There was a scene in Half Blood Prince where Dumbledore and Harry are talking about the horcruxes and Dumbledore looks at Harry and says "and I think I found another one."
@@alijaffery7735 im all up for good theories but this one is bs. dumbledore was purely talking about the locket, he knew already that harry was one himself.
When i saw this in the cinema at Midnight, at the premiere, you could hear a pin drop. No sound at all, everybody in the room was sobbing. Still got chills when i think about it.
What I hate about these reactions is when Snape shows his patronus they all just say "It was him the whole time" they seem to miss the thing that makes it the most sad. The fact that his patronus is the same as Lily's.
It seems to me that in the movies they don't talk much about the patronus of the other characters. So those who haven't read the book don't know about this.
I always wanted someone to notice that.. look at the possibilities.. snape loved Lilly to an extent that he still carried her within himself.. the patrons symbolises the love he holds for her.. But it also means that somewhere within Severus, Lilly still lives and in that way, his mother still lives and maybe that's what helps Snape go forth with his plan to betray voldemort all along. Initially, it was a lover forlorn but then it continued as a mother scorned.
I don't blame them I watched those movies a bunch of times and i only truly understood the meaning of that reading someone explaining it in a TH-cam comment I think if you read the book you have better chances to understand it
Well it’s more of an Easter egg for the book fans and dumbledore can lead them to the deeper connection with lily because of what he said. They did that on purpose.
can i kindly ask the reason why they had the same patronus? i haven't read the books and i always wanted to appreciate that scene and understand the main reason why dumbledore knew
That's why Snape wanted Harry to look him in his eyes when he took his last breaths. Because he had his mother's eyes. He wanted to look at Lily one last time.
@@goodtaste4 I say it was a mix between "he is the son of the love of my life, but he is also the son of the person who took her away from me and humiliated me." In the first few movies Snape definitely doesn't treat him well, but after the 3rd or so on, he's still cold to him, but he doesn't treat him so terribly anymore. He took care of him in his own way and began to feel some affection towards him over time. It's not something that happened quickly. Plus, he unfortunately had to maintain the image of being the Head of Slytherin and try to not blow out his real loyalty because he was basically being under the noses of the "death eaters" and bad people who were loyal to Voldemort. ***sorry for my english***
@@BlOoDyVaMpIyour English is fine 😊 And I agree! I also think that if snaps didn’t have to pretend to hate harry etc that he would have shown more affection towards him outwardly. Instead he had to hide it and shove it down.
@@BlOoDyVaMpI James didn't take Lily away from Snape. Snape took Lily away from Snape. They were friends, but then he called her a Mudblood and that was the last one for Lily. She knew he wanted to become a Death Eater, that he hated Muggle-Borns in general and she said "Why should I be different?" and it was during their fifth year, two years before James and Lily started dating. She didn't even was friend with James back then, she didn't even like him. So see, it's all Snape's fault if he didn't get the girl. That and the fact that Lily only ever saw him as a friend. James has nothing to do with it.
I find Snape going to Godric's Hollow revolting. Lily is in hiding with her family because Snape willingly joined the Death Eaters, knowing they tortured and murdered mugglueborns, spied for Voldemort and told the known murderer that a baby was a threat to his reign. Lily ended her friendship with Snape years prior because she knew the path Snape was heading down was a danger to her and that still wasn't enough. Lily was killed along with her husband and very nearly her child too but how touching would it be for Snape to swoop in and fondle her corpse to make it all about his pain.
Everybody..But everybody, misunderstood the sentences at 3:31 " Don't tell me now that you've grown to care for the boy" words... Everybody think that Dumbledore doesn't care Harry... That is a stupid idea.. Dumbledore try to say, we care Harry but you didn't care for him.. So right now, dont tell me now you've grown to care for the boy... That's simple.. How can they misunderstand this?
@@W_Junior But he is sarcastic for Snape.. Not for himself.. Snape always seems like hate Harry .. So he talk about this point.. This is so easy to understand..
Snap does hate Harry that is clear in the books! In the books Snape replies, “for him?!” And the. Makes Lilly’s doe. He never cared for Harry he just loves Lilly so much he is will to protect her son.
He speaks coldly to show the audience that dumbledore wasent the perfect caring person harry thought he knew and it counteracts well with us learning snape wasent the cold hearted selfish person harry thought snape was.
Before book 7 came out, we were all debating which side Snape was on. I had heard a theory that Snape was in love with Lily before, but it was a theory mixed in with a bunch of others, so I didn't give it any more credence than any of the others. Obviously in the two years between Half-Blood Prince and Deathly Hallows releases, I was convinced he was bad, but then when I went back to read the entire series again before DH came out, I really did feel like Snape had plenty of opportunities to hurt Harry and never did, and in fact protected him many times, so I found myself agreeing with Bellatrix in the Unbreakable Vow scene that his explanations are just too convenient for why he thwarted Quirrell in the first book, why he didn't answer Voldemort's summons when he returned in the 4th, etc. I wasn't sure what his endgame was. I wasn't sure if Dumbledore and Snape had plotted Dumbledore's death ahead of time, though I certainly thought it was a possibility. I did feel like Harry needed to die for this series to really have a full story, and I'd say he did, even if it was only for a fraction of time.
I also was discussing some theories on the internet. And at some point, I was quite sure he wasn't bad and they planned Dumbledore's deaths. Didn't recognize that Dumbledore was doomed anyway, though. Just had a feeling that "Severus, please" meant "do what we agreed on". Couldn't imagine him begging for his life. What a time... all the discussions and theories. That was fun.
Snape is good and bad. He cares deeply but mainly for just Lily and Dumbledore. He was right about James for the first half but Snape decided to learn dark magic Lily didn’t like and he physically was rude to some students from the agony he holds in for 20 years at least. I can tell at least movie wise he still has a good heart. Believe he wasn’t as nice in the book(been a decade since I read the books)
Oooh, all these happy people who can enjoy the surprise. I've read the books when we had to wait for the next one. And during the waiting time, we discussed online. Besides, the books contain much more information. So we knew Severus and Lily were friends. And Harry was on the list of horcruxes for most readers.
Worst thing about this is that Harry saw it: His gaze of protection, all this time, first year on the quidditch, second year when filtch though he cursed his cat, third year when Remus turned into a werewolf he throwed himself between the trio, fourth year believing that he didn’t threw his name into the goblet of fire, fifth year Occlumency, and then in the end He has to learn he was raised like a swine to die Honestly 10/10 story writing
Snape was such a great friend and then fell in love with Lilly but couldn't have her so he was hurt but Realize that he had to protect the boy for her.
@szubidubi9473 you have not looked even further. There’s much you fail to understand. You won’t understand even we tell you, because you don’t realize what else there is to realize! There is far more to Snape than what you think to be all there is!
@szubidubi9473 it’s even been said this about Professor Snape, “I know you become extremely angry when someone takes away something you love. But we also have to consider how much he sacrificed for this boy. A man who, since childhood, has lost his dearest things and has become emotionally hardened. Yet, he never hesitated to give his life for this boy, simply because he is the son of the woman he loved. And I think he was always tough on the followers of Lord Voldemort to ensure there was no doubt about his loyalty."
Here is how you know if someone has read the series:”Why did they leave that part out?! Why did they change it?!”(that was me first time I watched it but still my favorite remake of a series)❤
A hero who was none the less vindictive and cruel to a small boy for the sole reason that he hated that boy's father. People seem to glance over that little fact.
@@Cerrydwenn "I know you become extremely angry when someone takes away something you love. But we also have to consider how much he sacrificed for this boy. A man who, since childhood, has lost his dearest things and has become emotionally hardened. Yet, he never hesitated to give his life for this boy, simply because he is the son of the woman he loved. And I think he was always tough on the followers of Lord Voldemort to ensure there was no doubt about his loyalty."
I use to hate snape before this moment in the movie. This exact moment turned my hate into love for him. Man, he was always protecting Harry, alone. Even though Harry's father was abusive to him. His love for Lily is so much that he pushed everything aside for her to protect what is left of her in the world, Harry.
They weren't in love though. That couple got it sort of wrong. Snape was in love with Lily but Lily was never in love with him, she *loved* him because he was her friend but it never had a chance to go beyond that because of how Snape changed as they grow up. They were never meant to be together, but there was always a love there that also connected to Harry.
I think that the relationship between Snape towards Harry in the movies, was more kind of love-hate, 'cause he loved him, because of Lilly and his resemblance to her; and he hated Harry, 'cause of the bullying that James inflicted on Snape 🥲
I'm so pissed that the movie never explained about Snape's Patronus... When a wizard loves sincerely and purely someone, his/her Patronus changes to the same the person they love... That's why Snape's Patronus turned into a female deer
i just hope in the harry potter show they dont imply snape to be a double agent or even much good, the closest thing is when he helps harry when he says "no idea" when umbridge asks about padfoot, not sure what the books show though
Severus invocando el ciervo de lily, es lo mas profundo. Significa que él tenia la espada de grifindor, el era el mas merecedor de tenerla hasta que se la entrega a harry.
Everyone has it wrong. Snape never cared about Harry as a person, ever. He only did as Dumbledore wanted because of his love of Lilly. Period. As he lay dying he told Harry to look at him so he could see Lilly’s eyes once more. He only saw Harry as Jame’s son whom he hated. Snape’s patronus was a doe, same as Lilly’s.
You are wrong. Snape cared for Harry because he was a part of Lily. Apparently you did not watch the movie or read the book. He loved Lily with all his heart
@@ahmedabdullah3539 I did apparently watch and read. The books are the true indicator of Snape’s feelings. He only asked Dumbledore to protect Lilly at first even though Riddle was after Harry. He hated James to the core and saw Harry as his not Lilly’s son. After the Order abandoned Grimauld Place as a hideout Snape snuck in and found a letter Lilly had written Sirius thanking him for Harry’s toy broomstick, and there was a picture of the three of them. Snape tore the picture to take Lilly’s image and threw the part with Harry and James under the bed. He also only took the second page of the letter with Lilly’s signature and “love” on it. How can you explain Snape’s horrendous and cruel treatment of Harry at school? He went to Dumbledore and said Harry was all the things he hated in James when all the other teachers said Harry was humble and kind. He saw NOTHING in Harry that was Lilly, nothing but his eyes. Ppl always want a villain to redeem themselves. Snape was a Death Eater. He didn’t care about Riddle killing and subjugating Muggles or Mudbloods .. except when Lilly was targeted. And Snape didn’t truly love Lilly anyway, he only thought he did or he never would have become a Death Eater who hated Mudbloods. He even slipped up and called Lilly one once. If he’d truly loved her he never would’ve followed Riddle because it displeased her. Don’t you remember the argument they had at school when Lilly said “you’ve chosen your way, I’ve chosen mine”? You need to reread the books .. *carefully* this time.
@@RohitSharma-oh8qm Harry never bullied anyone in either book or movie. It was James Potter and Serius Black who bullied Severus Snape while children. But Snape gave as good as he got, the hatred was mutual. But Snape transferred his hatred of James to his son Harry without giving the boy the least chance because he looked like his father.
Snape didn't love Harry, he only loved Lilly. Over all, in the books, he did the right thing in the end, but he was not really a good guy. If it wasn't for Lilly's death, he might have been a death eater till the end.
tf was that girl watching? cause it was certainly not harry potter. at the water when sirius was about to die it was not a doe patronus, it was a stag, caster by harry
People really only got from this that Snape hated Harry 😂what a bunch of wankers that’s not what you should be taking from this 👊🏻❤️dude Snape looked at Harry in the eyes more than dumbledoor did and protected him throughout 7 series , how brain dead are you guys , dude clearly didn’t like James but to sit here and say hate that’s ridiculous , everyone gets some form of bullying in school but the dude from every single movie produced had Harry’s back and through the very end had his back
If you read the ending of The Cursed Child where Harry and his son met the graves, Harry and his son both say that Snape and Dumbledore were both good men! So the books even establish Snape to being good. I even read the books before the movies came out, and Snape being good all along was what I got from after reading the seventh book. The same goes for many others who’ve read the books! You may say Snape isn’t a good person, or the same between both the movies and the books, but the movies and the books established that Snape was a good person all along; someone who may have made past mistakes sure, but was secretly good all along since he tried to protect the Potters with Dumbledore’s help which is how the Potters went into hiding in Godric’s Hollow. But that protection plan Snape and Dumbledore came up with didn’t work out, because Peter Pettigrew betrayed the Potters out of fear for his own life by telling Voldemort where the Potters were being kept in hiding. That’s then how Voldemort found the Potters and killed the parents, and tried to kill Harry but failed to. Snape worked with Dumbledore to try and hide them. That’s why Snape said, “Hide them! Hide them all! I beg you!” Severus before that even confessed to Dumbledore to having been a death eater, but after finding out Voldemort was hunting the Potters down, he secretly started to work with Dumbledore. After Voldemort killed the Potters except for Harry, Snape then officially wanted to undermine Voldemort in every way and make sure Harry destroyed him, Voldemort not knowing Severus Snape was trying to help Harry destroy him all along ever since Harry’s parents were killed. Snape had made mistakes yes, but he proved himself to be good in the end. Sure he still held grudges against James Potter, but with Severus Snape having been abused by his muggle father at home during the summer and being bullied by James and his friends every day at school, you can’t expect his hard feelings for James or his own muggle father to go away. So yeah, Snape was traumatized and that being why he was so bitter around even Harry, but despite all of that, Harry came to realize Snape was a good man all along. Ever since after Voldemort’s death by Harry’s hand, while talking about Snape, Harry said, “He was the bravest man I had ever known.”
@@thebosstex1172 Sue, 10 year old Severus was good. So was Darth Vader at that age. But as Remus describe Pettigrew "He sold Harry and James to Voldemort" If she'd lived he'd've moved right in to comfort the grieving widow until he got in her pants. Same trick used in Ghost. More proof? Went out of his way to bully the child who proved 'his girl' loved someone else. And not as a peer, but an adult with authority. He certainly saw similarity between Harry and his own bad childhood. I think the real world explanation is JKR liked Rickman and so redeemed Snape. Great and all, but we all cheered when Hanz dropped from Nakatome Tower compliments of Willis.
@@ashhabimran239 Not really, they're just saying they love the book passionately and aren't a fan of the film. People are always going to have their likes and dislikes and we can agree to disagree. They're allowed.
That was the only time Dumbledore was surprised. Really surprised
cut to his reaction at Harry's name coming out of the goblet of fire.
@@JojahnYes after all……he said it calmly.
All these reactions are the right ones towards Snape, Alan played this character to perfection. RIP Alan Rickman ❤
Rip 😢
@rgv 1:23
Literally your comment was the thing to make me cry. Damn you 😅
JK Rowling is a nutjob now but, it was cool that she told Alan about his fait and no one else.
There was a scene in Half Blood Prince where Dumbledore and Harry are talking about the horcruxes and Dumbledore looks at Harry and says "and I think I found another one."
Yea, the locket, thats why they went to get it.
@@brittanylewandowski6200 The locket and that is also when he realized Harry was a Horcrux.
@@alijaffery7735 Nah he knew it long before that at least by his 3rd year
@@abinabraham4732 can u tell me full story?
@@alijaffery7735 im all up for good theories but this one is bs. dumbledore was purely talking about the locket, he knew already that harry was one himself.
"After all this time?" - "Always"
"My father was a grape man."
"Your father was a wine."
“Swine”
@@therivster "you must be fun at parties"
😂😂
That's funny.
I laughed more at this than i should have 😂😂
When i saw this in the cinema at Midnight, at the premiere, you could hear a pin drop. No sound at all, everybody in the room was sobbing. Still got chills when i think about it.
What I hate about these reactions is when Snape shows his patronus they all just say "It was him the whole time" they seem to miss the thing that makes it the most sad. The fact that his patronus is the same as Lily's.
It seems to me that in the movies they don't talk much about the patronus of the other characters. So those who haven't read the book don't know about this.
I always wanted someone to notice that.. look at the possibilities.. snape loved Lilly to an extent that he still carried her within himself.. the patrons symbolises the love he holds for her..
But it also means that somewhere within Severus, Lilly still lives and in that way, his mother still lives and maybe that's what helps Snape go forth with his plan to betray voldemort all along.
Initially, it was a lover forlorn but then it continued as a mother scorned.
I don't blame them
I watched those movies a bunch of times and i only truly understood the meaning of that reading someone explaining it in a TH-cam comment
I think if you read the book you have better chances to understand it
Well it’s more of an Easter egg for the book fans and dumbledore can lead them to the deeper connection with lily because of what he said. They did that on purpose.
can i kindly ask the reason why they had the same patronus? i haven't read the books and i always wanted to appreciate that scene and understand the main reason why dumbledore knew
That's why Snape wanted Harry to look him in his eyes when he took his last breaths. Because he had his mother's eyes. He wanted to look at Lily one last time.
He loved Lily with all of his heart so he protected her son with all of his strength.
But the also used ever chance he could to bully the shit out of harry.
@@goodtaste4 I say it was a mix between "he is the son of the love of my life, but he is also the son of the person who took her away from me and humiliated me." In the first few movies Snape definitely doesn't treat him well, but after the 3rd or so on, he's still cold to him, but he doesn't treat him so terribly anymore. He took care of him in his own way and began to feel some affection towards him over time. It's not something that happened quickly. Plus, he unfortunately had to maintain the image of being the Head of Slytherin and try to not blow out his real loyalty because he was basically being under the noses of the "death eaters" and bad people who were loyal to Voldemort.
***sorry for my english***
@@BlOoDyVaMpIyour English is fine 😊
And I agree! I also think that if snaps didn’t have to pretend to hate harry etc that he would have shown more affection towards him outwardly. Instead he had to hide it and shove it down.
He despised Harry. lol. He protected him bc Dumbleledore but he really never liked Harry bc his resemblance to James.
@@BlOoDyVaMpI James didn't take Lily away from Snape. Snape took Lily away from Snape. They were friends, but then he called her a Mudblood and that was the last one for Lily. She knew he wanted to become a Death Eater, that he hated Muggle-Borns in general and she said "Why should I be different?" and it was during their fifth year, two years before James and Lily started dating. She didn't even was friend with James back then, she didn't even like him. So see, it's all Snape's fault if he didn't get the girl. That and the fact that Lily only ever saw him as a friend. James has nothing to do with it.
RIP Alan Rickman you were amazing as Snape.
Snape never went to Godric's Hollow in the book. It was put in the movie to make Snape more sympathetic. A truly marvelous move.
It really put Snape's feelings towards Lily in perspective, it was the feelings for her that finally turned him
Actually you don't know that.. It was not mentioned in the book was it?
The movie takes the W over the book on that one
I find Snape going to Godric's Hollow revolting.
Lily is in hiding with her family because Snape willingly joined the Death Eaters, knowing they tortured and murdered mugglueborns, spied for Voldemort and told the known murderer that a baby was a threat to his reign. Lily ended her friendship with Snape years prior because she knew the path Snape was heading down was a danger to her and that still wasn't enough.
Lily was killed along with her husband and very nearly her child too but how touching would it be for Snape to swoop in and fondle her corpse to make it all about his pain.
@@maraudentium2607 THANK YOU !!!
All I did was cry when I read Deathly hallows
I hated Dumbledore
Ive never read a book with so much passion and anger and fear..
Alan Fucking Rickman…. What an actor.
Rest In Peace
With one word Alan brought us to tears, always. 😢
Snape is the father harry didn't wanted but needed
Everybody..But everybody, misunderstood the sentences at 3:31 " Don't tell me now that you've grown to care for the boy" words... Everybody think that Dumbledore doesn't care Harry... That is a stupid idea.. Dumbledore try to say, we care Harry but you didn't care for him.. So right now, dont tell me now you've grown to care for the boy... That's simple.. How can they misunderstand this?
Because he says it in a sarcastic way
@@W_Junior But he is sarcastic for Snape.. Not for himself.. Snape always seems like hate Harry .. So he talk about this point.. This is so easy to understand..
Snap does hate Harry that is clear in the books! In the books Snape replies, “for him?!” And the. Makes Lilly’s doe. He never cared for Harry he just loves Lilly so much he is will to protect her son.
I always interpreted that way! It was clear to me that Dumbledore truly cared for Harry
He speaks coldly to show the audience that dumbledore wasent the perfect caring person harry thought he knew and it counteracts well with us learning snape wasent the cold hearted selfish person harry thought snape was.
itachi of hogwarts
We were all already under his Patronus😢❤
Ni que fuera infinity war para que estén llorando
@@tecontesto3922infinity war was lame
Before book 7 came out, we were all debating which side Snape was on. I had heard a theory that Snape was in love with Lily before, but it was a theory mixed in with a bunch of others, so I didn't give it any more credence than any of the others. Obviously in the two years between Half-Blood Prince and Deathly Hallows releases, I was convinced he was bad, but then when I went back to read the entire series again before DH came out, I really did feel like Snape had plenty of opportunities to hurt Harry and never did, and in fact protected him many times, so I found myself agreeing with Bellatrix in the Unbreakable Vow scene that his explanations are just too convenient for why he thwarted Quirrell in the first book, why he didn't answer Voldemort's summons when he returned in the 4th, etc. I wasn't sure what his endgame was. I wasn't sure if Dumbledore and Snape had plotted Dumbledore's death ahead of time, though I certainly thought it was a possibility. I did feel like Harry needed to die for this series to really have a full story, and I'd say he did, even if it was only for a fraction of time.
I also was discussing some theories on the internet. And at some point, I was quite sure he wasn't bad and they planned Dumbledore's deaths. Didn't recognize that Dumbledore was doomed anyway, though. Just had a feeling that "Severus, please" meant "do what we agreed on". Couldn't imagine him begging for his life.
What a time... all the discussions and theories. That was fun.
Snape is good and bad. He cares deeply but mainly for just Lily and Dumbledore. He was right about James for the first half but Snape decided to learn dark magic Lily didn’t like and he physically was rude to some students from the agony he holds in for 20 years at least. I can tell at least movie wise he still has a good heart. Believe he wasn’t as nice in the book(been a decade since I read the books)
The most tragic form that love takes is the one that endures from afar.
He did in fact hate Harry. He was a constant reminder that James got Lily and not him
He hated james and loved lily and Harry is the product of both.complication
A pesar de todo lo protegió, es lo entraordinario.
Thank you! Finally someone who read the book and gets it!
This scene royally messed me up when I saw it in theaters. I was UGLY crying 😂
Oooh, all these happy people who can enjoy the surprise. I've read the books when we had to wait for the next one. And during the waiting time, we discussed online. Besides, the books contain much more information. So we knew Severus and Lily were friends. And Harry was on the list of horcruxes for most readers.
It's really heartbroken 💔 but always remember it's just an act they are just acting ❤
I keel crying
One of the greatest scenes in cinematic history!
Worst thing about this is that Harry saw it: His gaze of protection, all this time, first year on the quidditch, second year when filtch though he cursed his cat, third year when Remus turned into a werewolf he throwed himself between the trio, fourth year believing that he didn’t threw his name into the goblet of fire, fifth year Occlumency, and then in the end
He has to learn he was raised like a swine to die
Honestly 10/10 story writing
Snape was such a great friend and then fell in love with Lilly but couldn't have her so he was hurt but Realize that he had to protect the boy for her.
Snake was racist and a bully, how could lily like him if he hated people like her
@szubidubi9473 you have not looked even further. There’s much you fail to understand. You won’t understand even we tell you, because you don’t realize what else there is to realize! There is far more to Snape than what you think to be all there is!
@szubidubi9473 it’s even been said this about Professor Snape, “I know you become extremely angry when someone takes away something you love. But we also have to consider how much he sacrificed for this boy. A man who, since childhood, has lost his dearest things and has become emotionally hardened. Yet, he never hesitated to give his life for this boy, simply because he is the son of the woman he loved. And I think he was always tough on the followers of Lord Voldemort to ensure there was no doubt about his loyalty."
Here is how you know if someone has read the series:”Why did they leave that part out?! Why did they change it?!”(that was me first time I watched it but still my favorite remake of a series)❤
At the end of the film, everyone knows that Professor snape is the real hero❤️🥹
A hero who was none the less vindictive and cruel to a small boy for the sole reason that he hated that boy's father. People seem to glance over that little fact.
@@Cerrydwenn "I know you become extremely angry when someone takes away something you love. But we also have to consider how much he sacrificed for this boy. A man who, since childhood, has lost his dearest things and has become emotionally hardened. Yet, he never hesitated to give his life for this boy, simply because he is the son of the woman he loved. And I think he was always tough on the followers of Lord Voldemort to ensure there was no doubt about his loyalty."
No he's not.
He started off gray, he ended off gray. He is no hero.
this scene deserves every damn prize that exists in this world
I ❤ Ash and Hannah.
It’s way more worse in books you can’t stop crying while reading his memories
Always ❤
RIP Alan Rickman ❤
Sin duda una escena fuerte
Snape from the movie is VERY different from book Snape
❤
3:08
Yes movie snape is incredible. Book snape was a complicated character and quite mean and nasty.
Snape is more loveable in the movies, courtesy of Alan Rickman’s incredible performance
@@ashhabimran239 And that's why I don't like Alan Rickman's performance. It's misleading.
I use to hate snape before this moment in the movie. This exact moment turned my hate into love for him. Man, he was always protecting Harry, alone. Even though Harry's father was abusive to him. His love for Lily is so much that he pushed everything aside for her to protect what is left of her in the world, Harry.
'oh, they were in love'
*cries immediately*
They weren't in love though. That couple got it sort of wrong. Snape was in love with Lily but Lily was never in love with him, she *loved* him because he was her friend but it never had a chance to go beyond that because of how Snape changed as they grow up.
They were never meant to be together, but there was always a love there that also connected to Harry.
I think that the relationship between Snape towards Harry in the movies, was more kind of love-hate, 'cause he loved him, because of Lilly and his resemblance to her; and he hated Harry, 'cause of the bullying that James inflicted on Snape 🥲
these were amazing reactions it made me sad watching them
Always
This man is the GOAT!
I still don't get where people get the "he loved Harry the most".
The only time he protected him was when Quirell hexed his broom 😭😭
Yo viendo todo el tiempo la saga, para ver a mi personaje favorito Snape el mejor.
Snape: always
I'm so pissed that the movie never explained about Snape's Patronus... When a wizard loves sincerely and purely someone, his/her Patronus changes to the same the person they love... That's why Snape's Patronus turned into a female deer
Anyone with a brain could infer that when he literally casts the fucking doe and dumber sore immediately says "Lily" wtf else could u even think
i just hope in the harry potter show they dont imply snape to be a double agent or even much good, the closest thing is when he helps harry when he says "no idea" when umbridge asks about padfoot, not sure what the books show though
Who cut onions😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Severus invocando el ciervo de lily, es lo mas profundo. Significa que él tenia la espada de grifindor, el era el mas merecedor de tenerla hasta que se la entrega a harry.
Everyone has it wrong. Snape never cared about Harry as a person, ever. He only did as Dumbledore wanted because of his love of Lilly. Period. As he lay dying he told Harry to look at him so he could see Lilly’s eyes once more. He only saw Harry as Jame’s son whom he hated. Snape’s patronus was a doe, same as Lilly’s.
That’s a book vs movie thing. Snape in the movies is actually charismatic and likeable
You are wrong. Snape cared for Harry because he was a part of Lily. Apparently you did not watch the movie or read the book. He loved Lily with all his heart
@@ahmedabdullah3539 I did apparently watch and read. The books are the true indicator of Snape’s feelings. He only asked Dumbledore to protect Lilly at first even though Riddle was after Harry. He hated James to the core and saw Harry as his not Lilly’s son. After the Order abandoned Grimauld Place as a hideout Snape snuck in and found a letter Lilly had written Sirius thanking him for Harry’s toy broomstick, and there was a picture of the three of them. Snape tore the picture to take Lilly’s image and threw the part with Harry and James under the bed. He also only took the second page of the letter with Lilly’s signature and “love” on it. How can you explain Snape’s horrendous and cruel treatment of Harry at school? He went to Dumbledore and said Harry was all the things he hated in James when all the other teachers said Harry was humble and kind. He saw NOTHING in Harry that was Lilly, nothing but his eyes. Ppl always want a villain to redeem themselves. Snape was a Death Eater. He didn’t care about Riddle killing and subjugating Muggles or Mudbloods .. except when Lilly was targeted. And Snape didn’t truly love Lilly anyway, he only thought he did or he never would have become a Death Eater who hated Mudbloods. He even slipped up and called Lilly one once. If he’d truly loved her he never would’ve followed Riddle because it displeased her. Don’t you remember the argument they had at school when Lilly said “you’ve chosen your way, I’ve chosen mine”? You need to reread the books .. *carefully* this time.
@@LisaG442 not sure about books but in movies at least, wasn't james a bully. James potter bullied snape severely. would you care for your bully ?
@@RohitSharma-oh8qm Harry never bullied anyone in either book or movie. It was James Potter and Serius Black who bullied Severus Snape while children. But Snape gave as good as he got, the hatred was mutual. But Snape transferred his hatred of James to his son Harry without giving the boy the least chance because he looked like his father.
Snape is a badass dobble agent protected harry bad ass
How did I nitpick cry
Always!
Haven’t these people read the books?
These are first time reactions to the series. What’s with the gatekeeping attitude?
@@ashhabimran239 People should remember Harry Potter is a series of books and read them first
SNAPE the gratest SIMP of all times 🤣
Snape didn't love Harry, he only loved Lilly. Over all, in the books, he did the right thing in the end, but he was not really a good guy. If it wasn't for Lilly's death, he might have been a death eater till the end.
Name of girl crying
Crying girl
😢😢😢🥀😢😢😢
tf was that girl watching? cause it was certainly not harry potter. at the water when sirius was about to die it was not a doe patronus, it was a stag, caster by harry
Maybe about the last parts
It was about the pond where Harry and Ron have found a sword.
Should ask yourself that question
I love that "ITs liLY pOtAh"
No his dad use to bully him
And after all of this, most fans still keep saying Severus Snape was a horrible person! What ignorance!!
People really only got from this that Snape hated Harry 😂what a bunch of wankers that’s not what you should be taking from this 👊🏻❤️dude Snape looked at Harry in the eyes more than dumbledoor did and protected him throughout 7 series , how brain dead are you guys , dude clearly didn’t like James but to sit here and say hate that’s ridiculous , everyone gets some form of bullying in school but the dude from every single movie produced had Harry’s back and through the very end had his back
Snape was nothing but evil. Sold out James and Harry to Voldemort to get Lily, then sold out Voldemort for revenge when that didn't work out for him.
Wait wait wait wait.
He had no way to know the boy of the half listened prophecy, in fact he panicked when he understood Voldemort's intentions
@@antoninofrisella4906 I like the conspiracy theory. That and DD's 93 chances for bad guys.
Movie snaps and book snape are not the same characters
If you read the ending of The Cursed Child where Harry and his son met the graves, Harry and his son both say that Snape and Dumbledore were both good men! So the books even establish Snape to being good. I even read the books before the movies came out, and Snape being good all along was what I got from after reading the seventh book. The same goes for many others who’ve read the books! You may say Snape isn’t a good person, or the same between both the movies and the books, but the movies and the books established that Snape was a good person all along; someone who may have made past mistakes sure, but was secretly good all along since he tried to protect the Potters with Dumbledore’s help which is how the Potters went into hiding in Godric’s Hollow. But that protection plan Snape and Dumbledore came up with didn’t work out, because Peter Pettigrew betrayed the Potters out of fear for his own life by telling Voldemort where the Potters were being kept in hiding. That’s then how Voldemort found the Potters and killed the parents, and tried to kill Harry but failed to. Snape worked with Dumbledore to try and hide them. That’s why Snape said, “Hide them! Hide them all! I beg you!” Severus before that even confessed to Dumbledore to having been a death eater, but after finding out Voldemort was hunting the Potters down, he secretly started to work with Dumbledore. After Voldemort killed the Potters except for Harry, Snape then officially wanted to undermine Voldemort in every way and make sure Harry destroyed him, Voldemort not knowing Severus Snape was trying to help Harry destroy him all along ever since Harry’s parents were killed.
Snape had made mistakes yes, but he proved himself to be good in the end. Sure he still held grudges against James Potter, but with Severus Snape having been abused by his muggle father at home during the summer and being bullied by James and his friends every day at school, you can’t expect his hard feelings for James or his own muggle father to go away. So yeah, Snape was traumatized and that being why he was so bitter around even Harry, but despite all of that, Harry came to realize Snape was a good man all along. Ever since after Voldemort’s death by Harry’s hand, while talking about Snape, Harry said, “He was the bravest man I had ever known.”
@@thebosstex1172 Sue, 10 year old Severus was good. So was Darth Vader at that age. But as Remus describe Pettigrew "He sold Harry and James to Voldemort" If she'd lived he'd've moved right in to comfort the grieving widow until he got in her pants. Same trick used in Ghost.
More proof? Went out of his way to bully the child who proved 'his girl' loved someone else. And not as a peer, but an adult with authority. He certainly saw similarity between Harry and his own bad childhood.
I think the real world explanation is JKR liked Rickman and so redeemed Snape. Great and all, but we all cheered when Hanz dropped from Nakatome Tower compliments of Willis.
soo fake
I refuse to believe some of these reactions are genuine. It's been like more than a decade this movie has been aired.
Not everyone lives your life bro
WE are just OLD !
most of these people probably aren't british
I support JK Rowling
💯
Gayest video in youtube 😂😂
Children, read a book better than to look at these pathetic attempts by Yates
They're adults.
🤡
Says the one acting like a child
This is one of the most masterful scenes in cinema history. The movie is just as good as the book for this scene.
@@ashhabimran239 Not really, they're just saying they love the book passionately and aren't a fan of the film. People are always going to have their likes and dislikes and we can agree to disagree. They're allowed.
Странно, словно люди не читали книг, такая реакция у всех, на правду, лол 😂😂😂 эх вы западники