Terrifying video shows woman shoved into moving subway train
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ต.ค. 2024
- A terrifying subway shove during the evening commute this week was captured on video and police say the victim is lucky to be alive.
Exclusive video shows the suspect approach her victim and then violently push the woman right into an oncoming train.
The unprovoked assault was captured by police body-worn cameras at the Lexington Avenue/59th Street station.
Two officers were standing on the platform where it happened just after 5:30 Tuesday night. They jumped into action and arrested the suspect right away.
Read more: 7ny.tv/360gOzD
Check out more Eyewitness News - 7ny.tv/2suJHTd
NEW HERE? -
Hi! We’re abc7NY, also known as Channel 7 on TV, home to Eyewitness News, New York’s Number 1 news. We hope you love us on TH-cam as much as you do on television!
OUR SOCIAL MEDIA -
FACEBOOK: / abc7ny
TWITTER: / abc7ny
INSTAGRAM: / abc7ny
NEWS TIPS:
Online: 7ny.tv/36UsL9a
Phone: 917-260-7700
Email: abc7ny@abc.com
#abc7NY #subway #nypd
The fact that a person is willing to kill someone so easily shows they need to be locked up for the rest of their life and never let out.
He wanted to go to jail my dude, it’s a warm place to stay and 3 meals a day
That’s what Australia was for
@@ricisjanevks1722 - “he”? Suspect is a female named LINDA. Please don’t assume by gender profiling
@@Fat_Catt ok, sorry my dude
@@Fat_Catt nope your both wrong not a he or a she it a it that was not a human
I think the fact that she randomly wanted to kill a stranger is more dangerous than a criminal that actually has a motive. I mean this person can do this anywhere she wanted. She can target anyone she wants.
Well not anymore right?
We dont know how many people were her victims
I agree... Wen for no reason some1 wants to just kill a random person... It is scarier.
It could be any1 at any time
Your just chillin and bang
She didnt look like a dealer or in a gang ,crew or a person who would have some1 even want to harm them...
She had a bloodlust.
We don't know if it was random perhaps the suspects husband was cheating or she thought he was and the victim was either the one he was cheating with or the suspect thought she was.
I can't even imagine how terrified she was. Not knowing anything but how close she came to dying
Yeah, it’s a f788cked up feeling when you realize you could’ve just died
This sounded like a propaganda. “Luckily our officers were where they needed to be”.. “if the cups weren’t here to immediately arrest that suspect”.. question everything you see.
@Gabriel We live in nature so it's inevitable.
Definitely would have PTSD after
@@DX-d they just used the opportunity to propaganda, the cops couldn't avoid the woman's death it was just luck that she survived
When she said, "I'm not ok please help me " literally broke my heart
):
Who would do this?!
@Haku Yuki shes not, imagine how it would feel getting hit by a 1 ton object moving at 50 mph
@Haku Yuki I know right, perhaps all d others you’ve pushed were stronger.
@@aaydinturk : Answer: Disgruntled workers could do this if downsized by the department due to psychological tensions and exaggerated or lying accusations.
That’s why I don’t stand close to the tracks!!! This was so disgusting.
mmm, a few weeks ago a lady was pushed too and she was in the middle of the platform, but you're right too. After I watched that lady fall I am just vigilant.
I need to stay away from the edge myself now that mention it 😳
@@Solisium-Channel I used to stand up there too until I saw a ton of these videos lol
@@mariee.5912 yeah I started seeing all these videos recently and now I pay close attention to my surroundings while I'm waiting for the train lol
I've always stayed away from the track, even since being a kid, mostly in case I tripped I suppose. I've always associated standing at the edge of the platform as akin to standing 6 feet out into a busy road, you wouldn't stand within inches of rushing cars so why stand within inches of a rushing train when 90% of the platform is empty?
She did that in front of cops?!? She will never not be a danger to the public.
It’s a great thing that the cop was there. In other videos where the same situation happens, New Yorkers just these criminals and let them get away.
Kill it burn it that’s what I say, death sentence need to come back
Problem is she can pretend to be insane and avoid prison.
Yes she will. The system is broken. She should have life but current laws won't allow that.
@@computermech regardless she doesn’t need to be back in society she needs to be locked away
She's not crazy, she knew what she was doing.
Edit: I'm talking about the kind of crazy that keeps you out of prison by claiming you dont understand what you did. She is aware enough to be charged with murder.
Then wtf wrong with her 💀
@@lifegoeson7806 She's evil & needs to be held responsible for her actions.
@@HeavenlySunset24 well said angel 😇 😉
Right i could not believe what I saw. She was trying her best to k!ll that woman and got caught immediately after.
Being "crazy" doesn't mean you don't know what you're doing. If she's schizophrenic then voices could have been telling her to do it or else SHE'LL be killed instead. Does that make it ok, of course not. But this is why we need proper health care in america.
“I’m not okay, please someone help me!” absolutely broke my heart. :(
Shes faking to sue for money
@@bubbamaster3116 dude she literally just got pushed into a fast moving train, and she was probably traumatized. Had she been pushed a second earlier she most likely would’ve died
@@L_gend why is she doing a lawsuit then?
@@bubbamaster3116 uhhh because someone literally pushed her into a train??????
@@L_gend she sue the metro transportation and last time i checked they didnt push her into the train did they? Ye its about money sorry
In Korea, there's another door that covers between you and the railway, the door will open once the train is completely stop. They should add those things if this kind of case still exists. For maximize the safety
Yes, that should be the safety standard everywhere.
Platform screen doors~~~~~
Yes. They also have these in Japan-I noticed when I visited. Although I was told over there it’s to prevent suicides.
@@ktkole4017
Same here in Paris, it's to prevent suicides, and probably homeless people walking on the tracks too.
agreed
This is why I NEVER EVER EVER stand anywhere near that yellow line until the train is at the station and doors are opening. People are sick and we need to be alert at all times. I get so much anxiety just seeing people standing near the platform edge.
Me too
Next time show them this video
Exactly. Always be on the lookout. So many cases where random people gets pushed down the elevators or stairs too. We just never know who is standing next to or near us. That said, I always say a prayer before leaving my home everyday. And also keeping my family in prayers. Just to have a peace of mind.
Yup, don't stand anywhere near the edge of a platform with a train yet to approach and along the same idea don't stand with your toes hanging off the edge of street corner curbs waiting to cross... I've seen alot of cars take a tight right turn and their rear tire goes over the curb.
@Zed 4 i agree, i dont know why people love standing near the yellow line to wait for the train
Sick how she immediately accepted her arrest like she wasn't even planning on getting away with it. She just wanted to watch someone innocent and unsuspecting die
There must have been some sort of beef between the two people, I couldn't imagine some random woman would look at someone and just try to murder them.
Edit: Woops I started a debate
@@SC4TTER_ You suffer from "lack of imagination" ;)
@@SC4TTER_ pretty valid argument
@@SC4TTER_ You're right it must have been a beef. Couldn't have been mental illness
@@5PYZ3R either or …
i dont live in new york but this is why I always stand up against a building when waiting for the bus. you never know who could be walking behind you.
The fact that the person who attacked her looks like any person you pass on the sidewalk is terrifying
Ummm what do you expect? A monster? A homeless person? “It”the clown??
@@prometheus5995 evil people must dress up like supervillains, otherwise how else are we supposed to know they’re evil
@@Gamed-dd7tj fax
That attacker probably has a history of mental health and is probably out and about when they should be committed.
Sending her to jail does not address the issue as she will get out again at some point.
What's more terrifying is judging a book by its cover.
new fear unlocked
Deadass
honestly, this is the most accurate comment 😥
bro just stick to the walls
unlocked
Yep
The wickedness of this world knows no boundaries.
Amen!!!
I hate anyone who would dsuch a thing.
@@rawdoggers Hate is such ways of the World, I don't ever want to hate again.
The world and rest of the animals are O.K. , it's just our species that is wicked.
America is not world, it's place were all kind of psycho collected.
Here in Japan, like in South Korea and Hong Kong, we have glass barriers that only open once the train arrives.
Why does NYC not consider doing that?
@DanteOokami I think in some places in the US has that. But for it to be feasible. They're not seen as cost effective as they're expensive, especially when a rail system has multiple types of vehicles that have different door positioning.
They also require trains to stop consistently, within a small section on the platform, which not all systems are designed to do.
thats the point. you people have been brainwashed into thinking safety standards should not be a requirement.@@Stephan5916I bet you they can fund it using a tiny fraction what they are using to fund the police.
Because it makes since, it's too easy, and requires a functioning brain!
@@Stephan5916 You said, "Not cost effective" ! Do you mean life is so cheap in the US>
The technologically advance rich country can make it or buy it any day it wants.
But then, you are right, it is not cost-effective. Those lives don't count.
Only criminal's lives matter in the Untidy States.
because they hate us
That woman is going to have PTSD everytime she uses the subway...
She should try and leave the city, take it as a sign.
If she ever even sets a foot in a subway/trainstaion again, then most certainly PTSD over 9000
Man I'm getting PTSD just watching this. Imma stand near the wall now at all times. The woman tho might even stop taking the subway at all from now on
they should make some kind of gate/safety wall system, that only opens when people bord or exit the train
well i dont think she is going to use the subway anymore, shes probably gonna move city thats what i would have done at least
Never wait for the train in that area, I lean up against a wall, don't care if I'm the last one in.
I dont blame u buddy
Good, probably helps prevent pick pockets as well.
Also if you stand next to the tracks there watch your surroundings
If you were doing that with an express train in NY at rush hour, you wouldn't be in a train till at least 3 hrs later. I tried that. Every sardine for themselves.
@@Rahkhellthen stand close and don’t use a phone and pay attention to your surroundings but I think you will be fine because theres a lot of people
As a native New Yorker I am shocked people stand so close to the track, I always have stood by the wall or where those benches are. I have seen enough evil in this city to see the bad side of people. Same goes with crossing streets when it shows "red" look both ways if you are gonna do it.
exactely Taco! I've been taking the subway for years and I would never stand beside the edge for that same reason. I DON'T TRUST HUMAN! There's too many psycho out there!
SAME! I always sit on the chairs by the wall or just stand against the wall, people are crazy
The simple reasoning behind this is some people are already going through some thought process and dealing with their inner turmoils silently so they lose focus.
I'd say here, people need to look out for each other, that's the only way to counter these psychopaths they encounter randomly everywhere.
I'm paranoid so I always stand back because I'm even afraid I'll trip lol. Most people aren't paranoid enough and many are tourists so they don't realize
@@sweet_amir Some people do. In her case it was not. Use your logic instead of judgement driven by bias:
How many people are there in the video? Literally herself lol. Why would she want to 'get in faster to get a seat' when there are literally 3 people only around LMAO.
Your statement hence definitely does not apply in this case.
This person can never be left out of jail.
People need to learn that with all the crazies out there, they should stand a good distance back from the edge of the platform. I've seen this too many times. Even school kids fooling around on the platform pretending to shove their friends in front of a train. Now that train crew has to go through a whole process because of this nonsense. Stay back till the train is in the station moving slowly or stopped.
Yes you are right I'm from Chicago where they kill for sports I see NY like to attack people on trains and kill them.its crazy when you have sick people out here in this world like this that taking a life for no reason means nothing to them.
She probably felt safe because she was standing in front of one of the pillars. 0:20
Well, we can see how safe she was. It's better to stand where someone cannot get behind you without being seen. Also, I have seen people fall in front of trains on their own, collapsing from health issues, excessive heat or intoxication. I operated NYC subway trains for 27 years, I know it is better to stand way back from the edge, preferably with your back against a wall or some other fixed object. It's not like you will miss your train being 15' back from the edge.
@@PaulPavloPablo your never safe. Don't stand by the edge too long and be aware who's around you
Not everyone is from the city so it's unreasonable to expect everyone to know what could happen. Some of the past victims were immigrants, tourists or non-natives. The MTA, City and State has a responsibility to protect the wellbeing of its passengers. Other countries have already implemented barriers to prevent suicides and these despicable crimes so there's no excuse for the city to ignore this.
I have lived in NYC for over 5 years. I always tell my siblings and friends to never stand anywhere near the yellow line. It doesn’t even have to be about someone trying to murder you. Someone could just accidentally bump into you, which is enough to throw you off the platform. Glad the women got caught though. People like that have no place in society-
Biden’s new nominee for HHS secretary.
Didn’t mean to push her!
It's right, there's no good reason to stand close to the tracks or even near the yellow safety line. It's not like you're actually saving time by standing closer, the train isn't going to set off any faster once you're on it. Don't put yourself in or even near harms way. Whenever I'm waiting for a train I'm usually sitting on a bench or leaning back on a wall or pillar nowhere near the track but constantly watching for the train and people watching, i like to see myself as a kind of unofficial lifeguard just in case there's any kids or drunkards going to near the edge of the platform or bothering anyone. Long story short my uncle is a train driver and he's seen people get hit up close and it was highly traumatic for him because there's literally no fast way to stop those things and it's a mess. I'd pull someone up off the tracks but i don't have any family or kids to look after, I wouldn't recommend doing it to anyone else but seriously folks don't go near the track or close to the edge of a fast flowing river or anything where your gut says maybe that's too close, trust that instinct because you might just be saving 2 lives, yourself and the poor guy like me who jumps in after you trying to pull you out to the side. Also if you see someone acting strange near a railway line report it immediately and keep an eye on them, if they're depressed and planning suicide you can talk to them but report it first and do not get too close to them if they are near anything dangerous, you don't want to get pulled in or over with them. Stay safe out there folks and try to smile, peace and love x
Sorry for the long comment btw guys, i find writing therapeutic sometimes.
@@chucknutly3290 We'll forgive you this time if you promise to take the time and effort to introduce some formatting into your future posts.
@@BicycleFunk I tried to edit my comment to correct some things but TH-cam wouldn't have it unfortunately. Thanks for your reply and your forgiveness, not many people offer that as readily as you do.
Seeing that woman getting tackled immediately is so satisfying.
yeeessss
That was hardly a tackle.
I would say they were a little too gentle with her
wish i was there bro, i would of shown her what the word tackle means
what tackle lol
A similar thing happened to me when I was little it was declared a accident but while waiting for the train with my grandfather on the yellow line a Teenage girl bumped me really hard while the train was starting to approach I clogged to my grandfather's hand for dear life since I stumbled forward really hard. Luckily my grandmother was and still is a strong man and pulled me back so fast it hurt my arm.
My grandfather reported it and since the teen wasn't found and no one was hurt it was just a scary accident.
My father always taught me as a little girl while taking the train , back all the way away from the platform and always watch your surroundings. Stuck with me to this day.
Hope he taught you about cars too. People have been pushed into the streets to on coming car as well.
@@monkeyking-self-proclaimed7050 the problem with cars is the footpaths are close to the road
Me too! whenever I come to NY bc my dad lives here he always tells me to never stand next to the train track bc many homeless ppl will push u
@@Andreadolphin homeless??? It can be anyone wtf
@@Andreadolphin Why did you have to put homeless? It's all types of people boy
You can’t trust anyone. Always stay aware of your surroundings because you never know when something like this could happen
Evil is always around us beware
360 degrees all the time brotha
that’s literally my worst fear. that’s why i dont stand near the platform
This why i gotta have a car i hate public transportation too many people around u that u dont know anything can happen
@Fite Mi It was a joke.
And no I am not going to kill someone.
Thats why in beijing they got guard doors on the platform. The guard doors dont open until the train stops and the train doors open.this is better it prevents suicides, garbage, and accidents from happening on the tracks.
Can't do it here because the different train models etc. Would be off in measurements in Beijing they all have the same models and was built with that in mind
@@TheLunzDen they just bought new trains...buy trains that can work with platform gates. Or whats better, mta been taking all that money can invest in their own team to design a train that works with platform gates. Better than putting scupltures and paintings and new high design teminals that leak in months of their grand opening...there no such thing as cant.
@@pedicabfilms8791 I can imagine the fare hike that would be involved if the mta decided to do that. They can't even operate the moving platforms for those stations with the big gaps between the train and the platform. A few years ago someone got stuck in between the moving platform and the train. And the thing repeatedly opened and closed while they were trying to get him out. I don't think they're capable of doing it and this subway is really old and not uniform in any way. It would be expensive and probably wouldn't work well
All im saying is people said they was no way people would be able to fly...but we can fly everyday via airplanes. They can attach a gate system onto the platform. the gate doors only open when the magnet is activated by the train door magnets when in the right position. The magnets for the doors can be attached ro any train. ALL IM SAYING CANT AINT A GOOD ENOUGH REASON.
Why US never have one ? 😥
I can't imagine doing this to someone😢
How sadistic do you have to be to commit such an act?😡?
You gotta be insane literally. A schizophrenic did the same not so long ago where I live
It's really that easy you don'thave to be crazy @@irgendeinname9256
I wanna know the reason why she did that. How could a person just do that someone knowing it could cause them death. What a vile human being
Trying to walk it off too so pissy man I hope she got a lot of time
It's in our nature. Like this fact or not.
@@GodVanisher not relaly, this type of behaviour is provoked over time
@@leogard8396 Provoked by our nature. Even animals kill for fun.
@@GodVanisher did she just try to kill the woman for fun? Why did she do that?
I seriously do not understand why we dont adapt the Hong Kong Metro glass wall infront of the train entrances. It completely eliminates that exact possibility. So glad that women is alright
Hong Kong is such a marvel of a city, it really does do so many things right.
There are a few potential reasons I can think of:
1) Cost
2) Implementation on existing structures
3) The modifications required for trains.
In London on the Tube, I’ve seen the concept implemented on the newer ‘Jubilee Extension Line’ but IiRC implementing it on an extension for a different Line has to be delayed because the current rolling stock doesn’t support it, although the stations have the framework in place.
I wouldn’t be surprised if these are only implemented on the Subway if either there’s a major renovation project or worse the cost of life becomes too great.
Yea Singapore has it too, really wish this barrier was more common
Welcome to America where they can't even put a suicide barrier on the Golden Gate Bridge.
Those are all new cities compared to NYC. The cost to implement all that great fancy stuff is too great. I've been on the train in Singapore. It's a beauty
And this is why I don’t stand close to the edge because people are taking this as a joke smh
Smh smh
And when they end up in court they will be all crocodile tears and say it's by accident. Sure it's not like you tripped over thin air and stuck your arms onto someone like an anime girl. That's not even cute it just results more injury especially in the subway where people die from these accidents
When I lived in NYC, I always made sure I stood away from the edge or with my back against one of the beams if possible
Right, And she was screaming for someone to help her, like she did nothing wrong.
@@peppermintt3879 No, that was the injured lady screaming.
This is definitely "Attempted Murder".
_"Luckily for us our officers were where they were supposed to be"_
No, luckily the perp had bad timing.
Should be a guard rail so this aint even possible
They caught her though and arrested her immediately otherwise she could’ve gotten away .
@@KourtneeMonroe yeah in England a crackhead pushed an athletic guy who kept his balance and didn't fall so he went to the next station and to do it again and pushed an old man onto the tracks. The police being there matters too
@@misspollysdolly that is insane 🥺🥺
i swear if cops arrested all the murderers and rapists out there then you people will still say ACAB and want to free the criminals 😂
💀
it's horrifying how she just has no motive. she saw an innocent woman standing, waiting for the subway and just decided to push her in front of an oncoming train, just for the fun of it.
maybe she thought she was a trump supporter
@@pegwy126 OMG somebody with a different opinion I must k¡ll them 😐
@@pegwy126 dude, what the heck
@@pegwy126 the internet exaderates everything, real life isn't as volatile as TH-cam comment section
How do you know she had no motive?
Evil exists in this world. Take precautions, always be aware, and stay safe everyone.
Yeah..Evils exist in this world...but GOD too!! She didn't die as the devil would have wished :)
@@Loch-Ness66 yeah instead millions of children die every year! Thank GOD
@@Loch-Ness66 is there any situation where you don't automatically plug your propaganda? i hope you never attended a single funeral in your entire life
@M J You read too far into it
@@josua3 God cant always stay by our side, maybe these children who died at such young age or even unfairly can have a way better afterlife
That poor woman. I hope she can heal emotionally from this.
A woman's emotions change like the wind.
@@ayeflippumget more serius if its your mom , right ? ... ironic😂
@@ayeflippumI truly hope you remain alone until you let go of that stupidiy.
@@ayeflippum😂u dont get any woman thats y u always hating
@@hanalala3164 Yeah? Should I let my wife know?
Why can't we see Linda's Chavez face? People need to be on the look out for her. This women does not look crazy to me.
Val Chung Well, you’re not gonna get a good look at her whole face anyway because she was wearing a face mask, and as far being on the lookout for her, she got caught in the act and was arrested on the spot. She’s probably looking at her 25 years or so for attempted murder.
@@LouieV6 it's NY, she's pregnant already back on the street.
@@naelyneurkopfen9741 disgusting, evil person have kids. I can't imagine this world become..
@@LouieV6 You dont get to wear a mask when they take your mugshot, if you did there would be no point, use your brain.
"Look out for her"? Do you honestly believe she will ever get out of jail for an attempted murder charge?
In Singapore, after a few cases of suicides by jumping into the tracks, they erected fencing with gates that would only open when the train stops
Here in Germany, that'd take decades to build. Bureaucracy at its best.
@@leDespicable Our MRT started in 1987. The underground stations already have such screen doors. But the stations on elevated platforms did not have it. On January 2008, a decision was made to roll it out and the project was completed in March 2012. So also took a while to get it done
@@leDespicable In one rare statistic released during a court case, there were 30 cases of "track intrusions" between 2004 and 2010.
Seoul is like that too. See through glass which opens when train arrives.
@@dennisthemenace3695 We just had one in Feb 2021. A foreign worker managed to find an entry via a small hill into a tunnel track. He was killed. That access point is now wired up with barb wires.
She tried to kill her. Tried to push her in front of the train but was too slow... This is so terrifying. Just trying to get where you need to go and have to worry about people like this. We have to stay praying for our safety and the safety of our loved ones.
Got the devil in her as you notice
Praying won’t do anything. Actually go do something about this. Maybe go convince the government to force mandatory subway safety measures. I don’t know. But sitting and praying will do nothing for you.
Amen
But if you die you go to heaven, why so scared?
@@johnathant6735 Jesus christ bruh. So now in the 21st century hoping for the best is a thought crime? And when you say go do something? Have you lol? Be honest with yourself. Just ignore the comment, especially if you have nothing intelligent to say.
this has been happening more and more often in my city and its terrifying to worry about taking a train to get to my uni
They should have some sort of gate or barrier built and only opens when train has come to a full stop at the station. For as much money as NyC charges its citizens to use PUBLIC transportation it should ensure their safety as well.
DC is more expensive and so is Philadelphia
If you think the New York subway is expensive, you'd slip into a coma when you read about the London Underground.
SRSLY. If other places can get that done then why not here? Il
@@coffeepandacat different train car lengths on the same line with different door positions for one.
We're talking a multiple billion dollar job to have platform doors in the major stations. Only waist high ones as well probably.
@@visionist7 they can make it happen would create jobs too
I’m disgusted, barely even know the women and attempted to do that. Lesson, stay away from the subway train when waiting
We can't be sure that she doesn't know her but either way this is a terrifying situation to be in
What is the psychology behind people who like to do something bad for others and make people feel miserable? And why?
I'm wondering if that victim hurted her in some extreme way that she tried to get revenge in pretty much broad daylight. Any rational sensible killer would probably attack her in the dark of night or somewhere obscure. Tbh she just looks like a hurt woman but I may be wrong. There might a delusional person underneath that mask.
@@adhithyap.9441 It looks like the woman is troubled and is probably hearing voices telling her to push people in front of a train. There are many others who are just evil and want to cause harm to others but plan strategically. Someone that tries to commit murder in front of everyone to someone they don’t know is almost always mentally unstable. There are other people that do many other horrible and evil things to others or their properties just because they’re jealous of what others have and they don’t. Murder isn’t the only evil thing humans are capable of.
@@happyemoji6553 yup that's a great theory. I'd say torture is most evil thing humans are capable of
the fact that she even did it infront of police just shows she didnt care.
I don't think she realized the Police were there tbh
It could be a one year thing,but with amount of Mentally ill around,it could go on for another Winter and maybe Attacks on Asian Folks also for no Reason.🤪😈
@@brucekilby9957 dude, you cant even tell the ethnicity of the lady in the video. Thats not why she pushed her
@@brucekilby9957 A police spokesperson said Chavez is believed to be emotionally disturbed. source:Queenspost
@@brucekilby9957 your grammar is horrible
Stop victim blaming her! Instead of blaming her for standing too close to edge, maybe blame the criminal trying to push her off? I dunno, bit of a wild guess.
Nobody’s victim blaming she should not of been standing close to the edge and it’s less victim blaming more telling other people how to prevent situations like this
its not the victims fault however even so she almost died and if she had died it wouldnt matter who is right or wrong because she would be dead, so hopefully she can take a lesson out of this and not stand too close to the subway rails so it cant happen again
@@Gooses_Pond These comments or lack of them, She will NEVER ever stand in a position like that.
Use common sense. Imagine asking that woman, "are you going to stand like that again, EVER?"
The answer will be a big NO.
And that is exactly what people are doing here, telling each other not to stand close to the tracks.
Sick, what an awful traumatic experience, hope the victim recovers soon, and that justice is served.
I can’t imagine the horrible nightmares she might still be having about it. They said her arm was injured so probably not broken at least. But I immediately thought the same thing that was said that just a second or two sooner would’ve been deadly.
@@thatoscarguy9965 i dont want to watch what happened
@@sunipye7051 not that bad, there was a train and the suspect pushed her into the side of it (not the front) so she just bounced off
yeah she most probably got some bruise and a scratch but the ptsd of standing near train tracks or even the road is gonna remain with her forever
@@mrquaackers thank GOD
I’m so clumsy I would’ve definitely died. She held her balance as a train was barreling across her body. Miraculous. She had a guardian angel protecting her.
Those are two contradicting statements but ya it’s amassing that she survived
@@demydevil why contradiction... She has good balance and a helping positive force.
@@housec8059 i think they were talking about "she held her balance" and "a gardian angel protecting her"
blaaaack liveees maaatteeeeer
@@reilley7734 You’re right I did kinda contradict myself.
She had both. Maybe her guardian angel was helping her balance. Regardless, it’s miraculous that the train didn’t drag her down.
this is happening way too often...when the train is coming, back up...they are doing this in front of police...
I guess the more it is on the news the more it glorifies it for other crazy people to do it
@@Chillcat584 It's a warning for people to be more vigilant in staying safe on platforms. A shame no one saw the crazy person before it happened. They usually have the tell tale signs of doing something off hand before they do it.
@@adamm.6386 yeah call me nieve but I didn't know people did this until I saw a ton of videos of it over the last few months. I don't stand that close anymore
@NICHOLAS HURLEY The message is for those like you. These types are calculating individuals. Be safe and never assume. Anyone can be a danger on platforms or anywhere where they can take advantage of the situation. It sounds over protective, but people like her exist. Stay safe.
Any updates?
To clarify, I’m not saying I could understand murdering someone under any circumstance, but imagine going to jail for attempted murder because you decided to push... a stranger in front of a train? She threw away her whole life for that moment? People continue to blow my mind and horrify me every day.
@Joonatan Isoaho @FBI right here
@@KaiCSGO i guess i can’t relate - i would never stoop to that level
It can't be a sane person though, I bet the woman who did that was most likely sick in her head, maybe she heard voices that told her to do it, it doesn't justify what she tried to do, but it can atleast maybe explain the reason behind why such a thing can happen.
@@bobmalibaliyahmarley1551 actually crazy people are less violent than normal sane people. It's most likely a person with a dark personality disorder. They like to fake being crazy, and hearing voices is often used.
@@bobmalibaliyahmarley1551 it's definitely possible! it still would be a strange thing for her to carry into the future, going to jail just to push a stranger for a split second.
What is going on in NYC? This is like the 3rd one I've seen in a few weeks. Are y'all alright??! Why is this happening? 😐
Those ppl are off up there
Too many chemtrails, whatevers in the water, media, 5G radiation. All of that
come to Canada! :)
Sunshine Monroe I live in nyc. In here you don't see cops often after defunding them. When you get ready for work in the morning and have to take the train station to get there. There's men you can tell ceasing the opportunity to harm someone who looks vulnerable to them without any reason. Common sense is gone.
@@mirinboy1745 They actually went through with defunding the police?
The timing of the train, woman's push, and positioning of the police were almost meant to be. What if this woman had also done this before?
The last sentence doesn’t really make sense. I mean, she could’ve but she probably woulda got caught
I wouldn't be surprised if this isn't her first attack. There were several similar incidents in the past month.
@@gjune36 I guess they have no cameras there. Budget cuts...
Never rely on the cops to help you, especially NYPD.
What if this happened to that woman?
The question is why? I don't understand the thought process behind pushing a random stranger into a moving train
Crazy impulsive thoughts.
That's why I like the subways in Korea. They have a huge glass door barrier on all subways so it's nearly impossible to fall into the tracks or in this case, be pushed into them
Korea seems like a great place from everything that ive heard and seen. I WISSHH America would take tips from there
@@G.o.digger123Hegotme we kinda gave them a lot. Also korea isnt some haven
@@muradsawalha3121 better than America though. That's the point.
@@lilli798 its not
We malaysians added that to out MRTs thanks to the smart inspiration of the Koreans
I think this is everyone's nightmare. We're always thinking about this when someone is behind us
Just because things can happen doesn't mean you have to worry about them. There are countless situations were you might die 0.000001% chance. Just life your life. Life is too short to worry about death.
@@Utoko lol were just talking about waiting on a train station. Just dont stand in the edge lol. Has nothing to do with fearing death all the time
wisco i wouldn't mind that much. i don't have much to live for.
nightmare = being tortured by illness or cruelty
That's why you always look behind you to see whose around you when in the subway station.
@@wisco9er536 fax
That’s why you don’t stand close to the tracks, my moms taught me this since I was young, so sad
Why don't we have railings yet that open when the train stops to let people on...why are we still in the stone age
@Kim Markle in NYC, "moms" is a colloquial term for mother. But families come in all shapes and sizes. Make valuable or funny comments instead of f*cking dumb ones like you just did. Also, had to add that you misused the apostrophe. 🤣
@@velocity1012 you can't take a joke, huh?
@Kim Markle moms --> mom's --> mom has
I think something like this,, she just forgot the apostrophe.
@@zunghsi You expect the crazy psychos to have basic decency? You can only take care of yourself, you can't control other people's actions.
family members will say this is "out of character" and she's a "pillar of the community"
This is the EXACT reason I stand at the back of the platform, until the train has safely stopped!
Lol smart
Wise
i live in the bronx work in tribeca, NY i ride in the 4,5,6 to manhattan and them the A,C to canal street and I always stand in the middle of the platform with my back to a column or the side of the stairs and whenever the train approaches I keep an eye on people near me for safety...
That's smart. I should actually start doing that.
i really hope she gets well and overcome this , but you have to admire her for keeping her balance for just a split second to not fall in front of the train
Yes, I was about to say, she got some fast reflexes.
Yeah, she could also be dead instead.
"I'm not OK" 😢 I hope she's OK now. It shouldn't be that easy to do that to someone.
They should install a simple wall with sliding doors that open when the train is present, but even a safety railing would be better than having it open like that. And don't tell me it's too expensive. If NY can spend money trying to make the homeless miserable they can spend money on basic safety.
I totally agree!
A lot of trains station in asian countries have these barrier lol. Just America being America.. slow
@@legokingtm9462 The glass barriers are indeed cheap. However, the problem is that the train needs a more advanced AI/computer system and rewiring (only in newer transit systems) , so that the train doors stop in exact spots, lining up with the glass barrier openings. It is much more expensive to replace all the 6000+ subway cars.
@@legokingtm9462 I mean to be fair, Germany has one of the most advanced train networks in the world and many of their subways don’t have these safeties either. At least not in München or Nürnberg.
@@aceidel That's still not an excuse. Moving the yellow line back and adding a simple railing would stop cases like this as well. As would the train slowing before it reaches the station to make injuries and deaths impossible.
I don't see how they can afford to not do this. Between unemployment costs, medical costs, cleanup costs, etc. I'd argue that the cost of doing nothing is greater than doing something.
“Why did you push her?”
“She exists.”
“…”
SERIOUSLY?! WHAT DID SHE DO? HOW SICK DO YOU HAVE TO BE TO COMMIT SUCH A HORRIBLE ACT?!
I'm thinking she just had one of those "I could kill this person right now" moments but actually went through with it.
Lmao
honestly probably
If the cop went full Derek Chauvin on her neck I don't think anyone would care
linda chavez =of course they would@@-_______________________.___
@@-_______________________.___ of course, because she was actually doing something bad
but someone should derek chauvin the real derek chauvin
The victim was so lucky to have fallen at an angle towards the side of the train and not toward the tracks
yes thank you for stating what was stated in the video again in the comments xqcL
@@e2k220 xqcL
@@e2k220 Unexpected juicer
No way I’m blind so thanks for letting me know how lucky she was
I'm blind, and deaf. Thanks for explaining the video so those of us that are incapable of watching it ourselves can understand what's happening
This is not the first time this happened at the subway and doesn't always end well. Never stand at the edge of the subway and always keep your eyes open!
but why do they do it?
@@hasanalmonem5713 that's the second question.
I'm 50 years old and you NEVER had to worry about this when I was younger living in NYC. This is why voting has consequences... all these DA's and Mayor's letting everyone out No-Bail and giving a slap on the wrist to violent crime... then there's the "Defund the Police" nonsense... THIS is the RESULT.
Reap what you sow NYC.. glad I moved out of NY for good. It's not remotely the place I grew up in.
@@hasanalmonem5713 exactly? Was that woman crazy? Did someone hire her to target the victim? We will never know tune in next time
@@christineguttilla6465 ok boomer
How could someone do this 😞
Humans are the most terrifying species on Earth I have ever seen.
As a demonologist, I agree.
a lot animals kill each other too.
@@kamerad_marzuki3631 not at all for the same reasons humans do
@@DiamanteDea hmmm, chimps.
As an Alien watching this.... I agree. They are so strange
This is getting out of control, nobody is safe anymore.
It’s NYC. Nobody ever was.
@@Fat_Catt nyc has gotten better over the years. You still get your crazies and incidents but now you have to hug the pillars so you won't get pushed into a train??? Come on, that was never the norm.
You're safe in Christ.
@@Kee2Oz - is that the uptown express?
@@Fat_Catt Be humble and travel coach.
How much of a selfish person can you be to try to murder another human being?? Thank god the woman is ok.
Thank God indeed. Truly shows he is watching over us
@benzo lol,, a basic excuse atheists always make to debunk the existence of GOD. It debunks nothing.
@@johannfer7073 I believe in God buf we can't disprove anything either
@@johannfer7073 fr
@@johannfer7073 A basic excuse but you still can't answer his question despite it being so simple?
Hmhm.
SO GLAD SHE'S OKAY
Thank you.
The fact that this could happen to anyone literally anywhere and at any time is mind-boggling.
You're not kidding when you say ''anyone''. Did you see the video of the two pigeons pushing a third one in front of a train? LOL. They knew what they were doing. Watch it, it's crazy. The pigeon survived unscathed btw, he managed to stay put under the passing train.
What about places that don't have subway trains? 😄
Devil's advocate
i dont understand why they dont just make the trains slow down before entering the station... if they are going slow enough to stop incase this happens, it will never happen again.. sure it will slow down the trains a bit but isnt that worth it to save lives?
@@Gravitics Trains have a very long braking distance. I doubt that slowing down the trains a bit would actually save lives.
@@Gravitics or how bout putting barricades in each station, is that too difficult to understand? its the same thing when they put fences on bridges...
She’s lucky she didn’t push any earlier
Yea, if that woman was smarter she would have pushed her 5 seconds earlier, even if she pushed her 15 secs earlier i dont think she could have got out the tracks in time.
@@Tatusiek_1 You mean dumber? It would be dumber if she did it any earlier because she would be charged with murder.
@@1x9_ethan83 I’m pretty sure she was trying to kill her, and she failed.
@@Tatusiek_1 Rite
@@1x9_ethan83 she already tried killing her and obviously meant to be charged with murder all the same, and even failed, she's at her dumbest. If she tried killing her and succeeded, she's just slightly less dumb. Not sure what you're talking about lol
I see comments like : why was she standing so close to the edge etc.
Have you people lost your sense? The fact remains that a PERSON pushed another one on the tracks!
Exactly
Yes, but it’s good general advice to stand away from the yellow line. It makes occurrences like this less likely, and it’s just safer overall.
No, we haven't lost our senses. I get your point. However we have come to a point that when people are out in public, they need to be constantly aware of their surroundings...it's called "situational awareness," and people need to make themselves harder for criminals to victimize.
No, I think you have been prvileged not to see attempted murder. This is not shocking and it is not surprising I expect this. Its surprising it doesnt happen more
you answered your own question
A year ago?
Bet she is wandering around NYC right now.
Beware.
Actually she plead guilty to attempted murder and accepted a 6 year sentence. She is currently serving her time at Bedford Hills. With time served she will be out in 2027 at the latest. Chavez will have a parole hearing in December 2025.
Living in NY my whole life my mom always taught me to NEVER stand close to the platform because of folks like Chavez 🤦🏾♀️ I'm so glad she hit the train instead and gets to see another day.
For real. I am always on guard but maybe that's just from being brought up here and living in dangerous neighborhoods. When I see people standing next to the edge I'm so baffled by their obliviousness to potential threats around them. Same thing when I see people wearing headphones walking late at night not paying attention to their surroundings. This is NYC not some nice suburb somewhere. People need to pay attention.
@@levity90 datz watcha get from livin in da city!
@levity90 You are so right I agree with you. My favorite thing to do on the train is wear my head phones but won't have any music on. I can act like I can't hear you or if anything goes down I know what's going on lol. It's a sad way to live sometimes but we got to do what we can to survive especially here in the city.
@@hightonesdrifterkent6600 one or several cities out of every other city you mean?
@@hightonesdrifterkent6600 I will never live in a suburb.
I swear Everytime I hear the train comimg I back away from the edge. Trust no one suspect everyone.
Trust nuttin expect da worse all day all nite fool
livin in da city!!
one time I actually danced in front of the train and the operator honked at me and told me to shut up
She was VERY VERY LUCKY THAT DAY SHE HAD A ANGEL WATCHING OVER HER FOR SURE !!!
She will never ever be the same again.
No, the perp mistimed the push.. No angels were involved here.. LMMFAO
This only happens in the USA. Other countries don't have this problem.😁
Person: *was attacked and severely injured*
People: oMg So lUcKy
@@LaoSoftware that’s actually not true but say what u wanna say
After a horrifying story my friend told me of a lady fall in to a train track and got crushed. I will never stand near the track ever again except when the train stop or there is a fence. True story or not, it still scary. May the lady soul rest in peace.
I want to know what this woman’s motivation was. That was pure evil.
Woman had no motivation.evil is it's own reward.that is why it is so senseless and frightening to normal people.always be aware of your surroundings.
@@schmittyconstanz You don't know that. For all that we know the victim could've killed her brother or something. Just playing devil's advocate, no details on this were released so it's impossible to know. This may not have been just random. Though it was in New York City so it likely was.
@@johnwest6690 the banality of evil
Probably schizophrenic
She could’ve had schizophrenia and was having delusions or hearing voices telling she needed to push her, you never know. She might not be an evil person at heart and could be suffering from mental illness
What’s wrong with ppl in the train station these days. this craziness never end...
This is murder!
It's getting crazy in NYC
@@bosschedda_ - crazIER
avoid city folk
@@hightonesdrifterkent6600 You can’t avoid city folk
Wtf why are people being shoved lately?
I know right?
They closed all the mental institutions, and all these people were just let out into society.
I noticed that too, 2 weeks ago trains at Elmhurs ave were out due to someone being pushed on the track, both MTA worker confirmed it and also the displaying screen on the station... however, it wasnt on the news at all. If you pay attention shoving ppl on the rails is getting rampant all over the city for a while now but it seems media try not to make people anxious about that fact. Don't look at your phone, keep earbuds out and stay with your back to the wall!
Well this is what happens when you defund police, vilify them, get rid of 75% percent of'em and support senseless stupid dangerous riots because they keep chanting an obvious slogan.. U wanted radical changes, right? Well here ya go, u got it! Unfortunately when a cpl of misguided misinformed ppl keep yelling "fire" and there is none, innocent ppl will get hurt! Sad but true.. 😳😐👈
@@rickyb533 I don't support neither of what you mentioned above, i am originally from Eastern Europe living in USA (NY) for the last 3 years. Compared to Polish, Russian, Serbian police - USA police is Mother Terresa, Americans aren't aware the fact that they have it the best and the most fair police in the world since they are incapsulated into their own world of delusion of injustice. I survived 2 wars and lived in ruined country so i know how to recognize when s**t hits the fan in the country but unfortonatelly most of New Yorkers aren't even slightly aware of the omens and signs that precede the fall of the system. People (talking for NYC) aren't used to rough life and im afraid what gonna happen once the reality hits them in the face.
In NYC the courts are likely to say, "No death, no crime. You're free to go."
Wtf NY, give her life without parole. As a tourist this makes me afraid to come to NYC the transit system is already confusing as hell now I have to worry about being pushed to my death in front of a train.
Same, as a Bostonian I’m afraid to go to New York. :(
Yo she almost killed someone yes she might get life without parole you talking like that's a bad thing
@@miltongibbs1540 don't think he is
Just adds to the authentic New York experience! Come on down! There’s a “I love NY” shirt down in the tracks for every tourist that gets shoved
@@Fat_Catt this is no joking matter, but that comment was funny 😆 good one
I can only imagine the sheer terror you would feel from watching helplessly as you're falling towards a moving train... that poor lady will probably be traumatized for life.
Hope she okay.
This video proves 2 things:
1. Some people will kill you for literally no reason
2. The Subway system needs some safety protocols.
Yeah don't stand in front of the line
@@destinyelle7120 the train was seconds from coming. kinda like how some people wait for the bus just seconds away. don't victim blame.
I very much agree with number 2. They put more lettuce than bread on my sandwich. :((
@@coconutmomentyeah Thank You.
@@neptaim2795 If you think about it, the yellow line is THE MOST dangerous when a train is just seconds away. Just pointing that out.
I've read several stories now about people being shoved on the subway. Stand back and look behind you, be safe out there
that poor lady. she's so lucky to have avoided death so easily but i can't even begin to imagine how much trauma that gave her.
I would not be surprised if she will be traumatized for life.
These things haunt everyone involved except the pusher. The driver will most likely suffer from nightmares of hitting and killing the woman, the woman herself will definetly have nightmares or even PTSD, even people who saw what happened could see some bad stuff in their dreams about what had happened.
The pusher, too, after a while.. so much unnecessary pain and suffering
Exactly
This is one of the reasons I don't wanna leave my house.
With all of the shootings and stabbings that are happening in Toronto Canada it makes me reluctant to leave the house too. The weekend just past was a holiday weekend and I didn't even go outside. What makes it even scarier is that my next door neighbor has a Pitbull.
She wanted the victim to fall under the train. This is attempted murder.
This exactly happened to me in October 2019 where a woman tried to push me in the subway 23rd street while waiting for the path train. No one really came up for help, luckily I got into my senses before she could use any force on me to push me on the track. While I was trying to rescue myself she escaped. NYPD please tighten the security as much as you can.
I hope your doing okay! Hope that woman is behind the bars by now or atleast for karma to give her a taste
@@drep2443 Not that it matters when there's a new subway attacker born every week now.
@Pris I'm sorry this happened to you 3 years ago in October 2019 that woman was a coward one day karma will get her I am glad u are okay and your right Police officers need to be in subway station.
Do you know why she did that? Where I live a man pushed a child in front of a train. Turned out he was a schizophrenic. Makes people incredible unpredictable and irrational
Thank you for sharing your harrowing experience. I wish for you to always be divinely protected wherever you are.
You can never predict the actions of others. The best thing we can do is be aware and protect ourselves
You can actually, well I can maybe you can't and I would predict that. People are EXTREMELY predictable. People will always act in a way that benefits their ego there is no exception
I’m upset that no one came to her aid when she was screaming help on the floor. I understand the cops needed to get the suspect but people were just on their phones or watching rather than checking to see if the lady was ok. Sad.
What are they supposed to do? The cop already took care of the problem.
@@Tserinac_Backwards Probably, idk HELP HER? Like, you just got pushed into a train car it would hurt and no one was helping her
@@regrubmaH Im pretty sure they called the ambulance right after arresting the most they can do is comfort her anyways
@@regrubmaH it’s funny how easy it is to criticize when your not the one in the situation. Just saying
Do you have first aid training? Personally, I don't. And I'm aware that aimlessly standing around an injured person saying "Are you ok?" is akin to doing nothing at all. Even though everybody else apparently seems to think that's life-saving.
And all the other people just standing around not helping the victim. That's that New York love right there.
I can't be the only one curious as to the motive? A woman goes 33 years before just randomly deciding to murder a stranger in public? There's got to be more than that.
Yeah it's pretty strange, regardless nothing can excuse the fact that woman is a psychopath but it would be interesting to know the reason she attempted to kill someone in plain sight, there had to be an extreme amount of hatred built up to do that
I think most likely, she had one of those "I could kill her right now" thought but went through with it.
Same way you can think "I can turn this steering wheel RIGHT NOW and drive off this cliff"
When driving.
It's some psychological thing I'm too lazy to elaborate on but it's kinda crazy she didn't have a filter if that's the case..
it doesnt matter what the motive is you do not push someone to their death
@@Hiyorin871 did anyone suggest otherwise? bruhh
@@mikahoolwerff3563 you didnt get what i meant? ppl keep asking what was the motive what was the motive? I'm saying doesnt matter what it was why anyone even wanna know as if it will change the result
what was the point of trying to murder someone
she just said "i wonder what happens if i kill someone in public"
It be that way sometimes
Was it a psychopath or a sociopath? Which was the one that feels no guilt, and gets a rise out of evoking emotions out of other people?
@@potaterjim That's a Pyscho, or something, but a sociopath doesn't feel empathy or sympathy. Most sociopaths tend to be pretty smart tho, and do well in business. The pusher looked like neither.
Maybe they should build barriers on the tracks now to protect people this is ridiculous. That woman was lucky to be bounced off the first car. Omg I can't imagine how she felt being pushed and almost losing her life
This is why I lost faith in humanity years ago. It's sad we live in this type of world. I'm losing my belief in God too.
@@stuckinthe90sThegoldenera ??
@@Whimsicalwizardofwisdom I'm trying not to.
@Nighty-Night true but its more so to prevent people from falling on the tracks. It would be (and I'm sorry to use this as an example) but what happened to this woman. She was inches away from falling on the tracks but the incoming train practically bounced her away from the tracks.
@Jorge Fierro sorry I'm so confused but what you said. what you mean by BLM game, Jorge? And why should I know this?
People have lost their minds...unbelievable
Keep your back against the wall.
Stupid Trump supporter
@@GregoryAlanBaileygamereviews you must be a mind reader to come to that conclusion.
@@GregoryAlanBaileygamereviews - Keep your back against the wall....wimp.
@@jjp5259 Da Fuq?
@@GregoryAlanBaileygamereviews
I don't even like trump but that was disrespectful
at this point, nobody should be even standing that close to the edge to begin with
I always tell my kids to be aware of their surroundings like as if the world is out to get them. It's something I learned before I retired while in the military.
What a miserable life - to be looking over your shoulder every second of every day. I rather get killed than life an entire life in fear and paranoia
Why would your kids be out on the streets you dipshit
@M A toxic feminists
Any updates on this? Tried? Convicted? Sentenced? Can't find update on internet.