Share and Subscribe the Next Free Lightsaber Could Be Yours! Support the Channel: www.patreon.com/ppsw Community Discord: discord.gg/RdBUUrKRJT Twitch Account: www.twitch.tv/pentepatrol Lightsaber Giveaway: docs.google.com/document/d/1C0Jb95iY_kWJ-iq_mNcLNFOJS8y0Hc_q_-looDcyIxw/edit
Dude, just finished watching this. Decided to listen while putting together the Darth Vader Meditation Chamber Lego set. The story telling, the immersion, the creativity. A solid 10/10 for Star Wars What If content, that’s what your channel is. Keep up the amazing work!
@@PentePatrolStarWars what if Anakin and Padme ran away together and left everything behind . what if Mace survived . what if Palpatine got killed before order 66 had been given by him . what if an Ewok was a Jedi master in the council . what if Threepio had power of the force . what if Solo never joined the rebellion . what if Luke killed Vader on Bespin . what if Leia was hidden on Tatooine and Luke was sent to Alderaan Duran . what if Chewbacca hid Luke and Liea on Cashack . what if Vader had been in The First Order new galactic Empire and faced against Kylo Ren . Death Star new looks . 🌐 🛑 🌓 🌝 🎱 🏀 ⚾️ 🎃 ⚽️ 🧿 🔮 🧶 🎯 🪀 💿 ☯️ ☢ 🟣 🧭 😆
@@jeremycool1731 he would likely be recruited Palpatine early in the clone wars and work under Dooku. Replacing Asajj role but successful in killing Dooku during the war. Possibly becoming Darth Vader earlier without being burned, so he would be stronger than canon because Anakin didn't replace most of his body with cybernetic.
Honestly, I don't see what the big deal is. Tusken Raiders are assholes who kill and rob people. Hell, they were shooting at racers in the pod race, just for fun! Slaughtering those assholes was a good thing to do.
The skywalker twins as little kids are so sweet and heartwarming! Kind of reminds me of the Solo twins from the Legends timeline, especially during The Crystal Star. Look up that publication if you haven’t already.
I have a strange idea for a what if. Suppose R2-D2 had stayed with Anikan/Vader after Mustafar? The little Droid could have had a profound effect on Vader over time. I see R2-D2 slowly making Vader's suit less cumbersome and painful. In tiny ways. subliminal ways, R2-D2 reminds Anikan that he's still there. It might even culminate in a moment where Palpatine decides, rightly the Droid is a good influence and destroys R2-D2. Or at least tries. Anikan stops him. Much to Palpatine's surprise Vader's suit is longer clunky or susceptible to force lightning. R2-D2 made the changes over years, one indecernable change after another. The Droid does have the patience of a Jedi master. He may be the only Droid in history to be force sensitive after all. Just saying it would explain alot. So Palpatine fails to kill Vader/Anikan or R2-D2. But being unable to kill Palpatine inreturn are forced to flee. At this point Vader/Anikan decides to destroy the unfinished death star. Supposedly it's so Vader can mess up Palpatine's plans before replacing him as the top sith. But R2-D2 knows Anikan is coming back. This time when Vader meets Leia he is not a clouded by the dark side and recognizes his daughter. Having not blown up Alderan and having blown up the death star, she is far more willing to listen. It ends with Anikan killing Palpatine of course. But how that exactly happens is always the fun part.
Ahsoka being a good mom to Luke and Leia makes 100% sense Also I love the use of time travel even though I know it was basically exactly why they rid of the World between Worlds so something like this wouldn't happen but Alt timelines are always the best
This was a masterpiece. I am a massive fan of Star Wars ElseWorlds version of What If Ashoka Trained Luke and Leia and can’t wait for his series to continue. So seeing you another incredible Star Wars what if TH-camr do his own take on it was equally awsome it feels like the good old days of Star Wars Theory himself back in 2016 and 2017 incredible job keep up the incredible work.
@@mattthesilent777RED Lol tbh it's something I heard someone say in my discord server and I threw it in because I thought it was funny -- I never watched else world's video
@@PentePatrolStarWars I love the fact that you made a full story for what if Ahsoka raised Luke and Leia because Star Wars Elseworld's still hasn't finished the story and your story of that Star Wars what if Ahsoka raised Luke and Leia intro and description is way better than Star Wars Elseworld's
That was amazing!! I loved every moment of Ahsoka raising the kids, to Shak Ti surviving and Obi-Wan coming back as uncle to the kids. I loved the bond between Luke and Leia and the power that they have. Glad to see Obi-Wan working with Rex, the bad Batch and all the others. Like the addition of Ezra. I liked the world between worlds saving Anakin and Padme and Satine. Thank you, so much for this tale
- What if the surviving Jedi joined the CIS? - What if Windu's strike team found Palpatine's secret hideout (storyline of Labyrinth of the Evil) before the CIS launched the attack on Coruscant? - What if the Jedi bodyguards saved Palpatine before Grievous took him?
I loved this story. So many twists and turns from Barris being an inquisitor to mace having round 2 with palatine, which was my favorite part. One of your best stories to date!
That was Outstanding . Yes , Ahsoka as the House Mother/Nanny would be ideal . The ONE and ONLY (non) Jedi with Pure White Light-sabres . The actual Incarnation of The Daughter . Nice to see Shaak-Ti as a Survivor too .
@@PentePatrolStarWars yo I joust finished and realized something padme would be 27 Vader 45 and Luke and liea are Like 22 so padme is now just 5 years older than her children
Incredible! This was so well written and told. It pulled me in, stirred my emotions, and kept me listening. It is the first of the "What Ifs" that I have listened to but now I want to hear them all!
This was absolutely brilliant to listen to. I loved every bit of it really. My fav part was that Shaak Ti was alive. Two of her deaths were deleted scenes, 1 from a game turned non canon, and 1 from a force vision which as stated in lore is never 100% accurate. I kinda wish Disney would pick up on that and use her especially with the whole "fOrCe Is FeMaLe" trope from KK. Also I do feel it was a bit too easy for Luke and Leia to turn Vader back to Anakin but I just love how it was done. Great job really I mean it.
50:25 I rebuke that for a few reasons 1: She's the one who raised them for the last 10/11 years 2: In those years she's the one who took primary care of them and loved them unconditionally 3: Out of everyone in the room, she's the one who volunteered to take both of them and raise them herself I love to say it, they her children Ani boy
I remember reading a fanfic like this. Sadly the sequel is stuck at the part that takes place during the 1st movie and the twins are prisoners of Jabba while trying to rescue Han. Along the way while the twins were young they kept finding young force users so they dropped them off on degooba so Yoda wound up taking care of more and more kids and Asoka finding more and more survivors bringing together a cobbled together new order with majority of the members being Luke and Leia's age, 1st kid was a red haired little girl. Asoka was aunt to them.
What if palpatine was not force sensitive and was just a good senator that plagius used and manipulated to cause the clone wars I think it would be interesting to see how it would shape things if he was used as a puppet what would his relationship be like with the Jedi, Anakin etc (kinda like how Lucas was originally going to use him in revenge of the south as a guy who was a mouth piece with now real power
@@wyattkinnaman54 His own take meaning version as he has done what if Anakin was trained by Mace which was on someone else's channel there is no upper limit to copying what ifs as there is coming up with ones. But yes you can copy other what ifs.
A few issues with the second half: the Night of a Thousand Tears came much later, as a direct consequence of the events of Rebels, i.e. after Bo-Katan got the Darksaber from Sabine. Also, you should really read the first Thrawn novel to get an idea of Lothal politics at this time.
I don't usually like fan alternate histories apart from a few Warhammer 40k and Star Trek ones. This was the best Star Wars inspired effort I've read in years, well done.
I would really love to hear more about the bond between Obi-Wan and Rex. Hearing about those two and the Bad Batch travel the galaxy together. That I believe would be a great story.
Just had a random thought, what if Darman Skirata (RC-1136) was with Etain Tur-Mukan (the Jedi general he had had a child with) when Order-66 happened and their bond over came the compulsion of the order and shorted his inhibitor chip so he helped her escape.
I know i already asked this, but what if Savage Opress was trained by Shaak Ti as a jedi O: ? Walking bulldozer with graceful and precise strikes >:) I think they'd have kind of a sister/brother relationship like obi-wan and anikan
Omg, another amazing story, i can't get enough of these. Everything is just so perfect. Everytime i listen to one of your beautifully written stories, i get so much inspiration to write my own, or draw little sketchs about these characters. Keep it going, we love these
This was your best so far man! Getting really good at worldbuilding and immersion! Amazing story and bringing lore from Rebels into it! Keep it up, can't wait for the next one
@@fallenicexofficial I'm not sure cause I don't remember, but if it's the eighth sister, I made the position up so that I could slide Barris into the Inquisitiorius
I just love the Vidoe. It is soo good and emotionally balanced. And I would really watch a 4-hour video of a depth version of this video/movie. Also bringing Satine back was a good move. It brings a lot of Uniqueness to this story. Since it helps Obi-Wan get balance in his life. And the same with Padme. Giving Anakin what he needed the most and his main objective in his life. Also, Ahsoka is such a key part of most stories related to Anakin. Also having Shaak Ti there made a difference too since she is a mother figure. R2D2 is making such a difference too in the story since the droid would be very protective of the twins. Windu would take any chance to kill Darth Sidious. That's a really nice touch you did. Currently, my two favorite videos you made are this one and "What if Shaak Ti Trained Anakin Skywalker". That you Made. Great Video PPSW. ❤❤
Wow, that's was good. This is a quite an "happy ending" but I really like it. I have watch a lot of what if about star wars and that's one of the best i saw 👏
Sir you have outdone yourself You have outdone yourself this was amazing this was amazing better than any Star wars movie I ever seen I love how you brought the main character of Star wars rebels into the story I love it I love it so much and I wish this was a Canon event dude even though you will probably make something like this again one day that will never be able to top this story thank you for your time and I have spoken
Honestly, I love this idea far more than what Disney gave us with the Sequel Trilogy. I concur that Luke & Leia mentioning that they could save Padme was the crucial turning point of Vader coming back to the Light, as that desire was the determining factor to his fall. Bringing together all the members from the shows was an amazing idea as well, as it incorporates some of the new lore into the story, which is a great concept.
MAGNIFICENT storey telling. Reminiscent of the days of Radio when families would gather around in multiple generations to listen and be regaled! Thank you greatly. I am a 1966 area Trekkie and this was utterly enjoyable!
@@PentePatrolStarWars hey your welcome. You got a follow from me. Hope to see more content from ya. Oh also. Dont be affraid to innovate. Voice actors, a sound track trust me. The production could be an investment
Holy sh* this was fantastic, all I've done for the last 2 hours is sit here and stare at images going by while listening to your amazing, creative and immersive story telling. I'm not one to leave comments on youtube videos, but this was fantastic. Amazing work bro!
Pente Patrol Star Wars I would love to see: _What if Queen Padme had rewarded the Young Hero Of The Battle of Naboo:_ by sending representatives to Tatooine and buying his mother Shmee's freedom. Perhaps offering her a choice of occupation and a small estate to live in. Then he would not have the worry about his mother while training as a Jedi.
10 out of fucking 10 my dude, but one thing is, you stutter a lot (or maybe its for the effect) as if your nervous, but, you have nothing to worry about, speak with confidence, you have all these people rallying with you. You are an excellent writer and I cant wait for your next one on ROTJ
Thank you so much! And yes usually if it's in I either missed it (which in a 2 hour video happens XDD or it's intentional.. like a very blunt 2-4 second pause in the middle of the sentence)
I found this story to be very interesting, it was a bit jarring when the manipulation of time and space happened via the world between worlds, but then again I haven't seen much of The Clone Wars and Rebels so I'm not sure how it works, I just know it and the ones exist. I do hope that this gets a continuation pulling from Legends post-RotJ content (prior to the time skip all the way to when Cade is around that is).
What if the vong attacked during the clone wars? What if Anakin and Padme only had Luke? What if the Jedi weren’t based on corusant and stayed at their other temples like tythion etc (more spread out)? What if palpatine framed the sith as a religion that he believed in and was open when he was chancellor, as it’s not illegal to be a sith and most just think the force is a religion? What if thrawn remained with the chiss and formed a coalition of others in the unknown region to fight the vong (kinda like the empire of the hand)?
Just finished watching this what if was my all-time favorite of all the hundreds that I watched please do more and hopefully other people will follow your lead 10 15 30 minutes just isn't enough to tell the story right
Awesome work! I wish this story would somehow become the actual way the story develops, but I doubt the 'powers that be' over Star Wars would ever accept a great idea like this.
If I were to choose someone in the Star Wars universe to marry, my choice would probably be Ahsoka. The main reason being that I now know what a wonderful mother she would be.
I know you said it would be too long for a video but I would love to see the hypothetical 3 hour version of the story, and many other stories you have done
I love the pair of Ashoka and Shakti! And the idea of bringing people back to life with the portal between worlds and love seeing Obi wan and Santine as well!
Such a incredible piece of art that is this story! I got chills and shed some tears. Thank you for sharing this story with us and I truly believe that this is the greatest story ever. I do noticed that sometime you don’t handle criticism greatly but hey you’re doing and amazing job thank you again and please keep up the way you do your channel.
What if Ahsoka Tano and Lux Bonteri became a couple and stood together? I wanna see that one, please. This is for PentePatrolStarWars, the creator of these videos.
Your script writer does such a great job truly amazing. The announcer and editor could use some serious work tho. The writer is really being held back.
What if leia organa solo completed her jedi training and became a jedi knight. Then helped grandmaster luke skywalker to train future jedi. Ben solo, luke skywalker and leia organa solo in the same room. No way she doesn't put her hand on top of luke's to stop him from doing something stupid. What next. Do luke and leia discover sith mental manipulation, snoke and the survival of palpatine. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.
Ive heard 3 different mommy ahsoka fictions and this one is the best. While happy endings are not always good for movies, this story was fun and enjoyable. Thank you.
This is the single greatest What If I've ever seen/heard. Truly and dearly love it! Keep going and soon you'll work for Lucasfilm. Then we all will finally be happy ever after.
What if earth was in the Star Wars universe What if anakin was a foundling of the true mandalorians What if Luke became a foundling What if anakin was revans reincarnation or descendent What if shmi was a former Jedi either exiled or left the order
I like 2 hour stories or however long they are because after all these are such great stories . wish I could have my own lightsaber it would be so cool .
Awesome! I loved the heart warming family life Ahsoka got to have & her joyful reunion with Shakti. At some point, I anticipated more involvement with the Ghost squad. But that’s a whole B plot, and you probably wanted to stay on track. Then you brought Satine back to life; I started anticipating Bo-Katan reaching out for help with reuniting the Mandalorians. But that’s a C plot! lol Loved this story! Stay awesome dude! P.s. What happened to the sound effects & voice acting? Not enough interest from other listeners? Budget/effort constraints?
Share and Subscribe the Next Free Lightsaber Could Be Yours!
Support the Channel: www.patreon.com/ppsw
Community Discord: discord.gg/RdBUUrKRJT
Twitch Account: www.twitch.tv/pentepatrol
Lightsaber Giveaway: docs.google.com/document/d/1C0Jb95iY_kWJ-iq_mNcLNFOJS8y0Hc_q_-looDcyIxw/edit
What if anakin fell in love with duchess satin
What if anakin fell In love Barris offee
What if anakin fell in love with ahsoka tano
What if adi Gallia trained anakin
What if anakin fell in love with master luminara or was trained by her
Dude, just finished watching this. Decided to listen while putting together the Darth Vader Meditation Chamber Lego set. The story telling, the immersion, the creativity. A solid 10/10 for Star Wars What If content, that’s what your channel is. Keep up the amazing work!
Awesome! Thank you so much!
@@PentePatrolStarWars Hey, so for the next video, are you going to do a what if Bly and Aayla feel in love? Please make that happen
@@PentePatrolStarWars
what if Anakin and Padme ran away together and left everything behind .
what if Mace survived .
what if Palpatine got killed before order 66 had been given by him .
what if an Ewok was a Jedi master in the council .
what if Threepio
had power of the force .
what if Solo never joined
the rebellion .
what if Luke
killed Vader on Bespin .
what if Leia was hidden on Tatooine and Luke was sent to Alderaan Duran .
what if Chewbacca hid Luke and Liea on Cashack .
what if Vader had been in The First Order new galactic Empire and faced against Kylo Ren .
Death Star new looks .
🌐 🛑 🌓 🌝 🎱
🏀 ⚾️ 🎃 ⚽️ 🧿
🔮 🧶 🎯 🪀 💿
☯️ ☢ 🟣 🧭
😆
@@patrickwentzell4638l,,
What if Padme told the Jedi Council that Anakin killed the Tuskin Raiders.
Than anakin would have been expelled from the order and lost all love he had for padme I think
@@jeremycool1731 he would likely be recruited Palpatine early in the clone wars and work under Dooku. Replacing Asajj role but successful in killing Dooku during the war. Possibly becoming Darth Vader earlier without being burned, so he would be stronger than canon because Anakin didn't replace most of his body with cybernetic.
@cool dude Yoda's just a bro like that.
virgin windu: just stand back and let me kill this man
Chad Yoda: Understand your feelings i do, perhaps in order alternate solutions are
Honestly, I don't see what the big deal is. Tusken Raiders are assholes who kill and rob people. Hell, they were shooting at racers in the pod race, just for fun! Slaughtering those assholes was a good thing to do.
The skywalker twins as little kids are so sweet and heartwarming! Kind of reminds me of the Solo twins from the Legends timeline, especially during The Crystal Star. Look up that publication if you haven’t already.
it does and that is the one story of legends i refuse to let go of i hate the newer movies just for getting rid of the solo kids
Agreed
I have a strange idea for a what if. Suppose R2-D2 had stayed with Anikan/Vader after Mustafar? The little Droid could have had a profound effect on Vader over time. I see R2-D2 slowly making Vader's suit less cumbersome and painful. In tiny ways. subliminal ways, R2-D2 reminds Anikan that he's still there. It might even culminate in a moment where Palpatine decides, rightly the Droid is a good influence and destroys R2-D2. Or at least tries. Anikan stops him. Much to Palpatine's surprise Vader's suit is longer clunky or susceptible to force lightning. R2-D2 made the changes over years, one indecernable change after another. The Droid does have the patience of a Jedi master. He may be the only Droid in history to be force sensitive after all. Just saying it would explain alot.
So Palpatine fails to kill Vader/Anikan or R2-D2. But being unable to kill Palpatine inreturn are forced to flee.
At this point Vader/Anikan decides to destroy the unfinished death star. Supposedly it's so Vader can mess up Palpatine's plans before replacing him as the top sith. But R2-D2 knows Anikan is coming back.
This time when Vader meets Leia he is not a clouded by the dark side and recognizes his daughter. Having not blown up Alderan and having blown up the death star, she is far more willing to listen.
It ends with Anikan killing Palpatine of course. But how that exactly happens is always the fun part.
this is great I wonder how vader/anakin kills Palpatine it would be a very cool what if scenario
Great idea, but don't make him force sensitive. The bond he shared with Anakin gave him the patience to save him.
Master r2 d2
Ahsoka being a good mom to Luke and Leia makes 100% sense
Also I love the use of time travel even though I know it was basically exactly why they rid of the World between Worlds so something like this wouldn't happen but Alt timelines are always the best
As you likely know, theh Brought Back the "World Between Worlds" in the Ahsoka Show for the Exact Reasons it was previously Removed from the Canon.
This was a masterpiece.
I am a massive fan of Star Wars ElseWorlds version of What If Ashoka Trained Luke and Leia and can’t wait for his series to continue. So seeing you another incredible Star Wars what if TH-camr do his own take on it was equally awsome it feels like the good old days of Star Wars Theory himself back in 2016 and 2017 incredible job keep up the incredible work.
Thank you so much!
@@PentePatrolStarWars Yeah, Star Wars Elseworlds came up with the name "Momma 'Soka"
@@mattthesilent777RED Lol tbh it's something I heard someone say in my discord server and I threw it in because I thought it was funny -- I never watched else world's video
@@PentePatrolStarWars I love the fact that you made a full story for what if Ahsoka raised Luke and Leia because Star Wars Elseworld's still hasn't finished the story and your story of that Star Wars what if Ahsoka raised Luke and Leia intro and description is way better than Star Wars Elseworld's
@@PentePatrolStarWars Lol. I watched it. It took 1 year to finish. This was way better.
That was amazing!! I loved every moment of Ahsoka raising the kids, to Shak Ti surviving and Obi-Wan coming back as uncle to the kids. I loved the bond between Luke and Leia and the power that they have. Glad to see Obi-Wan working with Rex, the bad Batch and all the others. Like the addition of Ezra. I liked the world between worlds saving Anakin and Padme and Satine. Thank you, so much for this tale
Thank you so much!!
SPOILERSSSSSSS
- What if the surviving Jedi joined the CIS?
- What if Windu's strike team found Palpatine's secret hideout (storyline of Labyrinth of the Evil) before the CIS launched the attack on Coruscant?
- What if the Jedi bodyguards saved Palpatine before Grievous took him?
What if Grievous killed Obi Wan?
What if Palpatine killed Windu before Anakin arrived?
What if Dooku killed Kenobi in Episode II?
That was a good one!
I have suggested this before: What if Anakin simply didn't buy Palpitine's lies?
Anakin was like "Hey yo I never said anything about my wife, OH YOU GAVE ME THOSE DREAMS, Ya master windu arrest this man" XD
Good, he would have been
Still, have ketamine addiction I have
@@KetamineUser69the cause of your speech patter, is ketamine?
@@Happysecret180 moved on from that, I have
Invented new shits called ketamphetamine with master Window, I have
I loved this story. So many twists and turns from Barris being an inquisitor to mace having round 2 with palatine, which was my favorite part. One of your best stories to date!
Palatine
That was Outstanding . Yes , Ahsoka as the House Mother/Nanny would be ideal . The ONE and ONLY (non) Jedi with Pure White Light-sabres .
The actual Incarnation of The Daughter . Nice to see Shaak-Ti as a Survivor too .
Thank you so much!
@@PentePatrolStarWars Now delete her death and rewrite it 6 times :)
i honestly think thats not a theory anymore....its just a hard fact she is
I gotta say, this was one of if not my absolute favorite story you've written so far, this was INCREDIBLE, great job dude!
I would do ANYTHING to see this as an actual film
Thank you so much!
@@PentePatrolStarWars hey, so are you going to do a what if Bly and Aayla feel in love?
@@PentePatrolStarWars yo I joust finished and realized something padme would be 27 Vader 45 and Luke and liea are Like 22 so padme is now just 5 years older than her children
@@bobafett5399 HAHA
Love this story, feels official and like I’m listening to a audiobook. Feels like Star Wars and I love it when Anakin reaches his full True potential.
Thank you so much!
I would love it if you would eventually find the time to do a What if Anakin had a twin brother
Just like how George Lucas originally wanted Boba Fett to be his younger brother.
Or sister
Incredible! This was so well written and told. It pulled me in, stirred my emotions, and kept me listening. It is the first of the "What Ifs" that I have listened to but now I want to hear them all!
Thank you so much!
This was absolutely brilliant to listen to. I loved every bit of it really. My fav part was that Shaak Ti was alive. Two of her deaths were deleted scenes, 1 from a game turned non canon, and 1 from a force vision which as stated in lore is never 100% accurate. I kinda wish Disney would pick up on that and use her especially with the whole "fOrCe Is FeMaLe" trope from KK. Also I do feel it was a bit too easy for Luke and Leia to turn Vader back to Anakin but I just love how it was done. Great job really I mean it.
Thank you so much!
50:25
I rebuke that for a few reasons
1: She's the one who raised them for the last 10/11 years
2: In those years she's the one who took primary care of them and loved them unconditionally
3: Out of everyone in the room, she's the one who volunteered to take both of them and raise them herself
I love to say it, they her children Ani boy
F, we must reply to Anakin
*NOW GIVE ME MY KETAMINE YOU SON OF A BI-*
Really, hate fills your heart just as it filled anakin
@@GamePlays_1230 How?
I remember reading a fanfic like this. Sadly the sequel is stuck at the part that takes place during the 1st movie and the twins are prisoners of Jabba while trying to rescue Han.
Along the way while the twins were young they kept finding young force users so they dropped them off on degooba so Yoda wound up taking care of more and more kids and Asoka finding more and more survivors bringing together a cobbled together new order with majority of the members being Luke and Leia's age, 1st kid was a red haired little girl.
Asoka was aunt to them.
What if palpatine was not force sensitive and was just a good senator that plagius used and manipulated to cause the clone wars I think it would be interesting to see how it would shape things if he was used as a puppet what would his relationship be like with the Jedi, Anakin etc (kinda like how Lucas was originally going to use him in revenge of the south as a guy who was a mouth piece with now real power
@@Ono-Lin_Tam that’s a theory on someone else’s channel
@@wyattkinnaman54 His own take meaning version as he has done what if Anakin was trained by Mace which was on someone else's channel there is no upper limit to copying what ifs as there is coming up with ones. But yes you can copy other what ifs.
Revenge of the South???
"This food has a lot of flavor in it. Is it possible to learn how to cook like this? "
"Not from a jedi!"
@@Ono-Lin_Tam what if Adrian I am guessing?
This is the best Star Wars What If? I’ve ever heard. Phenomenal work Pente!
Thank you so much!
A few issues with the second half: the Night of a Thousand Tears came much later, as a direct consequence of the events of Rebels, i.e. after Bo-Katan got the Darksaber from Sabine.
Also, you should really read the first Thrawn novel to get an idea of Lothal politics at this time.
I don't usually like fan alternate histories apart from a few Warhammer 40k and Star Trek ones. This was the best Star Wars inspired effort I've read in years, well done.
Thank you so much!
I would really love to hear more about the bond between Obi-Wan and Rex. Hearing about those two and the Bad Batch travel the galaxy together. That I believe would be a great story.
Just had a random thought, what if Darman Skirata (RC-1136) was with Etain Tur-Mukan (the Jedi general he had had a child with) when Order-66 happened and their bond over came the compulsion of the order and shorted his inhibitor chip so he helped her escape.
I know i already asked this, but what if Savage Opress was trained by Shaak Ti as a jedi O: ? Walking bulldozer with graceful and precise strikes >:) I think they'd have kind of a sister/brother relationship like obi-wan and anikan
Omg, another amazing story, i can't get enough of these. Everything is just so perfect. Everytime i listen to one of your beautifully written stories, i get so much inspiration to write my own, or draw little sketchs about these characters. Keep it going, we love these
This was your best so far man! Getting really good at worldbuilding and immersion! Amazing story and bringing lore from Rebels into it! Keep it up, can't wait for the next one
Thank you so much!
@@PentePatrolStarWars did you mean the 8th brother? Btw I like that you take your time and make long, addicting what if’s
@@fallenicexofficial I'm not sure cause I don't remember, but if it's the eighth sister, I made the position up so that I could slide Barris into the Inquisitiorius
@@PentePatrolStarWars there is a possibility I believe that she is the 7th sister
She wasn’t seen after order 66
This was so good! Definitely your best scenario to date.
Thank you so much!
This should be made as a movie. Good job writing this.
Thank you so much!
I think this is the best one yet! It didn't even feel like two hours listening to this
What if Luminara Unduli trained Galen Marek?
She could've been taking refuge with Galen's parents on Kashyyyk when the Empire invaded
I just love the Vidoe. It is soo good and emotionally balanced. And I would really watch a 4-hour video of a depth version of this video/movie. Also bringing Satine back was a good move. It brings a lot of Uniqueness to this story. Since it helps Obi-Wan get balance in his life. And the same with Padme. Giving Anakin what he needed the most and his main objective in his life. Also, Ahsoka is such a key part of most stories related to Anakin. Also having Shaak Ti there made a difference too since she is a mother figure.
R2D2 is making such a difference too in the story since the droid would be very protective of the twins. Windu would take any chance to kill Darth Sidious. That's a really nice touch you did. Currently, my two favorite videos you made are this one and "What if Shaak Ti Trained Anakin Skywalker". That you Made. Great Video PPSW. ❤❤
Thank you so much!!
Wow, that's was good. This is a quite an "happy ending" but I really like it. I have watch a lot of what if about star wars and that's one of the best i saw 👏
Thank you so much!
This was my favourite starwars fanfic ever. Thank you, I'll be revisiting this
Thank you so much!
Sir you have outdone yourself You have outdone yourself this was amazing this was amazing better than any Star wars movie I ever seen I love how you brought the main character of Star wars rebels into the story I love it I love it so much and I wish this was a Canon event dude even though you will probably make something like this again one day that will never be able to top this story thank you for your time and I have spoken
Thank you so much!!
@@PentePatrolStarWars no thank you for sharing this amazing story with me
@@technokingshadow6323
@@PentePatrolStarWars Aww thanks man
Even a month later I rewatch this and this is usually my favorite fanfic and all the other ones are great keep up the good work
What a absolute haymaker into my emotions! My goodness, absolutely incredible! Nothing but praise 👏 🙌 🙏
Honestly, I love this idea far more than what Disney gave us with the Sequel Trilogy.
I concur that Luke & Leia mentioning that they could save Padme was the crucial turning point of Vader coming back to the Light, as that desire was the determining factor to his fall.
Bringing together all the members from the shows was an amazing idea as well, as it incorporates some of the new lore into the story, which is a great concept.
MAGNIFICENT
storey telling.
Reminiscent of the days of Radio when families would gather around in multiple generations to listen and be regaled!
Thank you greatly.
I am a 1966 area Trekkie and this was utterly enjoyable!
Thank you so much! I'm glad you enjoyed!
I like to think R2 would show recordings of battles to the kids when Ahsoka wasn’t watching
What if the Jedi temple hadn’t been built on top of the Sith temple
But, the jedi temple is on top of a sith temple.
@@alphacenturi5117 read it again
@@vavman4242 Just did, I am a fool. I have been bamboozled.
@@alphacenturi5117 lol its all good
that would be tython or Ossus
This, this was amazing. This is how things should have happened, so heartwarming.
Thank you so much!
Awesome what if man. Definitely worth the 2 hours and one of my now favorites
Thank you so much!
Fantastic job! Really excited to see where this channel goes!
Thank you so much!
Love this story bro. I love how the charecters developed and how you utilized all the charecters and plot details.
Thank you so much!
@@PentePatrolStarWars hey your welcome. You got a follow from me. Hope to see more content from ya.
Oh also. Dont be affraid to innovate. Voice actors, a sound track trust me. The production could be an investment
Holy sh* this was fantastic, all I've done for the last 2 hours is sit here and stare at images going by while listening to your amazing, creative and immersive story telling. I'm not one to leave comments on youtube videos, but this was fantastic. Amazing work bro!
Thank you so much!
Wow! This was epic! Well done. Definitely one of my favorites. A very satisfying ending!
Pente Patrol Star Wars I would love to see: _What if Queen Padme had rewarded the Young Hero Of The Battle of Naboo:_ by sending representatives to Tatooine and buying his mother Shmee's freedom. Perhaps offering her a choice of occupation and a small estate to live in. Then he would not have the worry about his mother while training as a Jedi.
10 out of fucking 10 my dude, but one thing is, you stutter a lot (or maybe its for the effect) as if your nervous, but, you have nothing to worry about, speak with confidence, you have all these people rallying with you. You are an excellent writer and I cant wait for your next one on ROTJ
Thank you so much! And yes usually if it's in I either missed it (which in a 2 hour video happens XDD or it's intentional.. like a very blunt 2-4 second pause in the middle of the sentence)
What if, instead of killing ALL the Tusken Raiders, Anakin only killed the men, letting the women and children live?!?
This was so damn good. Such a great and masterful piece of storytelling well done sir!
Thank you so much!
I absolutely love how after 2 hours snoke only gets about 3 seconds.
I found this story to be very interesting, it was a bit jarring when the manipulation of time and space happened via the world between worlds, but then again I haven't seen much of The Clone Wars and Rebels so I'm not sure how it works, I just know it and the ones exist. I do hope that this gets a continuation pulling from Legends post-RotJ content (prior to the time skip all the way to when Cade is around that is).
Honestly lore wise and timeline-wise this would have been interesting to see. Definitely an interesting story.
What if the vong attacked during the clone wars?
What if Anakin and Padme only had Luke?
What if the Jedi weren’t based on corusant and stayed at their other temples like tythion etc (more spread out)?
What if palpatine framed the sith as a religion that he believed in and was open when he was chancellor, as it’s not illegal to be a sith and most just think the force is a religion?
What if thrawn remained with the chiss and formed a coalition of others in the unknown region to fight the vong (kinda like the empire of the hand)?
Love the "What if" stories. Very creative story telling.
I love how your videos are usually positive 😌
Just finished watching this what if was my all-time favorite of all the hundreds that I watched please do more and hopefully other people will follow your lead 10 15 30 minutes just isn't enough to tell the story right
This was awesome! I would love for Disney to do a what if for star wars as they did for the MCU and turn this into a full movie/series.
I love these long videos. Amazing. They’re basically movies. Thank you!
Thank you so much!
Awesome work! I wish this story would somehow become the actual way the story develops, but I doubt the 'powers that be' over Star Wars would ever accept a great idea like this.
Thank you so much!
If I were to choose someone in the Star Wars universe to marry, my choice would probably be Ahsoka. The main reason being that I now know what a wonderful mother she would be.
Ahoska is my childhood crush
What if Luke helps Sabine and Ahsoka find Ezra and Ahsoka shows Sabine and Luke the world between worlds?
What if ahsoka was trained by count dooku.
This is so much better then what disney is doning! Thanks for the wonderfull story
What if Padme was an sith lord
Darth amidala
For this incredible and magnificent story someone should make a film
Outstanding storytelling!
Thank you!
I know you said it would be too long for a video but I would love to see the hypothetical 3 hour version of the story, and many other stories you have done
this was amazingly! this feels like a totally natural ending.
Why can I perfectly see Ahsoka being someone who can be a motherly figure to children?
Awesome!! I love to see the Star Wars universe through very creative eyes. The universe is big enough for all the creative minds out there.
I love the implication that if Ahsoka was there and had raised Luke and Leia everything would just turn out fine and the world would beat piece
Shaak Ti hiding out on Felucia, nice Classic Expanded Universe reference there.
I love the pair of Ashoka and Shakti! And the idea of bringing people back to life with the portal between worlds and love seeing Obi wan and Santine as well!
Love it. Even if Shaak Ti had died during Order 66.
Glad she's alive here...
“He loves them with all of his circuit board”
U know what that was too cute 🥰
Such a incredible piece of art that is this story! I got chills and shed some tears. Thank you for sharing this story with us and I truly believe that this is the greatest story ever. I do noticed that sometime you don’t handle criticism greatly but hey you’re doing and amazing job thank you again and please keep up the way you do your channel.
This best story of year 10/10 keep up the work 💪🏻
Thank you so much!!
What if Ahsoka Tano and Lux Bonteri became a couple and stood together? I wanna see that one, please. This is for PentePatrolStarWars, the creator of these videos.
Your script writer does such a great job truly amazing. The announcer and editor could use some serious work tho. The writer is really being held back.
You need to get this made into a movie this was a great story
Thank you so much!
Awesome brother! Enjoyed it very much. Keep on going on. Imagination is everything!
What if leia organa solo completed her jedi training and became a jedi knight. Then helped grandmaster luke skywalker to train future jedi. Ben solo, luke skywalker and leia organa solo in the same room. No way she doesn't put her hand on top of luke's to stop him from doing something stupid. What next. Do luke and leia discover sith mental manipulation, snoke and the survival of palpatine. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.
Shaak ti who died in 4 different ways is somehow alive 😂😂
Ive heard 3 different mommy ahsoka fictions and this one is the best. While happy endings are not always good for movies, this story was fun and enjoyable. Thank you.
This is my favorite so far!
What if Darth Vader//Anakin came back when Ahsoka meet him in Rebels.
Thank you so much!
Basically suggesting what if Vader joined the rebellion and I am 100% down for that
I absolutely loved this what if!!
This is the single greatest What If I've ever seen/heard. Truly and dearly love it!
Keep going and soon you'll work for Lucasfilm. Then we all will finally be happy ever after.
Thank you so much!
“R2D2 loved them with all his circuit boards” laughed at this a bit too loud
Momma Snips is so beautiful and cute. Just imagine Ahsoka protecting her little kins.
I was seeing every scene while listening to this. Just amazing.
I like how Leia and Ahsoka look so majestic and elegant but Like looks genuinely concerned for his life lol 😆
Cause the poor boy is outnumbered by bad ass females to keep his "Anakin tendencies " in line lol
What if earth was in the Star Wars universe
What if anakin was a foundling of the true mandalorians
What if Luke became a foundling
What if anakin was revans reincarnation or descendent
What if shmi was a former Jedi either exiled or left the order
Aunty Ahsoka gone straight into Mommy mode right there in this story I like it 🔥
It's a good sign when you start writing and you can't stop. It means there's more story to be told and it's so natural that you never hit a wall
This is so factual!!
@@PentePatrolStarWars plus it usually is less forced because you don't have to come up with as much bs to make more plot
I like 2 hour stories or however long they are because after all these are such great stories .
wish I could have my own lightsaber it would be so cool .
Awesome!
I loved the heart warming family life Ahsoka got to have & her joyful reunion with Shakti.
At some point, I anticipated more involvement with the Ghost squad. But that’s a whole B plot, and you probably wanted to stay on track.
Then you brought Satine back to life; I started anticipating Bo-Katan reaching out for help with reuniting the Mandalorians. But that’s a C plot! lol
Loved this story! Stay awesome dude!
P.s. What happened to the sound effects & voice acting? Not enough interest from other listeners? Budget/effort constraints?
Thank you so much!
This was one of the best videos for sure
Well done....I am really enjoying your "What If" stories