ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 มิ.ย. 2024
- Bruce Robbins, a Jewish professor at Columbia University, has commented on claims that anti-Semitism has taken over leading universities.
He says slogans such as "intifada" aren't anti-Semitic because they represent the rights of the Palestinians.
Subscribe: trt.world/subscribe
Livestream: trt.world/ytlive
Facebook: trt.world/facebook
X (Twitter): trt.world/twitter
Instagram: trt.world/instagram
Threads: threads.net/@trtworld
TikTok: / trtworld
WhatsApp: trtworld.com/whatsapp
Telegram: t.me/trtworld
Visit our website: trt.world
Right on, sir. It is not anti-Semitic to express those views. People are simply conditioned to believe otherwise.
Семиты -это🇵🇸 палестинцы, все арабы, мальтийцы, ассирийцы, а вот сионисты не имеют никакого отношения к семитам !
Семиты -это палестинцы 🇵🇸,все арабы, ассирийцы, мальтийцы, а вот сионисты не имеют НИКАКОГО отношения к семитам !
In fact I have heard that an "israeli" figure directly said "anti-semitism" is a trick to silence people speaking up against "israel"'s atrocities.
Thank you for your decency.
Israel is a settler colonial apartheid and no apartheid has a right to exist.
EXACTLY!
@@JohnFelinn Bang on mate
@@yn7798😅😅😅😅😅😅
Indeed free soul, I applaud you ❤
Any source ON how Israel IS an Apartheid colonial state when Israel literally belongs to the native jews and Not Arab colonizers WHO came AS cheap labours
Being truthful is the fundamental mile stone of scholarship. Thank u restoring truth.
Except he did not
This prof is not truthful, though. Ask him what Hamas mean by "from the river to the sea". Maybe ask him which river and sea are meant.
Thank you.
"I don't remember one occupation in which the occupier presented himself as the victim, “we are the victims, we are forced to kill their children, poor us.” -Israeli journalist Gideon Levy
❤
Well said
Normally the occupier / conquorer annihilates or subjugates the population , but after losing 6 wars , Palestinians chose terrorism & that's why they now getting annihilated.
Plus Jews are the original owners of the land . Pallys came in 1850s from Jordan , Syria & Egypt.
...and 16,000 children d€@d too! UNBELIEVABLE! It's a war on children/babies for sure, no doubt about it.
I have heard that an "israeli" figure directly said that the concept of "anti-semitism" as used by "israel" is a trick to silence people speaking up against "israel"'s atrocities.
They want to make it a law that to criticise those things or say those slogans will be included in rhe definition of "anti Semitism". Be careful check those law projects and do something about it.
The original Jews this is how righteously can sacrifice saint hood
God bless you for saying the truth about the situation in Gaza and Palestine
This Man is a Professor ... Educated and Open minded . A True Human being that can see the Truth . Those that cant understand this are the reason why the world is in such turmoil .
Imagine not being appalled as a Jewish person witnessing the scenes of slaughter and destruction in Gaza.Even without considering the horror of the Holocaust.The truth is more alarming with 85% of Israeli Citizens in support of the destruction and death in Gaza..
That's the hardest part. And on top, Israelis seriously believe it's their land. It's shocking how they can speak against holocaust against their own but commit same against another and justify and support it.
the issue is most serious victims of the holocaust and the direct descendants of holocaust victims are no longer the majority of jewish people. most of the jews who actually survived those atrocities did so because they were kapo who worked for the nazi party. if you see descendants who actually care about upholding the history of the holocaust and those atrocities, the few remaining you will typically find on the pro-palestine side.
Imagine being a Gazan, seeing how terrible Gaza is right now and still supporting the government of Hamas.
@@martinmcmartinezface4243 You have little idea about struggle against occupation and persecution..
@@deselby6669 part of my country is occupied by the UK, but we wouldn't support a government that gets US into a war against the UK
Thank you professor❤
Palestine 🇵🇸 has the right to defend itself against all foreign invaders from Europe..
Y not america
*Read Hamas charter.* It clearly says there can be no peace. And it clearly says that Jihad is the only way to cleanse not just Israel but the rest of the world.
What about the jews from Africa?
Not all jews are foem europe
😂 you obviously do not understand the complexity of global networks . This guy is lying ,or he genuinely hasnt got a clue who Palestinians are run by .
Well said Sir, it is blatantly obvious but unfortunately there are people who are brainwashed and blind to see it.
FREE FREE 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
DNA testing is not allowed in Israel mainly because their ancestors are from Europe...
Boycott & divest for the independence of Falastine
Boycott & divest for the independence of Falastine
Even Moses married a non-Israelite woman who converted to Judaism. Read numbers 12. King David’s great grandmother Ruth was a Moabite who converted to Judaism. When the Romans ethnically cleansed the Jews out of the land they renamed it Palestine. Jews intermingled with many populations as they were cast about the earth. Allah has regathered them just as the Israelite prophets declared before.
That is false. There is no law prohibiting DNA testing in Israel. There's 2 laws regulating it however, one states that paternity tests can only be done when a court order is issued (standard law present in many other countries). And one that states that DNA testing for research purposes or for the purposes of establishing ancestry need to be done by recognized and licensed genetic institutes.
@@BobcatSmokey They're also aware that DNA testing companies (like 23 and a me) share your genetic information and material with a network of institutions and can really do what the want with it in the future, which is a scary idea. These are also Jewish/Israeli run companies.
The Anti-Semitic card got torn up a long time ago..
Mind Begs the Question:
▪︎If a Semitic State
▪︎Engage in Apartheid/Genocide
▪︎To speak,act against it
▪︎Is Anti-Semitic or Pro-Humanity?
you are so right
Thank you Sir for the clarification
Thank you for being honest
His body language doesn't seem much honest.
@@safetsinsu can’t stand it, can u?
@@shh57431 no, it is not that, the reason. I want Palestine to be free, too. But look this guy how is all the time avoiding eye contact, as much as possible. That's a sign he is not sincere on what he is saying.
@@safetsins or maybe he’s ashamed? I would be too if they were conflating their ideology with my religion. It is shameful what they are doing in the name of Judaism
@@safetsins why you say that ?
Israel is the occupier and not the victim
The mental change in the respect and recognition of equality for Palestinians will come from Jews like yourself. Keep expressing your message of peace.
PREACH!!!
A real scholar, not like ours who are silent in here Algeria 🇩🇿 we thank you professor🙏 and free Palestine🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
May Allah suffice all Palestinians and muslims and grant the Palestinians victory over these kuffaar and hypocrites
Ameen
Boycott & divest for the independence of Falastine
Don't forget Palestinian Christians and Jews too. They're also being killed by I*rael for being Palestinian.
It’s so refreshing to hear an intelligent, knowledgeable person simply stating the facts.
♥️🖤🖤🖤🖤
♥️♥️🤍🤍🤍
♥️💚💚💚💚
❤🇵🇸
@@WanderingExistence 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@FreeSpeechThought Says the person that doesn't understand basic current events...
@@WanderingExistence we know that. But cool 😎 that you confirm this
@@WanderingExistence cool that you've confirmed your lack of knowledge and information
Its ok killing 40k people??not unconfortable for the genocide?the kind of words coming out from this people are sickenning
Half are armed soldiers, which unfortunately Palestinians are unwilling to admit . Under international law , if you keep hostages you are also a combatant. Hamas and the other Muslims Brotherhood groups arm children, another stat not conveniently reported. Any under 18 years old is a child , Hamas arms boys 14 years and up , just like the Houthies.
Its estimated there's a 1-1 civilian to armed combatant .
Well never know for sure because Hamas are master PR and lies
From the river to the sea Palestinians existence should be granted equal as Jews. Period
That's not what "from the river to the sea" means bud :))
They been offered several times in the last 100 years , and by Isreali left leadership, not a more . They have created a right wing government now who have had enough.
What are you doing to stop this?
Boycott & divest for the independence of Falastine
He is speaking up. The least he can do. What are you doing other than asking people on TH-cam what they did?
Nothing
The one who is going to ask about our capabilities is Allah,everyone will do thier part inshah Allah
Why is a Jewish professor's word more valuable than anyone else's? Of course intifada is not anti-Semitic.
Cus this is Arab propaganda.
all the info In this video is misinformation being spoken out of the mouth of someone they think we would find reputable.
Thank you & respect Professor for being truthfull and fair in your speech.
What not condem the killing of Palestinian civilians your are insane!😢
Boycott & divest for the independence of Falastine
Los reales judíos son representados por este Profesor 😈😈😈
Israel has the right to defend itself.
In a land of olive trees and old rocks,
Where the sun softly meets the ground.
In a tired place where bravery thrives.
A dark land at night.
Children's cries echo throughout Gaza.
Mothers weep for sons taken too soon.
A glimmer of hope appears.
After a war-torn desert.
The Palestinians show great strength and resilience.
They stay resilient during tough times.
The heartfelt song expressed their indomitable spirit.
An optimistic message echoing through the mountains.
In the chaos, they plant peace.
They had passionate eyes and fiery hearts.
Longing to release with every stride.
Overcoming fear to embrace a brighter future.
In the ruins of their shattered dreams,
They tirelessly construct with steady hands.
Their laughter reverberating in the sun.
An optimistic melody, a burning desire.
Expose their suffering to the world.
Be impressed by their resilience and perseverance.
A bright beacon shines in the darkness.
Palestinians, warriors of illumination.
In sorrowful Gaza,
Amid debris and dust,
The Palestinians persisted.
They have eternal hope in their hearts.
At dawn, they assembled quietly in defiance.
A resolute group of individuals.
They had a strong bond in their eyes.
Against occupation.
They used shovels and bricks to work together.
Rebuilding war-torn homes.
Each wall showed how hard they worked.
United in purpose throughout the damaged land.
Mothers show resilient and steadfast love.
Cradling exhausted infants.
They sang lullabies to the sky.
A solemn vow to provide protection and support.
Kids were playing in the rubble.
Their laughter helped to heal past wounds.
A hint of happiness in their innocence.
Hope never dies.
Men farmed.
Cultivating resilience in a challenging environment.
Their sweat and the tears of new life mingling.
Revitalizing the land with nourishment.
In the streets once controlled by fear.
The sound of hammers and nails echoed.
As houses were reconstructed, a shared dream came true.
A tribute to the unwavering resolve of the Palestinians.
Through bustling streets and markets.
Life pulsed with an unmatched rhythm.
A strong party under the night sky.
Each heartbeat is a triumph.
Sun set west.
Creating long and golden shadows.
And in the faces of those who dared to defy.
A strong light gave courage to the soul.
Night descended, and the land became quiet.
The moon whispered to the sleeping trees.
Quietly holding hands.
Bringing together hearts as powerful as the seas.
In free Gaza.
The Palestinians danced to a timeless beat.
They sang together in perfect harmony.
An optimistic and generous group singing together.
They stood beneath the starry sky.
A unified population striving for peace.
Their resilience demonstrates the power of the human spirit.
Endless hope land.
A new day starts with the soft touch of dawn.
The sky glows with promising golden hues.
Resilience flourishes in Palestine.
Unyielding spirit, strong resilience.
The hills tell stories of ancient wars.
From old lands and lasting battles.
In the valleys where hope was searched for.
A promised future.
A river meanders through the olive trees.
The water is essential for the land and its creatures.
Resilient Palestinian people.
Intense passion in their eyes.
The wind carries ancient song echoes.
Hearts joined in a common melody.
Each step forward is a win.
In grief.
Women dressed in vibrant and stylish attire.
Striding boldly across fields.
Their hands embracing a new world.
Where peace and justice are constant.
Kids happily play in green fields.
Their laughter was music to the ears.
Dreams spinning in an unseen world.
Dreams come to life in the soft twilight.
Men with calloused hands and intense gaze.
Work the land diligently.
Their sweat mingling with the maze of the earth.
Each heartbeat has a story to tell.
In cities with previously high walls,
Now give in to time's pressure.
Evidence of a country's need.
A positive signal for the beat of freedom.
Markets are bustling and full of energy.
Vendors proudly offer their products for sale.
Under close monitoring from the nearby land.
A place where many have sacrificed their lives.
Underneath the towering minarets.
Whispers pray for peace.
Faith merging with the sky.
Within a nation's freedom.
As twilight softly descends.
Stars shine.
Vladimir Jabotinski a zionist came up with that slogan, & Likud revised version on the political party manifesto slogan is called "between the sea and the Jordan there will be only Israeli sovereignty
If anything Filastinians are revising the slogan for Justice not genocide like the average zionist.
Zionism is a term used by Christians, Africans and the Islamic version is ......a home land . I think Middle East were on the verge of peace and normalisation with Isreal and Palestinians didnt like it .
THANK YOU FOR STANDING UP!!!
Recognized by the international law? ...Since when? Isnt the international "law" condeming Hamas, the group of Palestininans that rise up against the occupation?
Establish regular Namaz and Pay ZAKAT
Boycott & divest for the independence of Falastine
I am going to leave ten words for the algorithm
Not a single Jewish student felt uncomfortable... not one.
There are Liars and there are those who might be upset their Colonial Seige and Occupation is coming to an end - if that make them feel uncomfortable, so beit.
Well said Professor ❤
Thanks for speaking out the truth. Respect ✊🏻
LONG LIVE PALESTINE 🇵🇸
❤❤❤❤❤ for stating and stating what's the truth
Thanks for your honesty
Those Israelis students don't feel uncomfortable when IDF soldiers make videos bullying Palestinians , actually Netanyahu said from the river to the sea , and Palestinians' "real semites" don't call him anti-semetic . Israelis are not semetic. They are from Europe, Rusia, and USA.
And a majority do not profess a belief in God, they immigrated from Communist countries.
The founding Settlers Colonialists were Bolshevics, followers of Ber Borochov. They were from Poltava Poland, some like Ben Gurion were from Poltava and politicized there, some were exiled to Poltava by the Czar, for sedition.
All jews pray and turn to Jerusalem, a historic history recorded in the old testament and in archaeology.
Muslim pray toward mecca and turn their backs on dome of the rock , because , just like Christians who built churches over Pagan sites , Muslims built it over Jewish temples.
Facts are facts and Infitada , is used by Islamist to signify a war . In this case a fight for Jerusalem.
Thank you for explaining this.
One people’s feelings are far less important than another people’s lives.
Thanks to you for your humanitarian utterimg Sir.
Thanks for explaining that and providing simple translations. Zionists have used the "river to sea" slogan, suggesting a total removal of non-Israeli Palestinians.
A field goal is normally 17 yards (7 yards in Canadian football) longer than the distance of the line of scrimmage to the goal line, as it includes the end zone (10 yards) and 7 yards in which the holder stands behind.
Thank you for this ❤️🇯🇴🇯🇴
Thank you for your reasonable comments. From Bangladesh.
Thank you very much, your voice is appreciated ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
A paid shill
Thank you Prof. Bruce Robbins .
Tq for telling the truth.
May God bless you, honored you and your family peace and happiness
Sir I salute you for your honesty and courage 🫡👏
The world needs more people like you ❤️
Appreciate you enlightening to those who may not understand..
If the slogans are more discomforting to them than the atrocities of their government, then so be it. They need to re-align their fairness.
Great to listen to people who are honest and speak out without fear because they are only telling the truth after all.
KEEP BOYCOTTING the Western Brands the countries the people the politicians the institutions that support the Gen0Cid3,
KEEP SHARING the Media, Never Stop Boycotting !!
Never Stop Sharing !!
It REALLY DOES make a Difference!!
Thank you for being on the right side of history and educating people on these words
7th oct is the consequence of inhumane and unacceptable things happened to Palestinians by occupier🇮🇱
And how much is your university paying you to turn on your own people hahahaha
Thank uou for speaking calmly and clearly. Some experiences may be hard but not harmful.
If someone uses that term outside of what it means, know that they are panicking because they know they lost the debate.
When injustice becomes law, Resistance becomes duty. 🇵🇸
Came from the most educated professor and a Jew. Why can't the sheeples see that?
Great respect for you sir. Speaking up a word of truth, speaking up against injustice even when it’s not you who is being directly harmed is truly beautiful.
God Bless you❤❤❤
Intifada as a word is not antisemitic, but the second 'intifada' in which the method of rising up was blowing up civilians in busses is what makes people uncomfortable with saying that that should happen a third time. It is violence against civilians sir.
Who cares if they feel uncomfortable? Imagine how uncomfortable have the Palestinians felt for the last 75 years.
Stop the apartheid and the occupation.
Offended by everything, ashamed of nothing.
He forgot to mention that it's about violent uprising, not just uprising. We all know that a lot of civilians were killed in both intifadas
Disgusting
This is the completely wrong take. It is extremely anti semitic to say from the ‘river to the sea’. This man is fundamentally wrong
The uprising of population under occupation, be it by inside or outside force, is a democratic principle. The right to self determination is not reserved for a select nationality
Thank u
From south Africa
Lol
Kettle pot?
So true that it won't get any reach as good things are always neglected in the present world😢
If Palestinians are semites and most Israelis are from Europe not semites ,who are the semites that zionist always talking about ?
I wish this clip had included the “From the River to the sea” explanation which he also referenced.
It’s obviously the one phrase that is controversial and both opposing sides have a different interpretation.
Outlawing Arabic words like "intifada" is categorcally "AntiSemitism".
Mexico is a good example of intifada, we shook off being Spanish colony, declared independence from their rule. Then decades later when the French tried to appropriate Mexico, we wouldn't let them, shook them off too. Then US was high off manifest destiny and did a major land grab of Texas and California. We lost that intifada, I suppose. Now Mexicans are demonized for migrating to what was been historically Mexico, a contiguous land mass where our cousins have been this whole time. In some ways Mexico has more legitimacy to recover what's historically theirs, than Israel sighting 2000 year absence as the rain Palestine belongs to them.
Thank you for honest..you are so right❤❤❤❤
How can you be a refugee for 75 years & not choose repatriation & immigration .
How can you claim indigenous when the land has been conquored & swapped ownership 14 times in 2000 years .
Too much blood in the sand , Arabs move along & forget about river & the sea ,
Mind Begs the Question:
▪︎If Jews protest Apartheid
▪︎Jews beaten by Police/Govt
▪︎Protecting - Jews or Apartheid?
Thanks Sir.. for ur honest speech! ❤
There are still decent people on Earth,
Many thanks to him
That is right and I would say those students, if killing and destroying Palestinians do not make you uncomfortable, if the cruel occupation of Isreal do not make you uncomfortable, then the resistance of those oppressors wouldn’t make you uncomfortable. Simple
may God bless you for your honesty
Finally. Someone at the school who understands the word intifadah.
Even someone like him spewing the facts.. IDK why those people remains asleep? ( actually i do, overwhelming being brainwashed, it is hard to squeeze that off)
Lots of love to your courage to tell the truth❤
TOTALLY AGREE 👍 THANK YOU GENTLEMEN
As a professor this man should be more careful with his language - his words “ some Jewish students have been made to feel uncomfortable …” Who “made” them feel uncomfortable, No One! If these students don’t know what intifada actually means they should look it up and study the real history of israel/Palestine for at least 100+ years!! If they’re still uncomfortable, then they have a clear lack of humanity which is not the problem of the Pro-Palestinians who have humanity which is precious.
❤🕊️
I wonder why from the river to the sea bothers jews oh wait becuse the og prhase is "from river to sea palstine will be arab"
When was the word semitic taken to mean only Jewish origin? The Israeli's are being "anti-semitic" in the true meaning of the word semitic.
That right to rise up is also a human right and this is why they are offended. They hate and dehumanize so they can excuse their abhorrent behavior and beliefs.
They are made to feel uncomfortable? Sir this is nothing compared to losing your life, your family, your house and living the rest of your life as a physically and mentally disabled person which by the way are all Palestinians going through right now.
Anyone who has a heart and is capable of rational thinking will come to the same conclusion
He’s drunk the Kool-Aid. Papa Yahya thanks you for your service as a human shield.
Who is the arbitrator of international law?
NO NO ZAYONISM