I will tell you a small story. I work for a Fortune 500 company and we were thinking of expanding our team to emerging markets to reduce our costs. We picked 3 possible contenders: 1. India 2. Philippines 3. Pakistan - because of team lead was a Pakistani and we thought it would be easy to do things given that he was from there We did choose Pakistan because of our team lead and time zone wasnt too far behind London and we did try. The first hurdle was lack of ecosystem. There were no existing/thriving ecosystem for IT or SW development like India or Philippines. We wanted to be part of the silicon valley of the region so, we weren't alone in this country. There were none in Pakistan. India had several - Bengaluru, Noida, Hyderabad etc. Philippines had a few - Manila Metro, Davoa etc. Then, there were no frequent direct flights from London to Pakistan. There are only three direct flights to Islamabad from London per week. Compared that to Bengaluru which isn't even the capital of India which has direct flights every single day and price of the ticket is also so much cheaper. And, Delhi has tens of direct flights from London. Then, bureaucracy. We just didn't know how to setup a business in Pakistan. We didn't know a single company that had setup businesses in Pakistan so, we can ask them how it can be done. This is even after our team lead was a Pakistani who knew Urdu. I can't imagine what it will be like for a foreigner. Then, remittance to pay our employees. Apparently, a lot of Pakistani people send money via black market since it gives them better rates. The rate difference that we heard from black markets were so much higher than what the proper/legal way gave us. Ofc, we didn't want to use the shady way to transfer funds to Pakistan to run our business. Finally, lack of diverse talent pool. In India, you would find industry working closely with educational institutions (although not to the level of China or other western countries). Pakistan had none. There were two different things. We found it will be so hard to build products there if this relationship didn't exist. So, eventually, we chose India because it had solutions for all the things I described. Just gives an idea for fellow Pakistani what needs to be fixed.
The fact that Pakistan was chosen initially doesn't speak highly of your organisation - it seems to be driven by the choices or prejudices of individuals rather than actual facts which can lead to business success.
@@SkpalTube Sumit, that is not a correct interpretation. He did mention that the lead was a Pakistani citizen, which was a sensible reason to expand the business to Pakistan. He also showed the due diligence that they did in Pakistan. It is quite likely that their team leader would have a problem to stay long and operate in India, something that he himself probably didn't want to do.
@@sachin265 Sorry, but I disagree. Your nationality should not have any impact on your rational decision making. This shows your bias. There are a lot of Indian CEOs in multinational companies - but none of them are trying to invest in India for areas which we are not good at currently, say high-tech manufacturing.
I'm an Indian and have worked in multiple MNCs over the years in Gurgaon, Bangalore and Mumbai. Sometimes I think what would I've been doing had there been no such companies. Really thankful to people who had vision to bring these companies to India, otherwise ours could have been a fate similar to Pakistan.
Modi or Rahul or Kejriwal we would attract these companies due to pool of educated Indians that will work. Indians are ideal workers in many respects. This is both good and bad for us.
I have purchased land on the outskirts of Bangalore and went to a village Panchayat office to get the purchase registered. EVERY payment was online and transparent. Photo ID's were taken on the spot, transfer of ownership done immediately, proof printed out and given, and also sent to me electronically. I had budgeted 2 days for the exercise. Was in and out in 30 minutes. Spent the rest of the time sightseeing in Bangalore (Only regret - did not go to Mysore to sight see - struck me too late on the 2nd day that I could/ should have). And mind you, this was in a VILLAGE
@@walterwhite9520this is not sadistic pleasure.. we would have been like Pakistan if we voted Congress on 2014.. our conditions were very close to Pakistan. In fact till 2008 Pakistan had bigger per capita GDP than us z
It is all about politics. If you do not elect a correct India development focused government then yes, India will be another Pakistan. Look at our state Telangana. We never voted BJP. But all the national Highways and major railway projects happening in our state are being constructed in the past 6~7 years. The existing highways were constructed during Vajpeyye era. After a gap of 10 years 2004-14 now again all the infra projects are gooing on fast pace. Remember that Telangana (combined Andhra) was the main reason for Congress forming overnment in 2004 and 2009 at the center because Andhra alone gave 35+ MP seats to Congress party. Yet they have done nothing in our state. Now, we have given just 4 MP seats to BJP in 2019 elections and 1 mp SEAT in 2004 elections. Still the number of projects that center is allocating to our state is massive. So, it is clearly evident that irrespective of politics BJP is supporting Telangana's progress keeping in Mind India's progress. @@walterwhite9520
It's really sad that there are more comments here from India than from Pakistan i believe that Pakistanis are not interested to listen to intellectual discussion.
@@ravinunna1168I wish BJP had the same attitude towards AP that it did towards TS. But the difference is that BJP sees political future in TS and hence the interest versus no interest in AP due to dismal political future prospects and hence no interest.
😂😂. What about the recent 350 crore cash haul from a businessman- politician? Cash in circulation is HIGHER than pre demonetization 😁. UPI is definitely a success, but is being used for low value transactions .
@@DankelkarIndia ed blocks dollars investment of politicians and as strict money laundering laws .... So corruption money of indian politicians are in India 99% Ed in India is so strong it will catch politicians easily. 2000 notes are not in circulation Only 500 when it will go 😅
@@Dankelkargst tax base of India is 140 crore now 5crore business loans is given on high tax payed for 5 years. Only. 10lakh loan is without income tax Education loans too
Behen soldiers ne aapki jesi khawateen k liye glaciers ki thand me aur deserts ki garmi me aapki hifaazat ki hai. Army buri nhi army k generals aur upper ranked officers Bure Hain. Aur army ne humen 1960 -1970 tk boht serve Kiya hai
@@syedmuhammadsairsherazithis is exactly the kind of confusion which is created in our society and which is why we have complete lost track. Islander Mirza ke ghaltee thee army kee naheen, Yahya ke ghaltee thee army kee naheen, zia kee ghaltee thee army kee naheen, musharraf kee ghaltee thee army kee naheen. Point is you as a country is now a third tier country, no one cares about you because you still glorify your army and not educate your people, improve human development...I got out 21 years ago and I thank Allah every single day.....
I am from India.. Working decently in a financial institution.. The economic knowledge the guest has is very on point. Pak need such minds as their advisors. 👍👍
That airport thing he spoke is so true. I can completely relate with it. When I started traveling abroad from India in early 2000, used to dread coming back to India to face the immigration and customs which behaved just like he mentioned. Now for the last 10 years, there is massive change in Indian airports. The sarkari officials seem clearly hesitant to harass ordinary travellers. Major Airports have become world beaters. Every Indian seeing this video needs to understand that we need BJP in power for another 2 decades at any cost otherwise we will once again become like Pakistan.
Mai govt. Office me duplicate driving license banwane gaya, ye sarkari log muje aise treat krre ke mai koi inka private customer hoon. 112 me rat ke 1 bje call karo police 2 mint me aa jati hai. Location batane ki zarurat nahi, call se hi location nikaal k pahuch jate hai. Ye to ek aad example de raha hoon mai. System bahut behtar hua hai India me.
with BJP in power we will become like pakistan: insular, hate between communities, first class and second class citizens based on religion, non-state violent actors promoted by the state, failure of institutions etc. We are in a hopeless loop with Modi and RSS
@@ParthMusic You don't realize BJP is hollowing India from inside and it shall collapse all of a sudden. Pakistan Army made Pakistan hollow from inside. BJP is making it the same.
This young man with Junaid bhai and their discussion and understanding is far far far superior than any prime time show on TV and so called journalists! Wonderful hour passed! Excellent humorous and intellectual discussion!
Watching from India, Junaid is such a brilliant guy talking with logic and basic things required to implements. Please bring this guy more often , so much to learn from. The point he talked about nutrients is so important throughout our sub-continent because people are not getting it and large population are denied of this basic thing, I am glad that Indian Govt working on the plan to provide free food scheme to 80% ppl
Junaid and Habib bhaion, In 1960s, in my village there was just one motor bike, no cars at all and rest few cycles. There were three renting cycle shops. Cement was in black market, rice was rationed. This is the story of 95% Indian villages till 1970. Then came green revolution (rice and wheat) and India became self sufficient in grains. Then came white revolution (milk). I still remember, the waiting time for purchasing a Bajaj scooter was 12 years, not months. Such were the type of controls the government had on business. In 1991, Narasimha Rao and Manmohan Singh duo changed the face of the country, from begger to giver. In 15 years the open market policy changed the fortunes of the country. Today, in 2020s, there are more than 1500 motor bikes, nearly 120 cars, half of the houses with air conditioners. Reasons are, there are lots of opportunities and at least one kid is sending dollars from a foreign land. It takes a gritty government policies to change the country’s status and people with patience. Pakistan has youth fed with completely falsified history and truth. Allah Islam is dead and mullahs Islam is ruling. This is called a point of no return. Put all mullaahs in prison and invite open market. Pakistan will be a great country soon. Jai hind.
Correction: 1. In 1991, Narasimha Rao and Manmohan Singh were forced to change because of IMF/World bank, NOT due to to any progressive congress policies!! M. Singh was catastrophic idiot in his career & did nothing good for the nation!! Rao was better though & more pragmatic!! 2. Put all mullaahs in prison and invite open market. Pakistan will be a great country soon: Pakistani elite is too corrupt and radicalized Islamic!! Unless there is BIG existential pressure from west & Arab world, it won't change!! And west won't like that change even if Arabs want it!!
Usually in a one and a half hour talk people talk “ain bain shain”, talk about irrelevant things. But hats off to Ammar Habib his analysis is to the point and perfect about what and why our economic crisis are. Following him from now on absolutely 💯
I am working in Germany, and I noticed 1 more issue that companies are not coming to Pakistan are the absence of data protection laws and regulations in Pakistan.
Also islamic radicalized mindset(pata nahi kab office ko aag laga de gustakhi ke gunah me) which is 95% of yr population. even yr elite class is full of hatred towards india and dreams of converting hindus to islam.
@@vb9950 No even that..... China has ethics at least for the Chinese.... The problem with Pakistan is that, they don't even have ethics for anyone,even to Pakistan...
As an Indian muslim…Kashmir is an integral part of INDIA and its a fact agar POK india join krle toh 50 saal ki developments sirf 5 saal me hojayegi…lekin nhi logo me ego hi itna hai bas kya kare….tumhare ziyal ul haq ne tumhare country ko 50% khud hi barbaad krke margaya due to his own Ego
Bro what ego they hv??? Egoistic people r considered to be dignified and they hv code of honour. Ye to parly darjy k begherat log hyn or oper sy bhekari bhi hyn. porkistan k army waly apni maa bhen betiyaan bhej kar america sy dollars kama sakhty hyn to aap kya expect kr rahy hu in sy ye ab ego waly bn gaiy hyn hahaah 😂😂😂 ye begherat neech or 1 number k bhekari log hy.
How is Kashmir an integral part of India? There was no India before British. Kashmir is part of the Harappan civilization, with the people's land stretching from the Indus River in modern day Pakistan to the Arabian Sea. Kashmir is not part of the Ganges civilization, Kashmir has never been part of present India, Kashmir lies in the Himalayan region of the Punjab and it is a natural part of Pakistan, all routes to Kashmir are from Skardu, Rawalpindi, Muzaffarabad in Pakistan. We all speak the same language, different forms of Punjabi. Plz tell us what do you have anything in common with a Tamil, Manipuri, Nagalandi, Gujrati, Bihari, Assami, Karnaataki, Bengali etc etc?
@@sabrinakhan8217there was no india before British 😂😂😂 Again as mentioned in video you studied history from Pakistan studies😂 means all lies Famous Greek writer Megasthenes in his book indica written in 5th century BC defines india as east of persia to south of Himalayas spread over 3000kms land east to west India bharat hindustan all the 3 words are thousands of years old Actual truth is there was no Pakistan word before 1940s
@@sabrinakhan8217what is common with indian languages 😂😂 Do a simple google search on the word Kashmir Kashmir itself is a sanskrit word it comes from the name of famous rishi Kashyapa Sanskrit is the oldest language in the world most of indic languages are derived from Sanskrit Your knowledge of language is also zero😂😂 There is no word or language called karnaataki😂 Its called kannad Just knowing the name of the state and adding "i" in the end how lame is your knowledge of languages
@@sabrinakhan8217when did punjabi become your language? Your national language is only urdu whose birthplace is Lucknow india You people are ashmed of punjabi language. Punjabi is neither your national language nor official language of Pakistan Punjabi is written in the distinctive Gurmukhi script, which is particularly associated with the Sikhs. That script is a member of the Indic family of scripts Its india who has given punjabi language and punjabi music international recognition not pak Punjabi is official language of india along with 21 other languages I am actually shocked you owning up harappa mohenjadaro indus civilizationals as your own because these civilizations had absolutely nothing to do with muslims or islamic republic Please also own taxila worlds oldest university now in Pakistan also own chanakya teacher of taxila and chandra gupta mourya student of taxila Make these people your hero Instead of making turks arabs persian afghan foreign invaders your hero who butchered people of your own land & killed your ancestors
We as Pakistanis must be happy with the progress of our Nabour India. We have to learn from India . Only as best Nabour’s both countries can grow . Mumtaz Ali
Tum apna dekho, we dont need Pakistan to grow for India to grow. You need India to grow, the sooner you realise this the better it will be for Pakistan. Else jaisa Modi ne bola hai "Pakistan apni maut khud marega" !!
Economics stands apart, sirs knowledge is commendable shows the difference of mindset of common people on issue and economic experts views , incredible person
Like many things have changed in my village, many things changed in my country too. Today, India is, The largest two wheeler manufacturer The third largest car manufacturer With 1500 million population, grain and milk production is at export level The third largest medicine producer in the world and most economical too The most economical satellite launcher One of the best medical tourism places in the world Very good education and very good reputation as hard working diaspora. Excellent road and railway network. What else do we need as citizens. We are proud of our country. Jai hind.
I was married to Indonesian, one day i was driving around to fill up the fuel. My wife said dont go to this petrol station it is international company. Go to the next one it is Indonesian company. That's is how loyal they are with the country. Whereas in Pakistan, we love imported products.
I am an Indian living in Delhi. To be honest, I listen to this prodcast to feel good about the living conditions in my city which are much better. By looking at our neighbours' situation, I feel much better and happy to have born in Delhi
India has similar problems. Toxic air in Delhi reduces lifespan by 5-10 years. Indians should compare ourselves with S Korea, China etc in order to improve. Even Vietnam, Thailand, Malaysia are good benchmarks. They are all VERY CLEAN and doing better than India. There is no point in watching Paki Yourubers just to feel good about ourselves. We should learn frim Vietnam about school education. In a recent study, Vietnamese children did better than US/UK ❤❤❤.
Abe chutiyee compare with china Europe , America and south east countrys we are just nothing. Or too or abhi India kae matches hai south africa Mae dekha kya, south africa ka infrastructure bhi India se kafi acha hai😂🖕
Pakistan's biggest obstacle in the growth is religion. No one dared to admit that . Pakistan can progress only if religion is thrown out from the education system. Thank you
I am not sure why all these so called educated Pakistanis are missing this point or they are too scared of the radical mulllahs , who are unfortunately, in majority. And another reason is Pakistan has spent all its resources on destabilising its neighbours like India and Afghanistan. And forget about Kashmir as you really think much stronger India will give up Kashmir to Pakistan, instead spend those resources on your education.
What these guys don’t want to share in this podcast is this: The deliberate discouraging of formal businesses has direct relation to the prevalence of Fauji foundation promoted businesses in every sphere of business. From toothpaste to bread to dairy to cement, every leading company across sectors is a front managed by Fauji foundation. Pakistani ordinary citizens are nothing more than economic slaves managed by the Pakistani defence establishment. They will never ever allow this slave force to escape their clutches and put their future generations at risk.
@hotice31 soon you will receive hate comments for hitting the bullseye 🎯 the elites with the army will keep the population in their control by brainwashing them with religious agenda and these people on podcast will not even look that way!
Yes indeed. All these discussions, which readers are praising, is idle gossip because the root cause is never discussed. Without addressing the root cause (which is unaddresseable), they can keep discussing this topic till qayaamat, but nothing will change.
Soo good. Listening to Ammar felt like only if we get proper educated, solution oriented policy makers, we can make something of this huge full potential country.
but tumhare current PM ko to india k hinduo ko Islam me convert karne me zyada interest hai. he said we will try even if it takes a millenia to convince them.
I hold a Ph.D. in Economics and have been residing in the United States since 1976. Prior to relocating, I completed my Master's degree in Economics at Punjab University in Lahore, Pakistan. Subsequently, I pursued my doctoral studies in the United States. Presently, I am employed as an economist and have established permanent residency in the USA
@@princeranjan_inyou still believe that?? The video was exposed years ago, he was actually quoting a bjp mla, who went to that village few days ago Not a congressi btw
I was in 10th in 2005. since then, I was hearing that Pakistan is failed state. Now I know more as I have many friends from Pakistan who tell me reality
What a wonderful podcast. I was hooked. It is such a pity that our powers that be are blind to such simple solutions. Anyhow, thank you so much for introducing me to another good economist after Uzair Younis.
Not really, In It over 5000 years of history, the current region of Pakistan was part of the British and Muighal-created India for less than 600 years. The province of KPK less than 200 years. There was no India before the British. Secondly, Ghouri, and Ghaznavi didn't kill any in Northwestern regions ( current Pakistan). To create hate and friction between Hindus and Muslims, this lie was concocted by Britsh and later Arya smaj, Maha Saba, Viveknnada, Gwaliar, RSS schools of thought , in late 1800's. Ghaznavi attacked ganga Jamna with the full support of Northwest just like Maurya, Kushan, Porus, Dahir have always attacked Ganga Jamna. Mauryans alone killed 5 million Ganga Jamnis. They didn't know what Bharat Hindusthan ( made by ghouri) Hindu is. These empires from Northwest Indus valley and Gandhara always had trade and cultural ties with Central Asia ( Afganistan, Iran, Uzbikistan) and attacks towards ganga jamuna. Ask South Indians . They hate Indus valley and its kings. They were even protesting against the term " Hindu" ( ppl of Indus Sindh) until Indra Gandhi bombed Tamil Tigers twice. Im not going to even talk about Chinese burmse Tibet states of Northeast India Captured by the British and forcefully included in British created India. It's been 70 years the whole northeast is a no go zone. Indian army is deployed there to kill freedom fighters on daily basis.
Nothing is going to change as long as your _fauj_ controls the country. It isn't lack of knowledge that is holding Pakistan back - it's the hold that your Army has on your country. Pakistan is a military dictatorship in hiding. It will continue going down.
Your army controls your economy that's the main problem. And the funny thing is nobody can even talk bad about the army, that's the lvl of democracy in pakistan.
Before 2014 our Indian airports is also look like Pakistani airport but after Modi's government there is a massive change it becomes world-class even better of some western countries
It baffles me to see in Pakistan, there is only a single two-wheeler company that is Honda and that basic bike costs 1,70,000 and not a single home made two-wheeler whereas most of India's two-wheeler sales is from India make companies
good point about public buildings designed to deny access. Colonial architecture was designed to instill fear, awe and distance from the colonised masses. Unfortunately, th colonial mind set continues which is why the govt continues to treat the citizens with contempt. All British India buildings should be made museums.
Indian Railway stations were not made to instil fear, and so were many other colonial buildings. Many of them have already been converted into museums.
Fellow Indians in comments are already living in amritkaal. China's gdp growth rate was 10%+ when they were at our level. What economic boom have we seen in last decade comparable to IT boom in early 2000s and auto boom in early 2010s? We are still just reaping fruits of those booms.
Since 2014, Modi Era, many booms not seen in previous 70 years have happened: 1. Infrastructure boom!! 2. Telecom & Internet boom!! 3. Digital Transactions boom!! 4. Banking boom + congress era bad debts / NPA redress-al!! 5. Laws & regulations: Useless laws & regulations dissolved.. ++ 6. Civilization-al & cultural boom There are many more booms one can recollect since just last 10 years!!
Pleased to hear you both. First time watching the full podcast. I really feel sad about youth and young kids of Pakistan how they are being manipulated by local administration and governmnent. This is very true that if you manipulate your history to misguide and mislead your present, for sure your future will be direction less. I think people like you shuold motivate your youth and conduct free seminars to make them aware of today's world and its dynamics.
I am an engineer who can open multiple factories but becz of agencies, commissions and taxes i would rather migrate n build a factory in a different country whr my efforts are treated well and awarded
And why not in Turkey, Central Asia or say many Muslim-majority developed countries. In India, low consumption of meat is the main reason for stunting among children.
*Neutral Property Dealers Ne Poora Mulk Barbaad Kardiya* 🥲 *Pakistan ko 100 Aur 9th May Ki Zarurat Hai* , *Tab Jaakar Property Dealers Se Azaadi Milegi* 😡
Bro just leave the country immediately and focus to make ur life better. pak is not ur concern its a concern of napak army n politicians. If u found a better opportunity outside from this deadland leave immediately. dont waste ur time here.
The taxes are placed by the army to stop international companies. Bahadur fauj is controlling trade and we aren't aware of the deals and the money Pak fauj has. It's a mafia.
@Skywimz you need freedom from your army unless you break them or your countrey nothing going to change pakistan will only exist to serve them and sustain them
25:35 you are so right. there’s a youtuber Momina Munir who opened a food cart in Karachi. she had to pay so many people to make it work. after the import ban her cart was briefly unprofitable as well.
Hey Junaid Akram, i watched this podcast till the end. And i believe, people now should come up and talk to the government people. We should write legislation by ourselves and submit them to their hand. It is a rude to compare Pakistan with any other neighbouring country but we are in hands of uniform people and same state of mind is transferring down the line whereas people live and grow when there is peace of mind and enough resources. Ammar is a clever guy he does know the problem and their solutions too. Invite him again. And you may also have a chit chat with me on some reforms and survival in recent times. Take care.
India is doing so much better than Pakistan on all fronts however I can still relate to the corruption and way of working that Amar Habib is describing here. We share so much but I feel happy that India has left such petty corruption and Mismanagement behind and is now looking forward to future with hope. Really sad to see a group of people who share a common ancestry and culture with India are unable to rise to their potential.
I’m a small business owner in UK, my experience is that if you go by the books the hurdles, problems and issue also exist here in the UK as well. Plus you will also have to pay VAT, capital gain tax, insurance, pension and other tax expenses. The point is, doing things by the book is not easy and simple but you have to do it, regardless of its expenses and easiness. I guess as nation our mindset need to be change, you must pay taxes, you must follow rules and regulations, you must adhere to local tax and business rules and regulations and you must do it. It is absurd that making an excuse that people not paying taxes or going by the book because there is too much paperwork or rules and regulations to follow.
How many times will you all break down Pak's economic crises? Just accept the fact that there is no option but to face reality. And the reality is "Implosion."
You are 100% on the spot. USA is doing immigration in Dubai. If you are traveling to Us you do your custom and immigration at Dubai. So when you land at USA it is your local flight. You just walk in the USA without any further check up.
Totally agree with his views, these are core issues of our society. But again! I hear a lot of people again and again I never hear the detailed solutions of these issues. No one knows how to come up with a greatest solution which will turn around Pakistan's path. I believe everything is affected by "domino effect" we just have to flip the top basic starting domino (country's Industrial growth strategies) that will flip the thinking of people. Majority of our population is so "laid back/lazy" we don't build anything we don't create anything in this country to compete in international markets. Until unless we don't create these opportunities we are doomed.
The books behind junaid sir is 1) The spy chronicles --story between ISI and RAW wtitten by aditya sinha, A.S.Dulat indian author 2) Origions - About earth and human history by lewis dartnel 3) OSHO living life dangerous -- indian origion American philosopher book on understanding life.
The best way to get rid of corruption is to use high end technology so human intervention is minimised. But the problem is when you have most of uneducated population technology can’t do anything. 10 yrs invest in high quality education a must do to start with.
If any mnc is coming they ask for good infrastructure, super highways for transport, 24 hour non stop electricity, 24 hour water supply, good civilised people . international air port and direct acess to each country is all available in pakistan, and more on that digital infrastructure.
First of all MNCs are not leaving pakistan coz of local small companies doing work on cash 🤦 it doesnt make much of impact for them. Same thing happens in india and so many countries bht MNCs are still operating there. Its gov policies, security and economic stability which are cuasing all the issue. 2 twitter post kr k economist ban jao
Because in other countries the consumer for MNCs and local companies can differ. That is not the case in Pakistan and even in some states of India. So he is correct. Taxation should be the same for everyone.
I am a student in INDIA and from last 5 years I don’t use cash even am travelling far , becz all petrol pump ,restaurant, shopes,bus etc has UPI, Even for biscuits or some 10 rupees thing i do UPI it just took 5 to 10 seconds to payment
Two biggest reasons for Pakistan’s failure as a nation: 1. Extreme levels of radical islam. 2. No focus on research, development, scientific rigour and strategic thinking.
All of the issues are the government. When you have theifs on top, laws are not followed or enforced, then no one will come here. We as a whole need to stand up to the government and not be scared. We need to fight for our rights and have accountable government, and then the majority of our issues will settle. On top of that, we are a nuclear power Muslim country, west don't want us to be top. We need to be united.
I will tell you a small story.
I work for a Fortune 500 company and we were thinking of expanding our team to emerging markets to reduce our costs. We picked 3 possible contenders:
1. India
2. Philippines
3. Pakistan - because of team lead was a Pakistani and we thought it would be easy to do things given that he was from there
We did choose Pakistan because of our team lead and time zone wasnt too far behind London and we did try. The first hurdle was lack of ecosystem. There were no existing/thriving ecosystem for IT or SW development like India or Philippines. We wanted to be part of the silicon valley of the region so, we weren't alone in this country. There were none in Pakistan. India had several - Bengaluru, Noida, Hyderabad etc. Philippines had a few - Manila Metro, Davoa etc.
Then, there were no frequent direct flights from London to Pakistan. There are only three direct flights to Islamabad from London per week. Compared that to Bengaluru which isn't even the capital of India which has direct flights every single day and price of the ticket is also so much cheaper. And, Delhi has tens of direct flights from London.
Then, bureaucracy. We just didn't know how to setup a business in Pakistan. We didn't know a single company that had setup businesses in Pakistan so, we can ask them how it can be done. This is even after our team lead was a Pakistani who knew Urdu. I can't imagine what it will be like for a foreigner.
Then, remittance to pay our employees. Apparently, a lot of Pakistani people send money via black market since it gives them better rates. The rate difference that we heard from black markets were so much higher than what the proper/legal way gave us. Ofc, we didn't want to use the shady way to transfer funds to Pakistan to run our business.
Finally, lack of diverse talent pool. In India, you would find industry working closely with educational institutions (although not to the level of China or other western countries). Pakistan had none. There were two different things. We found it will be so hard to build products there if this relationship didn't exist.
So, eventually, we chose India because it had solutions for all the things I described. Just gives an idea for fellow Pakistani what needs to be fixed.
As an Indian, I’m gonna thank you for choosing India ❤ 🇮🇳
The fact that Pakistan was chosen initially doesn't speak highly of your organisation - it seems to be driven by the choices or prejudices of individuals rather than actual facts which can lead to business success.
@@SkpalTube Sumit, that is not a correct interpretation. He did mention that the lead was a Pakistani citizen, which was a sensible reason to expand the business to Pakistan. He also showed the due diligence that they did in Pakistan. It is quite likely that their team leader would have a problem to stay long and operate in India, something that he himself probably didn't want to do.
Thanks for coming to India, hope you get multiple chances to visit beautiful places of this country.
@@sachin265 Sorry, but I disagree. Your nationality should not have any impact on your rational decision making. This shows your bias. There are a lot of Indian CEOs in multinational companies - but none of them are trying to invest in India for areas which we are not good at currently, say high-tech manufacturing.
I'm an Indian and have worked in multiple MNCs over the years in Gurgaon, Bangalore and Mumbai. Sometimes I think what would I've been doing had there been no such companies. Really thankful to people who had vision to bring these companies to India, otherwise ours could have been a fate similar to Pakistan.
Thanks to Modiji for bringing these companies..... Hang on.....😮
Not similiar to Pakistan.....with our population.....it could have been a 1000 times worse than Pakistan....
Thank PV Narasimha Rao
You are right.
Modi or Rahul or Kejriwal we would attract these companies due to pool of educated Indians that will work. Indians are ideal workers in many respects. This is both good and bad for us.
I have purchased land on the outskirts of Bangalore and went to a village Panchayat office to get the purchase registered. EVERY payment was online and transparent. Photo ID's were taken on the spot, transfer of ownership done immediately, proof printed out and given, and also sent to me electronically. I had budgeted 2 days for the exercise. Was in and out in 30 minutes. Spent the rest of the time sightseeing in Bangalore (Only regret - did not go to Mysore to sight see - struck me too late on the 2nd day that I could/ should have). And mind you, this was in a VILLAGE
Main bhi nahi jaa paya tha Mysore 😢 when i was in Bangalore
@@walterwhite9520this is not sadistic pleasure.. we would have been like Pakistan if we voted Congress on 2014.. our conditions were very close to Pakistan. In fact till 2008 Pakistan had bigger per capita GDP than us z
It is all about politics. If you do not elect a correct India development focused government then yes, India will be another Pakistan. Look at our state Telangana. We never voted BJP. But all the national Highways and major railway projects happening in our state are being constructed in the past 6~7 years. The existing highways were constructed during Vajpeyye era. After a gap of 10 years 2004-14 now again all the infra projects are gooing on fast pace. Remember that Telangana (combined Andhra) was the main reason for Congress forming overnment in 2004 and 2009 at the center because Andhra alone gave 35+ MP seats to Congress party. Yet they have done nothing in our state. Now, we have given just 4 MP seats to BJP in 2019 elections and 1 mp SEAT in 2004 elections. Still the number of projects that center is allocating to our state is massive. So, it is clearly evident that irrespective of politics BJP is supporting Telangana's progress keeping in Mind India's progress. @@walterwhite9520
It's really sad that there are more comments here from India than from Pakistan i believe that Pakistanis are not interested to listen to intellectual discussion.
@@ravinunna1168I wish BJP had the same attitude towards AP that it did towards TS. But the difference is that BJP sees political future in TS and hence the interest versus no interest in AP due to dismal political future prospects and hence no interest.
In India people have forgotten how to use cash transactions...
If UPI is withdrawn tomorrow business will virtually come to a halt
I now feel that I have to wash my hands after handling paper cash notes.
😂😂. What about the recent 350 crore cash haul from a businessman- politician? Cash in circulation is HIGHER than pre demonetization 😁. UPI is definitely a success, but is being used for low value transactions .
@@Dankelkar UPI is not a solution for "that economy" or used case. Tihar might be a solution, properly implemented.
@@DankelkarIndia ed blocks dollars investment of politicians and as strict money laundering laws ....
So corruption money of indian politicians are in India 99%
Ed in India is so strong it will catch politicians easily.
2000 notes are not in circulation
Only 500 when it will go 😅
@@Dankelkargst tax base of India is 140 crore now
5crore business loans is given on high tax payed for 5 years. Only.
10lakh loan is without income tax
Education loans too
This one video is helping Pakistan more than the Pak army itself has done for Pakistan for the past 76 years!
Hahahahah yeah TH-cam trends follow krny se behtr ha 1 hour k lie yehi sun len 😅
Behen soldiers ne aapki jesi khawateen k liye glaciers ki thand me aur deserts ki garmi me aapki hifaazat ki hai. Army buri nhi army k generals aur upper ranked officers Bure Hain. Aur army ne humen 1960 -1970 tk boht serve Kiya hai
@@syedmuhammadsairsheraziwo bhi yehi kahna chah rhi ha...ke Army ke senior officers corrupt and unloyal hain
@@syedmuhammadsairsherazithis is exactly the kind of confusion which is created in our society and which is why we have complete lost track. Islander Mirza ke ghaltee thee army kee naheen, Yahya ke ghaltee thee army kee naheen, zia kee ghaltee thee army kee naheen, musharraf kee ghaltee thee army kee naheen. Point is you as a country is now a third tier country, no one cares about you because you still glorify your army and not educate your people, improve human development...I got out 21 years ago and I thank Allah every single day.....
Haha. Spot on! Best comment ever.
I am from India.. Working decently in a financial institution.. The economic knowledge the guest has is very on point. Pak need such minds as their advisors. 👍👍
Should one pursue CA or not ?? How do you see it's scope in the near future?
Btw what is mult-eye ?? If I'm not wrong it's multi.... multinational
That airport thing he spoke is so true.
I can completely relate with it. When I started traveling abroad from India in early 2000, used to dread coming back to India to face the immigration and customs which behaved just like he mentioned. Now for the last 10 years, there is massive change in Indian airports. The sarkari officials seem clearly hesitant to harass ordinary travellers. Major Airports have become world beaters.
Every Indian seeing this video needs to understand that we need BJP in power for another 2 decades at any cost otherwise we will once again become like Pakistan.
Mai govt. Office me duplicate driving license banwane gaya, ye sarkari log muje aise treat krre ke mai koi inka private customer hoon.
112 me rat ke 1 bje call karo police 2 mint me aa jati hai. Location batane ki zarurat nahi, call se hi location nikaal k pahuch jate hai.
Ye to ek aad example de raha hoon mai.
System bahut behtar hua hai India me.
with BJP in power we will become like pakistan: insular, hate between communities, first class and second class citizens based on religion, non-state violent actors promoted by the state, failure of institutions etc. We are in a hopeless loop with Modi and RSS
BJP will make you like Pakistan. We need congress.
@@Maryam-Fatma 10 saal se to hua nahi. Pakistan se to behtar hi hai hum
@@ParthMusic You don't realize BJP is hollowing India from inside and it shall collapse all of a sudden.
Pakistan Army made Pakistan hollow from inside.
BJP is making it the same.
This young man with Junaid bhai and their discussion and understanding is far far far superior than any prime time show on TV and so called journalists! Wonderful hour passed! Excellent humorous and intellectual discussion!
this is not an intellectual discussion these guys don't have any data to prove what they are saying
Do only one thing to improve Pakistan ,,, keep away your Allah+Quran+MullaMoulavi+Generals....within 5 years > trillion economy
When reality is before our eyes, is data that significant
@@leahburke7579no data but realistic discussion. You should only be watching ptv.
@@leahburke7579 Ammar Khan is an economist, should he show you slides during discussion.
Watching from India, Junaid is such a brilliant guy talking with logic and basic things required to implements. Please bring this guy more often , so much to learn from. The point he talked about nutrients is so important throughout our sub-continent because people are not getting it and large population are denied of this basic thing, I am glad that Indian Govt working on the plan to provide free food scheme to 80% ppl
Junaid and Habib bhaion,
In 1960s, in my village there was just one motor bike, no cars at all and rest few cycles. There were three renting cycle shops. Cement was in black market, rice was rationed. This is the story of 95% Indian villages till 1970.
Then came green revolution (rice and wheat) and India became self sufficient in grains. Then came white revolution (milk). I still remember, the waiting time for purchasing a Bajaj scooter was 12 years, not months. Such were the type of controls the government had on business.
In 1991, Narasimha Rao and Manmohan Singh duo changed the face of the country, from begger to giver. In 15 years the open market policy changed the fortunes of the country.
Today, in 2020s, there are more than 1500 motor bikes, nearly 120 cars, half of the houses with air conditioners. Reasons are, there are lots of opportunities and at least one kid is sending dollars from a foreign land.
It takes a gritty government policies to change the country’s status and people with patience. Pakistan has youth fed with completely falsified history and truth. Allah Islam is dead and mullahs Islam is ruling. This is called a point of no return. Put all mullaahs in prison and invite open market.
Pakistan will be a great country soon.
Jai hind.
Correction:
1. In 1991, Narasimha Rao and Manmohan Singh were forced to change because of IMF/World bank, NOT due to to any progressive congress policies!!
M. Singh was catastrophic idiot in his career & did nothing good for the nation!! Rao was better though & more pragmatic!!
2. Put all mullaahs in prison and invite open market.
Pakistan will be a great country soon:
Pakistani elite is too corrupt and radicalized Islamic!! Unless there is BIG existential pressure from west & Arab world, it won't change!! And west won't like that change even if Arabs want it!!
BCCI (bank)
Narsimha Rao is the Rishi who brought about this change.
Well said. But your advice will fall on deaf ears.
@@seekingpartner manmohan singh did, he was the finance minister. Rao ka kya hi economic intelligence tha.
Usually in a one and a half hour talk people talk “ain bain shain”, talk about irrelevant things. But hats off to Ammar Habib his analysis is to the point and perfect about what and why our economic crisis are. Following him from now on absolutely 💯
I am working in Germany, and I noticed 1 more issue that companies are not coming to Pakistan are the absence of data protection laws and regulations in Pakistan.
Absence of humanity is the major factor...
and Everything is linked to that@@saqir
There is no data protection laws and regulations in china as well. Stabiity is important.
Also islamic radicalized mindset(pata nahi kab office ko aag laga de gustakhi ke gunah me) which is 95% of yr population. even yr elite class is full of hatred towards india and dreams of converting hindus to islam.
@@vb9950 No even that..... China has ethics at least for the Chinese.... The problem with Pakistan is that, they don't even have ethics for anyone,even to Pakistan...
As an Indian muslim…Kashmir is an integral part of INDIA and its a fact agar POK india join krle toh 50 saal ki developments sirf 5 saal me hojayegi…lekin nhi logo me ego hi itna hai bas kya kare….tumhare ziyal ul haq ne tumhare country ko 50% khud hi barbaad krke margaya due to his own Ego
Bro what ego they hv??? Egoistic people r considered to be dignified and they hv code of honour. Ye to parly darjy k begherat log hyn or oper sy bhekari bhi hyn. porkistan k army waly apni maa bhen betiyaan bhej kar america sy dollars kama sakhty hyn to aap kya expect kr rahy hu in sy ye ab ego waly bn gaiy hyn hahaah 😂😂😂 ye begherat neech or 1 number k bhekari log hy.
How is Kashmir an integral part of India? There was no India before British. Kashmir is part of the Harappan civilization, with the people's land stretching from the Indus River in modern day Pakistan to the Arabian Sea. Kashmir is not part of the Ganges civilization, Kashmir has never been part of present India, Kashmir lies in the Himalayan region of the Punjab and it is a natural part of Pakistan, all routes to Kashmir are from Skardu, Rawalpindi, Muzaffarabad in Pakistan. We all speak the same language, different forms of Punjabi.
Plz tell us what do you have anything in common with a Tamil, Manipuri, Nagalandi, Gujrati, Bihari, Assami, Karnaataki, Bengali etc etc?
@@sabrinakhan8217there was no india before British 😂😂😂
Again as mentioned in video you studied history from Pakistan studies😂 means all lies
Famous Greek writer Megasthenes in his book indica written in 5th century BC defines india as east of persia to south of Himalayas spread over 3000kms land east to west
India bharat hindustan all the 3 words are thousands of years old
Actual truth is there was no Pakistan word before 1940s
@@sabrinakhan8217what is common with indian languages 😂😂
Do a simple google search on the word Kashmir
Kashmir itself is a sanskrit word it comes from the name of famous rishi Kashyapa
Sanskrit is the oldest language in the world most of indic languages are derived from Sanskrit
Your knowledge of language is also zero😂😂
There is no word or language called karnaataki😂
Its called kannad
Just knowing the name of the state and adding "i" in the end how lame is your knowledge of languages
@@sabrinakhan8217when did punjabi become your language?
Your national language is only urdu whose birthplace is Lucknow india
You people are ashmed of punjabi language. Punjabi is neither your national language nor official language of Pakistan
Punjabi is written in the distinctive Gurmukhi script, which is particularly associated with the Sikhs. That script is a member of the Indic family of scripts
Its india who has given punjabi language and punjabi music international recognition not pak
Punjabi is official language of india along with 21 other languages
I am actually shocked you owning up harappa mohenjadaro indus civilizationals as your own because these civilizations had absolutely nothing to do with muslims or islamic republic
Please also own taxila worlds oldest university now in Pakistan also own chanakya teacher of taxila and chandra gupta mourya student of taxila
Make these people your hero
Instead of making turks arabs persian afghan foreign invaders your hero who butchered people of your own land & killed your ancestors
i love how Ammar sir is not speaking in jargon. makes his observations and views easier to understand.
I'm very lucky to have working under Ammar, I've learned alot under working with him.
We as Pakistanis must be happy with the progress of our Nabour India. We have to learn from India . Only as best Nabour’s both countries can grow . Mumtaz Ali
Tum apna dekho, we dont need Pakistan to grow for India to grow. You need India to grow, the sooner you realise this the better it will be for Pakistan. Else jaisa Modi ne bola hai "Pakistan apni maut khud marega" !!
What a delight listening to Ammar. Would love to know what he is doing. He should be made minister of tourism as he has good ideas. Love from India.
Economics stands apart, sirs knowledge is commendable shows the difference of mindset of common people on issue and economic experts views , incredible person
Like many things have changed in my village, many things changed in my country too.
Today, India is,
The largest two wheeler manufacturer
The third largest car manufacturer
With 1500 million population, grain and milk production is at export level
The third largest medicine producer in the world and most economical too
The most economical satellite launcher
One of the best medical tourism places in the world
Very good education and very good reputation as hard working diaspora.
Excellent road and railway network.
What else do we need as citizens. We are proud of our country. Jai hind.
Better medical and education infrastructure
Your percapital income is $2700 china's percapital income is 15000
@@ashar29 pakistan pee capita 1500 😌 with 8 billion dollar foreign reserves
I was married to Indonesian, one day i was driving around to fill up the fuel. My wife said dont go to this petrol station it is international company. Go to the next one it is Indonesian company. That's is how loyal they are with the country. Whereas in Pakistan, we love imported products.
Junaidbhai we need plenty of more people like you to bring Pakistan up.
Kaise junaid bhai pakistan ko uplift kar sakhte hain. Establishment gand pharde ga...
Ammar is incredibly well spoken. Great episode.
It saddens me to see the suffering of the Pakistani people. But it equally worries me.
I am an Indian living in Delhi. To be honest, I listen to this prodcast to feel good about the living conditions in my city which are much better. By looking at our neighbours' situation, I feel much better and happy to have born in Delhi
Ram ram g
India has similar problems. Toxic air in Delhi reduces lifespan by 5-10 years. Indians should compare ourselves with S Korea, China etc in order to improve. Even Vietnam, Thailand, Malaysia are good benchmarks. They are all VERY CLEAN and doing better than India.
There is no point in watching Paki Yourubers just to feel good about ourselves.
We should learn frim Vietnam about school education. In a recent study, Vietnamese children did better than US/UK ❤❤❤.
Bhai pakistan ko islam le dooba.. wo islam jo pakistani samjhte hai wo islaam hai hi nahi.
@@akhirmalboosa2929 wo phir kya hai. Christianiti hai
Abe chutiyee compare with china Europe , America and south east countrys we are just nothing.
Or too or abhi India kae matches hai south africa Mae dekha kya, south africa ka infrastructure bhi India se kafi acha hai😂🖕
First time I am hearing a very intelligent talk. You guys are very intelligent and knowledgeable, wish your leaders were 5% oh you guys
This is a conversation which opens our minds....people are Precious like Ammar Bhai ....❤
Pakistan's biggest obstacle in the growth is religion. No one dared to admit that . Pakistan can progress only if religion is thrown out from the education system. Thank you
Pakistan ka masla kya: la illaha ill allah
Strange to hear that from a Muslim
@@saurabhjazz2132 yeh unn 10L,exmuslims mwin se hain
Israel's education system is knee deep in religion, pal.
I am not sure why all these so called educated Pakistanis are missing this point or they are too scared of the radical mulllahs , who are unfortunately, in majority. And another reason is Pakistan has spent all its resources on destabilising its neighbours like India and Afghanistan. And forget about Kashmir as you really think much stronger India will give up Kashmir to Pakistan, instead spend those resources on your education.
What these guys don’t want to share in this podcast is this:
The deliberate discouraging of formal businesses has direct relation to the prevalence of Fauji foundation promoted businesses in every sphere of business. From toothpaste to bread to dairy to cement, every leading company across sectors is a front managed by Fauji foundation.
Pakistani ordinary citizens are nothing more than economic slaves managed by the Pakistani defence establishment. They will never ever allow this slave force to escape their clutches and put their future generations at risk.
Very few people in Pakistan can understand that the economic issues are related to both the Government and Military in the business.
@hotice31 soon you will receive hate comments for hitting the bullseye 🎯 the elites with the army will keep the population in their control by brainwashing them with religious agenda and these people on podcast will not even look that way!
Yep. That's why both say "ye hamare pay grade se upar ki baat hai".
This is the core problem. .unless it is uprooted nothing good can happen
Yes indeed. All these discussions, which readers are praising, is idle gossip because the root cause is never discussed. Without addressing the root cause (which is unaddresseable), they can keep discussing this topic till qayaamat, but nothing will change.
Soo good. Listening to Ammar felt like only if we get proper educated, solution oriented policy makers, we can make something of this huge full potential country.
A country that thinks non believers are wajib-ul-qatl have no scope to grow....
Forget the potential...
but tumhare current PM ko to india k hinduo ko Islam me convert karne me zyada interest hai. he said we will try even if it takes a millenia to convince them.
@@AA13494 yeh EK chumtiya quom Hain..... Inka kucch Nahi hona...
Saari Duniya inn jaahilon se pareshaan hain
What a great podcast. Only critique is that it should have been longer. Guest needs a callback in the future for sure.
I hold a Ph.D. in Economics and have been residing in the United States since 1976. Prior to relocating, I completed my Master's degree in Economics at Punjab University in Lahore, Pakistan. Subsequently, I pursued my doctoral studies in the United States. Presently, I am employed as an economist and have established permanent residency in the USA
Another example of innovation is how MCD changed potatoes in India. The potatoes before McDonalds had high water content which weren't good for fries.
Lie. Sorry to bother, my Hero Rahul Gandhi ji made a potato machine which can even turn Potatoes into golds....
Everybody is a gangster until POTATO 🥔 ARRIVED
@@princeranjan_inyou still believe that?? The video was exposed years ago, he was actually quoting a bjp mla, who went to that village few days ago
Not a congressi btw
@@princeranjan_intypical bhakt i guess we all know what demonetisation and it cell made India
@@vipint3694 5th largest economy I guess
I never posted any comments , but your ideas of transportation give me tears ....
I was in 10th in 2005. since then, I was hearing that Pakistan is failed state. Now I know more as I have many friends from Pakistan who tell me reality
It was a privilege listening to this gentleman.
What a wonderful podcast. I was hooked. It is such a pity that our powers that be are blind to such simple solutions. Anyhow, thank you so much for introducing me to another good economist after Uzair Younis.
Amazing interview. Habbib ji explained everything in such a simple way. I wish someone would analyze Indian economy too in such simple way.
great podcast, this guy truly is knowledgeable
Not really, In It over 5000 years of history, the current region of Pakistan was part of the British and Muighal-created India for less than 600 years. The province of KPK less than 200 years. There was no India before the British. Secondly, Ghouri, and Ghaznavi didn't kill any in Northwestern regions ( current Pakistan). To create hate and friction between Hindus and Muslims, this lie was concocted by Britsh and later Arya smaj, Maha Saba, Viveknnada, Gwaliar, RSS schools of thought , in late 1800's. Ghaznavi attacked ganga Jamna with the full support of Northwest just like Maurya, Kushan, Porus, Dahir have always attacked Ganga Jamna. Mauryans alone killed 5 million Ganga Jamnis. They didn't know what Bharat Hindusthan ( made by ghouri) Hindu is. These empires from Northwest Indus valley and Gandhara always had trade and cultural ties with Central Asia ( Afganistan, Iran, Uzbikistan) and attacks towards ganga jamuna. Ask South Indians . They hate Indus valley and its kings. They were even protesting against the term " Hindu" ( ppl of Indus Sindh) until Indra Gandhi bombed Tamil Tigers twice. Im not going to even talk about Chinese burmse Tibet states of Northeast India Captured by the British and forcefully included in British created India. It's been 70 years the whole northeast is a no go zone. Indian army is deployed there to kill freedom fighters on daily basis.
Appreciated the best conversation . Long live our beloved country ❤Pakistan❤. Only the best minds like both of you can change our country . Mumtaz Ali
Nothing is going to change as long as your _fauj_ controls the country. It isn't lack of knowledge that is holding Pakistan back - it's the hold that your Army has on your country.
Pakistan is a military dictatorship in hiding. It will continue going down.
Your army controls your economy that's the main problem. And the funny thing is nobody can even talk bad about the army, that's the lvl of democracy in pakistan.
The guest is very wise man, enjoyed listening to his views.
Before 2014 our Indian airports is also look like Pakistani airport but after Modi's government there is a massive change it becomes world-class even better of some western countries
Bangalore Terminal 2 is mind-blowing. Uff Kamal ka hai Naya wala to.
Thanks for having wonderful discussions that make it easy for a common man to know what’s wrong with our Economy
Boss, this is economics 101. Thank-you
He is very clear in his ideas.
Imaan ka jazba hai na. Aur kya chahiye. Roz 4 baar mashallah subhanallah bolenge, sab teek hojayega. 😂
Big fan of yours Sir Ammar ❤️❤️ been following you from 8 years now from WHE too.
Pakistan four major problem
1. Religion first
2.Army
3.Madarsa education
4.Denial of it's history
It baffles me to see in Pakistan, there is only a single two-wheeler company that is Honda and that basic bike costs 1,70,000 and not a single home made two-wheeler whereas most of India's two-wheeler sales is from India make companies
A very smart man....need to get basic rights for any country to move forward.
16:58 ..... Basic issue
47:12 ..... Quetta
47:41 ..... Sind natural resources
1:02:55 ..... Transport
1:05:31 ..... Inaction
...
...
...
Every minute of this whole conversation is worth watching ......
good point about public buildings designed to deny access. Colonial architecture was designed to instill fear, awe and distance from the colonised masses. Unfortunately, th colonial mind set continues which is why the govt continues to treat the citizens with contempt. All British India buildings should be made museums.
Indian Railway stations were not made to instil fear, and so were many other colonial buildings. Many of them have already been converted into museums.
What an intellectual conversation you guys had 👍
Fellow Indians in comments are already living in amritkaal. China's gdp growth rate was 10%+ when they were at our level. What economic boom have we seen in last decade comparable to IT boom in early 2000s and auto boom in early 2010s? We are still just reaping fruits of those booms.
Since 2014, Modi Era, many booms not seen in previous 70 years have happened:
1. Infrastructure boom!!
2. Telecom & Internet boom!!
3. Digital Transactions boom!!
4. Banking boom + congress era bad debts / NPA redress-al!!
5. Laws & regulations: Useless laws & regulations dissolved.. ++
6. Civilization-al & cultural boom
There are many more booms one can recollect since just last 10 years!!
@@rka-truthalwayswins5127 If things are so great in india then why there are so many endians here in UAE. Most of them are working as labours 😂😂
I love Ammar. Could listen to him for hours
💯👌
Pleased to hear you both. First time watching the full podcast. I really feel sad about youth and young kids of Pakistan how they are being manipulated by local administration and governmnent. This is very true that if you manipulate your history to misguide and mislead your present, for sure your future will be direction less. I think people like you shuold motivate your youth and conduct free seminars to make them aware of today's world and its dynamics.
In latest Telenor is going to sell it's 100% share to PTCL. Another company is existing from Pakistan.
PTCL is owned by the army. Now we know what is going on.
Telenor har jagah esa he kerta hy. Thats there policy
I am an engineer who can open multiple factories but becz of agencies, commissions and taxes i would rather migrate n build a factory in a different country whr my efforts are treated well and awarded
ISLAM is the core issue and reason of this kind of situation of Pakistan .
And why not in Turkey, Central Asia or say many Muslim-majority developed countries. In India, low consumption of meat is the main reason for stunting among children.
@@vinsin328turkey and all those Central Asian countries are secular
Loving the comment section specially how Indians are appreciating Ammar .
One of the finest podcast i've listened keep it up junaid bhai👍👍
Wonderful analysis by this man, watching it after 7 months of upload date but it’s more relevant today then it ever was
*Neutral Property Dealers Ne Poora Mulk Barbaad Kardiya* 🥲
*Pakistan ko 100 Aur 9th May Ki Zarurat Hai* ,
*Tab Jaakar Property Dealers Se Azaadi Milegi* 😡
Bro just leave the country immediately and focus to make ur life better. pak is not ur concern its a concern of napak army n politicians. If u found a better opportunity outside from this deadland leave immediately. dont waste ur time here.
The taxes are placed by the army to stop international companies. Bahadur fauj is controlling trade and we aren't aware of the deals and the money Pak fauj has. It's a mafia.
Do you want your software update?
Leave immediately
@Skywimz
you need freedom from your army unless you break them or your countrey nothing going to change pakistan will only exist to serve them and sustain them
@@Anonymous-px9wk I am not running away.
This is my Pakistan, it doesn't belong to the Army
100 baato ki 1 baat cool your people down when it comes to religion, dont take it too seriously and you will see miracles in your country.
what a thought-provoking and productive discussion. much better than our prime-time talk shows.
Ganjiswag criticising real estate, yet still does advertising for them has to be the biggest hypocrisy ever
Why is the youth not revolting? Are they apathetic?
@@ramkumarkashyap2078 why would hey revolt aginast a guy, doing sponsored posts.
Yes definitely he is bajibul Qatal
seriously !
dont you want to make money as he wants and he did higlithed is a problem so ....
So sad to hear, it’s very difficult, the government, establishment and the elite needs to take action!!!
Wo action Q leingy? wo khud is corrupt system k beneficiaries hain...
lol woh action lenge??? 😅
@@ahsanali2513 you are absolutely correct, but it’s the common man that suffers, this feeds further hate and resentment towards society
@@ahsanali2513 Seriously? U mean corrupt Punjabi and Robber Sindhi Mafia woud take action?
U really expect them to take action?
25:35 you are so right. there’s a youtuber Momina Munir who opened a food cart in Karachi. she had to pay so many people to make it work. after the import ban her cart was briefly unprofitable as well.
This is a time to talk about solution not problems everyone knows problems
Hey Junaid Akram, i watched this podcast till the end. And i believe, people now should come up and talk to the government people. We should write legislation by ourselves and submit them to their hand. It is a rude to compare Pakistan with any other neighbouring country but we are in hands of uniform people and same state of mind is transferring down the line whereas people live and grow when there is peace of mind and enough resources. Ammar is a clever guy he does know the problem and their solutions too. Invite him again. And you may also have a chit chat with me on some reforms and survival in recent times. Take care.
India is doing so much better than Pakistan on all fronts however I can still relate to the corruption and way of working that Amar Habib is describing here. We share so much but I feel happy that India has left such petty corruption and Mismanagement behind and is now looking forward to future with hope.
Really sad to see a group of people who share a common ancestry and culture with India are unable to rise to their potential.
Army kha gai mulk ko 😂
I’m a small business owner in UK, my experience is that if you go by the books the hurdles, problems and issue also exist here in the UK as well. Plus you will also have to pay VAT, capital gain tax, insurance, pension and other tax expenses.
The point is, doing things by the book is not easy and simple but you have to do it, regardless of its expenses and easiness.
I guess as nation our mindset need to be change, you must pay taxes, you must follow rules and regulations, you must adhere to local tax and business rules and regulations and you must do it.
It is absurd that making an excuse that people not paying taxes or going by the book because there is too much paperwork or rules and regulations to follow.
The UK is a TERRIBLE counter-example to offer for Pakistan. Because the UK is also an economy in decline.
How many times will you all break down Pak's economic crises? Just accept the fact that there is no option but to face reality. And the reality is "Implosion."
You are 100% on the spot. USA is doing immigration in Dubai. If you are traveling to Us you do your custom and immigration at Dubai. So when you land at USA it is your local flight. You just walk in the USA without any further check up.
Surprised to hear the the phrase magajmari! This is a typical phrase used in India (derived from magaj which means brain in Gujarati)
Totally agree with his views, these are core issues of our society. But again! I hear a lot of people again and again I never hear the detailed solutions of these issues. No one knows how to come up with a greatest solution which will turn around Pakistan's path. I believe everything is affected by "domino effect" we just have to flip the top basic starting domino (country's Industrial growth strategies) that will flip the thinking of people. Majority of our population is so "laid back/lazy" we don't build anything we don't create anything in this country to compete in international markets. Until unless we don't create these opportunities we are doomed.
Mast banda hai guest... knowledgeable hai
Do only one thing to improve Pakistan ,,, keep away your Allah+Quran+MullaMoulavi+Generals....within 5 years > trillion economy
The books behind junaid sir is
1) The spy chronicles --story between ISI and RAW wtitten by aditya sinha, A.S.Dulat indian author
2) Origions - About earth and human history by lewis dartnel
3) OSHO living life dangerous -- indian origion American philosopher book on understanding life.
Economic for dummies! Brilliant economist !
Ammar as always appreciate your insights, you are always a good primer on Economics
'Han Bhai Kya Hal hai bhayya' always makes my day
from India ✌️
Amazing podcast 👏
Thank You Gandhi, I am proudly India and growing so fast in this century
Than sardar patel for it. Gandhi actually wanted pakistanis to have residence in india and free travel without borders
@@srinidhirao1620yes sardar patel sir and godse.... Otherwise gandhi would have given everything
Good to hear some intellectual talk from Pakistan. Best wishes.
The best way to get rid of corruption is to use high end technology so human intervention is minimised. But the problem is when you have most of uneducated population technology can’t do anything. 10 yrs invest in high quality education a must do to start with.
If any mnc is coming they ask for good infrastructure, super highways for transport, 24 hour non stop electricity, 24 hour water supply, good civilised people . international air port and direct acess to each country is all available in pakistan, and more on that digital infrastructure.
First of all MNCs are not leaving pakistan coz of local small companies doing work on cash 🤦 it doesnt make much of impact for them. Same thing happens in india and so many countries bht MNCs are still operating there.
Its gov policies, security and economic stability which are cuasing all the issue. 2 twitter post kr k economist ban jao
Ab ghoncho ultimately woh bhi yahi bat kr rahy hain. Intro dekh k comment kr dete jahil
Because in other countries the consumer for MNCs and local companies can differ. That is not the case in Pakistan and even in some states of India. So he is correct. Taxation should be the same for everyone.
FIRST INTELLIGENT PERSON IN PAKISTAN
I am a student in INDIA and from last 5 years I don’t use cash even am travelling far , becz all petrol pump ,restaurant, shopes,bus etc has UPI,
Even for biscuits or some 10 rupees thing i do UPI it just took 5 to 10 seconds to payment
Smart Guy with good general Knowledge.
there is nothing left to loose in this banana republic
Very true ye sab hota hy Karachi airport ke light change kare bhut depression lagta hy
Yeh . It reminds me of Pakistani doctor’s clinic
Fun fact : Chinese Armada exports more fish to the world from Arabian Sea than Pakistan
Masha Allah boht Kuch sikhne smjhne ko mila
Two biggest reasons for Pakistan’s failure as a nation:
1. Extreme levels of radical islam.
2. No focus on research, development, scientific rigour and strategic thinking.
These same endians are working in Gulf countries as labours while Arabs make them work 24/7 as a slave 😂
All of the issues are the government. When you have theifs on top, laws are not followed or enforced, then no one will come here. We as a whole need to stand up to the government and not be scared. We need to fight for our rights and have accountable government, and then the majority of our issues will settle. On top of that, we are a nuclear power Muslim country, west don't want us to be top. We need to be united.
Blasphemy law itna aggressive hoga agar toh bahar ki company aane mein hichkichayegi.....Example Srilankan manager ko zinda jala dia tha
What clarity of thought. Bravo
Indonesia is about to become 6th largest economy 😂. What a high level talk !
He immediately corrected though.
I am surprised....still there are people in Pakistan who talk sense 😱