Those who have stanned TVXQ when they were still 5 members, were the lucky ones. They have seen the ups and downs of Kpop before. Forever a Cassiopeia in my heart. There will be no TVXQ 2.0. No one can replace them in my heart. Memories of them just flashback in an instant..
Its been a toughful journey though.. i first started loving them when i was 8 yrs old.. and now.. im 22.. looking at how mean korean industry is making me hate kpop so much (see what happened to jyj.. yoochun 😢).. but i cant leave this 5 men here.. no matter how painful it is.. i cant stop loving them.. still stanning them though.. they r so talented.. for the past 16yrs.. i was hoping to see them reunite.. but for now.. i just want them to have a happy life.. meet someone nicer.. build a happy family.. i want them to be happy..
trueeee but you must check the boyz...i think they a group can be like tvxq because they have powerful vocalist and harmonies.this link they sing ost of reply 1986 th-cam.com/video/v1su8GvyxGI/w-d-xo.html this link th-cam.com/video/iNNcfk0QQPI/w-d-xo.html half by one of their member sing ost..this song really sad and his voices touch my hearttt..huhu..btw tvxq is my first group im into kpop and love in the ice is my fav song
Check out this cover by KNK m.th-cam.com/video/kItF6jiw8do/w-d-xo.html At that time the group was only 1 year old (they debuted in 2016) so they were still rookies but I think they did pretty because they have strong vocalists Sorry for my bad english ^^;;
Same thing happens to me probably because i heard the Japanese version first and had it on repeat for so long that i am more used to sing it than the Korean version ^^~
이도 아...방탄소년단을 폄하하는것은 절대 아니지만 동방신기 정도로 밸런스가 맞진 않아요. 시아준수 수준으로 성량이 좋은 메보는 아예 드물기도 하고.. 오히려 비투비라는 그룹이 노래실력은 평균적으로 훨씬 더 좋은 편이죠. 방탄소년단은 트렌드에 맞는 ‘음색’을 가지고 있고 가창력부분은 중상정도인 그룹이구요.(뷔,정국,지민)방탄소년단이 떨어진다는건 아니에요. 밸런스 좋은 그룹임은 틀림없지만 그 정도가 동방신기5명일때 비교를 하기에는 조금 모자란 감이 있다는 부분입니다:)!
Songs from 2nd gen group bring me lots of my childhood memory. It's great to listen this masterpiece from time to time. I miss them so much, and I hope they live the life they want now.
이노랜 라이브가 너무 좋아서 오히려 이렇게 씨디로 듣는게 뭔가 빈듯한 느낌이 든다 물론 이렇게 듣는것도 다른타돌곡들에 비한다면 넘사벽으로 좋다만 그래도 뭔가 아쉬워... 근데 이 5인 조합을 다신 못듣는다는게 아직은 올려진 영상으로밖에 들을방법이 없다는게 너무 아쉽다 만약이라도 다시 뭉칠날이 온다면 그땐 눈물광광쏟으며 보고들을듯... 진짜 벅차다는 기분을 과거 영상보는걸로도 느끼는데.. 하ㅠㅠㅠ
D beauty of dese 5 guys will NVR leave d earth coz it's eternal...der songs are!!! Nd for many years to come I can say dis song nd dbsk5 will b remembered ....even if by minority......I'm proud cassiopeia to love my dbsk5!!!
It’s been a while ... feel so good to be here again !!!!!!!!!!! I’m not gonna lie but SoonSeok brings me here and thank to them , they bring me back here , bring me back to the good old day
*cries intensely*.....this isnt fair i joined them so late why do i still hurt the fact ot5 isnt together ah its srsly making me cry 4:10 ....oh gosh....my heart is crying and so is every celll in my body
Los escuché por primera vez en 2008, han pasado 16 años y aún no logro dejar de llorar con esta canción 😢 después de su separación al menos los pude ver como JYJ en Chile, pero jamás será lo mismo que en esos años.
9year ago my bff told me to play this on her wedding day😍 this is it I'm listening to this for her wedding this coming sunday😍😍😍awwwwwww❤❤❤❤ twinnieeee you dont know how much i love you my soulmate 💗 I'm really happy for you too see you as a strong independent woman and now finally it's your best day 💖💓💗 best wishes my dear twinnie and to your hubby❤
I have a small history with this song, in short, every time i listened into this song, i feel safe because of them. Emoshinki strikes again after years :")
![Big Bang - Haru Haru (하루 하루) [Hangul/Romanization/English] Color & Picture Coded HD](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/WtAuSC3lk14/mqdefault.jpg)
![กี่หมื่นฟ้า | Your Sky Series EP.1 [2/4]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qJbQs_nhjD4/mqdefault.jpg)
![U-Kiss - 0330 [Hangul/Romanization/English] Color & Picture Coded HD](/img/n.gif)
비교적 세련된 스타일링로 찍은 다섯 명 모습 다 모은 거 보니깐 조합이 ㄹㅇ 지리긴 하다
Those who have stanned TVXQ when they were still 5 members, were the lucky ones. They have seen the ups and downs of Kpop before. Forever a Cassiopeia in my heart. There will be no TVXQ 2.0. No one can replace them in my heart. Memories of them just flashback in an instant..
Its been a toughful journey though.. i first started loving them when i was 8 yrs old.. and now.. im 22.. looking at how mean korean industry is making me hate kpop so much (see what happened to jyj.. yoochun 😢).. but i cant leave this 5 men here.. no matter how painful it is.. i cant stop loving them.. still stanning them though.. they r so talented.. for the past 16yrs.. i was hoping to see them reunite.. but for now.. i just want them to have a happy life.. meet someone nicer.. build a happy family.. i want them to be happy..
@yunho's passion fruit drug scandal also he was framed before
When JYJ left TVXQ that was my 1st brokenheart.. then i stan 2ne1. And you know all the rest 😭😭😭😭
@@jatifallat3651 yeah..... everyone feel that..... who stan tvxq ..... but they're truly legend in kpop they're only best kpop group i think.....
@@kimhaneul637 yoochun is a criminal why would anyone pity him????
2024년 방문하신분 !?
여기는 2024. 3월 😢
여기는 2024.4월
여기는 2024.05
5월입니다 😂😂
여기는 2024년 8월!
Nowadays new generation kpop cnt sing the feel like this..so touch and sad when listen :(
trueeee but you must check the boyz...i think they a group can be like tvxq because they have powerful vocalist and harmonies.this link they sing ost of reply 1986 th-cam.com/video/v1su8GvyxGI/w-d-xo.html this link th-cam.com/video/iNNcfk0QQPI/w-d-xo.html half by one of their member sing ost..this song really sad and his voices touch my hearttt..huhu..btw tvxq is my first group im into kpop and love in the ice is my fav song
Winwin's mum and sehun wife Cant sing ??? where ya ears ?
One of ballad inheritance is Btob-Blue.. You should try to listen them 😊💙..
Check out this cover by KNK
m.th-cam.com/video/kItF6jiw8do/w-d-xo.html
At that time the group was only 1 year old (they debuted in 2016) so they were still rookies but I think they did pretty because they have strong vocalists
Sorry for my bad english ^^;;
u should check out astro
Am I the only one that struggles to sing the Korean ver since I'm so used to and in love with the Japanese ver
Same thing happens to me probably because i heard the Japanese version first and had it on repeat for so long that i am more used to sing it than the Korean version ^^~
same . . I'm use to hear Japanese version . .
The opposite happens for me! I struggle singing along with Japanese version, the Korean version has always been my favourite
Nadine Hernandez YESSSSSSS
It happened a lot with TVXQ for me since I heard a lot of their japanese versions before the korean versions
얼굴,키,노래,댄스,퍼포먼스,인기 이모든것을 완벽하게 갖춘 그룹이 나오기는 정말 힘들것이다.
이도 아...방탄소년단을 폄하하는것은 절대 아니지만 동방신기 정도로 밸런스가 맞진 않아요. 시아준수 수준으로 성량이 좋은 메보는 아예 드물기도 하고..
오히려 비투비라는 그룹이 노래실력은 평균적으로 훨씬 더 좋은 편이죠. 방탄소년단은 트렌드에 맞는 ‘음색’을 가지고 있고 가창력부분은 중상정도인 그룹이구요.(뷔,정국,지민)방탄소년단이 떨어진다는건 아니에요. 밸런스 좋은 그룹임은 틀림없지만 그 정도가 동방신기5명일때 비교를 하기에는 조금 모자란 감이 있다는 부분입니다:)!
mk han 인정인정 아미인데 탄이들은 퍼포먼스에 더 능력치를 찍었음 동방은 ㄹㅇ 이런 밸런스가 또 있을까 싶을정도로 약점이 하나도 없어.... 아 몇몇 인성이 약점은 있지만...ㅠ
@I do 방탄을 비비려고 하는애들보면 ㄹㅇ ㅂㅅ같애
@I do 방탄은 동방신기에 비해서는 퍼포먼스 그룹이죠..
@I do 방탄이 아예 노래를 못한다는게 아니라 동방신기에 비해서는 퍼포먼스가 더 많다는 말인데요
Before other idols come, there was TVXQ,SUJU,SHINEE,SNSD. I stan this 4 😭❤❤
just say u are SM STAN...u dumbass
Don't forget T-ara Cuz they were one of the best until the stupid bully controversy
Golden era
changmin write this beautiful lyrics 😢😢😢
I miss DBSK so much. Ot5 forever❤️. I think they are still the best vocal group that I've heard in kpop until now. They are LEGENDS👑
i came hear after nct 127 cover ..the song was so nice to hear!!!💓💓
5명 전부 메인보컬임...ㄷㄷ
I wish I stanned them when they were 5 T-T
Those were great times... I can assure you of that.
U can stand dem now too though
I did. But it was heartbreaking. So, feel lucky you didn't go through that
my 1st ever kpop group to Stan, and I felt so blessed.
Stan T-ara too
2019 and still in love with Junsu's voice damn
Our changmin wrote these beautiful lyrics
So proud of him
2019 and the heck this is still one of my best playlist i won't lie
JEON BUNNY same. Forever gold
Same here. Missing them with 5 members T.T
Came back in 2017 to rewatch this song. They're the true legend. :') I miss Five in the black.
DB5K
no one can replace them in cassie's heart
TVXQ the best vocais
i will not cry. i will not cr.........yyyyy 😭😭😭😭😭
Songs from 2nd gen group bring me lots of my childhood memory. It's great to listen this masterpiece from time to time. I miss them so much, and I hope they live the life they want now.
2020년... 손들어요...
저욧 ㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ남자지만 시아준수팬..
저요..... 큼
hot처럼 동쪽에서 방구끼는 신기한 기술 다시뭉쳣으면 합니다. 잘못한건 잘못한거고..주변에서 점점 틀딱이라고 하니 그냥보고 싶네요..
ㅋㅋ̤̫ㅋ̤̮ㅋ̤̻ ㅋ̤̫ㅋ̤̮ㅋ̤̻ ㅋ̤̫ㅋ̤̮ㅋ̤̻ 동쪽에서 ｦｦｦｦｦｦｦｦｦｦｦｦｦ 너무나 동년배네요... ㅎ
아 진짜 주문때 개쩔었는데
그게 마지막 팀플이라니.. 군머가기전에 제일 좋아하더 그룹이었는데ㅠ 군머에선 비스트가 좋았ㄷㆍ
5명이 있었기에 이 노래가 최고의곡이 될수있었던거야
이노랜 라이브가 너무 좋아서 오히려 이렇게 씨디로 듣는게 뭔가 빈듯한 느낌이 든다 물론 이렇게 듣는것도 다른타돌곡들에 비한다면 넘사벽으로 좋다만 그래도 뭔가 아쉬워... 근데 이 5인 조합을 다신 못듣는다는게 아직은 올려진 영상으로밖에 들을방법이 없다는게 너무 아쉽다 만약이라도 다시 뭉칠날이 온다면 그땐 눈물광광쏟으며 보고들을듯... 진짜 벅차다는 기분을 과거 영상보는걸로도 느끼는데.. 하ㅠㅠㅠ
I'm just introduce to them by mixnine, so beautiful😢
This song got me thru many hard times and still continues to do so. THANK YOU TVXQ ❤️
I feel honored just by knowing this song that is a never ending masterpiece.
DB5K
+Jennis148 JUNSU
D beauty of dese 5 guys will NVR leave d earth coz it's eternal...der songs are!!! Nd for many years to come I can say dis song nd dbsk5 will b remembered ....even if by minority......I'm proud cassiopeia to love my dbsk5!!!
This is the reason i never waver from these guys.... They just perfect....
2023년..아직도 듣고 계신 분 있어요;;??
me
저요~!
Me
ㅇㅅㅇㅋ
심지어 컬러링으로 해놓음..ㅎ
❤. Can't we have another song like this?
#AlwaysKeepTheFaith
I just found them in 2007. TV5XQ brings me into Kpop world and they will always be my favorite boy group.
AKTF ❤
Changmin really genius how can he come up with these much of meaning words
He is so talented
He translated the song, he did good but dont forget about the actual lyricist
Yes
Such a masterpiece. Xia's solo always gives me goosebumps
It’s been a while ... feel so good to be here again !!!!!!!!!!!
I’m not gonna lie but SoonSeok brings me here and thank to them , they bring me back here , bring me back to the good old day
2021은.. 발들어요..
2022 껴도 됨..?
ㅗ
2022는 뭘 들면 될까요..
발.. 끼잉
2022.. 11월 쌀쌀해서 왔습니다만..
Listening to this song in 2019 remind me how much I miss them. ❤ TVXQ forever.
2024년에 왔습니다❤ 여기
love this song so much though I'm not much of their fan. need to admit that this song is ❤ though. love Junsu's voice. and changmin's
I always feel like TVXQ is better when they sing live 😭😭
*cries intensely*.....this isnt fair i joined them so late why do i still hurt the fact ot5 isnt together ah its srsly making me cry
4:10 ....oh gosh....my heart is crying and so is every celll in my body
Me too... I joined them so late 😭😭😭
I cry every time I hear this song. Plus their voices that's full of emotions. 😭
진짜 이 곡이랑 퍼플라인이 goat임
Los escuché por primera vez en 2008, han pasado 16 años y aún no logro dejar de llorar con esta canción 😢 después de su separación al menos los pude ver como JYJ en Chile, pero jamás será lo mismo que en esos años.
2019 and forever remains legendary.
Always keep the faith, until the end... My beloved ones... Thank you for sharing.
Sad
Thank you changmin for writing the lyrics to this beautiful song
Changmin you did a gud job writting this amazing song.... Boys did justicee to this.... One of my fav
9year ago my bff told me to play this on her wedding day😍 this is it I'm listening to this for her wedding this coming sunday😍😍😍awwwwwww❤❤❤❤ twinnieeee you dont know how much i love you my soulmate 💗 I'm really happy for you too see you as a strong independent woman and now finally it's your best day 💖💓💗 best wishes my dear twinnie and to your hubby❤
can’t get enough of this 💔
이 노래는 정말 오랜만에 다시 들어도 조아요ㅠㅜㅠ 🥺
Jaesu harmonization... Chef kiss
OK THAT'S IT I'M STANNING
i keep on crying every time i listen to this song istg
Kyliee Durano same
The beginning reminded me of Produce 101’s “Always” :) They are part of my childhood ❤️
Omg i'm in love with this song 😭❤
남돌 역사상 최고. GOAT 5방신기
Coming back here after watching changmin solo comeback. Pls support him guysss
My heart hurts. This song. This group ❤️
I have a small history with this song,
in short, every time i listened into this song, i feel safe because of them.
Emoshinki strikes again after years :")
So proud to TVXQ fan
The harmonization of them especially between Junsu and Yunho gave me chills.......
2024년인데 아직도 듣고 있는분 있나요
LITI is one of their most covered songs and it's easy to see why. Love TVXQ!
Yes
Goosebumps
2024년 이거 들으러 오신 분 있나요?
no group can cover TVXQ song easily. every TVXQ song is really hard to cover.
Agree
3:35 레전드의 시작,,,
The song that would be able to calm me whenever I’m giving up
How beautiful their voices are - our beloved idols 😊🥰
2023은… 손가락들어요…
BEAUTIFUL :')
DBSK forever 😍😍😍😍💞💞💞
2018 still the best song for me... 😭
하... 사방신기만이라도 나이먹고 더 깊어진 감성으로 부르는 노래를 다시 듣는 날이 올까나
Forever one of my fav songs
YUNJAE😍😍😍😍😍
2023 👍
너흴 좋아했다고 하기가 창피한 날이 올 줄은 몰랐다 이 나쁜놈들아…………
최강창민 빼고…
This makes me so happy, AKTF :')
What is aktf
I miss them ❤️
El mejor grupo K-pop que canta y baila al mismo tiempo ❤❤ 2019 siempre presenta mis bbes😍😔
November 13th, 2023 at 9:08AM
I still get the same feelings I did when I first heard this song.
보이스코리아 보고 왔는데
왜 이런 띵곡을 이제야 안건가...
안녕하세요 2024년입니다..
2023💞👍🇺🇸
2021. Anyone?
2023년.. 손드세요..
2021 i still miss them so much 😢
2023 손 ✋️
aaa. . wanna cry! miss them
永遠に 聴きたいほど
大好きすぎる 曲😍
ありがとうございます😃
from🇯🇵
I really miss you guys, TVSQ Q__Q
이건 ㄹㅇ 개띵곡인데 아이돌이고 뭐고 한국에서 이런 노래 나온적이 없었음
작사작곡 일본인이한거고 일본에서 먼저 음반내고 한국에 번역해서 1년뒤에낸거
Such a beautiful song
amazing
전설....
here from SMTOWN JP video aespa Karina said she likes tvxq lovein the ice
I knew the harmony part only before
now I will keep it in my playlist 💗
2021년 마지막 다와가면서 다시 듣기…ㅜ…