Nice selective history, sensed no White Supremacist sympathies *AT ALL* Now do the Havaara agreement And the British Israel Foundation _"I propose an Aryan Semitic alliance in order to create a Superior Caucasian Race"_ Benjamin Disraeli UK PM 1890 Bought the Seuz Canal on behalf of Rosschild from the National Treasury Three guesses; what was the only Political Party recognised by Hitlers Nazi's Go on Guess Trump, Barr, Bannon, Cippolone, Gore, Guiliani, Leo, Alito, Thomas, and Barrett are all Opus Dei. Trump trained alongside Epstein and Roger Stone under Roy Cohn, who used kids to blackmail politicians on behalf of Mossad. Cohn trained under Meyer Lansky, who trained under Hoover. Robert Mercer and Rupert Murdoch are both Knights of Malta. Saville, Bezos, Gates, Koch, Rogan, Walsh, Crowder, Kirk, Fuentes, Dore, Knowles, Kulinksi, Ball, Iverson, Icke, Woods, Watson, Cernovich, Abbott, Jones, Robinson, Woods, Pool, Rubin, Peterson, Posobeic, Duke, Molyneux, Yilanopouse, Gionet, Richardson, Tillerson, Greene, Manaforte, Flynn, Ducey, Acosta, Attwood, Stone, Pence, Desantis, Meadows, Trump, Eastman, Black, Kerik, Melania, Barr, Bannon, Hawley, Gingrich, Abrams, Comey, Cuomo, Kerry, Abrams, Gore, Spencer, Blassio, Pompeo, Bolton, McCarthy, Nugent, Cruz, Rubio, Gaetz, Santos, Tucker, Gutfield, O'Reilly, Beck, Scarborough, Devos, Kasich, Mercer, Murdoch, Rosschild, Ingram, Kelly, Lake, Conway, Coulter, Huckabee, McEnany, Hannity, Spicer, Christie, Prager, Maher, Colbert, Corbett, Hayes, Biden, Harris, Fauci, Pelosi, Menendez, Pirro, Manchin, Cooper, Maddow, AOC, Newsom, Uyger, Dawkins, Hitchens, Hancock, Sitchin, Ventura, Morgan, Cowell, Farage, Johnson, May, Merkel, Blair, Cameron, Brown, Blair, Mogg, Benjamin, Trudeau, Putin, Bolsanaro, Stalin, Lenin, Tito, Trotsky, Hitler. All Roman Catholic. Then there's the Roman Abromavich connection to Boris Johnson and Nigel Farage, the key players behind Brexit, and the Sex Ring Superyacht he sold to Trump via Adnan Kashoggi, who is Mossad, just like Kushner, and Epstein, who listed SA as his home and had a Wahabbi funeral just like Osama Bin Laden, whose family did Brunch at the Bush Mansion in 2001, and now build the pipelines through the Isis occupied Golan heights, which Trump ceded to israel on it's 70th anniversary. The Golan Heights being where Genie Oil operates, on the board are Texas Senator Bill Richardson, who gave Elon over $3 Billion in taxpayer money. James Woolsey, Dir CIA under Bush, Art Smuggler Micheal Steinhardt, Rupert Murdoch, Sec Def under Bush Donald Rumsfeld. Also CEO of Halliburton and Vice President under Bush Dick Cheney, Larry Summers (Treasurer under Bush). Jakob Rosschild, and Wilbur Ross, Commerce Secretary under Bush and Treasurer under Trump, CEO of the Bank of Cyprus. Trump also gave the Saudis permits to make Nuclear Reactors, and the missing documents likely pertain to weaponising Uranium, this after israel cracked their Dimona Reactor, also stolen from the US. Saudi Arabia was founded in 1934 by Churchill and the Crown to protect israel against Arab revolt. Wahabbism was founded by Sabbatai Zevi, the Donmer Messiah of 1666. Sisi, Erdogan, Ahmadinejad, Saudi Royals; all Donmer. Osama Bin Laden was Wahabbi, so was Epstein, both tie to Bush and Trump, as well as the Crown and israel. It's also the ideology of Isis, Al Nusra, Hamas, and the Taliban. Western proxies to justify military actions a la Gladio B and Propaganda Deux. Donald (King) John Trump (the Great) is Aleister Crowley's Moonchild, and paints himself to represent Apollo, son of Zeus, Seig Hail is a Salute to Zeus, and how his friends greet him. He was born on a Super Wolf Blood Moon to Fred Christ and Mary McKleod with the help of L Ron Hubbard founder of Scientology. He was inaugurated aged 70 years 7 months and 7 days old, moving the embassy to Jerusalem on israel's 70th anniversary, being born 700 days before it's founding. He reads verbatim from _My New Order_ a collection of Hitler's speeches he keeps with him at all times and lives on the 66th floor of 666ft Trump Tower in a gold painted Penthouse built by Napoleon's Daddy: Louis XIV (NXIVM) the Sun King. His name means Messiah in Gematria and Deceit in Latin, Maga is Witch in Latin, and the name Baron is a title bestowed by the God King Emperor of the Holy Roman Empire, also known as Führer. He even comes from Vienna Bavaria, so too Epstein, the Sassoons (Clinton's) and Rosschild, the home of the Hapsberg Dynasty and Capital of the Holy Roman Empire. At the time Boris Johnson's Great Grandad and architect of the Armenian Genocide sent his Great Grandad to America, in 1922. June 14 is known as the Day of the Pharoah, Birthday of Osiris, John the Baptist, and Aushwitz, which was constructed with the aid of Prescott Bush. Prince William was born on a lunar eclipse on the Summer Solstice by induced birth to Diana, the name of Aleister Crowley's Great Goddess. Btw Hitler, Catholic AND Chosen His wife, cook, driver, bodyguard, mentor, SS, financial manager All Chosen Same with Trump. Holy Roman Empire Court Jews of the Hapsberg Dynasty in Vienna Bavaria capital of the Holy Roman Empire, home to Rosschild, Trump, Clinton's, Epstein's, Hitler, Stalin, Lenin, Trotsky, Tito, Orwell*, Freud, and Franz Ferdinand Melanias father was a Tito Party Leader, Ben Zion's Mentor Menachem Begin was the founder of the Irgun Stern, and his mentor was Zeve Jabotinksy, founder of the NKVD/ KGB. Most of israel's govt is non religious Russians. Ukraine sent a lot of Jews to israel Baron is a title bestowed by the God King Emperor of the Holy Roman Empire, which was the first Reich of Charlemagne, (Maga/Magi/Magus/Great/Trump) Trump in Gematria is Messiah It also means to Deceive, as does Jesuit. _"The Mosiach will deliver my people from Europe to Palestine by 1948"_ Rabbi Crool 1812, in a debate with a Protestant Minister. Napoleon was a Chosen Messiah, he and Hitler lived the same lives 129 years apart, even dying on the same day, and then escaping to Argentina with the stolen gold, with which he started Ancient Aliens Vril Cult with Eric Von Danikan, author of Chariots of the Gods. 2000 Aristocratic Argentinians attended his funeral.... Don't forget South Africa, also home to Elon, and Elon went to the same Jesuit University as Trump, (Wharton). Epstein introduced Elongs brother to his wife and Trump lawyer Dershowitz said he was introduced to Epstein by Lynn de Forrester Rosschild. The CEO of the BBC Marcus Agius married Kate de Roshchild. William and Megyn were married on the 66th anniversary of Hitler's wedding, Epstein died aged 66, and Trump lives on the 66th floor of 666ft Trump Tower. He was born on a Super Wolf Blood Moon to Fred Christ and Mary McKleod on the Date Crowley gave for his Moonchild; June 14, day of the Pharoah, birthday of Osiris John the Baptist and Aushwitz, which was built by Prescott Bush. 700 days before the founding of israel. All with the help of L Ron Hubbard founder of Scientology. William was born 7 days later on the Summer Solstice during a Lunar eclipse with induced birth, Diana is the name of Aleister Crowley's Great Goddess, Isis. Trump paints himself Orange to represent Apollo the Dawnbringer of Aleister Crowley's Golden Dawn. Just saying...
Phenomenal work. The most comprehensive breakdown on the conflict I've seen. It takes bravery and integrity to do this without leaving out inconvenient truths to seem unbiased. An honest and detailed assessment will always be worth more than a balanced one.
I have been teaching the history of the Middle East for over 25 years on a college campus. First time I ran into your channel. I see you made a 3 hour video on this. I will have to give it all a watch. I tell people you can't learn the history of the Middle east in a 10 second tik tok. I have a 19-video playlist as well, several hours long that covers events as far back as the ancient world until today. When I have some time I will watch as much of this as I can, would be curious to see how it compares to what I have been teaching.
So I have watched about an hour of it, and I have to say I am very impressed. What is crazy is even with the detail this video gives, it only picks up from relatively recent history. It actually has more detail then some of my videos on the modern period, but to fully understand the region you also need to be familiar with the Ancient History. I will try to watch the rest of it as well. @@guybarget7013
But it is colonialism: "The Jewish Colonisation Association in America spelled Jewish Colonization Association, is an organisation created on September 11, 1891, by Baron Maurice de Hirsch. Its aim was to facilitate the mass emigration of Jews from Russia and other Eastern European countries, by settling them in agricultural colonies on lands purchased by the committee in North America (Canada and the United States), South America (Argentina and Brazil) and Ottoman Palestine. "
@@moma8956 Considering that your comment doesn't even try to be nuanced, I'll just respond in an equally simplistic manner: Islam and Arab influence in general was spread by colonialism, genocide, and ethnic cleansing. But I am sure that in THAT case, you'll make an exception for colonialism. As my original comment implied: you need nuance and patience to understand the complexities. Otherwise it all just degenerates. But I guess you want that, because then you don't need put any effort into it.
@@erloriel if you want more nuance, listen to "Fear and loathing in the new Jerusalem" Podcast or any book by a real non-casual historian like Benny Morris, Illan Pappe, Avi Shlaim..etc
@@erlorielislam and arabs didn’t genocide generally, in fact it would be hard to find examples of such. Besides Islams expansion is mainly peaceful. Yes it was spread by the sword at certain points but that is just how the age of empires worked. You cannot call Islamic lands Colonies because regularly they were annexed which is not the same. Colonies aren’t annexed they are used as resources for colonists. Also when it comes to Palestine specifically All the Christians in the area were let and the jews who by the way were kicked out by the Christians were allowed back. The fact that you compare a medieval empire with a colonial state which continues to treat its jews and nonjews differently, continues to abhor the rights of Palestinians. The reason Palestinians don’t agree to solutions isn’t because they hate jews, there were jews living in Palestine before Israel. The real reason is that Israel continues to push for unacceptable conditions such as no right to bear arms no right to return. Moreover, The Israeli government still illegally settles, still abuses the populace. Etc. from and outside perspective i can totally understand why people would hate the Israeli government. Especially when its roots are actually terrorist roots.
@@abd_mdwhy can’t a Jew live in Gaza or in the West Bank if muslins live in Israel? When Jews live in the West Bank they are called colonizers. Do you think that Islam was spread through 49 countries peacefully? If this isn’t colonialism I don’t know what it is…..
Excellent video! As someone living in Israel and involved with teaching her history; I am really impressed with the amount of detail you have gone into here and throughout your videos on the topic. Keep up the great work!
Absolutely outstanding video. I am 62 and self taught on this conflict and the details in your videos are next level. When you learn about the actions of the Grand Mufti that you cannot blame the Jews for their response. Please note that the majority of attacks were Arabs on Jews till the mid 1930s and then the Jews finally kicked it into gear. We always hear about Dier Yassan but never hear about Hebron, 1929 or Jerusalem, 1921. I have noticed that “the usual suspects” leave vile comments. Sort of sad that reciting the actual history justifies their actions. All I can say is, no comment.
Imagine fighting against an occupation of your land and people almost a century later are trying to justify an actual genocide? When you lock people in a concentration camp, count their calories, every few years you "mow the lawn" (actual words being used by the class knesset members) by leveling a few neighborhoods and killing thousands, not let them repair their acquifer so 95% of their water is unsafe for consumption, banning things from entering such as chocolate, potato chips and baby chicks, not allowing them any type of economic ties with the world...and so much more...you should expect them to fight back. The young men who broke through the fence on October 7th were born into this brutal blockade (which amounts to a crime against humanity per human rights watch and amnesty international), they had no past, no present, and no hope for any future. Do you really expect them to simply languish and die in their cage? Would you not fight back any way you can? Israel is a brutal apartheid state committing the greatest crime of the 21st century. And after this, they will be a pariah state. And your american friends have become politcalaly radioactive on the world stage. Also, when you set out to exterminate an entire group of people, expect them to fight to their last breath. Israel cannot win, and they will be vilified and humiliated in the end. "Give me liberty or give me death"....unless you are arab then you are a terrorist apparently. After over 10,000 children killed, thousands more still under the rubble, 1.7 million homeless, oh and the IPC has officially classified the Gaza as being a in a true famine, which is over 20% of people at extreme risk of starving to death and/or already dead. Yet people still make comments like "You can't blame them for their response".. AlL i CaN sAy Is No CoMmEnT
your comment is disgusting, you are blaming palestinians for resisting settler colonialism because they wanted to be treated like their neighbours in the other mandates and for lands not to be given to others. then you justify whatever the zionists have done afterwards of massacers and ethnic cleansing. you have no morality
They're Russians and Roman Catholics Hence the media and politicians The CEO of the BBC Marcus Agius married a Rosschild Baroness The title is from the Holy Roman Empire and means the same thing as Fuehrer Alan Dershowitz said he was introduced to Epstein by Baroness Lynn De Forrester Rosschild He also hooked up Elon's brother, and Elon attended the same Jesuit University as Trump, and Trump and David Woods being Wharton and Fordham. Trump, Barr, Bannon, Cippolone, Gore, Guiliani, Leo, Alito, Thomas, and Barrett are all Opus Dei. Trump trained alongside Epstein and Roger Stone under Roy Cohn, who used kids to blackmail politicians on behalf of Mossad. Cohn trained under Meyer Lansky, who trained under Hoover. Robert Mercer and Rupert Murdoch are both Knights of Malta. Saville, Bezos, Gates, Koch, Rogan, Walsh, Crowder, Kirk, Fuentes, Dore, Knowles, Kulinksi, Ball, Iverson, Icke, Woods, Watson, Cernovich, Abbott, Jones, Robinson, Woods, Pool, Rubin, Peterson, Posobeic, Duke, Molyneux, Yilanopouse, Gionet, Richardson, Tillerson, Greene, Manaforte, Flynn, Ducey, Acosta, Attwood, Stone, Pence, Desantis, Meadows, Trump, Eastman, Black, Kerik, Melania, Barr, Bannon, Hawley, Gingrich, Abrams, Comey, Cuomo, Kerry, Abrams, Gore, Spencer, Blassio, Pompeo, Bolton, McCarthy, Nugent, Cruz, Rubio, Gaetz, Santos, Tucker, Gutfield, O'Reilly, Beck, Scarborough, Devos, Kasich, Mercer, Murdoch, Rosschild, Ingram, Kelly, Lake, Conway, Coulter, Huckabee, McEnany, Hannity, Spicer, Christie, Prager, Maher, Colbert, Corbett, Hayes, Biden, Harris, Fauci, Pelosi, Menendez, Pirro, Manchin, Cooper, Maddow, AOC, Newsom, Uyger, Dawkins, Hitchens, Hancock, Sitchin, Ventura, Morgan, Cowell, Farage, Johnson, May, Merkel, Blair, Cameron, Brown, Blair, Mogg, Benjamin, Trudeau, Putin, Bolsanaro, Stalin, Lenin, Tito, Trotsky, Hitler. All Roman Catholic. Then there's the Roman Abromavich connection to Boris Johnson and Nigel Farage, the key players behind Brexit, and the Sex Ring Superyacht he sold to Trump via Adnan Kashoggi, who is Mossad, just like Kushner, and Epstein, who listed SA as his home and had a Wahabbi funeral just like Osama Bin Laden, whose family did Brunch at the Bush Mansion in 2001, and now build the pipelines through the Isis occupied Golan heights, which Trump ceded to israel on it's 70th anniversary. The Golan Heights being where Genie Oil operates, on the board are Texas Senator Bill Richardson, who gave Elon over $3 Billion in taxpayer money. James Woolsey, Dir CIA under Bush, Art Smuggler Micheal Steinhardt, Rupert Murdoch, Sec Def under Bush Donald Rumsfeld. Also CEO of Halliburton and Vice President under Bush Dick Cheney, Larry Summers (Treasurer under Bush). Jakob Rosschild, and Wilbur Ross, Commerce Secretary under Bush and Treasurer under Trump, CEO of the Bank of Cyprus. Erdogan is a Wahabbi, like the Saudi Royals, Assad, Jordans king, Sisi, Epstein, Osama, and Isis A Xionist puppet of the Crown and Rome. "islamic terrorism" was a western puppet show Using Saudi Wahabbis and Secret agents to dehumanise Palestinians Think about all the times they inject Palestine into the terrorist narrative, all the claims of billions of dollars They use religious fundamentalists to undermine secular democracies, just like they did with Trump in America. _"Claim everything, deny everything, explain nothing"_ Prescott Bush _"Deny Deflect Disinform"_ Roger Stone _"If you're not with us you're with the Terrorists"_ George Bush Jr 2001 _"I propose an Aryan/Semitic alliance in order to create a superior caucasian race"_ Benjamin Disraeli, UK PM 1890. _"But they want nothing but Palestine, because Palestine represents the geostrategic center for World Control"_ Dr Nahum Goldmann. _"Today I declare the Crusades won"_ General Edmunde Allenby 1917 upon liberating Palestine. _"the New World 0rder will be ruled from the Temple in Jerusalem"_ Ben Gurion, Bolshevik, First PM of israel _"We must put an end to anything which brings about any Islamic unity between the sons of the Muslims. As we have already succeeded in finishing off the Caliphate, so we must ensure that there will never rise again unity for the Muslims, whether it be intellectual or cultural unity.“_ George Curzon, 1st Marquess Curzon of Kedleston, British Foreign Minister 1920. _"By Deceit we wage War"_ Mossad Motto _"The NW0 will begin Sept 17 2001, during Rosh Hashanah Feast of Trumpets, Resurrection of the Dead, on the First Crescent of the New Moon, in the year 6000 of the Great Pyramid Calendar, in order to cleanse the earth and humanity in preparation for his Kingdom to come"_ British Israel Foundation memo 1922. To the Chosen we are all Palestine, and when the time comes, the world will watch the same thing done to you, unless we stand up and demand our leaders step down and demand Democracy by Referendum If we want a future of _any_ kind We must be able to call a snake a snake, because that's what they do _slither_ So Without as Within So Below as Above It's inverted The Bible was written by Canaanites using a Mirror Hence Accusation in a Mirror or Gaslighting, aka Grooming. Every Accusation is a Confession A Hatespeech incitement technique used in Genocide like the one in Rwanda, and Burma and Guatemala. The Serpent's who speak with forked tongues were present at each For your Father is the Father of Lies And with Lies you Wage War
I live in Israel and I would just like to add my own quick summary of the history here. The Ottoman Empire was one of the Central Powers on the losing side of World War One. The League of Nations divided the Empire into sections (for example Iraq, Syria, etc) with borders which had never before existed. These sections were placed under the rule of Britain or France until they would become independent states. One section was called Palestine. Britain was given a mandate to make it into a Jewish state. I would speculate that the British government saw a Jewish state in Palestine as being a reliable ally to help Britain defend the crucial Suez Canal. (This actually happened eventually in the 1956 Suez Crisis.) The map of Palestine was drawn carefully to include the port of Eilat in the south and Haifa in the north, giving Palestine access to both ends of the canal. About 80% of Palestine came under Jewish control in 1948 and the remainder in 1967. However the Muslim population of Palestine grew, and continues to grow, much more quickly than anyone in 1918 expected thanks to better diet, cleaner water and vaccinations. Additionally most Muslims have been vehemently against the idea of giving Palestine to the Jews. The result is a Jewish state but with a large and growing hostile Muslim population disenfranchised and living in Bantustans. Regarding Muslim refugees who fled Palestine in 1948, every war creates refugees. Loyalist refugees fleeing the United States following the American Revolution founded Ontario while the property which they left was confiscated by the US government. No one seems to be very worried about the American loyalists' right of return. It should be mentioned that Muslims do not recognize the concepts of human rights and international law but they hypocritically criticize Jews for violating human rights and international law.
Umm, ontarians can totally go to the US and become citizens there if they wanted to. Not possible at all for Palestinians. The comment on HR is beyond garbage. Not only is it not true, but that is not a reason to deny someone's human rights.
@@brinag8604 No, Canadians cannot return to the US and become citizens and they certainly cannot reclaim their ancestors' property, which is now some of the most expensive real estate in the world in Manhattan. And neither can the grandchildren of refugees anywhere else in the world. At the end of World War II there were millions of refugees, Germans who were living outside the new borders of Germany, Jews who were not able to return to their previous homes in central Europe and others. Where are their descendants today? Does anyone know or care? The Palestinian "refugee" concept is a scam created by Muslims in the hopes of using it to foment hatred toward Israel among Western liberals. Have you checked the humans rights records of Saudi Arabia, Iran or any other Muslim majority country? How do you feel about beating women to death because their hair isn't covered, executing blasphemers and homosexuals? Muslims out and proudly reject the entire concept of human rights. You have no rights. You have the privilege of obeying whatever Muhammed allegedly said 1400 years ago. About international law. For 1300 years Muslims were imperialists, slavers and colonizers. No Muslim leader has ever apologized for all that. They are proud of it and would do it again given the opportunity. However now that the shoe is on the other foot, Muslims beg Western liberals for help and sympathy. Nothing I'm saying is a secret. Get off the internet and read a book.
More than 50 percent Jews living in Israel came from Europe...If you want land there are many land in Amazon jungle and Sahara desert etc...Go live there not by snatching someone's land and creating your holy land on the Mass Graves of babies...You killed 8000 babies...how can someone be so cruel and barbaric? I literally cried many days watching what's happening with the people of Palestine...you can't have peace ...you can't get peace on the mass Graves of babies...You should end the occupation now Free Palestine 🇵🇸
I started to learn Middle East history from decent Chinese history professors 20 years ago. The historical facts they cited/quoted are pretty much in line with yours, and the narratives were pretty neutral and mainstream English history teaching. It’s interesting that these historical narratives are contradictory to current Chinese government propaganda (CCP) position or the old textbooks during the Cultural Revolution in Mao’s era which was similar to the modern day western leftist narratives. The history we tell, the people we become.
Jesuit Directive 24: Blame the Victim of that which you are doing yourself Islamic terrorism is a CIA Saudi/Scionist creation to justify genocide Blaming Hamas is just an excuse to murder children and steal their land, no different to 2001, Iraq WMDs, Libya, Afghanistan, Syria, Lebanon, Egypt, Sudan, Ethiopia, Somalia, Yemen, all in the name of a democracy they dont believe in. Tens of millions killed in a worldwide genocide of Muslims by Rome and Chazars, all based on LIES Bombing hospitals, schools, using white phosphorus, and cluster bombs, filling in wells, burning olive orchards stealing cattle. Targeting pregnant women and kids is terrorism! Kidnapping kids in the middle of the night, strapping them to vehicles as human shields is terrorism. Rape, abuse, medical experiments, poisoning, and assault is terrorism, stealing their homes is terrorism. Sterilising Ethiopians, radiating Shepardics and using Yemenis for organ harvest all examples of your Terrorist heritage Irgun Stern, King David Hotel, USS Liberty, the 67 war, Bali, Fukushima, Burma, Bosnia, 2001, Mexico, Vegas, Boston, on and on, all proof of your Terrorism. Cast Lead, Vigilante Guardian, Lavon Affair, Oded Yinon, Tantura, Nakba, all prove who the terrorist are You have terrorised Palestinians for nearly a century, engaged in outright brutality, pulling kids limb from limb after raping them, forcing petrol down the throats of kids before burning them alive then laughing at their suffering, taking joy in depriving them of water and food and medicine; all acts of terrorism. Spitting on them, burning down churches and defacing Palestinian graves. And not just Palestine but Bosnia, Fauklands, Myanmar, Rwanda, Guatemala, Columbia, Brazil, Argentina, Honduras, Mexico, Kenya, Egypt, Sth Africa, France, Germany, UK, Boko Haram, Isis, Taliban, Hamas: you supply arms to terrorist groups, promote genocides and persecute Muslims using your Jesuit media and Mossad Death Squads You use the word Terrorist as a substitute for Migger, no different to how Nazis used the word Jude Every accusation is a confession: Look in the mirror lest the irony kill you. The accuser claims he cannot be wrong, so then what is the difference between "God's Chosen" who cannot be criticised or held accountable and "Master Race" engaged in slaughter and fascism. The world will not forget! Eternity is a long time to be branded evil, and your evil vile comments and your campaign of strawmen and disinformation and hate prove you never wanted Peace, never saw Semitic Palestinians as humans, never recognised their right to their own state, it was all lies from the start. You cry self defence, but what you really mean is a right to rape murder and steal. You claim Satan's Hell has a right to defend itself while stealing land, imprisoning women and children and murdering kids, it's the definition of a call to genocide. You claim Palestinians want to wipe you off the map, as you wiped them off the map All accusation in a mirror Bombing refugee camps and crying "Hamas" So it's all just Accusation in a Mirror aka Gaslighting aka Grooming, a Hatespeech incitement technique used in Genocide, and the Jesuit media, cults, and the sexual abuse of children, which Republicans are always getting caught doing Remember the law of the Prophets: Treat others as you would have the treat you The world will not forget your lies And soon they will see it was ALL lies Then where will you go? How will you be treated, who will mourn your dead If you see us as animals how should we see you? Who will listen to your excuses when everything you spew is lies and Gaslighting? Who will care for you? Rules for thee but not for ye? Is it any wonder you're despised around the world, no one will trust you, no one will speak to you, no one will do business with you, your descendants will carry your cross for 1000 years, everything you stole and hoarded will be taken from you And they will say, these people can only lie, it is their curse, do not give them shelter, lest they mirder you in your sleep and steal your house Everything you say now will be used whenever you speak, your own rhetoric will be spoken to you, and will be used to judge you They will say, "these people are cowards, even unarmed children can defeat their armies" Woe Great Babylon! Come out of her my people so that she may be judged!
As an American Gentile observer and (admittedly casual) scholar of the situation in the Middle East since my college days in the 1960s, I believe this lecture to be relatively well balanced and objective. That's not easy to do when the subject matter is so hotly controversial and passions are running as high as they are today. I must say that I was disappointed at times when our lecturer failed to accurately read the important quotations verbatim, sometimes distorting their meaning. But overall this was very informative in its detailed granularity of events that occurred in the first half of the 20th Century in Palestine as well as diplomatically in the centers of power in Europe, the Middle East, and the United States. Grade B+
Nothing controversial about a Genocide done on an indigenous population What has gotten into you that you struggle with Colonialism being a crime? If israel hit its own people at the festival, and built the hospital base that they used themselves, and if israel funded Hamas... Do they really want the hostages back alive? And who really beheaded all those babies? Can they recite the Mossad motto? What language do Palestinians speak?
@@Uncanny_MountainAh yes, touting debunked conspiracy theories such as: “Israel killed its own people on October 7th” makes you look really goddamn stupid.
At 3:02:23: "The Jews may have a case, and a strong one too, but their case is based on humanity, and official documents and promises, nonsensical considerations in a period of crude realism... There is not an Arab who wants to see himself ruled by Jews, but there is not also an Arab with sense who wants to see himself ruled by assassins." - Yusuf Hanna
20 % of Israeli Arabs with Israeli citizenship. He was clearly not right with his statement. And yes the vast majority would not want to be ruled by either the PA nor Hamas.
Hey @CasualHistorian I just wanted to say thank you. I am a Jewish person who has just discovered your Chanel and I appreciate your historiography of Israel/Palestine and your videos exposing antisemitism. You have gained a new subscriber.
If one party does objectively more bad things then that party should be criticized more. Arabs have objectively done a lot of bad and horrible attacks against uninvolved Jews so they should be scrutinized more. If anything they don't get scrutinized enough, while every little questionable thing Israel does is placed under a microscope. It's quite laughable that you believe Arabs in any way shape or form receive disproportionate critcism.
Nice to get both side of story most ppl lean to one side or closed of entirely to one side and unable to stay open minded that both sides have played a part in the violence and propaganda
I study most wars and empires in history. Specially also the area of Canaan. 1 thing I can say the area is more as 4000 years under war. And war is never good for the looser 🤷🏼
I would start this story in 1882 with a quick look back to 700s.It is also important to understand the underlying reasons for the conflict. without that, none of this makes sense.
Yeah, without talking about the Ottoman land reforms of the 1850’s as well as the fact that the concept of land ownership was foreign to nearly every Arab (of course excluding the wealthy ones), you can’t understand why Arabs started getting angry at the European Jews who started moving into the countryside in 1882 (the vast majority of Jewish immigration prior to was to an urban environment (aka Jerusalem)). Prior to 1882, there wasn’t much tension between Jews and Muslims (especially compared to their relationship with the Christians). By skipping straight to 1919, you give the impression that there had always been tensions between the religious communities and the Muslims have always been antisemitic like Christians have, which is simply not true.
@@Mbwunionso Muslims were ok with Jews being subjugated dhimmis. They were threatened by diaspora Jews who legally purchased land where none of them even lived on because they couldn't comprehend that Jews can have the same rights as dhimmis
@@Mbwunionthe reason why there wasn't much "tension" is because Arab abuse of Jews was systematic and rampant and the Jews couldn't do anything about it and had to accept it. It's like a slave owner saying that before slavery ended there wasn't much "tension" between him and the slave. Well yeah if you oppress the shit out of someone and completely break their will and determination ofc they won't give you problems. But the absence of a visible problem doesn't mean there isn't one
🎉great videos, very informative, loaded with facts and information that empowers me to shut down idiots who know nothing about Israel’s struggle to build Israel into what it is today-a miracle of accomplishment and a bastion of moral uprightness and democracy. The Palestinians are simply not wired this way. This is why it’s been so troublesome.
Something is missing,or of little mention . The hard working culture of migrated jews .My grand-grand father bought a sizeable lot of land from an Arab landlord .With his remaining wealth he transformed that totally bare,infertile land into a true garden .In 1948 the Arab vendor litteraly with other muslims attacked our house .My father died defending our land and house .After the war the Arabs with no properties were expelled from our land.Not a single one with a house on their name .If you look at the map of Israel on 15 of may 1948 not 1 single square km that was not bought by Jews.Except Negev desert owned by nobody .So ,Israel occupy “Palestinian”land is just a myth .Nothing else !
I get what you're trying to say. But that is just a dumb way to look at things. A land owner can do whatever they want to the land. If they dont want to develop it then that's their damn business. If your gggggrand dad wanna make a flowerbed out of it that fine. If the previous owner wanted to left it to rot then that's their perogative too. Subtlely propping your ancestor up while putting down its predecessor serves nothing but dehumanize the predecossors, making you complicit.
So you’re saying, the reason that the Zionist did not hire the indigenous Arab population, had nothing to do with bigotry? Seems very selective to me your interpretation that is.
Zionists wanted Jews to work the land. They didn't want it to become a feudal situation that existed before. And also these people were not indigenous. They themselves either migrated from our were descendants of those migrated from other areas like Egypt, syria, Lebanon, Iraq , trans Jordan, Arabia, Algerian, etc
He did not in fact say that. I'm sure there was bigotry, but that's not really the point. The Arabs were not exactly completely free from bigotry either.
Thanks for addressing this important issue. Looking at your sources, I cannot help but notice that they’re extremely one sided in Israel’s favor and ignores other voices, both Israeli and Palestinian. I would highly recommend reading the works of Ilan Pappe and Avi Shlaim for a more balanced Israeli perspective. I would also highly recommend reading Palestinian American voices such as Rashid Khalidi and Edward Said.
Surely, reading multiple views and scrutinizing the evidence proffered by them results in a more accurate understanding of the facts than reading books that are so clearly one sided. I think that you’d certainly agree with that if someone made a video about the history citing mostly Palestinian leaders and very pro-Palestine Palestinian historians? Books by the founder of Israel such as Moche Diane, Chaim Weismann and Ben Gurion are exactly the inverse of reading books by Yaser Arafat, and the Hussaini mayors of Jerusalem.
Sadly I have tried reading the "other sources" now and again and many are more like information coming from "Comical Ali- the Iraqi information minister and less an historical account.@@aas.993
I’ve read a lot on this subject and find this video to be excellent with deep detail elucidating many of the complexities of the matter, eg, the part the big Arab landowners played in establishing unrest and rejection of a Jewish presence.
I can't believe this video only has 46k views. It's by far the most complete, well-researched, accessible and nuanced piece of background information about the present conflict on the entire internet. It's a genuinely astonishing achievement that you managed to tell this story in just three hours. I studied history and Holocaust & Genocide Studies for 7 years, read dozens of books and articles on the Middle East, Jewish history and colonialism, and yet I still learned so very much from this video. Any historian will love this. And everyone who suddenly has a very strong opinion on a conflict they don't understand in the slightest may begin to realize that any black and white portrayal of history is simply wrong, and that the loudest voices are often the least informed. Understanding requires effort, nuance, and much more than slacktivist retweets and 2-minute TikTok 'explainers'. Maybe that's why this video has only 46k views...
That's because the majority of people that talk about this issue don't actually care all that much, if it isn't a 20 second video about their "team" painted in a way they want they do not care to hear about it
Re Sir Herbert Samuel. You say he was the first Jew to hold a cabinet position. Does that mean that the prime minister does not count as a cabinet position? Because if it does, we have to count Benjamin Disraeli as the first.
This is the _Faisal-Weizmann agreement._ Anybody interested can type that into a search engine and the wiki page will pop up. It's not that he simply didn't talk about it. He presented it as the complete OPPOSITE !!! This is just one example of the little tiny things that biased the whole video to one side. A lot of people says he gave a fair and balance view. He did not. It's almost as if somebody who is -biased- heavily favours one side, realized that he isn't neutral, tries to correct for it, but fails. I'll give him that he did try to make an effort to be sorta more balanced, but still he cannot bring himself to go all the way, and there's this little tiny things here and there. Imagine he is in journalism school, and submitted this as a written assignment. His professor would mark it all over the place where he's missed the mark, and say _try harder, I know you can do it. Fix it up and resubmit in two weeks. You can get a better grade._
@@danielch6662 Yeah i know he is clearly biased. The note i am talking about said that he(Faisal) will not be answerable to carry out the agreement if British broke the promise.
I didn’t have to watch very much of this to realise it’s just pro-Israeli propaganda. So I’m certainly not going to waste three hours of my life on the rest of it. It seems to be largely based on the writings of Ephraim Karsh. His “Palestine betrayed”, which you quote repeatedly, is a work of propaganda not a serious history book. (I have written a review of it on Amazon.) Like Karsh, you gloss over the fact that the Zionists were not coming to Palestine in order to integrate peacefully into the local society, but to destroy that society and replace it with another society, ethnically Jewish and based on European culture. They were willing to tolerate Arabs perhaps, but only as a minority in a Jewish state. Some Zionists were quite willing to contemplate ethnic cleansing. Like Karsh, you find the Arab attitude unreasonable. Why were they so unwilling to cooperate with those who wanted to replace their society? Hmmm. It must’ve been antisemitism. Or maybe they were tricked by Arab leaders.
> Zionists were not coming to Palestine in order to integrate peacefully into the local society, but to destroy that society and replace it with another society, ethnically Jewish and based on European culture. "Destroy" and "European culture" doing a lot of legwork. How so? Modern Israel is culturally pretty Middle Eastern, and even with all of the bad stuff Israel has done, Arabs are still culturally Arab. > They were willing to tolerate Arabs perhaps, but only as a minority in a Jewish state. Oh? Sort of like how the Arabs wanted to force Jews to exist as a minority in an Arab state? If being a minority is so bad, surely that's all the more of a reason Jews should be allowed to create a majority at least somewhere. > Some Zionists were quite willing to contemplate ethnic cleansing. As opposed to… the Arabs? Who actively tried to force out all the Jews prior to anything that can be considered an act of ethnic cleansing by the Jews?
He clearly includes the different factions within zionism and different views of zionists of how the national home should be realized, you not watching the video really shows
Integrate with traditional Arab society? You have no idea what you're talking about. You speak of tribal Arabs of the late 19th century as if they're some modern liberal nation that you could just join. When Jews came to Palestine, the only thing they could do was build a new way of life and a new society, which is what they did.
As someone who is pretty familiar with the conflict and has read extensively on it, this a laughably one sided video. Protraying Jobotinsku as wanting a peaceful settlement with Arabs, saying that Arabs just hated the Jews, not talking about Ottoman land reforms, not mentioning the multiple major zionist figures who expressed an intention to take the land from Palestinians.
Also very few of them actually owned the land they lived on. Majority of the land was owned by either ottomans and later British or absentee landlords. Many Arabs were tenant farmers who worked the land and had to pay exorbitant rent imposed by the wealthy absentee landlords or the wealthy effendis
Most people on this earth do not legally own the land they live on. People living in cities who live in houses only own their houses and property attached to it. They don't own the stretch of the street or sidewalk they live on.
no time to school you on other events but how convenient is that...the point was how casually you stitch together all your videos to paint a story but i get you dont wanna get removed from youtube but know that story of history is alwasy on the hearts of palestinians like it was yesterday and didnt end @@CasualHistorian
@@charlie2485do we know? Please enlighten us with your tik tok sound bites of nonsense. I can't wait for the conspiracy theories of jews control insert whatever in here.
30 seconds in and you messes up. There was no Palestinian flag until 1964, this is because there was no Palestinian people, or country. It's like referring to the highlands In Scotland, it's a region not a people. You are too casual for me. If you started atound 1850 youd learn the local jews had started buying large tracks of land from the Arabs, who laughed at them as they thought it worthless. It was later on that muslims started to stop these purchases. Oh and lets be clear, they were buying back land that was stolen from them by the romans, Tuks and muslims.
This documentary was impressive. Thanks much for well researched history and thoughtful approach to the historiography. I would highly recommend this work to anyone interested in this critical period to a difficult period in a difficult region.
All I can say about this is…is he biased? Yes, obviously. It is very clear what side he is on. However, the sources used are irrefutable. The truth doesn’t change because the person that’s saying it…agrees with the truth being told.
@@stvdiascholastica4599 Please share example of this where it is in fact the case then, so we can have a fairer and more objective interpretation of such facts.
@@stvdiascholastica4599Precisely. And not to mention some glaring omissions that heavily indicate these biases. The language of that Balfour Declaration so conveniently glossed over is enough by itself to prove the callous dehumanization of indigenous Palestinians at the core of Zionism as an ideology.
@@harrywalmsley8616 I think the worst of it is he presented nearly every Arab or Palestinian attack as unprovoked and every Israeli attack as responsive or forced. Palestinians and other Arabs are framed as violent and unreasonable so much that it borders on racist.
@@SegzWithTedCruz You can be a white America-born man like John Walker Lindh and still go full Islam. Thanks for telling everyone your ignorant and racist without telling everyone your ignorant and racist.
@anthonyschepsis4750 it's always some brainlet who thinks they can win a point with the over used non insult of racism. Are you European? If so perhaps you need to stay silent after all the pogroms, expulsions, discrimination and the holocaust of jews perpetrated by Europeans. Such smugness.
Some conclusions. 1) The Jews also were not saints. 2) The Arabs were much more violent 2) Arabs refused almost any type of agreement. 3) Arabs made every mistake in the book (and are still doing so till this day)
Exactly. No one says Israel did everything right and were flawless. But many people who bash Israel on all the allegedly bad things it did completely ignore the much worse actions that Arabs have done. It turns out getting attacked by Arabs for generations after generations made Israelis more violent, radicalized, and brutal. Funny how these same people always say that Arabs becomes radicalized because of Israeli checkpoints, security measures, and retaliatory bombings. But choose to dismiss the fact that a lot of Arab terrorist attacks such as dozens of suicide bombings during the second intifada played a major role in radicalizing Israelis too. It's almost like they want a free pass to do whatever they want without consequences
Great detailed video. If you're watching this factual recounting of events and thinking its biased you should investigate the facts presented using reliable sources. If you cant refute the facts, it's time to investigate your own bias.
the most ridiculous start to the episode - you can't even get the basics right! The palestinian mandate included most of Jordan as well, which was split off in 1924.. First 3 seconds and already a lie or incompetence. Stop pretending you've done any research, with a start like this it would be a waste of time continuing.
And by starting where he did in the video he got to skip the whole part on how the British mandate for a Jewish state was the payoff for the jewish people using the power and influence to keep Russia from pulling out of world war 1 and getting America to fully commit to war world one. This wasnt a natural movement that the jewish people have there own state it was the pay off for helping the allies to beat Germany in world war 1
Jews referred to as palestinians because during the Ottoman empire, that was the name of the region. Arab muslims didnt use that to refer to themselves until after the 1960s
The 50% growth was also due to more than 30,000 Arabs moving into Palestine due to the job prospects. In fact the number 30,000 is probably far too small as the British only recorded the Jews coming in and did nothing to prevent the Arabs moving in. Hence the 700,000 Arabs who left Palestine as refugee were probably 40% foreigners. Hence the UN definition of a Palestinian refugee as someone who have been living in Palestine for just 2 years prior to 1948!
The Jews are the indigenous people of Palestine the way the blacks are the indigenous people of South Africa! "Who can challenge the rights of the Jews in Palestine? Good Lord, HISTORICALLY IT IS REALLY YOUR COUNTRY..." Yusuf Diya al-Khalidi, Arab Mayor of Jerusalem, 1829. Three facts about Palestine you never know: 1. There has NEVER been an independent state of Palestine, nor an Arab state of Palestine. 2. The name "Palestine" comes from the Romans who renamed "Judea and Samaria" Syria Palestine to punish the Jews for their revolt against the Romans ... before Islam even existed. 3. Palestine Arabs today are not indigenous. They are "ethnic Arabs," and the vast majority of them come to the land with the Islamic conquerors in 634 CE.
@@nathanwoltermann2639 And still, you are more closely related to me, a northern European, than you are to that region. You are about 60% European and the Palestinians are around 90%< Levant. So, the Palestinians are direct descendants of the peoples living in that area(ancient Canaanite, Israelite, Judean and what have you) and therefore indigenous people, whereas the Jews are a culture/religious entity.
@@chinedujosephezengige5721 Nothing that you say will ever grant the Jewish diaspora the right to supplant the indigenous Palestinians. With your logic African Americans should be allowed to go back to Africa and start massacring Ghanaians and Cameroonians. Also you do understand that over 2 thousand years religious conversion can happen right? The Palestinian Muslims living in the levant have ancestors who practiced Judaism.
@@RikkiSan1if you believe God promised the jews a land which people already lived in before them for thousands of years and yet they had the right to kick them out then I'm sorry I don't buy the idea
@@RikkiSan1I found in the bible (don't ask which version) that I was promised the piece of land you live in right now so please leave now or I call my daddy America
The Ottomans. Land ownership in the levant was mostly Turk. And also Arabs in some cases. A lot of it was useless swamp land that got turned into farm land.
@@Shakshuka69 Correct. I'm tired of people talking about "stolen land" with regard to Israel even though over 80% of the Arabs who left didn't actually own the land they lived on but were tenants of absentee landlords who'd sold to Jews.
@@eafstudios6436 So because the Palestinians didn't have paperwork for land that they lived on for generations the Jews had a right to ethnically cleanse them? Someone tell the Native Americans they could've prevented their massacre if they had just presented their deeds to the white settlers.
@@jjab430 The truth is that the Arabs started a war with the aim of expelling the Jews or even slaughtering them, and they lost and were expelled, and that's how wars work.
If you would watch more than 30 seconds of the video, instead of waiting for your favorite anti-Semitic dog whistles to be mentioned, you might realize you're wrong. The Haganah is mentioned, many times, and Lehi is not because it was founded in 1940, while the video's narrative ends in 1939. And if you think I'm being selective to make the Israelis look better, I also didn't mention that the Mufti was a LITERAL Nazi Collaborator.
I didn't get to take your survey in time. How far back into ancient times do you usually work? I'm proportionally more fascinated the farther back we go 👍 your stuff is all good though. Thank you 🤙
Yes. Resettle the Palestinians to the Sinai. They'll have an even bigger country than Israel, oil, tourism, two major water access points, and they'll be on one side of Israel rather than sandwiching Israel (dramatically reducing the security concerns of Israel).
I don't delete comments. I have a comment filter that catches explicit anti-semitism. So if you aren't being an anti-Semite, your comment should be there.
oh wow Thank you for detailing this , just found his socials and WOW to say the least.. I cant sub to anyone who openly supports genocide and apartheid , never again means never again for everyone @@DudeBadTake
@@t95kush27 Just so we can validate your genocide claim, can you provide a rough date or year in the future in which you believe the Palestinian people will have all been killed? Do you expect this to happen in this next year or two or longer?
Self-fulfilling prophecy. “I was worried this guy would beat me up. So I punched him to try to prevent it even though he wasn’t attacking me, but then he beat me up, which proves I was right to worry.”
@@CasualHistorian How so? Were you planning on using the Bible? It seems odd that you would say that when even the scientific evidence on the genetic origins of the Palestinians seems to indicate their indigenous status in the land.
@@daiyumyoif you were to start farther back you would have to get into Arab migration into the land during the Ottoman Empire, showing that a majority of the Palestinians migrated to Palestine during that era. And there is no genetic study that can show “who is native” because you have nothing to compare it to. What these studies do is compare the genetics of one region to another, so the genetic studies you are referring to simply show that Palestinian Arabs share more genetic material with Egyptians/syrians/Jordanians then some Jews. You cant tie that genetic makeup to a particular area of the land.
Go to piavpn.com/casualhistorian to get 83% off Private Internet Access with 4 months free!
Great video, earned a sub :D
Nice selective history, sensed no White Supremacist sympathies *AT ALL*
Now do the Havaara agreement
And the British Israel Foundation
_"I propose an Aryan Semitic alliance in order to create a Superior Caucasian Race"_
Benjamin Disraeli UK PM 1890
Bought the Seuz Canal on behalf of Rosschild from the National Treasury
Three guesses; what was the only Political Party recognised by Hitlers Nazi's
Go on
Guess
Trump, Barr, Bannon, Cippolone, Gore, Guiliani, Leo, Alito, Thomas, and Barrett are all Opus Dei. Trump trained alongside Epstein and Roger Stone under Roy Cohn, who used kids to blackmail politicians on behalf of Mossad. Cohn trained under Meyer Lansky, who trained under Hoover. Robert Mercer and Rupert Murdoch are both Knights of Malta.
Saville, Bezos, Gates, Koch, Rogan, Walsh, Crowder, Kirk, Fuentes, Dore, Knowles, Kulinksi, Ball, Iverson, Icke, Woods, Watson, Cernovich, Abbott, Jones, Robinson, Woods, Pool, Rubin, Peterson, Posobeic, Duke, Molyneux, Yilanopouse, Gionet, Richardson, Tillerson, Greene, Manaforte, Flynn, Ducey, Acosta, Attwood, Stone, Pence, Desantis, Meadows, Trump, Eastman, Black, Kerik, Melania, Barr, Bannon, Hawley, Gingrich, Abrams, Comey, Cuomo, Kerry, Abrams, Gore, Spencer, Blassio, Pompeo, Bolton, McCarthy, Nugent, Cruz, Rubio, Gaetz, Santos, Tucker, Gutfield, O'Reilly, Beck, Scarborough, Devos, Kasich, Mercer, Murdoch, Rosschild, Ingram, Kelly, Lake, Conway, Coulter, Huckabee, McEnany, Hannity, Spicer, Christie, Prager, Maher, Colbert, Corbett, Hayes, Biden, Harris, Fauci, Pelosi, Menendez, Pirro, Manchin, Cooper, Maddow, AOC, Newsom, Uyger, Dawkins, Hitchens, Hancock, Sitchin, Ventura, Morgan, Cowell, Farage, Johnson, May, Merkel, Blair, Cameron, Brown, Blair, Mogg, Benjamin, Trudeau, Putin, Bolsanaro, Stalin, Lenin, Tito, Trotsky, Hitler.
All Roman Catholic.
Then there's the Roman Abromavich connection to Boris Johnson and Nigel Farage, the key players behind Brexit, and the Sex Ring Superyacht he sold to Trump via Adnan Kashoggi, who is Mossad, just like Kushner, and Epstein, who listed SA as his home and had a Wahabbi funeral just like Osama Bin Laden, whose family did Brunch at the Bush Mansion in 2001, and now build the pipelines through the Isis occupied Golan heights, which Trump ceded to israel on it's 70th anniversary.
The Golan Heights being where Genie Oil operates, on the board are Texas Senator Bill Richardson, who gave Elon over $3 Billion in taxpayer money. James Woolsey, Dir CIA under Bush, Art Smuggler Micheal Steinhardt, Rupert Murdoch, Sec Def under Bush Donald Rumsfeld. Also CEO of Halliburton and Vice President under Bush Dick Cheney, Larry Summers (Treasurer under Bush). Jakob Rosschild, and Wilbur Ross, Commerce Secretary under Bush and Treasurer under Trump, CEO of the Bank of Cyprus.
Trump also gave the Saudis permits to make Nuclear Reactors, and the missing documents likely pertain to weaponising Uranium, this after israel cracked their Dimona Reactor, also stolen from the US.
Saudi Arabia was founded in 1934 by Churchill and the Crown to protect israel against Arab revolt. Wahabbism was founded by Sabbatai Zevi, the Donmer Messiah of 1666. Sisi, Erdogan, Ahmadinejad, Saudi Royals; all Donmer. Osama Bin Laden was Wahabbi, so was Epstein, both tie to Bush and Trump, as well as the Crown and israel. It's also the ideology of Isis, Al Nusra, Hamas, and the Taliban. Western proxies to justify military actions a la Gladio B and Propaganda Deux.
Donald (King) John Trump (the Great) is Aleister Crowley's Moonchild, and paints himself to represent Apollo, son of Zeus, Seig Hail is a Salute to Zeus, and how his friends greet him. He was born on a Super Wolf Blood Moon to Fred Christ and Mary McKleod with the help of L Ron Hubbard founder of Scientology. He was inaugurated aged 70 years 7 months and 7 days old, moving the embassy to Jerusalem on israel's 70th anniversary, being born 700 days before it's founding.
He reads verbatim from _My New Order_ a collection of Hitler's speeches he keeps with him at all times and lives on the 66th floor of 666ft Trump Tower in a gold painted Penthouse built by Napoleon's Daddy: Louis XIV (NXIVM) the Sun King.
His name means Messiah in Gematria and Deceit in Latin, Maga is Witch in Latin, and the name Baron is a title bestowed by the God King Emperor of the Holy Roman Empire, also known as Führer.
He even comes from Vienna Bavaria, so too Epstein, the Sassoons (Clinton's) and Rosschild, the home of the Hapsberg Dynasty and Capital of the Holy Roman Empire.
At the time Boris Johnson's Great Grandad and architect of the Armenian Genocide sent his Great Grandad to America, in 1922.
June 14 is known as the Day of the Pharoah, Birthday of Osiris, John the Baptist, and Aushwitz, which was constructed with the aid of Prescott Bush. Prince William was born on a lunar eclipse on the Summer Solstice by induced birth to Diana, the name of Aleister Crowley's Great Goddess.
Btw
Hitler, Catholic AND Chosen
His wife, cook, driver, bodyguard, mentor, SS, financial manager
All Chosen
Same with Trump.
Holy Roman Empire Court Jews of the Hapsberg Dynasty in Vienna Bavaria capital of the Holy Roman Empire, home to Rosschild, Trump, Clinton's, Epstein's, Hitler, Stalin, Lenin, Trotsky, Tito, Orwell*, Freud, and Franz Ferdinand
Melanias father was a Tito Party Leader, Ben Zion's Mentor Menachem Begin was the founder of the Irgun Stern, and his mentor was Zeve Jabotinksy, founder of the NKVD/ KGB. Most of israel's govt is non religious Russians. Ukraine sent a lot of Jews to israel
Baron is a title bestowed by the God King Emperor of the Holy Roman Empire, which was the first Reich of Charlemagne, (Maga/Magi/Magus/Great/Trump)
Trump in Gematria is Messiah
It also means to Deceive, as does Jesuit.
_"The Mosiach will deliver my people from Europe to Palestine by 1948"_
Rabbi Crool 1812, in a debate with a Protestant Minister.
Napoleon was a Chosen Messiah, he and Hitler lived the same lives 129 years apart, even dying on the same day, and then escaping to Argentina with the stolen gold, with which he started Ancient Aliens Vril Cult with Eric Von Danikan, author of Chariots of the Gods. 2000 Aristocratic Argentinians attended his funeral....
Don't forget South Africa, also home to Elon, and Elon went to the same Jesuit University as Trump, (Wharton). Epstein introduced Elongs brother to his wife and Trump lawyer Dershowitz said he was introduced to Epstein by Lynn de Forrester Rosschild. The CEO of the BBC Marcus Agius married Kate de Roshchild. William and Megyn were married on the 66th anniversary of Hitler's wedding, Epstein died aged 66, and Trump lives on the 66th floor of 666ft Trump Tower. He was born on a Super Wolf Blood Moon to Fred Christ and Mary McKleod on the Date Crowley gave for his Moonchild; June 14, day of the Pharoah, birthday of Osiris John the Baptist and Aushwitz, which was built by Prescott Bush. 700 days before the founding of israel.
All with the help of L Ron Hubbard founder of Scientology.
William was born 7 days later on the Summer Solstice during a Lunar eclipse with induced birth, Diana is the name of Aleister Crowley's Great Goddess, Isis.
Trump paints himself Orange to represent Apollo the Dawnbringer of Aleister Crowley's Golden Dawn.
Just saying...
The channel "Shaun" made a good video about the subject titled "Palestine".
Phenomenal work. The most comprehensive breakdown on the conflict I've seen. It takes bravery and integrity to do this without leaving out inconvenient truths to seem unbiased. An honest and detailed assessment will always be worth more than a balanced one.
A Crock of Xionist shit 😂
The channel "Shaun" made a good video about the subject titled "Palestine".
@@17-MASYI’ll have a look. Nowadays revisionism has overtaken even wiki.
@@1961Bullet Wiki has been like that for over a decade due to being owned by leftist interest groups
Glad you enjoyed this. As the author of one of the books on which this is primarily based, I urge you to also read the books themselves.
I have been teaching the history of the Middle East for over 25 years on a college campus. First time I ran into your channel. I see you made a 3 hour video on this. I will have to give it all a watch. I tell people you can't learn the history of the Middle east in a 10 second tik tok. I have a 19-video playlist as well, several hours long that covers events as far back as the ancient world until today. When I have some time I will watch as much of this as I can, would be curious to see how it compares to what I have been teaching.
the internet is a great source for information but you hate to tread it carefully
@@noammkw3770 amen!
Would be interested to hear what you think about this video if you manage to get around to it please @me in your response
Bump
So I have watched about an hour of it, and I have to say I am very impressed. What is crazy is even with the detail this video gives, it only picks up from relatively recent history. It actually has more detail then some of my videos on the modern period, but to fully understand the region you also need to be familiar with the Ancient History. I will try to watch the rest of it as well. @@guybarget7013
Personally I am just happy that this video (unlike 90% of all others) doesn't just say "colonialism!" and call it a day.
But it is colonialism: "The Jewish Colonisation Association in America spelled Jewish Colonization Association, is an organisation created on September 11, 1891, by Baron Maurice de Hirsch. Its aim was to facilitate the mass emigration of Jews from Russia and other Eastern European countries, by settling them in agricultural colonies on lands purchased by the committee in North America (Canada and the United States), South America (Argentina and Brazil) and Ottoman Palestine. "
@@moma8956 Considering that your comment doesn't even try to be nuanced, I'll just respond in an equally simplistic manner:
Islam and Arab influence in general was spread by colonialism, genocide, and ethnic cleansing. But I am sure that in THAT case, you'll make an exception for colonialism.
As my original comment implied: you need nuance and patience to understand the complexities. Otherwise it all just degenerates. But I guess you want that, because then you don't need put any effort into it.
@@erloriel if you want more nuance, listen to "Fear and loathing in the new Jerusalem" Podcast or any book by a real non-casual historian like Benny Morris, Illan Pappe, Avi Shlaim..etc
@@erlorielislam and arabs didn’t genocide generally, in fact it would be hard to find examples of such. Besides Islams expansion is mainly peaceful. Yes it was spread by the sword at certain points but that is just how the age of empires worked. You cannot call Islamic lands Colonies because regularly they were annexed which is not the same. Colonies aren’t annexed they are used as resources for colonists. Also when it comes to Palestine specifically All the Christians in the area were let and the jews who by the way were kicked out by the Christians were allowed back. The fact that you compare a medieval empire with a colonial state which continues to treat its jews and nonjews differently, continues to abhor the rights of Palestinians. The reason Palestinians don’t agree to solutions isn’t because they hate jews, there were jews living in Palestine before Israel. The real reason is that Israel continues to push for unacceptable conditions such as no right to bear arms no right to return. Moreover, The Israeli government still illegally settles, still abuses the populace. Etc. from and outside perspective i can totally understand why people would hate the Israeli government. Especially when its roots are actually terrorist roots.
@@abd_mdwhy can’t a Jew live in Gaza or in the West Bank if muslins live in Israel? When Jews live in the West Bank they are called colonizers. Do you think that Islam was spread through 49 countries peacefully? If this isn’t colonialism I don’t know what it is…..
Excellent video! As someone living in Israel and involved with teaching her history; I am really impressed with the amount of detail you have gone into here and throughout your videos on the topic. Keep up the great work!
Go back where you came from
Absolutely outstanding video. I am 62 and self taught on this conflict and the details in your videos are next level.
When you learn about the actions of the Grand Mufti that you cannot blame the Jews for their response. Please note that the majority of attacks were Arabs on Jews till the mid 1930s and then the Jews finally kicked it into gear. We always hear about Dier Yassan but never hear about Hebron, 1929 or Jerusalem, 1921.
I have noticed that “the usual suspects” leave vile comments. Sort of sad that reciting the actual history justifies their actions. All I can say is, no comment.
Imagine fighting against an occupation of your land and people almost a century later are trying to justify an actual genocide?
When you lock people in a concentration camp, count their calories, every few years you "mow the lawn" (actual words being used by the class knesset members) by leveling a few neighborhoods and killing thousands, not let them repair their acquifer so 95% of their water is unsafe for consumption, banning things from entering such as chocolate, potato chips and baby chicks, not allowing them any type of economic ties with the world...and so much more...you should expect them to fight back.
The young men who broke through the fence on October 7th were born into this brutal blockade (which amounts to a crime against humanity per human rights watch and amnesty international), they had no past, no present, and no hope for any future. Do you really expect them to simply languish and die in their cage? Would you not fight back any way you can?
Israel is a brutal apartheid state committing the greatest crime of the 21st century. And after this, they will be a pariah state. And your american friends have become politcalaly radioactive on the world stage. Also, when you set out to exterminate an entire group of people, expect them to fight to their last breath. Israel cannot win, and they will be vilified and humiliated in the end. "Give me liberty or give me death"....unless you are arab then you are a terrorist apparently.
After over 10,000 children killed, thousands more still under the rubble, 1.7 million homeless, oh and the IPC has officially classified the Gaza as being a in a true famine, which is over 20% of people at extreme risk of starving to death and/or already dead. Yet people still make comments like "You can't blame them for their response"..
AlL i CaN sAy Is No CoMmEnT
your comment is disgusting, you are blaming palestinians for resisting settler colonialism because they wanted to be treated like their neighbours in the other mandates and for lands not to be given to others. then you justify whatever the zionists have done afterwards of massacers and ethnic cleansing. you have no morality
The Cube Worshippers scream when they massacre you
They're Russians and Roman Catholics
Hence the media and politicians The CEO of the BBC Marcus Agius married a Rosschild Baroness
The title is from the Holy Roman Empire and means the same thing as Fuehrer
Alan Dershowitz said he was introduced to Epstein by Baroness Lynn De Forrester Rosschild
He also hooked up Elon's brother, and Elon attended the same Jesuit University as Trump, and Trump and David Woods being Wharton and Fordham.
Trump, Barr, Bannon, Cippolone, Gore, Guiliani, Leo, Alito, Thomas, and Barrett are all Opus Dei. Trump trained alongside Epstein and Roger Stone under Roy Cohn, who used kids to blackmail politicians on behalf of Mossad. Cohn trained under Meyer Lansky, who trained under Hoover. Robert Mercer and Rupert Murdoch are both Knights of Malta.
Saville, Bezos, Gates, Koch, Rogan, Walsh, Crowder, Kirk, Fuentes, Dore, Knowles, Kulinksi, Ball, Iverson, Icke, Woods, Watson, Cernovich, Abbott, Jones, Robinson, Woods, Pool, Rubin, Peterson, Posobeic, Duke, Molyneux, Yilanopouse, Gionet, Richardson, Tillerson, Greene, Manaforte, Flynn, Ducey, Acosta, Attwood, Stone, Pence, Desantis, Meadows, Trump, Eastman, Black, Kerik, Melania, Barr, Bannon, Hawley, Gingrich, Abrams, Comey, Cuomo, Kerry, Abrams, Gore, Spencer, Blassio, Pompeo, Bolton, McCarthy, Nugent, Cruz, Rubio, Gaetz, Santos, Tucker, Gutfield, O'Reilly, Beck, Scarborough, Devos, Kasich, Mercer, Murdoch, Rosschild, Ingram, Kelly, Lake, Conway, Coulter, Huckabee, McEnany, Hannity, Spicer, Christie, Prager, Maher, Colbert, Corbett, Hayes, Biden, Harris, Fauci, Pelosi, Menendez, Pirro, Manchin, Cooper, Maddow, AOC, Newsom, Uyger, Dawkins, Hitchens, Hancock, Sitchin, Ventura, Morgan, Cowell, Farage, Johnson, May, Merkel, Blair, Cameron, Brown, Blair, Mogg, Benjamin, Trudeau, Putin, Bolsanaro, Stalin, Lenin, Tito, Trotsky, Hitler.
All Roman Catholic.
Then there's the Roman Abromavich connection to Boris Johnson and Nigel Farage, the key players behind Brexit, and the Sex Ring Superyacht he sold to Trump via Adnan Kashoggi, who is Mossad, just like Kushner, and Epstein, who listed SA as his home and had a Wahabbi funeral just like Osama Bin Laden, whose family did Brunch at the Bush Mansion in 2001, and now build the pipelines through the Isis occupied Golan heights, which Trump ceded to israel on it's 70th anniversary.
The Golan Heights being where Genie Oil operates, on the board are Texas Senator Bill Richardson, who gave Elon over $3 Billion in taxpayer money. James Woolsey, Dir CIA under Bush, Art Smuggler Micheal Steinhardt, Rupert Murdoch, Sec Def under Bush Donald Rumsfeld. Also CEO of Halliburton and Vice President under Bush Dick Cheney, Larry Summers (Treasurer under Bush). Jakob Rosschild, and Wilbur Ross, Commerce Secretary under Bush and Treasurer under Trump, CEO of the Bank of Cyprus.
Erdogan is a Wahabbi, like the Saudi Royals, Assad, Jordans king, Sisi, Epstein, Osama, and Isis
A Xionist puppet of the Crown and Rome. "islamic terrorism" was a western puppet show
Using Saudi Wahabbis and Secret agents to dehumanise Palestinians
Think about all the times they inject Palestine into the terrorist narrative, all the claims of billions of dollars
They use religious fundamentalists to undermine secular democracies, just like they did with Trump in America.
_"Claim everything, deny everything, explain nothing"_
Prescott Bush
_"Deny Deflect Disinform"_
Roger Stone
_"If you're not with us you're with the Terrorists"_
George Bush Jr 2001
_"I propose an Aryan/Semitic alliance in order to create a superior caucasian race"_
Benjamin Disraeli, UK PM 1890.
_"But they want nothing but Palestine, because Palestine represents the geostrategic center for World Control"_
Dr Nahum Goldmann.
_"Today I declare the Crusades won"_
General Edmunde Allenby 1917 upon liberating Palestine.
_"the New World 0rder will be ruled from the Temple in Jerusalem"_
Ben Gurion, Bolshevik, First PM of israel
_"We must put an end to anything which brings about any Islamic unity between the sons of the Muslims. As we have already succeeded in finishing off the Caliphate, so we must ensure that there will never rise again unity for the Muslims, whether it be intellectual or cultural unity.“_
George Curzon, 1st Marquess Curzon of Kedleston, British Foreign Minister 1920.
_"By Deceit we wage War"_
Mossad Motto
_"The NW0 will begin Sept 17 2001, during Rosh Hashanah Feast of Trumpets, Resurrection of the Dead, on the First Crescent of the New Moon, in the year 6000 of the Great Pyramid Calendar, in order to cleanse the earth and humanity in preparation for his Kingdom to come"_
British Israel Foundation memo 1922.
To the Chosen we are all Palestine, and when the time comes, the world will watch the same thing done to you, unless we stand up and demand our leaders step down and demand Democracy by Referendum
If we want a future of _any_ kind
We must be able to call a snake a snake, because that's what they do
_slither_
So Without as Within
So Below as Above
It's inverted
The Bible was written by Canaanites using a Mirror
Hence Accusation in a Mirror or Gaslighting, aka Grooming.
Every Accusation is a Confession
A Hatespeech incitement technique used in Genocide like the one in Rwanda, and Burma and Guatemala. The Serpent's who speak with forked tongues were present at each
For your Father is the Father of Lies
And with Lies you Wage War
we dont worship the mecca cube mate, we worship the same god you worship@@DogeickBateman
Thanks!
As a student of history, I found your analysis to be excellent as is all your material. A pleasure to watch and learn.
What a incredible piece of work! Thank you so much!
I live in Israel and I would just like to add my own quick summary of the history here.
The Ottoman Empire was one of the Central Powers on the losing side of World War One. The League of Nations divided the Empire into sections (for example Iraq, Syria, etc) with borders which had never before existed. These sections were placed under the rule of Britain or France until they would become independent states. One section was called Palestine. Britain was given a mandate to make it into a Jewish state. I would speculate that the British government saw a Jewish state in Palestine as being a reliable ally to help Britain defend the crucial Suez Canal. (This actually happened eventually in the 1956 Suez Crisis.) The map of Palestine was drawn carefully to include the port of Eilat in the south and Haifa in the north, giving Palestine access to both ends of the canal.
About 80% of Palestine came under Jewish control in 1948 and the remainder in 1967.
However the Muslim population of Palestine grew, and continues to grow, much more quickly than anyone in 1918 expected thanks to better diet, cleaner water and vaccinations. Additionally most Muslims have been vehemently against the idea of giving Palestine to the Jews. The result is a Jewish state but with a large and growing hostile Muslim population disenfranchised and living in Bantustans.
Regarding Muslim refugees who fled Palestine in 1948, every war creates refugees. Loyalist refugees fleeing the United States following the American Revolution founded Ontario while the property which they left was confiscated by the US government. No one seems to be very worried about the American loyalists' right of return.
It should be mentioned that Muslims do not recognize the concepts of human rights and international law but they hypocritically criticize Jews for violating human rights and international law.
Nice work.
Umm, ontarians can totally go to the US and become citizens there if they wanted to. Not possible at all for Palestinians. The comment on HR is beyond garbage. Not only is it not true, but that is not a reason to deny someone's human rights.
@@brinag8604 No, Canadians cannot return to the US and become citizens and they certainly cannot reclaim their ancestors' property, which is now some of the most expensive real estate in the world in Manhattan. And neither can the grandchildren of refugees anywhere else in the world. At the end of World War II there were millions of refugees, Germans who were living outside the new borders of Germany, Jews who were not able to return to their previous homes in central Europe and others. Where are their descendants today? Does anyone know or care? The Palestinian "refugee" concept is a scam created by Muslims in the hopes of using it to foment hatred toward Israel among Western liberals.
Have you checked the humans rights records of Saudi Arabia, Iran or any other Muslim majority country? How do you feel about beating women to death because their hair isn't covered, executing blasphemers and homosexuals? Muslims out and proudly reject the entire concept of human rights. You have no rights. You have the privilege of obeying whatever Muhammed allegedly said 1400 years ago.
About international law. For 1300 years Muslims were imperialists, slavers and colonizers. No Muslim leader has ever apologized for all that. They are proud of it and would do it again given the opportunity. However now that the shoe is on the other foot, Muslims beg Western liberals for help and sympathy.
Nothing I'm saying is a secret. Get off the internet and read a book.
If it's ok that every war creates refugees then the Jews had no right to return to Palestine.
More than 50 percent Jews living in Israel came from Europe...If you want land there are many land in Amazon jungle and Sahara desert etc...Go live there not by snatching someone's land and creating your holy land on the Mass Graves of babies...You killed 8000 babies...how can someone be so cruel and barbaric? I literally cried many days watching what's happening with the people of Palestine...you can't have peace ...you can't get peace on the mass Graves of babies...You should end the occupation now Free Palestine 🇵🇸
A well put together and interesting video!
Only 12 minutes late and I have been waiting for this masterpiece. Thank You. Very reliable content on topics I know little about.
How do you know it's very reliable if you know little about it?
@@darrenwithers3628 I tend to know some things and in any case I am not sure I meant accurate.
😂😂😂😂
Xiobot detected
Xionazi Propaganda confirmed 😂😂😂😂😂
@@Uncanny_Mountain10 year old detected.
I started to learn Middle East history from decent Chinese history professors 20 years ago. The historical facts they cited/quoted are pretty much in line with yours, and the narratives were pretty neutral and mainstream English history teaching. It’s interesting that these historical narratives are contradictory to current Chinese government propaganda (CCP) position or the old textbooks during the Cultural Revolution in Mao’s era which was similar to the modern day western leftist narratives. The history we tell, the people we become.
All Leftism/Socialism is inherently antisemitic
Jesuit Directive 24:
Blame the Victim of that which you are doing yourself
Islamic terrorism is a CIA Saudi/Scionist creation to justify genocide
Blaming Hamas is just an excuse to murder children and steal their land, no different to 2001, Iraq WMDs, Libya, Afghanistan, Syria, Lebanon, Egypt, Sudan, Ethiopia, Somalia, Yemen, all in the name of a democracy they dont believe in.
Tens of millions killed in a worldwide genocide of Muslims by Rome and Chazars, all based on LIES
Bombing hospitals, schools, using white phosphorus, and cluster bombs, filling in wells, burning olive orchards stealing cattle. Targeting pregnant women and kids is terrorism! Kidnapping kids in the middle of the night, strapping them to vehicles as human shields is terrorism. Rape, abuse, medical experiments, poisoning, and assault is terrorism, stealing their homes is terrorism. Sterilising Ethiopians, radiating Shepardics and using Yemenis for organ harvest all examples of your Terrorist heritage
Irgun Stern, King David Hotel, USS Liberty, the 67 war, Bali, Fukushima, Burma, Bosnia, 2001, Mexico, Vegas, Boston, on and on, all proof of your Terrorism.
Cast Lead, Vigilante Guardian, Lavon Affair, Oded Yinon, Tantura, Nakba, all prove who the terrorist are
You have terrorised Palestinians for nearly a century, engaged in outright brutality, pulling kids limb from limb after raping them, forcing petrol down the throats of kids before burning them alive then laughing at their suffering, taking joy in depriving them of water and food and medicine; all acts of terrorism. Spitting on them, burning down churches and defacing Palestinian graves.
And not just Palestine but Bosnia, Fauklands, Myanmar, Rwanda, Guatemala, Columbia, Brazil, Argentina, Honduras, Mexico, Kenya, Egypt, Sth Africa, France, Germany, UK, Boko Haram, Isis, Taliban, Hamas: you supply arms to terrorist groups, promote genocides and persecute Muslims using your Jesuit media and Mossad Death Squads
You use the word Terrorist as a substitute for Migger, no different to how Nazis used the word Jude
Every accusation is a confession:
Look in the mirror lest the irony kill you. The accuser claims he cannot be wrong, so then what is the difference between "God's Chosen" who cannot be criticised or held accountable and "Master Race" engaged in slaughter and fascism.
The world will not forget!
Eternity is a long time to be branded evil, and your evil vile comments and your campaign of strawmen and disinformation and hate prove you never wanted Peace, never saw Semitic Palestinians as humans, never recognised their right to their own state, it was all lies from the start. You cry self defence, but what you really mean is a right to rape murder and steal.
You claim Satan's Hell has a right to defend itself while stealing land, imprisoning women and children and murdering kids, it's the definition of a call to genocide. You claim Palestinians want to wipe you off the map, as you wiped them off the map
All accusation in a mirror
Bombing refugee camps and crying "Hamas"
So it's all just Accusation in a Mirror aka Gaslighting aka Grooming, a Hatespeech incitement technique used in Genocide, and the Jesuit media, cults, and the sexual abuse of children, which Republicans are always getting caught doing
Remember the law of the Prophets: Treat others as you would have the treat you
The world will not forget your lies
And soon they will see it was ALL lies
Then where will you go?
How will you be treated, who will mourn your dead
If you see us as animals how should we see you? Who will listen to your excuses when everything you spew is lies and Gaslighting?
Who will care for you?
Rules for thee but not for ye?
Is it any wonder you're despised around the world, no one will trust you, no one will speak to you, no one will do business with you, your descendants will carry your cross for 1000 years, everything you stole and hoarded will be taken from you
And they will say, these people can only lie, it is their curse, do not give them shelter, lest they mirder you in your sleep and steal your house
Everything you say now will be used whenever you speak, your own rhetoric will be spoken to you, and will be used to judge you
They will say, "these people are cowards, even unarmed children can defeat their armies"
Woe Great Babylon!
Come out of her my people
so that she may be judged!
As an American Gentile observer and (admittedly casual) scholar of the situation in the Middle East since my college days in the 1960s, I believe this lecture to be relatively well balanced and objective. That's not easy to do when the subject matter is so hotly controversial and passions are running as high as they are today. I must say that I was disappointed at times when our lecturer failed to accurately read the important quotations verbatim, sometimes distorting their meaning. But overall this was very informative in its detailed granularity of events that occurred in the first half of the 20th Century in Palestine as well as diplomatically in the centers of power in Europe, the Middle East, and the United States.
Grade B+
A
Nothing controversial about a Genocide done on an indigenous population
What has gotten into you that you struggle with Colonialism being a crime?
If israel hit its own people at the festival, and built the hospital base that they used themselves, and if israel funded Hamas... Do they really want the hostages back alive?
And who really beheaded all those babies? Can they recite the Mossad motto?
What language do Palestinians speak?
@@Uncanny_Mountainman, Israel sure sucks at genocide. The population of Palestine keeps growing!
@@mookosh And, it's growing pretty fast.
@@Uncanny_MountainAh yes, touting debunked conspiracy theories such as: “Israel killed its own people on October 7th” makes you look really goddamn stupid.
Will you be covering the period between 1939 and 1948?
At 3:02:23: "The Jews may have a case, and a strong one too, but their case is based on humanity, and official documents and promises, nonsensical considerations in a period of crude realism... There is not an Arab who wants to see himself ruled by Jews, but there is not also an Arab with sense who wants to see himself ruled by assassins." - Yusuf Hanna
20 % of Israeli Arabs with Israeli citizenship. He was clearly not right with his statement. And yes the vast majority would not want to be ruled by either the PA nor Hamas.
Hey @CasualHistorian I just wanted to say thank you. I am a Jewish person who has just discovered your Chanel and I appreciate your historiography of Israel/Palestine and your videos exposing antisemitism. You have gained a new subscriber.
Great video! Thank you!
I know this video was intended to be non biased but maybe we should compare the # of times each party is criticized
thats the wrong question. the real question is did he ever leave out relevant context.
@@slothhq1929 Everything critical of zisrael
Whenever a text or video is more conplex than "west/imperialism baf" it's biased lmao
@@geraldmeehan8942 he literally didn't. maybe you should reference some specific things that he didn't mention.
If one party does objectively more bad things then that party should be criticized more.
Arabs have objectively done a lot of bad and horrible attacks against uninvolved Jews so they should be scrutinized more.
If anything they don't get scrutinized enough, while every little questionable thing Israel does is placed under a microscope.
It's quite laughable that you believe Arabs in any way shape or form receive disproportionate critcism.
Nice to get both side of story most ppl lean to one side or closed of entirely to one side and unable to stay open minded that both sides have played a part in the violence and propaganda
I study most wars and empires in history. Specially also the area of Canaan.
1 thing I can say the area is more as 4000 years under war. And war is never good for the looser 🤷🏼
Amazing video, will watch all over the next few days.
I would start this story in 1882 with a quick look back to 700s.It is also important to understand the underlying reasons for the conflict. without that, none of this makes sense.
Yeah, without talking about the Ottoman land reforms of the 1850’s as well as the fact that the concept of land ownership was foreign to nearly every Arab (of course excluding the wealthy ones), you can’t understand why Arabs started getting angry at the European Jews who started moving into the countryside in 1882 (the vast majority of Jewish immigration prior to was to an urban environment (aka Jerusalem)). Prior to 1882, there wasn’t much tension between Jews and Muslims (especially compared to their relationship with the Christians). By skipping straight to 1919, you give the impression that there had always been tensions between the religious communities and the Muslims have always been antisemitic like Christians have, which is simply not true.
Muslims have always been as anti semitic as Christians yes @@Mbwunion
@@Mbwunionso Muslims were ok with Jews being subjugated dhimmis. They were threatened by diaspora Jews who legally purchased land where none of them even lived on because they couldn't comprehend that Jews can have the same rights as dhimmis
@@Mbwunionthe reason why there wasn't much "tension" is because Arab abuse of Jews was systematic and rampant and the Jews couldn't do anything about it and had to accept it.
It's like a slave owner saying that before slavery ended there wasn't much "tension" between him and the slave.
Well yeah if you oppress the shit out of someone and completely break their will and determination ofc they won't give you problems. But the absence of a visible problem doesn't mean there isn't one
Another great video! Keep up the great content
This is a very in depth look at this problem, compared to what I have seen elsewhere. I have a different view after watching this.
Please we need a Continuation to this video and make it long 😁👍🏽
From 1939-1947, the British disarmed Arabs, while ignoring Jewish militias acquisition of military grade small arms.
the arabs had their own independent militias similar to zionist extremist griups like lehi and the irgun!!!!
Probably because of the Arab revolt
Completely wrong. The other way around
@@ajvorob9117stop watching prpoganda videos and start reading actual historians account even Benny morris has admitted this and he is pro Israel
🎉great videos, very informative, loaded with facts and information that empowers me to shut down idiots who know nothing about Israel’s struggle to build Israel into what it is today-a miracle of accomplishment and a bastion of moral uprightness and democracy. The Palestinians are simply not wired this way. This is why it’s been so troublesome.
Great video, thank you!
Something is missing,or of little mention . The hard working culture of migrated jews .My grand-grand father bought a sizeable lot of land from an Arab landlord .With his remaining wealth he transformed that totally bare,infertile land into a true garden .In 1948 the Arab vendor litteraly with other muslims attacked our house .My father died defending our land and house .After the war the Arabs with no properties were expelled from our land.Not a single one with a house on their name .If you look at the map of Israel on 15 of may 1948 not 1 single square km that was not bought by Jews.Except Negev desert owned by nobody .So ,Israel occupy “Palestinian”land is just a myth .Nothing else !
That's a lie bucko. Entire cities full of Arabs were forcibly cleared out. That's a fact. Example: Lydda and Ramle. Stop peddling lies.
There are records of Jews burning and foresting houses, there are no houses because they were destroyed. You simplify alot of the conflict.
@@thotslayer9914I highly advise you to leave. We cannot take responsibility for you living in a shit hole. God forbid.
I get what you're trying to say. But that is just a dumb way to look at things. A land owner can do whatever they want to the land. If they dont want to develop it then that's their damn business. If your gggggrand dad wanna make a flowerbed out of it that fine. If the previous owner wanted to left it to rot then that's their perogative too. Subtlely propping your ancestor up while putting down its predecessor serves nothing but dehumanize the predecossors, making you complicit.
@@Disgruntled1986you want it now only because it is so beautiful and PROFITABLE.😊
Excellent video. It is clear thru the video who always wanted progress.and peace and who never did.
Best account of the Middle East I have ever seen, excellent job 3:04:54
So you’re saying, the reason that the Zionist did not hire the indigenous Arab population, had nothing to do with bigotry? Seems very selective to me your interpretation that is.
Zionists wanted Jews to work the land. They didn't want it to become a feudal situation that existed before.
And also these people were not indigenous. They themselves either migrated from our were descendants of those migrated from other areas like Egypt, syria, Lebanon, Iraq , trans Jordan, Arabia, Algerian, etc
Did any Arab business ever hire Jews?
Yeah I didn't think so. Spare me your hypocritical whining .
He did not in fact say that. I'm sure there was bigotry, but that's not really the point. The Arabs were not exactly completely free from bigotry either.
Thanks for addressing this important issue. Looking at your sources, I cannot help but notice that they’re extremely one sided in Israel’s favor and ignores other voices, both Israeli and Palestinian. I would highly recommend reading the works of Ilan Pappe and Avi Shlaim for a more balanced Israeli perspective. I would also highly recommend reading Palestinian American voices such as Rashid Khalidi and Edward Said.
"Other voices" doesn't mean more accurate facts .
Surely, reading multiple views and scrutinizing the evidence proffered by them results in a more accurate understanding of the facts than reading books that are so clearly one sided. I think that you’d certainly agree with that if someone made a video about the history citing mostly Palestinian leaders and very pro-Palestine Palestinian historians? Books by the founder of Israel such as Moche Diane, Chaim Weismann and Ben Gurion are exactly the inverse of reading books by Yaser Arafat, and the Hussaini mayors of Jerusalem.
Sadly I have tried reading the "other sources" now and again and many are more like information coming from "Comical Ali- the Iraqi information minister and less an historical account.@@aas.993
I think you're assuming he hasn't read them. It's entirely possible he has read the sources you suggest but didn't find their narratives compelling.
he sourced khalidi
A well narrated documentary of the conflict, just a bit monotoned for me. But well done.
thanks..i follow pat condell here on youtube...he speaks very clearly and i enjoy you and he.
I’ve read a lot on this subject and find this video to be excellent with deep detail elucidating many of the complexities of the matter, eg, the part the big Arab landowners played in establishing unrest and rejection of a Jewish presence.
Xiobot 😂
If thousands of invaders started arriving en masse, formed gangs, and tried to take control of the government you'd reject them too.
@@jjab430So who was the governor or leader of Palestine before Zionists arrived??
@@Uncanny_Mountainchild
I can't believe this video only has 46k views. It's by far the most complete, well-researched, accessible and nuanced piece of background information about the present conflict on the entire internet. It's a genuinely astonishing achievement that you managed to tell this story in just three hours. I studied history and Holocaust & Genocide Studies for 7 years, read dozens of books and articles on the Middle East, Jewish history and colonialism, and yet I still learned so very much from this video. Any historian will love this. And everyone who suddenly has a very strong opinion on a conflict they don't understand in the slightest may begin to realize that any black and white portrayal of history is simply wrong, and that the loudest voices are often the least informed.
Understanding requires effort, nuance, and much more than slacktivist retweets and 2-minute TikTok 'explainers'. Maybe that's why this video has only 46k views...
That's because the majority of people that talk about this issue don't actually care all that much, if it isn't a 20 second video about their "team" painted in a way they want they do not care to hear about it
@@Scornfull Sadly you are 100% correct my friend...
Re Sir Herbert Samuel. You say he was the first Jew to hold a cabinet position. Does that mean that the prime minister does not count as a cabinet position? Because if it does, we have to count Benjamin Disraeli as the first.
Herbert Samuel was the first practicing Jew in the Cabinet. Disraeli has converted to Anglicanism by the time he entered Parliament.
😂those voices imitating orhers, with the inflections right on the situations. ❤😂😊
The most unbiased comprehensive video on this issue there is & it’s not close. Almost every other video leaves out a lot of details on one side
There was note written on the end of this agreement by Faisal. Why would you not talk about it.? 6:16
This is the _Faisal-Weizmann agreement._ Anybody interested can type that into a search engine and the wiki page will pop up.
It's not that he simply didn't talk about it. He presented it as the complete OPPOSITE !!! This is just one example of the little tiny things that biased the whole video to one side. A lot of people says he gave a fair and balance view. He did not. It's almost as if somebody who is -biased- heavily favours one side, realized that he isn't neutral, tries to correct for it, but fails. I'll give him that he did try to make an effort to be sorta more balanced, but still he cannot bring himself to go all the way, and there's this little tiny things here and there. Imagine he is in journalism school, and submitted this as a written assignment. His professor would mark it all over the place where he's missed the mark, and say _try harder, I know you can do it. Fix it up and resubmit in two weeks. You can get a better grade._
@@danielch6662 Yeah i know he is clearly biased. The note i am talking about said that he(Faisal) will not be answerable to carry out the agreement if British broke the promise.
I didn’t have to watch very much of this to realise it’s just pro-Israeli propaganda. So I’m certainly not going to waste three hours of my life on the rest of it. It seems to be largely based on the writings of Ephraim Karsh. His “Palestine betrayed”, which you quote repeatedly, is a work of propaganda not a serious history book. (I have written a review of it on Amazon.)
Like Karsh, you gloss over the fact that the Zionists were not coming to Palestine in order to integrate peacefully into the local society, but to destroy that society and replace it with another society, ethnically Jewish and based on European culture. They were willing to tolerate Arabs perhaps, but only as a minority in a Jewish state. Some Zionists were quite willing to contemplate ethnic cleansing.
Like Karsh, you find the Arab attitude unreasonable. Why were they so unwilling to cooperate with those who wanted to replace their society? Hmmm. It must’ve been antisemitism. Or maybe they were tricked by Arab leaders.
Thank you for admitting your ignorance from the outset.
You seems to be forgetting that more than 50% of Jewish Israel population came from Muslim countries.
> Zionists were not coming to Palestine in order to integrate peacefully into the local society, but to destroy that society and replace it with another society, ethnically Jewish and based on European culture.
"Destroy" and "European culture" doing a lot of legwork. How so? Modern Israel is culturally pretty Middle Eastern, and even with all of the bad stuff Israel has done, Arabs are still culturally Arab.
> They were willing to tolerate Arabs perhaps, but only as a minority in a Jewish state.
Oh? Sort of like how the Arabs wanted to force Jews to exist as a minority in an Arab state? If being a minority is so bad, surely that's all the more of a reason Jews should be allowed to create a majority at least somewhere.
> Some Zionists were quite willing to contemplate ethnic cleansing.
As opposed to… the Arabs? Who actively tried to force out all the Jews prior to anything that can be considered an act of ethnic cleansing by the Jews?
He clearly includes the different factions within zionism and different views of zionists of how the national home should be realized, you not watching the video really shows
Integrate with traditional Arab society? You have no idea what you're talking about. You speak of tribal Arabs of the late 19th century as if they're some modern liberal nation that you could just join. When Jews came to Palestine, the only thing they could do was build a new way of life and a new society, which is what they did.
The mosque with a golden dome is not Al aqsa mosque😀. It’s Dome of the rock. Al aqsa is a modest one nearby
As someone who is pretty familiar with the conflict and has read extensively on it, this a laughably one sided video. Protraying Jobotinsku as wanting a peaceful settlement with Arabs, saying that Arabs just hated the Jews, not talking about Ottoman land reforms, not mentioning the multiple major zionist figures who expressed an intention to take the land from Palestinians.
Give me a better video.
The Arabs did hate Jews. This is undeniable.
Otherwise they wouldn't murder Jews in Hebron or in Tiberias in the 1930s.
Also very few of them actually owned the land they lived on. Majority of the land was owned by either ottomans and later British or absentee landlords. Many Arabs were tenant farmers who worked the land and had to pay exorbitant rent imposed by the wealthy absentee landlords or the wealthy effendis
Most people on this earth do not legally own the land they live on. People living in cities who live in houses only own their houses and property attached to it. They don't own the stretch of the street or sidewalk they live on.
@@RikkiSan1besDMarx channel has an on going series thats exhaustively well documented debunking pro-zionists spins on the history
Subscribed, thank you
Zero mention of King David Hotel bombing? I wonder why...
cmon we know why that and others actions are not mentioned lol
The story ends in 1939, and the King David bombing was in 1946.
no time to school you on other events but how convenient is that...the point was how casually you stitch together all your videos to paint a story but i get you dont wanna get removed from youtube but know that story of history is alwasy on the hearts of palestinians like it was yesterday and didnt end @@CasualHistorian
@@charlie2485ok emotional baby. This video presented a well rounded historical analysis and your response is feelings.
@@charlie2485do we know? Please enlighten us with your tik tok sound bites of nonsense. I can't wait for the conspiracy theories of jews control insert whatever in here.
30 seconds in and you messes up. There was no Palestinian flag until 1964, this is because there was no Palestinian people, or country. It's like referring to the highlands In Scotland, it's a region not a people. You are too casual for me. If you started atound 1850 youd learn the local jews had started buying large tracks of land from the Arabs, who laughed at them as they thought it worthless. It was later on that muslims started to stop these purchases. Oh and lets be clear, they were buying back land that was stolen from them by the romans, Tuks and muslims.
Just say no to Islamastine.
Racist
@@watchmojosh Racists these days don't blow themselves up or strip a dead girl on the back of a pickup truck while shouting Aloha Snackbar.
@@watchmojosh R*cists these days don't blow themselves up or strip a dead girl on the back of a pickup truck while shouting Aloha Snackbar.
@@watchmojosh Liar
@@watchmojoshthe R word doesn't work any more.
This documentary was impressive. Thanks much for well researched history and thoughtful approach to the historiography. I would highly recommend this work to anyone interested in this critical period to a difficult period in a difficult region.
as an israeli i thank you for this video
another excellent video! Thank you.
All I can say about this is…is he biased? Yes, obviously. It is very clear what side he is on. However, the sources used are irrefutable. The truth doesn’t change because the person that’s saying it…agrees with the truth being told.
Sources are not immune from a biased framing, framing is just as important as the facts of the matter.
@@stvdiascholastica4599 Please share example of this where it is in fact the case then, so we can have a fairer and more objective interpretation of such facts.
Honey applied to salt may make it sweeter, but it is still salt😊
@@stvdiascholastica4599Precisely. And not to mention some glaring omissions that heavily indicate these biases. The language of that Balfour Declaration so conveniently glossed over is enough by itself to prove the callous dehumanization of indigenous Palestinians at the core of Zionism as an ideology.
@@watchmojoshlook into the Israeli declaration of Independent
This is the perfect video for the roots of the conflict
God bless you and God bless Sam 🙏🏽
splendid
Casual, 3hrs, you keep using that word but 😅
Kidding aside, phenomenal, unbiased and comprehensive work 👏
This might actually the most biased presentation on this topic I've ever listened to.
What did he get wrong, I’m curious?
@@harrywalmsley8616 I think the worst of it is he presented nearly every Arab or Palestinian attack as unprovoked and every Israeli attack as responsive or forced. Palestinians and other Arabs are framed as violent and unreasonable so much that it borders on racist.
@@milosminionSo your basically denying that this events happened and the Arabs didn’t conduct this attacks.
@@milosminionmaybe, just maybe that is exactly how arabs were in this conflict lmao
@@sharwama992 I'm not. But every attack by Israel is presented as provoked and nearly every Arab attack as unprovoked, even though that's impossible.
Don't go full Islam.
It's always the americans with two american first names first and last that are the most racist lmao mark garret.
@@SegzWithTedCruzAn ideology isn't a race.
@@SegzWithTedCruz You can be a white America-born man like John Walker Lindh and still go full Islam.
Thanks for telling everyone your ignorant and racist without telling everyone your ignorant and racist.
@anthonyschepsis4750 it's always some brainlet who thinks they can win a point with the over used non insult of racism.
Are you European? If so perhaps you need to stay silent after all the pogroms, expulsions, discrimination and the holocaust of jews perpetrated by Europeans. Such smugness.
@@SegzWithTedCruz at least we can pronounce his name, tf is a schepsis
Some conclusions. 1) The Jews also were not saints. 2) The Arabs were much more violent 2) Arabs refused almost any type of agreement. 3) Arabs made every mistake in the book (and are still doing so till this day)
Exactly. No one says Israel did everything right and were flawless.
But many people who bash Israel on all the allegedly bad things it did completely ignore the much worse actions that Arabs have done.
It turns out getting attacked by Arabs for generations after generations made Israelis more violent, radicalized, and brutal.
Funny how these same people always say that Arabs becomes radicalized because of Israeli checkpoints, security measures, and retaliatory bombings. But choose to dismiss the fact that a lot of Arab terrorist attacks such as dozens of suicide bombings during the second intifada played a major role in radicalizing Israelis too.
It's almost like they want a free pass to do whatever they want without consequences
I hope this video keeps alive because it's one of the best if not the Best I have seen
Great detailed video. If you're watching this factual recounting of events and thinking its biased you should investigate the facts presented using reliable sources. If you cant refute the facts, it's time to investigate your own bias.
You sound like an AI Bot from israel
@@Uncanny_Mountainchild
@@Uncanny_Mountainyour response literally proved his point. You're so willing to acknowledge your own bias that you start slinging ad hominem
This is great!
the most ridiculous start to the episode - you can't even get the basics right! The palestinian mandate included most of Jordan as well, which was split off in 1924.. First 3 seconds and already a lie or incompetence. Stop pretending you've done any research, with a start like this it would be a waste of time continuing.
Ok...point me to a video that has the best explanation of this.
Obviously this project wasn't going to be well from the start.
And by starting where he did in the video he got to skip the whole part on how the British mandate for a Jewish state was the payoff for the jewish people using the power and influence to keep Russia from pulling out of world war 1 and getting America to fully commit to war world one. This wasnt a natural movement that the jewish people have there own state it was the pay off for helping the allies to beat Germany in world war 1
Lol? 😂 You mean the war they actively didn't want to happen? If this isn't blatant conspiracy idk what is
Its name was Palestine and its name will remain Palestine - Palestinian poet Mahmoud Darwish-
Jews referred to as palestinians because during the Ottoman empire, that was the name of the region. Arab muslims didnt use that to refer to themselves until after the 1960s
@@kirasgirl during the ottman empire it wasn't called Palestine. Europeans used that name but the official name changed
The 50% growth was also due to more than 30,000 Arabs moving into Palestine due to the job prospects. In fact the number 30,000 is probably far too small as the British only recorded the Jews coming in and did nothing to prevent the Arabs moving in. Hence the 700,000 Arabs who left Palestine as refugee were probably 40% foreigners. Hence the UN definition of a Palestinian refugee as someone who have been living in Palestine for just 2 years prior to 1948!
Absolutely fabulous video. Learned so much, well researched and put together. Amazing!
A masterpiece, thanks so much.
The Jews are the indigenous people of Palestine the way the blacks are the indigenous people of South Africa!
"Who can challenge the rights of the Jews in Palestine? Good Lord, HISTORICALLY IT IS REALLY YOUR COUNTRY..."
Yusuf Diya al-Khalidi, Arab Mayor of Jerusalem, 1829.
Three facts about Palestine you never know:
1. There has NEVER been an independent state of Palestine, nor an Arab state of Palestine.
2. The name "Palestine" comes from the Romans who renamed "Judea and Samaria" Syria Palestine to punish the Jews for their revolt against the Romans ... before Islam even existed.
3. Palestine Arabs today are not indigenous. They are "ethnic Arabs," and the vast majority of them come to the land with the Islamic conquerors in 634 CE.
Yet, the Palestinians are genetically more Jewish than the European Jews.
@@pasifred8589Ashkenazi Jews can trace their paternal DNA to the middle east. Which is not surprising because we are cousins.
@@nathanwoltermann2639 And still, you are more closely related to me, a northern European, than you are to that region.
You are about 60% European and the Palestinians are around 90%< Levant.
So, the Palestinians are direct descendants of the peoples living in that area(ancient Canaanite, Israelite, Judean and what have you) and therefore indigenous people, whereas the Jews are a culture/religious entity.
@@pasifred8589it doesn't matter, Jews are Jews,they originate in one place which is Palestine, Jews are actually the owners of the land
@@chinedujosephezengige5721 Nothing that you say will ever grant the Jewish diaspora the right to supplant the indigenous Palestinians. With your logic African Americans should be allowed to go back to Africa and start massacring Ghanaians and Cameroonians.
Also you do understand that over 2 thousand years religious conversion can happen right? The Palestinian Muslims living in the levant have ancestors who practiced Judaism.
The 5:55 ts should explain the problem clearly. Do they have a melonin ? No !
If your historical knowledge is like this you should stay as a casual historian not a professional.
Let me guess he got it all wrong and the Jews are the bad guys and Arabs the real good guys right?
@@RikkiSan1if you believe God promised the jews a land which people already lived in before them for thousands of years and yet they had the right to kick them out then I'm sorry I don't buy the idea
@@RikkiSan1I found in the bible (don't ask which version) that I was promised the piece of land you live in right now so please leave now or I call my daddy America
Nice
💥 I already watched this video with another title. This is not fair ! 😮😮😮
They boughs t th that land from who?
The Ottomans. Land ownership in the levant was mostly Turk. And also Arabs in some cases. A lot of it was useless swamp land that got turned into farm land.
From whoever had local legal ownership. First under the laws of Ottoman Empire, then the British mandate.
@@Shakshuka69 Correct. I'm tired of people talking about "stolen land" with regard to Israel even though over 80% of the Arabs who left didn't actually own the land they lived on but were tenants of absentee landlords who'd sold to Jews.
@@eafstudios6436 So because the Palestinians didn't have paperwork for land that they lived on for generations the Jews had a right to ethnically cleanse them? Someone tell the Native Americans they could've prevented their massacre if they had just presented their deeds to the white settlers.
@@jjab430 The truth is that the Arabs started a war with the aim of expelling the Jews or even slaughtering them, and they lost and were expelled, and that's how wars work.
Highly informative!
Damn they still talk exactly the same
No Haganah or Stern group ...amazing
If you would watch more than 30 seconds of the video, instead of waiting for your favorite anti-Semitic dog whistles to be mentioned, you might realize you're wrong.
The Haganah is mentioned, many times, and Lehi is not because it was founded in 1940, while the video's narrative ends in 1939. And if you think I'm being selective to make the Israelis look better, I also didn't mention that the Mufti was a LITERAL Nazi Collaborator.
@@CasualHistorian😂😂 you're complete JOKE.
I guess you don't like the truth @@skp8748
Yes we think you’re being selective to make the Israelis look better
@@Dudemeister you just can't handle the truth
I thoroughly enjoyed that, thanks
I didn't get to take your survey in time. How far back into ancient times do you usually work? I'm proportionally more fascinated the farther back we go 👍 your stuff is all good though. Thank you 🤙
is this even fixable?
Yes. Resettle the Palestinians to the Sinai. They'll have an even bigger country than Israel, oil, tourism, two major water access points, and they'll be on one side of Israel rather than sandwiching Israel (dramatically reducing the security concerns of Israel).
@@mookoshthe Egyptians do not want even one individual from Gaza to live in any part of Egypt, not even Sinea.😊
@@eliegroff392 then don't bitch about Israel doing what it needs to do.
Deleting comments?
I don't delete comments. I have a comment filter that catches explicit anti-semitism. So if you aren't being an anti-Semite, your comment should be there.
@@CasualHistorian didn't know TH-cam considered criticism of Israel as anti-Semitism
@@DudeBadTakedude he literally used historical sources . It's a fact that Arabs are the aggressors in the conflict
oh wow Thank you for detailing this , just found his socials and WOW to say the least.. I cant sub to anyone who openly supports genocide and apartheid , never again means never again for everyone
@@DudeBadTake
@@t95kush27 Just so we can validate your genocide claim, can you provide a rough date or year in the future in which you believe the Palestinian people will have all been killed? Do you expect this to happen in this next year or two or longer?
this video is a w
The channel "Shaun" made a good video about the subject titled "Palestine".
Ha! Shaun is a god damn communist who sellectively chooses oppresed groups
@wmk4454 yea, he is just a generic communist "america bad" shill.
You can't be pro Israel without being pro Palestine and you can't be pro Palestine without being pro Israel ! Peace is the only way 🇵🇸🇮🇱☮️💜
Thats not possible now.
Nice video dude, never new some of the things.
SUP👹🔥
finally someone know true history
This is extremely one sided and biased. Not looking for narrativised history, just the facts. NEXT
What did he get wrong?
Don’t you just adore British and French PATHÉ?
thanks prager u
Do you do the voices? Not bad….
If u ask me there war or mortal enemies since biblical times
so all these "claims" that had arabs worried came true huh....
Self-fulfilling prophecy.
“I was worried this guy would beat me up. So I punched him to try to prevent it even though he wasn’t attacking me, but then he beat me up, which proves I was right to worry.”
Wow. This is so disappointing. Your bias is so obvious and from the very start! 🤦♂️
Start the history of the area farther back.
You do realize the further back you start the story the weaker the Palestinian narrative is, right?
@@CasualHistorian How so? Were you planning on using the Bible?
It seems odd that you would say that when even the scientific evidence on the genetic origins of the Palestinians seems to indicate their indigenous status in the land.
@@daiyumyoyes and no. 50% of the Jews in Israel today are Shepardic origin (basically Arab bloodlines)
@@daiyumyoif you were to start farther back you would have to get into Arab migration into the land during the Ottoman Empire, showing that a majority of the Palestinians migrated to Palestine during that era.
And there is no genetic study that can show “who is native” because you have nothing to compare it to. What these studies do is compare the genetics of one region to another, so the genetic studies you are referring to simply show that Palestinian Arabs share more genetic material with Egyptians/syrians/Jordanians then some Jews. You cant tie that genetic makeup to a particular area of the land.
@@shafsteryellow oh really? How did you get Canaanite DNA? You have a Time Machine?
Nice act at pretending to be neutral.
Truth hurts you i suppose,
This felt like a very bais video.
Because it is
If it was biased in the other direction it would have already been yanked down and a strike would have been issued
@@DiscoGeminino its not😅
The guy literally has every single source, he has transcripts and direct quotes, I an sorry that its not your typical social media or Al Jazeera
When you call a factual retelling of events biased it's time to take a look at your own bias.
The colonization propaganda didn’t age well in the internet age.
Indeed I've learnt so much about Islamic colonisation.