Phenomena of Trump and Modi are completely different says Arundhati Roy
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 ต.ค. 2017
- "Modi is a culmination of 100 years of Hindutva", says Arundhati Roy on May 3rd, 2017 in San Francisco
Event: lannan.org/events/arundhati-r...
Original video: • Arundhati Roy with Ant...
Follow on twitter for updates: [@aroybot | / aroybot ]
![[TH] GEN vs SEN | FPX vs TH - VALORANT Champions 2024 DAY 1](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VcyH-0LAlhs/mqdefault.jpg)
She said(5:01): ''No one has been secular but at least they pretended to be and now there will be no pretence''. Love her honesty.
@Ramya Maddali I m a businessperson..I m from Punjab..I go to Kashmir every other month..spend 7-8 days there in between Kashmiri youth..I see them, I talk to them..they themselves will tell u what they want..they want progress..they want a slice of new India..which your Arundhati does not want them to get..she wants them to be handed over to Pakistanis..Kashmiris r our children..r u telling me to through my own kids at the wolf? What kind of woman r u? I m a mother of two children..I can feel a mother's anguish when her kid blow himself up. I can understand Arundhati and mehbooba speaks for money..but not the same for u, y do u want 2 push the kashmiris to certain death?
Really? Speak for yourself.
@@mrs.niludas8941 kashmiris do want a slice of new India and want progress. Right!
@@lovereachable I bet u r 1000 of miles away from Kashmir.. I m saying what I m saying from inbetween then so sir/ma'am dont sweat it.
@@mrs.niludas8941 I replied in agreement with you. There was no sarcasm! By "right" meant "right".
Excellence from a real educated human being. I am a Hindu by birth but my Bengali Hindu upbringing never told me that We are any different from any religion and to hate anyone. I think people who spread hatred and kill people in the name of religion have no religion. They are just uneducated and lack any moral standard to be called human. When I was growing up my mother told me that being Hindu means that God lives inside me. Hence if that is the logic a real Hindu will never harm any human being as Good lives in him too. And if the war is which God is higher, then Hindu means man/ woman is the highest God.
Being a dalit myself , every word she uttered is utmost true.🙏🙏
You have been brainwashed for anti modi vote
I would love to see her debate with Rajiv Malhotra on various topics relating to india, both past and present.
@Ajey Chahal he is a pseudo science peddler
@@softgrowl And that's why he was a professor at the Columbia University, isn't it ?
@@rahulray9983 what has that to do with what he is doing.
@@softgrowl she won't stand a chance if Malhotra gets a forum with her. I can somewhat respect her as a writer, but her politics is atrocious.
@@rutvikrs she can't buy the crap and bs of the pseudo malotra
The fault is not in the country but the people who live in it who doesn't even want to talk about the atrocities being done to fellow country men and supporting a regime based solely on race caste and religion. Many years after this the future generation will wonder what we were doing and why we didn't take any action when we had time just like we wonder about our ancestor that how did they let british rule us for so long.
All the bhakts high on gaumotra criticizing her...tell me a single thing she was wrong about
Everything is wrong that she told because who the mother fucker would criticise that happend with kashmiri pandits in 1990. And you Mr. ''Chamche'' read the history first of all that if Muslim loved India and they wanted to live in india than why they asked a different country for Muslims in 1947 and after the division why only 60% of Muslims went to live in pakistan.
And people like you and her(Roy) are biased. I have never heard a single word against Islamic terrorism and jihad that is going on not only In India but also all over the world. Read some international newspapers what is going on in Sweden, New Zealand, France, And London. Latest from Sri Lanka.
India will never be a Islamic country and people who speaks everything wrong about RSS and WHP, I would like to give an advice them अनुनय विनय नहीं युयुत्सा
... everything....lol
She ....is against the India...she should be expelled from India...or jailed
Selectively biased she is
How about EVEYTHING.
"All hail hydra."
Great introspection of the facts, true ground realities, a lawless India for now. A man got lynched dead and morons testing what kind of meat is in his fridge. Hindutba behave well when ruled by some other folks. Rushing for the same now. They will get it back soon.
I am Indian Muslim...and she is a
Radical Leftist... Just ignore her...🙏
Chota burhan wani
Wow. Brave woman. She breaks it down like no one else. Cuts through the fluff and says it like it is. The rise of the RSS is dangerous for the existence of India.
Their no wow in it how she still mentally sane talking ill about her own country world is thirsty for negetive news more so from india
Agreed what about Islamic terrorism? RSS is no where close to Islamic terrorism.
Even Muslims
Existence of your India, sure. RSS and BJP are heralding the dawn of a new India, an India proud of its civilisational identity, that is Santana Dharma. An India that will reclaim its rightful place in the world. An India that will embrace modernism and advance Hinduism into a new enlightened Golden Age, through reform and renaissance.
RSS is the one which has saved india.
Excellent
A classic case of Cry the beloved country. So glad my parents left for a better life elsewhere post-Independence. It took a while but the shit has well and truly hit the fan now
This is never to say India is the only country with issues like this. What do you think the KKK or the Proud Boys in America is if not a white evangelical version of RSS? The current trend of global politics is moving towards totalitarian right wing governments. Arundhati is 100% right about what’s happening in India, but that doesn’t mean Boris Johnson, American imperialism, Erdogan, Bolsonaro etc are any better. If you read Roy’s work, she is anti-American. She calls herself that. Obviously in this video, she isn’t sharing her particular ways on other countries.
@Sourav Aggarwal she has never had anything but sympathy for Kashmiri Pandits. Please read her actual work. She has talked about how the government is using their real life struggles and trauma as propaganda, not that their actual lives are propaganda.
Arundhati Roy is spot on, on this.
And that's why you have to edit such a spot on comment
@Ramya Maddali I m a businessperson..I m from Punjab..I go to Kashmir every other month..spend 7-8 days there in between Kashmiri youth..I see them, I talk to them..they themselves will tell u what they want..they want progress..they want a slice of new India..which your Arundhati does not want them to get..she wants them to be handed over to Pakistanis..Kashmiris r our children..r u telling me to through my own kids at the wolf? What kind of woman r u? I m a mother of two children..I can feel a mother's anguish when her kid blow himself up. I can understand Arundhati and mehbooba speaks for money..but not the same for u, y do u want 2 push the kashmiris to certain death?
Hyperbolic outrageous statements.
@@mrs.niludas8941 yes, kashmiris want a slice of new India. They want progress.
Muslim league was the first religious party founded in India. In Kerala they always use to hold education ministry which led to the increase in the number of Madrasas
I have been hearing this women's speech for many years. However, in all of her speech she portrays Muslims as the victims in India especially the Kashmir issue. Unfortunately she forgets to mention that Kashmiris muslim have the propaganda to create a separate state and join Pakistan. Their first step was to kill, torture and Wade away the Kashmiri pandits of Indian administered Kashmir. It is so sad that some Indians always think about fame rather than the truth. She is completely biased.
Where were u when Hindus of Kashmir were forced to stay in refugee camps in Jammu
Oh...you called this mad lady
Ma'am u r really brilliant and humanresource not for India but for whole global society
you nailed it.
What India is and what she wants to propagate are as different as Malaysia and Afghanistan.
An amazing intelligent, thoughtful and intriguing spirit. 💕✌️💪
@Ramya Maddali I m a businessperson..I m from Punjab..I go to Kashmir every other month..spend 7-8 days there in between Kashmiri youth..I see them, I talk to them..they themselves will tell u what they want..they want progress..they want a slice of new India..which your Arundhati does not want them to get..she wants them to be handed over to Pakistanis..Kashmiris r our children..r u telling me to through my own kids at the wolf? What kind of woman r u? I m a mother of two children..I can feel a mother's anguish when her kid blow himself up. I can understand Arundhati and mehbooba speaks for money..but not the same for u, y do u want 2 push the kashmiris to certain death?
How long did it take you to think up those words 😂😂 Wannabe intellectuals
I wonder where were these intellectual seculars when Taslima Nasrin was harrased and our very own Mir a comedian from Kolkata was pathetically trolled and threatened by the people of his community just for comparing his father to his god. Freedom of speech is a vital issue now a days. But use it in every aspect of your social life. Otherwise it would be difficult for us to believe you.
A citizen, who has her straight forward opinion, can't please everybody, liked it, accept it, if not live it, everyone has the right to freedom of speech, Constitution right. Of many woman in India, she seems to be one of the extraordinary intelligent.
I'm an Indian. .yes she is saying right
She is speaking what is rightly happening in india.
She is catholic Christian where rude structure related to religion is present .but she use to give lecture on how Hindu and hindusim becoming a radical.
*She makes a complete fool out of Trump !*
Arundhati Roy thanks for being the voice of the unheard.
Is she describing RSS or Hydra? Which Muslim has been taken to concentration camp.
At the same time I do agree with many of things she says. Including this is zenith of RSS idealogy, I wish for a steep decline hereafter.
Silly don't you remember 2002? What about regular lynching and encounters of young muslim boys that keep taking place.
@@iraneko6326 totally agree, things are far from decent. But are there concentration camps. Also has RSS idology inflitrated to the extent she says.
I want to see a time when she praise modi and hindutva, and that time comes soon when anti national will be thrown out of the country
I read news daily and this lady is not a liar but an illusionist. Communal tension have happened before Modi, were happening under his tenure and will happen after his tenure as well. While each incidence of communal violence is a huge black spot for any government, this lady is over exaggerating the situation beyond the boundaries of fiction.
(Thus demeaning the sufferings of people who have actually gone through such incidences)
Being a democratic country India has to tolerate these "Traitors ". Unfortunate but True. There are some weak points of Democracy.
Yes. rightly said. she is a big traitor!!
Yes why don't u guys sent her to Pakistan?
Are you actually bashing democracy? Democracy is the only reason you’re allowed to have an (almost) uncensored Internet connectivity, or a right to roam freely on the street. You fucking Hindu fundamentalist, bashing the one thing which gives you freedom. Karma is a bitch.
I love her
I love my Great And Beautiful India
She's a intellect Lol !!!😁
Not really she was very dishonest here.
She is a jihadist supporter. She is all screwed up, supported by the new world news media.
Such a sweet but a powerful voice!! Iron lady..
I am Indian Muslim.. And she is
Saying half truth...🙏
Voice of sanity
What she said is true .. thoothukodi issue is an example..13 innocent people were killed by police men for peaceful protest..
Its been 5 years since and her propaganda has failed miserably
Where Kashmiri pandits or rather I would say Kashmiri Hindus have gone ???
Arundhati ji.Any answer for this
I must say she is the best ...... Fictional character
A courageous intelligent woman who is constantly under attack from the hindu right wing..some of them in the comments below..
When someone abuses your mother and only find the faults and expose them to the neighbour and public.... Will you support and compliment the person!!!
Of course people. She speaks the truth. Even for the sake of country, she speaks the truth and that's doesn't sees any mother or father. Speak sense. Humans are humans. No Hindu, no Indians
Indeed she is a brave lady not like Modi who pretends to be a caretaker of Hindus.
Watch some of Brigitte gabriel's videos..
She says that thousands of intellectual are jailed ,then with all this reorectic against a Hindu India ,for the first time in Indian history of 60 years of democracy .
Why is she happy in debates ,why is she not jailed .
The problem with India is ,it's got too much Democratic values to encourage pseudo humanists like her to blossom.
My blood pressure rises as soon as o hear this woman talk..btw i noticed she is so "unsure" about what she says..not a great representative of the left wingers I would say
read "what can and can't be said" the conversation she and John Cussak and Edward Snowden and Daniel Elsberg had
Absolutely, mine too. Because she states that fact without prejudice. And Truth is bitter and it rises blood pressure, irrespective of who's saying it. It's really not very comfortable for any indian to hear the clear facts of "Barbarization of India". You have a choice between Blood-pressure and Ostrich-syndrome. It's your call.
Its obvious your blood pressure increases because of the bitter reality she is telling
Get some high blood pressure medicine or go get an education. And, btw she's the best representative we all can have!
I wish shoe would have been in China and speak the way she is doing.
Brothers.... Anything that goes against the unity of the nation and harms INDIA and gives strength to the enemy state... Must be stopped.... She decleared that all is so very bad in India as if it has become a rouge state and Banana Republic... Why?
What I don't understand is how DOES Modi deal with the BJP's RSS-ish religious wing if he s a Sikh? I saw him with a Sikh turban in a photo when he go elected.
Neither BJP nor RSS are religious. They are social movements.
There is no beef between RSS and Sikhs.
😀😀😀 I am
Living in India and she is exaggerating things ,, she can roam and talk to media that itself shows that India is democratic and tolerant
How is she exaggerating?
She literally quoted incidents that have already happened
And she can't roam and talk to media like this inside India...we all know what happens to those who raise their voice against the establishment
She makes a lot of sense if one turns their back of facts. Otherwise, I am a great admirer, she has a special talent for language and perception, but her views are best explained by Thomas Sowell in his book Conflict of Visions. She ignores human nature and human history for the delusion of perfection can be just around the corner. Humans are a extraordinary and horrible species, exhibiting astonishing feats of brilliance on one hand and horror on the other. No amount of rhetoric or pleasing vision will change this. It is the inherent reality we deal with, sometimes better than others.
Wow, So I got to know that I live in such a bad place ... everything is so bad in our country ... I didn't feel even a bit of it when I was sitting in the heart of India ...
Lol
@@lovereachable yeah...felt the same....am i missing anything or she is just exaggerating
She's pointed to a handful of of incidences out of a nation of 1.2 billion, as if it were the first time this is happening. In fact the amount of violence between communities is going down.
Agreed
They might kill her, she should get protection.
She is really great and really cares for human beings
The Lady thinks she is ultra intelligent but she is far from it😂
Sandeep Singh she just talked about the brutal incidents that took place under Modi's government.
@@jpriyadharshini I know her better than you. No need for your information. This bitch never talks about brutalities happened to Kashmiri, Bengali, Assamese Hindus.
Truth is bitter and no Indian will be happy to hear the story of "Barbarization of India". And obviously one who speaks about it like Arundhati Roy cannot be popular.
why,,, do you mean people all over the world are dumb were you stopped from watching it
She is so disciplined.. I had seen many videos of hers and in all of them she had said only NEGATIVES about India.. few facts and 90% figments of her imagination...
That's the reason even after being a successful writer hardly people know them in India.
People like her just know to criticize.. I have never heard or read any concrete words from her how to improve things...
Yes indian peoples not know her well becz they do not want to listen the truth
Poor congress can’t earn money in corruption and bribery that’s your problem Ms Roy?🤔
Only corporate money cannot bring by the same way all parties are backed by corporate money
A beatiful lady Arundhati Roy. She speaks her heart for the oppressed in India. Brave lady.
As a Indian, I need u to be prime minister of India 😔
The only Intellectual in Eurasia right now..Give her the Nobel already.
Really? Or was that sarcasm I didn't get?
@@oberynmartell8154 Yeah.. Honey.. She has already been shortlisted for the Nobel thrice.. And last year she was nominated for the Alternative Nobel Prize (New Academy Prize) from India..Not to mention her 4th position on Times Most Influential List in 2014 (and some 28 Literary Prizes).. So I guess get your General Knowledge act together baby.
@@ANKITPANDEY-vm8kx She seems to have got a few literally prizes along with honorary Booker Prize but please enlighten me with any links to go through where it claims she was nominated for Noble Prize (or alternative) I just went through her Wiki again to check if I missed anything but I was dejected that I didn't.
@@oberynmartell8154 honorary Booker??.. Dude.. You really need learn to surf the Internet????...The God of Small Things has fucking won the 1997 Man Booker.. Also Man Booker doesn't give honorary prizes at all. Seriously... Also just buy her books online (if you can afford all 9 of them) and read them (if your intelligent enough to understand her writing) and please ignore Wikipedia as much as you can.
@@ANKITPANDEY-vm8kx When I said "honorary" I used it as an adjective to the Man Booker Prize, nevermind I understand your frustration.
Now can you please help me with sources where it's cited that she was nominated for Noble Prize or alternative? May be you can calm down a bit, research and send me the links/ sources instead of being concerned if I can afford to buy her books?
How many lies you can peddle?
Lol when i saw her first . I thought she was the one who got locked up in a room for 20 years. Betwen she seems to be a good person
It would be nice if she can talk about Goa Inquisition when thousands of Indians - Hindus, Christians (orthodox) and muslims were put to death. However, she may try, Indians will not allow a repeat of what happened to Navajo Indians in the U.S.
Brilliant mind; So proud that she is Indian!
Will all of what she is saying possible to be done in 3 years?
She became next prime minster of India and just see what she can offer Indian.
Where are the 1 crore jobs, PM.Modi?
Its in saudi arabia.
Seriously, Muslims are driven in to refugees camp. She must be talking about Rohingyas who are originally refugees. Well her speech was more fascinating adding real incidents to achieve her agenda.
She is exaggerating everything.
Roy is great personality anf always stand for unprivileged people and trible people
Ever she attended any RSS unit or function ? Or even read any of the RSS books.. nothing such happens because of this govt.but a public doing ..
she is one whistle alarmer who is roaming free and does not need zblackcat security.she is the perfect example of freedom of speech and for democracy in her homeland without her endorsing any ngo,corporate.maosists are the last samurais
Rss has thousand of woman and dalit workers. Indian president is dalit and pm is obc. They both are from rss.on the other hand so called humanitarian leftist parties don't have any big leader from lower castes. Most of the leftist intellectuals are brahmin. You are a lier
Clear framed propaganda..
She is a kind of lady...whom I called real terrorist. ...people like her use literature to spread there view and chant about well being of one particular religion. ..because this is how they can only get famous...how can people like her called himself secular???? People like her should sent behind bars ....because they are the real people who weakens the root of India's tolerance with there negative speech. ...they are the real communal....
Brilliant magnification of the current reality by an intellect (not intelligent, the word intelligence is misunderstood by most intellectuals). Creative writers always come up with a story that is interesting, and will have to weave such conflicts and twists. I would love to read what she writes but it will not influence one inch of my idea about india. The fact that you are expressing your views and criticisms from this soil is a testimony to our intolerance and freedom of speech. Good luck for your next best selling book mam! You are a good writer though and you got my respect for your literary work but I cannnot trust you. This is what my heart says truly.
Where does she get such hate stories.... I don't like few things about how we are going now a day but she seems to create a total paranoia out of it..... Incredible
You're spot on... But why are we wasting our time listening to such disgruntled people?
@@chitrakrishnan822 because of the forum and stature she occupies? It requires a measured response.
How can someone lie so casually?
She is Maoist (Communist), what can you expect from her.
WOW! Absolutely wow.
In kashmir where is Army tank.
Wow, she's brilliant as always, and if you peruse the comments, you'll see extremists everywhere.
I respect her work, but isn't this lady just sharing one side of the story on an international platform, thus totally misleading the audience?
She is a parasite !
No, she is more intellectual than u, u won't able to understand
@@vivekgaikwad5427 No one questioned her intellect. She is biased, so are most of us. And, instead of trying to teach me about myself, what my intellect can grasp and cannot why don't you use your intellect and correct your grammar. All the best.
Shut up u Aryan invaders . U don't belong to this country . Go back to Eurasia
OMG!!.. I think Muslims are living much peaceful life here than even in Iraq or Syria isn't it??.. She is speaking as if there is a military regime here.. Umm and if RSS has invaded the publications.. So has Muslims as well as Christians.. So why only RSS is being singled out??.. She should actually go to North kerala where in some areas Muslims are the majority.. Can she name even one place where Hindus are a majority outside India??..
She is a damn liar.
She is a sellout, she gets paid by her British masters to say what she is saying.
She is from Kerala lmao! Clearly you don't know what you are talking about
I'm from Bangladesh, and in many places here Hindus are the majority. Even in Dhaka, there are restaurants where they don't sell beef to respect the majority Hindu customers. Also, RSS is an institution that only works for a select few individuals, it doesn't represent the whole Hindu community of India, but uses their sentiment to further their own extreme views.
she pick up the current condition of india.
She is absolutely right.
Someone ask her about Jesus travel to india and meeting a saint ( MAHAVATAR BABAJI) which is not mentioned in the Bible. Is this the saint whom Jesus called Father. Ask her Nosterdamus predictions about india, an immortal ruler from the south. Whether there is any connection between this and the holy secret what church is hidding.
Very true.... Facisicist regime has taken over India... Rioters r free.. Police is with riotet... Judiciary is incapable.... N govt is RSS. Rest in peace humanity in India. V true in these days... Yet worse is to come in next 4 years.
What about Islamic terrorism? Is RSS more dangerous than Islamist terrorist groups?
Still nothing happened
Has she paid all the tax for over rupees 2 crore she got for her book and for divorcing her husband. Has she donated anything to poor.
I really don't know why this lady thinks that rich people are evil !! And they cannot do politics !!!!! Because this world is equal to both rich and poor but they way she says is like rich people must not be allowed to take part in elections is irritating me a lot !!!
She is a gem of our modern India....
Arundhati Roy♥️
Its time now that Indian Muslims decide their future and demand for a new and separate country like others did. #CAA #CAB #NRC
You can go to Pakistan , Bangladesh or best China people like you are just burden on INDIA
If Arundhati were in Pakistan and said the same thing that she has said here, she would be risking her life. Thanks to India's tolerance.
Just criticize your local MLA for bad quality roads and you will be labelled anti national too
@@shubbi300 You are stupid. Definitely you can criticize but you will be ignored, and nothing will happen.
BOTH TRUMP & MODI ARE THE TWO SIDES OF THE SAME COIN!
ARUNDHATI ROY STORY TELLER PAR EXCELLENCE. WOULD BE NICE IF STORIES HAD SOME STATS TO SUPPORT THE BEAUTIFULLY TEMPERED RANT, WHICH OTHERWISE COULD BE MISUNDERSTOOD AS A SERIOUS COMMENTARY, WITH COMPARISONS BETWEEN DIFFERENT PERIODS OF GOVERNANCE.
IT WOULD BE NICER IF YOU COULD TALK ABOUT YOUR IDEA OF INDIA, RATHER THAN WHAT IT SHOULDN'T BE.
Republican is also more than 100 year institutions.
Evry word she said is true. However I wonder if there is a solution to it.
👍👍👍
If india can not be Hindu National then tel dear Mom which country can be Hindu nation.
She is saying "socialist" in USA 🤣🤣🤣
Arundhati Roy is such a wonderful joy! Golden tower, Golden shower! 😂 killed me!
Not sure why Americans are interested in India. As an Indian and a responsible one I should tell you 90℅ of what she said were lies 😅