Guha is an historian? When did an untrained public intellectual become a historian? It's sad that we label every person that can write flowery Socratic words on history as historian. It really insults the decades of study and dedicated hard-work (field work, textual analysis, manuscript analysis etc.) of real historians. What's worse is we treat a Doon school grads who grew up with deep political connections as authoritative historian. No wonder our politics is so ridiculous, we keep labeling charlatans as experts in their adopted fields.
Intellectual elitism at its finest. It's amusing to watch these people complain as their hackneyed narratives about India unravel. Vandana's bias was immediately apparent from her first question. She should study Shekhar in OTC with Vikram Sampath to learn how it's done.
@@libshastra I don't get what you're trying to insinuate but Anne Besant was a British citizen born in London. Coming to the Anglo Indian quota, it's been 2yrs ig since it got abolished.
Wonderful interview and a unique view of the freedom struggle... One thing to point out Annie Besant being Irish understood colonial oppression since Ireland was the oldest British colony (800+ years of occupation and cultural suppression until independence in 1921)
Meh, His enthusiasm is boderlining desperation , Eminent distorian's desperate attempts to save his career of Quackery/Sycophancy (I mean historiography). Alas Damage is already done, he has been established as Persona Non Grata. Irony is Late Respectable Savarkar taking vengeance from him and his fellow Quacks after death.🤣🤣
@@atyanthdutt6632 You remind me of my engineering college days where my room mate was a huge fan on the occult & filled the room with books on tantra. He used to claim he was a tantrik too to anyone who cared to listen. Of course , all his knowledge was bookish with no initiation or practice in tantra. That he was from Bongo as many would have guessed by now is purely co incidental.
He is a historian, by qualification and profession. Just cos you don't like a person or adhere to a particular ideology which is against him, you can't disparage him. He's written good books which are quite sought after for UPSC preparation, he's a historian and print hasn't done anything wrong.
@@atyanthdutt6632 that insults real historians. He's an economic grad with 0 scholarly work in history. He just happens to write books about it and we are gullible enough to treat it as authoritative. That's sad.
@@libshastra Oh boy....."0 scholarly work in history". Your delusional, his books are one of the best with regards to modern Indian history, he's done a fellowship program (equivalent to PhD) on social history of forestry in Uttrakhand. His books are must for UPSC preparation. He's a honorary foreign awardee from the American historical Association, second ig after Jadunath Sarkar, prominent Bengali historian and activist. Before you start putting dirt on Sarkar, he was a great man who helped East Bengali Hindus.
@@atyanthdutt6632 Publishing book is not the same as publishing scholarly works and doing a thesis defense in front of a panel. I'm sorry, I have high standards for who is called a scholar and not. It's not delusional to ask for better.
It's hilarious to see Guha being labelled as a "Historian" by woke media but at the same time they'll put out hit pieces against anyone who dare challenge the dynasty historians narrative calling them untrained amateurs 😂
Aah, here comes the hentai watching unemployed youth studying in 3rs tier College giving commentary. Lol. How pathetic can you be loser Brahmin. Still blame dalit for not getting job? Also zyada maat bolo, Ghar Mai ake piyaaz gar Mai dal dunga
@@helcurt2509 Naam bata apna ghar ke samne ki naali jaam ha aur pyaaj leke ghar aa rha ha to lizol lete aana kam karwana ha tujhse 😂😂😂 Doing a grade 4 job cleaning platforms and you dare utter the name of the greatest scholars in the world typical
@@atyanthdutt6632 lol but sadly the fall of nehruvian republic is inevitable and people won't regret because nothing of value will be lost....better prepare yourself or get hurt...there's no going back.
@@atyanthdutt6632 Says a Bong for whom presumably the Communists in Bongo followed by Momota were & are some of the most enlightened leaders. Verily is it said among the bhadralok - why kiss anyone else's arse when we kiss our own no matter how hairy dark & stinky it is . After all it's our own.
@@Dhruv_Jain 😂😂😂, these gobars are trying or willing to rewrite history based on their primitive ideology but sadly they got little or no academics in their fold, not surprising.
people like guha were gatekeeping indian history like their own property for too long, now when their false narratives are being challenged these clowns are crying....they had space more than they deserved, it's time real historians should get their due.
@@EILF7842 You're profile says it all. You have give in to your delusion, get well soon. If you want to reveal "true history", then why don't you write a book quoting facts or take part in academic debate not debates held in news channels.
@@atyanthdutt6632 it doesn't require common sense and no need to become intellectual historian. We are told - Indians politely in non violent manner requested British to leave and Britishers left in gentlemanly way. For 70yrs we were fed with this and we beleived it
Print Why you are mocking at .. ..the lacs of people killed and .....lacs of women who suffered heniuous attrocities and ....at the invaluable treasure loot.. .all committed against India and Indians by foreign rulers?
When you talk of Christianity /Christian - do you know what Christianity is all about? Did you read BIBLE , ( OT & NT) with critical thinking and analysis ? Do you know the tenets of Christianity ? It's most intolerant and most violent theological past and even now ? When you talk of Communism , do you know the basic tenets of COMMUNISM ? Most intolerant and most violent ideology ? why there are a dozen COMMUNIST parties operating in INDIA ? which one is true COMMUNIST ideology ? When you talk about ISLAM or MUSALMANS - do you understand the basic tenets of ISLAM ? Did you read SIRA, did you read HADIS and did you read QURAN ? Most intolerant, most violent theology/ideology? A true humanist , progressive, liberal democratic, peace lover will tell that these 3 ideologies are dangerous to human civilization. do not belong in human civilization. History has proof . Each one - caused the death, destruction of immeasurable amount .
You are right . All "most intolerant and most violent ideology " must be totally condemned including violent Senas, RSS, Hindutva's and communal and castist ideology.
@@renudidi47 - Yes you beat ( like COMMUNIST fascists ) , HITLERS propaganda CHIEF - JOSEPH Goebble !!!!!!!!!! Tell a lie ( without any evidence) and keep repeating that lie for hundreds of times , - so in time truth becomes a lie, and a lie becomes truth !!!!!!!! This is Indian communist main weapon , concealing their own most violent ideology ( remember how many people were killed in INDIA by COMMUNIST terrorists during the past 60 years ?? Count them. Plese respond - Are you ready to debate ? What about JIHADISTS and CRUSADERS ???? I repeat , ISLAM, COMMUNISM, Christianity are the most intolerant and most violent fascist, totalitarian dogmas imposed- imported --- by fear, force and terror on you . Any pseudo historian is welcomed to debate on this .
@@rajch1196 Bruh. Himmler, head of ss loved Hinduism and characters like Arjuna etc and ppl like Savitri Devi considered Hitler as a avatar of Vishnu and Nazis literally arrested Catholic and Protestant priests like Martin Neimoller. Who killed Gauri lankesh, Govind Pansare, MM Kalburgi, Narendra Dabolkar???, Who killed Graham Staines and his sons in 1999???, Who lynched Mohammad Aklaq in Dadri in 2015 and many others???? Who killed innocent muslims in Jammu in 1947???, Who r*ped nuns and killed priest during the kandhamal riots in Orrisa???who killed Muslims in gujarat in 2002. Every religion has good folk and bad folk, learn to accept it and stop being intolerant.
Right Wingers wants to hate. Because how could other humans help humans? Unable to say that, so all the anger directed at the best historian of our times - Mr Ramachandran Guha
@@npd9758 "Questioned".....no one stopped you from questioning anyone except if you're trying to propagate hate. Coming to Guha, he's an academic not your usual panelist on news channels. If you want to question him, write a book quoting facts to refute him. There's a difference between academic and political debates that occur in news channels.
@@manuvatsal5902 Thank you! In fact, "Right" wing should be called something else. I like "Regressive" wing, but that still doesn't completely describe their stand. May be you could suggest a more descriptive word or phrase. Devil's wing?
Guha is an historian? When did an untrained public intellectual become a historian? It's sad that we label every person that can write flowery Socratic words on history as historian. It really insults the decades of study and dedicated hard-work (field work, textual analysis, manuscript analysis etc.) of real historians.
What's worse is we treat a Doon school grads who grew up with deep political connections as authoritative historian.
No wonder our politics is so ridiculous, we keep labeling charlatans as experts in their adopted fields.
Intellectual elitism at its finest. It's amusing to watch these people complain as their hackneyed narratives about India unravel. Vandana's bias was immediately apparent from her first question. She should study Shekhar in OTC with Vikram Sampath to learn how it's done.
Annie Besant is a foreigner !?! That's why we have reservation for Anglo Indians right? Because they are foreigners? Right?
@@libshastra I don't get what you're trying to insinuate but Anne Besant was a British citizen born in London. Coming to the Anglo Indian quota, it's been 2yrs ig since it got abolished.
@@atyanthdutt6632 I'm saying implying that she is a foreigner makes her an "Other" and diminishes her contribution.
Wonderful interview and a unique view of the freedom struggle... One thing to point out Annie Besant being Irish understood colonial oppression since Ireland was the oldest British colony (800+ years of occupation and cultural suppression until independence in 1921)
Guha- history will not remember guha as historian. ,😄😄
Well, he's a historian whether you or I like it or not, his qualifications are such. Might as well give his books a try.
😂
@@atyanthdutt6632 He's a Communist........Communists are Not Historians........they are trouble makers.
@@sunnymitra6372 Where's the proof that he's a communist, he's against BJP but that doesn't make him a communist
@@atyanthdutt6632 Pls list the universities which prescribe his book as syllabus. In case you aren't aware the answer is zero. He's a pop historian.
Lol, historian. Right!!!
Meh, His enthusiasm is boderlining desperation , Eminent distorian's desperate attempts to save his career of Quackery/Sycophancy (I mean historiography).
Alas Damage is already done, he has been established as Persona Non Grata.
Irony is Late Respectable Savarkar taking vengeance from him and his fellow Quacks after death.🤣🤣
Gaurav Singh snorted a tonne of cocaine before commenting......😂😂
@@atyanthdutt6632 Guess it's experience speaking . In any case for those not in the know , Guha isn't a Bong.
@@ic9771 Yes, my experience dealing with crackheads like you and Gaurav Singh.
@@atyanthdutt6632 You remind me of my engineering college days where my room mate was a huge fan on the occult & filled the room with books on tantra.
He used to claim he was a tantrik too to anyone who cared to listen. Of course , all his knowledge was bookish with no initiation or practice in tantra.
That he was from Bongo as many would have guessed by now is purely co incidental.
Guha likes to call himself historian , why is this not funny?
Why, this historian is not able to delve on the Indians per se who inspired fought, sacrificed and died for the Nation?
Calling him "historian" , summaries the IQ level of Print
bastard statement
He is a historian, by qualification and profession. Just cos you don't like a person or adhere to a particular ideology which is against him, you can't disparage him. He's written good books which are quite sought after for UPSC preparation, he's a historian and print hasn't done anything wrong.
@@atyanthdutt6632 that insults real historians. He's an economic grad with 0 scholarly work in history. He just happens to write books about it and we are gullible enough to treat it as authoritative. That's sad.
@@libshastra Oh boy....."0 scholarly work in history". Your delusional, his books are one of the best with regards to modern Indian history, he's done a fellowship program (equivalent to PhD) on social history of forestry in Uttrakhand. His books are must for UPSC preparation. He's a honorary foreign awardee from the American historical Association, second ig after Jadunath Sarkar, prominent Bengali historian and activist. Before you start putting dirt on Sarkar, he was a great man who helped East Bengali Hindus.
@@atyanthdutt6632 Publishing book is not the same as publishing scholarly works and doing a thesis defense in front of a panel. I'm sorry, I have high standards for who is called a scholar and not. It's not delusional to ask for better.
It's hilarious to see Guha being labelled as a "Historian" by woke media but at the same time they'll put out hit pieces against anyone who dare challenge the dynasty historians narrative calling them untrained amateurs 😂
Aah, here comes the hentai watching unemployed youth studying in 3rs tier College giving commentary. Lol. How pathetic can you be loser Brahmin. Still blame dalit for not getting job? Also zyada maat bolo, Ghar Mai ake piyaaz gar Mai dal dunga
@@helcurt2509 Naam bata apna ghar ke samne ki naali jaam ha aur pyaaj leke ghar aa rha ha to lizol lete aana kam karwana ha tujhse 😂😂😂
Doing a grade 4 job cleaning platforms and you dare utter the name of the greatest scholars in the world typical
Pity, didn't you come across a lesson in humility watching all this hentai? mishra
@@iki740 First tell me your name/caste/category boy You might have some cleaning to do after I'm done watching my hentai
@@helcurt2509 and Guha is an upper caste kayastha ignorant dumbass 😂😂😂
Pathetic attempt to revive the Nehruvian era with a little bit of neo wokism flavour
I prefer the Nehurvian era with all its shortcomings rather than the present bigoted and inefficacious regime.
@@atyanthdutt6632 lol but sadly the fall of nehruvian republic is inevitable and people won't regret because nothing of value will be lost....better prepare yourself or get hurt...there's no going back.
@@EILF7842 Delusional to say the least......😂😂😂
@@atyanthdutt6632 Says a Bong for whom presumably the Communists in Bongo followed by Momota were & are some of the most enlightened leaders.
Verily is it said among the bhadralok - why kiss anyone else's arse when we kiss our own no matter how hairy dark & stinky it is . After all it's our own.
@@pratapmandal1046 You're free to kiss your own arse Mondol . You don't need my validation or permission for that . 🙂
Looks like Mr. Guha has his own trolls that follow him along 😂. Anyways good work @print.
😂😂 Kids need work, don't they....
Lol, you are the kids who think he is a historian. Start reading what real history is, get out of your 12 th class history dimwits
@@sadbradwithabat2413 "Real history"...name one good book written by a credible person which states "Real history".
Uff!! One more book for UPSC aspirants!!
It is hilarious when he say that he doesn't want to get engaged in debate on history with other's. Soo chuhe kha kar billi .....
Cause he is an academic, not a stupid internet Influencer. You want to debate? Write a book with reference to original text.
@@iki740 These are No Braincells 2 Rupees IT Cell Gobar Bhakts You think they can write a book? 😂 They will just believe what the supreme leader tells
@@Dhruv_Jain 😂😂😂, these gobars are trying or willing to rewrite history based on their primitive ideology but sadly they got little or no academics in their fold, not surprising.
@@iki740 An academic with ulterior motives ranting on twitter and when called out, out come the gooo trolls.
@@iki740 lol, he is an academic, my foot. How narrow minded you are
I came here to only read comments.
It's ok, ppl like Guha too need some space. And that too as HISTORIAN
people like guha were gatekeeping indian history like their own property for too long, now when their false narratives are being challenged these clowns are crying....they had space more than they deserved, it's time real historians should get their due.
@@EILF7842 You're profile says it all. You have give in to your delusion, get well soon. If you want to reveal "true history", then why don't you write a book quoting facts or take part in academic debate not debates held in news channels.
@@atyanthdutt6632 it doesn't require common sense and no need to become intellectual historian. We are told - Indians politely in non violent manner requested British to leave and Britishers left in gentlemanly way.
For 70yrs we were fed with this and we beleived it
@@atyanthdutt6632 Why Aurangzeb was not a fascist???
@@pbkvijaykulkarni6404 Finally we Indians are challenging the Congress backed Historians
I don't know what to say on Guha's historical findings and conclusions drawn by him. Rubbish
Biased storyteller guha
One question. Where is he living now....I rest my case
Bangalore, seen him a couple of times. So what's your case exactly....😂😂😂
Print
Why you are mocking at ..
..the lacs of people killed and
.....lacs of women who suffered heniuous attrocities and
....at the invaluable treasure loot..
.all committed against India and Indians by foreign rulers?
What ?!!!
❤
When you talk of Christianity /Christian - do you know what Christianity is all about? Did you read BIBLE , ( OT & NT) with critical thinking and analysis ? Do you know the tenets of Christianity ? It's most intolerant and most violent theological past and even now ?
When you talk of Communism , do you know the basic tenets of COMMUNISM ? Most intolerant and most violent ideology ? why there are a dozen COMMUNIST parties operating in INDIA ? which one is true COMMUNIST ideology ?
When you talk about ISLAM or MUSALMANS - do you understand the basic tenets of ISLAM ?
Did you read SIRA, did you read HADIS and did you read QURAN ? Most intolerant, most violent theology/ideology? A true humanist , progressive, liberal democratic, peace lover will tell that these 3 ideologies are dangerous to human civilization. do not belong in human civilization. History has proof . Each one - caused the death, destruction of immeasurable amount .
You are right . All "most intolerant and most violent ideology " must be totally condemned including violent Senas, RSS, Hindutva's and communal and castist ideology.
@@renudidi47 - Yes you beat ( like COMMUNIST fascists ) , HITLERS propaganda CHIEF - JOSEPH Goebble !!!!!!!!!! Tell a lie ( without any evidence) and keep repeating that lie for hundreds of times , - so in time truth becomes a lie, and a lie becomes truth !!!!!!!! This is Indian communist main weapon , concealing their own most violent ideology ( remember how many people were killed in INDIA by COMMUNIST terrorists during the past 60 years ?? Count them. Plese respond - Are you ready to debate ? What about JIHADISTS and CRUSADERS ???? I repeat , ISLAM, COMMUNISM, Christianity are the most intolerant and most violent fascist, totalitarian dogmas imposed- imported --- by fear, force and terror on you . Any pseudo historian is welcomed to debate on this .
@@rajch1196 Bruh. Himmler, head of ss loved Hinduism and characters like Arjuna etc and ppl like Savitri Devi considered Hitler as a avatar of Vishnu and Nazis literally arrested Catholic and Protestant priests like Martin Neimoller. Who killed Gauri lankesh, Govind Pansare, MM Kalburgi, Narendra Dabolkar???, Who killed Graham Staines and his sons in 1999???, Who lynched Mohammad Aklaq in Dadri in 2015 and many others???? Who killed innocent muslims in Jammu in 1947???, Who r*ped nuns and killed priest during the kandhamal riots in Orrisa???who killed Muslims in gujarat in 2002. Every religion has good folk and bad folk, learn to accept it and stop being intolerant.
Guha lost his relevance…
I don't understand a bit
Manrega has become like you can't chew or ?
Why did you even make this video? Your mostly right wing viewership does not care about it at all.
Nah, there are many who care. Why give in to the demands of few snowflakes who can't tolerate history.
Right Wingers wants to hate. Because how could other humans help humans? Unable to say that, so all the anger directed at the best historian of our times - Mr Ramachandran Guha
But it's left wingers who block others when they are questioned, yet they talk of intolerance
Indian right wingers are hardly even 1%. 99% of bjp supporters are not even right wing, but poor people with need of money.
@@npd9758 "Questioned".....no one stopped you from questioning anyone except if you're trying to propagate hate. Coming to Guha, he's an academic not your usual panelist on news channels. If you want to question him, write a book quoting facts to refute him. There's a difference between academic and political debates that occur in news channels.
@@manuvatsal5902 Thank you! In fact, "Right" wing should be called something else. I like "Regressive" wing, but that still doesn't completely describe their stand. May be you could suggest a more descriptive word or phrase. Devil's wing?
@@meta5291 There's No Right wing in India.
Guha is a historian? 😂
He is a distorian not historian!!
GUHA IS KNOWLEGABLE BALANCED AND SENSIBLE MAN. SADLY TODAYS POLARISED SOCIETY WILL NOT UNDERSTAND THIS.