@@GurdasGuruhaan toh bhai kisiko bahar thodi Kiya jaa raha hai reservation se!!!! Bas Jo ati pichde warg hain unko aage laane ki koshish ki jaa rahi hai SC dwara.... 🤔🤔
Agar SC Jo kuchh bhi kar sakte he to , Jati baad ko khatam kare . Reservation ke pichhe kyu.... Jatibaad khatam hone se Reservation aapne aap khatam ho jayega
@@b.kishorkumar1356 toh 2019 mein general waalo nay ro ro kar 10% EWS kyu liya tha ..tabh supreme court m yahi bolte ki caste system khatam kro..ji EWS liya woh reservation nahi hai kya
@@_KUHUSINGH sc st reservation is based on social discrimination.and untouchability..which is also a valid reason...and ek baat sun lo..and agar EWS reservation valid hai toh ..saba usko pvt sector m implement krna chaiya yaha par 97% employment hai na ki govt sector mein..is it logical to give EWS reservation in only 3% employment..aur aap desh ki gareebi dur kar rhay ho..govt sector m reservation dena ka objective bas itna hai ki sabki representation ho govt m..aap govt ki job apni gareebi dur krnay k liya krna chahti ho yaa desh ki sewa k liya..shame on you..aap jaisay log hai jo yeah soch laikr aatey hai aur corruption krtay ho fir
This decision is good but what about the loopholes used by the privilege section like Pooja khedekar, needy and marginalized section will not get what they deserve until unless these wealthy people will not stop using reservation anyhow.
Haa or obc mai koi bhi reservation ko apne layak nahi hai kuki sabhi obc kabhi bhi socially supress nahi hai example Krishna yaduvanshi the or dwarka king to wo kaha se upekshit ho gaye
@@Studybpscanduppcs jaise hi baat OBC /SC/ST pe ati h turrat EWS Pe kood padte h reserve category wale piche 70 year se reservation le rahe h kuch nhi 5- 6 year ke EWS se kitna dard hota h inko
@@adichauhan4758 और सवर्ण जो पिछले 3000 सालों से 100% rservation ले रहे थे उसका क्या, क्या "जाति" नामक Virus दलित , पिछड़ों या आदिवासियों ने बनाई थी, "जाती नामक Virus" बनाने वाले भी तो सवर्ण हीं हैं, इन 70 सालों में Reservation से SC,ST की Literacy rate करीब 60% और OBC Literacy rate 70%+ हीं पहुंच पाई है,इसी में सवर्णों के पेट में दर्द होने लगी, सवर्णों को 16% होकर 51% seat मिल रहा है वो reservation नहीं है? अब आप कहोगे हम ज्यादा अंक लाकर job प्राप्त करते हैं, और SC,ST वाले कम, इसका मूल कारण है,सवर्णों में Literacy rate 80%+ है,इसीलिए तो Quality balance के लिए 51% seats General है,और Quality support के लिए OBC Category भी हैं, रही बात SC और ST की तो जिस दिन इनकी आर्थिक और शैक्षणिक स्थिति General के 50-60% भी पहुंच गई,उस दिन आपकी ये तकलीफ भी खत्म हो जाएगी, example के लिए कुछ छोटे Gov. Jobs में ST का cutoff SC से ज्यादा या same होता है,जबकि ST और SC में करीब 10% का Literacy gap है , आजादी के 40 सालों तक तो Reservation से किसी को तकलीफ नहीं थी, तभी इतना जनसंख्या विस्फोट नहीं था जबकि तभी हिंदू के भी औसतन 4-6 बच्चे होते थे, जबकि आज 60% से ज्यादा हिंदू के 2-3 बच्चे हीं होते हैं, और आंकड़ों के मुताबिक पिछले 20 सालों में 50 लाख भारतीयों ने विदेशी नागरिकता स्वीकार कर ली, फिर भी इतनी JOB Crisis क्यूं, इसका मुख्य कारण है, politicians और इनके Votes Banks और Voting Game changer Bangladeshi और Rohingya Migrants क्यूंकि सांसद में 60% से अधिक नेताओं criminal back ground होना , जिस देश में criminals कानून बनाते हों,तो आम जनता का भला कैसे होगा। और क्यूंकि भारत में 90% लोग जातिगत मानसिकता का शिकार हैं तो उन्हें politicians का दोष नहीं दिखता, Same case Supreme Court के जजों के साथ भी है, क्योंकि Supreme Court में एक विशेष जाति का प्रभुत्व कायम है, इन्हें Collegium System नजर नहीं आता, इनके पास तो सबकुछ पीढ़ी दर पीढ़ी से हीं है,धन ,दौलत,इज्जत, कानूनी ताकत , इनको तो जातीय भेदभाव, छुआ-छूत नहीं झेलना पड़ा, फिर खुद क्यूं Reservation (Collegium System) का लाभ ले रहे हैं।
@@Paradox82827 sir, EWS is only for economically weaker sections,not for rich general classes, however it has been largely used by rich general class. Here sc,st and OBC have been excluded from ews or Those who belong to sc st or obs cannot be accessed this EWS. EWS is only for general castes reservations
@@Englishliterature1013 Bro don't write anything without knowing....EWS can be accessed by anyone if he/she comes in criteria of EWS....but u can't access 2 reservation benefit simultaneously.
Great Decision... OBC waalon ka bhi bhut jyada Rreservation de rakha... Mere college mai ek ladka tha... Uske maa baap ke paas kaafi pasie the... More than 20 Lac Per Annum Income... Likin Uske baap ne Naukari ki income show kari sirf... Or OBC ka benfit liya... Agriculture land 20 Acre se jyada hai usse jo income hui woh nahi include kari... Or woh ladka IIM Indore mai sirf 87 percentile mai chala gaya... Or uska chota Bhai bhi OBC ka reservation lekar NIT Bhopal se Chemical Engineering kiya... Aise logo ki bhi pehchaan hoke unka reservation khatam karna chahiye
3000 वर्षों तक सामान्य वर्ग ने देश के सभी संसाधनों पर 100% आरक्षण लिया जितने भी सरकारी जॉब थे उन पर 100% आरक्षण का लाभ दिया और आज भी SC ST ke sath jaati ke naam per bhedbhav Kiya Jata Hai
Sc ,st mein jiske perents government job mein hsi । Use to cremie layer mein ho । Par jo sc ,st ke parents rikshaw ya chota kaam karte hai । Reservation ki jada jarurat unhe hai । Bs
@@bpp827toh Jo purvajo ne kiya hoga uska bhugtaan kitne saal tk bharna pdega or? Kb tk bheek maang ke jeete rahoge ?? Uss hisab toh Aaj ke Britishers ko bhi ban krdena chahiye India after what they did in India. Creamy layer is important for fairness.
@@VinesS-no7ljshadi or jaati dono alag hai bhai jab brahman ka baccha baniya mai shadi nai kar sakta baniya ka baccha rajput mai shadi nai kar sakta ..obc sc mai shadi nahi kar sakta .. to ye shadi Or social justice ko ye gandi mansikta ke log mix ku karna chahte hai shame on u..... Ye hamare bhart ki sanskriti hai ... Jise budha ne bhi mana wo cast system ke against nai the unhone rashtriya ko brahman se shreshtha mana per cast system khatam karne ki baat nai ki ..... Samnta or shadi mai antar hai bahi per jahil to apne logic denge haina kuki padna unko nahi hai bas reservation dedo or kuch nai .... Sharm aani chahiye
SC ka faishla sahi hai but Justice Bela M.Triveri ka v point of view hmko sahi lga es pr v vichar hona chahiye tha...states pr sb kuch chhod dena sahi nhi h or states kis standards pr subcategory divide krti h use v review krna chahiye.. Thank u sir 🙏
EWS is already a sub category under general. Not any general can get the EWS reservation. For that they should have annual income of less than 8 LPA while at the same time there are restrictions on property also.
Everything thing is fine until they put government job as criteria. Because most of SC valmiki community got jobs in MCD in my area and my father was working in mcd since 25 years and still didn't got permanent letter. there salary is just 12500 as non permanent worker. Though we have government job but still not in much good condition. So, i hope government should consider this point👍🙏
Justice BR Gavai's statement is accurate and i agree with him. There are so many community who have already excelled and doing well economically and socially throughout generations, still they are getting reservations. One of example I know from my school in rajasthan, there Meena and Bydwal community which comes under SC category are top in politics,are IAS, doctors and engineers and they use this reservation which is totally undeserving. Thanks to justice Gawai for his stand for people who actually needs support.
Reservation must be on the Economic basis... Every Gender,Caste,Religion, etc. should be treated Equally w.r.t. constitution's firstmost Fundamental Right of Equality.
Koi v upper cast agar ye bol raha hai ki jisko milna chahiye usko nahi mil raha wo sabse bara wala dhurt hai..kyunki inko ye bardast hi nahi hota ki koi chhoti jaati ka aadmi saala hamare barabar me kaise baith ja raha hai ..or wo to reservation ko hi khatam kar dena chahta hai..isliye ye bolna ki hum to bhai support kar rahe hai faisle ko ye bakwaas hai...
Agar koi creamy layer wala apne hi samaj ke ati pichde waalon ko aage nahin badhne de raha, aur usko iss decision mein bhi burayi nazar aa raha,, matlab woh maha dhrut hai.... 🤔🤔🤔 Abe tujhse koi nahin chin raha category, phir bhi tujhe kis baat ka problem hai????? 🤔🤔🤔
@@vikashkr4285 sahi bola jaae toh tu maha dhrut hai.... Khud hi neta banke apne hi logon ko aage nahin badhne de raha.... 🤔🤔 Lekin kis reason ke liye yeh samajh ni aa raha???? 🤔🤔🤔 Chamar mochi naali saaf karne walaa agar padh likh lega toh tujhe kya problem hai???? 🤔🤔
आप मनूवादीयो एस एसी को कानूनी जामा पहनाया जावे और नौवीं सूचीबद्ध कर कानून बनाया जाये। जयभीम जय भारत आर एस राणा अलीगढ़ से बौद्धाचार्य ओल्ड वामसेफ कांशी राम।
Supreme Court must not make the law Only parliament should make the law. Sc st reservation should not be compared with the reservation of obc. Creamy layer is not applicable on sc/st reservation. While giving decision, the constitution is ignored by the judges of the Supreme Court.
S.T S C Catagory May Un Priwaron Ko Khaskr Nokri Mai Km Se Km Aik Priwar Member Ko Reservation Ka Pravdhan Krne Ki Sifarish Krna Bhut Hi Aavshayk Ta Haim.
But jese obc ke liye creamy lyear 8 hai, vese abhi sc kely kitna hai ? Jo creamy lyear honge ? Or justice bela M trivedi ka bhi stetment sahi he , kyonki dicision majority pan nhi hotti , ye koi election nhi he , Jo constitution me Diya he usse dicision hotta he,, tho sub state ye dicide kese karegi, precedent ko karna chahiye na.
Reservation khatam krne se jatigat bhedbhav khatam ho Jayega kya .......... Jab tak intercast marriage nhi start hogi tab tak log jatigat bhedbhav krte rahenge ......Hn ye sahi h ki kota me kota ho but ye rules jitne pakke dikh rhe h utne hi pakke rahne chahiye.....
Justice B.R. Gavai...👌 I'm appreciate and agree with him decision If someone no need of Reservation so that Reservation should be given of needy people....🙏🏻👍
We need representation. Not reservation.accoding to. Caste census do we need caste census. Yes who is taking our shares. It is divided and rule policy. We already 6243 division it sc. St. Obc minorities.
Kya soch hai teri... Waah 👏👏👏👏 Abe kisiki category thodi chini jaa rahi hai, bas Jo independence ke 70 years mein bhi ati pichde reh gaye unko samaj mein samil kiya jaa raha.... Galat kya hai ismein tu bata.... 🤔🤔🤔🤔
Indigenous Peoples land should be given back to them to plant 🪴 Food Crops for Sustainability immediately. Brahminvad came to our paradise ✨️ Fiji Islands ✨️ 🇫🇯 🚢 🏝 ♥️ and destroyed our Girmitya Ancestors hard Work and now we are Landless, Homeless and Nationless. Jay Bheem Namo Buddhaye, Jay SAMVIDHAN, Bandagi Saheb. Regards
12:44 Suprim court ne ye faisla aarthik aadhaar par hee diya hai ...jateegat aadhaar par nahee diya hai. Jabki JULM aur ATYACHAR to aaj bhee ho rahen hain......ye kab band honge ......? Inko bhee to suprim court ko dekhna chahiye ........? Kab tak SC. ST. OBC. k log sahate rahenge ....? Aakhir ye silsila kab tak chalta rahega...?
@@VinesS-no7lj evidence kaha ki dalito me Amir aur grib hone lage jab 8% population ke pass Bharat ka sara wealth 83% already hai remaining population ke pass kitna hoga bata aur job too private ho chuki hai 2005 se kitne dalit Amir hogye dikha evidence proof
@@MkRKG589 matlb man ko ek rviads ye chmar ka koi job reservation ke leta hai to ky wo upper caste ban jaega ky? 😂 Ar bhai rahega to wo lower caste hi chuchut aaj bhi practice hota hai but us level ka nahi jese 1960 70s mai hota tha but hota to hai ab jisne job liye ky uska ladka Brahmin ki ladki se shadi kar payega ky ? Nahi na tab to jaat dekho ge castism hota ha to Paisa ya ye dekh ke to nahi krte na ki isne reservation le liye to isko nahi jisne nahi kiya uske sath hoga corporate mai sc st ka jina hall ho jata hai kyuki waa jatiavd charm pe hi mere khud ke friends ke bahi ne 15 lakh ka nuakri chod di just because of caste discrimination mana ki dusre ko mauka milna chahiye but hata doge to kase chalega ab Brahmin to hai nahi na hi obc hai jo log humko bada equilty se treat karenge ek job ho jati hai log jalne lagte hai
@@FINDMYDEVICERAVIDAS tu jo device leke comment kar raha hai naa,, bahut ati pichde jaati hain aur naali mein ghush ke saaf kar reh hain unko yeh cellphone tak nasib nahi hai..... Tera baap toh tujhe cellphone dilaa diya, par woh insaan apne bete ko khana bhi nahi khilapata..... Swagat karna chahiye Supreme Court ke iss faisle ka.... 🙏🙏🙏 Isse kisiko bhi uske category se bahar nahi kiya jaa raha, Jo ati pichde hain unko bhi samaj mein unka hakk mile isi ka kaushis Kiya Gaya hai.... 🤔🤔🤔
sir that means the person who comes in creamy layer that is who earn more than 8 lakh will comes in general ? and for central govt jobs like upsc how will sub classification occurs or will they come in general
Cast system ko khatm karke economic aadhar par categories karna chaiye
Economic category me bahut saare loop hole h...jaise EWS me bahut se example bhare pde h...
@@DS-st9jk pahle too hindu granth ved puran se varna gotraa caste hatwaa
Good decision of dupream court
Justice BR gaval is 10000% right
Those who are in good situation they should not get the reservation.. instead give more to the people who r in need
That's not true....reservation economic based nhi...socially based h.......jb log SC/ST discrimination aaj b hota h...chahe wo creamy ho ya non creamy
To bhai phir ..seedha caste system hatao na
Phir jo garib hai unko do reservation!!!
Karna hi hai to jad ko to hatao which is caste system
@@GurdasGuruhaan toh bhai kisiko bahar thodi Kiya jaa raha hai reservation se!!!! Bas Jo ati pichde warg hain unko aage laane ki koshish ki jaa rahi hai SC dwara.... 🤔🤔
@@GurdasGuru to same rituals follow karne se society me equality ayega....job mein reservation se ni
@@marlborostag isko reservations km krna hi bolte h.....15% ko 7.5 m ho jayega....ho gya km is hisab se to..sir
Judgesaheban Ap Sahi Logonka Abhinandan Dilse Bahut Acha Nirnay Apne Liya Hai.
Shukriya sir aapne hum sabki baat ko dhyn me rkhke important topics in news ki alag video create krdi h 😊
Hii
@@Studywithsoulraj hi
@@khushiparveen1069 hiii
@@Studywithsoulraj hy
@@khushiparveen1069 telegram nhi chalati ho
Agar SC Jo kuchh bhi kar sakte he to , Jati baad ko khatam kare . Reservation ke pichhe kyu.... Jatibaad khatam hone se Reservation aapne aap khatam ho jayega
Sahi h pr ye right president ko hona chahiye state government ko nhi Esase inequality aayegi
@@b.kishorkumar1356 toh 2019 mein general waalo nay ro ro kar 10% EWS kyu liya tha ..tabh supreme court m yahi bolte ki caste system khatam kro..ji EWS liya woh reservation nahi hai kya
@@VishalTiger-jo4vk EWS is based on economic reason which is a valid reason . It has nothing to do with caste based reservations.
@@_KUHUSINGH sc st reservation is based on social discrimination.and untouchability..which is also a valid reason...and ek baat sun lo..and agar EWS reservation valid hai toh ..saba usko pvt sector m implement krna chaiya yaha par 97% employment hai na ki govt sector mein..is it logical to give EWS reservation in only 3% employment..aur aap desh ki gareebi dur kar rhay ho..govt sector m reservation dena ka objective bas itna hai ki sabki representation ho govt m..aap govt ki job apni gareebi dur krnay k liya krna chahti ho yaa desh ki sewa k liya..shame on you..aap jaisay log hai jo yeah soch laikr aatey hai aur corruption krtay ho fir
Old arakshan ho New arakshan note India gindabad jaibhim jaisavidhan
Superb justice B.R Gavai.
This decision is good but what about the loopholes used by the privilege section like Pooja khedekar, needy and marginalized section will not get what they deserve until unless these wealthy people will not stop using reservation anyhow.
Supreme court yeah bhi ensure kray ki EWS reservation mein koi bhi fraud na ho..bahot log ismay fraudulent way m benifits lay rhay hai
Haa or obc mai koi bhi reservation ko apne layak nahi hai kuki sabhi obc kabhi bhi socially supress nahi hai example Krishna yaduvanshi the or dwarka king to wo kaha se upekshit ho gaye
@@Studybpscanduppcs jaise hi baat OBC /SC/ST pe ati h turrat EWS Pe kood padte h reserve category wale piche 70 year se reservation le rahe h kuch nhi 5- 6 year ke EWS se kitna dard hota h inko
@@VishalTiger-jo4vk . I see many cases in present scenario
@@adichauhan4758 so many cases are there dear it is actually big consern
@@adichauhan4758
और सवर्ण जो पिछले 3000 सालों से 100% rservation ले रहे थे उसका क्या, क्या "जाति" नामक Virus दलित , पिछड़ों या आदिवासियों ने बनाई थी, "जाती नामक Virus" बनाने वाले भी तो सवर्ण हीं हैं, इन 70 सालों में Reservation से SC,ST की Literacy rate करीब 60% और OBC Literacy rate 70%+ हीं पहुंच पाई है,इसी में सवर्णों के पेट में दर्द होने लगी, सवर्णों को 16% होकर 51% seat मिल रहा है वो reservation नहीं है?
अब आप कहोगे हम ज्यादा अंक लाकर job प्राप्त करते हैं, और SC,ST वाले कम, इसका मूल कारण है,सवर्णों में Literacy rate 80%+ है,इसीलिए तो Quality balance के लिए 51% seats General है,और Quality support के लिए OBC Category भी हैं, रही बात SC और ST की तो जिस दिन इनकी आर्थिक और शैक्षणिक स्थिति General के 50-60% भी पहुंच गई,उस दिन आपकी ये तकलीफ भी खत्म हो जाएगी, example के लिए कुछ छोटे Gov. Jobs में ST का cutoff SC से ज्यादा या same होता है,जबकि ST और SC में करीब 10% का Literacy gap है , आजादी के 40 सालों तक तो Reservation से किसी को तकलीफ नहीं थी, तभी इतना जनसंख्या विस्फोट नहीं था जबकि तभी हिंदू के भी औसतन 4-6 बच्चे होते थे, जबकि आज 60% से ज्यादा हिंदू के 2-3 बच्चे हीं होते हैं, और आंकड़ों के मुताबिक पिछले 20 सालों में 50 लाख भारतीयों ने विदेशी नागरिकता स्वीकार कर ली,
फिर भी इतनी JOB Crisis क्यूं,
इसका मुख्य कारण है, politicians और इनके Votes Banks और Voting Game changer Bangladeshi और Rohingya Migrants
क्यूंकि सांसद में 60% से अधिक नेताओं criminal back ground होना , जिस देश में criminals कानून बनाते हों,तो आम जनता का भला कैसे होगा। और क्यूंकि भारत में 90% लोग जातिगत मानसिकता का शिकार हैं तो उन्हें politicians का दोष नहीं दिखता,
Same case Supreme Court के जजों के साथ भी है, क्योंकि Supreme Court में एक विशेष जाति का प्रभुत्व कायम है, इन्हें Collegium System नजर नहीं आता,
इनके पास तो सबकुछ पीढ़ी दर पीढ़ी से हीं है,धन ,दौलत,इज्जत, कानूनी ताकत , इनको तो जातीय भेदभाव, छुआ-छूत नहीं झेलना पड़ा,
फिर खुद क्यूं Reservation (Collegium System) का लाभ ले रहे हैं।
Historic decision made by Supreme Court of India.
Special thanks to Justice B. R. Gavai for their factual statement.
Kese ...tum kis jat ko h
Hindu hai@@barbiebebo8428
Great decision aur janch hokar certificate bnee taki vo farzi waada na ho sake
EWS reservations for general castes.... have lots of loopholes......
It's not reaching out to the right candidate...
Do it from here😅
@@Englishliterature1013 you are right my brother Ravi kumar sihag also product of this loop hole.
but it is given on basis of incomw...a OBC/SC/ST candidate can access EWS but not vice versa....also it is given to every religion
@@Paradox82827 sir, EWS is only for economically weaker sections,not for rich general classes, however it has been largely used by rich general class.
Here sc,st and OBC have been excluded from ews or
Those who belong to sc st or obs cannot be accessed this EWS.
EWS is only for general castes reservations
@@Englishliterature1013
Bro don't write anything without knowing....EWS can be accessed by anyone if he/she comes in criteria of EWS....but u can't access 2 reservation benefit simultaneously.
@@Paradox20194 what's wrong in it.....
Great Decision... OBC waalon ka bhi bhut jyada Rreservation de rakha... Mere college mai ek ladka tha... Uske maa baap ke paas kaafi pasie the... More than 20 Lac Per Annum Income... Likin Uske baap ne Naukari ki income show kari sirf... Or OBC ka benfit liya... Agriculture land 20 Acre se jyada hai usse jo income hui woh nahi include kari...
Or woh ladka IIM Indore mai sirf 87 percentile mai chala gaya... Or uska chota Bhai bhi OBC ka reservation lekar NIT Bhopal se Chemical Engineering kiya... Aise logo ki bhi pehchaan hoke unka reservation khatam karna chahiye
Pehle ye bata agriculture par income tax lagta hai?
क्या reservation मैं sub categorisation से जातिवाद कम हो जाएगा???
it should be no casteism, no reservation.
rt
Excellent judgment by b.R gavi sir
Ek sum justice full decisions 🎉
EWS ke Naam pe jo fraud ho rhi h us pe judges step kyo nhi lete
Case kar na court maii
Case karega tabhi to court me sunvai hogi
@@SanjuRajbhar-j4r courts are biased...So don't expect much from these collegium judges...
Jo Log Patra Hai Unko Jarur Reservation Milna Chahiye.
Thank you Judges
apsc disila bhai ??
Amazing video... Thank you sir❤😊
UP m obc ,sc ki scholarship rok kr EWS ko di ja rhi h
Great decision by BR Gavai sir
Very informative.... Thank you sir❤
Great decision by SC
❤ good decision by SC
3000 वर्षों तक सामान्य वर्ग ने देश के सभी संसाधनों पर 100% आरक्षण लिया जितने भी सरकारी जॉब थे उन पर 100% आरक्षण का लाभ दिया और आज भी SC ST ke sath jaati ke naam per bhedbhav Kiya Jata Hai
Sc ,st mein jiske perents government job mein hsi । Use to cremie layer mein ho । Par jo sc ,st ke parents rikshaw ya chota kaam karte hai । Reservation ki jada jarurat unhe hai । Bs
Govt job me hai to wo Swarn nahi ban jayegaa 😂😂.. hajaro sal se jativad kiya uska hisab to tumhari supreme court nahi degi..
Jo judge uche uche pdo pr baith kr apna fesla sunate h.....unko phle....vo kaam krna chaiye jo sc st ke log krte h.......fool judge h
@@Deepak06singh right 👍👍👍
Govt job mehnat se aata hai...sc st bolke padhei nahi karega to rickshawala nahi banega to kya bsnega
@@bpp827toh Jo purvajo ne kiya hoga uska bhugtaan kitne saal tk bharna pdega or? Kb tk bheek maang ke jeete rahoge ?? Uss hisab toh Aaj ke Britishers ko bhi ban krdena chahiye India after what they did in India. Creamy layer is important for fairness.
Justice B.R Gaval 💯💯
Justice br ko tnxs a lot m ye bat bahut din se soch rhi thi
Reservation खत्म तो जाति भी खत्म करो 💯💯
Jaati khatm ho gayi hai mai nhi maanta jaati ko tum v mat maano maine to dusre caste mai shadi ki tum v apni shadi kisi or caste mai kr lo caste khatm
Kya koi Patel ya brahamhan apni beti ki sadi karayega dalit k ladke k sath??@@VinesS-no7lj
Sadi ke baad Tera ladka hoga,,
Uski jati bhi wahi hogi ,jo teri jati hai
Esliye jati sadi krne ke baad bhi end nhi hogi
@@VinesS-no7ljIss bande ke kehne se Jati khatam ho gayi. Isse Nobel prize dedo koi. Modi ji ko batao. Bharat Ratna bhi dedo.
@@VinesS-no7ljshadi or jaati dono alag hai bhai jab brahman ka baccha baniya mai shadi nai kar sakta baniya ka baccha rajput mai shadi nai kar sakta ..obc sc mai shadi nahi kar sakta .. to ye shadi Or social justice ko ye gandi mansikta ke log mix ku karna chahte hai shame on u..... Ye hamare bhart ki sanskriti hai ... Jise budha ne bhi mana wo cast system ke against nai the unhone rashtriya ko brahman se shreshtha mana per cast system khatam karne ki baat nai ki ..... Samnta or shadi mai antar hai bahi per jahil to apne logic denge haina kuki padna unko nahi hai bas reservation dedo or kuch nai .... Sharm aani chahiye
Justice b.r gawai👏👏👏
SC ka faishla sahi hai but Justice Bela M.Triveri ka v point of view hmko sahi lga es pr v vichar hona chahiye tha...states pr sb kuch chhod dena sahi nhi h or states kis standards pr subcategory divide krti h use v review krna chahiye..
Thank u sir 🙏
Respect botton down 👇 for Justice Bela M.Trivedi🫡
👇❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
EWS m bhi subcategories ki jarurat h 👈
Well said
Meena ko sabse pahle htaao sc, st se mja aa jaayega😄
EWS is already a sub category under general. Not any general can get the EWS reservation. For that they should have annual income of less than 8 LPA while at the same time there are restrictions on property also.
Are pagl ensan phle s hi cateogries h general mujhe tho koi EWS nhi mila h
Ews ko hi hata do jb kuch nhi milta to..
Great decision ❤❤❤
10 लाख income वाले भी EWS आरक्षण खा रहे है 😂😅😂
I like it
Infact all Indians like it ❤
Especially aspirants
Everything thing is fine until they put government job as criteria. Because most of SC valmiki community got jobs in MCD in my area and my father was working in mcd since 25 years and still didn't got permanent letter. there salary is just 12500 as non permanent worker. Though we have government job but still not in much good condition.
So, i hope government should consider this point👍🙏
Great work...
Justice BR Gavai's statement is accurate and i agree with him. There are so many community who have already excelled and doing well economically and socially throughout generations, still they are getting reservations. One of example I know from my school in rajasthan, there Meena and Bydwal community which comes under SC category are top in politics,are IAS, doctors and engineers and they use this reservation which is totally undeserving. Thanks to justice Gawai for his stand for people who actually needs support.
Thank you sir
Reservation must be on the Economic basis... Every Gender,Caste,Religion, etc. should be treated Equally w.r.t. constitution's firstmost Fundamental Right of Equality.
Justice BR gaval is 100% ri8
so here government comparing poor sc/st with rich sc/st not all SCs with generals
Best decision 👏🎉❤
Good.news.for.special.s.c
Kab se implement hoga ye law...time frame?
Thank you🙏🙏
अब SC/ST सही गरीबो को आरक्षण का लाभ मिलेगा
Koi v upper cast agar ye bol raha hai ki jisko milna chahiye usko nahi mil raha wo sabse bara wala dhurt hai..kyunki inko ye bardast hi nahi hota ki koi chhoti jaati ka aadmi saala hamare barabar me kaise baith ja raha hai ..or wo to reservation ko hi khatam kar dena chahta hai..isliye ye bolna ki hum to bhai support kar rahe hai faisle ko ye bakwaas hai...
Tujhe kyu mirchi lag rahi ab or koi poor sc, st banega tum jaise uncha sc nhi
@@VinesS-no7ljja be EWS vala
Agar koi creamy layer wala apne hi samaj ke ati pichde waalon ko aage nahin badhne de raha, aur usko iss decision mein bhi burayi nazar aa raha,, matlab woh maha dhrut hai.... 🤔🤔🤔
Abe tujhse koi nahin chin raha category, phir bhi tujhe kis baat ka problem hai????? 🤔🤔🤔
@@vikashkr4285 sahi bola jaae toh tu maha dhrut hai.... Khud hi neta banke apne hi logon ko aage nahin badhne de raha.... 🤔🤔 Lekin kis reason ke liye yeh samajh ni aa raha???? 🤔🤔🤔
Chamar mochi naali saaf karne walaa agar padh likh lega toh tujhe kya problem hai???? 🤔🤔
Nice video explaining sir ji
आप मनूवादीयो एस एसी को कानूनी जामा पहनाया जावे और नौवीं सूचीबद्ध
कर कानून बनाया जाये। जयभीम जय भारत आर एस राणा अलीगढ़ से बौद्धाचार्य ओल्ड वामसेफ कांशी राम।
Thank gods, it's done🔥
I support this decision
Good decision❤
Correct decision
Supreme Court must not make the law
Only parliament should make the law.
Sc st reservation should not be compared with the reservation of obc.
Creamy layer is not applicable on sc/st reservation.
While giving decision, the constitution is ignored by the judges of the Supreme Court.
S.T S C Catagory May Un Priwaron Ko Khaskr Nokri Mai Km Se Km Aik Priwar Member Ko Reservation Ka Pravdhan Krne Ki Sifarish Krna Bhut Hi Aavshayk Ta Haim.
Jaise sc aur st me sub quota kr rhe waise hi general me bhi sub quota hona chahiye.
But jese obc ke liye creamy lyear 8 hai, vese abhi sc kely kitna hai ? Jo creamy lyear honge ?
Or justice bela M trivedi ka bhi stetment sahi he , kyonki dicision majority pan nhi hotti , ye koi election nhi he , Jo constitution me Diya he usse dicision hotta he,, tho sub state ye dicide kese karegi, precedent ko karna chahiye na.
Sc st के लिए 10 लाख तक होना चाइए
B R GAVAI is totally right his This should be done
Thank you so much sir ❤
Jai hind 🎉
Reservation khatam krne se jatigat bhedbhav khatam ho Jayega kya .......... Jab tak intercast marriage nhi start hogi tab tak log jatigat bhedbhav krte rahenge ......Hn ye sahi h ki kota me kota ho but ye rules jitne pakke dikh rhe h utne hi pakke rahne chahiye.....
Thanks you sir❤❤❤❤❤
Thank you so much sir 🥰🙏
I welcome this decision ❤❤❤
Justice B.R. Gavai...👌
I'm appreciate and agree with him decision If someone no need of Reservation so that Reservation should be given of needy people....🙏🏻👍
very good verdict. equity over equality
Bilkul sir ye decision pehle hi lena chahiye tha kyuki ab kafi SC st ki situation sudhar chuki aur unko milna chaiye jo vastav mai jrurtmand hain
Sudharne wale sc ke sath bhi Tum bhed bhav to karte hi ho.. aur ..kya tum jo amir dalit ban gaye ho uske ke sath marriage karoge..
👍@@bpp827
Great decision ❤
Aise hi hamara desh aage badhega
❤❤
Itn is a right ▶️👍🏽 decision
We need representation. Not reservation.accoding to. Caste census do we need caste census. Yes who is taking our shares. It is divided and rule policy. We already 6243 division it sc. St. Obc minorities.
Me SC hu and mera papa ka year ka Income 1.2L/PA hai to kuch to hoga hi nehi and..90%SC ka family income 8L/PA se kam hai
Reservation benefit is to be given only once in lifetime... Not to children of reservation beneficiaries
Divide and Rule Policy by Chalak Manuwadi judge
Quota wadi judge chahiye mandbuddhi?
Justice BR Gavai khud SC categories se hai. Aur unhone khud SC/ST mai creamy layer ko insert karne ka judgement diya hai😂
Koi dalit manuwadi nahi hosakta, koi Brahmin manavtawadi nahi hoskta kya? Wah re soch😂@@pkmkb7412
Kya soch hai teri... Waah 👏👏👏👏
Abe kisiki category thodi chini jaa rahi hai, bas Jo independence ke 70 years mein bhi ati pichde reh gaye unko samaj mein samil kiya jaa raha.... Galat kya hai ismein tu bata.... 🤔🤔🤔🤔
Sambidhan birodhi sochko hm jante hain woh hamesha dominant karna chahenge ,woh sabse jyada kyun khush ho rahen hain iss khel ko samjho
Good decision. No reservations to second generation SC, ST, OBC candidates.
Great decision
Sahi decision
Thankyou judges ❤
Exactly
*Thanku sir ❤️🥰*
Yeh bahut jaruri tha thank you so much ji🙏🙏
Indigenous Peoples land should be given back to them to plant 🪴 Food Crops for Sustainability immediately.
Brahminvad came to our paradise ✨️ Fiji Islands ✨️ 🇫🇯 🚢 🏝 ♥️ and destroyed our Girmitya Ancestors hard Work and now we are Landless, Homeless and Nationless. Jay Bheem Namo Buddhaye, Jay SAMVIDHAN, Bandagi Saheb. Regards
12:44 Suprim court ne ye faisla
aarthik aadhaar par hee diya hai ...jateegat aadhaar par nahee diya hai. Jabki JULM aur ATYACHAR to aaj bhee ho rahen hain......ye kab band honge ......? Inko bhee to suprim court ko dekhna chahiye ........? Kab tak SC. ST. OBC. k log sahate rahenge ....?
Aakhir ye silsila kab tak chalta rahega...?
Cut off alag alag hoga kya phir creamy and Non creamy students ka
Good decision 😊😊
We appreciate....
Rich SC/St also Faces Casteism 😢 !
Reach people never face anything they live happily 😂
Divide And Rule Policy by the Chalak Manuwadi
Nhi bhai ye hamlog jaise poor sc, st ke liye achha rahega
Manuwadi ke tax ke paiso pe palte hue sharam nhi aati . Jitne % awazi utna % tax . Jitna doge utna milega . 2% logo tax pe palte hai 98% nikamme
@@VinesS-no7lj evidence kaha ki dalito me Amir aur grib hone lage jab 8% population ke pass Bharat ka sara wealth 83% already hai remaining population ke pass kitna hoga bata aur job too private ho chuki hai 2005 se kitne dalit Amir hogye dikha evidence proof
Salute to bela dwibedi ,gavoi ji thinking as elite class can't understand the ground reality
Sub category pta h?
Spell correct his name.. Its gawai
@@FACTS_TIME_07
Jinhone reservation use kar powerful ban gaye... FIR se achhe conditione ke bad bhi fir use na kar sake...
Unka alag vibhajan
@@MkRKG589 matlb man ko ek rviads ye chmar ka koi job reservation ke leta hai to ky wo upper caste ban jaega ky? 😂 Ar bhai rahega to wo lower caste hi chuchut aaj bhi practice hota hai but us level ka nahi jese 1960 70s mai hota tha but hota to hai ab jisne job liye ky uska ladka Brahmin ki ladki se shadi kar payega ky ? Nahi na tab to jaat dekho ge castism hota ha to Paisa ya ye dekh ke to nahi krte na ki isne reservation le liye to isko nahi jisne nahi kiya uske sath hoga corporate mai sc st ka jina hall ho jata hai kyuki waa jatiavd charm pe hi mere khud ke friends ke bahi ne 15 lakh ka nuakri chod di just because of caste discrimination mana ki dusre ko mauka milna chahiye but hata doge to kase chalega ab Brahmin to hai nahi na hi obc hai jo log humko bada equilty se treat karenge ek job ho jati hai log jalne lagte hai
@@FINDMYDEVICERAVIDAS tu jo device leke comment kar raha hai naa,, bahut ati pichde jaati hain aur naali mein ghush ke saaf kar reh hain unko yeh cellphone tak nasib nahi hai.....
Tera baap toh tujhe cellphone dilaa diya, par woh insaan apne bete ko khana bhi nahi khilapata.....
Swagat karna chahiye Supreme Court ke iss faisle ka.... 🙏🙏🙏
Isse kisiko bhi uske category se bahar nahi kiya jaa raha, Jo ati pichde hain unko bhi samaj mein unka hakk mile isi ka kaushis Kiya Gaya hai.... 🤔🤔🤔
Goood decision....
Good decision
Main sub catogry ke paksh main hun lekin Sc st obc reservation ki seema ko 50 % ki limit se badhana chaiye aur ews main bhi sub catogry banai chaiye
Hn bhai 💯 kr dena chahiye yar .....
sir that means the person who comes in creamy layer that is who earn more than 8 lakh will comes in general ? and for central govt jobs like upsc how will sub classification occurs or will they come in general
Sir ese hi short video dalte raho❤
Supreme court ne ye sahi nhi kiya gya hy ese vapas len padega !
In my views reservation should only be given to person with disability of 40% rest all should be revoked...And merit should be applied in general..
👏👏👏👏👏👏 for sc judge 👍👍👍👍
Best decision is taken by super ime court...🙏ab ham general Kho justice milega...
Kese bhyii?
Bhai tum logo ki bhadaas nikli hai bas or khuch nahi hua hai
Reservation utna hi hai jitna pahle tha
Bas sc/st ko unke number ke adhar par usi fixed reservation mai idhar udhar kiya jayega
Samjhe bhai shab
Ews main bhi sub catogry ko banana chahiye
video ek aur bar acche dekho 😂😂
Best decision