In this Example can we increase the bonus tolerance to 0.2 from 0.1, or is there a rule that it should be less than the size tolerance? I appreciate you making these tutorials, I learnt a lot! sending regards from Canada!
The correct terminology to be used in this case is Derived Median Line, the general term that we use day to day is Axis. Center Line is the term that we use to represent an axis in a drawing.
And for a person who is just starting out with GD&T you could do a playlist or something to get them in right direction of video watching. Just a suggestion
Good explaining , But, The sound of closing the shell every now and then so that the marker pen does not dry out disturbs the comprehension of the sentence. So remove this kind of irritating sound. And please note this point while making any explaining video
when we apply straightness gd&t on a long shaft then length of shaft play any role in achieving ?? means can we mention length of shaft also for long shaft ?? along with straightness tolerance ??
Sir, Suppose on side dimension is 24.9 mm and other side dimension is 25.1 mm. Then with Straightness Tol of 0.1, The dimensions on one side could be 24.9-0.05 = 24.85 and dimensions on other side could be 25.1+0.05 = 25.15, Hence Rule 1 is overidden. Am i right ? Thank you for sharing your knowledge sir. Just a suggestion, Could have been much better if you could have presented in Presentation form like in the previous Tutorials. We can get the Pdf as well as refer to a video. Thank you once again sir.
When strightness is applied on surface, the part has to enter into MMC boundary envelope. so we can not override Rule #1 consolidated presentation is available as GD&T Mini ebook, hope you have downloaded
@@PalaniKailash Thank you for your GD&T tutorial video. I have the same question with Manuj Arora. You answered when straightness is applied on surface, the part hs to enter into MMC boundary. How about other situations such as flatness tolerance, circularity tolerance?. I hope you can answer my question.
if the material is in its Leats Material Condition(LMC), its dia is 24.9 mm. Then the axis deviation could be 0.3 since the envelope diameter is 25.2. You can better understand it one of the previous videos.
Thank you for this great tutorial. I continue to watch your videos to expedite my understanding. Very helpful and very appreciated!
Great to hear!
Very useful learning. Easy to understand. To the point explanation.
Glad it was helpful!
Great video Sir. Can you please give an example in which cases or when should we apply straightness on the surface and on axis/centerline?
Sure, the videos are in queue
In this Example can we increase the bonus tolerance to 0.2 from 0.1, or is there a rule that it should be less than the size tolerance?
I appreciate you making these tutorials, I learnt a lot! sending regards from Canada!
Good explanation.. And also it's very easily to understand
Thanks
Maybe axis is not the word to be used. Centreline is the appropriate word. Hope it makes sense. And ya another good video sir.
The correct terminology to be used in this case is Derived Median Line, the general term that we use day to day is Axis.
Center Line is the term that we use to represent an axis in a drawing.
Thank you sir
And for a person who is just starting out with GD&T you could do a playlist or something to get them in right direction of video watching. Just a suggestion
Thanks for your suggestions, will look into it
thanks for the explaination!
Thank you Sir 🙏
Sir
Explain straightness in plate instead of shaft
Good explaining ,
But,
The sound of closing the shell every now and then so that the marker pen does not dry out disturbs the comprehension of the sentence.
So remove this kind of irritating sound. And
please note this point while making any explaining video
Is it possible to have the straightness tolerance added both to the axis of the shaft and the surface of the feature?
Great video sir
By rule a part should be at perfect form in MMC but in this video form error of 0.1 is allowed in MMC .
Can you explain it sir?
perfect form is required when geometric tolerance is not applied
@@PalaniKailash i didnt get that part right 25+/- 0.1 means there is an envelope of 25.1 and 25.2 wont fit in that envelope please explain
great video sir.. when we use axis straightness ?? and what is difference between surface straightness and axis straightness..?? what is difference..
Axis straightness will override Rule #1, and can have flexibility by using material conditions
If I will give location tol to fos ,can i give gtol! It is right?
Hello sir,
How straightness of axis is achieved in manufacturing as axis can't be seen in real life.
What is difference between straight ness and flatness
At the ending of the video for MMC, what are the size of the envelope, do we apply rule# 1?
Hello Sir,
Why tolerance zone increased in case of LMC and it remains same in case of MMC
when we apply straightness gd&t on a long shaft then length of shaft play any role in achieving ??
means can we mention length of shaft also for long shaft ?? along with straightness tolerance ??
Sir why can't we apply material condition like MMC and LMC to a surface except feature of size?
I think at end if video the LMC should be 0.02 and not 0.03 ? Am I right sir?
Thank you ..!!!
Sir, Suppose on side dimension is 24.9 mm and other side dimension is 25.1 mm. Then with Straightness Tol of 0.1, The dimensions on one side could be 24.9-0.05 = 24.85 and dimensions on other side could be 25.1+0.05 = 25.15, Hence Rule 1 is overidden. Am i right ?
Thank you for sharing your knowledge sir. Just a suggestion, Could have been much better if you could have presented in Presentation form like in the previous Tutorials. We can get the Pdf as well as refer to a video. Thank you once again sir.
When strightness is applied on surface, the part has to enter into MMC boundary envelope. so we can not override Rule #1
consolidated presentation is available as GD&T Mini ebook, hope you have downloaded
@@PalaniKailash Thank you for your GD&T tutorial video. I have the same question with Manuj Arora. You answered when straightness is applied on surface, the part hs to enter into MMC boundary. How about other situations such as flatness tolerance, circularity tolerance?. I hope you can answer my question.
Sir, Could you please explain Composite Straightness Tolerance
It is not composite straightness tolerance, it is straightness on unit basis, nothing much to explain in that
@@PalaniKailash Than k you sir
Great .....!!!
Thanks
where did you get 0.3 from ?
if the material is in its Leats Material Condition(LMC), its dia is 24.9 mm. Then the axis deviation could be 0.3 since the envelope diameter is 25.2. You can better understand it one of the previous videos.
For a shaft the envelope would be the smallest hole touching all the highest points
So shaft dia is 24.9 at LMC, how can the envelope size be 25.2?