Melanie Phillips: I Was "Othered" By the Left After I Became Pro-Israel | The Quad Interviews
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 ต.ค. 2024
- The Quad interview columnist and author Melanie Phillips about her harrowing journey from the left, why she prefers to be in Israel over anywhere else and how, despite the hardships and pain, Israel will prevail over its enemies.
Watch the full show here: • Melanie Phillips: My J...
Subscribe Now to @JNS_TV
Stay informed about Israel and the Jewish World!
Latest news: Get in-depth analysis at bit.ly/jewish_...
Subscribe for more: Never miss a story - sign up for our newsletter bit.ly/subscri...
Support our work: Your donation helps JNS fight for accurate headlines: bit.ly/Support...
The Quad (Fleur Hassan Nahoum, Emily Schrader, Vivian Bercovici and Ashira Solomon) premieres on
TH-cam: @JNS_TV
Facebook: / jns.org
Twitter: / jns_org
Website: jns.org
Melanie Phillips deserve double the NOBEL PRIZE for being a morality compass in this insane world.
Morality compass?!! With some of her views she seems to me to be part of the insanity
She’s sick
No, I wouldn't say that. The Nobel prize lost its value the moment Arafat received it. Melanie deserves much more! ❤❤❤
@@miraladak2314 There there.
@@miraladak2314 YOU seem to me to be part of the insanity that interferes with the defense of the Jews.
Thank you for explaining the hypocrisy of the liberals. "Soft bigotry" ... great term.
Indeed 😊👍
Melanie is a big source of light and elegance. She brings clarity of the dubject and insight to the conversation
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” Netanyahu told his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy"
Haaretz, October 2023.
@@jjohn408 Hi Goebbels
Wow where’s the source or did they just make it up. For example I can say:
Obama said to his cabinet that supporting china is imperative to preventing the republicans from rising to power
It doesn’t make it true. If Obama’s enemies can make up any quote that he allegedly said without evidence then what has the world come to
@@jjohn408 Haaretz is a radical left newspaper they bashing slamming against the right or anyone who is not in their club so one takes them seriously They praised Hitler as a responsible and promising politician before he rose to power
@@jjohn408 It was said by someone who wasn't even in the meeting. Politics...
The Palestinians are united by one goal, undoing Israel. Having a state when that is their mindset can be fatal to Israel can be fatal.
Israel's support came from several reasons:
1. Until the Palestinians decide what they want besides being united about destroying Israel. Having different governments under the West Bank and Gaza is a strategic move. So our government can check the water with a proposal for peace every now and then which was never received
2. Hamas is the government in Gaza, improving the Gazans' life was seen as an essential phase in reducing the desire for terror. You can't have the help economy of Gaza without their government.
Obviously, this method failed and now Hamas has to be removed from any position of power in Gaza. Work in progress.
Such a courageous, well spoken, direct lady. I do hope she takes care.
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” Netanyahu told his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy"
Haaretz, October 2023.
@@jjohn408 Hi Goebbels
Huge appreciation to Melanie. Please don’t be intimidated by these bullies.
When Melanie Phillips isn't speaking for me, she's speaking about me with 100% accuracy. She really is a prophet.
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” Netanyahu told his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy"
Haaretz, October 2023.
@@jjohn408 I'm guessing he changed his mind after October 7th. Wouldn't you?
@@jjohn408 Hi Goebbels
Thats a lie.. another one@@jjohn408
Ja ja ja ja ja kära vän
Most people calling London "Londonistan" today don't even know it was the title of her book, back in 2006!
Your intelligence, knowledge and courage is unparalleled!
I stand with Israel from South Africa 🇮🇱🇿🇦
Israel, God is with you in your battles. Oh yes, the Jewish people will prevail. God's covenant covers you. Praise God for his love and protection.
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” Netanyahu told his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy"
Haaretz, October 2023.
@@jjohn408 Hi Goebbels
@@jjohn408 Lying and spinning fake narratives doesnt help your side anymore. For sure, many buy into it. Even many buy into thinking ''israel'' is behind the establishment, when in fact the establishment is deeply anti-israel (as they are against any strong sense of community and culture, especially if they are strongly pro-morality).
However as more people buy into those false narratives, the contrast between you and those that have morals and who aim for a bright future for all, deepens.
The more obvious the badness of the other side is, the more people will wake up and see this war for what it really is. A war for the very moral survival of humanity, against those that have been slowly corrupting it for many years.
Does God supports genocidal maniacs? Who openly blaspheme the name God and his son Christ. May God give you conscience to see the lies you have been made to believe.
Godspeed 🇮🇱🙏
I admire this woman’s integrity and honesty.
Mrs Phillips is formidable! Courage, intelligence, and humanity
Thanks and respect!
the USA stands with Israel! Stay strong Melanie!
Some of the USA does, some are asleep , and others are mindlessly chanting to the tune of the foreign Simon sez.....
Thank you Melanie!
I am an ally to Israel and the Jewish people. Love from America. 💙🙏
There is one thing I don't understand. How and why one would ever be not Pro-Israel?
One reason might just be simple anti semitism. Another, much more complex, is a brainwashing that has been inculcated in children forever. The inculcated mindset Melanie spoke of that infects the left.
@@D1it4FNthat IDF has killed 15.000 children that last month
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” Netanyahu told his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy"
Haaretz, October 2023.
IMO because socialist academics have been brainwashed into thinking we are and should be one big tribe when in fact there are multiple tribes..that dont always coexist peacefully...one of the smallest being jews and the largest being muslims
Jews have a long memory of the regular massacre of arab jews by other arabs dating back over 1000 years something that many academics conveniently ignore jmo
@@jjohn408 Hi, Goebbels
Stand with Israel,🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
Melanie, you saved my day. Definitely Israel will prevail.
There is a magic to that land, to the people !
Melanie is, without a doubt, a great woman with intelligence, rationality, decency, and common sense.
National thesaurus ❤
He, he, he! Luckily for me I never harboured any delusions about Guardian or BBC types. My working class nose sniffed out their cant in a few minutes. Best to dump the telly where they are practically rabid now against the white working class and ignore them completely. Imagine paying that whopping £160 license just to be insulted by them any chance they get!
Rabbi Tovia Singer talks about the racism of The Guardian in his brilliant talk, “Anti-Israel Bias.”
It matches perfectly with Melanie’s experiences.
❤
Israel is fighting for it's life. They are also fighting for us if only we did but know.
Exactly
Palestinians, too, are fighting for their life. They too have just as much right to exist
They are coming for us next and surprise they are already here
Israel is by no means innocent in all this. Trying to play a victim after behaving like the regional bully boy
@@miraladak2314 400 million Arabs in 22 Muslim countries vs 7 million Jews in one country … and you think Israel is the bully?
How uneducated.
Great interview!
The old hatred has returned, if it ever left.
It's newest manifestation is antizionism.
It never really leaves, goes under the surface for a while but always resurfaces.
@@jacobcohen9205 Sadly true, Blessings.
Quite
@@randomobserver683 Sadly, yes.
Melanie is brilliant and so well spoken. The entire world should listen to this super intelligent woman.
Thank you Melanie as you say that some of the comments here on TH-cam will not convince
But you are exactly right with every word you say❤️
Congrats to you Melanie Philips, for speaking the truth utterly and bravely. Warms my heart ❤🙏
ISRAEL HAS TO GET YOUR FINGER BACK ON THE PULSE!
ISRAEL STAND STRONG AND KEEP MOVING FORWARD! GOD HAS BLESSED ISRAEL!
She's always on point 💯🌸💯🌸💯🌸💯
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” Netanyahu told his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy"
Haaretz, October 2023.
@@jjohn408 If you were in his shoes, what would you have done differently???
I love listening to her.
Sooo true Lady! Very sadly true
I love listening to melanie phillips❤
Brilliant 👏
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” Netanyahu told his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy"
Haaretz, October 2023..
@@jjohn408 thank you
Yes I'm the enemy of the Left as well ... God bless Isreal . Viva Israel 🇮🇱
Израиль 🇮🇱 навсегда!
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” Netanyahu told his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy"
Haaretz, October 2023.
@@jjohn408 Hi Goebbels
@@jjohn408 who cares. Israel is morally correct to oppose a izan allied state from forming next them.
Amen.
What an impressive woman! We would be very happy to have you as a Knesset member.
Yes. And Caroline Glick as PM.
Agree 100 percent
She brings light to the Trio of Shame: Finkelstein, Mate' & Chomsky. Thank you Melanie.
Bless Melanie Phillips. Amen.
Am Yisrael Chai
Ah. We have to describe unsuccessful countries as “developing world” countries. We have been assuming “development” happens automatically over time. It turns out, it isn’t automatic, and it takes blood, toil, tears and sweat. And not being misled by false religious ideas. Civilisation is a precious jewel, and a rarity! Few better things we could be doing than fighting for its preservation. Be led by Israel, guys!
The best way to support Israel is to buy Israeli government bonds.❤❤❤
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” Netanyahu told his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy"
Haaretz, October 2023..
@@jjohn408 Hi Goebbels
@jjohn408
Divide and Rule. PM Sharon plan was to divide the Palestinians into 3 groups. GAZA, East Jerusalem and Area A of the West Bank. Gaza was to become an autonomous Singapore and eventual independence. East Jerusalam population annexed to Israel. Area A to become walled Palestinians cities. Palestinians in area B and C moved to Area A and annexed. Hamas in Gaza changed all that. It decided to fight. Is that noble or dumb?
@@jjohn408whatever he did at the time was right for the time. You try and make something of a political point today that is meaningless.
Melanie those friends who have deserted you were never your friends. True friends stay with us through thick and thin…Regards.
Melanie I have always admired your honest views on world affairs.you are a very trustworthy journalist/writer / reporter.keep safe and all good wishes.
God bless Israel & MAGA2024🇮🇱🇺🇸🇮🇱🇺🇸
An excellent education and a high IQ are not indicators of decency and common sense.
Amazing woman is Mel
Not *Prophet, **Oracle.
Israel will prevail, survive and prosper. Israel ISreal!
Amazing insight
Amazing guest. She understands basic Islam, which can be beautiful, but is in need of reform. No Jew or Christian can do that for them, so we are left with prayer for them, and hard work as a community for us.
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” Netanyahu told his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy"
Haaretz, October 2023.
@@jjohn408 Hi Goebbels
@@jjohn408Get a job.
@@jjohn408Much like the US armed Stalin to fight against Hitler, and then after the war communism became a global threat.
Israelis just have this sense that nothing was given to them for free. They worked hard to achieve and build everything in israel. If a new road or building is built they take pride in it. They understand that only by coming together they can thrive🇮🇱🫶
For me, Melanie is still one of us on the left. Melanie had the correct values as a young woman on the Guardian. She still has these all important values.
Bravo to this lady!
Why would someone be pro-israel during a genocide
Thank you
In Britain (and France where I am) people are downbeat because they know the government, media, and almosts entire elite, have nothing but disdain for the people and their country.
As an older woman, I'm always looking for other older women whose looks and style that I can admire. I love her earrings, haircut and face.
This lady is very right wing, she has been against Gay Rights for a long time, too.
I agree with her regarding Islam though.
If she s against gay marriage, that means she values God s word.
@@ancadan9935 We don't have sharia law in the UK, whether it be Jewish, Christian or Muslim. No one is forcing any religion to marry gay people. We have a secular government.
@@bunjijumper5345 who said anything about Sharia law in the UK? Sure you don t have Sharia in the UK! If that was the case, gays would be taught to fall from the highest buildings. I m not even joking.
And who said anything about gays being FORCED to marry each other?? I was talking about gays being allowed (by the church) to marry each other.
Gay rights. What rights? What a joke. An excuse for unbridled sexual perversion.
She is still naive. It's not an interpretation it is simply a matter of when they choose to act violently according to the beliefs. The text is the text and cannot be personally interpreted.
missiles tend to focus the mind
Londonistan 2006 book
Israel is there, because God wants it there.
Amen
Melanie Phillips, the only thing that is correct is that insanity is your best friend!
She’s got a mind like a steel trap, logical and precise. You should listen and learn.
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
Well I’m sorry that British intelligence didn’t see it coming but you did.
I think someone needs to listen to what you’re saying and not British intelligence.
It’s funny I don’t feel safe too.
I like to ask Melanie Phillips, all moral and religious sentiments aside, the continued massacres of the innocents in Gaza are justified?
She speaks of a new Israeli fascism. She should be ashamed
Isntt it a little bit funny when those who warn about the danger of extremists are labeled insane and at the same time we, in the West, give those extremists the insanity label to explain away their t acts
Beautiful, woman of courage
Well said Melanie and thank you Ladies.
❤❤❤❤❤
She speaks for all in Christ, God bless her .
Jesus said this in John 16:2 (NASB20) “They will ban you from the synagogue, yet an hour is coming for everyone who kills you to think that he is offering a service to God.”
I’m a born again Christian, and I believe many Jewish people will recognize Jesus someday as their Messiah. We see the clear threat from those hostile to the Jewish people and continue to pray for the peace of Jerusalem.
🙏🏻❤️🇮🇱
According to most Jews in Israel, they believe that the west need to do more for Israel. The US Congress should pay more compensation to Israel for the holocaust.
Divide and Rule. PM Sharon plan was to divide the Palestinians into 3 groups. GAZA, East Jerusalem and Area A of the West Bank. Gaza was to become an autonomous Singapore and eventual independence. East Jerusalam population annexed to Israel. Area A to become walled Palestinians cities. Palestinians in area B and C moved to Area A and annexed. Hamas in Gaza changed all that. It decided to fight. Is that noble or dumb?
Imagine being pro genocide because some lefty was mean to you once. lol
Imagine being the delusional clown who has a personal subjective delusional belief that there's a genocide going on right now when there objectively is not, and then commenting attacks with intent to hold others accountable for a genocide that doesn't exist outside of your own personal belief. And *is* the problem being referred to in this video clip.
On TH-cam (CHRISTIANITY & ISLAM DEBATES) very informative for European…….
Thank God we have a King. Isaiah 9:6. If it wasn't for Melanie Phillips I would have never found God. Thank you, Melanie, and God Bless. The truth should never be hidden. Justus Sustermans 1636. John 16:13, John 6:63. Revelation 13:18. Long Live Christ the King. 32.6996° N, 35.3035° E
Loved this lady all the way back to "Thw World Upside Down". Whatever she speaks MUST be heeded to as she has never gotten it wrong for the simple fact that she faces the truth head on from a spiritual, moral point of view. I am one of her biggest fans from the U.S..
Melanie's final appeal lands like a half-soliloquy. Those taxi drivers and indeed almost the whole population have, it seems, fallen completely asleep to an absolute cornucopia of pre-requisites for having and being able to defend a fulfilling existence. I don't actually blame the encroaching mass of other-minded people at that point. I blame those who have fallen asleep. They have failed themselves and their children by untold leaps and bounds.
Phillips has enough awareness of the cognitive dissonance involved in saying everyone in Israel is aware of the situation Israel is in to interrupt herself and walk it back for a second, but only for a second, and then she proceeded as if she hadn't said it. The Israeli Fifth Ciolumn isn't as dominant as it once was, but it is still the most powerful threat to continued Israeli existence. Most recently HAMAS killed six hostages and the usual suspects were on the streets in large numbers to blame Netanyahu for not giving HAMAS what it wants. Ignoring the need to shame and disempower the numerous useful idiots who infest Jewry is not sustainable.
Brilliant lady, I love listening to Melanie.
There are only 2 sides God and Israel and the rest of the world put it this way i rather but judgment from the people and stand with God and stand with the world and be judgment from him this world can kiss my butt
MP has been moving from the extreme left to the extreme tight of politics for decades. She has found a home in Israel, where the Government including religious fanatics and self-avowed fascists suits her new mindset.
This lady is the proof that enlightenment was a bad phenomena that produced rationalists like her
Tragic truth.
The irony which seems to escape Melanie is that she lives in Israel because she herself gave up on Britain.
We are in the last days.
Without honour in his not her own country is the saying.
Melanie Phillips is brilliant.
..and they were right. 🤦♂️
I am pro Israel and anti Hamas and the “Palestinian” cause. I am also on the Left in my politics. I am not othering you. I am baffled at the success of the Hamas propaganda campaign. Please. Left leaning progressive politics are what have made most of the advancements we are all privileged to.
True. But it went rotten in the last few years.
God's chosen people my ass.
Intelligents Service, that’s a misnomer.
yes its too late for the uk
Thank you
What's behind this is the Brits' resentment of the sometimes-violent, sometimes-peaceful campaign by the Yishuv against the British empire in the 1940s and the drive to kick out the Brits and establish a Jewish state. While this is way in the past, it became part of the British collective unconscious and is there just below the surface.
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” Netanyahu told his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy"
Haaretz, October 2023.
A state they had been promised by britain almost 30 years earlier that included present day jordan
@@jjohn408 Hi Goebbels
Haaretz is not a newspaper.
Fake propaganda.
She is off her head.. always was .. 🤦♂️
I suspect Emily Shrader herself is much closer to the Guardian's position and would too consider Melanie "the crazy bibist likudnik", if not now, then certainly before the 7/10.
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” Netanyahu told his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy"
Haaretz, October 2023.
@@jjohn408 Hi Goebbels
@jjohn408 and he was right. The army had to contain hamas and guard the wall, and FAILED criminally. The Army did.
Why be bothered with others opinions? It is just that, opinions.
“Anyone who wants to thwart the establishment of a Palestinian state has to support bolstering Hamas and transferring money to Hamas,” Netanyahu told his Likud party’s Knesset members in March 2019. “This is part of our strategy"
Haaretz, October 2023..
@@jjohn408 Hi Goebbels
Macbeth’s three witches!!! ‘Something wicked this way comes’ 😂😂😂
I hope you guys know it is too late. There is nothing you can do. Your control doesn't have the political will, and even if it did, it won't last. But you had a good run.
Yet another deluded soul