What Amphibia Did Better Than The Owl House
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.ย. 2024
- So last week, I gave a lot of praise towards The Owl House and bashed Amphibia quite a bit. So to even things out, I'm doing the inverse. Well sort of. In reality, I'm tipping the scales more in favor of Amphibia because that is the show I prefer overall lol
Follow me on Twitter: / marngel23
Join our Discord server: / discord
Become a TH-cam member: / @marngelrambles
Become a patron: / marngel
Credit to @Kalamity_Music for the background music:
• Amphibia x The Owl Hou...
#amphibia #theowlhouse #disney #disneychannel #gravityfalls #memes #disneychannel #videoessay - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
While I do adore both of these shows equally, it’s great hearing someone talk about Amphibia’s strengths over The Owl House considering how much people tend to do it the other way around.
I know right cause honestly I think amphibia did stuff so much better, also while I don’t hate it, owl house is overrated
@@abareamphibia6812I agree. I like the show, but amphibia just does it better for me
Same
@@TripleAAABatteriesStudioyeah I prefer Amphibia than The Olel House
Owl House
Amphibia really has the best character development in any show PERIOD. The way it focuses on the ENTIRE town really makes you believe and feel for the townsfolk. Not to mention when the townsfolk develop, so do the main characters. Even though there are main characters, EVERYONE gets a chance to shine which is really incredible. It makes the world feel WAY more connected then the Owl House and this helps the stakes of Season 3 (of Amphibia) feel even bigger when you realize just how many people are affected by it. Heck, even the citizens of Newtopia were shown as well. Having main characters grow at the same time as the side characters really helps make things come together, something the Owl House really lacked as its focus was heavily on its main characters. That’s why (I feel) the end of the world/resistance thing didn’t really work as well in the Owl House as it did in Amphibia. In Amphibia you SAW and FELT the impact of the end of the world but for the Owl House it’s was kind of just an inconvenience because there was barely any character development/world building. The only others places visited in the Owl House were uninhabited by people or weren’t really residents of the Boiling aisles (The Titan Hunters were located in another realm so to speak). In Amphibia EVERYONE was working together to defeat Andrias but in the Owl House it was only a select few students. And yes, I am aware that the owl house was shortened so there may have been more time to develop characters that was cancelled but you have to judge a show based on what it is.
A bittersweet ending is almost always more powerful than a purely happy one. Owl house had the good guys kill the villain and then everyone got the happiest possible ending. Luz in particular gets to have the best of both worlds, literally! Amphibia had the girls say goodbye to their Amphibia friends and family potentially forever, and the emotions there felt real. The characters on both sides move on, but would never forget the relationships they had made with each other. To me that felt much more poignant than one where every good guy gets everything they could ever want.
I understand your opinion. I don't completely agree, but I get it. Just a small correction, because you said /every good guy gets everything they could ever want./ - King wanted more than anything to get together with his father to find out what he is, well, yes, he found out what he is, but his father is already completely dead, and now he lives in his lifeless corpse and is presumed to be the last of his kind. I don't see this as something he would want. Or Eda and Lilith both still have their curses, yes, they manage them, but they still have to drink their elixirs and accordingly they can't do natural magic either, I suppose that the harpy forms are some kind of compromise, but still. Or Hunter, who is not only covered in scars, but also lost his best friend, and to some extent he himself killed him with his own hands, not by his will, obviously, but still, and regardless of the fact that he was replaced, , he didn't get it back in any way, and that's something he really valued and I don't think he ever wanted that. And Luz somewhat had a downside because she lost her glyphs, and yes I know they brought it back because King now has his own now but his are no match for the previous titan's and will most likely take millennia to develop until he grows up, so somewhat from a certain point of view, She also has a downside and I think they let her learn magic not so much because she will be able to use it but rather out of generosity. And let's not forget and perhaps the most important detail - they are actually not out of danger at all, because as it turned out the Archivists are still alive and are still somewhere around the universe, we saw for ourselves what the Collector can do, imagine what four are capable of , and as we know they are much more aware than their younger brother and much more extreme in their actions, I mean if anyone dares to contradict them they literally wipe out entire planets, if these guys find out there is still life on the planet and that there is one surviving titan, the good guys are absolutely, to say the least, finished and that's not even debatable.
And I'm not saying it because I want to argue with you or because it annoys me that someone has a different opinion, but these are simply the facts.
You would have more of a point if any of these things were actually focused on as something to make the ending less happy. In my initial post, I almost added "(short of bringing back the dead)" thinking of the Titan and Flapjack, but deleted it because Luz literally did come back from the dead. Glyph magic dying is very much mitigated by new glyphs. The acceptance of the Owl Beast and the Harpy forms is a happier outcome than purging the owl beast would have been. If there were to be a sequel series the archivists potentially being a threat would give us pause, but as there is nothing planned, there's really no need to dwell on them at all; the characters sure didn't.
Basically, given the characters who died, the ending we got was the happiest possible one we could have gotten, to the point where they even undid the coven sigils, and Hunter got a new Palisman! Given how the first two season finales leaned very much into that bittersweet "we succeeded, but at what cost" vibe, it was surprising that the show concluded with an entirely happy ending. Also, any loss the good side sustained in the finale, whether permanent or temporary, was merely a result of Belos acting evil, rather than a sacrifice anyone on the good side made.
@@TiMoThY211991 I'm sorry but what. No, I totally have a point. Because first of all, these are facts, no matter who focuses on what, I can focus on everything good that happens on, say, a specific day, but that won't make all the bad things that happen parallel to it invalid, right? Also thought about the following, if the ending was all sad and played out and focused as such, would that make some things that are frankly nice, invalid, simply because they are not in focus, but nevertheless exist and are known about by the viewers.
And I say again - I don't want to argue with you, and I didn't say this to annoy you, and in fact, from a purely technical point of view, I agree with you, but these are simply things that cannot be ignored. You can't tell me that kid, his father died and now he lives in his corpse and tell me that this is what he always wanted because it obviously isn't .............. /unless we're talking about a sociopath child / .
Also - how come the characters did not reflect the danger of the Archivists, in the prologue Amity is seen holding a book on which three huge figures are drawn, hinting that they have not forgotten about them at all and plan to find out as much as possible about their history. for this was, as far as can be said, a history book. Saying these guys aren't a threat is potentially like saying Bill Cipher is out of the picture simply because no one on the show focused on the fact that he would still be alive, yes the characters didn't know about the reverse message but if I I have a literal god as an enemy, I personally would have one in mind, / information from comics does not count /
@@borislavangelov2933 The fact that some bad stuff did happen, does not actually make the ending feel less happy. I'm mostly talking about the epilogue here, because admittedly there was a bittersweet moment when Luz told King about his father, but after the time jump, everything worked out just about as well as it possibly could have. I don't expect the archivists to come back and kill everyone offscreen, so unless The Owl House somehow continues, they are not canonically a threat that will have to be dealt with. They absolutely could have made the ending feel bittersweet, but that is not the tone they chose. And to me, the "everything is better now" plus "main character gets to have it all" feel they went with for the epilogue of the Owl House felt less poignant than the ending of Amphibia.
@@timgilbert9572 My guess is that they chose the happy ending for Luz mainly because purely thematically it is more related to the idea of the story. Anyway, I say again, I don't say this out of disagreement, but rather because some things that we have seen as an existing fact, which are frankly not exactly happy, are being ignored. Otherwise, the ending was super happy, that's right, but I don't understand why this is a problem for some, as long as it makes sense in relation to the story being told, I personally don't mind any ending. I mean, everyone I ask who is of this opinion says something along the lines of "one made me cry more", so what exactly is the criterion here, which made me cry more, because I don't see that at all as good criteria for two reasons. First - it's super subjective. Second - I've seen people non-ironically cry like babies at movies like Revenge of the Sith / which is not an example of a good movie at all / and non-ironically say that the movie is great because they felt great emotions, ignoring the fact that the movie is super wooden and sterile almost all the time.
To me, Amphibia connects with me more on an emotional level that The Owl House does. The drama between the characters is more significant and it’s executed really well.
Also, Calamity Anne is awesome. It’s a great take on the super form cliche that reminds me a lot of Super Sonic.
And the series finale hits a lot harder. Seeing the characters never go back to Amphibia hits a lot harder than the character in TOH not being able to use magic. Really, the ending for TOH isn’t really an ending. It’s an opportunity for Disney to expand the franchise.
(Also, it is a war crime that the full OST isn’t on Spotify.)
I agree. Bittersweet endings always hit harder.
Amphibia's main family did a better job at feeling like they grew naturally into a family for me. Luz, Eda, and King had more of a vibe of staying at your gay aunt's place for the summer.
I agree with this. I also add that the "visiting gay aunt's place for summer" vibe is certainly not a bad one despite the point.
Only to fall off the face of the earth in terms of writing by the time Season 3 rolls around.
@@infinityheart_tm9270 Amphibia was trash from start to finish.
@@DragonKingMadaraUchiha Correct.
@@DragonKingMadaraUchihaI disagree heavily with that.
If there's one thing I definitely appreciate about Amphibia is that it takes the Spider-Man 2 approach of developing as many side characters/inhabitants of the town/city as possible. In Amphibia's case, that's mainly Wartwood.
That way, when said towns are put in danger for the finale, Wartwood for Season 1, Newtopia for Season 2, and to a lesser extent Earth in Season 3, you care about what's at stake. Wartwood especially is important. Had the show never developed Wally, Ivy, Mayor Toadstool, and Loggle, I would not have cared about what happens to the town in Season 1 when Sasha threatens mass murder on them. But because the show did develop them, it makes them standing up to Toad Tower all the more powerful.
In The Owl House, I don't really know much about the rest of the Boiling Isles besides the main cast. I don't know much about Boscha, Skara, The Bat Queen, or even Principal Bump. I still care for them, and like how they stand up to Belos, but it's just not as powerful as Wartwood standing up to the Sasha and Grime.
I agree about Amphiba's emotional moments. Even now rewatching Amphibia's most emotional moments they still get to me. I'm 30 years old and an emotional moment I have seen many many times can still tug at my heartstrings. The Owl House's moment can hit me, but to the same extent or as frequently.
I agree foggy and amphibia still means a lot to me with those emotional moments!
I agree, and also the fact that it feels like EVERY. SINGLE. PERSON. IS LGBTQ+. I’m not homophobic, I’m pan myself, but I think they went a bit overboard with the lgbtq+ people in the show.
I think Amphibia also handled its supporting cast a lot better too as most of them get moments/episodes to shine.
The reason why I love Amphibia better, because (for me) it resonates with me more. I geniully love continouity, arcs and lore stuffs, but I need some set-backs with some "funny" episodes between them, and then continue the journey
I know right
I think both shows had the right ending for what their respective themes were. Amphibia was always about change and learning to accept that, so it works really well for the worlds to be divided and for the trio to move on with their memories of their time in Amphibia. The Owl House was about finding acceptance and community with other people - something Luz was sorely lacking prior to the story. She found that community in the Boiling Isles, friends and a second family, and was able to reconcile with her mom because of it. She found her belonging, she was always meant to have both. Whereas Amphibia was more of a Stage In Life for Ann - something that was good and important and you miss it when it's gone, but it can't last forever.
I honestly agree that Amphibia's ending was stronger, but I think both were excellent in what they were trying to do. TOH's ending might've been idealistic, but it made just as much thematic sense as Amphibia's did
I agree, which is why I don’t think either ending is “better” than the other since the two end on different conclusions that many people will enjoy regardless.
Yeah Both shows have Strong merits but Amphibia just resonates with me more over the years, with world-building, character arcs, and the Lore/history of the World of Amphibia.
Which I personally feel was inspired by Zelda Breath of the Wild style, or Adventure Time and the land of OOO. Both worlds have that cool open world feeling that you just wanted to explore the history of.
Course my obsession of exploring how the story of Amphibia was gonna end played into this factor.
Honestly if Season 3 wasn’t forced into taking the tonal whiplash and actually played it’s strengths to it’s limits in Season 3 would’ve been 10/10 show to me.
Honestly, I actually agree with you on some of the stuff in this. I think the Cultural representation, visual gags, world building, heck even the messaging, although for Owl House it did made sense, works a lot well in Amphibia. However, I also think both the character development and emotional moments actually works well for both shows.
I always did hold TOH's happy ending against it tbh. It felt like a nod back to the renaissance era of Disney and not something fitting for the current time. By keeping it bittersweet by means of the means of maximum perceivable happiness being "indefinite" instead of convincingly "permanent" (that is to say re-connection between worlds), Amphibia concluded much more fluidly I would say.
Besides, 10 years is what I would call the average change time (ACT). It seems like something major happens every decade that shifts societal thinking in a different direction or makes a major splash that sticks out in most minds for about that much time. Eras themselves seem to last that long.
My point being that 10 years seems long enough for Amphibia and Earth to have grown independently and reconnect again without compromising any maturity and health in the process. It felt that way when I had my 10-year high school reunion last year. People were similar and different at the same time in good ways.
As for your other points
-A+ Cultural Representation: With the massive emphasis on how much it meant to Anne, I was inspired to look up Thai culture as a research hobby. I would go on record and say that other shows that make a pass at CR without going into further depth about it and provide so many interesting examples do not warrant that kind of interest-grabbing and research-prompting sway.
- Emotional moments. TOH has a lot of them, but so many of them, I find it almost desensitizing. Amphibia plays that circular illusion you described so brilliantly that it is probably why the reveal in "The Beginning of the End" of Marcy being treated like a third wheel by Anne and Sasha horrified me and hit closer to home than almost anything else in the entire show. I've watched a lot of hard-hitting shows, but nothing hit harder than this right here.
- Comedy. Perfectly funny and expertly nuanced with the major emotional moments here and there. By keeping the designs simple most of the time, the animators had a lot more liberty to put those meme-worthy facial moments in there.
- World-building: Coming from me who is too intimidated to get deep into games like Terraria and Skyrim due to the difficult/unfulfilling tutorials and early branches, this has so much to it that points that it's easy to make a casual Role Play with them and make them plausible within the show itself. There's just so much world-building that the potential for short stories, novels, prequels, midquels, and filler background details is endless.
The thing that drives me insane with toh’s ending is how it directly contradicts Amphibia’s ending, which is that you have to let go of things, no matter how hard it is, meanwhile Luz gets this idealistic ending of staying with both worlds, with just really bugs me.
And I’m all for darker-themed shows, I love hfjONE (which is an object show) but even though toh is darker, I prefer amphibia because, like he said, the happy moments only help amplify the darker and emotional aspects of the show, and I prefer that over toh.
I've said this before and I'll say it again:
Two things I think Amphibia did VERY well, better than any show I've seen, are worldbuilding and subtle foreshadowing.
Amphibia feels like a world where anything could exist, especially now that we've gotten the reveal of an entirely new continent that we literally know nothing about. It's amazing how much of Amphibia we DID manage to explore though, to the point where I'm surprised at just how creative the crew got with it while still managing to tell a coherent story.
And the foreshadowing. Like I've said, Gravity Falls was the nearest competition in this regard, but Amphibia surpassed its predecessor. While Gravity Falls had clear foreshadowing moments with its whole Mystery and Secrets element surrounding the entire town, Amphibia's was more of the subtle variety. Sometimes you wouldn't even *guess* that something was foreshadowing until it came true. Ex: Loggle's buff statue of himself way back in season 1, Anne calling Domino "an interdimensional being beyond all time and space," and Polly getting an itchy butt right before she grew her legs.
i personally do prefer amphibia over the owl house and gravity falls not only are the characters more relatable to me as people (mainly marcy and anne) i just think that amphibia just means a lot more to me it's affected my life WAY more than owl house, i feel like most of the TOH fandom watched TOH for the lgbt representation than the story, i do have many MANY complaints about amphibias story pacing and the responses to trauma but as a child friendly light-hearted show i think it did pretty well, i honestly didn't connect to the owl house's characters as much as amphibias i like amphibias character designs more i like the plot (although it could've been more focused on) both amphibia and the owl house honestly deserve way more runtime than what they got i am upset that amphibia didn't explore more amphibians and TOH as a whole didn't focus on the world building as much as amphibia did but the characters in toh are way more well established personality wise (im not saying that amphibia's characters are lacking just that IF amphibia could show more response to Anne or Sasha seeing marcy die literally in front of them that would be pretty neat) but generally as a whole i prefer amphibia amd its CRIMINAL how underrated it is (srry for bad grammar/punctuation im rlly bad at wording)
I‘m a massive TOH fan and I definitely watched it for the story, the lgbtqia+ representation was just a nice bonus on top
@@legobrickstudios21I’m glad I’m not the only one who dislikes it when people say people only watched TOH due to the representation because it discredits all of the thought and effort put into the story line regardless if it being rushed in some places. It’s a bit insulting to the writers and to the fans.
I honestly understand why ToH went with a happy ending because Amity and Luz were dating. That would suck if they had to separate. everyone would be mad.
One thing I feel like the owl house did better, was the villain, tbh I was expecting Andrias to be evil, he didn’t seem right, but with belos, we knew he was evil from the start, but as the show went on, he just got even more dark and evil than ever, like have you seen hollow mind, that had my fling out of my seat, gaming chair, and anyother sittable thing, that was a masterpiece
Imo belos was average at best he wasn't really all that threatening
While Luz is able to visit both worlds unlike the Calamity Trio, there are still things she had to learn to live without & start over again - she could no longer use magic the way she once did & had to learn from scratch. This was devastating l for her - with her even crying over it.
I take that as learning to teach yourself something you used to love doing, all over again.
Honestly, having to leave something you grew to love just hits harder than not being able to use magic.
Dude, the reason why I love Amphibia more is definitely tied to the character interactions and comedy. It's so funny, and I have such a blast watching these characters and the world, that I don't even care if nothing plot important is happening. Some of my favorite episodes are "filler" episodes. The Owl House is great, don't get me wrong, but it's clear it's more plot heavy and that's what Dana wanted to do but Disney forced it into an episodic slat in s1 at least.
I totally agree with you - Amphibia connected more with me better than the Owl House did. Sure, when TOH premiered, what excited me most about it was Luz, a Latin American character that I could relate to as a Latinx person. But I didn't get interested for too long, and probably another slight con of its representation is just simply the lack of experiences that Luz gets regarding her ethnicity - maybe because simply, the creator isn't Latin American and therefore didn't make it a core part like Matt Braly did. Regardless, Luz was represented excellently and it's clear Dana and the writers put their best efforts. One of the reasons I love Amphibia is because of it's characters - Marcy in particular since I strongly related to her and loved her to bits (and still do!). Another point is that simply, Amphibia's worldbuliding is slightly more original. When you think about it, The Owl House has relatively a similar world to that of Harry Potter and other media involving witches and medieval fantasy. It has its interesting points, but Amphibia's tropical frog world is an upgrade for me - and you also have unique creatures and robots! Either way, both shows are excellent as you have said, and everyone will take them differently.
I completely agree with you amphibia just hits harder and it's great
That’s why it’s my favorite show of all time along with avatar the last airbender
For me, while I still adore both of these shows, Amphibia to me, just connects with me more. This is really some solid analysis! I'm not very good at explaining things on why I love this show so much. But you explain it really well in the video. Everything about the world, characters and lore just resonates with me more, especially the messages about change and why I can relate to Anne so much as a protagonist. And thank you adding that clip at 8:37. Hopping Mall's ending always tear me up every time I re-watch that episode. Again, solid writing and performances to Brenda Song and Justin Felbinger during that beautiful scene. :'(
Amphibia had the more heartfelt moments for me and hopping mall is a great example of that and Marcy poring her heart out when she admits she got the girls stranded on purpose,punched me in the gut
I do love Amphibia a lot, but sometimes I do feel like the comedic moments hinder it's story occasionally. I understand not all shows need some grandeur plot and climax, but I feel like in some crucial moments (ie: Mother Olm telling Anne about the Ultimate sacrifice) could do with a little less comedy. Otherwise, I do recognize that amphibia's emotional moments did hit harder than some of the Owl House's.
For me, the Amphibia world felt more alive, and more nuanced. The boiling isles has more outlandish designs for its demon world. But it seems we see just of lot of humanoid looking characters and not much else. Yeah Amphibia’s Civilians are only one of three species, but they have more varied designs, and it feels every new location includes new background characters that makes the world feel populated. It just feels like we see the same background characters in TOH.
We also see more species in Amphibia that make it feel like a thriving planet with complete ecosystems. We barely see many species in The Owl House.
We also see there is a species based caste system in Amphibia, whereas we don’t really see any kinds of bias in the Isles. One would think there might be some kind of history of prejudice, maybe there would be Witch supremacists, who see Witches as the best species because they are the most dominant. Maybe there is hatred against demons without magic, and they are seen as burdens to society, the way humans see those with physical and mental disabilities as burdens. Maybe that is why we only see bipeds in Hexside.
That’s honestly How I feel about Amphibia’s world as a whole really. There’s just a more “lived in” feeling that Amphibia’s towns and cities just make it all feel real. All the named side characters we meet in Wartwood, Newtopia, and even Toad Tower and several miscellaneous towns didn’t just feel like one and done characters we meet once and won’t ever care about again, they felt like people.
@@toadlord8594amphibia really does feel like a world that I would want to explore, honestly the boiling isles felt like a generic fantasy world,
@@abareamphibia6812 Look, in principle, I understand any opinion, but what you said is simply scandalous. The Boiling Isles are a pretty unique location for a fantasy setting, and they're pretty subverted actually. Do you know what Generic is? I will tell you . Generic is / especially in fantasy / mostly conflicts in cold or wooded lands with handsome knights in shiny armor fighting evil forces that appeared out of nowhere, with castles, prophecies, dark lords and of course my "favorite" the chosen hero or heroes who will save the world from evil or prove themselves or become kings or some other tired trope we've seen 1,000,000 times. In other words, it's something that's been seen so many times that it makes you sick when you hear it.
Now tell me which of these descriptions could apply to the Boiling Isles. I will tell you / with the exception of the fact that there is magic / none of these descriptions can be found on the boiling islands. The setting is located in the corpse of a fallen titan from thousands of years ago - tell me how many stories have you read or watched where the setting is like this, such a location for a home would you expect from a villain, hell, tell me how many stories will include titans as the main characters players, side note Attack on Titan doesn't count because it's not exactly fantasy, or at least not completely. The characters and in general the inhabitants of the boiling islands are also quite atypical, in normal fantasy stories they will be presented as the villains, separately the setting itself is very grotesque looking considering that this is the environment for the good guys as well. Yes, there are forests and castles from time to time, but they are by no means the main focus. There are no dark lords here, no prophecies, no invincible evil, and thank god there is no chosen one, because if I see this again, I will shoot myself.
But speaking of that, let's see Amphibia's setup, shall we? Forests and castles - here. warriors - kind of . An evil that must be defeated, otherwise it all ends - here. Prophecy - here. Chosen heroes assigned to save everything - oh YEAH, here.
Well, it turns out that Amphibia is quite generic, my friend. The only difference is that there are amphibians instead of people. If you take people from the Middle Ages and put them there, there won't be any difference as a way of life, which cannot be said for the Boiling Isles.
@@abareamphibia6812 I can understand where you are coming from, and you make various great points, such as how the isles is definitely more unique than Amphibia. I think The Owl House’s problem is that it doesn’t really explore the full potential of it’s world. Mythical creatures stem from the isles, we barely see any outside of unicorns, griffons, and some dragons. In Amphibia, we see multiple species, which live in multiple environments. While Anne does stay in Wartwood for most of the series, we see many more towns and environments such as deserts, tundras, villages, and Newtopia. In the Owl House, we don’t really see any other town other than bonesbourough. We see Latissa, but even Luz acknowledges she hasn’t seen much of the isles outside of that one town.
@@docfox4353 I think amphibia is more unique a place the boiling isles honestly has so much wasted potential. I mean It’s on the skeletal remains of a titan and honestly they did nothing creative with it society wise amphibia it really feels like a real world
From a subjective point of view, I can understand your position, but I would strongly disapprove of one specific thing, and that is that Amphibia's emotional moments are stronger because the show is mostly silly and when something dark happens, it is felt more strongly. I'm not happy with it because while, yes, it does create a contrast and it's felt, but from a structural point of view, I don't think it's a good idea because if it's fun most of the time, the build-up is lost, and the supposed emotion grabs you out of nowhere, and that breaks the balance. If anyone wants proof, look at almost the entire third season, it was a tonal mess - in one episode the frog family /for some reason/ instead of worrying about the situation they are in, go visit a Taiwanese temple and have fun /wtf/ and keep in mind that a supposed war is on the horizon and these types of scenarios continue all season long. it's one thing to do it once or twice and thus fake the calm before the storm, but they do it constantly after the third episode in a row where Anne and the frogs do some stupid thing instead of really thinking about things in Newtopia and apart from that until at this point as far as they know Marcy is DEAD and no one cares or cares enough, it's starting to annoy me personally. By raising the stakes so high, you can't constantly joke along the way, so firstly, you destroy the tone for the viewers, and secondly, which is more important, in fact, the emotional moments come not so much as pure emotion, but rather as emotional manipulation, because until two years ago episode, we've been defeating the bad guys with dances and suddenly now someone dies, I mean, that's not ok for me.
Yeah that actually makes sense. There was something didn’t like about the ending and I think this describes my issue. It did lack the build up and suspense that should’ve have gone along with the circumstances. And when the time did come it came all at once
They kinda did it with the B plot with Sasha preparing the people for the war. But when we’d cut back over to Anne it kinda lost momentum when it seems like they aren’t really processing what’s happening
It did have some impactful effect, doing it this way, but it certainly detracted at least a little from this big story beat
While I vastly prefer TOH there is a few things Amphibia did better those being
1) Handling of side characters
2) Music
3) Sometimes character development (Sometimes TOH does it better Sometimes Amphibia does so I'm mentioning it too)
I really prefer amphibia's ending but the owl houses pride rep was great too, and we can't forget gravity falls. Tbh I don't have an opinion on which is better, I like them all equally, the owl house, gravity falls, amphibia, big city greens, and star vs the forces of evil.
Imagine how great Amphibia would’ve been without the tonal whiplash
But like it doesn't
@@retexcrafted Marcy gets stabbed five minutes later Anne has an anime reaction to 5G and it’s back to light hearted adventures In not expecting the show to get gritty but to at least take itself more seriously
@@owlbert2020 That was an entire season later. Even if you started watching it after all the episodes available and didn't have to wait months, you still see why they wouldn't focus on that, right? Anne doesn't have time to actually think about that because she's focusing on Earth. After Marcy gets possessed Olivia and Yunan don't crack jokes, no it fades to a very creepy credit scheme and the next few times we see her it's very serious.
@@captainsprinkles6557 I’ll give you that but there’s no excuses for Season 3B
@@owlbert2020 it does take itself seriously though. Anne bottles up all her fear of that. Like I have watched so much and I personally dont geel whip lash. Although I see your point it's like the road trip episode of gravity falls
I more or less agree about the mentioned advantages that Amphibia has over TOH and for me there's another one. I really like the idea of three separated, yet united with their previous bond, characters who find teir own way in this alien world and give us their different view of the world and their previous relationship. For me this one allows Amphibia to really outshine TOH even if sasha and Marcy were underutilized in the show itself. But this is just subjective of course.
I told this to my friend how I preferred Amphibia over the Owl House and they were surprised because owl house does have everything I’m into in it but the reason why I prefer Amphibia was its themes. Don’t get me wrong owl house does have good themes but its main theme was weirdos stick together and I have seen that so much already. Where Amphibia’s main theme was friendship and yes I know there are a lot more shows that talks about the power of friendship BUT not like how Amphibia showed both good and bad sides of friendships like how toxic Sasha was at the beginning. It did something that I haven’t seen many kid shows do before. That’s why over all I prefer Amphibia over the owl house still love owl house tho.
I agree the comedy in amphibia passes the owl house in s1 of the owl house I didn't see the difference in the comedy but in s2 of the owl house I learned that amphibias comedy wasuch nicer to enjoy than the owl house dark moments like if you agree
Amphibia will always have a higher pillar in my heart because I relate more to Anne and Marcy more than Luz. Plus I love frogs. The Owl House,though, has its own strengths. I also saw Amphibia first, and didn’t get into the owl house until the Season 1 hiatus when I was bored and looking for something else to watch. Anne’s self esteem struggles mirrored my own, and by the end of the series, I had a higher opinion of my self like Anne did.
I agree Amphibia is the superior show OVERALL, but for different reasons:
First, you’re right, Amphibia’s world building is more in depth, but it also has more originality to it. The boiling isles is creative but on the surface it’s just another fantasy world, we haven’t seen a world with talking amphibians before this.
Second, I actually disagree with you about the humor, the Owl house has a slight advantage because the humor comes from the ENVIRONMENT, not just the characters, plus the humor is more consistent.
Third, with the exception of Luz, all the characters in Amphibia are either more interesting or more relatable than the Owl houses characters.
I always say, 'A good writer can pull an audience, but a great author can change a hater's mind'. I never liked the stereotypical 'slice of life' style episodes, even in shows I'd argue are my top hyperfixations. That kind of show or episode never grew on me and was that one episode or show I avoided at all cost, I hated that style of writing so much. But Amphibia season 1 is like 90% 'slice of life' so why do I like it, but not in other super hyper fixations? The reason is that it's meant to be like that in the first place. Amphibia thrives in it's character arks. For Anne, it was growing to accept responsibility and a change of pace in life. We saw both in the start of the series and in the flashbacks, that on Earth the Anne we knew was mostly her with her friends, doing dumb pointless fast-paced things. She was a type of kid who gave into peer pressure from her friend Sasha, and did whatever she was told. The Anne we came to love was someone who was forced away from her parents, making her miss them since this time she didn't CHOSE to leave them, and her connecting with her frog family, in a slow paced unaccepting environment without Sasha to tell her what to do. I love that the slice of life style of the show was used to improve Anne as a character, instead of one shot style adventures that mean nothing to the plot.
Personally I just felt Amphibia was the better show, the story felt more unique since it focused alot more on tackling growing up, dealing with potentially toxic or harmful relationships, the world was more interesting and the ending felt more impactful. Anne and the others had to say goodbye to Amphibia and their friends, while Luz basically gets to have everything she wanted consequence free.
Agreed.
This is so true. The Owl house was always fast paced and never had a chance for funny filler episodes like Amphibia (probably because of the show cut short, but they still had some room for it)
Good point with Amphibia having a more poetic ending. Don’t think Owl House could pull off the same thing though because like Luz and Amity were together, they’d have to split, and there also wasn’t any reason she’d have to go home and never return since King would grow up eventually and could just casually open portals even if you said the collector couldn’t do that. It would raise more questions than answers if they did it, and would be pretty sad
The problem with worldbuilding is I don’t think Owl House opens itself up to the typical worldbuilding because of the weird nature of the island
We got some interesting locations like the raised knee and the head
We never learn why the head is sacred or why the knee has so much more magic, maybe there’s more titans blood deposits at the knee or something and maybe the head is sacred for obvious reasons since the Titan is like a god
But there’s not much you can really do with it. Amphibia is abit more open to being classical fantasy like, these cities can have governments and history and whatnot, whereas Owl House just had the emperor and all his guys being basically the entire government
The simplicity of its world limits what you can say with world-building. Maybe that’s a sign of poor world-building, or maybe it means you don’t need a complex world. I can’t really decide
These are my thoughts on Amphibia as a whole: I have recently watched Amphibia and at first, I thought that Anne's flaws were beyond that of a regular teenage girl by immediately jumping into driving Bessie the snail without considering reading Hop Pop's manual in order to do it properly, giving in to peer pressure from the tad tax collectors, even though she's been told that they are willing to damage people's homes to find the tax, not being a fan of playing teams in sport, having trouble trusting her teachers, being desparate for answers to the point of getting into trouble, accepting a shady deal with the curator because she discovered a CD player from Earth, that lead her to being a victim of being petrified into a wax figure, standing inside the parade when she was just supposed to be watching it from the side, threatening the kids who cut in front of her while she waited for 3 hours in line for the Newtopia arcade, thinking that she was trying to be assertive and speak up, and many more reckless and impulsive decisions. And the episodes in Season 1 were your typical slice-of-life stories where the characters learn valuable life lessons like you see in The Proud Family, Pepper Ann, Static Shock, The Loud House, My Little Pony, and most preschool shows, to be honest. But once I've watched the rest of the series, Oh my God, this is My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic and Steven Universe Future all over again. I have heard so many people say that Amphibia is one of the greatest cartoons of all time, and by looking back at this, I can see exactly why. Amphibia stands out as an example of the power of simplicity and how it can make a story more engaging with a story built on impressive worldbuilding and life lessons that were cleverly used as steps towards character development, charming humor that is guaranteed to give all audiences a smile, a refreshingly light-hearted tone that makes the later dark moments more effective, a refreshing and authentic representation of Thai culture with Anne Boonchuy and her family, nice animation with charmingly simplistic designs, a vibrant Amphibian-themed world, and engaging battle sequences, loveable characters that can range from having an enjoyable personality, to having lots of flaws while still being likeable, some of the best character development with Anne and her friends learning from their bad habits and becoming more loveable people, an emotional core that shows how much the characters actually care about each other, a sublte exploration of how even the strongest friendships can be toxic at times, the flashbacks show that their flaws are because they are willing to give a good contribution to their friendship, even if things go wrong, and a message of change and letting go of the things you love to grow as a better person. This is definitely a must watch for anyone who is curious.
Amphibia is wonderful and my favorite part was anne giving her life to save amphibia so that is still a great show! 😊🐸😍👍
Amphibia is my second favorite show ever
I agree and I love amphibia
@@mayracordero382same
Curious - what's your first?
The owl house
They are both rly good
i believe the cultural representation in amphibia is so much better than the owl houses’s because amphibia’s creator is thai and anne’s experiences are inspired by his own, whereas, toh’s creator is white and only learned about luz’s background through research and her friends
Personally who watched all three shows i prefer gravity falls
Amphibia did a LOT of things better than TOH
I know right
Agreed.
Amphibia is my favorite Disney show
Mine too
I think there's two sides to some of these points. I completely agree, Amphibia's world building is more in depth and covers more people and locations. Paradoxically, this makes Amphibia's world feel smaller. It feels like we have a full understanding and background of every species in Amphibia. It works really well for Wartwood as a small town, but it feels like what we seen on screen encompasses most of what happens in Amphibia. This could very well be a me thing, but I wonder if anyone else feels the same?
Also, while Amphibia is overwhelmingly lighthearted with a few intentionally placed emotional scenes, the latter part of the Owl House is the inverse. As the tone gets darker, mundane or comedic moments become rare and more meaningful. Them's the Brakes Kid is a break from the plot for both the audience and the characters. It's just Eda telling a fun, slice-of-life story to her family. It's a wholesome episode wouldn't have the same impact if it were placed in season one. Or an even better example of this juxtaposition: goop Belos dragging his decaying body across a mass grave of his brother's clones and telling them to shut up.
In my opinion the only thing that I did hate was how anne just kinda ignored Marcys death but i do agree even if TOH got a complete s2 and full s3 I'd still think character writing and story goes to amphibia
I think spilling the milk missed a bloody gold mine
tbh owl house was good but i feel like amphibia developed their not main characters better
like besides hunter, eda, king, luz and kinda amity nobody else really got any memorable development
gus and willow got like maybe 6 episodes total and mostly in early season 1 and i wish they got more because i love those two
i litterally almost forgot amity was a bully before luz im not sure if it was just me but i thought she changed from bully to friend a lil too quick
none of the hexide students/teachers got developed at all pretty much
none of the non-witch characters got developed pretty much (besides king and hooty i guess)
srsly there were so many characters with cool designs that wernt witches and pretty much none of them got ant any attention besides being background characters
i also feel like we could have gone more places other than the owl house, hexide, bonesborogh, etc. like i get we went other places before but honestly t feels like the world of toh is a lot smaller than the world of amphibia because weve seen a lot of places in amphibia
i agree with everything you say but actually i just like amphibia better than TOH because it proves to be a really good show without romance
They’re both great shows, and your video essay is astounding, but one thing I disagree with you on is the ending. They both ended on different notes because the shows were both about different things. The owl house was about finding your people, so Luz got the best of both worlds, and Amphibia was about change, so Anne never sees Amphibia again (this previous sentence may have a bit of bad word choice but yk what I mean) The shows are just about different things so of course they’ll have different endings.
The owl house is my die hard favorite and probably always will be but the points in this video are great ones, and it’s really great hearing comparisons between the two shows that aren’t just tone deaf headbutts into a wall and shouting matches explaining why one is better than the other without going into detail why.
YES FINALY ive been after just finishing the owl house literally yesterday sept 8 i've been thinking this is so good but amphibia is still better overall (its my 4th favourite show with the owl house in 5th)like amphibia is more emotionally resonant and hits harder and i can relate and care for the characters way more due to amphibia's more grounded characters and cast. i still think toh is good but amphibia is better
In a perfect world, both shows would have had all the needed time to shine, with two full fledged seasons.
But if the fate of one of them was inevitable, I personally feel the one to be shortened should have been Amphibia. And this is NOT a slander on the show nor am I claiming which one "deserved" it or not. As I said, in a perfect world, both of them would have had their full time to shine.
But in comparison, if the second half of TOH was a bit rushed and didn't get to explain all the details about its lore and even just its story and characters, Amphibia on the other had a third season that wasn't necessary in its entirety. And this is not saying I didn't enjoy it, it was fun, but I feel it's a common sentiment that it didn't hit quite all the spots it needed to.
If the fates of the two shows were inverted, I feel like it could actually be somewhat "beneficial" (again, still taking into consideration that in an ideal world both TOH and Amphibia are telling all the story they need at the pace they want) to have three specials instead of one full, a bit dispersive, season.
The first special, just like "Thanks to Them", is dedicated to Anne and the Planters in the human world. Sure, the shenanigans were fun and all, but let's be honest, not all of them were that necessary in the grand scheme of things, and concentrating on the most focal things could make some of the criticisms towards season 3A fade away.
The second special is dedicated to when they go back to Amphibia and join the resistance. In the grand scheme of things, some of those episodes didn't amount to much and could very easily be shortened in a more compact story.
The third and last special would be of course the last two episodes of the canon show, either left as they are or with just a few sequences here and there cut to fit into the timing. They're good as a finale as they are, after all.
So yeah, don't mind me, it was just a bit of a thought experiment we may say, and I also reiterate that with this I'm not saying Amphibia deserved to be shortened more than The Owl House: neither of them did. But it's funny to imagine alternative scenarios sometimes.
In the 2010’s, we had Tangled vs Frozen. These days, it’s Amphibia vs The Owl House
Amphibia wins
@@abareamphibia6812 nah
I prefer The Owl House a bit more over Amphibia but I really love both
@razzberry Out of curiosity, when it comes to Tangled vs Frozen, which do you prefer?
i love both of them but TOH felt a lot more dull than Amphibia
I feel like having 3 humans w a past history in the new land theyre basically isekai’d too adds a whole extra layer on top of the story while to me TOH felt a bit. Lacking in that sort of message of connection? Its hard to describe
Another aspect of it is providing. Amphibia as a world is just so much more charming and unique than the boiling isles are. Like yeah theres unique stuff about that w titans and whatever but in the end it just boils down to generic fantasy lore VS a charming homey but dangerous world with FROGS
@@user-rb4cj7mb8f thats what im talking abt, amphibia's world is so much more interesting having a whole society with layers and stuff. we could see a lot of it thanks to the less plot-relevant episodes
the idea of amphibians is also so unique comparing to plain old hummanoid beings and some demons here and there.
TOH? Dull? I think you mean the other way around. The way the characters interact in amphibia just so plain and lifeless.
@@StellarPixie Wow.. I absolutely have no words of how much wrong that you have made to your opinion here.. This is just plain sad to see.. Please leave..
They're both great shows. I loved Amphibia a lot more, but it's not like I didn't enjoy The Owl House, I loved it. We really need a new batch of Gravity Falls derivates!
I honestly don’t prefer one show over the other; both Owl House and Amphibia are two of the best shows I’ve ever seen.
But on the subject of their endings; I honestly prefer Owl House overall. Call it ‘idealistic’, but frankly, after all the hardship Luz went through, she deserved a happy ending. If she was cut off from the Demon Realm, where she found friendship, identity and, above all, love, it would destroy her.
To be honest, I’m not fond of the idea of ‘leaving fantasy for reality’ angle; it implies Amphibia wasn’t real for the Trio, when it was. Even so, it’s still a wonderful ending, and I love it.
yeah i really like Amphibia more than Owlhouse I prefer Amphibia way of storytelling more. 💚💙❤
Amphibia rely on the world building to tell the story and get us attach to the character which make the show unpredictable, cause we barely know anything about the story (there was so much character development and plot twist on the show lol)
while The Owlhouse use the character lives for world building and tell the story which make the story predictable, cause we already know the enemy(i literally predicted more than half of big things that happened in the show with just a first few ep lol)
I love Amphibia...but I think Owl House had a more relatable protagonist, personally speaking
Even though I fine amphibia more relatable, I can totally see how you can find characters from TOH more relatable. It all depends on your life
Anne is a better character than Luz, Luz is so damn annoying
@@azizshamsi6044 To you, maybe but her behavior (and backstory) were VERY relatable to the rest of us
I love both shows equally. There were jokes in Amphibia that were actually funny, and that's a good thing. I loved both finales but I definitely liked the Amphibia finale more. But I also loved The Owl House finale too, I just preferred the Amphibia one.
I still can't decide which one I prefer because I literally love both shows equally, but there were things in both that kind-of balanced eachother out (if that makes sense).
🐸
While I’m personally an Owl House Stan and even a little bit of a downer on Amphibia as a whole (I mostly like it, I love season two and three a I just do not like a lot of season one and with the exception of the last two episodes season three kinda compared to the thirty plus episodes right before) I do realize that I’m in the majority and it’s nice to hear a differing opinion on two good shows. I think it’s really funny how with the exception of the cultural aspects and the tones of the two shows everything you said about Amphibia is what I’d say about the Owl House.
They Are The Same We Equal Them Both We Don't Need To Say Amphibia Is Better Than The Owl House Or The Owl House Is Better Than Amphibia We Can Treat Them The Same We Like Them Both But Saying One Thing Better Than The Other Thing Is Like Saying Ice Cream Is Better Than Cake
I just finished watching amphibia, and I believe it tops both Owl House and Gravity Falls
Amphibia is the definitive Magnum Opus of animation as a whole
You and I think alike
9:16 the scene almost made me cry
I also think a point that you didn't say is that amphibia's background music is really beautiful,I'm serious,I have amphibia's background song in my playlist!
I constantly switch between thinking The Owl House is better and thinking Amphibia is better, it's too hard to choose!
Personally I do prefer The Owl House over Amphibia, so videos like this worry me because I take criticism towards the former more personal than towards the latter (I know. It's really stupid and childish that I think like this), but you bring up really good points I didn't think about. I just wish people didn't treat stuff like this like the Apple vs Android of cartoons or something like that. I hate seeing two fandoms of shows I love, arguing to no end and crapping on the other in every aspect imaginable. In any case, I think I especially agree on the last point. I really love Watching and Dreaming, but I prefer The Beginning of the end/All In/The hardest thing for the message of change and discovering oneself. TOH reasonates with me better, but characters like Anne are an exception. I really relate to her in terms of self-discovery and I'd also count Sprig here for how hard is for me to accept change, just like it happens to him and I embrace Anne's final message, even quoting it to others
Agreed.
“I don’t feel safe.”
Agreed. That moment at the end of Hopping Mall was so emotional!!
It gave me shivers.
Oddly while I like both shows, the visual gags actually kinda put me off of Amphibia. It felt abit… idk, it was just strange sometimes
TOH: Better storytelling, better plot pacing, better LGBTQ+ representation, and darker themes
Amphibia: Better characterization, better world building, better culture, better humor, better themes, and better ending
Overall, Amphibia is better for me because it feels more full. They don’t just cut ideas halfway or rush storylines the way TOH does, they have a full world with characters to fill it up, and they have more interesting filler episode ideas.
I do agree with most of these points, but the reason why so many plot points in the owl house were left unfinished is that the show wasn’t given a full season 3. (Unlike Amphibia)
@@liampemberton9320 Yeah, but even with what TOH had (mainly looking at season 1), the characters barely had anything to them and unless your name is Luz, Hunter, King, or Belos, you’re irrelevant
@@NAVIGATIONATORS fair
2:07 - NO PLEASE, NOT AGAIN…
I fully agree with this whole video this was wonderful
Amphibia was an amazing show so was the owl house but amphibia just was a good show and I preferred it better than the owl house like and comment of you agreee
I agree
@@MelonLord379 thats right
I do not have a diverse cultural background actully i have more of a lgbt side myself. Yet i still thought the cultural representation in amphibia was really really good and in my opinion better than the lgbt representation in owl house
Either way, both shows are great additions to the DTVA Renaissance!
I like amphibia more than toh but I still do love toh
Me personally I don’t think that just because a character is of a diverse cultural or or racial background, it doesn’t have to be a defining aspect of their character. Different people are affected differently by such things, and it all comes down to so many different factors in their life.
For me Owl House touched on something different, with this heavy overarching theme of dealing with discrimination based on defying what others saw as ok or normal
The plot got started because Luz was seen as weird and bullied for it. Immediately at the start the Boiling Isles has the confirmatorium for similar reasons. There are Titan Hunters who killed Titans either out of fear or in homage to the Archivists. It’s unclear which.
And then the main antagonist is literally there to commit genocide against all of the witches because religious upbringing
Owl House had a scope for its theme and pulled it off wonderfully
This theme I feel is what really appeals to queer folk like myself watching the show. It’s a theme you can easily relate in that case.
The way I see it, Anne is simply more involved in her Thai culture than Luz is in her own culture. She may have very well been born outside of that culture so really has no connection to it outside of her blood. And that’s fine I think. Like I said before different people have different ties to their culture
A good point is made with education however, and I would enjoy if we did have the opportunity to see some Dominican culture in Owl House. I just wouldn’t deduct points from Owl House for not doing it.
to be honest i have only watched till 0:21 but my opinion is Amphibia is way better then the owl house i still think the owl house is great but there is something about Amphibia that makes it WAY BETTER in my opinion
Amphibia feels more original, Owl House just loves to copy and paste from other shows
How so?
Everyone's opinion matters. Because it's rightfully their own.
Me personally, I don't think a show has to go deep into the cultural backgrounds of a character. I think luz speaking Spanish was enough for me to be happy since it reminded me of me and my mom. Yeah, it's cool that Anne got to show that she's Thai but that doesn't always have to be a big part of a character's story. I think it's unfair to say that the owl house is worse because of Luz not sharing her culture. Maybe she doesn't want too. Not everyone eants to show that side of them. Luz not showing her Latina side can be interpreted as she might actually not know much of that culture besides the language and quinceneras and I think that's representation for me since in the same situation. Thanks if you read this far, I know this is kinda long (:
He never said it was worse, just what Amphibia did better than TOH.
I've always been an Amphibia person I didn't hate owl house I actually enjoyed it quite a bit It just wasn't really my cup of tea
Amphibia is my favourite show
Mine too
Personally i prefer the Owl house but you made some good points.
LONG HAVE I AWAITED THIS VIDEO
Same! :)
Agreed finally someone acknowledged that amphibia does some things better than the owl house
The thing amphiba did better then the owl house was having more then 3 episodes in there third season
I like Amphibia more than toh because it’s basically a anime
Edit cause I called toh toe
Tbh, I started watching amphibia and owl house at the same time, like one to one, first owl house episode 1, then amphibia episode one, then owl house episode two etc.. but amphibia felt very slow, so I started watching more owl house, and then I noticed the next episode came out next week, so i started watching amphibia again, and I got HOOKED, so then the next episode of amphibia is coming out next week, but hey, owl house has a new episode! So I watched it, then 1 week later I got amphibia then owl house then amphibia, etc.. but then, amphibia finished, and I was sad, but then I realized I can watch owl house, so I did, then I had to wait months, then I finished both shows, and I was like: what now? . In conclusion I think both shows are great, you should definitely watch em both
The only thing that i dont like about amphibia is the fact that the first thing Anne said in s3 was “IM HOMEEE” not something about seing her friend literally get stabbed in front of her, but other than that, Amphibia is criminally underrated, like it’s better than the owl house there’s no debate about it
It's like Mike Tyson vs a baby
How so
I HAVE NEVER BEEN THIS EARLY WOW
9:03. This scene hit me and my mom hard. This is one of the best moments in the show.
I am so on the fence with these two shows man. Like i genuinely don't know if I like one more than the other. I want to say I like toh more but honestly some part of Me disagrees and vice verse.
Amphibia and The Owl House are part of The Casagrandes series along with The Casagrandes.
I agree with a lot of what you say, but I also disagree with several key points. But all in all you are correct, each show did several things better than the other show. I will say that I thought the character development was done better in the owl house.
The owl house side characters wasn't really special they were less interesting to look like it you agree
thank you. i have seen so many videos saying why toh is better and its just so annoying
It is
Owl house >>>>>
I agree with pretty much every point you mentioned in this video 12 hours ago.