Imtiaz Ali on Chamkila & the Animal Debate: Beyond Judgement to Artistic Freedom
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 เม.ย. 2024
- Join filmmaker Imtiaz Ali as he delves into the world of Amar Singh Chamkila, Punjab's controversial yet legendary musician. In this insightful interview, Ali shares his perspective on artistic freedom, societal judgement, and the enduring legacy of Chamkila's music. From exploring the origins of Chamkila's artistry to reflecting on contemporary debates surrounding films like "Animal," Ali offers a thought-provoking discussion on the intersection of art, culture, and social responsibility.
#chamkila #imtiazali #exclusiveinterview #diljitdosanjh #parineetichopra #amarsinghchamkila #doublemeaning #casteissue #punjab
No one knows Mumbai better than us. #madeinmumbai.
For more Bollywood, news and sports videos subscribe here: bit.ly/2KUYCyq
Facebook: / middayindia
Twitter: / mid_day
Instagram: / middayindia - บันเทิง
The interviewer has a very nice way of asking good questions in a very polite manner.
Wow! Such a great interview and movie talk.....The interviewer should do interview with every amazing film-maker after their film releases and do conversation about the cinema language of the film....Great stuff!
Her questions are interesting and Imtiaz is very sensible. Love him and his work!
All such wonderful questions and so gracefully answered by the guest.
Interviewer's name? Her questions are very well thought through and very well articulated.
If Sandeep Reddy Vanga's Animal is bad for society. Then Quentin Tarantino like Filmmakers should stop making films????? How can people be so dumb. Tomorrow if you are watching a gangster film. Are you becoming gangster next day ??? It's a character it's a story you like the story or don't like the story or film that's a different thing. Bad for society??? Please then watch wedding videos films like Hum Saath Saath Hain or Hum Aapke hai Kaun. 🎞🎥🎬🤘🏻
True
If any 1 movie can change your personality and character than there is a fault in your upbringing, parenting and society
Quentin Tarantino’s audience is majorly in the west. Where people have more consciousness and they are aware that there is consequences to their behaviour.
Ghanta 😂 @@AyeshaKhan-ti9gj
@@AyeshaKhan-ti9gj lol! That's why they shoot each other like a tribe of gorilla on steroids.
@@AyeshaKhan-ti9gj Crap
Good conversation. Good film journalism.
Animal was a film about a hyperviolent, psychopathic man-child who loses everything due to his actions. The film very clearly shows that his actions weren't good or ideal.
Yeah, it's funny when some people act like his character is presented as a role model or something lol
But he's shown to be surrounded by his loved ones and friends in the beginning of the movie(in the distant future), he's telling his story as if he's the second coming of Christ and is applauded by them
No one there questions his decisions, no one's there to judge him for his actions
It's shown that her wife left him but also that his son loves him despite of everything he's done
He's shown ultimately to be like a flawed human who has made mistakes but is ultimately a tragic figure
Even tho he's clearly a terrible human, cheats and kills and don't regret anything he has done
@@AriaIsara the complaints are with the technique. when low camera angles are used as he walks over his enemies, when heroic music is played behind him as he walks in slow motion, the filmmaker does give away that he wants you to idolise him. Flawed characters have been shown in arts for hundreds of years, be it crime and punishment, or Madame Bovary, or Michael Corleone in the godfather. But you never saw Coppola ever saying through his shot taking that he wants us to admire Michael Corleone, in fact he used almost documentary like shot taking to show us the cracks and loneliness of this man who wants to stay away from everything that he became. That’s what people complained about with animal. The filmmaking, the shot taking was of a teenage boy who was way beyond his depth, his character was too complicated for his own understanding.
@@sagrophobia you're incorrect. Badass music can be used when a villain is in action, it has been done many times in US content. It doesn't mean the viewer should idolize him. An example is Tom Cruise's character in Interview With The Vampire, and the use of the catchy rock song "Sympathy For The Devil" as he is about to kill an innocent man. Things aren't as black and white as you portray them.
@@AriaIsara you’ve used a really bad example. A tragic vampire figure is fantasy. We’re talking about real people here. Gaze is something a filmmaker needs to be responsible for, I cannot be any clearer. Even Gaspar noe who makes the most controversial films about some of the most despicable people, uses music. But that music almost works as an ironic commentary to what’s happening on screen. It horrifies you. You need to watch a little more cinema than this commercial balderdash.
Good journalism.. imtiaz was so interested to answer !!
The interviewer we need.. great job
Good conversation.
Well structured questions.. refreshing interview
Vanga is a phenomenal creator. He is very talented. You have every right to criticise as nothing is perfect in this world. But i challenge you to find faults in his craft, BGM, taste of Music and having a grip on a scene. His movies like reddy, animal is being taught is cinema school. Its huge in the movie making community.
And you guys are against animal and never said a word agains gangs of wasseypur, Mirzapur, sacred games. That times all these critics praise Anurag. If u cant see this clear bias than sorry but something is wrong with your perspective. Its a movie, just a story. It would have been a different scenario if it went against our country or any religion.
Which film school? Animal released in December 2023 and already added to the syllabus? There are legendary movies with self-destructing male as the lead like Taxi driver, Raging bull, fight club, wolf of wall street, Joker or a series like Breaking Bad. So I'm very interested, which film school chose Vangas movies ahead of these?
@@alvinvazha1144 Whatsapp University
Which film school?? Animal is an okay movie!! The director clearly understands how the audience's mind works!! Added chauvinism and sex unnecessarily for a storyline that was about a man who was craving for his dad's attention!! And the difference between him and anurag kashyap is that...he doesn't come to interviews and say that he stands by his character's behavior whereas vanga believes in his characters and thinks they r r8 ...and that my dear friend is the PROBLEM!!!!!!
WhatsApp University
@@lavanyakrishnakumar8984Nowhere Vanga justifies his characters. See the end of Animal, it's a tragedy. The character, inspite of waging a war, betraying his wife loses his father to cancer, doesn't even get the share of love he deserved. His wife leaves him and there exists a psycho butcher chasing him for his blood.
Vanga criticised the critics who not picked his film in the name of criticism and ignored all other aspects of his craft. He is a passionate filmmaker who loves his craft way more than anyone else, kind of possessive.
movies only change your hairstyles not the society
Manoj Bajpayee
The interviewer is Very Good at her job. Refreshing👍
What an observation ....great intervuew
8:11 - 8:14 The sound she was making.
hmmmrrr rrrmmmmmrr
Imtiaz made me believe every daadi wala violent thought carrier admi is a so called "legend film maker" Untill and unless the legend himself shows up,,,,, Bow to you Imtiaz Ali 👏👏
😂😂
Here also the interviewer tried to pose a problem, and Imtiaz had to react to it or solve it, it was an equal interview.
Parineeti was supposed to be the original actress of Animal too.
Nice movie chamkila ❤❤❤❤❤
Understand the real hidden agenda that Sandeep Vanga portrayed: he depicted "some" Hindu rituals and family bonds/companionship Unity in a very positive and subtle way. He also cleverly exposed an Xian pastor (pray confession drama). However, this portrayal was not accepted by the left ecosystem, which believes and influences exactly opposite to it and has a special love(?) for defaming, insulting, and degrading Hindu Dharma in a very soft, clever way. I respect this gentleman Imtiaz Ali, who is a master at it. The way he promotes Islamic imaginary beliefs through Sufi music is commonly popular. Additionally, leaving everything and going solo No family bond and how to protect it is not in his syllabus. This is the reason why Vanga is targeted - how can he achieve so much success and money, of course. In Last I watched Animal thrice in theatre and Proud of it what a cinematic experience it was.
Bro..u are absolutely right.. h imtiaz Ali a true propogandist in every sense
Field beyond right and wrong took me to rockstar
Now stop criticizing.. or tagging "agenda film" etc. to movies....
It ultimately people who decide....
Ahmmmm Asmr sounds.
I think the animal scenario is trvialized. It would have been nice to discuss it a little elaborately.
I agree if both the creator and the viewer exhibit responsibility it is great, if not it creates a mob like scenario that is dangerous. Then there is a definite need to regulate.
A simple humble human being has a good reason that guides good and the bad.
Unconscious commercial mob breaches the good and the bad constantly and create chaos and confusion for all.
One more film with SRK plz
Chamkila very nice film ❤
I disagree with Imtiaz, I believe artists do have a moral obligation to create work that is not dangerous to society. By Imtiaz Ali's argument, movies like Kerala Story and Kashmir Files should also be justified then, even though these films are made primarily to cater to the majority population, increase hatred against minorities, and create divisions in society.
I am huge ranbir fan but chamkila rockstar> chamkila>animal
Ma'am please watch Article 15, Buddhia Singh and some of the Prakash Jha movies. You will realise caste talks are already in mainstream cinema.
Autocracy starts when a person think.s I am the only one who can uplifts the society. The live examples are Russia and North korea. Who decides what is right and wrong. Freedom of expression is utmost for any society to move forward The animal director is expressing his world view. And btw I liked Arjun Reddy and didn't like Animal.
Yes same, I also liked Arjun Reddy and didn't like Animal, but the criticism has been over the top to be honest.
Seems like interviewer was here to talk more than Imtiaz.
Animal is best movie so as Chamkila
Venga has the right to make trash
especially if it makes 1000 crore
majority of people accepted animal..!! So go n fys
Yes he makes Trash 😅
See who is saying thrash a uncle who like to watch sugar coated movies and who still leaves backward in his life
@@RolexSir213 Vanga is below average video maker not even a grown up man to be called as a film maker. He is an irritated kid.
By the logic of chamkila Pan masala and gutka company and drug suppliers be like people are consuming then they are wrong if they will not why would we sell ....
Animal was a blunder I don't know all went ans watched and loved it and why. I mean there was no plot. I am okay to see violence, action, but where is the plot. He is saving his dad in the entire movie and at the end is dad is anyway dying. I found it baseless and like I watched a 3 hour
Tumhe nahi aachi lagi doesn't mean ki film aachi nahi hai..
Sara time to aunty Boli ja RHI hain
Animal is pure horseshit, the movie had good things that anyone can add superficially BUT lacked a story, how incredibly under developed and half baked
with whatever showed conveyed in a headache inducing manner.
It felt like looking at a concoction of brain frying ekta kapoor melodrama nonsense and elements of shady tv shows like savdhaan india crime patrol , and kgf influence spiced
12th fail
12th fail talk about that