Which book in Aqeedah, authored by an Imam from the Salaf, endorses khurooj i.e. rebellion against Muslim rulers? KHAWARIJ: th-cam.com/video/52BEa7WSxec/w-d-xo.html PLAYLIST: th-cam.com/video/hdqwMZKQYho/w-d-xo.html
Salaam Alaikum Brothers, I have been watching your videos, and as a Muslim, I am proud to see people like you guys spreading the deen correctly. always promoting the scholars, the Quran, and the hadeeth. I have contacted you brothers on Instagram about a question I and my father had regarding zakat and investments. my name on Instagram is inamz21 could you please reply to that message so we can contact you. Barakallahu feekom.
@@interfaceking1137 Wa Alaykum Salaam wa Rahmatullah. We forwarded your message to the brothers so hopefully you'll received a response soon. You can also ask questions via our brothers at: qa.mpubs.org Wa feekum baarak Allah brother
My grandfather passed away yesterday leaving behind two wives, nine children and around 25 grandchildren. He left this world completing all Five Pillars of Islam. Please make duaa.
Alhamdulillah for Islam.. Thank you Brother Shamsi.. May Allah shower His blessings upon you and all our brothers in da'wah.. May Allah keep you all with patience, wisdom and strength to continue sharing the beauty and the truth about Islam.. And may Allah keep our hearts in Islam and Insya Allah be together in Jannah by His Mercy.. Aamiin Ya Rabbal 'Aalaamiin.. Lots of love & respect from your Muslim Brother in Malaysia..
@@cyberman3797 Wallahi This Shamsi is one of the Lion's of Ahlu-l-Sunnah wal-Jama'ah. May Allah protect him and bless him. Hajji is an innovator and a liar.
Imam Abu Muhammed Abdurrahman bin Abi Hatim Ar-razi (RahimUllah) (توفى ٢٧٧ھ) in his book (كتاب اصل السنة واعتقاد الدين) mentions the same thing… he also cited many other great scholars from Hijaz, Iraq, Egypt, Syria and also Yemen. ولانرى الخروج على الائمة ولا القتال فى الفتنة
May Allah keep you humble brother. Your dawah is beautiful and may Allah guide the misguided people through this channel and protect brother shamsi from any arrogance and self amazement because none of us are safe from it and may Allah give him more and more knowledge. Aameen
Shamsi brought out some great information from the books that he referred to. This guy's aqeedah is on the right path hamdulilah, if that was he's teaching the people from these books, then anyone who's learning from him will gain benefits inshallah. He's unique wallahi, not like the stooges Hajji Jahil, Mohammed Hijab and Ali needs Dawa (not Da'wah) and the other imbeciles of the speakers corner. May Allah guide us all to the righteous path, Ameen.
@@RRUU198 no no, sorry, you're not being naive or anything, I was just referring to my previous comment but it didn't post for some reason so I re-posted it. Check again, but I'll post it here too: For those wondering who shamsi is talking about, then the person is a *jaahil* who doesn't learn from the explanation of the scholars on books. Rather, he speaks ill of the scholars It burns him that shamsi doesn't mention his name, and he can burn in his rage. May Allah guide him and his followers or silence them In other words, the person shamsi is speaking about is: 1) A jaahil 2) A khaariji from the khawaarij ul-qa'diyyah 3) The donkey of Birmingham
@@RRUU198 no worries bro, may Allah bless you. Alhamdulilah we can see the difference between those who take the unclear back to the clear and those who hold to the unclear and base their principles upon that. May Allah protect us
Barak allah feekum brother shamshi for this video may Allah bless u protect u and give u more ilm Ameen I have been asking one simple question since past one year on hajji a videos and post but he has all the time to make scripts and videos but not once he tried to answer my question which is What does allah mean by When u differ among urself go back to allah and his messenger If someone differs on a issue should he go back to allah and his messenger Or Should that person stay with one of the opinion and not go back to allah and his messenger Hajji never respond also his viewers none of them say anything
On the issue of wiping over the socks. I don’t know if bro hajji is actually that jaahil that he didn’t know the answer or he intentionally tried to misguide his followers. Thoughts? Jaahil or intentionally misguiding his followers
@@weldjibla6425 yeh he is jaahil without doubt but on this matter he must of known the answer already but I think he used it to deceive the juhaal who follow him as they wouldn’t know and claim victory for bro hajji
Al Bidaya Wal Nihaya by Ibn Kathir is really good book about before rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam was born and after his death sallallahu alayhi wa sallam
As salam alaykoum They are greater scholars than al barbahary who said it is not permissible to rebel against injust muslim ruler. - al bukhary (he brings ijma3 of scholars he met in his life, more than 1 thousand) - abu zur3ah al razy, abu hatim al razy and his son - sufyan al thawry - qutaybah ibn said : student of imam malik, he teached hadith to sahib kutub sittah (except ibn majah) and imam ahmad. - harb ibn ismail al kirmany (he brings the aqeedah of imam ahmad and ishaq ibn rahawayh) - al tahawy (he brings the aqeedah of imam abu haneefah) - al muzany (student of al shafi3y) - ibn abee zayd al qayrawany (one of the famous maliky scholar) - ibn taymiyyah - muhammad ibn abdil wahhab Only a ignoramus or a mubtadi3 can oppose this point of creed... (Sorry if my english is not correct)
Shamsi teaches at daarussunnah in West London. Spubs is in Birmingham. Check out "salafi publications" on twitter and who they follow, likewise masjid bin baaz in East London. Which city are you from?
@@mrb7935 Thank you for the help bro. I’m actually from Oakland California brodie. I might take a trip to the UK so I wanted to know where he at. So there’s only 3 salafi mosques in London? The one shamsi go to, the spubs one and the one where dawah man go to?
@@seeyalater3510there is masjid ibn seeren in Bristol and I'm pretty sure there is also a salafi masjid in tower hamlets although I don't know their name
@@alfirqahannajiyahand there is one in slough although I also don't know the names. Although I am also from America so I don't know much about the UK. Are you visiting us for this upcoming Philadelphia conference akhi?
o.b5z.net/i/u/6103974/f/creed_4_imaams.pdf here is a link to a pdf that quotes abu hanifa and proves his aqeedah. if you cannot tap it search. “the creed of the 4 imams” on Google and tap the third link.
@@hamidzain1055 ٱلْـحَـمْـدُ لِلّٰه but remember what abu hanifa said. “when i say something contradicting the book of Allah the Exalted or what is narrated from the messenger, then ignore my saying.”
@@khalido50ko good but why you people like Najdi but other scholars they were born before Najdi many years before I imam abu Hanifa was born 60 or 65 hijri after prophet and Najdi was born in 1703 and died in 1793AD
Last time I asked "ok you run to history books, but which aqeeda book actually teaches khuruuj", i got the reply "issue of khuruuj is not from the aqeeda". Some people will come up with anything to defend their khuruuj.
One of his arguments is that some of the Salaf did the act itself of rebellion or whatever in the past. And from this he wants to conclude that their action justifies it, in some cases, even if in the book the "general rule" (as he says) is that it is forbiden.
1. No one from the companions rebelled against a Muslim ruler! 2. IF one or two among the Salaf rebelled, how does that make it correct to rebel when we have clear Hadith stating not to rebel?! You gonna follow The Prophet ﷺ or the mistake of a righteous man?! 3. The meaning of the shahaada: 'Muhammed is the messenger of Allah' is that you give precedence to the hadith over & above everyone no matter who it is
You can understand your belief based on history. Then a Shia can claim sahaba spoke ill of one another so we can as well. But no, in our aqeedah is we don’t speak ill of sahaba
@@Zakneteur as Shamsi stated, aqidah is NOT taken from history books. This is the way of the extreme deviants, Shia, khawaarij and other than them. Aqidah is taken from the books of aqaa'id.
Bro hajji, also known as: 1. Abu Misquote (known for misquoting scholars to further push the Aqeedah of the khawarij 2. Bro Khariji 3. Donkey of Birmingham (As Allah says كمثل الحمار يحمل أسفار “is as the likeness of a donkey who carries huge burdens of books (but understands nothing from them) [Muhsin Khan Translation]).
Most people don’t care about narrations, they just see things from their own perspective. They yell oppression oppression, while riding illuminated broad roads in safety build by those same leaders they accuse of oppression. The hypocrisy, ignorance & and ungratefulness rises above their throats, and Allah’s refuge is sought to become like this sheep.
You forgot Usul as-Sunnah of Imam of Ahlus-Sunnah wal-Jama'ah, Ahmad ibnu Muhammad ibnu Hanbal ash-Shaybani, rahimahullah. As he wanna describe as a follower of Imam Hanbal. A joke, to laugh and cry upon.
Email the brothers if you don’t know. There @ is in the description box. The brother is well acquainted with the students of knowledge from maktabah salafiyyah whom many scholars have praised the maktabah as a whole and at times, individuals from the maktabah. He studied and benefited from them and likewise the scholars from their lectures (online/cassette tapes). Likewise would sit with the scholars that would travel to the Uk (or thru tele-links) and benefit from them (the likes of shaykh Akkur, Shaykh Ubaid, Shaykh Zayd Al-Madkhali, Shaykh Ahmad An-Najmi, Shaykh Abdullah Al-Ghudayaan, etc). - Lastly, he knows the Arabic language so he would read the books of the salaf w/ explanation of the scholars الحمد لله (he also stated that when talking about the ignorance of Bro Khariji). - I’d email using the email in the description box , or contact him on WhatsApp if your able to, or contact him on Facebook @ Shamsi Bensafi. If you live in the Uk, then go to his mosque at Shepherd Bush but if not, then use the above information as a guide in shaa Allah.
Why doesn't shamsi debate bro Hajji, do a Zoom and make things clear. I see bro Hajji evidence is clear on screen where Shamsi isn't as clear and just presented his evidence in this clip as taking his word for it. I prefer not to take peoples word and blind follow, the text should be shown with a Scholars explanation at least.
th-cam.com/video/DgLAL38tOls/w-d-xo.html 1. Hajji has been caught out misquoting the scholars so your argument is weak. 2. the text not on screen is just you looking for an excuse (which is not valid) to follow hajji. 3. Shamsi's question still stands regardless if the text on screen or not and neither u nor hajji can answer it. Btw, do you even know Arabic language?
akhi. do not base your deen on whoever wins debates. indeed one person can be more eloquent in language and therefore better in debate than another. and words can be twisted and misquoted during a debate. That is why the salaf used to hate to debate. Imam Malik was asked by a man to debate him multiple times. and even he refused. and the whole ummah knows how knowledgeable imam malik is.
secondly, just because hajji presents evidence on screen, does not make it more clear. it may be that you misunderstood shamsi. and if you think that this one wasn’t clear then you can research more of his videos you may find one where he explains it in a way that is clearer to you.
He has literally given you the source material's, shown you all the books where to get the information from on the screen and translated the quotes from inside the books. Not sure what more you need from him? That's why he encourages you to read the books yourself, he told you the books names. Usool as sunnah by imam ahmad, buy it and read it, you'll see.
Imām an-Nawawī said in Sharh Sahīh Muslim (12/229): “And as for revolt - meaning against the rulers - and fighting them, then it is forbidden by unanimous agreement (ijmāʿ) of the Muslims, even if they are sinful oppressors. And the Prophetic narrations are abundantly overwhelming with the meaning that I have mentioned. And Ahlus-Sunnah are united that the ruler is not to be removed, on account of his sinfulness. As for the angle that has been mentioned in some of the books of jurisprudence of some of our associates, that he is to be removed, and which is quoted from the [deviated] Muʿtazilites, then this is an error on behalf of the one who says it and is in opposition to the unanimous agreement. And the Scholars have said that the reason for the prevention of his removal and the forbiddance of revolting against him is due to what arises from that of tribulations, and shedding of blood, and also corruption that is evident. Hence, the harm from his removal is greater than from him remaining in place.”
AQEEDAH AS SALAF Fiqhul Absat Abu Hanifa Fiqhul Akbar Abu hanifa Aqeedah tahaqiyyah Imam tahawiyyah FIRST LINE IN THAT BOOK This is AQEEDAH of abu hanifa Khalas need not waste time with the aqeedah of the Khalaf
@@hamidzain1055 you are confusing aqeedah and fiqh. let’s forget the scholars for a second. which did the prophet do? where did he put his hands during prayer?
‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️We need to unite under one flag of pure Tawhid, Instead of National flags and political banners. We must raise slogans of Allahu Akbar and Kalima Tayyib together, Instead of raising Patriotic and Nationalist slogans. Our Victory lies in loyalty to Quran Not National constitutions.💓💓💓💓💓
You let hajji fool you! There is no group called madkhalism: th-cam.com/video/g4g27Wk6ew8/w-d-xo.html If hajji is following the salaf, how come he can't answer Shamsi's question: th-cam.com/video/DgLAL38tOls/w-d-xo.html Don't let hajji fool you bro!
My brother and sisters read books of four greatest Imams in fikh, they are Imam Abu Hanifa, Ahmad ibn Hanbal, Imam Shafee and Malik ibn Anas. In Aqeeda read Imam Ash'aree and Imam Ma'turidee. May Allah bless you and ur family🤲🏼
Dear brother, read the books of Salaf us-Saaliheen regarding Aqeedah. Maturidi promoted erroneous Aqeedah desr brother. Please to read www.maturidis.com/maturidi/ More information about Imam Abu al-Hassan al-Ash'ari. Please to read www.asharis.com/creed/ May Allah guide us to follow Sunnah with understanding of Sahabah RadhiAllahu Anhum.
may allah guide you brother. imam ash’ari changed his aqeedah before the end of his life. he was on the aqeedah of the salaf just as we who follow this channel intend to be on. it is not for us to follow the aqeedah of one man or blindly follow the fiqh of one man. we intend to be on the aqeedah and madhab of the salaf first and foremost. think about it, who is more knowledgeable. one or two guys? or the students who took from the companions themselves? so we refuse to follow what you are calling to akhi.
Which book in Aqeedah, authored by an Imam from the Salaf, endorses khurooj i.e. rebellion against Muslim rulers?
KHAWARIJ: th-cam.com/video/52BEa7WSxec/w-d-xo.html
PLAYLIST: th-cam.com/video/hdqwMZKQYho/w-d-xo.html
Salaam Alaikum Brothers, I have been watching your videos, and as a Muslim, I am proud to see people like you guys spreading the deen correctly. always promoting the scholars, the Quran, and the hadeeth. I have contacted you brothers on Instagram about a question I and my father had regarding zakat and investments. my name on Instagram is inamz21 could you please reply to that message so we can contact you. Barakallahu feekom.
@@interfaceking1137 try email them akhi
@@interfaceking1137 Wa Alaykum Salaam wa Rahmatullah. We forwarded your message to the brothers so hopefully you'll received a response soon.
You can also ask questions via our brothers at: qa.mpubs.org Wa feekum baarak Allah brother
@@shakeelmoosa3770 email is in the description box
My grandfather passed away yesterday leaving behind two wives, nine children and around 25 grandchildren. He left this world completing all Five Pillars of Islam. Please make duaa.
إنا لله وإنا إليه راجعون
May Allah have mercy upon him and give your family patience.
Allah yarhimu. Ameen
My grandmother passed away this year May Allah grant them jannah and make their children pious that will make dua for them
@@iceyy8741 May Allah have mercy upon our grandparents and all Muslims.
الحمد لله
Alhamdulillah for Islam.. Thank you Brother Shamsi.. May Allah shower His blessings upon you and all our brothers in da'wah.. May Allah keep you all with patience, wisdom and strength to continue sharing the beauty and the truth about Islam.. And may Allah keep our hearts in Islam and Insya Allah be together in Jannah by His Mercy.. Aamiin Ya Rabbal 'Aalaamiin.. Lots of love & respect from your Muslim Brother in Malaysia..
Very beneficial video. May allah reward shamsi and all the brothers part of this youtube channel.
Ameen
th-cam.com/video/DgLAL38tOls/w-d-xo.html
Love from Indonesia
"Please give us simple answer, don't tell us your life story."
"He didn't listen, he told us his life story" LOL
And who said that ?!
@@weldjibla6425 shamsi around 2.35mins
@@weldjibla6425 this explains: th-cam.com/video/DgLAL38tOls/w-d-xo.html
@@cyberman3797 Wallahi This Shamsi is one of the Lion's of Ahlu-l-Sunnah wal-Jama'ah. May Allah protect him and bless him. Hajji is an innovator and a liar.
@@weldjibla6425 and a filthy kharji
Theres no ikhtilaaf today regarding the matter. In today’s generation anyone who disagrees is not from ahlul sunnah.
بارك الله فيك شمسي و الله يجزيك الخير.
بارك الله فيك اخي شمسي
JazakAllahkayr ustadh
Imam Abu Muhammed Abdurrahman bin Abi Hatim Ar-razi (RahimUllah) (توفى ٢٧٧ھ) in his book (كتاب اصل السنة واعتقاد الدين) mentions the same thing… he also cited many other great scholars from Hijaz, Iraq, Egypt, Syria and also Yemen.
ولانرى الخروج على الائمة ولا القتال فى الفتنة
Asalamu alaykum watching from somaliland. Alhamdulilaah. Barakallahu feek
Wa alaikumusalaam warahmatullaahi wabarakaatuhu
Shamsi May Allah reward you,
When will you be going through Kitaab at tawheed
Barakallahu feek brother
May Allah keep you humble brother. Your dawah is beautiful and may Allah guide the misguided people through this channel and protect brother shamsi from any arrogance and self amazement because none of us are safe from it and may Allah give him more and more knowledge. Aameen
Love you from a dense jungle of Assam India.♥️🇮🇳
🇧🇩
may Allah love you and Shamsi
Barakallahu feek akhi
Barak Allah Feekum, Love from UAE
السلام عليكم حياكم الله و بياكم و جعل الجنة مئوانا و مئواكم
I LOVE YOU BROTHER SAMSI FROM BANGLADESH
কি খবর ভ্রো?
@@amithassan1608 আলহামদুলিল্লাহ্। আল্লাহর অশেষ মেহের বানীতে ভালো। আপনি কেমন আছেন?
From Shepherds Bush to Bangladesh wow
@@binalauddinsarkar6789 th-cam.com/video/DgLAL38tOls/w-d-xo.html
@@amithassan1608 আরে মিয়া, আপনে কি করেন এখানে? চিনছেন আমারে?
Baraka Allaho fik may Allah accounted in your account in the day nothing benefits you money and children🇩🇿💪
انت علی حق یجب داٸما الرجوع الی الاصل حتی لا تتشعب وتختلط الامور 👍
بارك الله فيك و جزاك عنا و كل خير
من فضلك ،من فضلك يا ريت فيديوهات باللغة العربية نكون ممنونين
بارك الله فيك، شكرا
Jazakallahu khayran
May Allah reward you
Baaraka Allahuu Feekom
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
جزاك الله خيرا أخي شمسي
وفقك الله لنشر عقيدة السلف الصالح و التوحيد
بارك الله فيك اخي
Jazakallahu khaira akhi omg that saying made me laugh of the donkey 😂😂😂
May allah reward brother shamsi
Shamsi brought out some great information from the books that he referred to. This guy's aqeedah is on the right path hamdulilah, if that was he's teaching the people from these books, then anyone who's learning from him will gain benefits inshallah. He's unique wallahi, not like the stooges Hajji Jahil, Mohammed Hijab and Ali needs Dawa (not Da'wah) and the other imbeciles of the speakers corner. May Allah guide us all to the righteous path, Ameen.
Alsalam alleikum wa rahmatu Allah wa barakatuh how to buy this books
Can you help me please Jazak Allah kheir
Who is shamsi referring to, Hajji? May Allah reward Shamsi.
I answered you in my comment on this video
@@mrb7935 sorry I’m being naive, where?
@@RRUU198 no no, sorry, you're not being naive or anything, I was just referring to my previous comment but it didn't post for some reason so I re-posted it. Check again, but I'll post it here too:
For those wondering who shamsi is talking about, then the person is a *jaahil* who doesn't learn from the explanation of the scholars on books. Rather, he speaks ill of the scholars
It burns him that shamsi doesn't mention his name, and he can burn in his rage. May Allah guide him and his followers or silence them
In other words, the person shamsi is speaking about is:
1) A jaahil
2) A khaariji from the khawaarij ul-qa'diyyah
3) The donkey of Birmingham
@@mrb7935 thank you 👊🏻
@@RRUU198 no worries bro, may Allah bless you. Alhamdulilah we can see the difference between those who take the unclear back to the clear and those who hold to the unclear and base their principles upon that. May Allah protect us
Barak allah feekum brother shamshi for this video may Allah bless u protect u and give u more ilm
Ameen
I have been asking one simple question since past one year on hajji a videos and post but he has all the time to make scripts and videos but not once he tried to answer my question which is
What does allah mean by
When u differ among urself go back to allah and his messenger
If someone differs on a issue should he go back to allah and his messenger
Or
Should that person stay with one of the opinion and not go back to allah and his messenger
Hajji never respond also his viewers none of them say anything
th-cam.com/video/DgLAL38tOls/w-d-xo.html
On the issue of wiping over the socks. I don’t know if bro hajji is actually that jaahil that he didn’t know the answer or he intentionally tried to misguide his followers.
Thoughts? Jaahil or intentionally misguiding his followers
Jahil Jahl murakkab
Hajji is nothing but an innovator, what do you think of him !?
@@weldjibla6425 yeh he is jaahil without doubt but on this matter he must of known the answer already but I think he used it to deceive the juhaal who follow him as they wouldn’t know and claim victory for bro hajji
@@abuabdillah9709 th-cam.com/video/DgLAL38tOls/w-d-xo.html
How do I learn history of Islam after death of Muhammad ?(S.A.W)
Al Bidaya Wal Nihaya by Ibn Kathir is really good book about before rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam was born and after his death sallallahu alayhi wa sallam
First...alhamdulillah.
الله يهديك
As salam alaykoum
They are greater scholars than al barbahary who said it is not permissible to rebel against injust muslim ruler.
- al bukhary (he brings ijma3 of scholars he met in his life, more than 1 thousand)
- abu zur3ah al razy, abu hatim al razy and his son
- sufyan al thawry
- qutaybah ibn said : student of imam malik, he teached hadith to sahib kutub sittah (except ibn majah) and imam ahmad.
- harb ibn ismail al kirmany (he brings the aqeedah of imam ahmad and ishaq ibn rahawayh)
- al tahawy (he brings the aqeedah of imam abu haneefah)
- al muzany (student of al shafi3y)
- ibn abee zayd al qayrawany (one of the famous maliky scholar)
- ibn taymiyyah
- muhammad ibn abdil wahhab
Only a ignoramus or a mubtadi3 can oppose this point of creed...
(Sorry if my english is not correct)
Love you for the sake of Allah akhi
Watch how quick donkey of Birmingham replies to this 🤣
He firsts needs to pick which nasheed will get his followers excited.
@@ibnhassanq657 who backbited or slandered
@@ibnhassanq657 go tell this hajji with his shamless adab who has a whole dictionary on insults and slanders.
He would reply to every video even if u record no one and title it...khurooj
th-cam.com/video/DgLAL38tOls/w-d-xo.html
Big love to saudi 💚
You mean from Saudi?
وفقك الله اخي لنشر المنهج السليم
حفظه الله
What mosque does shamsi go to? Where is the salafi mosque in the UK? What mosque is spubs based at?
Shamsi teaches at daarussunnah in West London. Spubs is in Birmingham. Check out "salafi publications" on twitter and who they follow, likewise masjid bin baaz in East London. Which city are you from?
@@mrb7935 Thank you for the help bro. I’m actually from Oakland California brodie. I might take a trip to the UK so I wanted to know where he at. So there’s only 3 salafi mosques in London? The one shamsi go to, the spubs one and the one where dawah man go to?
@@seeyalater3510 there are a few more as well
@@seeyalater3510there is masjid ibn seeren in Bristol and I'm pretty sure there is also a salafi masjid in tower hamlets although I don't know their name
@@alfirqahannajiyahand there is one in slough although I also don't know the names. Although I am also from America so I don't know much about the UK. Are you visiting us for this upcoming Philadelphia conference akhi?
4:29 "You are a Jāhil , Jāhil murakkab"
Wa lai kum salam
I wish i have good english so i can understand all of your videos
Which languages do you speak?
@@user-ne2uh7jz4u indonesian/bahasa
Dear Shamsi how about Ahnaf faith(aqeedah).
are you talking about abu hanifa? he was on the aqeedah of the salaf.
o.b5z.net/i/u/6103974/f/creed_4_imaams.pdf here is a link to a pdf that quotes abu hanifa and proves his aqeedah. if you cannot tap it search. “the creed of the 4 imams” on Google and tap the third link.
@@khalido50ko I know him he's was born in Kofa and we follow his faqih
@@hamidzain1055 ٱلْـحَـمْـدُ لِلّٰه
but remember what abu hanifa said. “when i say something contradicting the book of Allah the Exalted or what is narrated from the messenger, then ignore my saying.”
@@khalido50ko good but why you people like Najdi but other scholars they were born before Najdi many years before I imam abu Hanifa was born 60 or 65 hijri after prophet and Najdi was born in 1703 and died in 1793AD
Last time I asked "ok you run to history books, but which aqeeda book actually teaches khuruuj", i got the reply "issue of khuruuj is not from the aqeeda".
Some people will come up with anything to defend their khuruuj.
th-cam.com/video/DgLAL38tOls/w-d-xo.html
I call him Abu Misquote ahahahah
❤❤
One of his arguments is that some of the Salaf did the act itself of rebellion or whatever in the past. And from this he wants to conclude that their action justifies it, in some cases, even if in the book the "general rule" (as he says) is that it is forbiden.
its seems you missed the point bro or you haven't been following this issue
1. No one from the companions rebelled against a Muslim ruler!
2. IF one or two among the Salaf rebelled, how does that make it correct to rebel when we have clear Hadith stating not to rebel?!
You gonna follow The Prophet ﷺ or the mistake of a righteous man?!
3. The meaning of the shahaada: 'Muhammed is the messenger of Allah' is that you give precedence to the hadith over & above everyone no matter who it is
You can understand your belief based on history.
Then a Shia can claim sahaba spoke ill of one another so we can as well. But no, in our aqeedah is we don’t speak ill of sahaba
@@cyberman3797 yeah it makes sense. When he says some of the salaf rebelled, do you know who is he talking about and what event is he referring to ?
@@Zakneteur as Shamsi stated, aqidah is NOT taken from history books. This is the way of the extreme deviants, Shia, khawaarij and other than them. Aqidah is taken from the books of aqaa'id.
which individual is he referring to ?
Bro hajji, also known as:
1. Abu Misquote (known for misquoting scholars to further push the Aqeedah of the khawarij
2. Bro Khariji
3. Donkey of Birmingham (As Allah says كمثل الحمار يحمل أسفار “is as the likeness of a donkey who carries huge burdens of books (but understands nothing from them) [Muhsin Khan Translation]).
Most people don’t care about narrations, they just see things from their own perspective. They yell oppression oppression, while riding illuminated broad roads in safety build by those same leaders they accuse of oppression. The hypocrisy, ignorance & and ungratefulness rises above their throats, and Allah’s refuge is sought to become like this sheep.
You forgot Usul as-Sunnah of Imam of Ahlus-Sunnah wal-Jama'ah, Ahmad ibnu Muhammad ibnu Hanbal ash-Shaybani, rahimahullah. As he wanna describe as a follower of Imam Hanbal. A joke, to laugh and cry upon.
I need bro shamsi biography under whom he studied and his sanad from scholars or recommendation of scholars about him
Email the brothers if you don’t know. There @ is in the description box. The brother is well acquainted with the students of knowledge from maktabah salafiyyah whom many scholars have praised the maktabah as a whole and at times, individuals from the maktabah. He studied and benefited from them and likewise the scholars from their lectures (online/cassette tapes). Likewise would sit with the scholars that would travel to the Uk (or thru tele-links) and benefit from them (the likes of shaykh Akkur, Shaykh Ubaid, Shaykh Zayd Al-Madkhali, Shaykh Ahmad An-Najmi, Shaykh Abdullah Al-Ghudayaan, etc).
- Lastly, he knows the Arabic language so he would read the books of the salaf w/ explanation of the scholars الحمد لله (he also stated that when talking about the ignorance of Bro Khariji).
- I’d email using the email in the description box , or contact him on WhatsApp if your able to, or contact him on Facebook @ Shamsi Bensafi. If you live in the Uk, then go to his mosque at Shepherd Bush but if not, then use the above information as a guide in shaa Allah.
Shamsi vs bro hajji continues
th-cam.com/video/DgLAL38tOls/w-d-xo.html
And Br Shamsi keeps winning
قال الامام الطحاوي: ولا نرى الخروج على أئمتنا وولاة أمورنا وإن جاروا
Why doesn't shamsi debate bro Hajji, do a Zoom and make things clear. I see bro Hajji evidence is clear on screen where Shamsi isn't as clear and just presented his evidence in this clip as taking his word for it. I prefer not to take peoples word and blind follow, the text should be shown with a Scholars explanation at least.
th-cam.com/video/DgLAL38tOls/w-d-xo.html
1. Hajji has been caught out misquoting the scholars so your argument is weak.
2. the text not on screen is just you looking for an excuse (which is not valid) to follow hajji.
3. Shamsi's question still stands regardless if the text on screen or not and neither u nor hajji can answer it.
Btw, do you even know Arabic language?
akhi. do not base your deen on whoever wins debates. indeed one person can be more eloquent in language and therefore better in debate than another. and words can be twisted and misquoted during a debate. That is why the salaf used to hate to debate. Imam Malik was asked by a man to debate him multiple times. and even he refused. and the whole ummah knows how knowledgeable imam malik is.
secondly, just because hajji presents evidence on screen, does not make it more clear. it may be that you misunderstood shamsi. and if you think that this one wasn’t clear then you can research more of his videos you may find one where he explains it in a way that is clearer to you.
He has literally given you the source material's, shown you all the books where to get the information from on the screen and translated the quotes from inside the books.
Not sure what more you need from him?
That's why he encourages you to read the books yourself, he told you the books names.
Usool as sunnah by imam ahmad, buy it and read it, you'll see.
Its already clear. Shamsi has many videos on this topic. I don't know how you can not see that hajji js a dirty kharaji.
Brother did not Imam Nawawi say in his book that people rebelled against Hajjaj? My brother if I am mistaken, please let me know brother
Which book of Aqeedah is that?
Video was 14 minutes ago your comment is 7 minutes ago, u didn’t even watch the full vid yet you’re coming with questions.
So what? Did he said that they we're correct?
Imām an-Nawawī said in Sharh Sahīh Muslim (12/229):
“And as for revolt - meaning against the rulers - and fighting them, then it is forbidden by unanimous agreement (ijmāʿ) of the Muslims, even if they are sinful oppressors. And the Prophetic narrations are abundantly overwhelming with the meaning that I have mentioned. And Ahlus-Sunnah are united that the ruler is not to be removed, on account of his sinfulness.
As for the angle that has been mentioned in some of the books of jurisprudence of some of our associates, that he is to be removed, and which is quoted from the [deviated] Muʿtazilites, then this is an error on behalf of the one who says it and is in opposition to the unanimous agreement. And the Scholars have said that the reason for the prevention of his removal and the forbiddance of revolting against him is due to what arises from that of tribulations, and shedding of blood, and also corruption that is evident. Hence, the harm from his removal is greater than from him remaining in place.”
th-cam.com/video/tHVnH25zQp8/w-d-xo.html
www.abukhadeejah.com/ahlus-sunnah-wal-jamaah-believe-that-rebellion-against-the-rulers-is-forbidden/
www.abukhadeejah.com/revolt-of-the-early-scholars-against-the-tyranny-of-rulers-in-light-of-the-sunnah-and-salaf/
www.google.com/amp/s/abdurrahman.org/2017/12/13/it-is-not-permissible-to-fight-the-ruler-nor-to-rebel-against-him-even-if-he-oppresses/amp/
www.google.com/url?sa=t&source=web&rct=j&url=sahihalbukhari.com/sps/downloads/pdf/MNJ160006.pdf&ved=2ahUKEwjj6dHWrqjuAhUZ7KQKHc-kATUQFjAFegQIEBAB&usg=AOvVaw38EGSrVvo0uqdNv6h-CVgn&cshid=1611072026253
Akhee you did not even explain the issue of khurooj or respond to the uleama who allowed kurooj
th-cam.com/video/tHVnH25zQp8/w-d-xo.html
AQEEDAH AS SALAF
Fiqhul Absat Abu Hanifa
Fiqhul Akbar Abu hanifa
Aqeedah tahaqiyyah Imam tahawiyyah
FIRST LINE IN THAT BOOK This is AQEEDAH of abu hanifa
Khalas need not waste time with the aqeedah of the Khalaf
th-cam.com/video/DgLAL38tOls/w-d-xo.html
But people of Arab prefer to Abdul Wahab Najdi
What does this mean? Prefer *muhammed* bin Abdul wahhab to what?
could you make yourself clearer brother? i’m not understanding what you mean?
@@mrb7935 it means u follow his aqeedah like u hold your hands on chest during prayer but Ahnaf people don't do that
@@khalido50ko we have much problem with Wahabi people I don't like them
@@hamidzain1055 you are confusing aqeedah and fiqh. let’s forget the scholars for a second. which did the prophet do? where did he put his hands during prayer?
‼️‼️‼️‼️‼️We need to unite under one flag of pure Tawhid,
Instead of National flags and political banners.
We must raise slogans of Allahu Akbar and Kalima Tayyib together, Instead of raising Patriotic and Nationalist slogans.
Our Victory lies in loyalty to Quran Not National constitutions.💓💓💓💓💓
I left madhkalism because of haji. Alhamdulilah
You let hajji fool you!
There is no group called madkhalism:
th-cam.com/video/g4g27Wk6ew8/w-d-xo.html
If hajji is following the salaf, how come he can't answer Shamsi's question: th-cam.com/video/DgLAL38tOls/w-d-xo.html
Don't let hajji fool you bro!
I left Ikhwanism and Hizbiyyah by the will of Allah and brother Shamsi helped me in this.
You left reading the books of the Salaf for a TH-camr.
My brother and sisters read books of four greatest Imams in fikh, they are Imam Abu Hanifa, Ahmad ibn Hanbal, Imam Shafee and Malik ibn Anas. In Aqeeda read Imam Ash'aree and Imam Ma'turidee. May Allah bless you and ur family🤲🏼
Dear brother, read the books of Salaf us-Saaliheen regarding Aqeedah.
Maturidi promoted erroneous Aqeedah desr brother. Please to read
www.maturidis.com/maturidi/
More information about Imam Abu al-Hassan al-Ash'ari. Please to read
www.asharis.com/creed/
May Allah guide us to follow Sunnah with understanding of Sahabah RadhiAllahu Anhum.
may allah guide you brother. imam ash’ari changed his aqeedah before the end of his life. he was on the aqeedah of the salaf just as we who follow this channel intend to be on. it is not for us to follow the aqeedah of one man or blindly follow the fiqh of one man. we intend to be on the aqeedah and madhab of the salaf first and foremost. think about it, who is more knowledgeable. one or two guys? or the students who took from the companions themselves? so we refuse to follow what you are calling to akhi.
Why cherrypicking, while 4 imam is best in their aqidah than Ash'ari,.. while ash'ari is makes many mistakes and when finnaly follow the salaf aqidah.
th-cam.com/video/DgLAL38tOls/w-d-xo.html