@Tarun Singh mate the Indian corporate system is not even capitalism, it's just redistribution of wealth amongst the rich, and the farmers just asking for individuality, that's not communism dumb fuck
Situation is terrible after lockdown almost 30 million people lost their Jobs but no relief from govt.Only rich is getting richer and poor becoming poorer.
neoliberalism, the ungovernend power of money over people and democracy, makes the richest insanely rich, beggars the poor and makes everyone else poorer AND is pushing our entire species into the ecological abyss.
@Tarun Singh Socialism or Communism is 1000 times worse for India. Look at Failed Nations like Cuba or Venezuela. Even China abandoned Communism model, realizing its Futile and embraced Capitalism in 1979, Opening its Markets to American and ushering an Era of Prosperity.
@Tarun Singhoh bhai andhbhakt konsa state support kr raha hai koi ik bhi state bta de jaha se kissan aye ho aur boli ki yeh laws tik hai aur jetne ki bat rahi kb ka jit chuke hai sarkar hr koshish kr ke dekh chuki hai sb fail hoye hai
The ruler of today's India has many records of cruelty on the citizens when he and his party was ruling in his home state he murdered thousands of Muslim🔥 community to get popularity,, in majority community,, and thier party's ideology is based on fascism, torture, oppression on week section of the country,,,
@@deepsenpai6871 Still better than TMC and Congress In West Bengal,people are not given jobs despite good results in exam Congress supports China instead of India
@@PranabMallick. unemployment raises by 10%, it's central government problem. If BJP is against china then how china made 600 houses? Banning those apps was the only initiative they could take. And Arnab's whatsapp chat releases many hypocisy of BJP
Farmers deserve to make a living. Don’t let the rich take everything like they have in America. Big business put the little farmers out of their land. Bought them up.
@Tarun Singh oh mistaken kid Would you ever work for someone where you won't know that how much salary you would get Msp is minimum support price not maximum But in corporate world we buy commodities at MRP Maximum Retail Price Msp is required to sustain a farmer Farmers should be given Msp According to A2+C2 Formula
but there is not exist free breakfast farmers produce on their own and they are demanding price and customer accept it only With small price and this motivate them produce you have similar system of demanding but europe system is faster because of price numbers on goods every government just take taxes values create people
For no reason. I hope you educate yourself soon, the banks are seizing control of production and allocation of resources. NWO One World Government is looking more and more likely. Next they will ban eating meat.
@Tarun Singh Why only you're qualified to advice and pass comments on my all and sundry? Stop shooting from your blunderbuss. You impenitent shambolic. Your prevarication is uncared for. Shibboleth...
@Tarun Singh u don't know the struggle of farmers. Farming is a process of full of struggle. BJP blind supporters won't understand this. Go and sell 1kg potatoes privately u will know for how much prize they will ask
@@vyshakgowda6034 achha ye bta jb pehle wala law tha usse kya fayda ho rha tha kisano ko pehle bhi kisan atmahatya krte the lekin ye bill/act kisano ko kai vikalp dega apne saman ko bechne ki to isme galat kya h?
They can get it from other states than Punjab. Best solution for India is Balkanization. Smaller independent nation states will be able to provide better development per capita.
Even if the states are separated into nations, there will still be fights. Then, based on caste ,creed and probably religion and whole lot of other issues. Better to stay together and fight .
@Tarun Singh Even though you have a Punjabi name you ain’t even defending your fellow Punjabi famers... Even if she has a a non Punjabi name atleast she is defending her people unlike you...
@Tarun Singh hey bud don't call her Rice bag convert but western media always want to portray India badly and the thing is don't be Conservative, she is Christian but that doesn't mean she is anti-Modi or anti-India so chillax be liberal and conservative When it comes to politics
@@theguide1192 misleading how? for eating pizza? what they eat comes from their work. media shouldnt be concerned about that. i think the media is more misleading then the farmers
@TJ Wake up man! Farming is heavily subsidised across the globe but not in India! Modi has been bought by the Capitalists and can not be trusted .. end off!!
@Nirmal S a few? you do realise across the world millions of people are protesting because these laws affect them in one way or another. hundreds of thousands are sleeping on the road because they want to save the future generations from poverty. and you still say a few.
@Nirmal S funny. farmers in australia protested against the same laws a few years ago. farmers in america are in debt due to these laws. and now farmers in india are also protesting against the same 3 laws
Modi government only cares corporate all the rules and regulations they liberalise to favour corporate,Indian media also with there pocket so they are not giving importance to such news
@Tarun Singh har mandir sahib feed 50,00-80,000 people a day. it's considered the worlds largest kitchen. all gurudwaras feed people. khalsa aid goes around the world to feed people. so yes siks do basically feed the whole world.
@@ablockbathrooms8304 tirupati feeds 1lakh people each day, Isckon feeds 20lakh people each day , Akshaypatra feeds 18 lakh children each day. Not only sikhs do that apart from this there 100s other temples
@@davidshroff8752 RADHE RADHE, JAI SHREE RAM, HAR HAR MAHADEV, JAI SHREE HANUMAN, JAI BIBLE, JAI QURAN, JAI HIND , JAI BHARAT JAI HINDUSTAN, VANDE MATARAM
@Tarun Singh not like modi government.. modi know onlu sailing... Sailing railway airport oil corporation. Finally farmers... But the Communist still in India alive we are not allowed to continue with this bill. Socialism sindhabad
God protect the farmers! Prayers! My heart bleeds for you. Farmers are so special. They deserve rights and freedom and support. We thank farmers for the food on our plate, for our daily bread. Farmers work close to God!
A small shopkeeper also sells his goods at fixed prices. But a single farmer is the only one whose crop price is determined by other people. Why is it like this? I am also a son of farmer and support farmer protest.
Farmers have understood how these laws will destroy their livelyhood and give away everything to ambani adani corporations. Even BJP lawyers are not able to respond to farmers in debates.
@@JyotiSharma-ih8lp On about shut up, you can clearly you got a big damn mouth. But I think it would just be better if that mouth was closed. Also, a matter of fact, this news has spread worldwide, and even i'm sending all my love. Now what are you going to do??? tell me to shut up as well?????? because your a dumbass, and that is all you can say. And this person is just sending love. Why are you getting affected, it's not like he is coming to YOUR HOUSE TO KISS YOU.
The world needs to come together to support these farmers. Police brutality, human rights violations, poisonous capitalism. We need to wake up and help the Sikhs.
Take respect farmers,for your courageous stand to exact your rights, preserve livelihood.Hope the Government listens to your demands as you farmers the only growers defying cold-rain-heat for a country and the world alike to feed on.Without farmers,no choice but to starve.
@@navjotkaur8554 in simplest words - We produce so much wheat and rice in a single year that the extraa remaining wheat and rice is enough for whole African continent 1.5 - 2 years!!! But we can't send it to Africa as they have their own farming why would they buy it from us? We can't sell it, we can't store it...all that decays in open...and next year we get same amount of wheat and rice...which again goes to waste. Problem here is, that the extraa rice and wheat that our farmers produce....it's bought by govt in sarkari mandies at a fixed price...so basically we buy billions of doollar worth food to decay it in open To solve this issue...we need to encourage our farmers to produce veggies, fruits, flowers etc which are in demand in international and even in domestic market...and for that to happen we need corporates and their investment and their help to drive our farmers from traditional loss making water consuming farming to profit making farming. Feeling nervous is natural but change is a must thing in ever sector...we need many reforms in this country...like land acquisition reform, labor reform, reforms in law and enforcement...there is so much to do.. If this farming reform affects farmers in negative way...I will be the first one to protest...but just denying the ground situation and protesting on an assumption is very wrong and it affects future of India.
@Tarun Singh if you don't know whats happening, i suggest you don't speak,as over 80 people have died because of this protest..educate yourself then come back.
@@navjotkaur8554 tbhi to ye bill aaya h pehle mandiyo ki monopoly hoti thi aur usme bhi dalleh kisano ko loot te the aur bill/act ke aane se ab kisano ke pass vikalp honge to kisan kahi bhi apna saman bech skte h
@@Sanatani_kattar woh toh abhi bhi bech rhe hai...aap kya apple khane himachala jate hai ya fr kaju khane goa ya fr spices lene direct Kerala jate hai?
@@Noone-gz8li There is no law on MSP and big private player (BIG BULLS)first they give better price to farmers and with this government grain market get abolish and then big corporates makes our monopoly on the market and give low price to the farmers.The laws goes in the favour of big corporates players.
This policy is part of the WEF reset. The goal is to remove ownership of land from the farmers by forcing prices down for the crop. Well done to them for their hard resilient attitude.
@Tarun Singh abe jaa be modi apni biwi ko to sambhal nhi paya desh kese sambhalega , aur tum jese log jo bjp ko support karte ho tum log support karna band karo sale help nhi kar sakta na farmers ki to chup rhe aur sadte raho tum jese log jitna sadna Kissan ekta Zindabad
@Tarun Singh You are such a coward. Getting smashed by people at every thread where you are defending Fascist Modi, but you’re shameless. All you bakhts can do is cry everywhere.
Modi good at hate, false news, godi media, hindu muslim fights and communilism Under modi 1. Media sold 2. Rich got richer 3. Jobs gone 4. Gdp worse 5. Unemployment worse 6. Poverty worsened 7. Rape against women increased 8. Farmers situation worse 10. China occupied our land And bhakts still saying modi is good. Lol
I am an Indian farmer. I will tell you this. This issue is related to only 2 states that is Punjab and Haryana. No where else farmers are protesting in India. For a long time farmers in Punjab and Haryana grew at the expense of other farmers in India. Now that their monopoly is broken they are crying about it. I repeat I have no issue with the farm laws brought by Government of India.
MODI JI DOING GOOD. IF THESE PROTESTORS HAD FAITH ON USELESS CONGRESS FOR 70 YEARS THEN WHY CAN'T THEY HAVE FAITH ON MODI JI. MY QUESTION IS WHY MAJORITY OF FARMER UNIONS FROM DIFFERENT PARTS OF COUNTRY HAVE AGREED. ARE NOT THEY FARMERS?????? BEFORE BLAMING ANY ONE " BE THE CHANGE THAT U WANT TO SEE AROUND U.JAI SHREE RAM, VANDE MATARAM
True . Typical psycholgy . They are afraid of any change . Just want to continue growing wheat and rice and continue to get good money from govt . Thru MSP . BUT THE reality is unless farming mathods are improved and private partners are involve, no evolvment of farming mathods . No real long term benefits to farmers ... v. Sad and unfortunate
Talking about faith?? Seriously?? Modi tweeted about USA and about people who died in plane crash in Indonesia ...but doesn't have time to talk to the farmers just a few KM away from his residence.... Not even a single tweet when 70+ farmers have died due to cold....
@@GS-ku2gz sir ,they are doing suicide .no one is FORCING them to die in the cold. Government is ready to clear the doubts. Remember bill are for the entire country and many farmer association from different part of BHARAT have also agreed to it.JAI SHREE RAM ,VANDE MATARAM
1 sec is what takes modi to repeal law, repeal and make again, what's the deal ,he never died, but 130+ of us died, shame on bhakts, paid economists calling khalistani, maoist to the poor, black period for india ⚫
1. The three farm bills are already in place and working fine as of now and they are part of congress , bjp, ncf parties 2019 election manifesto. ex farmer minister of ncp and present congress chief minister of punjab also supported the same reforms in the past. Now all oppositon parties change their stand and making farmers scape goat. 2. post dialogue with farmers and govt ,On december 9th clarified with 10 point amendment that all the doubts farmers posed and will be tabled in next session of parliament. But protesting farmers unions change stand after dec 9th and want full repeal. 3. In 2019 farmers can't sell their produced rice/wheat/vegetables etc out side of the district or county and cant sell to any one outside of the APMC market yards/mandis and farmer has to pay 8.5 percent fees( 3% to market yard improvement, 3% to district development , 2.5% to licensed commision agents). In some markets they collect both from seller and buyer each 8.5% . These new 2020 farm laws allows farmers to sell to any where in india to any one . no restriction. It is upto local government to charge needed cess or fees. 4. In 2019 only 10% of total agriculture produce (mainly wheat and rice)was bought by government agency FCI (Food Corporation of India as a stockpile for emergeny security) . 85% was purchased by private buyers . In 2019 only 15% of produce of total agriculture was purchased at minimum support price (MSP) and rest was purchased at lower price. Till 2010 the minimum support price was lower than the international price of the goods. After 2010 the minimum support price was increased higher than international price and no exporter is buying at msp except govt agency and all godowns of FCI agency are full with 4.5 trillion tonnes of wheat and rice . 5. who is at loss due to this farm bills of 2020 are A. punjab state governments who charge 3% cess for district developement will loose around 15000 millions (1500 crores) indian rupees per year income. B. the punjab licensed commision agents (who are mainly punjabi sikh jat caste landlords )who get 2.5% charge per transaction thro markets will loose 1000 crores (10000 million) rupees per year only in punjab state. c. Other than punjab and haryana no other state charge district fees and market cess and they charge only commision agent fees. Some states there are no markets/mandis like in kerala (since 1980) and bihar (since 2008). 6. The funding for protest is happening by charging 500 rupees per farmer . 80% farmers own only less than 2 hectres /5 acre land. 7. The foreign punjab seperatist/secissionist group sikh for justice announced 1 millon dollars as donation and indian banks stoped the distribution asking account holder to show FCRA ( Foreign control regulatory) registrants for permission 8. All want farm reforms. Punjab and Haryana farmers unions want to repeal and rest of indian country farmers are happy that they can sell anywhere. I think if central/union govt gives that 1500 crores to punjab govt per year and 1000 crore to punjab commision agents it will stop.
@Tarun Singh Chal bhak Chutiye, unemployed and nonsense religious demands such nonsense. Educated people prefer better jobs and good quality of life for their citizens.
How dare they call farmers terrorists look at them in the cold look at them suffering look at their work, they starve just so we can have food. Modi, you need to open your eyes punjab is against your sins. Think of what you are doing to the elderly. We are not terrorists we are farmers. Farmers feed you, and the roti you eat is grown in Punjab if you think of that. If you don't do anything about the farm laws you won't have anything to eat and India won't have anything to eat. Look at the farmers suffering just look at them! They are doing these protests because they want their rights, our land our rights!!!! No farmers, No food, no future. KISAAN EKTA ZINDABAD!
This bill would affect farmers' lives the most yet they weren't allowed to have a say in it.... It's for farmers and let them decide for themselves. They have every right to protest against it.
i wouldn't say all of covid is a scan. but i would say the numbers in india definitely are a scam. theres no way that india went from 500 to like 5,000 over night when lockdown was newly enforced. numbers of cases in india are a total scam
Indian farmar doing flag off khalistan samarthak in red fort. This protest is wrong because of farmar have doing voilence in capital . I am in indian that time . #DELIPOLICE
If someone seeing my comment outside from India please do support farmers because Indian media is purchased by govt even govt did so many wrong things in past but media continuously supporting them despite people don't like
Thanks to BBC for coverage of farmers protest. Now all know why people are in Delhi for suspension of farmer bills they are not terrorist. Govt is trying to turn the agenda nd not fulfilling the demands of people of India. Its not democracy its dictatorship.
I just hope they get what they need. Sending lot's of love from England!!!!! Waheguru
Thankyou even indian media and news channels are not posting news about farmers because these all are sold to Indian government
Thank you Eligah!
Thank you
Waheguru
Thank u dear
Khalistaniyo ka keh ke lenge
Well done to the Indian Farmers! Let your voices be heard!
@Tarun Singh FAKE PROFILE TROLL SHAME ON YOU YOU ARE NOT A SINGH
If I say u, take a little poision.would u take,no .these bills r same as taking posion
@Tarun Singh and you are a paid troll of the government. Shame on you for showing our own brothers in bad light .
@Tarun Singh yes we are communist and also indians.
@Tarun Singh mate the Indian corporate system is not even capitalism, it's just redistribution of wealth amongst the rich, and the farmers just asking for individuality, that's not communism dumb fuck
I stand with the farmers.
Thank you
Me too. Always standing with them.
@@naz_183 thank you naz
@@mrsingh3586 It's heartbreaking to see all that's happening in Delhi. Really praying for our farmers.
From where ? Don't tell from Canada ☺️
Situation is terrible after lockdown almost 30 million people lost their Jobs but no relief from govt.Only rich is getting richer and poor becoming poorer.
It's crct, it's only happening by BJP
neoliberalism, the ungovernend power of money over people and democracy, makes the richest insanely rich, beggars the poor and makes everyone else poorer AND is pushing our entire species into the ecological abyss.
@Tarun Singh Socialism or Communism is 1000 times worse for India. Look at Failed Nations like Cuba or Venezuela. Even China abandoned Communism model, realizing its Futile and embraced Capitalism in 1979, Opening its Markets to American and ushering an Era of Prosperity.
Why not compare with the largest socialist country
Lol nobody is stopping you from getting rich.
Thanks BBC for covering Farmer's protest when maximum of India media is sold out in the hand of govt
I agree with you
@Tarun Singh" Media must be controlled"
-You
So according to you, the 4th pillar of democracy must be destroyed?
@Tarun Singh So if one person can do wrong, so can everyone else? That is pretty poor logic, not a productive mindset at all.
Indian media Lost Credibility
th-cam.com/video/GmP8nQUthjw/w-d-xo.html😅
Ye thx bruu this is truth
Over 120 farmers have lost their lives in this harsh weather. Idk when this govt will show mercy 😞
#freekashmir #freekhalickistan
@Tarun Singhoh bhai andhbhakt konsa state support kr raha hai koi ik bhi state bta de jaha se kissan aye ho aur boli ki yeh laws tik hai aur jetne ki bat rahi kb ka jit chuke hai sarkar hr koshish kr ke dekh chuki hai sb fail hoye hai
@Tarun Singh neo liberal government playing the "oh I don't know why they are so stupid" card
@Tarun Singh 50₹ per comment. Right? lol
@@ascheema191 arey bhai... Ye log jhuthe aankde de sakte hain. Jhuthe naam kahan se layenge 😂
The ruler is the guardian of his people, if he doesn't feel bad seeing his own countrymen in the street like this, then he is not fit to rule
@Avni Vassilis this define 50%-60% of BJP's politicians.
@@deepsenpai6871 This stands true for all political part
The ruler of today's India has many records of cruelty on the citizens when he and his party was ruling in his home state he murdered thousands of Muslim🔥 community to get popularity,, in majority community,, and thier party's ideology is based on fascism, torture, oppression on week section of the country,,,
@@deepsenpai6871 Still better than TMC and Congress
In West Bengal,people are not given jobs despite good results in exam
Congress supports China instead of India
@@PranabMallick. unemployment raises by 10%, it's central government problem.
If BJP is against china then how china made 600 houses? Banning those apps was the only initiative they could take.
And Arnab's whatsapp chat releases many hypocisy of BJP
Farmers deserve to make a living. Don’t let the rich take everything like they have in America. Big business put the little farmers out of their land. Bought them up.
@Tarun Singh oh mistaken kid
Would you ever work for someone where you won't know that how much salary you would get
Msp is minimum support price not maximum
But in corporate world we buy commodities at MRP Maximum Retail Price
Msp is required to sustain a farmer
Farmers should be given Msp According to A2+C2 Formula
@@gracethy6704 to msp kha hta h chutiye
@@Sanatani_kattar th-cam.com/channels/4mGFTV86AR8VeJmusu1QWQ.html
Watch their video you will understand why these are black laws
Farmers Subsidy
EU - 1068 Dollars
IND - 49 Dollars
Source - WTO.
Indian society lacks compassion.
but there is not exist free breakfast farmers produce on their own and they are demanding price and customer accept it only With small price and this motivate them produce you have similar system of demanding but europe system is faster because of price numbers on goods every government just take taxes values create people
It's happening every where. People are being suppressed for no reason.
For no reason. I hope you educate yourself soon, the banks are seizing control of production and allocation of resources. NWO One World Government is looking more and more likely. Next they will ban eating meat.
@@bertlegion683 I'll be really happy if they ban meat next.
@@papyrustheroyalguardsmen3446 I'd be really sad if they ban meat next.
NEW WORLD ORDER in INDIA
@@papyrustheroyalguardsmen3446 why? Meat tastes really good
My prayers with the farmers
🙏
@Tarun Singh communism is better than this clusterfuck
@@abdullahkhan010_ he still has the guts to write his own name rather than a bitchass librandu who's using an account with a random addage as the name
never bite the hands that feed you !
@Tarun Singh bhai farmers ki wajak se tere jaise fuddu logo k paas bhi paisa hai
Our economy is going just because of farmers
@Tarun Singh then stop eating food eat gobbar which is your favourite dish instead
They're amputating...
@Tarun Singh Why only you're qualified to advice and pass comments on my all and sundry? Stop shooting from your blunderbuss. You impenitent shambolic. Your prevarication is uncared for. Shibboleth...
This Farmers Bill is purely unscientific. This type bills won't work in India.
@Tarun Singh u don't know the struggle of farmers. Farming is a process of full of struggle. BJP blind supporters won't understand this. Go and sell 1kg potatoes privately u will know for how much prize they will ask
@@vyshakgowda6034 govt wants to end this struggle
@@sourabhs14 yes by encouraging farmers to quit farming.🤬
@Tarun Singh troll
@@vyshakgowda6034 achha ye bta jb pehle wala law tha usse kya fayda ho rha tha kisano ko pehle bhi kisan atmahatya krte the lekin ye bill/act kisano ko kai vikalp dega apne saman ko bechne ki to isme galat kya h?
Those 71 members who disliked please eat ur food in imagination
They can get it from other states than Punjab. Best solution for India is Balkanization. Smaller independent nation states will be able to provide better development per capita.
@@joemontana8290 India can deal with these challenges without balkanization
@@saisai0123 it can't and won't. Wishful thinking.
@Incompetent Tyrant just balkanize it on ethno-linguistic grounds. a state for punjabis, a state for odia. These already exist, de-facto.
Even if the states are separated into nations, there will still be fights. Then, based on caste ,creed and probably religion and whole lot of other issues. Better to stay together and fight .
FINALLY this is being talked about outside of the Asian community. It’s atrocious.
@Tarun Singh Even though you have a Punjabi name you ain’t even defending your fellow Punjabi famers... Even if she has a a non Punjabi name atleast she is defending her people unlike you...
@Tarun Singh Wow, amazing bud. Calling others rice bags, not making any actual arguments, You from Republic Bharat?
@sam Kayy Have you even read the laws? Economists are against them, but nah, the laws must be right, economists and farmers must be wrong.
@Tarun Singh hey bud don't call her Rice bag convert but western media always want to portray India badly and the thing is don't be Conservative, she is Christian but that doesn't mean she is anti-Modi or anti-India so chillax be liberal and conservative When it comes to politics
@Tarun Singh Tarun you must be another b*******like your PM
WE SUPPORT FARMERS
Me too but the Poor farmers are misleading unfortunately
@@theguide1192 misleading how? for eating pizza? what they eat comes from their work. media shouldnt be concerned about that. i think the media is more misleading then the farmers
@@theguide1192 do you think farmers are illiterates to mislead? Lol..bakht
@@PavanKumar-er2zb Based answer
@@மண்ணின்மைந்தன்-ள1ம Lol Congress Tail
Meanwhile Indian sellout Godi media be like : Why is the opposition misleading the farmers against supreme commander Modi !?
@Tarun Singh are bhai to
@PEOPLES VOICE I know what's the bill cons
@Tarun Singh velheya inne comment pon dya pkka IT cell ch kmm krda modi de
Middlemen spotted...
@TJ Wake up man!
Farming is heavily subsidised across the globe but not in India!
Modi has been bought by the Capitalists and can not be trusted .. end off!!
India’s largest? This is the largest in the world
Indian govt is bullshit similar like Hitler
Farmers Subsidy
EU - 1068 Dollars
IND - 49 Dollars
Source - WTO
@Tarun Singh fuck modi
@Tarun Singh pattern up he’s a fascist not a capitalist learn the difference
Modi and Amit are ruthless and cheap thieves. they want to rip these farmers off.
Best wishes brothers and sisters, especially to the man with the golden voice!
Love punjabi people from Nepal. Also farmers get what they want. God bless them.
@Nirmal S a few? you do realise across the world millions of people are protesting because these laws affect them in one way or another. hundreds of thousands are sleeping on the road because they want to save the future generations from poverty. and you still say a few.
@Nirmal S Kya tumare eye sight aur dimang teek hai na.ground reporting videos ko check karo.
@Nirmal S justin trudue is a politician he plays games, just like all politicians (including modi)
@Nirmal S funny. farmers in australia protested against the same laws a few years ago. farmers in america are in debt due to these laws. and now farmers in india are also protesting against the same 3 laws
@Tarun Singh you are the one mind your own job. Rss criminal.
Rss idiot
Love from Tamilnadu , land of Periyar who fought for the downtrodden , don't give up , victory will be yours
Long live periyar. Long live annadurai. Respect from Punjab.
@@ਜਗਜੀਤ-ਫ1ਜ superb...
Proud of our sikh brothers from Tamilnadu.... 👍 Happy they can't be fooled by govt and court...
@Tarun Singh socialism sindhabad
@Tarun Singh long live capitalism lol 😂!
Stay strong!! Best of luck!
@Tarun Singh yes communist we are communist... W we are always stant with farmers.....
Farmers should fight for decent pension and universal income too... they are souls of the nation not mere voters...
@Tarun Singh Kon tax evade kartha hai sab ko malum.shayat tumhare anke par Patti bandhe ho
Ok. Pay them
@np pp D brother gand ka ilaj hai, gandu k nahi😂
Pride of INDIA
Indian farmers
PUNJABI FARMERS
I swear on my mom my eyes are full with tears by watching your this report...
Power to farmers of India . Love from Nepal .
Modi prepared for "Hindu - Muslim" while Our FARMER'S came out of the syllabus 😂
PM never prepared for Hindu Muslim. He was born prepared
th-cam.com/video/_vobTAIBTBs/w-d-xo.html
...
@@hardeeprajput6564 lol man, he is trollin Modi and u helping him 🤣
@@hardeeprajput6564 Lol really? Enlighten me, Mr. Know-It-All.
@@hardeeprajput6564 no wonder his country is at loss coz he is busy worrying about his own shit
Shame modi!
@Tarun Singh shame on andh bhakts
@Tarun Singh Shame on Tarun Singh!
Long Live Democracy!
@Tarun Singh shame on your desperate ass 😂 seeking attention
@Tarun Singh gou dung eating bhakta spotted
@@sahibsingh2531 I agree, so much!!!!!
Curse on Modi and Shah Government ! O’roll if thunder hear our cry and send them to God 😢 Save India ! Jai Panjabi , Jai Kisan
@Tarun Singh Modi Muradabad.
M- Murderer
O- Of
D- Democracy
I- In India
@@thischanneldoesnotexist.2975 U don't exist according to ur channel name.so pls shut up.JAI SHREE RAM, VANDE MATARAM
@Tarun Singh the world is watching this b****** Modi destroying our farmers in India....all the atrocities from demonetization to fraud...
Arrarra arrarra raaaa. In the name of ricebag provider. Arara rararara
Very true
I support you The Actual Producer of GRAINS AND ROTI.
Modi government only cares corporate all the rules and regulations they liberalise to favour corporate,Indian media also with there pocket so they are not giving importance to such news
@@bhratsharma2878 use English dnt use any local language
So don't buy shares, don't use cars, don't fly, don't work in tech companies, don't buy mobile phones......
Hypocrite!!!
@Tarun Singh socialism sindhabad
Modi moordhabadu
Farmer should not allowed to starve like that. The government must reduce budget on arm to support them.
@Tarun Singh we who???
@Tarun Singh And here is me betting you are not even a sikh you dumb ass troll
@Tarun Singh har mandir sahib feed 50,00-80,000 people a day. it's considered the worlds largest kitchen. all gurudwaras feed people. khalsa aid goes around the world to feed people. so yes siks do basically feed the whole world.
@Tarun Singh get ur medicines soon trash
@@ablockbathrooms8304 tirupati feeds 1lakh people each day, Isckon feeds 20lakh people each day , Akshaypatra feeds 18 lakh children each day. Not only sikhs do that apart from this there 100s other temples
Deepest respect for the farmer brothers and sisters!
Minorities are being suppressed in India,Muslims Sikhs Christians dalits,
Modi government is doing every thing for vote bank ...
U r wrong.JAI SHREE RAM ,VANDE MATARAM
@@davidshroff8752 RADHE RADHE, JAI SHREE RAM, HAR HAR MAHADEV, JAI SHREE HANUMAN, JAI BIBLE, JAI QURAN, JAI HIND , JAI BHARAT JAI HINDUSTAN, VANDE MATARAM
@@davidshroff8752 JAI JAI JAI SHREE RAM AND SITA MATA
@@vineetagarwal1273 What Does RAM mean:Random acess memory
@@davidshroff8752 Oh god that's beautiful.
Thank you BBC for covering #farmersprotest !!! India’s media is sold out
@Tarun Singh buy you can't sold Indians heart..
We are waiting for socialist india.
Socialism sindhabad
Support Farmers 🙏
Yes support real farmer not fake farmers
@Tarun Singh Why so much hate? Did your dad make vegetables for you?
Tarun Singh shut up gobar bhakt!
@@ram007lal Trust me, he doesn't reply, this guy is too scared. But if he does then WOW what audacity!
@Tarun Singh not like modi government.. modi know onlu sailing... Sailing railway airport oil corporation. Finally farmers...
But the Communist still in India alive we are not allowed to continue with this bill.
Socialism sindhabad
God protect the farmers!
Prayers!
My heart bleeds for you. Farmers are so special.
They deserve rights and freedom and support. We thank farmers for the food on our plate, for our daily bread.
Farmers work close to God!
Feel proud of being an lndian made possible by our farmers especially the punjabi farmers in the forefront
Beautiful coverage, i am farmer but i love my india i hope goverment and farmers reach a truce fast. Love from tamil nadu
A small shopkeeper also sells his goods at fixed prices. But a single farmer is the only one whose crop price is determined by other people. Why is it like this? I am also a son of farmer and support farmer protest.
Those who are eating food plz pray for farmers
The Indian media is not even showing the protests.
Indian media
th-cam.com/video/GmP8nQUthjw/w-d-xo.html 😅
@Tarun Singhyeah...when the BJP or RSS dogs do a protest only then it is lawful...
Farmers Subsidy
EU - 1068 Dollars
IND - 49 Dollars
Source - WTO.
@Tarun Singh when BJPee is trying to save rapists... Then it is a protest otherwise not...lolll
Farmers have understood how these laws will destroy their livelyhood and give away everything to ambani adani corporations. Even BJP lawyers are not able to respond to farmers in debates.
@Tarun Singh we are fighting for socialist india... One the Day will sun rising like red.
Socialism sindhabad
Lala
Salam
Atleast BBC news notice this scenario......👍
@Tarun Singh left is a hope of india .. tomorrow Indian streets are full of red flag..
Lal salam
Socialism sindhabad
Sending love to you all, from England X
You shut up
Why are you saying shut up when he I'd Is saying something positive???
@@JyotiSharma-ih8lp On about shut up, you can clearly you got a big damn mouth. But I think it would just be better if that mouth was closed. Also, a matter of fact, this news has spread worldwide, and even i'm sending all my love. Now what are you going to do??? tell me to shut up as well?????? because your a dumbass, and that is all you can say. And this person is just sending love. Why are you getting affected, it's not like he is coming to YOUR HOUSE TO KISS YOU.
@Indian Atheist not every persons ancestors in the UK France and Portugal looted India though...
@@Sahd079 I totally agree.
Brave men and woman,my brother nlaw in Punjab went on a protest ,love to Punjab
Ssa bhrjai 🙏
may God bless those who are fighting for farmers.
The world needs to come together to support these farmers. Police brutality, human rights violations, poisonous capitalism. We need to wake up and help the Sikhs.
Take respect farmers,for your courageous stand to exact your rights, preserve livelihood.Hope the Government listens to your demands as you farmers the only growers defying cold-rain-heat for a country and the world alike to feed on.Without farmers,no choice but to starve.
May Allah protect all you farmers I pray for you brothers!!!
#supportfarmers 🚩
One of the best reporting
Modi won't even make a fart without the permission of Reliance and Adani.
@np pp D He was sarcastic.
Should have been "won't"
He literally have sold most of government companies to the billionaires! He is licking hips of billionaires and the common people are suffering
@Tarun Singh Bhai how much you are earning from the IT cell.. for every comment you are giving the reply
@@nikhildhasmana1021 yup I Agree you Nikhil
This is real media coverage not like godi media 📺
Tysm BBC for highlighting this news
@Tarun Singh we know that .
They are puppet of labour party
@Tarun Singh elaborate
@@taahaahmed4322 no need for that...they are anti india..
@@kunalmakwana7204 anti-india doesn't mean they are bad
@@aayushaparnaginimuge4172 so what does anti india mean
Really appreciate bbc to light on this fact 😔 feeling sad for all our old generation
@sam Kayy u know bout the law?
@sam Kayy no we don't know anything...kindly elaborate
@sam Kayy Did YOU do any research regarding the law? Economists have publicly called them harmful, but who cares, right?
Feeling sad for what?
@@navjotkaur8554 in simplest words - We produce so much wheat and rice in a single year that the extraa remaining wheat and rice is enough for whole African continent 1.5 - 2 years!!! But we can't send it to Africa as they have their own farming why would they buy it from us? We can't sell it, we can't store it...all that decays in open...and next year we get same amount of wheat and rice...which again goes to waste.
Problem here is, that the extraa rice and wheat that our farmers produce....it's bought by govt in sarkari mandies at a fixed price...so basically we buy billions of doollar worth food to decay it in open
To solve this issue...we need to encourage our farmers to produce veggies, fruits, flowers etc which are in demand in international and even in domestic market...and for that to happen we need corporates and their investment and their help to drive our farmers from traditional loss making water consuming farming to profit making farming.
Feeling nervous is natural but change is a must thing in ever sector...we need many reforms in this country...like land acquisition reform, labor reform, reforms in law and enforcement...there is so much to do..
If this farming reform affects farmers in negative way...I will be the first one to protest...but just denying the ground situation and protesting on an assumption is very wrong and it affects future of India.
Shame for India... those who feed a country have been compelled to die of starvation.
@Tarun Singh capitalist forces na kaho... Capitalist force kaho... Competition fair hona chahida bhra... Monopoly ni...akal nu hath maro
@Tarun Singh if you don't know whats happening, i suggest you don't speak,as over 80 people have died because of this protest..educate yourself then come back.
@@emiliasmith8425 don’t reply to this guy/bot- it’s a troll
@@navjotkaur8554 tbhi to ye bill aaya h pehle mandiyo ki monopoly hoti thi aur usme bhi dalleh kisano ko loot te the aur bill/act ke aane se ab kisano ke pass vikalp honge to kisan kahi bhi apna saman bech skte h
@@Sanatani_kattar woh toh abhi bhi bech rhe hai...aap kya apple khane himachala jate hai ya fr kaju khane goa ya fr spices lene direct Kerala jate hai?
I support farmers🙏
Government repeal the 3 Anti Farmers law as soon as possible.
Its not anti farmer farm bill is with farmers
What's is anti farmer in it ?
@@Noone-gz8li why r u so pissed??
If it is anti farmer then why majority of farmer unions agreed with this bill. JAI SHREE RAM ,VANDE MATARAM
@@Noone-gz8li There is no law on MSP and big private player (BIG BULLS)first they give better price to farmers and with this government grain market get abolish and then big corporates makes our monopoly on the market and give low price to the farmers.The laws goes in the favour of big corporates players.
@@vineetagarwal1273 *here come the slaves of government paid to curb internet activity against BJP*
This policy is part of the WEF reset. The goal is to remove ownership of land from the farmers by forcing prices down for the crop. Well done to them for their hard resilient attitude.
@Tarun Singh hmmm. Thanks Tarun. Written with the syntax of Indian education.....I wonder what your motive could be.
I wish the U.S. media was reporting on this.
Remove Modi he is totally unfit for Prime Minister post, he should start selling tea again.
Lol
@Tarun Singh abe jaa be modi apni biwi ko to sambhal nhi paya desh kese sambhalega , aur tum jese log jo bjp ko support karte ho tum log support karna band karo sale help nhi kar sakta na farmers ki to chup rhe aur sadte raho tum jese log jitna sadna
Kissan ekta Zindabad
@Tarun Singh tum jese log sirf bolne ke alawa aur kuch bhi nhi kar sakre
@Tarun Singh You are such a coward. Getting smashed by people at every thread where you are defending Fascist Modi, but you’re shameless. All you bakhts can do is cry everywhere.
Modi good at hate, false news, godi media, hindu muslim fights and communilism
Under modi
1. Media sold
2. Rich got richer
3. Jobs gone
4. Gdp worse
5. Unemployment worse
6. Poverty worsened
7. Rape against women increased
8. Farmers situation worse
10. China occupied our land
And bhakts still saying modi is good. Lol
I am an Indian farmer. I will tell you this. This issue is related to only 2 states that is Punjab and Haryana. No where else farmers are protesting in India. For a long time farmers in Punjab and Haryana grew at the expense of other farmers in India. Now that their monopoly is broken they are crying about it. I repeat I have no issue with the farm laws brought by Government of India.
Same propaganda as modi #liar
MODI JI DOING GOOD. IF THESE PROTESTORS HAD FAITH ON USELESS CONGRESS FOR 70 YEARS THEN WHY CAN'T THEY HAVE FAITH ON MODI JI. MY QUESTION IS WHY MAJORITY OF FARMER UNIONS FROM DIFFERENT PARTS OF COUNTRY HAVE AGREED. ARE NOT THEY FARMERS?????? BEFORE BLAMING ANY ONE " BE THE CHANGE THAT U WANT TO SEE AROUND U.JAI SHREE RAM, VANDE MATARAM
True . Typical psycholgy . They are afraid of any change . Just want to continue growing wheat and rice and continue to get good money from govt . Thru MSP . BUT THE reality is unless farming mathods are improved and private partners are involve, no evolvment of farming mathods . No real long term benefits to farmers ... v. Sad and unfortunate
Talking about faith?? Seriously?? Modi tweeted about USA and about people who died in plane crash in Indonesia ...but doesn't have time to talk to the farmers just a few KM away from his residence.... Not even a single tweet when 70+ farmers have died due to cold....
@@renupatel4704 farmers are not afraid of change.... Just unwilling to handover the future of their country in the hands of few rich corporate houses
Farmers Subsidy
EU - 1068 Dollars
IND - 49 Dollars
Source - WTO
@@GS-ku2gz sir ,they are doing suicide .no one is FORCING them to die in the cold. Government is ready to clear the doubts. Remember bill are for the entire country and many farmer association from different part of BHARAT have also agreed to it.JAI SHREE RAM ,VANDE MATARAM
May mother India be free of misery!
Ruthless government , democracy is fading here
@Tarun Singh your life is a joke.
NO FARMERS NO FOOD🙏
Modi has no shame about how the farmers are sitting out in the cold, shows what sort of a leader he is - one who cares about no one except himself.
@Tarun Singh ignore this guy’s comment hes trying to get his 2 rupees 🙃
Islam is the truth. Modi is a shaiytan.
Farmers Subsidy
EU - 1068 Dollars
IND - 49 Dollars
Source - WTO
Still didn't understand that what will be lose for the govt if they abandoned the proposed law?! 🤔
Love from Pakistan to farmers
1 sec is what takes modi to repeal law, repeal and make again, what's the deal ,he never died, but 130+ of us died, shame on bhakts, paid economists calling khalistani, maoist to the poor, black period for india ⚫
I stand with Farmers & always will...fight for what you believe in!
Thanku bro
@Tarun Singh they are real farmers not like u slaves of corporate
@@mshankar171 andh bhaghat we don't grow vegetables in Punjab we grow wheat in current season so don't be oversmart u don't even know abcd of farming
@@mshankar171 Don't u people have Brain to understand simple thing that we Punjab and haryana don't need this shiti bills it's easy to understand
@Tarun Singh yes humne theka liya huya purre desh ko gujrati choro se bachane ka abb boll
Next youngsters all around India will join the protest
We are celebrating 75 years of Independence
World's biggest protest.
BBC News is the reason we still have faith in good journalism.
*World's Largest Protest Ever in Human History*
BBC - Please change the title of the video
1. The three farm bills are already in place and working fine as of now
and they are part of congress , bjp, ncf parties 2019 election manifesto.
ex farmer minister of ncp and present congress chief minister of punjab also
supported the same reforms in the past. Now all oppositon parties change their stand and making farmers scape goat.
2. post dialogue with farmers and govt ,On december 9th clarified with 10 point
amendment
that all the doubts farmers posed and will be tabled in next session of
parliament. But protesting farmers unions change stand after dec 9th
and want full repeal.
3. In 2019 farmers can't sell their
produced rice/wheat/vegetables etc out side of the district or county
and cant sell to any one outside of the APMC market yards/mandis and
farmer has to pay 8.5 percent fees( 3% to market yard improvement, 3% to
district development , 2.5% to licensed commision agents). In some
markets they collect both from seller and buyer each 8.5% . These new
2020 farm laws allows farmers to sell to any where in india to any one .
no restriction. It is upto local government to charge needed cess or
fees.
4. In 2019 only 10% of total agriculture produce (mainly
wheat and rice)was bought by government agency FCI (Food Corporation of
India as a stockpile for emergeny security) . 85% was purchased by
private buyers . In 2019 only 15% of produce of total agriculture was
purchased at minimum support price (MSP) and rest was purchased at lower
price. Till 2010 the minimum support price was lower than the
international price of the goods. After 2010 the minimum support price
was increased higher than international price and no exporter is
buying at msp except govt agency and all godowns of FCI agency are full with 4.5 trillion tonnes of wheat and rice .
5. who is at loss due to this farm bills of 2020 are
A. punjab state governments who charge 3% cess for district
developement will loose around 15000 millions (1500 crores) indian
rupees per year income.
B. the punjab licensed commision agents (who are mainly punjabi sikh jat caste landlords )who get 2.5%
charge per transaction thro markets will loose 1000 crores (10000
million) rupees per year only in punjab state.
c. Other than punjab and haryana no other state charge district fees and market cess
and they charge only commision agent fees. Some states there are no
markets/mandis like in kerala (since 1980) and bihar (since 2008).
6. The funding for protest is happening by charging 500 rupees per farmer .
80% farmers own only less than 2 hectres /5 acre land.
7. The foreign punjab seperatist/secissionist group sikh for justice announced 1
millon dollars as donation and indian banks stoped the
distribution asking account holder to show FCRA ( Foreign control regulatory) registrants for permission
8. All want farm reforms. Punjab and Haryana farmers unions want to repeal
and rest of indian country farmers are happy that they can sell
anywhere. I think if central/union govt gives that 1500 crores to punjab
govt per year and 1000 crore to punjab commision agents it will stop.
For those who says farmers are getting paid for what they harvest , then military also got paid bro 🙂
SUPPORT FARMERS
This position is temporary for Ranga Billa. They'll be out of office in 2024
@Tarun Singh Chal bhak Chutiye, unemployed and nonsense religious demands such nonsense. Educated people prefer better jobs and good quality of life for their citizens.
Haha 😂, I bet you don't even know the names of three bills.
@Tarun Singh this is last year coming government is communist government......
Socialism sindhabad
How dare they call farmers terrorists look at them in the cold look at them suffering look at their work, they starve just so we can have food. Modi, you need to open your eyes punjab is against your sins. Think of what you are doing to the elderly. We are not terrorists we are farmers. Farmers feed you, and the roti you eat is grown in Punjab if you think of that. If you don't do anything about the farm laws you won't have anything to eat and India won't have anything to eat. Look at the farmers suffering just look at them! They are doing these protests because they want their rights, our land our rights!!!!
No farmers, No food, no future.
KISAAN EKTA ZINDABAD!
Autocracy government of India. Here aren't use of the people by the people for the people
@Tarun Singh please come to pakistan with me
@Tarun Singh tere baap ka nhi sale yeah hindu rast yeah punjab ki bheek hai jo tum ab apne app ko malak smjhte ho
This bill would affect farmers' lives the most yet they weren't allowed to have a say in it....
It's for farmers and let them decide for themselves. They have every right to protest against it.
I am sure Margaret Thatcher would do the same type of Bill. It smells Neo Liberalism to me.
What to do, our country is in worst condition, even the entire judiciary system is under the control of tyrant Modi government.
@Tarun Singh Desperate? No wonder your trying to comment on every comment for attention 😂
It's good that the farmers are protesting. The govt. cannot have its own way all the time.
i wouldn't say all of covid is a scan. but i would say the numbers in india definitely are a scam. theres no way that india went from 500 to like 5,000 over night when lockdown was newly enforced. numbers of cases in india are a total scam
Keep it up. Sir. You will got your demand DEFINITELY.
PM Modi crafted the Farm Loot Bills, in consultations with Ambani and Adani.
Farmers are lifeline of world ... salute farmers and bbc lifeline of truth
Good to see BBC taken this to world stage, keep support for our farmers.
True indians stands with farmers...Jai india jai farmers
#supportfarmer #istandwithfarmers #nofarmersnofood
Indian farmar doing flag off khalistan samarthak in red fort. This protest is wrong because of farmar have doing voilence in capital . I am in indian that time . #DELIPOLICE
How is jaagi doing? LoL
its not a laughing matter..jaagi my foot.
@@emiliasmith8425 Of course its funny LoL...they were protesting For him like stray dwgs too LoL
@@мувн-ш4ы Today, where is the mughal empire? After all that effort? One failed state called PK
@Taj Sidhu gandu nanak washes my toilet
@Taj Sidhu Yes, Hanuman ji was a bandar,
what's your point? Even a "bandar" is more intelligent then your guwu LoL
Farmers Subsidy
EU - 1068 Dollars
IND - 49 Dollars
Source - WTO
If someone seeing my comment outside from India please do support farmers because Indian media is purchased by govt even govt did so many wrong things in past but media continuously supporting them despite people don't like
Thanks to BBC for coverage of farmers protest. Now all know why people are in Delhi for suspension of farmer bills they are not terrorist. Govt is trying to turn the agenda nd not fulfilling the demands of people of India. Its not democracy its dictatorship.
sad for the farmers
@Tarun Singh and you need to stfu and take your inbread ass out of this comment section. Garbage ass human being.
@@navjotkaur8554 he is bjp bot, 1 rupee per comment.
@Tarun Singh Why are you getting affected, not like they're coming to knock on you door because you will be at their feet one day.
WHO THE F**k DISLIKED THIS?
GOD bless you and your family farmers
They produce and whole India eats farmers are for their Right