ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 พ.ย. 2023
- Piers Morgan Uncensored is joined by associate editor of The Spectator Douglas Murray, TalkTV contributor and lawyer Paula Rhone-Adrien and TalkTV contributor Esther Krakue to have a discussion about the migration crisis within the UK as net migration reaches record high.
Piers asks Paula whether the UK can sustain this level of migration when public services such as the NHS are already under pressure with understaffing and underfunding. Paula explains that is in fact why we need more people to come to this country because they can help prop up some of our struggling services such as the NHS.
Click here for more from TalkTV talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
#piersmorgan #migration #douglasmurray #debate #interview #talktv
The argument that we need immigrants doesn't stack up.
Even just on a very very basic level, services, infrastructure, and housing cannot keep up with the numbers, that alone, is a valid reason to stop it
it does thats how country stays wealthy
@@hattmancock6396 That's the thing, it's so basic yet we appear to be governed by people who are completely ignorant of the consequences. All good for the corporations and the share-owning elite though.
@@hassyg4083 Oh yes. How did you arrive at that conclusion?
@@hassyg4083 well you’re talking rubbish there, it’s how corporations stay wealthy, cheap labour to drive the taxis and deliver the food, pay very little taxes, they also bring dependants. These dependents need schooling, the older ones need health treatment, and eventually they will get old and retire then need to dip into what is already a failing pension system. So when this happens, more imports will be needed to put the next plaster on the wound and the cycle continues. Skilled migration is a benefit to us, but also detrimental to the country they leave. None skilled mass migration is a drain, it is not a boost, and I am not even touching on the obvious societal explosion which is coming very soon
The woman argues race self interest. She lies and lies and lies.
The ultimate race baiters And professional victims!
Blame Piers for giving her a platform.
@@lynnz7182why his fault ? So they can cry about nobody letting them
Speak?
@@davewestly307 Shouldn't give platform to liars.
Well she's hectoring for her team
We had the same issue in Sweden a few years back, we had leftist politicians saying we needed the immigrants, the reward will come later. I promise that none here in Sweden would dare to say that again. We have finally woken up and i hope you do too, and fast because your country is soon worse than ours.
I had a Swedish girlfriend from 2006-2012, I told her Sweden was making a big mistake by encouraging mass immigration. I'd like to know what she thinks now.
@@EQ2snorkle Ask her.
@@ShikuesiHe can’t she ran off with an immigrant 😉
@@sggibson62 Haha :)
Sweden didn't just let in immigrants...they were forced to resemble them too...
Did I hear that woman say we need more? Absolutely nuts!
She has no emotional connection to the land or the people, what she really means is she needs more none natives to satisfy her own emotional needs
That woman is one that also wants reperations.
@@EQ2snorkle let’s give it, 20k and a one way flight sounds perfect
@@hattmancock6396 Exactly. She cares naught for the British people or its history.
This Paula woman is just ridiculous.
Dangerous.
Deluded even 🤷🏻
The last thing we need is more people and especially not the people who come in who hate our culture ,you just have to look at what has happened to Britain and how this is destroying this great country
We need mass repatriation.
We owe these outsiders
Nothing
That's a simple concept everyone's forgotten
It's not our problem if a sub Saharan person hasn't got a good education or dreams of being a rich man in Europe
It simply isn't our problem .
Life's not fair .
Why should we destroy our society just to be the third worlds soup kitchen and hotel for third world waifs .
rich people don't have a problem with migration, it is the poors problem
Maybe if the west stops going to other countries “ to bring democracy “ maybe the people will not want to go to the UK.
Just go to countries pay fair price for resources and go back home. Most of the immigrants are coming from countries that have been destabilised by the West.
yeah i agree
immigrants who come in and don't respect the culture
those lot should be deported
We don't need more people, necessarily. Japan refuses to take in many migrants and they have done fine with negative population growth. They changed and coped. They protected their culture and values at the same time.
Yes, but the Japanese people have great insight , our countries governments do not .
The demographic time bomb has not yet exploded!
I agree that immigration is not the answer but we do need to address this and quickly
Japanese were allied to Nazis that says it all
Oh Muslims have even started going over there now! Look at vids on here. I hope they don’t live to regret it.
@@sh.4409 oh the europeans started to colonise Palestine sad really
Absolutely sick of this “we need more people” argument….it’s the last thing we want…I’m tired of hearing foreign languages every where I go,before we know it it won’t be England anymore.
don’t you love foreign people telling the british people what they need?
More people NO! Our public services are wrecked by the number of people we have already. Ridiculous woman
she talks about the ageing population, immigrants age as well ! There are also too many young people who wont do physical labour, leading to the import of outside labour ..
Nonsense. The UK has an aging population and a low fertility rate.
Immigrants are young and fit. People like that don't use hospitals, pays loads of tax that will pay for your pension.
Without immigration, the UK and the rest of Europe would be in trouble.
@@vincentl.9469Don’t waste your time with them, they can’t process that many factors at a time.
Its truly obscene.
Akin to the Crusades IV.
it's because of 13 years of underfunding by the conservative gov. have u been living under a rock?
We don't need more people. The country is full, and the corporations have their cheap labour.
CORPERATIONS
@@mikekayanderson408 CORPORATIONS
Oops 🙈🙈🙈
If we do need more people and we keep the foreign invasion out, we'll still get them. But they will be spawned natively and ready-integrated. Which would, for the most part, be a good thing.
😄@@Ozzyd22
We DO NOT need more people.. Lies✌️🇬🇧🇮🇱
Who are believing these lies? The country is falling apart!
You have two flags in your comment. Which one holds your primary allegiance?
If geert can do it.....then reform stands as good chance as any!
Vote reform!
It's going to be tough for sure! People moan about what's happening in the country then go vote the same people in and blame it on the other side for messing the country up lol!? I don't get some folk!
We can only hope and dream eh? And look on in wonder as other countries get the leaders they need right now while we carry on sinking into the channel lol.....
Dont hold your breath reform don't have any mps nor are they likely to have . They dont even have any any policies and if its about imigration look who there second in command is
No chance. 1 trick ponies.
@@raycorrigan3297wanna bet?
@raycorrigan3297 There's a big push to get people to vote Reform at next election. Get rid of the legacy voting mentality. Voting the same as your dad did is not a point of pride when the party is not the party your dad voted for. Labour will make this Conservative term look like a happy memory with what they have planned. Labour and Conservative as well as Liberal Democrats are the same party. They take turns with their hands in the cookie jar. Piss the populace off as far as they can, under one banner, and then carry on under another when the public knee jerk and force a name change, giving a cooling off period to the previous party. Reform will break that deadlock and if we can all vote for the one and not water down votes, trying to bring others in, or panic vote for lib dems in case cons or lab get in. Vote reform and break the liblabcon chokehold on us. Anything is better than the rabble we have now and opens the door for people to realise there is more than the three to select across. Make elections less predictable when people exercise choice. Even if they're 'one trick ponies' they break the liblabcon monopoly and get people realising, hopefully, there's more options than the corrupt trinity that had run this country into the ground.
Why do we need more people if we have 70-100 million here already plus illegals? Esther is great and a real beauty.
“Where are they gonna live?”
On council estates pushing locals out.
70 to 100 million??... Where is that number coming from?...
In any case this subject is not being addressed properly.
The UK (and the rest of Europe) has a aging population and a fertility problem.
If not enough babies are made to replace the older generations that difference will necessarily come from immigration.
It's inevitable.
Without immigration the British economy would lose output.
That's the reality that no politician wants to admit to its voters.
@@guleiro “We need skilled workers”, that’s just the excuse. The truth is, for what?
The “reality” is AI/automation will take most jobs soon, so then what are you going to do with all those people? Also, you aren’t getting “skilled” people and you don’t know who you are letting in. With no vettíng, it guarantees you also get in dangerøus víolent people. The irony is those same advocates would be losing their minds if Eurøpeans went in mass to a non Eurøpean country and started changing it but when it happens to Eurøpe it’s a “good thing”.
In the long run we don't really know the effects of the declining birthrate.
It could just as easily lead to cheaper assets such as housing due to lower demand which could help young people get a foot on the ladder.
Birth rates are dealing the world over (sub saharan Africa aside), wht does that mean we should destroy our own country?
You really need to get educated .... Importing cheap labour is exactly why our productivity is one of the lowest in Europe , Without cheap immigration we would invest in more automation .... cheap immigration is why their is a housing crisis it is the demand NOT supply that is the problem.. inovation moves us forward which is why one man with a modern digger and dig what it once took 20 men with spades ... watch this space with AI , then where will all your imported cheap labour work then?? the answer is all on benefits in crowded council estates in nothern towns ...@@guleiro
@@stleonards1066
Of course we know what a declining birth rate brings:
-an aging population
and
-lack of workers for the economy.
It's already happening in the uk e Europe.
We need the right sort of people ,not potential enemies to our culture.
So anyone who don't follow your culture are enemies?
Too late they are already here.
💯
@@mickc7388utter tosh too late!
What we need is to realise that the whole World is on the brink of an era, never experienced by humanity, which is threatening our very way of life....... war in the world and the disappearance of the Dollar currency
We dont NEED more people.
A big change is coming. People have really had enough of this nonsense.
People from all around the world in western societies are waking up.
That’s why they are now controlling speech and writing laws to stop people from speaking up (under the guise of hat3 speech). People are too afraid or naive to do anything about it. Only a few realize what’s going on, most believe the media and think replacement is a right wing myth.
People should have organized a long time ago and not only voted these politicians out but deported them and revoked citizenshíp. The vast majority of people realize not all migrants are bad, but that doesn’t mean you let everyone in and don’t get people. Who does that? It’s like leaving your front door open and letting in everyone, then simply “hope” nobody harms you or your family.
No bro , no change is coming, labour is set to win the next elections. British people have shifted into Stockholm Syndrome beyond the point of no return.
You'll have to actually do something
💯
The problem starts with saying " there is no problem".
And continues by saying that we need more immigrants without looking at a future where Britain will become a Muslim country.
The amount of Palestinian flags being put up overnight in some parts of London . You'd think we were in Islamic Palestine.
@@nutcracker2916 Mostly funded by Unions .
That’s the goal, so that’s not a “probłem” for advocates, it’s a “success”.
???@@Shaun-dr1mg
It's not the illegals or those arriving in boats that you can control; most of them are coming from war-torn countries that have been affected by the actions of the UK and USA. The real issue lies with student and work visas, which have become increasingly easy to obtain. Work permits, in particular, are practically handed out like peanuts. The Home Office is essentially selling these visas, making money from them. On top of that, they collect taxes from both employers and the individuals granted work visas. More people mean more tax, more money.
In the last three years, around 6 million Indians have come in. India is a peaceful country with a GDP larger than the UK, so why are they coming? Rents are high because of them, and they are taking jobs, even in the NHS. Complaints about minimum wages abound, but do you know how many visas the government has issued in healthcare and how many Nigerians and Indians have arrived? Yes, they will pay taxes, and that money will go to the government, but they're not going back, mate. Good luck finding a job.
Suella Braverman played a dirty trick by blaming Muslims for everything. She has left now, but she started Islamophobia, antisemitism, and far-right riots. Yet, no one asked her about the 6 million Indians and how we've been replaced within a year."
The uk has almost a third the population of the United States crammed onto a piece of land smaller than michigan and she's saying we need more people😡 new zealand is bigger than the uk and only has 5 million people and they manage perfectly fine
Have you seen how much of NZ is actually habitable compared to the UK?, it's no wonder only 5 million people live there...
We have about a 5th of the USA population, but we are officially the 3rd most densely populated country on the planet. I'm tired of idiots saying we need more people.
@@grahamtaylor6883 Yep we need more fried chicken shops and scooter drivers .
No actually we don't .
@@grahamtaylor6883 to stabilise the population, you need to accept lower economic growth. All you keep hearing from employers is 'we cant get the staff' so more overseas people arrive
@@mark-wh2qc???? That land isnt empty. NZ is a massive agrucultural nation. That 'uninhabited' land is put to use.
Or are you confusing NZ with Aus?
When I was a kid in the 70s/80s it was drummed into me that marriage and kids was the worst thing that could ever happen to me. I could be ‘so much more’ than a wife /mother/slave of the patriarchy, having kids was killing the planet and we were shown a graphic video of a woman giving birth - screaming, blood everything.
It worked.
I never got married and I never had kids. It felt like too big a risk and the men I met were only interested in hedonism and playing the field anyway. When we are told by those same people that we need mass immigration because we ‘chose’ to not have kids it makes me furious.
Well said. Tell your story to all girls and young women, as a cautionary tale. Bless you.
WOW., sorry! 😮
Yes while these migrants breed like rabbits 🐇
I concur, same experience.
you cant be christian then if that was drummed into you
The people coming are not with the skills that the country needs. People who say different are delusional.
to say delusional is a bit dismissive. you have to ask why these people are coming & what for …. it was nice when the “ great britainia “ went & invaded everyone taught them democracy & now you’re crying because it’s failed you’re privileged enough to wake up & eat & using free wifi. anyways take this with a pinch of salt & have a gracious day ✌️
you are delusional to think you can just move here without a visa lol
@@user-ok4zw9hp3cnobody invaded these people stop acting like that’s the case . They aren’t from war torn areas.
@hassyg4083 back of a lorry, coach, dingy, please bogus asylum been going on for decades.
@user-ok4zw9hp3c If you break it down, it comes down to money they come for the money. Whether that's to have a better life as in free services etc or send money back home, it comes down to the money. Certainly, isn't the weather.
We need more people? We could breed them, but we have to work to pay for Islamic immigration.
500 new lives a day are being exterminated in UK abortion clinics. Hence the imports.
Douglas wont be breeding anyone he is bent
Only 17% of Muslim men and women have jobs ..rest on welfare .
They don't get bothered by the welfare though .
That'd be racism
She’s a liar. She just wants to change the UK population. More people creates more problems. We can’t keep up
@@hassyg4083so are the local British girls who straggle to pay for education, child care and are not provided with work benefits to be able to care for children.
But ofc if you are an immigrant you get a benefit for every kid and free education, which is paid by the working Brit girl who can’t afford to do the same
I wonder how Poland and Hungary cope without all the enrichment of the third world.
Yes, and their streets are safe❤
they dont let them in
I mean look at their economies. Probably a reason loads of Polish people come here.
@@Logicsupersedestheir economy's are fine , they inky come here so they don't have to work and get benefits fir nothing
Walking around Warsaw at night feels perfectly safe. No drunk people on the street, London at night feels VERY dangerous. Poland is lovley. If we had some of their rules and laws things would be A LOT better here. It’s very noticeable and shocking how much nicer it is over there.
I don't think we can for my point of view it's become clear that immigrants inpartiular have more rights than British people I'm facing a section 21 eviction so that my Asian landlady can house 6 illegal immigrants at a rate of £500 each a week where my rent is £500 a month seems very unfair to me how this is aloud to happen very soon I can see British people living on the streets while those immigrants live in luxury
Fight back. I am training to become a children's lawyer but homelessness is a subject we have started going into. Get a solid well organised and trusty lawyer who deals specifically in housing and real estate laws etc as they'll be able to go into more depth and know things most do not, your landlord could be exploiting his right to own properties. Build a genuine case by going through everything with a lawyer and take, your landlord to court if it comes to it, (the fact they're illegally in the UK) it would gain public traction outside of what your landlords doing in secret, and would speak bigger volumes and get more people in the UK talking if it were to be a public case. You'd most likely win that case because of the outside noise and facts around your situation would be too damming to be ignored. You have play to it right, and see as your the landlords breaking the law and using you as sort of bait through calculated bullying tactics. I am pretty sure that breaches his/hers powers as a landlord, and the fact he's harboring illegals whilst having a binding license within the UK. Get a housing lawyer, see if there's anything you can do with it and go from there. 👍
On a recent trip to my local hospital in east London it was obvious to me that mostly immigrant staff were treating mostly immigrant patients. I had to walk through A&E and was shocked at how crowded was with immigrants. I noted just one native Brit who was an elderly man. The look of despondency on his face said it all.
The whole thing is a feed back loop
Import people to work in then public sector but the bring the family too (understandably) putting more pressure on the same services to the point we need more people to work in the
Rinse and Repeat
You've been in The London Hospital in Whitechapel then ? You should see the maternity ward. lol
It's a pyramid scheme
@@danielsleet6548 Yes, that woman said 'we need more people' . The more you have, the greater the population, the more you need to support that growth. More health workers, more building-and tradesmen which always seem to be in short supply, more care workers. Immigrants grow old too ..
@@vincentl.9469yeah exactly. If we'd focus on actually making our existing people competent , we wouldn't be in shortages. Start investing in our boys and girls properly and stop cutting corners.
Nothing wrong with saying no, we want to preserve our heritage, not erase it. Multiculturalism isn’t working. Enough is enough
The problem is people saying there isn’t a problem
Douglas is just awesome!
If migration is needed, then make it atractive for people of shared culture to come here. This isnt a third world country. We dont want it to become one.
We are not sustaining it! I can hardly afford my bills let alone save for emergencies, my 80 year old father according to his doctor has Parkinson’s and won’t give him medication until he’s seen a specialist, god only knows when he will be able to see a specialist and all the time he’s getting worse. Worked all his life for this.
His Doctor should be pushing for your dad to see a specialist, I know because my late husband had Parkinsons. There should be a help group. I think Parkinsons U K is in London which might be able to help, but I am out of touch with every thing now as my husband died a few years ago. Keep pushing Jemma. 💖
@@sandiethomas6157 Thanks I’ve tried and tried, they just say they have asked to quicken his appointment, I can’t see it happening as others must be in a similar boat or even worse and as he’s 80 I reckon they will put younger people before him, obviously that makes sense but it’s still cruel and no fault of my fathers. Sorry to hear about your husband one of many terrible illnesses. Never thought about ringing the charity I will have a look.
The rise of the right... Honestly.. this woman.
Douglas Murray for leader 💯
So is she saying amongst those badly needed 750,000 legal migrants are all skilled workers especially doctors and nurses? Is there 750,000 homes vacant for people to move into ? I’m no mathematician but something doesn’t add up.
What she is saying is the West need’s more immigrants to service the needs of immigrants in the West and the ones to come. It is a cycle that feeds on itself.
@@garrywynne1218 We certainly don’t need more unskilled workers competing against our own unskilled workers. Having large amounts of low skilled workers with few of these jobs available. Only people that benefit are the large businesses who are happy with this scenario and they are gladly driving down already meagre wages. My own thoughts this flood of immigration throughout the west is not by accident but by design.
@@Canadian_bear You sure? Feels like we definately need more deliveroo drivers
@@maverickmic You’re correct. It’s hard for fat people to get off of their arse to go down the road to pick up their take away or cook a meal for themselves or ping something in a microwave. I’ve changed my mind we need these immigrants to take care of the lazy people…not!
She’s a liar. She’s just happy at the population changing
Omg get rid of this woman .. is she for real we need more people.. wot the hell .. is she not seeing wots happening
Thank you for having Douglas on first so I could tune out as soon as Esther started talking!
NOOO resources..
How can you say, Bring in more Immigrants?
Local Brits Have NOO homes!
They will never accept that it’s going to blow
As a british person with disability who tries to get low skill work its getting worse and worse every year even if u getg it its low pay and people in them hardly speak english and just to much pressure .. that is part of the problem.
And speak in their home language in front of other workers , so rude.
Paula can do one. I'm not against immigration. If someone, for example, is coming for a degree at a high-class institution, then fair enough, but they shouldn't be bringing their families. They same with skilled workers. However, there is the effect of keeping wages down, which is a scandal. As for Paula, if she wasn't here, then there would be less strain on our services.
I don know about "keeping salaries down". Labourers on London construction sites earn minimum 160 per day. Skilled workers minimum 200. I asked once a manager (English) why he does not employ English people as there are so many unemployed, he said they don't want to work because they are better off on benefits (because their rent is paid and get cash on top) and they don't like waking up at 6 and taking orders from managers. He said he had a few but they stopped coming after a few days.
@@ileanamuntean7338 my husband has just retired after 50 years bricklaying, all around the north, and all the construction workers were British, apart from 1imigrant who didn't last the week, because being on a scaffold ,near the north coast ,wasn't very pleasant. London ,is not the rest of the country, get out of the London bubble ,and explore who is doing all the work.
@@ileanamuntean7338 The jobs excuse isn’t true. The truth is AI and automation will soon take most jobs. So this about something else and not about “jobs”.
For decades our country has discouraged families and if the argument is "We need more people" then the solution is to encourage people to remain in a marriage and encourage them to have children NOT to import adults.
Give married people tax breaks and the longer you are married the more breaks you get then give people more money/help for having more children so they do not have to worry about being able to afford another child, it would not take long for the next generation to increase solving the problem "We need more people" with the added bonus that those people are British.
This of course is for people who are born in the UK not immigrants and we would have to deport all the illegal migrants.
The government created this problem to justify importing people and we only started this after WW2 when we had so few people left we needed to import people but instead of stopping as soon as we had filled the lost people in WW2 we started to say "Diversity is our strength" and "Multi-culture is a good thing".
I'm not sure where you get the idea that the country was short of workers after the war. Women did a lot of the war work , and wanted to continue working ,after feeling independent. Four and a half million men were demobbed between 1945 -1947. About 40 thousand Italian and German POWs decided to stay and work here. Hence the 10 pound pom scheme .
your economy would fail without migration especially NHS
Multiculture was going on long before 1946. My mothers sister married a then indian man from a part of india lahore near montgomery which became pakistan in 1947. Where he lived he actually help a lot of the locals to become fairly wealthy people as he dealt with indian/pakistani gold. My uncle unas brought the people good fortune and the surrounding area loved him for how he helped
@@user-fp2wy8rk8e anglosaxon jewellery was made in India
@@lynnelowery8435
The country being short of workers after the war is just propaganda by the MSM and the government to imply that the British couldn’t run the country by themselves. That we needed immigration. Lord knows what the motive is.
Let's hope she isn't a victim of a serious crime like the innocent children in Dublin.
She might understand there's a bigger problem than she thinks.
European countries really need to get it together and start protecting their borders and have much much stricter guidelines as to who they are letting in. Some people say that it's a melting pot, but we all know that's bull$hit. When people from other countries come here, the first thing they do is move into their separate ghetto communities.
3rd Generation Brits of Pakistani Origin are still marrying their cousins
Exactly, well said
We’re not blaming immigrants for ills in society, but how can we look after our current population under strained public services? Never mind how many more people we’ll have coming in in the next year. We need regulations, immigrants coming here should be qualified for jobs that will help our country become better, to create better economy and society for all. My grandparents are immigrants, I don’t dislike immigrants, but we have to consider the entire population and be able to support everyone that’s already here first. And by support I mean providing an effective NHS, police force, education system etc. Right now they’re all struggling and our current residents are paying taxes and NI for inadequate services. It is ridiculous.
like Piers goes to a NHS hospital..BS!!!!!
@@ritchiedenham9572 he is poorer than Sunak
There is a vast difference between Illegal immigration and controlled immigration, what contribution will hundreds of young Albanian men, who have no work skills, bring to the UK? if you are being honest you have to say none.
NHS has been done in for years and under the tory rule it'll only get worse. Same goes for the dental practices, waiting lines in some areas are in excess of a year where there's no choice but to suffer or go private which people can't afford. It's gotten so bad that local pharmacists are selling self tooth extraction kits. It begs the question, what do we pay our taxes for?
What😮?
I needed an x-ray not so long ago, the ppl who did the x-ray questioned whether i needed the x-ray. Why? My doc said to give me an x-ray. Who do these ppl think they are?
I'm sorry I broke up your playtime x-ray ppl. You're at work.
NHS is run by foreign Dr's let be real when did you last see anglosaxon Dr lol
Come on it gets billions and billions it wastes it, it needs a complete reform not money. Labour will definitely bankrupt this country far quicker than the Conservatives. We need another party with common sense, balls and the best intentions for this country and its indigenous people.
Pay for freeeloading Migrants
It wasn't 750,000 it was 1.25 million. They reach a net migration figure of 750k by deducting the amount of people who have left Britain. I doubt very much if the people leaving were originally immigrants so that means our demographic has changed by another 1.25 million. We are only talking about 1 years figures. Whats the problem 🙄
It's laughable that in the midst of a chronic housing shortage she thinks we can absorb 700,000 people a year. We have never ever built anywhere enough houses for 700,000 people a year, even at the peak of housing building when we managed to build 300,000 a year in the early 1950s. And her argument seems to be that we need people to staff the NHS, so we should just open the doors to everyone. That's absurd: We can issue visas selectively, and it has been demonstrated that migrants from outside the EU take more in taxes than they contribute. People like her are the reason people are turning to 'far' right parties, and I would definitely vote for a Gilders.
More people to go the Uk, but not to Muslims.
Piers....WHY dont you interview Scott Ritter (military intelligence) his knowledge of current affairs in middle east is almost legendary!!!
Because he's a convicted sex offender maybe? I like him but that's probably the reason.
Being able to stay away from minors should be an extremely low bar that anyone should be able to easily pass … Scott Ritter has been convicted twice for sex crimes with minors (under the age of consent!)…. Maybe people in Russia have less problems with men in their 50s or 60s not being able to stay away from minors (under the age of consent!) and putting Ritter on (State TV) after being repeatedly convicted of sex crimes ….
I listened to him through out the Russia Ukraine conflict, and his military coverage was spot on. With this conflict though, it appears he’s emotional, the other day he said China might get involved which is absolute rubbish and I am sure he knows it is. But with Israel Palestine, there is no impartial coverage, everything is one sided, it’s almost a waste of time watching anything because you’re pretty much choosing a side not really learning anything
why would interview another zionist coloniser?
Theres too many people, let more in to work in our public services, theres too many people, let more people in to work in our public services. Nigel Farage pointed out that there was a supply and demand issue years ago and convinced people to leave the EU to regain control of our borders. More people is not the answer, the answer is regaining control of our borders, because the Labour Party signed away our powers and even leaving the EU has not got them back.
Did you not actually watch the video?
@@mark-wh2qc of course I watched the video, that was her initial reaction, carbon copy remainer argument. Saying we need more people for specific jobs, then allowing more in is a self fulfilling, never ending circle of migration.
Douglas..you are the voice Israel needs. Thank you
sorry But left the room after Douglas singed off ... not interested in what the muppets left behind think
The woman in white is,there is no other word for her,but crazy,I was never any good at maths,but even I can see we cannot sustain millions of people a year coming hear
Look at the well run, civilised and quiet street Douglas is reporting from. Nothing I have ever seen in Gaza, all I see is chaos, anger and rampant criminality. Great work Douglas!!!👍
Israel is a generally peaceful beautiful place, it's 10+ religions work together in relative peace and harmony including Jews, Muslims, Arab Christians, Arab Muslims, orthodox Jews, Orthodox Christians, Armenian Jews and Druze and so on.
@@shellybelly35yes, i was very surprised to learn that: Muslims in Israel and in Israeli Government.
Hi @@shellybelly35 I agree !!
You are obviously ignorant of life in Gaza and the fact the Israel controls Gaza..You are obviously ignorant of who controls the food,water,Fuel and cash flow..
Where do you expect him to report from, where there’s fighting and buildings collapsing and probably be at risk of being taken hostage…what a stupid comment
There is not a problem. Hahaha. People like her don't care how many come.
If you don’t believe you have a migration problem than you’re in denial! I live in Canada and I can see from here that you have a migration problem!
Lol 😂
I live in Sweden and i can also see that they have a big migration problem.
Canada was colonised by europeans. it doesnt belong to them
They have a population that has a Skill deficit . I am in South Africa,every message on LinkedIn is from some recruiter from Canada or the UK try to get you to move there because there is a lots of jobs but no1 to do them.
I live in Croatia and I can see UK as the biggest problem in Europe! It's outrageous what that beautiful country became now, specially because of all of those Muslims, I can't recognize this culture any more! Beautiful British spirit is gone (As a child I was growing up with amazing music and movies from that era (I was born 1978) that reflected amazing rich culture and witty spirit of British people.
A brilliantly measured account of event from Douglas. What is happening in Israel/palenstine is a portent of what is to come here.
Why dont we train our own or at least give people an opportunity to fill these missing places, or doesn't it tick the right box?
Why? Much cheaper to import schooled, trained labour.
We do but the truth is none of the indigenous people want to do the hard jobs. They all want the blue collar cushy jobs that pay which leaves gaps in employment i.e nurses, retail staff, tradesman to name a few. The work ethic of some of this young generation of people raised in western countries is absymal. The immigrants have a superior work ethic to them and the Indian community is a shining example of what ambition and hard work can achieve.
@@rioperez7461 Evidence for this? Or is it just an excuse to continue low pay so you can get stuff cheaper?
Douglas our saviour ! I love you!
So let me get this straight. We need more people to mitigate the fact we have too many people for the NHS to handle, rather than simply not bringing in more people in the first place to require even more people to compensate for the initial influx?
What percentage of these immigrants are putting more in to the system than not? Should we accept such immigrants in if they are not a net benefit and don't have jobs but require benefits?
Your answer would be no, because its not about the NHS, its not even about th3 immigrants, it's about your hatred for the native.
These people are past insanity and in the territory if treachery.
We have too many AGING people, meaning people who will in the next few decades leave the workforce and become dependants of the state (pension). Combine that with the a low birth rate from native brits and you have a generation of young workers who's taxes are mainly going to supporting those older people.
That migration number is the population of Norwich x 5. Any numpty can work out that isn't sustainable
It is such a nonsense to state that we need more workers because our own people won't do the work. The effect of mass low skilled immigration is to constantly depress wages eventually to thevlowest common denominator, further discouraging the incentive to work. The minimum wage rarely applies because so many of these immigrants work in the black economy where workers rights are also non-existent because employers know they will not complain because they probably have no right to be in the country. Further, immigrants grow old as well and will need care in their old age. So, how will we look after them? Answer, more unskilled mass immigration. The rise in immigration on this model will be exponential.
One can just feel the hatred from snidey smugface coming through the screen. She can barely contain herself.
Over the years the British people have constantly voted for less migration,what was the point? We do not live in a functioning democracy.
You need to ask the question of what percentage of the 700000 people actually contribute to society. In my opinion if its less than 50% then its not a benefit.
The country is full enough, we don’t need more people we need to work out how to manage with what we have.
The US state of Oregon is approximately the same size in land mass as Britain. The populations are dramatically different, with Oregon having: 4,240,137 (4.2 million) and Britain having: 67,827,150 (67.8 million) Which means there are 63 million more people occupying this land mass than there needs to be for comforts sake. It is over populated. Which would you imagine has the better quality of life? Britain or Oregon?
The weird argument, that comes from certain people, such as Jordan Peterson and Elon Musk, that "We need more people, vastly and desperately more" is completely baffling to me, and they are so vehement about it. Perhaps because North America, Canada especially is under populated and spacious. It is also from people who don't live in cities who think this the most. And as we see the quality of life in cities and large built up areas is an extreme contrast in degradation from that of small towns and villages. Pumping more and more people into already over populated areas can only decrease quality of life for everyone. People living on top of each other, racial and religious demographics aside, the sheer discomfort of traffic jams, crowds and the seething anguish of disparate ideologies unable to relate to each other is simply not desired by anyone. Cities are imploding under these unbearable conditions, all over the world. We all want abundance don't we? A house, safety, a garden with a fruit tree that grows old as we do. Not a return to serfdom under the new Lairds. Governments should be concentrating on the flourishing of life, the joy of living, serving and protecting us, beautifying and repairing, that's what we work hard and pay them for. Instead we get chaos.
We love our N.H.S. We are proud of it and it's faults. In my book I am biased, they saved my life. Although at the time not knowing how ill I was. I was taken by Ambulance to a hospital 21 miles from my home. On arriving one of the paramedics said it's going to be an all nighter 😮. There are 15 we are the 16th Ambulance. Pardon what ?. The paramedic said on some occasions our shift finished we returned the following day to find the patient still in the Ambulance. A senior doctor arrived accompanied by a ward sister and junior doctor entered the Ambulance and said," this patient needs to be in the ward NOW. Well I didn't wait long to get into a ward. At least I am here to tell the tale.
IMMIGRANTS GET OLD TOO
IM SICK OF THIS FANCIFUL IDEOLOGY
WE ARE FULL THE SYSTEM IS CRUMBLING AND WHEN ITS GONE THEY WILL STILL SAY WE NEED MORE
The system scales with its occupants. It's not a fixed sized pie. Give them the opportunity to pay tax, and everything works. In fact it works better due to the economies of scale.
Canada is also worryinv about the aging population, so lots of immigrants. So 50 years from now, these Muslim famllies with 6+ children will be the aging population. Immigration today will create a worse problem in the future.
Best part of that was Douglas Murray.
The issue with importing large numbers of health professionals is that they leave behind a crumbling health service in their own countries. Doctors and nurses don’t grow on trees if takes years and years of training and investment. No wonder we have health tourists here.
This is not a political failure it's gone perfectly to plan
Civil unrest is probably part of the plan, too.
whenever i go a&e the duty dr has like a 30minute coffee break after seeing each patient
We need more people we've had about 10 million in since 2000. It needs to be remembered that immigration affects people differently but the poor who are very much disproportionately affected.
Taking in more people to deal with the depleted services is like saying give more drugs to the addicts so they don’t feel the withdrawal symptoms, absolute irrational women, Esther schooled the argument
Esther Krakue, as always, the voice of common sense. I love her to bits! That Paula woman makes my blood boil. In her head, it's all about more of the ethnic minorities coming into this tiny island. Piers should have asked her what she considers as the maximum population that this country can sustain. I guarantee she wouldn't have an answer. It's blatantly clear to everyone who lives in this country that it has been massively overcrowded for many years. In my lifetime alone, the population has increased from 50 million to 70 million plus. However, this woman clearly doesn't live in the real world when she says we need more and more immigrants. Whoever said that the muslims' aim is to convert this country into a complete muslim community was absolutely right. You only have to look at the average number of offspring they produce compared to other religions. In the past, I have worked with a Pakistani muslim who had 9 kids by 3 different women....nice!! I doubt that this is unusual. All I can say is that I'm glad I won't be around to witness it!
Why you generalising?
I take it you're asking 'Why ARE you generalising?'@@sib1930 In what sense exactly? I thought my message was blatantly clear.
The one on the right is clearly insane
How does this woman not understand that more people equals more problems… 🤦🏼♂️
Our public services are on their knees. My wife works in an infants school and there are massive problems there which never get mentioned. It’s no wonder that the far right is on the rise.
Piers should have confronted her more on that, we aren't willing to sacrifice our only true home in this turbulent world for the sacred GDP !. It's time to look to our own people and get them to work these jobs for an actual living wage for a family not an immigrant sharing a house of 10 paying £30 pounds a week in rent.
I’ve had enough now,I used to be tolerant but the militant attitude of the people that have arrived here shouting to take over has pushed me the other way.
Anyone already here stays we deal with it.
No new arrivals legal or otherwise from now onwards, 750,000 people in one year is a bloody disgrace!
This won’t be for the better meant of anyone to have this country turned into an immigrant country.
I am sick of it,I’m sure the majority of us far right people are too.
Yes I’m far right now due to be ignored for 20years and loving my country the way it was.
Are we building 700000 houses every year? No. So there'll be massive pressure on housing stock. Supply and demand
Plus the need for more schools health centres ect.
It isn't "can we take", it is 'do the people want more people'
More people? Fkg hell
70 million ain’t enough apparently 🙄
This country would be so much better if we only had half as many people but unfortunately we're going in the opposite direction our destiny is to become like Bangladesh a giant city slum island
We don't have the infrastructure to deal with what we currently have, so the answer is to have more people.. with the same infrastructure.. right..
@@motey99 you need more people or UK will end up a poor little island
@@hassyg4083 we’ve had More immigration year after year after year ffs and things are still crap so what’s your point 🤔
thing is, non-african and non-Muslim migrants are generally great. Africans have some lingering issues from times of slavery and colonialosm, exacerbated by negative pop culture, but in general they are good migrants who integrate.
many Muslims are too, but the difference is that they have very strong value systems that are in opposition to our own, and very very strong loyalty to their own. if it comes to a conflict of interest (which it will) then even the moderates and secular Muslims will side with their own
She’s right because we all know that immigrants are never ill. They are in perfect health when they arrive and they don’t get old 🤡💩🇬🇧
No wonder Africa is in a mess
"We need more immigrants to support our public services"
Why are public services already failing? How is bringing more of the problem going to be a solution?
Perhaps if UK had less people (specially those who came ilegaly) there wouldn't be need to service so many people, to find home for so many people and to pay benefits to so many people.
The taxpayer pays for the public services, so where is the net benefit of bringing in foreigners to work in them? Unless they're being paid at least 50K they are a net burden.
The argument that services like the NHS benefit from immigration has a shred of truth but it's looking at the positive while ignoring all the negatives.
What is in effect happening (ignoring intangibles such as national identity and societal issues like ghettoisation) is that successive governments have been playing Jenga with the economy, using immigrant workers to garner extra votes and as a short term economic stimulus while degrading the national infrastructure that the whole rests upon.
The problem with this is that you can only pull out so many blocks from the bottom while adding to the top before the whole system collapses!
😂😂oh we need more people do we
The lady on the right is delusional!
15 million is not enough apparently. Look at the state of the economy, soo much for that great immigration wave
@@paulsmusic2908 UK the richest still in all EU lol
@@hassyg4083 See I've never understood that? We have no houses, oldest retirement age, smallest pension, crippled health service, depleted army forces, longest waiting lists to see a doctor and we are £3 Trillion in debt. It doesn't sound like we are very rich at all but I am sure you can point me in right direction?
@@paulsmusic2908no body bothers to learn the economics of it all and are just ignorant in their opinions, the whole world is drowning in debt and most people don't even notice it
It’s a circle , more skilled people come in then more needed to support them come in as well for health and education. One causes the other
Just no more.❤
Its not needed close the doors and take care of of your citizens
Its creacking because it under pressure to cope with so many,she wants more people to fix it🤷
The UK does not "need" any more immigration, it "needs" a program of active de-population. This could be achieved by simply not issuing or renewing visas, caps should be put on the amount of foreign students able to be accepted by universities. Citizenship tests should be made a lot harder more expensive and limited in numbers. Everyone always seems to look at the UK's problems with housing, infrastructure etc as being one of build more stuff as opposed to remove the demand. The future in most industry is automation, why on earth do we need to keep on importing more people when in 20 years time there won't be anything for them to do. With smaller class sizes better education can be delivered, less traffic on the road etc it's becoming ridiculous in the South of the UK, it's a very claustrophobic to live compared to even 25 years ago.
Mr. Murray is spot on. But he scratches merely the surface. I recommend to read OSWALD SPENGLER "Der Untergang des Abendlandes, Werk 1 und 2" and Huntington "Clash of Civilizations" and hear the Hungarian Professor of Politics Bogar Laszlo who educated the present president of Hungary Victor Orban, when he was young. And of course I am reading on Saturdays and Sundays out of all these books loud to my family members and add to these readings Douglas Murray s works. Best regards. König E Julia, a real German German Woman who does not suffer of masochism, as Mr. Murray mentioned.
Ireland has fallen 😢🇮🇪😢
Well the Celtic fans like to wave their Palestinian flags!
@@nutcracker2916I didn't mention flags but seen as you have , most Celtic supporters are Scottish, next it's Northern Ireland and then randomly throughout Ireland (ROI).
Mostly Sinn Gein IRA Supporters who know little about Palestine and even less about the current stage of the conflict... they are virtue signallers looking for a cause just like Sinn Fein and the IRA.
The fact that Piers gives air time to the "debate" of whether we need more people just shows you how much an enemy of the people he is!
I work in healthcare, most of my employees are from overseas. They're all fit healthy people, so don't take much from the system. We desperately need more people to work in healthcare
Who funds the healthcare?
As an American I’m rethinking this socialized healthcare.