PS3 has the best background and camera movements, while the PS4 has the best model imo, I like the cartoony look for the switch but for darker backgrounds like this it just makes the models look unfinished.
Yeoboseyo, it's Rebel-Metaloid! I feel like with the switch they took the animation and models from the ps4 and the shading from psp (also I like your profile picture)
Agreed, the lighting added alot of beauty to the set and made it easier to see around miku while also having a dark aesthetic they were in the board meeting for the game like Person 1: new game, on switch, should we be original? Person 2: ya know the effect we used to make deep sea city underground look unique? Were just gonna use that effect on all songs and just port everything from the first game Person 1: oki
Even though the graphics are inferior, the PS3 wins because the shadder and the camera takes and angles are simply amazing compared to any version, it looks so beautiful.
When you compare it like this, you realize how different and sometimes awkward the Switch lighting is, but when you're playing the game you don't really notice, especially when you're concentrating on hitting the notes
Honestly the toonshader had so much potential, I mean look at the new pvs for catch the wave and roki, would buy the game just for those two songs. If SEGA had just improved the pvs for the older songs maybe the toonshader wouldn't seem so out of place. I'm probably asking too much though seeing as the maximum number of new pvs they can make in a year is 3½
@@mm-tm1cp i feel like they wouldnt even have to edit that much, maybe just fix some colors? They could've also went for a more minimalistic style but just kept everything like so and yeeted a toon shader on
@@roxanaursa8715 I agree the colors are off, harmony = 0 for most of the models. That's why I think if they just started from scratch for the pvs, they would look much more cohesive. edit also just remembered, they could've gave megamix the same treatment as pdf if they were changing the art direction. Project Diva F is the only game I could think of thag overhauled the whole game and gave every model(kinda) and pv a new look. Honestly I'm just salty that SEGA still puts those (no offense to those who like it) stupid edit pvs that reuse the same robotic movements and assets between most of the songs and expects people to pay top dollar for the game when they could just give us better pvs. Sincerely, a bitter fan who only buys the games for the pvs
Graphically the ps4 of course.. But the presentation of Ps3 is a league on it's own. Not only that but the good ending on Ps3 is just freaking beautiful. God I wish they brought that to Future Tone and/or Mega 39's.
Psp: "we sell crack" Ps3: *is god* Ps4: "we are just gonna make miku realistic to hide the fact that there's nothing else interesting" Switch: "my run way look is serving beastars rendering realness"
PSP: cute hair physics PS3: Goes the fuck all out with effects and particles PS4: moody lighting, which emphasizes the dark tones of the song Switch: Runs the best
As someone who has played every Project Diva game since Project Diva 2nd on the PSP, this makes me very happy, while also making me realize that I've been playing these games for like... Holy crap, eight years?
I'm still new to vocaloid and SEGA but I have to say that the PS3 takes the cake for me, the shading on Miku is really nice and the scenery is beautiful (And just look at those special effects! Plus it's the only one with an animated intro). And to top it all off, the lighting is just fantastic. The PS4 one is good but like someone else in the comments said, her model is quite rubbery, plus I never liked how models' noses got shaded in PS4 because it looks kind of creepy, so I appreciate the Switch's graphics in that sense.
Huh, I'm actually surprised by how much more stylised the PS3 version is compared to the others, it honestly makes the PS3 version just much more aesthetically pleasing.
Most of the time, it's because a lot of songs in PSP were also in PS3, however, those select songs on PSP got on the Arcade first and THEN got added to PS3 and the stages on the PVs never got updated on the Arcade once the PS3 version got released, as we know, the PS4 version is an Arcade port, and the stages still didn't get changed by the time the PS4 version got released, and if those stages never get updated on the Arcade, they'll never come to PS4
Psp: weed for 1 dollar Ps3: *casually have way more vibrant colors and good background* Ps4: so we just going to put some shaders Switch: look I know that i look like plastic but switch isn't a sonic pc gamer or a mario sticker ps4
背景凝ってるのがPS3で、ミクさんが凝ってるのはPS4に見える
画質は圧倒的にPS4が勝っているけど、PS3には追加演出という特別な映像もあってそれが個人的にすごい魅力だと思ってる
賛成です！！
ps3めちゃくちゃ背景こだわってるし他より彩度の高いビビットな感じがボカロっぽくて好き
懐かしさを求めるならばPSP
バランスを求めるならばPS3
リアルさを求めるならばPS4
アニメっぽさを求めるならばSwitch
ロースペックの全力
グラフィックを犠牲にしたエフェクト
グラフィックステータス全振り
携帯機のフルパワー
って感じる
コレ答えやろ
PSPの見慣れたミクさんが好き
PS3の演出と色使いが好き
PS4の質感が好き
swichは原点回帰感が強いのに髪動きとかが進化してて好き
どのミクさんもすこだ…
PS3が1番凝ってる感じして好き
動きが滑らかなのはswitch
画質が綺麗なのは4
アレンジが聞いてて色が綺麗なのは3
懐かしくて感動するのはpsp
:)
PS3 has the best background and camera movements, while the PS4 has the best model imo, I like the cartoony look for the switch but for darker backgrounds like this it just makes the models look unfinished.
Yeoboseyo, it's Rebel-Metaloid! I feel like with the switch they took the animation and models from the ps4 and the shading from psp (also I like your profile picture)
Yea I agree.
Agreed, the lighting added alot of beauty to the set and made it easier to see around miku while also having a dark aesthetic
they were in the board meeting for the game like
Person 1: new game, on switch, should we be original?
Person 2: ya know the effect we used to make deep sea city underground look unique? Were just gonna use that effect on all songs and just port everything from the first game
Person 1: oki
Even though the graphics are inferior, the PS3 wins because the shadder and the camera takes and angles are simply amazing compared to any version, it looks so beautiful.
0:14 do you notice the difference?
PSP版のミクさんやっぱり可愛いな
このローポリ具合が機械感があって好き
技術の進化でだんだん人間らしくなったね
PS3の背景の作り込みとか演出が飛び抜けて素敵〜！PS4のミクさんは質感が素晴らしすぎて変態的だわ笑
リアル一辺倒にすることも出来たはずなのに、あえて背景はリアルに、キャラクターはデフォルメ寄りにすることで見やすさやアニメ感を出したあたり時代の流れを読んでいる感じがして好き。
ちょっと日本語が変だな。
「見やすさやアニメ感を重視したあたり」の方が良いね。
ps4の美麗さにps3の演出と表情が合わされば神になる予感
PS3の背景とPS4のミクちゃん組み合わされば最強な気がする
めっちゃわかる。
PS3の背景明るいし、コントラスト効いてるからめちゃくちゃ良いし、アーケードミク(ps4)はやっぱ完成度が他のものと比べもんにならないからな…。これ本当次ので背景改善してほしいな………
米粉パン もし開発されたら絶対売れますよね(確信)
PS持ってない勢ですけどこれは欲しくなる
今頃ですけど、、、
やっぱPS4はリアル感高いし､PS3は付け加えがいいのでやっぱ合わせたら確かに最強ですね!!(語彙力)
それは、わかるてかDIVAXなのかなそれなら
PS3のこだわりがすごい(薔薇とか薔薇とかタイトル出す時とか薔薇とか薔薇とか薔薇とか薔薇とか)
switchのモデルって顔の輪郭とパーツが少し弄られたほぼPS4っぽいね(髪とか服はほぼ一緒)
背景もほぼ演出一緒っぽいしキャラの陰影が主に弄られてるのかな
そう考えると持ち運べるswitchで完全据え置きのPS4レベルの物を動かしてるの凄いなぁ
PS3の背景とかエフェクト？の細かい作り込みが好きです
If the ps4 and ps3 version were together it would be perfect
PS4の圧倒的グラフィック
In my opinion, PS4 has the best model, while the PS3 has the best scenery.
The Spirit In Motion Company, International PS5 - best model and best scenery
PS4の質感が好きなんだけどPS3の明るさと演出がめっちゃ好き
In the Switch version Miku’s shaders said BYE
Ps4 is the opposite lmao
PS3の背景とPS4のミクちゃんをちょっと明るくしたらめちゃくちゃ綺麗に出来てそう
やっぱり新しくなる度に画質やエフェクトも凄くなるけど
自分の中でしっくり来るのは絶対PSPだと思う。
綺麗すぎない少し荒いあの質感がたまらん
そらいちばん綺麗なのはPS4だなって思うけれど、一番愛嬌があるのはPS3かなって個人的に思う
The ps3 PV is so beautiful. It's a little upsetting that they didnt continue to use the roses in later games
Bong Water Is Just Tea I’m a little disappointed too. All the effects made it look so magical and pretty.
PS3の演出でPS4のミクだったらいいな…光の具合もPS4のが綺麗かも
どれが一番とかじゃなくてそれぞれの良いところがあるのエモい
switch批判されまくってるけど生きたアニメ感あって好き
PSPも髪の毛の感じとか愛おしさすごいし
PS3は薔薇とか全体的にすごいし
PS4は現実感がすごい
とりあえずミクは全部好きだ！！
Switch、劣化というよりはSwitchでミクを楽しむ年齢層に合わせたライティングと質感って感じがする。
たなかさん
リアルだからいいというものではない。
私もすごくバランスの良いデフォルメだと思います。
実際Switchってps3より処理性能高いので、ps3より高い質感は表現できるはずですからね。
@@fk9005 というかswichはpspに合わせた感がすごいね。ps4まではいかなくともそれ並の感じにはできるのにわざとしなかった感がすごい。俺はありと思う
画質：PS4
色：PSPとSwitch
演出：PS3
にすれば最高
PS3が1番表情がでてて可愛い
ps3が、他verより曲のイメージを更に大切にしてくれてるんだろうなぁっていうのが伝わってくる。
PS3は光を強く、
PS4は影を強く、
SwitchはPSPを忠実に でもより綺麗に仕上げた
…ようなイメージ。PS3の曲ロゴとかステージのアレンジとかキラキラしてて好きだなー。
PSPはまぁ携帯器ではこんなもんよな
PS3は演出が好き
PS4はさすがのクオリティ
Switchは逆にミクが邪魔してるな
そう思った
1:47 ここのワンカットいれるだけでだいぶ違うわ
あの一瞬で目を奪われた
めっちゃわかる。ps4で無くなって悲し過ぎる
マスケット銃士 せっかく画質もミクの質感も上がったのに…
あれでPS3の演出があれば完璧だった…
ps3だけ力の入れ具合がえげつなくて草
When you compare it like this, you realize how different and sometimes awkward the Switch lighting is, but when you're playing the game you don't really notice, especially when you're concentrating on hitting the notes
皆の意見をまとめると、
どれも誰かにとっての1番
ってことですね。
PS4はせっかくゲームでも
最高レベルの画質なのに
なんか色味が足らないよなぁ
その点画質は劣るもののPS3は
色味は完璧。
PSPとスイッチは
ミクがちょっと浮いてる感じ
これが悪いってわけじゃなくて
ミクの捉え方によって変わってくるんだけど、
ミクはあくまでアンドロイドだから
どこか人間離れしたイメージを持ってる
人は浮いた方のが好みかも。
でも、そこのステージに"存在"
してる雰囲気が欲しいって人は、
陰影がちゃんとあるプレステ派かもね
一言で表すと、
PSP 懐かしさ
PS3 美しさ
PS4 リアルさ
Switch PS3～4の方が綺麗なんだ…
って感じ
psp - where it all started
ps3 - best stage and interpretation
ps4 - best graphics
switch - *sega what happened*
Switch: MY EYES!!! MY EYES!!!
Honestly the toonshader had so much potential, I mean look at the new pvs for catch the wave and roki, would buy the game just for those two songs. If SEGA had just improved the pvs for the older songs maybe the toonshader wouldn't seem so out of place.
I'm probably asking too much though seeing as the maximum number of new pvs they can make in a year is 3½
@@mm-tm1cp i feel like they wouldnt even have to edit that much, maybe just fix some colors? They could've also went for a more minimalistic style but just kept everything like so and yeeted a toon shader on
@@roxanaursa8715 I agree the colors are off, harmony = 0 for most of the models. That's why I think if they just started from scratch for the pvs, they would look much more cohesive. edit also just remembered, they could've gave megamix the same treatment as pdf if they were changing the art direction. Project Diva F is the only game I could think of thag overhauled the whole game and gave every model(kinda) and pv a new look.
Honestly I'm just salty that SEGA still puts those (no offense to those who like it) stupid edit pvs that reuse the same robotic movements and assets between most of the songs and expects people to pay top dollar for the game when they could just give us better pvs.
Sincerely, a bitter fan who only buys the games for the pvs
草生える
PS3が1番初音ミクの良さを引き出せてる気がする…
今のマジミラのミクに近い気はするよね
PSPは髪とかもそうだけど背景の白みとか影が淡い感じでふわふわ（？）してる感じがする。
PS3はかなりアレンジが効いてて演出や色付けがキリッとしたイメージ。
PS４は周りの暗さに一番馴染んでる気がするし、服の光沢や光が自然に映えてる。
Switchはミク自体はかなり単色で構成されてて、少し背景と馴染んでないようでバーチャル感をより感じた。比較するとPSPと似てるかも。
どれも個性が出てて素敵ですね！
Switchのキャラクターが浮いて見えちゃうのすっごく気になる…
PS4の様に背景とキャラクターが同じ様な画にできないなら、いっそSwitchの方キャラクターに合わせた背景にしたら全体的な画の違和感なかったんじゃないのかなって思ってしまった。
Switchで退化してるとか言う人いるけど、持ち運びも出来るやつでこれは凄いと思うべ
Graphically the ps4 of course.. But the presentation of Ps3 is a league on it's own. Not only that but the good ending on Ps3 is just freaking beautiful. God I wish they brought that to Future Tone and/or Mega 39's.
PS3とPS4ばかりに目が行く。
演出と色味とモデルはPS3が好みで､ミクちゃんの肌の質感と光の当たり方はPS4が好み､この2つが合わさったら個人的に神だと思う(語彙力皆無)
曲名の出し方の時点でPS3の優勝
質感はPS4が好きだけどPS3の演出がいい…
確かに、
それな(*´ω｀*)めっちゃわかるv(・∀・*)
分かります
(σ * ॑꒳ ॑*)σｿﾚﾅ♪
元々アーケード勢だから、ACよりのPS4版じゃないと違和感あるんですが・・・
1番やりこんだPS3にサムネからずっと目を惹かれる。綺麗なのは確実にPS4なんだけどなぁ
PS3の背景演出いいねぇ
Switchが1番新しいからいちばんきれいかと思いきやps4とか3がすごいな
Ps3が1番アニメチックな感じとリアルな感じが混じってて好き、ps4まで行くと影の表現が綺麗すぎてドール見てるみたい
PS4は正直に言っちゃうと…なんかロウ人形っぽいのよね
I love the PS3's background and certain flairs the best, but I like the shading and model of the PS4's as well.
PS4 の質感が一番好きだけど、PS3の演出もいいな
PVとしてはPS3のが一番気合い入れてて好き
PS4 had the model with most detail, but PS3 had amazing graphics, effects, and that title animation that was really cool.
Psp: "we sell crack"
Ps3: *is god*
Ps4: "we are just gonna make miku realistic to hide the fact that there's nothing else interesting"
Switch: "my run way look is serving beastars rendering realness"
PSP: cute hair physics
PS3: Goes the fuck all out with effects and particles
PS4: moody lighting, which emphasizes the dark tones of the song
Switch: Runs the best
Switch runs the best?
PS3 background +PS4 miku=perfect for me
演出とお顔はやっぱりPS3が一番好きかなぁ……質感はPS4が本当に存在してるみたいで好きだけど。こうやって並べると本当に画質綺麗になったなって思っちゃう😭
ミクちゃんリアルになったなぁ。
個人的にPS3のエフェクトゴリゴリラな感じが好き
どのミクちゃんでも可愛いんだけどやり込んでたのもあってPSPが私は1番好きかな〜！！！ほんとは全部好き
3と4の融合が最強だと思う…
pspは背景のステンドグラスの色加減も含め淡い優しい感じがしていいし、ps3は演出素晴らしいのとあくまでステージだという事を目立たせる光バキバキ多様なのが魅力。Switchはキャラクターデザインを目立たせていいとこ取り感、ps4は今の技術の暴力により重厚、荘厳でステージというより世界観に溶け込む照明の扱い方でどれも個性それぞれでいいですね！
機械的なミクさんが好きならPSP
凝ったPVが好きならPS3
よりリアルなCGが好きならPS4
ポップでアニメっぽい見た目が好きならSwitch
⋯かな？
同じCGと言えど表現の仕方が色々あって面白いなぁ
Bro F2nd really brought it home with all of the subtle animations and effects
As someone who has played every Project Diva game since Project Diva 2nd on the PSP, this makes me very happy, while also making me realize that I've been playing these games for like... Holy crap, eight years?
i like the ps4 one but the ps3 one has so many cool details like glares and other things that aren't in the other ones
PS4めっちゃ綺麗やな
I'm still new to vocaloid and SEGA but I have to say that the PS3 takes the cake for me, the shading on Miku is really nice and the scenery is beautiful (And just look at those special effects! Plus it's the only one with an animated intro). And to top it all off, the lighting is just fantastic. The PS4 one is good but like someone else in the comments said, her model is quite rubbery, plus I never liked how models' noses got shaded in PS4 because it looks kind of creepy, so I appreciate the Switch's graphics in that sense.
@Yanabay UTAU I went and checked out other comparison videos for different PVs and I have to agree.
こうやって見るとステージ自体結構違うんだな。PS3薔薇が舞ってるし生えてるしですごい好き
PS3のミクちゃんかわいいな 親しみやすさを感じる
PS4が一番好き
細かいところまでリアルな感じがいい👍
Honestly I like PS4's the best, the shadows and the details. But PS3 has some great color.
ミクちゃんはPS4が好きだけど、背景とか演出(?)はPS3が良き
F2ndが1番表情のつくり凝ってて好きだ
0:58とかF2ndだけがこっちを見ている
PSPの画質の感じがすげぇ懐かしい
PS3 is by far the best to me. It actually lools like miku is part of the set. The added lighting and roses etc gives it more character aswell.
Man they put so much more effort on the PS3 version
PS3の好きやけど、PS4のちょっと暗い感じも好き
こうやって見比べて思い返すほどPSP版には驚きと感動があったな
モデリングもローポリでここまで可愛く出来るのかと思った
PSPは昔のCG技術にしては動きとか瞬きとかちゃんとしてて凄い
PS3は背景とかステージの演出が凝ってる
PS4は背景の光とか影が現実に近くてリアル感が増してる
Switchは物理演算がちゃんとしてる
Switch背景はps4とほぼ一緒で良いけど、その分キャラが浮いちゃってる...
Huh, I'm actually surprised by how much more stylised the PS3 version is compared to the others, it honestly makes the PS3 version just much more aesthetically pleasing.
PS3がほどよく綺麗で
尚且つ演出1番凝っててレベル高いね
Ps4 lights and textures looks so good
PSPのミクちゃん髪がもちもちしてて可愛い
PS4が1番人間らしいよね
髪の毛とかめっちゃリアル
PS4が1番ポリゴン多くて可愛いよね
スイッチ否定してる人ここのコメ欄多いけど売上からしてスイッチの方が支持してる人多いんだよなぁ...リアル調のタッチって好み分かれるからアニメ調にして今の若者のウケを狙ったのは流石だと思う。ps3の時からやってる人だとリアル調の方が好きな気持ちも分かるけどね。
PSPがやっぱハードの限界に挑戦してる感あって好き
一番PS3がミク！って感じでめっさすき
PS3とPS4の性能ってほぼ同じらしいですよ
にしても綺麗ですね
Why can’t we have the models in ps4 and the lighting/effects from ps3 in one game? It would be such a perfect blend I don’t get it
Most of the time, it's because a lot of songs in PSP were also in PS3, however, those select songs on PSP got on the Arcade first and THEN got added to PS3 and the stages on the PVs never got updated on the Arcade once the PS3 version got released, as we know, the PS4 version is an Arcade port, and the stages still didn't get changed by the time the PS4 version got released, and if those stages never get updated on the Arcade, they'll never come to PS4
PSP : nice
PS3 : Wow! That's we call as improvement
PS4 : I LUV IT, TAKE MY MONEY
SWITCH :
Psp: weed for 1 dollar
Ps3: *casually have way more vibrant colors and good background*
Ps4: so we just going to put some shaders
Switch: look I know that i look like plastic but switch isn't a sonic pc gamer or a mario sticker ps4
ミク自身の素晴らしさはPS4に軍配だけど、他の表現部分はPS3に軍配上がる気がするな...
Switchはスペックの問題でPSには敵わないけど、懐かしさを感じると考えると良いミクな気がする
PS3 DIVAF〜Xシリーズまでがやっぱり一番好きだなぁ。
PS4のFuture Toneとかのリアルなやつも素敵ではあるんだけど、やっぱ「バーチャルっぽさ」を出せてこそ魅力が最大限に出せると考えてます
Switchはどこから光当ててんだろって位に眩しい