The Golan is as "Occupied" as East Prussia, which Germany lost to Lithuania, Poland, and Russia after losing the ultimate war of aggression, WW2. Syria lost the Golan after joining Egypt and Jordan after losing the Six Day War, started by the 3 Arab countries with Egypt's closing of the Straits of Tiran.
yeah not like Israel was forcefully created by violence and antisemite colonialist powers or anything, it has always been right there, sure thing, just out of the blue it was attacked one day
@@Joseph_thefather Nasser started the war while aligned with the Soviets in the aspiration to become the leader of a pan-Arab empire. He lost, Egypt lost, and so sued for Peace.
@JackHua-m9u It is not palestinian territory and historicly it never was! Israel kept the Golan Heights after syria lost the area by losing their war on Israel. The winner keeps all!
If you lost in war, your land/territory is lost. 1967, 6 days war, Israel won and got the Golan Heights. Annexed it in 1981. And in 2019, US recognized Golan Heights annexation and be part of Israel. So don't start the war in the first place.
I've heard that Israel has never left a region they have once occupied. Is that true? And does anyone have an explanation for that? If so, what's the difference to an imperialistic state?
They defeated the aggressors and captured aggressor's territory. "finders" -- keepers -- that was the rule #1 through the entire history of human race.
@@monmouthnj It doesn't work that way any longer. There's this thing called the UN Charter which explicitly forbids landgrabs. Educate yourself before you speak out.
The Golan Heights is a security measure. If Syria demonstrates it can ensure Israel's safety, the territory can be returned, similar to the agreement with Egypt.
Could be said for people all over the world. I’m not defending this behavior but Israel is generally detested for their occupation and apartheid and Palestinians are seen as sympathetic victims.
@@NewDealDem2187complete hasbara lies is his source. Israel sandbagged their response purposely in order to Holocaust the indigenous of this land. Isn’tReal has abdicated its case to continue existence.
Living in the Golan Heights is not 'normal' for anyone. That land was given to Israel by God long ago. Nevertheless idol worshipers have ignored that fact ever since Joshua led Israel into the into the land given to them by God.
The Agreement on Disengagement between Israel and Syria was signed on May 31, 1974. This agreement followed the Yom Kippur War and aimed to create a buffer zone monitored by a UN peacekeeping force to separate the opposing forces. The Assad Regime began in 1971. They no longer exist, neither does this agreement.
The Agreement on Disengagement between Israel and Syria was signed on May 31, 1974. This agreement followed the Yom Kippur War and aimed to create a buffer zone monitored by a UN peacekeeping force to separate the opposing forces. The Assad Regime began in 1971. They no longer exist, neither does this agreement.
@@peabase ? Assad was "the state", that was the fundamental problem. Let's see if the new Syrian state will make a new agreement. The prior agreement allowed UN oversight. Will the new Syrian state allow UN on the ground.
@@nuqwestr No-one is denying that Assad was an absolute ruler, but with or without him, there's still a sovereign state called Syria. No new agreements are needed, since the existing ones are still binding unless they're explicitly revoked. Don't make stuff up.
@O5d43y77 Israel claims ALL Palestinians are guilty "There are no innocent in Gaza" etc. This is not new of Israelis. Hamas copies the Israeli method of holding everyone equally responsible.
Yeah it's always about the "fresh memories" of Oct 7 for Israelis and not the decades of memories for Palestinians being subjugated by the occupying forces of a racist, imperialist ethnostate.
@@in-my-view For your comment to hold any credibility, you'd need to 1) prove that all Palestinians are Hamas, 2) justify Israel's illegal occupation of Palestinian land and their illegal detainment, without charge, of thousands of Palestinians. While you're at it, why don't you explain how Israel is justified murdering journalists, destroying schools and hospitals, and sniping children in the head while they're walking down the streets trying to find their demolished homes? I'll wait. Then again, you probably think this whole conflict began Oct 7, in which case telling you to look up the Balfour Declaration and its history would be pointless.
If DW know what is happening in gaza , they should know where is hostages too
If know how talk, maybe how to not like caveman speak?
Not even the celebrated Mossad, which knows where enemy commanders are, knows this. 😂
lul wut 😂
Yes, the entire population are hostages.
israel has right to occupy according to the six front war in 1983.🎉
Hypocrisy, they kill journalists but yet they are afraid to write in the title
Well they could be doubling up as Hamas affiliates too so maybe its better to not reveal details
How is this permitted by the international community. Intimidating people into abandoning their homes is unconscionable.
the golan should never be surrendered to any islamists.
Golan Heights became Israel when Syria started and lost the war against Israel. That's the nature of war. You started the war, you lost what you lost.
But the war isn't over. There's only a cease fire agreement. The best thing Israel can do is to sign a peace agreement with Syria.
Like Israel 3000 years ago. Long lost.
@@thejohannreinshow2497 why is Iraq not part of Kuwait. They started a war and lost too.
??????
The WAR started when Europeans invaded the area.
The Golan is as "Occupied" as East Prussia, which Germany lost to Lithuania, Poland, and Russia after losing the ultimate war of aggression, WW2. Syria lost the Golan after joining Egypt and Jordan after losing the Six Day War, started by the 3 Arab countries with Egypt's closing of the Straits of Tiran.
And why do you think the war started in the first place?
Israel attacked first and Six day war was planned years ahead. You are fine with it because it's not you who is kicked out from home.
Israel attacked first and Six day war was planned years ahead. You are fine with it because it's not you who is kicked out from home.
yeah not like Israel was forcefully created by violence and antisemite colonialist powers or anything, it has always been right there, sure thing, just out of the blue it was attacked one day
@@Joseph_thefather Nasser started the war while aligned with the Soviets in the aspiration to become the leader of a pan-Arab empire. He lost, Egypt lost, and so sued for Peace.
Simple question. Why are the hostages not being released?
Simple question. Why is Israel occupying and annexing Palestinian territory like what Russia is doing in Crimea and Donbas?
I question is why were they taken?
They are dead or was killed in a airstrike
@JackHua-m9uThere is no land called PALESTINE
@JackHua-m9u It is not palestinian territory and historicly it never was!
Israel kept the Golan Heights after syria lost the area by losing their war on Israel. The winner keeps all!
Airstrikes dont kill, Israel does. Get your headlines right!
🤣
😂🤣😆
Humus does
given back the hostages yet?
Israel defends against terror.
Anyone remember the hostages?
Netanyahu certainly doesn't
@@adz951thank you for your reply.
Hm's is nearly dust courtesy of Mr Netanyahu.
@O5d43y77 netanyahu internationally renowned WAR CR1MINAL.
Where are the hostages?
If you lost in war, your land/territory is lost. 1967, 6 days war, Israel won and got the Golan Heights. Annexed it in 1981. And in 2019, US recognized Golan Heights annexation and be part of Israel.
So don't start the war in the first place.
Sudan how many died
DW? Can you remember them?
I've heard that Israel has never left a region they have once occupied. Is that true? And does anyone have an explanation for that?
If so, what's the difference to an imperialistic state?
Gaza 2005??
Israel should ensure that Syria will never mess with it again.
That’s kind of sad at this point, always the victim
Russia also needs to ensure that Ukraine will never mess with it again.
What gives Israel the right to occupy the Golan heights?
Self defence.
They defeated the aggressors and captured aggressor's territory. "finders" -- keepers -- that was the rule #1 through the entire history of human race.
@@monmouthnj It doesn't work that way any longer. There's this thing called the UN Charter which explicitly forbids landgrabs. Educate yourself before you speak out.
Criminals breaks laws all the time
@@peabase And that UN charter is doing so good. Then why don't they send in the UN Criminal Court to enforce their forbiden land grabs.
The Golan Heights is a security measure. If Syria demonstrates it can ensure Israel's safety, the territory can be returned, similar to the agreement with Egypt.
It's really silly for journalists to be in an active war zone and then cry when they are hit.
Wow. So anyone in a war zone is a legitimate target Including journalists, doctors, aid workers and innocent children as well?
What cruel people.
They're basically hiring human shields
Dw sounds like a palestinian media house.
Truth hurts
Why? What do you perceive as bias or false narrative? Is anything mentioned here factually false in your opinion?
how so???
Lol you gotta be kidding me. It's ridiculously pro-Israeli
Because they are.
They were celebrating on the 7th of October
Could be said for people all over the world. I’m not defending this behavior but Israel is generally detested for their occupation and apartheid and Palestinians are seen as sympathetic victims.
Source?
@@NewDealDem2187complete hasbara lies is his source. Israel sandbagged their response purposely in order to Holocaust the indigenous of this land. Isn’tReal has abdicated its case to continue existence.
@@Tomer-oy1hj that’s not unique
Living in the Golan Heights is not 'normal' for anyone. That land was given to Israel by God long ago. Nevertheless idol worshipers have ignored that fact ever since Joshua led Israel into the into the land given to them by God.
Oh my
Were these 10 Hamas?
Dudes having a casual glass of wine while giving an interview for the news lol
"Demilitarized" yah, right...
The Agreement on Disengagement between Israel and Syria was signed on May 31, 1974. This agreement followed the Yom Kippur War and aimed to create a buffer zone monitored by a UN peacekeeping force to separate the opposing forces. The Assad Regime began in 1971. They no longer exist, neither does this agreement.
Balfore declaration include Golan hight land of Israel
Reporter in Jerusalem sounds doubtful???
The saying “the more the merrier “ comes to mind when considering this video.
The Agreement on Disengagement between Israel and Syria was signed on May 31, 1974. This agreement followed the Yom Kippur War and aimed to create a buffer zone monitored by a UN peacekeeping force to separate the opposing forces. The Assad Regime began in 1971. They no longer exist, neither does this agreement.
Let's see if Syria's new government will revoke said agreement. Such agreements bind states, not just their leaders.
@@peabase ? Assad was "the state", that was the fundamental problem. Let's see if the new Syrian state will make a new agreement. The prior agreement allowed UN oversight. Will the new Syrian state allow UN on the ground.
So everytime the party in power in Israel changes, all deals break down. Interesting to know.
@@nuqwestr No-one is denying that Assad was an absolute ruler, but with or without him, there's still a sovereign state called Syria. No new agreements are needed, since the existing ones are still binding unless they're explicitly revoked. Don't make stuff up.
@@peabase null and void. TBA
Do you trust Hamas State tv station of all about their report
Przypomnijcie,jak w exodus biblia, Mojżesz prowadził swoich rodaków, zobaczymy,co będzie dalej.
The cause and foundation of the problem is italy and France Paris,Rome,Napolitano,Napoli,America, Rome,Taranto,Torino,Sardegna?,,
What kind of s-adistic creatures commit this atrocities on civilians ?
Hmmm's
Hamas also only targetted the support structures of the IDF.
Why did Western nations get upset?
From the Nova music festival. Are you serious?
@O5d43y77 Israel claims ALL Palestinians are guilty "There are no innocent in Gaza" etc.
This is not new of Israelis.
Hamas copies the Israeli method of holding everyone equally responsible.
Yes Journalists!.......sure ...........of course.
What the heck are UN forces in the DMZ actually for if not this? Getting a tan?
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Odvajanje od gaza neke.. Lebanon nije gaza privatno
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
“Press” 😂
B D S
😂😂
❤
Yeah it's always about the "fresh memories" of Oct 7 for Israelis and not the decades of memories for Palestinians being subjugated by the occupying forces of a racist, imperialist ethnostate.
It seems that you are supporting Hamas.
@@in-my-view For your comment to hold any credibility, you'd need to 1) prove that all Palestinians are Hamas, 2) justify Israel's illegal occupation of Palestinian land and their illegal detainment, without charge, of thousands of Palestinians. While you're at it, why don't you explain how Israel is justified murdering journalists, destroying schools and hospitals, and sniping children in the head while they're walking down the streets trying to find their demolished homes? I'll wait. Then again, you probably think this whole conflict began Oct 7, in which case telling you to look up the Balfour Declaration and its history would be pointless.
😎😎😎
"Airstrikes kill 10 in Gaza" where did this airstrike come from? Maybe an alien from space?
Colonialism 2.0 🤣🤣
If DW know what is happening in gaza , they should know where is hostages too