India Is Going to Space, on a Budget
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 มิ.ย. 2024
- India is one of only a handful of nations that have sent probes to the moon and Mars. But the most impressive part of its space program is its cost-effectiveness. Unlike other government space organizations, India's agency is extremely efficient, with the lowest cost-per-kilogram in the industry. Now India is throwing open its doors to private companies and raising its stellar ambitions.
#India #Space #BloombergQuicktake
--------
Like this video? Subscribe: th-cam.com/users/Bloomberg?sub_...
Become a Quicktake Member for exclusive perks: th-cam.com/users/bloombergjoin
Subscribe to Quicktake Explained: bit.ly/3iERrup
QuickTake Originals is Bloomberg's official premium video channel. We bring you insights and analysis from business, science, and technology experts who are shaping our future. We’re home to Hello World, Giant Leap, Storylines, and the series powering CityLab, Bloomberg Businessweek, Bloomberg Green, and much more.
Subscribe for business news, but not as you've known it: exclusive interviews, fascinating profiles, data-driven analysis, and the latest in tech innovation from around the world.
Visit our partner channel QuickTake News for breaking global news and insight in an instant.
in 10 years, we can see an Indian guy on TH-cam on how to make a rocket at home
😂😂😂
That 1000% right!
Lol 🤣🤣🤣👌
"Hello guys, welcome to this tutorial on how to make a gslv mk2 rocket at home"
ikr
Dude 😂😂😂
If you ever get asked the practical benefit of ISRO's space programs - the 1999 super cyclone which hit Odisha took 10,000 lives as precise satellite modelling of the cyclone's path was not available and rescue came after it had passed. Today the cyclones hitting the east coast are precisely tracked by ISRO's satellite network in real time and evacuations done much in advance reducing fatalities to a low double digits or even lesser.
THIS IS WHY I AM VERY LUCKY TO LIVE IN INDIA MOST RICHEST COUNTRY, I CAN'T IMAGINE IF I WAS NOT BORN IN INDIA , VERY SAFE VERY CLEAN, ALWAYS RESPECT FOR WOMEN AND WE HAVE TOILETS ANYWHERE , INDIA IS ROLE MODEL COUNTRY TRUST ME 🤗🇮🇳 I KNOW U JEALOUS NOT LIVE IN INDIA 🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳🤗🇮🇳
This is a silly question. In India per-person cost for ISRO may be less than 100 Rs.
@@indiasuperclean6969 here comes the pakistani spammer
@@Aloksharma-oe1gm I think this spammer chinese
@@S-K555 atleast Chinese people didn't care poopdia 😁
ISRO mainly focuses on what we need instead of what we want. That's what makes it so efficient.
You don't buy what you want but what you need when you are on a tight budget.
Those individuals who r barking like "thank you or love from india ", should know that they r either unemployed or not in a position to represent india. So fuking stop it. Have shame !!
From a fellow indian
@@ffless man you're a grumpy kid. 😃
@@ffless another frustrated pakistani in the comment section 🤣
@Aakash Mandal Lol I am not an Indian but this man smells like he is an anti-Indian living in India, what can be more beneficial for us. Keep going 👍👍🤣
People question billions getting spent on space research, but never question trillions getting spent on weapons, and militaries.
I question both being a libertarian
True
@@jeremywendelin if it wasn't for space travel you may not have that smartphone in your pocket. It was the miniaturization of the transistor to be able to fit on rockets which gave rise to our current technology. So i think space travel is important.
They question rightfully as Indian spending on space research is for strategic, militaristic and national interest, not expanding boundaries of science
@@osamaz2780 and USA, China, Japan, Europe etc. spend billion with their whole heart for expanding boundaries of science. Why a country would spend billions on space? To expand boundaries of science?.
The amount of inspiration ISRO provides is priceless.
Ya propaganda is a powerful weapon, especially when played off people hopes, dreams, and imaginations.
@@philtanics1082 like weapons of mass destruction 🌝
@Manpreet Singh w*sterners 🤮
@Manpreet Singh Excessive patriotism and racism (not unusual in India) is pathetic in the 21st century. Couldn't find your money either, sorry.
@@tonyrandall3146Patriotism, racism what not!! Why are you guys so obsessed with India or associate anything with whatever India does. You guys are disgusting & racist yourself. Look at yourself in the mirror once. If a country is trying to work in education & science, what Patriotic & racist in it? Lately I've got know how pathetic you guys can be.
Dr. A. P. J Abdul Kalam, Dr Satish Dhawan, Dr. Vikram Sarabhai, Dr. Brahm Prakash were the some of the greats who laid the strong foundations for ISRO.
Dont forget Dr. UR Rao
dont forget H.J. Bhabha
@@its.Sarthak101 I think he was more into nuclear stuff than space
@@premprasun1516 he was actually one of the founding fathers of India's space program and India's space program was a branch of India's nuclear program in early days. . I will incorage you to listen ISRO podcast on Spotify. It worth listening.
Add Dr. Nambi narayan too..
I still remember new york times cartoon mocking India on its successful mars mission. There is so much to achieve and so much to prove for ISRO. Godspeed ISRO
it's horrible.. India has bad record of safety in everything from transportation to construction.
@@lifeisneverthesame910 so does that have any with indian space program?
@@youknowme2322 ignore it man...replying them is not worth it...it is their intention to insult...let them say whatever they want...we have a long and tough way ahead with alot of people like these...you can't reply to all of them....just focus on improvement...
@@youknowme2322 India simply can't compete with China in space exploration..
@@lifeisneverthesame910 pakistani triggered
Alternative title: India is doing space travel *"efficiently"*
One can be efficient with both a large budget and a small budge.
Cant get anymore efficient than they way its already being done - using CGI and models.
@@delhiboy0105 You can, but you won't. That's how large budget always works. India's Mars mission was so cost effective because it had to be, not because we chose to make it at 1/8th the cost of the US space program despite having the funds. Efficiency usually comes from constraints.
@@abishekraju4521 you're just assuming that all large budget projects are not efficiently executed. I'm simply saying that the title of the video is correct
@@philtanics1082 man you are weird
When people say that India should focus on their poor instead of spending so much on space exploration. I have an answer for you. We Indians don't do this for pleasure, tourism or for showing our grandeur. We do it on the basis on our needs. Unlike NASA, SpaceX, Blue origins we don't do it for rich people. We do it for our own national needs.
❤️❤️🎉💪🇮🇳
Well said 🔥
Well done bro you the things you said r 100%true
Many satellites launched by us are communication, defense, or survey satellites. No one realizes that many farmers get benefited by weather satellites. Communication satellites provide access in remote areas. Every year people are evacuated before cyclones strike due to weather satellites. Your statement is 100% correct.
@@aadixum yep
No matter what topic the video is made on India, Western media makes sure images of poor people are shoved down the throat of the audience. Also they do not miss a any opportunity to mock the accent. The praise is always sarcastic. Jealously is a sign that India is on the right path.
where did they show any of that here?
These white skinned are mocking us.
Lol.
Who takes them seriously lol6
You can’t deny that it exists Everywhere in India
@@joshuatheunkownuniverse.2475 your country’s government takes them seriously.
Yikes your comment is very aggressive for no particular reason. India is a poor country but after all it is developing. They receive a lot of support from the West
ISRO in my opinion is the most prime and precious sector of our country. We fail to succeed not to give up. I am so proud of ISRO and my country.
yes indeed isro shows that curiousity has no bounds ; not even lack of money
Those individuals who r barking like "thank you or love from india ", should know that they r either unemployed or not in a position to represent india. So fuking stop it. Have shame !!
From a fellow indian
@@ffless stop being grumpy, kid. 😂😂
@@ffless people like you should have so shame, not people who love their country and culture
@@ffless Take a nap 😴… relax..
We requested US for GPS during Kargil War, they denied so we built our IRNSS.
We requested US for upper stage Cryogenic engine, they denied and forced us to not buy it from Russia , so we built our own.
We just don't want to be dependent on anyone and we will persue to do what is best in the interest of our nation. Poverty is everywhere but it should not be able to anchor down a country's scientific progress.
One must be out of mind to rely on US
@@ST-ze8yh right! Russia has proven to be a more dependable partner
Beautifully said Deshmukh... Thank you Sir.
@@arjunarun9147 Yes, you are right too. Russia has never abundant their friends but US ever betrayed the past Vietnam, present Afghanistan and many others when they see their interests were exhausted... Unscrupulous
India ❤ Russia I never knew. I also didn't know USA and India weren't friends. Thanks for educating me.
One thing more, I would like to point out is the role of Indian people. Even though our people may be poor but they do understand the importance of space innovation, we celebrate our launches , we stand-by our scientist during failures. I think this is pretty commendable.
ignore it man...replying them is not worth it...it is their intention to insult...let them say whatever they want...we have a long and tough way ahead with alot of people like these...you can't reply to all of them....just focus on improvement...
Indians aren’t poor, poverty is everywhere
🌹🌹👍
من اليمن..
نبيل الرداعي
What an amazing sentiment. Would be amazing if we had Americans stand by our own scientists rather than how we currently bring them down for every innovation
@sagar Quoting "statistics" like you have mean nothing without providing your source. I could say Indian extreme poverty level is 93% and it would have the same validity as your figures because I too don't quote my source. I did of course, make up my figure there. Did you?
China and India rising powers, defying the west colonialist complex. The future is in Asia led by these two giants. I'm Mexican and have deep respect for China and India. Without destabilizing poor countries and financing armed conflict they have managed to rise through the headlines and become primary countries in the world stage.
But in reality it so sad the west are playing india in this fight for dominance in Asia!!!
But indian's are happy in getting played by america & Israel as long as they think they are getting seen & treated like equal's but in reality there still getting treated & seen like 2nd class citizens.
I think this documentary proves how the people in the west & in power really see indian's in general!!!
The world's a paradox the indian's have a caste system in there country but there considered untouchables by the western world!!!
@@3-Kashmir As an indian i could not care less about what western society thinks about us, nobody in india has the time to do that. Catse system was the gift from the british and biased western media made it a stereotype. Poverty is also one stereotype about india that west has. Secondly, no one is playing india, we are simply too big, too rich and too strong to become a pawn on the global stage, neither usa nor israel has the capability to "control" us. You seem to be a person that is either jealous or projecting the failures of your own country upon us, cope.
@@3-Kashmir And we know this.
We aren't fool.
Please don't come to America.
@@davidturner4076Don't send American companies to Indian colleges for placement and stop H1B visa.
we will consider India as Asia's big brother and hope India can surpass China in all aspects and I love Indian movies, love from Vietnam
Love from India
two trashbags greeting each other🤣
Love you too Bro.
@@dpjb38 really ?? Who's best in your view? Afganistan 😐
@@dpjb38 Abdul real id se aa
We Indians need to encourage Curiosity, Research and Innovation right from the primary public education.
Space is the future.
Curiosity is already there , remember everyone wanted to be astronaut , inventor scientist rather than engineering
It's society and gov that failed to deliver
@@kaustubhraizada engineering is all about Curiosity, Research and Innovation
Space program is just media, you want to go to "space" get into CGI and special effects, its how all the other countries do it.
Yet Tesla still face 100% import duty if they want to sell their EV in India?
@@ryannguyen7466 Tesla cars in India are not what India needs or what ordinary Indians can afford to buy. The rich Indians who can buy it can afford to pay the import duties.
India is an incredible nation..... Everyone in the earth will agree this!
❤❤❤ but not everyone will agree as there are many dumb haters and racists
Tnx. Btw we still have a long way to go
Well done my Indian friends... Glad to see it
beech shut up and keep working on ur life, stop blabbering nonsense. We got freedom same date as South korea got. Now where we r both we can imagine.
@@ffless bruhh!!!??
@@xlr8153 he is Pakistani
@@ffless Are you gone mad? First learn English and stop spamming before someone reports you.
Go India ♥️🇮🇳♥️🇺🇳
Those individuals who r barking like "thank you or love from india ", should know that they r either unemployed or not in a position to represent india. So fuking stop it. Have shame !!
From a fellow indian
@@ffless stop spamming dude
Dankjewel
@@ffless bot
Seeing india grow like this make me so proud to be Indian
india needs to focus on their slums
@@hsvr doesn't make sense ,
Let me tell you
The more we launch projects the more people will get jobs and the more poverty ratio will decrease
And when poverty ratio will decrease automatically people will change their living standards
@@hsvr that's the reason why India does these missions foreigner
@@hsvr he is just a hater
Because of modi and his gov
To the people who are still wondering why is it justifiable for any country to have a space program despite having 'poverty', please do us all a favor and educate yourself on the applications of remote sensing and satellite imagery, hopefully you'll get your answers.....
I wonder if Bloomberg would ever do a piece on how remote sensing and the satellites launched by ISRO has progressed multiple sectors in India, about how it made weather forecasting more accurate, how its application has played out in agriculture, disaster management, forest, land and water resource managements, education, business, defense, employment 'n research opportunities..... since it's Bloomberg, how about crunching some numbers and estimating how that lifted so many Indians above the poverty indicators.....Well, it's Bloomberg...might as well think homelessness would be nil and affordable medicine 'n Healthcare is possible in USA
Well said 👌🏼
Well said mam 🙌🏼
Bloomberg answered the same thing in this video itself from 10:25 ... i don't understand why you people can't bear even mentioning of challenges that our country is facing... such blindness!
Why are you nitpicking on issues of an other country to justify something nobody has a problem about?
Those individuals who r barking like "thank you or love from india ", should know that they r either unemployed or not in a position to represent india. So fuking stop it. Have shame !!
From a fellow indian
I m 16 Yrs Old from India I wanna Start My Own Space Exploration Company 🙂 I hope I can achieve this and make my country proud 😊
✌✌😍
Same but i wanna start camera manufacturing company
I want my company rule camera market 😩🥰
Don't be hesitate to ask for help. Best of luck bro!
All the best ✨
Samee broo..😁🤞
India literally started their space program from very little and during tough times.
Salute to ISRO
*Incoming comments about poverty and stuff. "You guys need to chill and take a break"*
ignore it man...replying them is not worth it...it is their intention to insult...let them say whatever they want...we have a long and tough way ahead with alot of people like these...you can't reply to all of them....just focus on improvement...
Westerners criticise Indians for just being patriotic but these guys are literally n*zis lol
But you can't deny the fac that india is still very poor right I mean these kinds of space developments all only are going help the upper middle class and above echelons of the society . A big part of India will still not helped with this. That's a fact . No offense iam Indian i totally am for this kind of space developments and reasearch and innovations
@@bloodwargaming3662 most of the stuff India does nowadays are for improvement of Indian society overall, I do agree with space tho, except the launching of Indian satelite are useful for Indian society
Failure is a part of success...
Maybe not today but one day ISRO will write a history that will be remembered forever !!
It will and it not so far
@@dkbros1592 yes bro 🇮🇳✨✌️👑
ISRO already wrote histrory with Mangalyan and Chandrayan missions. But yeah, many more accomplishments to come!
Already found water on the other side of moon 🌒
According to some people if isro budget will be spend on poverty then whole indian will start living in luxury😂
Wahi! 😂😂
While conveniently ignoring the benefits that space program bought!
We don't even spend that much on ISRO. Like 0.5% of our GDP
@@BlackHawkTejas EXACTLY. WHILE ALSO CONVENIENTLY IGNORING THE FACT THAT THE GOVT IS ALREADY SPENDING MANY TIMES MORE MONEY ON POVERTY THAN WE SPEND ON OUR SPACE PROGRAM.
@@rockyyadav1695 we spend like 0.01 percent of our GDP on ISRO
Funding space programs is worthless instead leave it to highly technology advanced,science,space to us,russia,china and india government should providing that money to poor ppl
I am remembering that how NYT mocked India when we successfully launched our managalyan mission . Mahatma Gandhi had said that first they will ignore u then they will make fun of u then u will win against them
They are being racist against Indians because India is not Africa, so no global outrage will create. This way they could fuel their racist/colonial mindset.
@@rajatsharma2611 exactly
@@rajatsharma2611 so true!!
Then they join you
Yeah they never did that. Idk why you Indians are so obsessed with Western media. Here the people of the West and our media is very empathetic towards you and your country. You are just trying to make enemies when in fact those same people are your friends and allies
Actually surprised to see the media reporting something positive about India, Indian companies and PM Narendra Modi! Finally some appreciation and different reporting
Yep! Was extremely surprised, lets see for how long they sustain it though!!
They would report more positive things if the government wasn’t doing overwhelmingly negative things
@@amansinghrathore2344 Government ain't doing overly negative thing! 🤦🏻♂️
@@BlackHawkTejas inflation, covid, unemployment, farmers, doctors, hate, Nationalism are overtly negative things.
@@kerriekupar6466 Unemployment, Covid I agree others are issues that are being made into! Also art to Covid state played joke!! The amount of negativity you guys say mostly comes from opposition & vested interests.
Mr Modi is doing it if this guy stays for 10 more years country would change, you showed the phote where 2 kids are sitting in candlelight , but when we see the data on ground government is not only spending on space , but is also provided more electrical grid coverage than before , and the number of toilets that re built in india since last term of pm modi is remarkable , india have made more toilets than whole of middleeast combined , and on top of that the coverage of toilets is above 90% which is crazy
If Modi stays for 10 year India will head to civil war
Yes offcourse 👍
@@ihavenojawandimustscream4681 well wat abt genocides in late 80 and early 90 when no modi was there
IMO, India should prioritize robotic autonomous space systems over human space missions.
India is working on it too. But human mission experience is immensely important as in the future Indians will have to explore other planets and human missions will always play a crucial role in that.
THE AMOUNT OF WORK WHAT NASA'S "CURIOSITY ROVER" IS DOING ON MARS FRO THE PLANNED YEARS
A HUMAN CAN DO IN A WEEK OR TWO
we can make robots but at some situations we need to some extra things that are not pre-planned for that humans are the one and will be.
Also robots take much time to do single mission even in future we make it fast to and more accurate
Still humans are no.1 choice to explore till Mars
@@sachindubey7560 space travel are very risky and also human are very weak. It need a life support (food, water, oxygen, etc) in order to survive. Those thing are very heavy and will cost alot of money in order to launch it to orbit
@@user-gc1hg9sp9k I THINK U ARE UNAWARE OF SPACE PHYSICS AND ENGINEERING
HUMANS ARE MADE TO DO THAT CHALLENGING OURSELF IS TO 8NCREASE THE UNDERSTANDING AND CAPABILITIES.
IF NASA THOUGHT THAT IN 1930S HUMANS WOULD HAVE NEVER WENT TO THE SPACE
SO ITS INDEED IS DANGER BUT MANY THINGS ARE DONE TO ESCAPE THE DEATH
@@sachindubey7560 it is possible....if you have the money. There reason why we can land on the moon in 1960-70s is because US government put billion dollar of money into NASA in roder to defeat soviet during space race,
But after the fall of soviet union nasa budget are cut signicantly. that the reason why we never put a man on the moob againt because it simply too expensive and nasa dont have budget to do such mission
If budget were like $20-40 billion then that 'poor country' argument was understandable (sort of) but western nations crying over just $2 billion budget (not even 0.1% of India's GDP)? Must be jealous or scared of ISRO's progress lol.
Both jealous and scared of ISRO'S progress
@Prasanta Debbarma exactly
Why should the West jealous about India? Lol. You guys aren't famous with space program but toilets
a mix of colonial jealousy and racism
@@yewsingooi9573 then why doesn't the west mind its own business, instead of mocking our achievements in space
Efficiency is the net word.
Just wait until the Indian space budget expands in the next few decades
Wait until the growing Indian private space industry starts bearing fruits
very impressive that India is doing the extraordinary that only a few countries are doing. Very inspirational and respected.
Space is the next frontier right
@White Fox it has very much improved, although one can never be sure because of the large population
@White Fox that's right bro
India is so backward.
@White Fox how u know that they have toilet problems ?
Show the world, India! Show the world space travel can be far economical than is being demonstrated!
Well SpaceX is doing that so let's hope that ISRO can achieve their status
@@napobg6842 There would be nothing wrong with having two space launch options that would be affordable. The big space launch companies have to get a grasp on reality. Just because it works a certain way does not mean it will not work in a more economical manner. Work used plastic trays to transport tools from work station to work station. It worked great for decades. Every year new plastic trays were bought. The old, damaged, plastic trays were thrown away but stayed in a landfill for a very long time and were quite pricey. Now we use thick, corrugated cardboard trays. We throw the trays onto the cardboard recycle machine when ever they break. Every week, we get new thick cardboard trays. The shipping cardboard is thrown into the machine also, used paper, and the such. Our tool transport trays are now only the cost of the fuel to run the machine. The fuel is nothing but diesel for the DC generator. On top of that, no plastic trays on the landfill. People have to start thinking of cheaper but equal ways of doing things for everything, not just space launches and exploration.
FIrst rocket of ISRO was transported on the back of cycle, like bike with pedals. You can google the real image its really a motivating story with lots of passion and not a lot of money but still achieving the obj they set to achieve
It was done to avoid detection by foreign spy agencies. Low budget is a foolish narrative spread by meme pages. Dont you think à country that can fund a rocket, cant use there military trucks to transport its satellite.
@@Abhishek-qv8zd no lol. It was a sounding rocket, not a threat to any country. They didn't use trucks because ISRO wasn't even considered seriously by govt officials at that time. It was seen a as a bunch of nerds doing nerd stuff and wasting money.
@@thekrakenrises9040 yes you are right , many Indians didn't even know that there's a thing like ISRO
Why is India so poor in the first place to have those stories? If it was certain other countries, the media would be saying how much of a failure they are and thus in need of regime change and dissolution.
@@tritium1998 This story is from 1963, and yes India was truly a poor country back then.
I was surprised when the video started that what happened to the Western media? Why are they not showing poor people and slums of India?
So 9:58 there you go. Western media never actually disappoints us. They always says a huge number of people are poor in India and India 🇮🇳 is sending money on building satellite. We know your concern Western countries and your media. We will build satellite and we will give you challenges in space sector.And it will surely grow us.
They will always mock India with poverty n all. But i don’t understand one thing. How does space exploration and poverty related? Many countries in Africa don't have space sector, but have more poverty than India. This is just a propaganda and sort of jealousy of westerners.
@@akshaykhandve1122 Yes, you are absolutely right. They are not concerned about poverty of India 🇮🇳. They are concerned about the progress of India 🇮🇳.
@@akshaykhandve1122 Look at history and you will understand
But isn't it true.. Why do u think we have so low budget on research and space sectore?? It's not that western countries stops from increasing our budget.. Stop playing the victim card and do something so that no one dares to say such things in the future..
@@ranvirsingh1004 We should just ignore them for now and keep developing the country while making strides into space. We can't develop without space technologies. The future is in space, and also, you can't please everyone. Thus, grab some water and relax... no need to get worked up over a TH-cam comment, of all things.
10:08
Correction:- India has 100% toilet access(govt sources) and
99%+(UN).
10:26
Awais Ahmed:-It's not about Either or,it's about both.
In modern technology having a satellite and space tech isn't a perk rather a necessity.
This doesn't only gives a certain dvantages but also motivates youth and fellow citizens.
These people are paid to do propoganda
Yeah but only for Urban areas. In rural areas the % is still over 20%
@@napobg6842 read wikipedia
@@napobg6842tbh it's not because toilets haven't reached those places
It's because the older generation in rural areas aren't ready to change their mindset and adopt measures for sanitation
@@valetudan234 Yeah sometimes it is hard to change the mindset especially of older people.
I'm very excited to see how ISRO does. India is a country of over a billion people. Do you realize how many engineers there are in a population of that size?
The amount of budget ISRO has it's doing really great and there are many important missions to be executed and launched in future.
I hope it succeeds in it.
@Neil Deep That's why ISRO spot at 5th best space agency of world
@@sdhappyprince if that is the case then India is no different from Pakistan who always relates science and scripture..
@Neil Deep That's why India have the thrid highest number of unicorn companies in the world.
@@lifeisneverthesame910 Atleast our scriptures don't tell us that the earth is flat. Hinduism has been made a religion, a thing it never was untill the Brits made it so. Zero, yes, the number, was first mentioned in an Indian religious scripture. The founder being Aryabhatta. Was any of what we have achieved possible without 0? . Our scriptures told us the distance between the Earth and the Sun way before space even became a prominent subject. And this is just a tip of the iceberg
Modi hug is a landmark that remains in hearts of millions
He's just show off photo opportunity 😂😂😂😂😂
@@ganeshnaik9463If he didn't hug sivan you guys will blame him by saying " why Modi didn't console him"
@@ganeshnaik9463 keep crying just like how communists and librandus are doing rn.
@@ganeshnaik9463 librandu
@@ganeshnaik9463 who has stopped other leaders to not do so? Do you know how idiotic you sound?
India because of it's shear size population and economic growth will always remain one of the most influential country in the world.
Yes large populations are helpful as workers and employees
@@mistric5951 that what other nations doing towards india.
Now india is in thirsty for a change
Most influential? 😂🤡
"will always remain"
Yup. Just like china and japan
These guys spent 15min talking about India's space industry without once mentioning about Gaganyaan or the upcoming space station 😂
Western Media's love for India. Its a no brainer.
Upcoming space station? India still hasn't just a human flight your 'upcoming spacestation' will be upcoming in 30's
@@vladimirsorokin9674 we're gonna have our first manned mission in the beginning of the next year... space station within 8-10 years
@@vladimirsorokin9674 Human flight is in 2023 , and Russia has train our Astronauts
But toilet definitely comes up in discussion.
People get weird about space spending but no one cares about military spending
Yes they do.
Double standards or lack of any basic knowledge!
@@pleasy13 Not on the same scale!!
@@BlackHawkTejas Literally, the main criticism of america is its military budget and people keep making jokes about it.
This is staggering what they have achieved.
@The Diffraction of LIGHT Get to Mars on their first attempt
@The Diffraction of LIGHT gravity
@@kuroki2986 bhai wo shaayad flat earth thinking waala h 😂 tu apna video dekh mast
@The Diffraction of LIGHT u need serious emergency education
@The Diffraction of LIGHT I bet you think the earth is flat right?
so if space is not real, so what you expect when you reach high up? a dome?
I really love Indian accent, so cute ❤ I don't like nations and nationalism any kind, but I stand for science and Indians are very big friend of science.
Sorry but most of the Indians identify themselves as Nationalist. Nationalism is in blood of people. Specially when I see at people from north eastern state of India I feel like I should salute those people and their nationalism and patriotism. Only Woke people don't identify themselves as Nationalist and as Elon Musk said, woke sucks.
Nationalism is based
@@mopping4600 and we only need based. Just like Us.
@@mopping4600 we need patriotism which has now been replaced with Nationalism and devotion to a particular party. Nationalism is cringe
@@AS-jo8qh hmm, I will consider it
INDIA never gives up , and with Chandrayaan 3 they proved it Today, 🤘
Of which year is the data of 360 million people under poverty?
Also 98.21% of people have access to toilet but yeah here 1-2 % also mean 1.25 crore + people but it's improving.
I think they hadn't upgraded their research.
Their data is outdated
@@ravanasura8308 yes
And those 1-2% people will never get toilet because the tribal peoples don't even now what is india
@@xavier7888 shut up the unknown tribal people who don't know about other world and technologies is only in senital Islands in Andaman and nicobar Islands of India.
In USA also some people don't have toilets, they literally 💩 on roads, underbridge, empty buildings, etc.
When it comes to budget and Quality, answer is India ..
Not really
@@davout5775 yes it is, India is also on its way to build it's own space station. If the ISRO had the same budget as NASA we will already be on Mars. Even in US Biden said that Indian Americans are taking over U.S despite being minority as 1% of the entire U.S population.
Talking about space and then suddenly.... Oh Poor Indians - No Toilets.....
What is this Bigotry...😏... Kitna jalte ho bhai 😂....
US Russia and Europe also had poors.... And now... When China has own Space Station and India has Budget friendly space missions... You are having existential crisis. 😂
It's kinda funny that they are trying to show "people using 4g smart phones, sitting alongside their parked 2 wheelers in front of a local shop that never runs of out stock" : as poor just because they are brown and are wearing a dhoti.
Why doesnt USA solve its student debt problem using NASA's budget?
Smartphones are dirt cheap thanks to China and the West. Especially cheap in cities.
@@Levitiy India does assemble most of its latest smartphones, and offers the lowest data rates in the world. Access to technology is academically equated to financial prosperity.
Except for South Indian people,, most people in rest of India doesn't wear dhoti,, here in West Bengal even the old people don't wear Dhoti (except for special occasions),, although people above 75 years age sometimes wear dhoti
@@Levitiy not the West....only thanks to China
@@sayanbiswas3563 So, what are you trying to say?
Small example of how much political will and domestic Intelligence can do SO PROUD TO SEE THIS🥳🥳
I love my isro and proud of my Indian scientist 🇮🇳😊
For hatters,
If you have any problem with someone being proud of their country then you are either living under a rock or thinking only your version of patriotism is correct 😑
@Pranav 🕵 no hatters
Koi hate wali comment hai hi nhi lekin pehle se hi ro de rhe ho😂😂😂😂
@@GamingwithBlaze hain bhai ek Chinese mf almost sabke comments me hate spread kar rhi hai
Indians buy more fire crackers during Diwali than the entire budget of ISRO, just to put things into perspective.Imagine India ramping up the program!
In future I will earn so much money that I can invest in isro
India is not a country, it's an emotion😍
@@dhawalyerne2570 lol hlo peaceful 😂
@@dhawalyerne2570 no update yourself
$2100 per capita.....
Yeah actually I love having a pride though the economy's less though there are problems...we still stand in not some but many global achievement so yeah emotion for India is endless..🙌👍
@@dhawalyerne2570 Maybe in your country Nationalism, patriotism depends on per capita, but not in ours.
@@dhawalyerne2570 yes
@@dhawalyerne2570 It depends on the cost of living & inflation. Pakistan has world's worst inflation. It's also about efficiency. With lesser than 0.5% of annual budget we've such successful space program. Matter of pride. It's not any small achievement. May be for your small mind Abdoool boy. Stick to what you're goot at.
I just tried Indian food for the first time ever, wow. Amazing
dude what did you eat?
😔
You
Yeah, very much relevant here.... 😶
Have some lamb curry and baati rice, also try some lamb(mutton) seekh keba.
Classic western media modus operandi: if you are talking about India remind the world of how poor India is with shots of garbage dumping grounds irrespective of the topic of discussion.
It would be nice if they stopped dumping their garbage into rivers, which then get into the sea. Even having garbage collection at all would be a great leap forward for them and others. They ought to stop asking for financial aid from the UK too. ;)
@@pleasy13 uk stopped giving aid in year 2014 or 2013 dude when is uk going to return stolen artifacts
@@pleasy13 give us back 45 trillion dollars and we surely will.
@@pleasy13 financial aid from the UK? Nice joke.
At least according to western media india isnt full of corruption and nepotism
I still remember how India was the first nation to reach Mars orbit in its first attempt! And at such an efficient and cheap price.
It was lower than the price of the Hollywood movie "gravity".
Yeah but still when it comes to price for what it is you can't really compare it to anything else. The Indian mission was nothing but a technology demonstrator. So really it was a test orbiter. If India attempted something of NASA's scale it would be much more expensive. Ofc it will not be as expensive let alone more expensive (maybe) but still. Also being able to do it on the first attempt is not all that impressive considering it was done in the 60s for the first time
@@davout5775 no we did actually research
@@piyushdevnath293 Some scientific work might have been done but it is only for technological demonstration and testing. That's pretty much it. That's why it cannot be compared with anything else from America
@@davout5775 even uk can't send rocket in space in 2023 lol shame on uk france 🤣🤣
Why lots of chinese pakistani bots spreading hatred against this video too??
I see them on TH-cam Instagram Facebook Twitter everywhere
@@user-nj6vp1hg5r Jalte hai isliye comment karte hai!
That day is not that far away when we’ll hear the news about India’s first Muslim astronaut fighting to wear a Burkha onboard the rocket instead of a spacesuit..
And we’ll see lots and lots of protesters supporting her decision..
Best wishes for India from Peshawar
ISRO is pride of India ❤️
10:15 I still don't know why always everyone telling India don't have enff toilets by 2020 India has almost 98% of toilets and poverty is now 20% plz don't talk trash by seeing old data
Space frontier will be amazing
@The Diffraction of LIGHT hahhahahahahhahahahahhaa
The final quote is key. About how Space travel and exploration is being done by certain part of the world with the capital. So, they have representation over everybody else.
There is only a handful of countries with the necessary financial means of getting into space. That is simply how the world works.
Something of which western media is jealous. Don't forget the cartoons released by NYT and BBC when India became the 4th nation in the world to send Orbiter to Mars.
India should get around $5-$6 billion is space budget to do really ambitious projects.
Surprisingly no negativity in this article.
Bloomberg is showing poverty,starving side of negative india
@@mohammedfaraaz1240 I wanted to hear verbal negativity, which normally any western chanel always shows. But they didn't use poor or hindu right wing etc words.
Fun fact - Many young indian students like me have a lot of interest in space but aren't able to chase their dream of becoming a space scientist / astrophysicist / astronomer just because in these professions, the salary is very menial. So, ultimately all those students choose COMPUTER SCIENCE ENGINNERING. And, hence the talent gets freakin' wasted.
Sit for BARC exam
Isro should focus on more different mission rather than doing same mission what others did so ISRO will have its own identity in space sectors ,i think it should implement AI in space like crazy more autonomos ,more navigational and many more so that it can be in its position around the world
Small steps initially for ISRO, however, repeated they may seem, will lead to taking an innovative giant leap later for humanity.
ISRO didn't even sent it's own astronaut crew into space like China, Russia and US. Idk what's the fuss about, Chinese space missions are more advanced, innovative and superior to Indian ones.
@@molamola8305 True. Unless we try we will always be busy catching up. This industry has a lot more potential and economic opportunity and also gives India the right place among the major players.
@@molamola8305 ah yes "this country does better than us so we must not be proud"
@@molamola8305 The fuss is about the low costs of the missions.
For your information ,That mission was 91% successful.
Its last stage was that landing ok which failed because of connection lost. So pls give accurate information.
In space it is all binary. You either get there or you dont. 0 or 1. All or nothing.
@@itsmesuryat7570 IN SCIENCE NOTHING IS SIMPLE OR BINARY. SCIENCE IS VERY COMPLEX AND NUANCED. IT WAS 90% SUCCESSFUL AND 10% FAILURE. THATS WHY MOST THINGS IN SCIENCE ARE MEASURED IN PERCENTAGES
@@itsmesuryat7570 there were two missions not just one ..one was successful other was not
@@itsmesuryat7570 rover successful and lander performed all manuver correctly except de acceleration on time
Waiting for a racist new york Times cartoon 🙌
We do everything on a budget 😂
So true
we have to thanks to the lovely british
cheaper than a movie is a slap on Hollywood and NASA for doing things very expensively. india is achieving and humiliating at the same time. btw frugal engineering in india stands for jugaad. we Indians are proud that this culture is in our space organization too
That's impressive but for India and it is definitely not humiliating anybody. It is a great achievement for India and their capabilities because they proved they can successfully send a orbiter around Mars. Yet you can't say that it is humiliating the likes on NASA or the American space industry as a whole. India has never done anything like what NASA is doing. And yes it is much more expensive to do it in the US due to much better paid engineers yet you can't say that it is humiliating. Also a direct comparison cannot be made with any NASA mission. The orbiter send on Mars was a capability tester. Meaning proving if India can send something there or not. You can't make comparisons
Prime Minister MODI is the real man behind Indian's aerospace sector getting boost. Be it private or govt companies, Modi knows space's imprtance.
we won't forget some western media were mocking on our failure.
Which one?
*This is great news.* the more people / countries / companies going to space, means it will get cheaper, faster, safer.
everything is going to be turned into weapons sooner or later, so safer is like ehhh MAYBE
@@laduzitv5019 I'm not sure about that. I think as we advance / evolve we are becoming less violent (as a species), even though it may not seem that way when looking at the world today.
@@laduzitv5019 no no, he has a point
@@JJs_playground let's be real here, we are going to have competition no matter what
@@JJs_playground tbh looking at the modern world I'd say the ancient times were more peaceful with less wars
To all my fellow Indians, instead of telling everyone how proud you are of our magnificent scientists, study hard and build upon their achievements! I am studying hard so that one day I can make my country people proud of me!
I've seen 100s of Bloomberg videos till date... All of them totally biased against the growth and well being of India. For the first time I was surprised to see it's video being almost not biased against the growth & future prospects of India. What's cooking???
China Pivot! A little diversification for Western nations. 😂 They need cheap labours, because lot of Americans don't want to work on frontlines. Someone has to do factories to make goods, that's where Chinese and Indians fill in - pretty much.
The views....is what they want
They are not biased ,it’s showing you the truth which you don’t like ,that’s why you find them biased
I may not like the current Govt much, but gotta say, under Modi, who also is the cabinet minister for DoS, ISRO's budget has increased rapidly. I remember it was 1.3 billion$ in 2017, and 2 billion$ in 2020. ISRO achieved so much by missions commissioned around 2010, I am very excited to see how this increased funding bores fruit in the next 5-6 years.
They now working many projects simultaneously in coming years we will see many Launches
For admiring anyone's work you need not to criticize the individual first . Modi is not a authoritarian ruler ,he won 2 times simultaneously general elections by indian votes . Have some sense
@@feedgyantv1780 It's become a habit. They want to hate Modi but they just can't 😂
Modi government ke under 1.4 trillion dollars se jyada ke infrastructure project chal rahe h 16 news aaim, 9IIT,6 IIM banaye 7 saal m congress 70 saal m 3 aiims, 6 IIT 3 IIM banaye the, 28 expressway ( including delhi mumbai) 120 semi highway, maal gaadi ke liye alag track WDFC EDFC) , RRTS rapid rail, bullet train, 100% railway electrification, 12 port 30 air port, 124 railway station ka redevelopment shamil h ( gandhi nagar, laxmi ,Rani kamlapati completed ) 6 new Metro 7 saal m banai 9 shaharo mai under construction h , jo sb 2026 tk pure ho jayenge kuch 2024 tk ho jayenge
So why you hate a person who bought development to India for the first time without corruption.
I don't like any politician but still I'll vote modi because there's no other f#@king option.
Like it or not under his govt. India chnaged much and people see it all around them.
Indian have great potential to be discover
Go India👍Push your limits!
a thing which people mostly do not mention is, the budget of isro is about 2 billion but one thing to remember is 2billion in India gets u much more things done than say the united states if u look at PPP perspective 2billion in India is around 7.5billlion in US
That is the problem of USA. Why should we be bother?
Actually that's not entirely true for the same reason why an iPhone actually costs more in India than in the US for example. India is not self-reliant in this industry. They import parts from countries like Russia and other places which means the PPP figure becomes unreliable
USD Spending: 47.7Billion
Chinese Spending: 8.9Billion
Indian Spending: 2Billion
I mean, I know the US has put a rover on Mars or 2. But China has a wholly owned space station and has several human missions last year already. Makes you think that the gap shouldn't be as wide as this.
Yeah i think chinese space program are very underrated, it's probably second most advance space agency behind the US
there is a simple reason for this, its mostly using technology which does not require research to build. that is why usa spends most, due to testing and research.
@@kh-fk3ko by your own words, endia should be able to do the same with the same Established technology. you endian invented the wheel so use it right? if everything is as easy as said, the world is not in turmoil. think about it
This data is fake.....NASA budget is 20 billion and China's have a budget of 5 billion. And ISRO has a budget of 2.1 billion.
Don't worry isro has plans for a space station too and if everything goes as planned india will too own a space station at lower cost so yup✌️
Why does India has the image of having no toilets etc. India may have the highest number of toilets anywhere in the world as it's population is big. India needs innovation to come out of poverty an d middle income status.
correct... and after 2014, phenomenal level of toilet building has been done in India
Imagine if india had the budget as nasa
Never would have learned how make things with low cost efficiency. The lack was their strenght
70 %of the budget would be corrupted by the Indian officials..
@@lifeisneverthesame910 lol.... malignant dog can't digest Indian space program's success
@@youknowme2322 🤦 he is just telling the truth the politicians can't let that happen india . iam Indian i very know corruption
@@bloodwargaming3662 exactly 👍
i am forever astounded by indian space program
I am astounded by the moonlander crashing instead of landing on the Moon. Indian space technology is astounding.
@@franktoh3041 isnt it though. its as if the modern west was completely blindsided by its very existence!
Those who ruled India for over 200 years , forget a moon lander , they don't even have a sounding rocket at their sight.... Faar from a basic carrier rocket.....so atleast we r better placed than them.... Also those who ruled us r one of the richest countrie's in this world.....😉
India does have it's own edge in Space Exploration, especially the technique of launching multi-satellites with only one rocket. But when it comes into the point of Asian budget of space, the hint from rising Asian space budget without even a bit mention of Chinese Space Program might be some kind of unfair.
You need to understand that it is Bloomberg. Didn't you notice that the guy who is talking is an Indian working for Bloomberg? Nevermind. China does not share information with outsiders on their space projects. They just keep working hard and suddenly their spring a surprise just like landing on the far side of the moon. Retrieving moon rocks remotely is even beyond words. Something that the US is completely flabbergasted. Deng XiaoPeng once said "we try not to shine too brightly".
@@strongchallenger2269 there's a difference between putting money into space sector to compete with other countries vs doing the same to benefit a population.
Bruh india launched more than 100 satellite with one rocket
@@sanjaymalik3694 It's not the quantity. You need to look at the numbers of satellites which is micro satellites. When it is too heavy a satellite, you might not be able to lift it up!
India can launch sand in space and claim the new record of launching millions of satellites in one little rocket.
India is a big brother of not just Asia but a mother of a civilization which will pave the way for future of the world
A video from the West about India without showing poverty in a totally unrelated topic? Of course!
It was related, how dumb are you, hiding poverty won't help you
MY HUMBLE MESSAGE TO ALL INDIANS IN THE COMMENT SECTION. KINDLY IGNORE ALL THOSE WESTERN BIGOTS WHO ARE SAYING THAT "INDIA SHOULD FEED ITS POOR PEOPLE OR BUILD TOILETS FIRST BEFORE GOING TO SPACE". PLEASE IGNORE PEOPLE LIKE THEM. PEOPLE LIKE THEM NEVER SEEM TO CHANGE AND WILL ALWAYS REMAIN IGNORANT. NO POINT IN ARGUING WITH THEM OR GIVING THEM UNNECESSARY ATTENTION. SIMPLY IGNORE THEM. THEY ARE NOT WORTH WASTING YOUR TIME.
NASA is travelling for money with lots of money but ISRO is travelling for knowledge with least cost for supporting poor countries
please stop beating up nasa its trying its best
Making this argument is really making you look extremely ignorant dude. Saying NASA is travelling for money... Extremely ignorant
IMO, ISRO should go for an IPO. It can do great things with little bit more money.
We have long way to go, let's not settle here, Jai Hind, Jai Bharat 🇮🇳.
Next time someone tells you India is poor show them an Indian wedding.
People save their entire life savings on it. It's just sad culture
@@arxalier2956 it's still better then western countries people Marriage can't even maintain marriage life for 5 years🙄 and divorcing like instant noodles and Having affairs while married to someone
2:11 It says Japan but the background is Tiananmen Square. I think Bloomberg forgot to change it to China because 1970 (the date shown on screen) was when China launched its first satellite.
For those who ask why don't india spend it's money on poor,there are a lot of social welfare programs taking place. Moreover a 2 bln dollars doesn't make any difference. Being a third world country doesn't mean it's supposed to do only third world things.
Yeah exactly they should focus on their poor first
The reason why modi only focused on space recently is because when he came in power in 2014 he had to first literally make toilets!! Yeh 60%of population didn't had access to toilets in 2014 now 99% indians have access to toilets in 2022, also the roads are getting better day by day cause of extremely capable road minister we have here...
It's true that India does have a lot of technology, the problem is using it to help their people prosper. Infrastructure problems, policy problems, bright minds leaving the country, political corruption, constant internal conflict and overall economy, needs a rapid change to make it happen. Even though India has border issues with everyone just like China, I do hope their development continues so that more people can be brought out of poverty.
India is changing in astonishing rate, we now have solved our 99% sanitary issue, we are building infrastructure on the world record rate(we literally have world record on building roads), India build its own locomotive and have worlds biggest Rail Roads, India now have record break FDI from all over the globe, now lot of tech companies have already leaving china and building their Factories in India, Like Apple, Foxconn, Samsung, Intel, and many many more.
In west Slums are hub of Drug trafficking, unproductive youth, prominent teen pregnancies, lot of Crimes. To the contrary, Indian slums are very productive and Majority of them are very loyal hardworking citizens trying their best to get better life. its actually Rich in India who are not productive and drawn in to drugs.
Yes! We have problems & those are being corrected & surely more needs to be done. It's not just India though all in countries in this world suffers from all the problems you mentioned, including yours but guess it's easy to point out India in general.
@@bullseye6969 “solved 99% of its sanitary issues.” You must be joking.
Nah, he isn’t joking.
@@prabeeshsidhu You must joking here right!! Get on with your life!
I wish isro lands a rover on titan, because these guys have brilliant engineering and they know how to make it perfect with their cost effectiveness.
India needs to take giantly not only the space but worlds heart😊
Yes we r not rich as nasa or space x.. but we have talent and ambitious 🙏