Survivor - What if Final 3s Were Final 2s
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 9 ก.พ. 2025
- In this video, I talk about what I think would have happened if all of the final 3s were to have been final 2s instead. I might as well mention here how I realized that discarding the first jury member actually makes it so that some of these final 2s could have accidentally tied so with certain seasons it would have been smarter to not do that, but it never ended up affecting the result so I guess it doesn't matter.
Imagine cagayan had a final three and this video was made. No one would ever think woo would take tony to the end instead of kass
This comment is so accurate
Tony would still win tho
@@brissa1x467 yeah
Yeah but based on his rules Kass would choose who to vote out but the finale would probably stay the same. She did say though that she would bring Tony at one point hoping for a bitter jury.
Hi Sierd 😘
I did a zoom call with Kelly Wentworth once and she told me she would never, ever vote for Chris. She didn’t respect that he was already voted out so I think she votes for Julie and I think with that Lauren probably votes Julie as well. But it doesn’t matter because Chris still wins
Kelly voteted cris
No she voted Gavin
סיון תורגמן
What up Liam lmao. Its Jonah. You literally beat me to the punch
JPB productions hey bro. Yo u we’re on that zoom call too 😂
Liam Duffy lmao. Small world. I think Chris beats Julie in an 11-3 vote with Kelley, Lauren, and Gavin all voting Julie to win and the other 11 jurors vote Chris. I think it’s possible that Aurora votes Julie to win over Chris making it 10-4 but no one else I think votes Julie to win
such an underrated channel
Agreed
Yup. One of my favorite channels!
This and peridiam are the best survivor/TAR/big brother channels ever lol
@@rainischalk-late3540 I co sign this... Facts
Such an underrated comment
I’ve never seen a hypothetical like this before, it’s interesting to think about :)
Honestly, if there was a final two of Michelle and Natalie in WaW, it would’ve been sick for Michelle to win. Imagine the narrative of going from one of the most controversial and arguably undeserving winners to winning an all winners season with a similar game.
Woud have loved a Michelle Final 2 win!
Michelle’s win would have been right below here 1st win in the winner rankings
Queen Michelle 🙌🏼🙌🏼
She didn't really have a similar game in WaW. I know because I used to literally hate Michelle with a burning passion just for beating Tai (Yes, I think Tai should have won) but her game in WaW really won back my respect.
Like 5 people wanted to vote Michele because Natalie did some pretty sketchy to downright bullying stuff on the Edge but they were so afraid of her winning they voted Tony. Adam, Wendell, Yul, Danni, Nick at least planned to vote for her.
It was confirmed Natalie had 7 locked votes but lost 3 of them to Tony. If there was a final 2 between her and Michele, Natalie would have won. The jury confirmed this in interviews.
@@randomyoutuber0524 Who were Natalie's 7 locked votes supposably.
The issue with this is that strategies change when people play for a final 2 versus a final 3. A lot of the time I think we’d end up with a different final 3 than we got if people think they’re playing for a final 2.
Agreed, but this is why it’s just speculation. It’s for fun.
yeah for this we have to treat it like it is surprise final 2s like Micronesia
Michele would definitely deserve the 2-time winner rank. Being one of the "worst" winners (not in my opinion), being on the bottom the whole game then coming back in the final 2 with an amazing game already??Yup
Todd said on his AMA that he would've voted Courtney in an Amanda/Courtney/Denise FTC so I see no different in an Amanda/Courtney FTC. Also he said that Courtney actually was winning going into FTC and that no one thought she did bad, but that Todd did amazing to steal some votes. So...Courtney beats Amanda.
I really don’t think that this has much truth past him maybe voting Courtney, which I think at the time he wouldn’t have, true. Amanda and Todd had a falling out (not Amanda and Parv scale), and Courtney is still one of his best friends so I imagine he’s going to sing Courtney’s praises as much as he can.
What is the ideal age to participate on Survivor ? I discussed about it on that video: th-cam.com/video/OTSaEBwzYVE/w-d-xo.html
@@HayatnHileleri shut up :]
Also Peih Gee said in an interview that she got very close to voting for Courtney just for her ability to explain and own her strategy to make it to the end. So with Todd, Denise, James and Peih Gee, Courtney would have won China
Yeah pretty much the cast came to the consensus to vote Courtney over Amanda
We could only hope that in an alternate survivor reality, courtney wins survivor China. Butt hey, all three there are good.
Michele winning WaW yep yep that works with my fantasy
Fantasy if tony isnt in the finale.
I think it’s possible gabby votes for Angelina, not that she wanted Angelina to win, but if it were a final 2, nick would have it locked up, so she may have thrown a vote for Angelina
An interesting idea for a smaller video would be what if the final 4 fire making twist was never a thing
I really like that idea! If it was the forced fire making challenge from HHH onwards, then that could be pretty cool!
I'm thinking chrissy wins 35
Wendell still wins 36 for it being a 2/2 tie vote, with him and ang. He still wins that and the game.
I'm not sure about 37, but I'm thinking maybe it's a 3-1 on Mike. And nick still wins but not too sure on that. It could still be a 3-1 on kara too but from the edit, it looked a little clear no one wanted to take Mike to the end.
38, Rick gets voted out 3-1, and Chris still wins. No question.
39, I think Lauren gets voted out 3-1 and Tommy still wins, there's a slight possibility there's still a fire making challenge between her and deen but I don't think she gets Tommy's vote to stay.
For season 40, I think this is the most interesting one, where it's most likely a 2-2 vote on Tony and Michele. Tony can get voted out by Sarah in a 3-1 vote and that would be really interesting. Sarah probably wins, not just on post game interviews but pre game, there were a lot of women saying that Sarah was the biggest threat to win. So, she can win, but it could still be up in the air. Now, Would tony win fire against Michele? Maybe not, and he could get voted out still. But if he wins that, he just wins the season.
Cool video idea!
can't win I think Devon wins HHH honestly
HHH: Ben is voted out and Devon wins.
GI: Wendell is voted out and Dom wins.
DvG: Nick still wins.
EEE: Chris still wins.
IOI: Tommy is still taken to the end and still wins.
WAW: Tony is voted out and Sarah wins.
Might as well do this for the modern seasons:
41: This is a difficult one because the edit made it unclear how a vote like this would have gone. I think it's likely that we get a 2-2 split between Deshawn and one of Erika/Heather. In Deshawn Vs Heather we know the result already, but Erika vs Deshawn would be interesting, although I think Deshawn would still win firemaking here. Either way, if Erika gets voted out here Heather wins the season instead (judging by post-season interviews Heather did have a respected game by the jury as her game was very similar to that of Erika's and they worked together all season), and if not then Erika still wins as usual and nothing changes.
42: A pretty clear 3-1 against Jonathan, in which case he still loses and Maryanne still wins as nothing changes.
43: Jesse gets voted out 3-1. However I think that without the firemaking twist, Cassidy actually wins. The jury blamed Cassidy's loss on her not throwing herself into firemaking. Without that I think Jeanine, Noelle, Ryan and Sami would all vote for Cassidy to win alongside James. Karla was clearly never voting for Cassidy and I think Cody would have voted for his ally Gabler. However the jury's logic regarding firemaking IS flawed and I think it's very likely that Cassidy still loses due to the jury being bitter (although it's worth noting here that Jesse would be less bitter against Cassidy as he would not hold her responsible for his boot so she might gain his vote here and get the win).
with becky it depends on if the jury gives her strategic credit for the yul moves or if they just think of her as a coattail rider
Sort of agree, but I also can't see how she wins. Ozzy would obviously still get the 4 votes he got over Yul and Becky already, and no chance at all Adam votes Becky over Ozzy. He didn't even want to vote Yul over Ozzy, but did due to his deal with Yul. So that is already at worst 5 votes for Ozzy, so he can't lose, unless possibly it goes to a 7 person jury. I do think Becky has a good shot of getting all 4 of Candice, Penner, Sundra, Yul over Ozzy, regardless if they give her credit for the Yul moves or not, since Penner and Candice both hated Ozzy, Sundra was closer to Becky, and Yul is obvious, so even that part doesn't matter much, as she probably gets those 4 whether they give her credit or not.
I would be 100% okay with Amanda winning China. That would mean we might get Todd back for a future season.
Yeah I agree. I’ve always wanted to see Todd play again.
Clearly, you don't pay attention. Todd's not playing again because he's been struggling with alcoholism, not because he doesn't want to play again or that production doesn't want him back. He's to much of a risk factor not only to himself, but to production as well.
@@flamrage3743 clearly we don’t give a shit. Stop trying to talk down to people buddy, it’s 2020, wake up.
@@flamrage3743 I've actually paid very close attention to his mental health issues and struggles with addiction. I actually follow him on Instagram with is POP figures as well!
I simply said it would mean we would see him because they had Amanda playing 3 times in a period of 5 seasons. He's easily the best 1 time player in my opinion.
@@iandean1112 Oh I know he's a great player. The point that I was trying to make is that because of his current mental state, it's very unlikely that we'll ever see him play again. I realize that how it came out may have seem condescending and I apologize for that.
This channel deserves more subscribers
Kim said when answering Christina’s jury question that she would’ve taken Sabrina with her to the final 2 if it had been a final 2 instead of a final 3. Yes she may have done that as a way of working the jury because maybe she felt like the jury was cropped with more Sabrina stans than Chelsea stans but Kim was probably telling the truth
I love your Survivor videos!
The way that Rob in Redemption Island got not only himself but all his entire Ometepe tribe post-merge to the end was truly impressive. And still Ralph could not reward that by giving Rob his vote in either a final 3 or a final 2. No respect for Ralph.
Well if anyone but Phillip or Natalie are at the end, there are a lot more people besides just Ralph who aren't voting him.
You should do a scenario where each final member of the jury wins the final immunity challenge. For example, in Palau, if Ian won immunity and took Katie, meaning Tom would be booted and it would be between Katie and Ian. Or as an example for a final 3, in Edge of Extinction, if Rick won immunity and took Julie, putting Gavin and Chris into a fire challenge which Chris likely wins, meaning the final 3 would be Rick, Julie, and Chris.
11:21 Ralph said he only voted for Phillip so that Natalie would get 3rd place. Without both of them in the finals, I do think he votes for Rob
I think he still votes Phillip over Rob even in a F2. He definitely votes Rob over Natalie though, he thought she was a joke.
I wonder if Ralph votes Phillip in every alternate Final 3 with Phillip and Natalie in it to ensure Natalie gets 3rd each time? Mind you if we are counting the entire merge and even the craziest hypothetical Final 3s there are some Final 3s with say one of the weaker Zapatera in it Rob might vote Natalie in. Can't see any of Ashley, Andrea, David, Mike, Matt, Grant, Julie, Steve, ever voting either Natalie or Phillip in any universe ever in a Final 3.
"With Phillip...I ain't gonna say he's crazy. Phillip I think is playing the game. He is the best player I have seen so far that has played the game, that's left. He's trying to make enemies and he's not doing it. You think you'd get rid of the enemy. They're not trying to get rid of him. I think Phillip is doing the best at the game playing-because I don't think that's himself, in real life, out here in the real world. He is the best player." - Ralph
I think Ralph votes Phillip every time except if Mike is up there. Phillip's only possible votes would be Ralph and Rob. Natalie's only possible votes are Ashley and Rob. Ashley and Rob would never vote either unless they're up against the weaker Zaps though.
My predictions and opinions (Cook Islands - Winners at War):
Cook Islands:
Becky Lee vs. Ozzy Lusth: Ozzy wins 5-4 as Adam votes for Ozzy. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Ozzy.
Ozzy Lusth vs. Yul Kwon: Yul still wins 5-4 as Becky votes for Yul. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Ozzy.
Realistic Final Two: Becky Lee vs. Ozzy Lusth
Fiji:
Earl Cole vs. Dreamz Herd: Earl still wins unanimously. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Earl.
Cassandra Franklin vs. Dreamz Herd: Cassandra wins 7-2 or 8-1 regardless of how Earl or Yau-Man vote in this scenario. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Cassandra.
Realistic Final Two: Cassandra Franklin vs. Dreamz Herd
China:
Amanda Kimmel vs. Courtney Yates: Amanda wins 4-3 or 5-2 or Courtney wins 4-3 or 5-2 depending on Todd or Peih-Gee. I personally believe Amanda wins despite her lackluster Final Tribal Council performance because Courtney was more unlikeable, Amanda played a stronger game, and Courtney's Final Tribal Council performance was not good either. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Amanda.
Amanda Kimmel vs. Todd Herzog: Todd wins 4-3 or 5-2 regardless of how Denise votes but I am inclined to think she votes for Todd. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Amanda.
Realistic Final Two: Amanda Kimmel vs. Courtney Yates
Gabon:
Bob Crowley vs. Susie Smith: Bob still wins 4-3 as Sugar would have voted for Bob, but if Sugar voted for Susie, then Susie would have won 4-3. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Bob.
Sugar Kiper vs. Susie Smith: Susie wins either unanimously or 6-1 depending on how Bob votes, but I think Bob votes for Susie. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Susie.
Realistic Final Two: Sugar Kiper vs. Susie Smith
Samoa:
Russell Hantz vs. Natalie White: Natalie still wins but either 7-2 or 6-3 regardless of how Mick votes but I think Mick votes for Russell. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Natalie.
Russell Hantz vs. Mick Trimming: Mick wins 7-2 or 6-3 depending on Natalie's vote, but I think Natalie votes for Mick. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Mick.
Realistic Final Two: Russell Hantz vs. Natalie White
Heroes vs. Villains:
Sandra Diaz-Twine vs. Russell Hantz: Sandra still wins but unanimously. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Sandra.
Russell Hantz vs. Parvati Shallow: Parvati wins unanimously. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Parvati.
Realistic Final Two: Sandra Diaz-Twine vs. Russell Hantz
Nicaragua:
Fabio Birza vs. Chase Rice: Fabio still wins but either 5-4 or 6-3 with or without Sash's vote. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Fabio.
Fabio Birza vs. Sash Lenahan: Fabio still wins but unanimously or 8-1 or 7-2 or 6-3 despite the votes of Chase, Holly, and Brenda. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Fabio.
Realistic Final Two: Fabio Birza vs. Sash Lenahan
Redemption Island:
Rob Mariano vs. Phillip Sheppard: Rob still wins 8-1. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Rob.
Rob Mariano vs. Natalie Tenerelli: Rob still wins 8-1. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Rob.
Realistic Final Two: Rob Mariano vs. Phillip Sheppard
South Pacific:
Sophie Clarke vs. Albert Destrade: Sophie still wins but unanimously. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Sophie.
Sophie Clarke vs. Coach Wade: Sophie still wins, but either 7-3 or 6-4 depending on Albert's vote. I think Albert votes for Coach. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Coach.
Realistic Final Two: Sophie Clarke vs. Albert Destrade
One World:
Kim Spradlin vs. Sabrina Thompson: Kim still wins 7-2. If I was a juror, I a would have voted for Kim.
Chelsea Messiner vs. Kim Spradlin: Kim still wins but unanimously. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Kim.
Realistic Scenario: Chelsea Messiner vs. Kim Spradlin
Philippines:
Michael Skupin vs. Denise Stapley: Denise still wins but 7-2. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Denise.
Michael Skupin vs. Lisa Welchel: Lisa wins 6-3. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Lisa.
Realistic Scenario: Michael Skupin vs. Lisa Welchel
Caramoan:
Sherri Biethman vs. John Cochran: John still wins unanimously. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Sherri.
John Cochran vs. Dawn Meehan: John still wins either unanimously or 8-1. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Dawn.
Realistic Scenario: John Cochran vs. Dawn Meehan
Blood vs. Water:
Tyson Apostol vs. Gervase Peterson: Tyson still wins but unanimously. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Tyson.
Tyson Apostol vs. Monica Culpepper: Tyson still wins but 8-1. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Tyson.
Realistic Scenario: Tyson Apostol vs. Gervase Peterson
San Juan Del Sur:
Natalie Anderson vs. Jaclyn Schultz: Natalie still wins but 8-1. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Natalie.
Missy Payne vs. Jaclyn Schultz: Jaclyn wins 8-1. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Jaclyn.
Realistic Scenario: Missy Payne vs. Jaclyn Schultz
Worlds Apart:
Mike Holloway vs. Carolyn Rivera: Mike still wins but 7-2. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Carolyn.
Mike Holloway vs. Will Sims II: Mike still wins but 8-1. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Mike.
Realistic Scenario: Mike Holloway vs. Carolyn Rivera
Cambodia:
Spender Bledsoe vs. Jeremy Collins: Jeremy still wins unanimously. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Jeremy.
Jeremy Collins vs. Tasha Fox: Jeremy still wins unanimously. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Jeremy.
Realistic Scenario: Jeremy Collins vs. Tasha Fox
Kaoh Rong:
Aubry Bracco vs. Michele Fitzgerald: Michele still wins but 4-3. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Michele.
Michele Fitzgerald vs. Tai Trang: Michele still wins 5-2. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Michele.
Realistic Scenario: Michele Fitzgerald vs. Tai Trang
Millennials vs. Gen X:
Adam Klein vs. Ken McNickle: Adam still wins unanimously. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Adam.
Ken McNickle vs. Hannah Shapiro: Hannah wins 9-1. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Hannah.
Realistic Scenario: Ken McNickle vs. Hannah Shapiro
Game Changers:
Brad Culpepper vs. Troyzan Robertson: Brad wins 6-4. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Troyzan.
Brad Culpepper vs. Sarah Lacina: Sarah still wins but 6-4. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Sarah.
Realistic Scenario: Brad Culpepper vs. Troyzan Robertson
Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers:
Ben Driebergen vs. Chrissy Hoefbeck: Ben still wins but 5-4. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Ben.
Chrissy Hoefbeck vs. Ryan Ulrich: Chrissy wins 5-4. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Chrissy.
Realistic Scenario: Chrissy Hoefbeck vs. Ryan Ulrich
Ghost Island:
Domenick Abbate vs. Laurel Johnson: Domenick wins either unanimously or 10-1 or 9-1. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Laurel.
Domenick Abbate vs. Wendell Holland: Wendell still wins but either 6-4 or 6-5. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Wendell.
Realistic Scenario: Domenick Abbate vs. Laurel Johnson
David vs. Goliath:
Mike White vs. Nick Wilson: Nick still wins 7-3 or 7-4. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Nick.
Angelina Keeley vs. Nick Wilson: Nick wins unanimously. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Nick.
Realistic Scenario: Angelina Keeley vs. Nick Wilson
Edge of Extinction:
Chris Underwood vs. Gavin Whitson: Chris still wins but either 9-5 or 10-4. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Chris.
Julie Rosenberg vs. Chris Underwood: Chris still wins but unanimously. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Chris.
Realistic Scenario: Julie Rosenberg vs. Chris Underwood
Island of the Idols:
Dean Kowalski vs. Noura Salmon: Dean wins unanimously. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Dean.
Noura Salmon vs. Tommy Sheehan: Tommy wins unanimously. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Tommy.
Realistic Scenario: Noura Salmon vs. Tommy Sheehan
Winners at War:
Natalie Anderson vs. Tony Vlachos: Tony still wins but 12-5. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Natalie.
Natalie Anderson vs. Michele Fitzgerald: Michele wins either 9-8 or 10-7 or 11-6. If I was a juror, I would have voted for Natalie.
Realistic Scenario: Natalie Anderson vs. Michele Fitzgerald
Rafe does not vote Natalie over Rob, LOL! The main reason he voted Ralph in the first place was to drop Natalie to 3rd.
I think Tony beats Natalie A 13-4. No idea why you think Michele would not vote Tony when she called him the one to beat constantly, which is why she was one of the few trying (in vein) to get him out.
Elizabeth, Missy, Aaron all hated Tommy, so not sure if he beats Noura unanimously or not.
What I think:
Cook Islands: Ozzy wins
Fiji: Cassandra wins
China: Amanda wins
Gabon: Susie wins
Samoa: Natalie wins
Heroes vs Villains: Sandra wins
Nicaragua: Fabio wins
Redemption island: Boston Rob wins
South Pacific: Sophie wins
One World: Kim wins
Philippines: Lisa wins
Caramoan: Cochran wins
Blood vs Water: Tyson wins
San Juan Del sur: Jaclyn wins
Worlds Apart: Mike wins
Cambodia: Jeremy wins
Kaoh Rong: Michele wins
Millennials vs Gen x: Hannah wins
Game Changers: Brad wins
Heroes vs Healers vs Hustlers: Ryan wins
Ghost Island: Domenick wins
David vs Goliath: Nick wins
Edge of extinction: Chris wins
Island of the idols: Dean wins
Winners at war: Natalie
Damn instead of Tony, Michelle can be two time winner 👁️👄👁️
In china I think courtney wins , she spoke better than he in the last tribal council...
@@ricardosalmeron1946 PERIODT
I think on China Amanda would still lose against Courtney, because amanda is really bad at explaining herself
Wajrasena YY Winchele Queensgerald
If the players knew there would be a Final 2, they would change their gameplay. You wouldn't get the exact same 3 people at the end on each given season.
13:36 does anybody know why Troyzan and Lief would not vote Kim, especially Troyzan?
25:46 I think she takes Dean. Supposedly she took Tommy to the end because Lauren would beat him in fire, and Noura didn’t want to go up against Lauren in FTC. This is the only instance where the final immunity winner takes someone they put in the fire-making challenge
I'm also okay with Michelle being a 2 time winner.
As long as we don’t get the evil timeline where Natalie wins.
I’m not. I would rather Sarah win WAW, and I’ve never been so mad at a player than I was at Sarah at final 6 and 5
@@voodoomcspaghettipants4082 Sarah did absolutely play the best game, but I loved Michele's story of playing from the bottom and finding a way to get through!
@@voodoomcspaghettipants4082 i think they meant in a Natalie-Michele situation because sarah or Tony beat anyone. but I think Michele wins and I'm fine with that
Logan Hall
Omg if natalie won, literally this season would be ranked 40/40. Like literally all the episodes you would need to watch would be the first and the last. 🤮 🤮 I’m sorry that’s disguting
I agree with everything except China.
Amanda's Incapability of answering Jury votes properly would probably land Courtney the win. I mean she could be in Final two or three for the next 5 seasons and would STILL lose the jury votes 😅
...She could be in final two with a ROCK. and that rock would STILL win 😬😂😂😂😂😂😂
just like micronesia
I love this channel man.
One thing to consider in Gabon is sugar outright quitting at f3 to give Bob the win because she knew she would never win s jury vote. The other thing to consider is that the onion alliance blamed Susie for flipping on Markus
Even if Corrine blames Susie, she still hated Sugar so much, there is no way she is ever voting her, even over Susie. So adding her to Matty, Ken, Crystal, who already voted Susie over both Sugar and Bob, and Susie wins with atleast 4 locked votes. Even if Charlie and Randy decide to vote Sugar somehow, and Bob does too.
Interesting video. Would be interesting to see the exact same thing but with Big Brother and how much that would end up changing things (assuming the final 3 faced the jury and the last pre-jury boot would get added to it).
21 out of 25 final tribal councils with three finalists have seen at least one finalist get zero votes. This tells me they should go back to final twos as a matter of course, since apparently they hardly ever have three people worthy of consideration.
20 actually. China, Philippines, del saur, world apart, and HHH are all 3 people finale with all getting votes
Morgan Kingsley Oh, I misses S30. Thanks. I think the point still stands.
It never should’ve been a final 3. It’s such a phony way to end the game and it’s clearly a production exploit and not part of the soul of the game. Survivor is a game of numbers where the majority chooses elimination until a majority can no longer be formed. Making it to the final 2 (when a majority can no longer possibly be formed) is truly making it as far as you can go in the game. Going from 3>1 feels like the game is being cheated by production.
Jaclyn definitely takes Missy to the end because she was just picking who deserved to win between Keith and Natalie
Michelle winning winners at war would have be the funniest thing ever people would have been so mad
Man, I love this videos!!!
Honestly I would have liked the final 2 thing happening in winners at war cause one of Tonys biggest moves was convincing woo to take him and it would have been funny, also Michelle played an excellent underdog game and it redeems her not deserving it over Aubry backlash she gets and she would be the only winner on the season to not be voted out and 2 time winner
Will you do what if the final 2s will be be final 3s for big brother
I second this so incredibly hard
I didn't plan on doing it right away, but I'm sure I will get around to it at some point.
TheMeranianReview it would be interesting to see finals like Janelle be in 2 final 3s or like in bb17 where Vanessa Rousso would be in the final 3 and BB21 where Nicole A would be there.
AccessDenied247 yea I would love to speculate if Vanessa would actually have the votes to win. I could care less about Nicole tho. She was very boring for me. Bb19 would also be interesting, bc the anti-Paul votes may have been split between Josh and xmas
Voodoo McSpaghettipants yeah I don’t actually Vanessa would win because of people being bitter and also the possibility of Xmas wining would so funny
I really can’t see Noura taking Tommy because from what I understood the reason she didn’t make Tommy go to fire is because he convinced her Lauren was the biggest threat and that he wouldn’t be able to beat her in firemaking but if she has to choose between dean and Tommy I think she recognizes that she can’t beat Tommy.
I’ve been waiting for this!
Leif votes for Kim if its a Kim vs Chelsea scenario because he voted Sabrina only because of their bond. So Leif wasn't exactly bitter towards Kim.
What if Final 3's were Final 10's with a 2 Person Jury System!
I wish you had at least addressed the possibility that someone else wins final 3 immunity, especially for scenarios with multiple physical threats still left in the game.
15:28 When answering Aras’s jury question, Monica stated she would vote for Tyson against Gervase
Great job!! The only qualm I might have is the fact that Sarah had Brads wedding ring. I'm worried he would take her for that reason
He would not even give his wedding ring to her as collateral if it were a F2.
You were right about everything except Noura vs. Dean. Its been confirmed that Dean loses to everyone, including Noura and Karishma.
Skyler Jones no way I believe that
@@minun73 Its not that hard to believe, he played a pretty horrible game and the only impact he had was when he flipped on the plan to take out Tommy, which was horrible for his game.
Nobody would lose to Karishma. Even Dan would beat her.
@@robdurdain5912 people respected her more which is a lot to say abt deans game
@@devondonato4609 Nobody respected Karishma more than anyone. The cast all said in the interviews after for awhile everyone wanted to take her to F3 since she was the easiest to beat in the whole cast.
6:38 I don’t think any of them would vote for Sugar, especially Corinne and Randy. Just imagine Sugar as a winner
this changes everything in heroes vs villains because he would not have taken out Jerri in final 4 because he thought it as his vote knowing it was a final 2 Parvati would go first
I don’t think that changes anything. If he decided to keep Jerri, and somehow take her to the final 2 he would still lose. People weren’t huge fans of Jerri but by no means did they dislike her as much as they disliked Russel. He loses against all of the potential people he could take to the final 2. Remember, that jury was PISSED and they had every right to be. There was no way Russel was winning that game. He was the goat in the final 3 and he would’ve been in the final 2.
@@ariellee2329 what I meant was going to beat Sandra because people liked Jerri and I truly believe she beats Sandra I know Russell does not win
Why do you think Russell will choose Sandra? They might have a fall off on F7, but Russell had on mind of Parv as his number 1 since day 1. He always think that the jury wont allow two time winner. And he's kinda obsessed with her, I think he still take Parv
14:19 RC is taken off the jury, and Penner likely votes for Lisa over Skupin
Michelle has the best jury management compared to ANYONE who plays.
She does have bad game play but I think that out balance her jury management skills
I love the idea of this video, but the flaw is that we assume the person whom won final 4 immunity would win the final 3 immunity challenge. For example natalie won in WAW where I think her and Michelle vote out Tony, but the next challenge would've been between Sarah, Nat, and Michelle where we dont know what would've happened
except that final four still probably ends in a fire challenge with Michelle and Tony instead of tony and Sarah in fire and I think that takes Michelle out then if Nat wins final three takes out Tony and then I think Sarah wins but if either Tony or Sarah win final Immunity then its both of them in final 2
@@michaelbowman2574 I honestly think Sarah Votes Tony out there? She knows she can't beat him and if he wins final 2 he definitely doesn't take her. I know they're close but I just can't see it
Now that you’ve done these 2 videos on final 2/3’s, can you make a video where you create your ideal updated Winners at War cast based on your updated winners list?
Island of the Idols hot take: no matter who Noura took, she gets swept. I feel like Michele would have won over Natalie. I would be okay with this.
I would be so devastated if tony got off tho XD
That's not even a hot take...
i thought dean would've been swept
I don’t think that’s a hot take, I don’t even think that’s a take it’s just a fact
Could you do a what if video for what if the winner of each season’s biggest threat got to the end instead of them? And like who would win
That's a good one👍
So, I went with whoever had the best post-merge challenge record, so it's more about who's most likely to win Final Immunity. Granted, it doesn't take into account what kind of challenges they're good at, so... take it with a grain of salt.
Cook Islands: Ozzy (6-1-0)
Fiji: Dreamz (3-2-2)
China: Amanda (5-2-1)
Gabon: Bob (5-2-0)
Samoa: Russell (3-1-1)
Heroes Vs Villains: Parvati (3-2-0)
Nicaragua: Fabio (5-4-2)
Redemption: Rob (4-1-0)
South Pacific: Sophie (3-1-0)
One World: Kim (6-2-2)
Philippines: Michael (3-2-1)
Caramoan: Cochran (6-2-0)
Blood Vs Water: Monica (3-2-1)
San Juan Del Sur: Natalie (4-2-2)
Worlds Apart: Mike (9-5-2)
Cambodia: Spencer (5-2-1)
Kaoh Rong: Michele (6-5-1)
MvGX: Ken (5-2-1)
Game Changers: Brad (8-2-1)
HvHvH: Chrissy (8-1-1)
Ghost Island: Domenick (4-4-1) (Broke the tie since Dom won final imm)
DvG: Nick (5-4-1)
EoE: Gavin (4-3-2)
IoI: Tommy (4-3-3) (Funny thing is, the only challenges Tommy ended up winning were reward challenges)
WaW: Tony (4-3-2)
Where has it been stated that Missy is getting Jeremy and Natalie's votes?
I believe at the reunion for San Juan del Sur they made it cleat that they would've voted for Missy over Jaclyn and Keith if Natalie had been voted out at the final four but it's been so long Idk
Jon would still vote Jaclyn? Or would be keep Keith from winning by voting Missy?@@kimspradlin4272
I would love to see an all time top 10 amazing race teams
Todd said he votes for Courtney over Amanda if he’s on the jury and he made a comment on his AMA where he said that Courtney beats Amanda
I’m not convinced. Jamie, Peih Gee and Erik were never going to vote Courtney, Frosti said in an interview that he wasn’t going to vote for Courtney because he wanted to vote for who played the best game and Jean Robert and Courtney mutually despised each other…
12:13 Jim Rice was the first to officially join the jury, so I would swap him out
Yeah I think if bob is on the jury he almost always votes for sugar, Susie was never getting his vote
I think Michelle wins against Natalie. I think the jurors knew how terribly received Chris was for playing 11 days, and this is to special of a season for someone like Natalie who plays 6 days. And didn't a few jurors publicly state they voted for Tony so Natalie wouldn't win.
Ken promised he would take Adam to the end so I mean idk him voting out David probably doesn’t happen at all if so.
It is not clear Fabio beats Chase. Chase already got 4 votes over him and Sash would vote Chase over Fabio, so that is 5 potentially.
Alina (one of Chase's votes) would be removed from the jury, so it would still be 5-4.
@@bencalebrod Good point. So yes the same result I guess.
also if I recall (could be wrong) 2 pf his voted where given by people who wanted him to get 2nd
@@sportydemons7630 That is obviously false since 3 of the 4 who voted Chase would have also voted Sash over Fabio- Holly, Alina, Brenda. There is no way on gods green earth Alina was ever voting Fabio vs anyone, anyone who followed the season knows that. And Holly went into FTC planning to vote Sash and switched to Chase. And the other is Jane who was always a pretty obvious Chase vote. Really Naonka was always the swing vote to decide which was going to win. And Kelly too since Kelly could have easily voted Sash and if she does, Chase wins, since Sash is the tiebreaking vote now and obivously picks Chase over Fabio.
@@sportydemons7630 I doubt that. Who that voted Chase was ever voting Fabio exactly? Maybe Jane if she were bitter enough.
I think Brad Culpepper is not a guaranteed win. I definitely think him being already being rich would lead toward Troyzan receiving more votes, though admittedly they're probably both fairly well off.
A lot of the jurors hated Brad. I could see it being surprisingly close.
Troyzan did nothing, so why would people vote him over Brad
@@vinhvo8937 Since jurors don't always vote objectively. Boston Rob would have lost RI to everyone but Phillip or Natalie T despite dominating the whole game.
Brad is an asshole, nobody liked him besides Sierra and Debbie who both wanted to vote him, and Troyzan of course. And he also did nothing apart from all his immunity wins, the one huge difference between his game and Troyzan's, but strategically and socially and in any other sense both did nothing.
I think Troy beats Brad. He’s definitely capable of making a better FTC speech than Brad and Troy came up with the Andrea blindside and made other moves that were edited out because of time constraints. I think he’d win.
I think troy and brad wouldve been a another brian vs clay,Brian who is brad in this case had a terrible ftc while clay who is troyzan had a good ftc.
Could you do if the final immunity challenge winner took the final member of the jury instead of the person they inevitably took to the end videos
So Kelly takes Rudy
Colby takes Keith
Kim takes Lex
etc....
It would also be cool if you did if every second place finisher in the final immunity challenge ended up beating the inevitable winner, who would’ve won?
You should do an opinion video of each of the placements for Russell hantz’s 100 greatest survivors. You don’t have to make you own list completely but just saying if you think it’s too high or low or just about right.
I think this idea should wait until the conclusion of bb22, but I would love to see a video discussing what if Big Brother always ended in a final 3
How about What If all Final 4 will have to go to Fire Making and who will be Final 3 and wins?
I don't think J.T would vote Russell, he was heavily influenced by Courtney due to her dating his best friend and I think candace also votes for parvati
I have heard JT and Courtney hated each other in Ponderosa it turned out, so I doubt they would automatically vote together despite the Stephen connection.
The person who would have the most influence on JT is Amanda who he had a huge crush on. Amanda hated Parvati so yeah JT probably never votes Parvati. If Amanda had voted Russell over Sandra, JT probably would have too as well.
Cochran votes out Dawn for sure. He was considering voting her out at the Final 4.
It doesn't matter who he picks. He still wins 9 votes either way. No way they would keep a 8 jury because of the time issue. Dawn votes cochran no matter what, so 9-0. And sherri admits in real life she would have voted cochran over dawn, so 9-0. He had that perfect game in lock
@@morgankingsley4992 Unless Dawn is bitter with Cochran cutting her, but she doesn't seem that type, and being aligned closely with Sherri as well she has to know her merge game atleast was ass, and wouldn't embarass her own credability by tossing a bitter vote to her. Sherri said she votes Cochran at the Reunion, so I believe that.
Sandra vs Russell could have had Russell votes. JT and Amanda seemed more anti Parvati. I honestly feel like Amanda voted Sandra just because she had the best shot at beating Parvati. If Parvati isn’t in the running I think she’s more likely to give her vote to Russell, though I think she still leans Sandra.
That is possible, but the other theory is Amanda, JT, Jerri, and to a lesser extent Candice all went into the F3 of Sandra-Parvati- Russell willing to vote Russell but didn't do to his awful FTC. So in that case Sandra would get all their votes still. Against Parvati he probably still picks up Amanda and JT, since they hated Parvati enough, and maybe Candice.
i don't see amanda voting for russell at all but maybe i missed something. other than that i agree, also great video!
I think Rob and Amber would vote Michele. Despite what Rob said in his confessional at the end. I think he clearly didn't like Natalie that much. Natalie was rather mean to Amber out there.
parvati, natalie and rob stole food from amber on EOE
Rob said he votes Sarah in a Final 3 of Michele, Natalie, Sarah, and he hated Sarah, and she called him a sexist and homophobe. On Ri in a post show interview he said he never votes Natalie T (who he was creepily close with, while hating most of the cast, especialy his alliance members like Grant, Ashley, Matt who he detested minus maybe Andrea) on RI except for maybe in a Final 2 with Phillip, and I would presume a Final 3 with Julie even though he didnt say that. He doesn't vote just who he likes or doesnt like unless it is Amber. He would vote Natalie over Michele just for being the stronger player.
Natalie and Michele are two of my Top 5 favorite winners ever. Both very strong, interesting players and women. Yet them being the Final 2 would be “the Darkest Timeline.” Interesting.
It would really just be the "darkest timeline" because of the fantastic game Tony played, and the fact that most people don't like the edge, it would make the winner really unsatisfying (with the edit we got), and Tony would be the ultimate fallen angel.
Well i think their winning games are great, but you have to look at how natalie literally skips allllll the tribals and gets to final 2 by winning immunities. Never ever surviving ONE tribal her whole time there. So tbh as much as I would like Michele to win, her game in WaW was not great at all. She never had any agency after OG Sele, and was constantly on the bottom.
It’s definitely a dark timeline. Michele was one of the worst players of the season and Natalie was the first boot
It truly would be dark to have to see a woman win Survivor these days, I guess is the general (implicit) consensus. If you're not making #BigMovez or making a fire, then are you really playing Survivor?
RedSoloJonay lol sarah or sophie would have been great winners. Michele and Natalie were very undeserving
There is no way Lauren votes Ryan over Chrissy. So Ryan's best case is a 4-4 tie. I don't think they have an 8 person jury though, but a 9 person jury.
in my opinion, courtney wins china in a courtney vs amanda final two. even with todd its suspected (confirmed by some) that courtney was winning going into it and todds ftc was just that good he stole votes. in this hypothetical scenario amanda still has a terrible ftc and the ftc ends with courtney having way more respect than amanda and wins.
Do rank of all the players who were voted out at day 38
If Heroes vs Villains had a final 2, it would have been Parvati and Russell and Parvati would win
Only if Parvati wins final immunity. Russell was not taking Parvati over Sandra. In fact in the scenario it is a Final 2, he probably votes Parvati off at Final 4 over Jerri now, as he only voted Jerri off at 4 with a Final 3, since he thought he had her jury vote.
21:56 If Troyzan somehow managed to get all those votes, it would be a 5-5 tie
18:17 Spencer and Tasha had a strong bond, so if anyone is going to vote for Tasha, it’s him. However, Jeremey still wins 10-0 or 9-1
and in a case of Spencer vs Tasha in a final 2, who wins ?
I think that’s a very close vote
Joe-Spencer
Kimmi-Tasha
Savage-Tasha
Kass-Spencer?
Abi-Tasha
Wentworth-Tasha
Ciera-Spencer
Fishbach-Spencer?
Keith-Spencer
Wiglesworth-Tasha
If Jeremy and Kass are on the jury, Spencer wins 6-5. If Kass is kicked off, I think it would be a 5-5 tie
@@sethbryant5539 nah i think jeremy votes for spencer
I once heard somebody said that in some interview abi said she wish tasha drowned in that one challenge so i don't think she voted for tasha so spencer
And i don't think savage votes for tasha.
@@miz_flamingo1470 That’s cuz Abi is rude af. Savage was bitter against Spencer, so I think he goes for Tasha over him
I don’t think Russell has a chance against Parvati in a f2. The jury hated him, and yes they hated her too but that was mostly because she was so attached to him.
All the villains vote for Parvati (since they all voted for her in reality except Courtney, and she actually liked Parvati, just not as much as Sandra). Going by your rules and replacing Coach with Sandra, that’s 4 votes locked. She already only needs one more vote to win. Of the 5 heroes, I’m inclined to agree with you that Candice and Amanda would vote for Russell, but I think JT would probably vote for Parvati, and I *definitely* think Rupert and Colby would vote for her. The final vote is most likely 7-2 maybe 6-3 for Parvati
I think if edge of extinction was never in play. The winners change for both seasons it was in:
Season 38’s winner: Victoria Baamonde
Season 40’s winner: Sarah Lacina
What about if Redemption island was never in play.
Survivor Boy 2020
I guess you’d want me to include the outcast twist too:
Pearl Islands: Sandra
Redemption Island: Boston Rob wins
South Pacific: Sophie
Blood vs Water: Tyson
So none of the winners would’ve changed but ironically I think both would’ve been different had edge of extinction never been a twist
Agreed with season 38
But for 40
Okay so tyson wouldn't be that important cuz he voted out like only 2 rounds later
So things happen
F5
Michele wins immunity
Tony and ben played their idols and denise goes home
F4
Michele is the last the second longest but since ben is here too but i don't know about ben if he can beat michele so i made 2 case
Ben wins
He probably saves sarah
Tony and michele go to fire i think tony wins and tony probably wins near unanimously sophie probably votes for sarah and thats about it 15-1-0
If michele wins she saves sarah
Ben vs tony and........ ben wins (Thank god eoe happen)
So this would be more interesting
Obviously ben gets no votes
Michele gets:Natalie,Nick,Jeremy,Adam,wendell,danni
Sarah probably gets the rest of the votes.
Actually thank god Eoe was a thing.
Todd said that had Amanda voted him out he would’ve hands down voted for Courtney. And for Gabon Charlie, Marcus and Randy were considering voting for sugar so Susie wouldn’t have been that big of a goat. And if Russell is in a final 2 with Parv he definitely does not get Amanda’s vote cause she cited people like Russell as her number one reason for not liking survivor anymore and Candace did say that she didn’t vote for Parv purely cause she didn’t like Russell so she was guilty by association so even if one singular person votes for Russell, Parv sweeps the vote with a near unanimous
Courtney 100% wins a Final 2 over Amanda that year. It isn't even a question.
Honestly...
Ozzy takes Yul. That was old school Survivor. Yul wins.
Of course Dreamz takes Cassandra. She was his main ally. And Alex, Mookie, and Lisi hated her more than Dreamz. Dreamz should win.
Amanda takes Courtney, and Amanda should win.
Susie takes Sugar and Susie wins
Russell/Nat Nat wins
Russell/Sandra Sandra wins
Didn't care for 21, it was spoiled who f3 was way early on. But Fabio takes Sash and wins
Rob takes Nat still wins
Sophie takes Coach and wins still
Kim takes Chelsea and wins
Tyson takes Gervase and wins
Jaclyn takes Missy and wins
Mike saved Carolyn at f4. He was not
taking Will
Yeah Jeremy/Tasha and Jeremy wins
Ugh glad this final two didnt happen in 32. Michele beats Tai.
Ken killed a lot of votes after he voted out his biggest ally. But Hannah wins.
Brad beats Troyzan
Didnt watch anymore.
Amber votes Natalie
Danni votes Natalie
Ethan votes Natalie
Tyson votes Natalie
Boston Rob votes Natalie
Parvati votes Natalie
Yul votes Michele
Wendell votes Michele
Adam votes Michele
Sophie votes Michele
Kim votes Michele
Jeremy votes Natalie
Nick votes Michele
Denise votes Michele
Ben votes Michele
Sarah votes Michele
Tony votes Michele
Michele wins against Natalie in a 10-7 vote
Sophie and Kim vote Natalie in this situation
Survivor Fan why the hell would they do that
JPB productions because they didn’t respect Michele’s gameplay at all and thought she did nothing
Danni votes for Michele. I think there’s a chance Kim and Sophie vote for Natalie. Either way, Michele wins with 9 locked votes
you know what i'm gonna ask for
final juror (fallen angel) ranking
It's coming. I've already started working on it, but with the current schedule it's probably a couple months away. Might make it the first video of next year at this point.
TheMeranianReview this should be done for survivor and big brother
@@TheMeranianReview wow, i didn't know it took that long to make a video lol. but thank you for respodning!
Mary Jasper What do you mean by fallen angel? Is that like when a player is good at the start then goes bad?
@@rainischalk-late3540 somebody who gets voted out right before final tribal
You should do what if big brother had a final 3
It might be too hard to do but doing what ifs eith certain moments would be interesting. So like what happens if James or Ozzy play their idols in their respective seasons
*with
I also think Jerri is less of a lock because Parvatis main flipping point in the vote was the guaranteed vote comment before she liked Russells game so without that Jerri votes Russell
Mack Jorgensen no parvati told her that and I brought that up in my comment but as she was leaving she was going to vote Russell and had parvati not said that I don’t think her vote changes and parvati has no need to say that because she was not even there I still think he loses but jerris vote could go to Russell
@@nickcampagna9907 Jerri said in her AMA on reddit it was not Parvati's comment that lost her vote, it was how Russell acted the whole FTC where he insulted all the jurors, including her, that was cut out of the edit.
You should do one with big brother where you breakdown what would happen if the final HOH winner was different
I feel Albert likely votes Coach over Sophie. He had a good relationship with Coach, and Sophie was starting to gaslight him and frustrate him in the late game. That would make it a 5-4 Sophie vote instead of 6-3, and only 1 other has to flip.
My only critique is for season 35-40 as a final 2 the fire making goes away so person voted out in 4th may change. For example in hhh Ben goes 4th then krissy chooses to take either Devon or Ryan to final 2. In winners there would be fire but it would be Tony vs Michelle and Tony advances. Then Nat cuts him at final 3 and loses to sara in the finals.
If WaW was a Final Two, Tony would have to use his black magic again.
I think Sophie would vote out coach and I think the reason she throws under him the bus to get the votes off of coach because of Brandon, That loyal girl to coach, and maybe Dawn.
If jaclyn made the move of voting out natalie when natalie put the idol on her and natalie goes home that would be probably top 3 moves of all time
Do what if the fire making challenge was in place from the beginning. See how that changes the game.
Interesting. I'm thinking Kelly takes Sue, partly as an olive branch and partly because she's the easiest to beat, and makes Rich and Rudy fight it out. I feel like that would be a toss-up.
If Rudy makes fire he wins the jury vote by a mile.
If Rich wins I think Sue is a zero-vote finalist; she's got all Rich's baggage and none of the ability to claim grudging respect. So it's essentially still a choice between Rich and Kelly, but without Sue voting. Assuming the other jurors all stay the same as before, that means a 3-3 tie, with Sue as a tie breaker. Probably she votes Rich (giving us the exact same result as what really happened), unless she really is that touched by the fact that Kelly took her along to the end and they patch things up on the last day.
However, it's long been suggested that Gervase had planned on voting for Rich but switched to Kelly because he felt bad for her after being so savaged by Sue. If Sue's not a juror then there's no snakes and rats speech, so maybe Gervase votes Rich and Rich wins 4-2. (I've always thought it strange that Gervase voted for Kelly; he seemed to be thinking in strategic terms, but only Joel wanted to play that way on Pagong, and after the merge Rich beat him to the draw. He really should have acknowledged that Rich was a worthy adversary and voted accordingly.)
@@aperson22222 A final 3 has Gretchen on the jury, and she probably votes for Kelly. I would like to see a redo of the ‘what if every season had forced fire making’ he did in February, but this time have only final 3s
@@sethbryant5539 I’m not certain Gretchen would have to be on the jury, but if she were, she was shown to be getting pretty close with Rich on the merge episode. In later interviews Rich said he’d hoped she would recognize that his ousting her did not mean that their bond was any less genuine and that he wanted to continue getting to know her later.
I don’t know whether his hopes were realized or not, but she’s the only member of that cast he talked about in that way (not counting his comments where he briefly touched on how much he’d enjoyed keeping in touch with Rudy, comments he made after Rudy died). I would think she leaned toward Rich, if she has to get a vote.
I disagree. Courtney wins in China because she gets Frostis and Todds votes to make it a 4-3
I don't think Albert votes Coach over Sophie, but if all votes stay the same Sophie would still win 5-4 at worst.
Sherri actually says she votes cochran. So he wins unanimously no matter what