Which Book is better Shubham Keswani or Atul Agarwal ? CA Final Audit May 24
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ม.ค. 2024
- For Free notes and updates
Join Telegram - t.me/cainsightswithvipul
Audit Playlist - • CA Final Audit May 24 ...
DT Playlist - • CA Final DT May 24
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 72 วันนี้!! คู่เอก "ก้องศึก vs โจอาคิม"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hT1EOSsRPac/mqdefault.jpg)
Atul Agarwal book is actually better than shubham keshwani provided in 1st revision u refer his question bank as well coz some topics which are not covered which is only 2-3% not in every chapter u get that in his question bank ......and his question bank is exhaustive than shubham keshwani..........shubham keshwani bank does not cover each and every q of past paper and rtp , mtp ............just refer Atul Agarwal concept book and his q bank and concepts which are not in his book but in q bank just make notes of it and keep it in your concept book only .......for 2 time revision just refer his concept book that's all and you're done with Audit .......I'm doing my second revision now after 1 revision I was able able to solve past paper q and rtp and mtp as well coz of his book only ......just don't refer his concept book only refer q bank as well that's all......... and remember u just have 1.5 days for revising audit irrespective of audit paper even of its out of box almost 40 to 50% concepts or questions are always similar or same in that paper see past paper u can get an overview of it .......u cant just refer concepts and avoid questions or just refer questions and avoid concepts u need to refer both cover all q's of ICAI past paprr, rtp , mtp and keywords........and if youre thinking to refer ICAI mat than higlight keywords in 1st revision itself or else you will panic in 1.5 day covering ICAI mat in 1.5 days is a challenge......only two good concept books are available for audit in market one is shubham keshwani and other is atul agarwal ........if someone has done the keyword part for you than why not make full use of it
Hey what if I refer atul sir concept book and shubham keswani ques bank?? Is it a good to go strategy
Boys : Atul Sir vs Shubham keswani
Legends : Pankaj Garj Vs Study material 😂
😂
Garg ❌ Garj ✅
@@ANKUR_JHA_ 😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣
bhai confused between BB or to go with atul sir ? I have less time giving both group? shall I go with his exam oriented 200hr class? is 1.5day enough for covering compact? kindly help
I would suggest to go for Atul sir as time is less.. Atul sir class me questions Kara dete hai almost and unka full Course 160 hrs ka hai..
Yes u can cover BB sir compact in 1.5 days but need multiple revisons to get hold on it..
Please review hemant somani book
I also ordered this book after shubham keswani book i noticed from RTI copies ICAI only want keywords same with suggested and gave 3/4 marks i answered only in 6 lines and pure keywords so Atul sir has made accordingly i think.
Could you please share your contact details
Could please share your contact info
Please review Hemant Somani's book as well ..
Vipul bhaiya agar Audit ki class leni hai for Nay-24 to kiski lu please tell me
Bhai can you please ask me on telegram or whatsapp?
Bhaiya can you please provide me your number I need guidance regarding Audit
Shubham keswani or neeraj arora sir
@@CAVipulSardanaQ bhai, aisa kya batane wale ho, public me batado ki ham log bhi जाने ki kiska class sahi rahega
Pragnesh Kanabar Sir
Sir please give guidance whose question bank should be refered
Atul sir or Pankaj Garg sir
Yes he didn't covered qb, atul
Shubham sir cover SA as per audit pronouncement as was applicable since nov 23 ,but now icai made chapter specifically for SA's differently,,,shubham sir should also change his matarial accordingly but he had not insteed added some topic from them called SA ADD ON. Still too much part is missing in shubham sir book
Like in sqc 1 eqcr documentation , ep documentation etc. Very much is still missing
As icai has changing his approch to conceptual q insteed of direct q.
Shubham sit still using rattafication approach with less conceptual which can be vary dangerous if q. Like icai added in sm came in exam ..
Without good conceptual knowledge no one can answer them
So now which material you are following
Bhai utna notes + question bank karlo utna bhi yaad ho jaye toh kaafi hai
Have you taken class from shubham sir?? Don't say without knowing him... His teaching style is next level... Before jump into concept he tells some story regarding that, and also he tells trick to remember that... That tricks blended with concept only.. no question of rattafying... U are mis leading man..
@@Karavali7kitne me bika bhai ye bhi bta de
@@shobhitmangla1719 exam oriented batch 6000 including books... Just see his one demo lecture... U will be fan of him... I guarantee
What about Kapil Goyal CA Final books?
I don't agree, I have also referred both but Atul sir has actually not covered various topics and also has not given even required explanation of points which are suppose to be written in exam.
E.g
Que. Advantage of Digital auditing ?
In this sir has only mention five head points only whereas in module each point has atleast 5-6 lines explanation, which is missing in sir's book.
I have notice this in atleast 6 concept till now.
I have a huge respect for Atul sir but referring this book as main concept book is a huge risk especially if you are doing the subject for first time or doing self study.
That's my opinion,
No hate
Radhe Radhe
Right.
that is because audit me as we all know key points/exact same headings ke marks hote hai, ap headings mann se nahi likh sakte but content andar ka likh sakte hai on your own. isliye sir sirf key points dete hai on assumption ki 1st reading me apne content padha hai, to make it easy to revise what actually needs to be retained
@@ShrutiSamra than preface of book should not mention that book is even for those who are going to read subject for first time
All in all I am trying to say that this book is best for revision but you can't expect to get good mark by writing the same content without adding icai content to it (and it would be very agnostic to think that I will add that content directly in exam hall)
Atul Agarwal book is actually better than shubham keshwani provided in 1st revision u refer his question bank as well coz some topics which are not covered which is only 2-3% not in every chapter u get that in his question bank ......and his question bank is exhaustive than shubham keshwani..........shubham keshwani bank does not cover each and every q of past paper and rtp , mtp ............just refer Atul Agarwal concept book and his q bank and concepts which are not in his book but in q bank just make notes of it and keep it in your concept book only .......for 2 time revision just refer his concept book that's all and you're done with Audit .......I'm doing my second revision now after 1 revision I was able able to solve past paper q and rtp and mtp as well coz of his book only ......just don't refer his concept book only refer q bank as well that's all
@@moviesden142
You are absolutely right and that's my point, unknowingly you are using concept book as revision book and comparing it with a well summarised concept book lol..
I have I said in earlier comments and I am saying it for last that Atul Agrawal book is best revision book but it is not a concept book for first time subject readers and that's it there is no comparison between them since like in using revision book your approach would first QB and than revision book but in concept book onces approach will be first concept book and then QB
That's it if anyone does not understand the basic diff between concept book and revision book than it's his or her fault
Also one more drawback of using only revision book like Atul sir book is problem in mcqs
Radhe Radhe
Bhai Main Audit self study karnewala hu to main pehle pura icai ka SM pura padhunga fir 2nd revision or exam ke 1.5 day ke liye atul sir ka book use karunga. Kya yeh approach sahi rahega? Please jawab jarur dena🙏
Yes u can do this..While ur first reading from study mat keep highlighting imp points for MCQ..
@@CAVipulSardana Thanks for replying 🙏
Please do w.r.t. IDT question bank bro
Kya atul sir ki book nov 24 attampt ke liye updated he???
Yes its updated..
Atul Agrawal book only 221 pages .summary ka vi summary
Risky one if icai asked deeply
Exactly
Best faculty for audit is abhishek bansal, but one drawback or I don't like is his main book. His chart book is awesome. I refer chart book only..❤❤
Sir aapke tel channel pr book ki pdf nhi mili kha hai ?
Plz dm me..not shared the pdf on my channel..
Review hemant somani sir book also..
Will Definately try
Maine bhi dono book mangai apne bilkul 💯% accurate review diya h sir
Thanks 🙏
Video start aisi lagi jaise 1.5x pe ho
After failing 3 times because of not using ICAI study material, I can confirm that it's a soocyde if you refer anything else. Other subs I can say icai material is very bad, don't risk for Audit subject 🥶
It's totally depends on experience of every person...Seen many students scoring exemptions with these authors books..
But at the end Study Mat is best if you can handle it 1.5 days before exams
Rishabh Jain's class notes are best for standards because standards are having highest focus in new syllabus...
Agree
Class notes jo unhone lecture me likhwaye hai ya wo book jisse padaya hai?
@@ganeshgupta9736 jo likhwaya hai wo
Pl guide me about QB of audit. I am referring pankaj Garg class note book.
U can go for atul sir or pankaj garg sir qb
Pankaj sir best hai... Icai mat coverage
Hi pankaj sir main book and class notes what's the difference which one is best for self study?
@@Kavyakanchukatla class notes is exam oriented
bhai jab book hath mai hai hi too kholkar dikha dete...aur no. of pages bhi bata dete
Bhai..dono books telegram pr PDFs available hai..aap dekh skte hai..
Atul and shubham are temporary, pankaj garg is permanent...
Pls can anyone tell which scanner is good
Atul sir or Pankaj garg sir
Please review hemant somani book also
yes plz
Students who took Audit classes refer their respective teacher books
Students who wish to prepare audit self. - Strictly refer Pankaj sir book or Icai book.
Pankaj sir class notes and main book what's the difference and which one will be best for self study?
@@Kavyakanchukatla
Class notes is summarised version of Main book. Pankaj sir uses the Main book for regular class and Class notes for Fast track batch.
If you have ample of time and wish to study Audit indepth :- Go with Main book
However if you want to study purely Exam Oriented :- Go with Class notes.
@@vishalmishra1706 Thanks. Does class notes cover all the concepts from ICAI Mat
@@Kavyakanchukatla Yes.
Guys refer Institute Study Material, it is the father of all books and authors
It's 💯 rgt if u r able to revise it 1.5 days before exam..That's not possible for everyone
Yes that's the main issue...how do we cover same in 1.5 days
@@CAVipulSardana we can revise in 1.5 days if we done multiple revision with highlighting key words
What about qb??
In qb of Atul Sir questions are more as compared to Shubham sir..But Shubham sir has covered those missing question in his concept book itself
What about pankaj garg?
Pankaj Garg sir book is good with detailed explanation ..For self study point of view sir's book is best
Atul sir ne bola hi tha meri book me at least 115 marks k aayenge hi
😂😂 kuch v..
@@wasimthewilloffire9972 acha to apka kya kehna hai ye bhi bta do sabko
Atul sir is best , u can understand even without coaching and Shubham book is ok
Mere hisaab se jise jis faculty ka samajh aaye uske liye wahi best hai
Exactly 💯
Pankaj garg class notes is very good .
Both of them dont cover all topics better to study from icai material or neeraj sir book
Yes always better to study from SM..But only if u are capable enough to revise from SM in 1.5 days
Siddharth Agarwal is best for Law & Audit
Apne inse li audit?
@@cricketplayer4539 . Yes I took so that I'm saying. You can search on TH-cam
@@cricketplayer4539 . Yes
Kaha se ho bhai aap. Classes lia h kya apne
@@Caguidance . Siddharth sir best for law & audit bcz i took classes from siddhharth sir. i'm from kolkata
Hemant Somani..his book is great too
Prashanth's chart book is faar faar better
Pankaj garg sir class note
Sarthak jain sir drone charts , no one can beat that
Hi bro what about aarthi mam book
No idea bro
@@CAVipulSardana bro according to you which book for audit is comprehensive and covers all concepts for understanding audit
@@saisriramabburi5359 Pankaj garg sir book is good from that perspective
I have been used aarthi lohati mam book It covers all topics but before exam its too heavy & also there is no space between each point
@@desu.usharani9904 then which book is best
Best chart book SETU for ca final audit by CA Jyoti Deshwal Each and every concept is covered
Her regular book and classes are also very awesome
Refer her you tube channel for demo and revisions videos guyz