demonstrate on. No disrespect shown by executing the techniques with a good degree of force to show the difference in impact. For student seeing is believing. Here in South Africa all decent dojos ensure proper body conditioning of our students so that hard hits are accepted without question. The streets won't show respect with soft blows. Rather get used to it in the dojo than landing up in ER.
This is show, not martial art
What 🤔
Kate.boudo.
A coach who beats athletes with his techniques without respect...is not a successful coach...the Japanese respect their opponent and do not use their strength because they are confident in their techniques
😟😞😤😤😤😤
Basic physics
.... Nothing new
You probably only watched the first part n skipped the rest of the vid hahaha
He needs a haircut badly.
Ian Mercredi sorry for not cutting my hair. It’s my Japanese wife’s fault. I begged her but she didn’t let me. Maybe you can cut my hair at a seminar? Thank you for your kind observations
@@andrebertel Don.t listen anybody. You have a remarkable haircut, that very suitable for you. Thank you very much for your technique demonstration. Your karate lessons to supply of energy and inspire me for my training. I wish you every success!
Buy a new belt,that one looks terrible,just because you belt looks like that doesn't mean your tough,I've trained 40 yrs,my belts not that bad
You don't know if that belt belonged to another master and was handed down. Maybe it's a cherished relic from his sensei?
@@animaterob maybe,but mostly a ploy
to look tough,like look at my belt I've been training a really long time,just like the pop of your gi,means your strikes are powerful,even if your an 80yr old master,just buy a new belt,
And I wouldn't wear my masters belt,I'd wear the one I earned,that's his accomplishment,not mine,I'd cherish it,but not wearing it
@@danhiser4891 howdy Dan , do you really think he needs to look tough !!
I think not .
I’m an aikido practitioner since 22 years now and my black belt looks terrible really bad. Do there is no explication for that.
I’ll ask my Master if I can change it.
Oss🥋
oss