This is one of her most poetic songs to date, I mean has anybody really just stopped and listened to those lyrics like omg, this & H.A.T.E.U. are phenominal
i'm glad to say she got a standing ovation from even after all this time (and thinking she lost her voice for sure)... and guys it's deffinitely live! she sings completely different from the original and when the backing track is on she just imporivises through!...
THIS IS SO LIVE!!! Why is it when she sings perfectly, she's lip syncing but when she sings or adds different notes to a song she can't sing anymore? What do you people want from her? She can still, was always able to, and will always be able to sing! That's why she is the BEST-SELLING FEMALE ARTIST OF ALL TIME! She has the most pitch-perfect voice of all time! That's why she is who she is! And another thing, if you like Mariah, why would you waste your time watching her video, and down her?
Could be pre-recorded coz she doesnt pull the mic far away but either way its different from the studio version coz at the climax she added another note to it. Still an iconic legend and noone can compare
Even though its not live, is still a great song and this performance brings me to tears, cuz I Don't Care if is lipped just the song itself is amazing!
mariah has been and will always be one of the greatest vocalists of all time... ask christina aguilera, ask rihanna, ask beyonce, ask brian mcknight, ask lionel richie, and a whole lot more, they all look up at mariah carey!
I'm 16 and all i see in the comments is she lipped sync. Who fucking cares enjoy the show like mariah has nothing to prove she already made her mark. Like stop and I'm a fan a big fan hello lambs. So stop with ur comments on her lip syncing. I could care less its mariah carey the one and only. Like she has nothing to prove she did everything theres a reason for her being the best female selling artist of all time not one but two songs of the decade. I could go on but it be a waste of time explaining to ppl who are not fans. And dont understand the concept that she made her mark and has nothing to prove. #Slayriah #L4L
she might act diva and all the shit but she's TRUe talent and I'm tempted to say she's right for actin diva cos she's one!!! I'm not her biggest fan but she can sing and she has true beautiful songs!!!
I can't wait for a fresxh album of hers to come out. It has been such a long time since I MC has had a great hit. I think that she needs to first release the ballads and the go with the Pop songs. This song would have been a major hit had been released before Obsessed, but unfortunately that was the case. But only they will have their reasons why! I hope that she comes up with a good album that will mirror Music Box and Daydream. Bring the old Carey back!
*note* all the pre-recorded vocals sound really high frequency, where as her actual live vocals are full sounding and bassy notice the difference at 2:50 between the backing and her live sound
Whoever say Mariah Carey lip sync the last part go and hear the studio version last part and this last part performance . totally different . #l4l #Lambily
@neilpacheco03 she is miming, ive done a video on how she mimes in 'i wanna know what love is.' mariah tends to mime 70% of the big endings in her songs. in this song she does sing song of the song live but the pre-recorded vocals come in at 3:10 (she turns her back to the audience and hears to see if the 'HEY' comes in to make sure her vocals are there, cuz theyve messed up before) plus when mariah mimes, she twiddles her fingers when she sings, thats another thing to look out for lol.
lipped or not when your infront of mariah its nothing as long as you will see her singing it will totally amazed you and melt you ^^ but i love every performance of her........ this is live ^^
I really don't think it matters if she's not singing all the way through her concerts. Based on her record sales and awards I'd say she's pretty much paid her dues to the music industry. At this point, it's a miracle she's even bothering to continue doing concerts and albums.
Wow amazing:) I love Mariah. She is good no doubt. For those people who say she is lip syncing, YOU WEREN'T THERE! YOU DON"T KNOW! YOU CAN'T SING! Stop hating geez grow up. Love u MC(^^,)
ewilliam..I agree on all accounts!! Its so obviously live! People have a hard time believing but it's their problem.. Have to add that this isn't even a difficult song for MC to sing..
@Gigglesxhx I understand what you're saying too, however, on a song like this, she has to use the back track because, there are so many vocal acrobatics that she done for back-up that her background singers can't do like her.
guys, i'm so sorry to dissapoint u, but this ain't LIVE(except for some ooohs and and aaaaaas). if this is live , i'm pope(and i'm not) . i m a big fan of Mariah's, but let's face it... gold time's gone ... we're living feeding ourselves with memories of one of the best voices ever. pitty...but we love her anyway, right? Go Mariah!!!
i gues the reason why she turns back, she's trying to hear herself from the speakers .. it's actually different when your in front and the speakers are at your back (the one's on the stage though) ... i do that too when i perform .. thats why ...
she looks like pregnant to her dress, but she's amazing ! HATERS expecting that she can't sing very well, but she can ! that's my Mariah carey ! wheeew ! Lambs? AGREE !!!!!!!!!!!!!
Yea i completly get that, her voice is too unique for just any singer to mimic. I was just saying sometimes she was lipping to the backtrack in small parts of this performance, but its all good :)
@danmillerscotland I'm actually not looking for a fight here. I'm just asking a question. And just to let you know, I have nothing against Mariah. She will always be Mariah Carey whatever other people say. I'm a fan and I'm just trying to know if she really is lipsyncing. I'm not gonna waste my time watching and commenting on this video if I don't love Mariah. And besides, my question doesn't make her a lesser performer. ü
Love MC so much,Hope this is 19th #1! I think though as a singer the most cringe worthy thing to do is mime. especially when you have the most beautiful voice, and when its part lipped you can hear the difference in quality, here there are a couple live ad libs
only the 2:37 to 3:11 is live -__- I'm not a singer but my ears can identify it clearly, the difference of the rest of the song is bizarre that the 2:37 - 3:11 On 2:37 you can here she sang the "Ohhh Ohhh Ahhh Ahhh Ahhh" part, that's the live singing up to 3:11, but after she turn in the side view way the song seemed lipped o.O like hmmm what happened?
A qestão ñ é por ser ao vivo ou ñ, as primeiras estrofes realmente tem um acompanhamento pq na gravação de studio as musicas de mariah tem muitos efeitos, vozes diferentes ao mesmo tempo e por isso ao vivo tem um acompanhamento, uma base se ñ a musica fica muito vaga, pode ver q fica uma voz no fundo enqanto ela faz os arranjos por cima, já na ultima parte, nas notas altas é ela qem faz, qem já ouviu a musica no disco sabe q mariah da uma performace vocal diferente nesse video, provando q ñ é play back coisa nenhuma
sharla gomes Exatamente ela em estúdio grava varias bases vocais como o sussurro os graves e os super agudos que ficam ao fundo da canção isso se chamar Back ups quando não existe a possibilidade das back in vocals fazerem o DJ solta o instrumental com os acompanhamentos que ela gravou em estúdio para ela poder cantar a parte principal da música
@jajafard OMG!!! You're in every frikkin' Mariah video posting nasty comments about her! Get a life honey or at least, admit that you're obsessed with her! If you hate someone that much you don't spend your time seeing videos and posting comments! And don't worry! A lot of people are just like you : Their animosity reflects their admiration! So, keep admiring babe! xoxo
@jajafard Lol I would like to personally thank you for adding to Mariah's views on here. Do you think you could go over to Yahoo! Music and do the same?? Those videos go towards chart performance so your hating can do alot more benefits there :D
Certain breathy notes are lipped but most of it is live if u listen to the album then this you can tell the live parts and the lipped parts. Her voice gets weak fast so she has to lip certain parts thru her concerts. But she sing the parts that matters :)
@BajcoTheSinger i think so too...no offense meant!i mean she is still my idol and all but let's face the fact..her glorious is starting to fade and failed her..
@Antiproton2009 lol You're wasting your time. I hate Mariah ever started lipping, cause people assume she's lost her voice because of it...and now when she gives a good performance live, people are all "It's lipped, she cant sing like that anymore!!!" This is obviously live, she's not singing it exactly the way it sounds on the album. Anyone who's heard the song from the album, can tell this is live. Even the ending note length is shorter, with more whistles as she gets breathless.
This is one of her most poetic songs to date, I mean has anybody really just stopped and listened to those lyrics like omg, this & H.A.T.E.U. are phenominal
She's singing like the studio , it's perfect
Yeah, the Angels Cry at the Palms is the best one cuz 100% live and really good.
That last note is sooo EPIC!
i'm glad to say she got a standing ovation from even after all this time (and thinking she lost her voice for sure)... and guys it's deffinitely live! she sings completely different from the original and when the backing track is on she just imporivises through!...
THIS IS SO LIVE!!! Why is it when she sings perfectly, she's lip syncing but when she sings or adds different notes to a song she can't sing anymore? What do you people want from her? She can still, was always able to, and will always be able to sing! That's why she is the BEST-SELLING FEMALE ARTIST OF ALL TIME! She has the most pitch-perfect voice of all time! That's why she is who she is! And another thing, if you like Mariah, why would you waste your time watching her video, and down her?
Thank you God for bringing us MC in this world.
God Bless Everyone! :D!
Dang Wang Q
It is live, you can tell, she is concentrating.
03:09 queen ♕
Ughh the nostalgia 🥰 This song & era was amazing 🦋
Could be pre-recorded coz she doesnt pull the mic far away but either way its different from the studio version coz at the climax she added another note to it. Still an iconic legend and noone can compare
Even though its not live, is still a great song and this performance brings me to tears, cuz I Don't Care if is lipped just the song itself is amazing!
love this song damn all her songs have meanings to them thats why i love you mariah carey !!!
mariah has been and will always be one of the greatest vocalists of all time... ask christina aguilera, ask rihanna, ask beyonce, ask brian mcknight, ask lionel richie, and a whole lot more, they all look up at mariah carey!
YES! Perfect, beautiful, gorgeous, lovely- Mariah IS the best!!
Yes she is the best, i love her too! Mariah is the ultimate!!!
I'm 16 and all i see in the comments is she lipped sync. Who fucking cares enjoy the show like mariah has nothing to prove she already made her mark. Like stop and I'm a fan a big fan hello lambs. So stop with ur comments on her lip syncing. I could care less its mariah carey the one and only. Like she has nothing to prove she did everything theres a reason for her being the best female selling artist of all time not one but two songs of the decade. I could go on but it be a waste of time explaining to ppl who are not fans. And dont understand the concept that she made her mark and has nothing to prove. #Slayriah #L4L
Mimi's Butterfly
MY GOD FOR ONCE A YOUNG ONE WITH MORE BRAINS THEN THE OTHER IDIOTS OUT THERE, THANK YOU FOR ACTKNOWLEDGING THE LEGEND
Mimi's Butterfly 13 here lol
marykacyy
yesss this is not lip sycn this real and 100% all Mariah live !! stop comment if you don't like Mariah fuck you !!! this is Special for Mariah haters
she might act diva and all the shit but she's TRUe talent and I'm tempted to say she's right for actin diva cos she's one!!! I'm not her biggest fan but she can sing and she has true beautiful songs!!!
ok this is so live! she did reall good. i love her~!!!! LAMB 4 EVER BABY!
😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍 i love you Mariah!
i love her appearance, her hair. fits her perfectly :)
One word. GODDESS.
She is my IDOL !!! I love MIMI
i was waiting for that high note at the end.
She looks so good, and she sounds AMAZING!!! I think she sings better when she's voluptuous like that!!!
I hope I get to see her in concert someday....
this is the very best song that i heard !!!
I love this song! she sounds sooooo pretty ;)
wow, wonderful
Wow
Beautiful
on the verge of tears :'(
so beautifl!
I can't wait for a fresxh album of hers to come out. It has been such a long time since I MC has had a great hit. I think that she needs to first release the ballads and the go with the Pop songs. This song would have been a major hit had been released before Obsessed, but unfortunately that was the case. But only they will have their reasons why! I hope that she comes up with a good album that will mirror Music Box and Daydream. Bring the old Carey back!
love it!!!!!!!!!
she's so freaking perfect that ppl think shes lip-syncing!!
Awesome, really emotion. I love her !
she should perform this with ne-yo at some show....it could be a big hit!! love this song so much
love u mariah
Shes amazingggg
golden pipes
*note* all the pre-recorded vocals sound really high frequency, where as her actual live vocals are full sounding and bassy notice the difference at 2:50 between the backing and her live sound
Whoever say Mariah Carey lip sync the last part go and hear the studio version last part and this last part performance . totally different . #l4l #Lambily
Yeah she just recorded it before the live performance...every performance of this song from the tour uses the same prerecord vocals
@@xennex213 GTFO
@@xennex213 You used facts and logic.
Delusional fans are confused!
@neilpacheco03 she is miming, ive done a video on how she mimes in 'i wanna know what love is.' mariah tends to mime 70% of the big endings in her songs. in this song she does sing song of the song live but the pre-recorded vocals come in at 3:10 (she turns her back to the audience and hears to see if the 'HEY' comes in to make sure her vocals are there, cuz theyve messed up before) plus when mariah mimes, she twiddles her fingers when she sings, thats another thing to look out for lol.
amzing..
Nobody is accusing her of not being able to sing because she still can, The whole concert was live accept this song.
she has to sing this when she comes to Singapore. =)
i love her hair! reminds me of her daydream days...
I Love Her. She Ain't Lip Syncing. You Can Tell.
She is definitely lip syncing. You can see it as well as hear it. It's totally lipped sync. If you don't believe it, you are delusional.
lipped or not when your infront of mariah its nothing as long as you will see her singing it will totally amazed you and melt you ^^ but i love every performance of her........ this is live ^^
Shes singin along with the track!
@ewilliams09 i agree with what your saying but in some parts of the song she is miming to the backing track, bt she is mostly singing all of it
im mariah carey's number one fan
but observe, i think she is doing LIP SYNCH here Dx
I really don't think it matters if she's not singing all the way through her concerts. Based on her record sales and awards I'd say she's pretty much paid her dues to the music industry. At this point, it's a miracle she's even bothering to continue doing concerts and albums.
Wow amazing:) I love Mariah. She is good no doubt. For those people who say she is lip syncing, YOU WEREN'T THERE! YOU DON"T KNOW! YOU CAN'T SING! Stop hating geez grow up. Love u MC(^^,)
@nicevidbro YES SHE HAS CHECK OUT TH PERL PERFORMANCE SEPT 11 AND OCT 12
She lip that when she goes down like that you would no she didn’t you would have to be a lamb to know and that high note at the end
ewilliam..I agree on all accounts!! Its so obviously live! People have a hard time believing but it's their problem..
Have to add that this isn't even a difficult song for MC to sing..
@Gigglesxhx I understand what you're saying too, however, on a song like this, she has to use the back track because, there are so many vocal acrobatics that she done for back-up that her background singers can't do like her.
guys, i'm so sorry to dissapoint u, but this ain't LIVE(except for some ooohs and and aaaaaas). if this is live , i'm pope(and i'm not) . i m a big fan of Mariah's, but let's face it... gold time's gone ... we're living feeding ourselves with memories of one of the best voices ever. pitty...but we love her anyway, right? Go Mariah!!!
i gues the reason why she turns back, she's trying to hear herself from the speakers .. it's actually different when your in front and the speakers are at your back (the one's on the stage though) ... i do that too when i perform .. thats why ...
@ctruf no! she's not lip syncing!!!
great camera skils.. :)
it's playback you can hear her sing along with the song I fucking love this song.
I love Mariah, but even I know that most of this wasn't live. There is a video of her singing this song live though.
Is this live?
she looks like pregnant to her dress, but she's amazing ! HATERS expecting that she can't sing very well, but she can !
that's my Mariah carey ! wheeew !
Lambs? AGREE !!!!!!!!!!!!!
Doesn't it seem like her voice is a lot healthier here? Even when she's speaking at the beginning... Maybe it's just me :P
@jajafard Keep talking about her baby!
That's great actually! :-))
You talke about her more than her fans! LMAO
We appreciate the love! Thx
xoxox
People who can't recognize a live version over a lipped one should thing before making statements. This is clearly live.
Yea i completly get that, her voice is too unique for just any singer to mimic. I was just saying sometimes she was lipping to the backtrack in small parts of this performance, but its all good :)
@SuperAiko92 She did For japan ill post them on my other channel! :)
@danmillerscotland I'm actually not looking for a fight here. I'm just asking a question. And just to let you know, I have nothing against Mariah. She will always be Mariah Carey whatever other people say. I'm a fan and I'm just trying to know if she really is lipsyncing. I'm not gonna waste my time watching and commenting on this video if I don't love Mariah. And besides, my question doesn't make her a lesser performer. ü
@jajafard Keep "loving" baby!
Haters are help and we don't argue with help!
xoxo
Why does the arrangement sound like that? Felt like she was singing along w/ a karaoke version!
lol....u mean lip sync?😑
@@arianagrandevevo2543 Lol Arianntors wtf? She wasn't lipsynching before the climax.
@@arianagrandevevo2543 Also she was talking about the arrangement not the vocals lmao. Arianntors really sucks.
Love MC so much,Hope this is 19th #1! I think though as a singer the most cringe worthy thing to do is mime. especially when you have the most beautiful voice, and when its part lipped you can hear the difference in quality, here there are a couple live ad libs
lypsync or not. enjoy :)
i believe this is live...
its def pre recorder its teh exact same one she recently did for the angels advocate tour!
@cassiehassan i didnt sad that shes a model.and i didnt sed that in bad way.
She can sing LIVE. It is LIVE...
is it alternative version of angels cry or what? where i can find the clear song of this version? can anybody tell me please? ? i love this version. .
Where can I find this version?! Without Neyo !
Junior Jimenez apple music
@SFFL1996 that's called pre-recorded live vocals! She hardly sings live and has't done in the last 10 yeras or so
@Mcvideos92 its not lipped
it's not live???
u can tell when she lip synces koz she re-positions the mic in her hand so you cant see her mouth..
is she live syncing?
only the 2:37 to 3:11 is live -__- I'm not a singer but my ears can identify it clearly, the difference of the rest of the song is bizarre that the 2:37 - 3:11
On 2:37 you can here she sang the "Ohhh Ohhh Ahhh Ahhh Ahhh" part, that's the live singing up to 3:11, but after she turn in the side view way the song seemed lipped o.O like hmmm what happened?
A qestão ñ é por ser ao vivo ou ñ, as primeiras estrofes realmente tem um acompanhamento pq na gravação de studio as musicas de mariah tem muitos efeitos, vozes diferentes ao mesmo tempo e por isso ao vivo tem um acompanhamento, uma base se ñ a musica fica muito vaga, pode ver q fica uma voz no fundo enqanto ela faz os arranjos por cima, já na ultima parte, nas notas altas é ela qem faz, qem já ouviu a musica no disco sabe q mariah da uma performace vocal diferente nesse video, provando q ñ é play back coisa nenhuma
sharla gomes Exatamente ela em estúdio grava varias bases vocais como o sussurro os graves e os super agudos que ficam ao fundo da canção isso se chamar Back ups quando não existe a possibilidade das back in vocals fazerem o DJ solta o instrumental com os acompanhamentos que ela gravou em estúdio para ela poder cantar a parte principal da música
Isso mesmo Brisa Deveza
Rex Liams enjoy the performance you idiot
@jajafard OMG!!! You're in every frikkin' Mariah video posting nasty comments about her!
Get a life honey or at least, admit that you're obsessed with her!
If you hate someone that much you don't spend your time seeing videos and posting comments!
And don't worry! A lot of people are just like you : Their animosity reflects their admiration!
So, keep admiring babe! xoxo
@jajafard Lol I would like to personally thank you for adding to Mariah's views on here. Do you think you could go over to Yahoo! Music and do the same?? Those videos go towards chart performance so your hating can do alot more benefits there :D
Certain breathy notes are lipped but most of it is live if u listen to the album then this you can tell the live parts and the lipped parts. Her voice gets weak fast so she has to lip certain parts thru her concerts. But she sing the parts that matters :)
try to compare her last note of " I Stay in love" @ AMA .. that was F5 ..compare to this
Think*
@Marina4785 shes a singer not a model
@BajcoTheSinger i think so too...no offense meant!i mean she is still my idol and all but let's face the fact..her glorious is starting to fade and failed her..
2 people don't know the angels are laughing at them
3:08
@jajafard So don't talk about her anymore honey! What about that?
If you don't have something nice to say, don't say anything at all! ok?
What's the matter if she is LIPPED or not, just enjoy de fucking show
yes it does matter, it is only acceptable if she was dancing like honey in the rainbow tour back in 98
@Antiproton2009 lol You're wasting your time.
I hate Mariah ever started lipping, cause people assume she's lost her voice because of it...and now when she gives a good performance live, people are all "It's lipped, she cant sing like that anymore!!!"
This is obviously live, she's not singing it exactly the way it sounds on the album. Anyone who's heard the song from the album, can tell this is live.
Even the ending note length is shorter, with more whistles as she gets breathless.
2:39 to 3:12