Thank you @dante_2831 for the request. First off, I'm sure a few noticed that I used the protagonist point, the main reason is because of the main cast point giving away which took the protagonist point. Feel free to ask about the category distribution. I will say themes, interactions, conclusion, and pacing are debatable. Main cast and deuteragonist was supposed to be Usogui, my bad. Next request is Omori vs Walter White. Next short is Protagonist Tournament Part 9.
I have read many mangas and these two are the best ones to me. And seems like you have the same taste with me right there, Usogui is just a tiny bit better
Goodnight Punpun is about a boy named Punpun Punyama. The whole manga follows the relationships Punpun has with his friends, family, and lovers. I would say the manga is worth going in as blind as possible, but that's just me.
I was confused about this comment, because I could've sworn it went to Usogui, and then I watched the short and realized that I gave it to Goodnight Punpun by accident. So yeah, Usogui takes. Here's the rough (very rough) category distribution: Introduction: Aiko Conclusion: Aiko Development: Kaji Journey: Kaji Depth of thought: Aiko Character Depth: Kaji Depth of themes: Aiko Overall depth: Aiko Complexity: Kaji Themes: Aiko Symbolism: Aiko Philosophies: Kaji Ideologies: Kaji Parallels: Kaji Psychological Accuracy: Kaji Psychological Portrait: Kaji Mentality: Kaji Overall Psychology: Kaji Narrative Impact: Kaji Emotional Impact: Aiko Overall Impact: Kaji Backstory: Aiko Emotions: Aiko Motivation: Kaji Goals: Kaji Building: Kaji Number of Peaks: Kaji Highest Peak: Aiko Overall Peaks: Kaji Quotes: Kaji Monologues: Kaji Dialogues: Kaji Interactions: Kaji Side Dynamics: Kaji Main Dynamic: Aiko Overall Dynamics: Aiko Consistency: Aiko Three dimensionality: Kaji Execution: Aiko Characterization: Kaji Compelling: Kaji Overall Writing: Kaji
![ร้อยพ่อพันแม่ - WanMai [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XY2pNYASEbg/mqdefault.jpg)
Thank you @dante_2831 for the request. First off, I'm sure a few noticed that I used the protagonist point, the main reason is because of the main cast point giving away which took the protagonist point.
Feel free to ask about the category distribution. I will say themes, interactions, conclusion, and pacing are debatable. Main cast and deuteragonist was supposed to be Usogui, my bad.
Next request is Omori vs Walter White.
Next short is Protagonist Tournament Part 9.
thanks man, literally the best take you could do (both destroys Berserk in writing)
@@Oyasumi_Editor No problem + fax
Damn that was smooth
Glad you think so
Very good edit
Thanks
Fair
W edit!! Imo I would have lowered the diff a little bit, probably Extreme Diff. Still a good take.
Thanks. I think your take is fantastic as well, I just scale Goodnight Punpun a little high.
The diff does say extreme :/
@@SoaringHigh2005 Extreme Diff (+), not extreme. My estimate is Extreme (-) to just Extreme.
@@basedcheese1 fair enough, both r goated though
@@SoaringHigh2005 Absolutely. Wild rides for both.
W edit but imo deuteragonist and conclusion goes to usogui
Yeah, conclusion could definitely go to Usogui. Deuteragonist was supposed to go to Usogui (as said in the pinned comment).
@@Zolaris-mx8lmBut Usogui isn’t even finished yet…
@@Athravdingledegenbutnotbased Yes it has? Usogui finished in 2017 (if I remember correctly).
@@Zolaris-mx8lm Nevermind it was a spinoff
@@Zolaris-mx8lm I’m still reading it
W edit , it was smooth. Conclusion to usogui.
Thanks + W take
W edit frfr🗣️
Thanks
I haven't read Goodnight Punpun, so I will say fax
You should, it's a good read
I have read many mangas and these two are the best ones to me. And seems like you have the same taste with me right there, Usogui is just a tiny bit better
Yeah, it seems so. These are my two favorite and highest rated mangas right now.
Thanks for the request
No problem
W edit+ fax
Thanks
W Edit bro 🔥🔥
Thanks
W, perfect diff
Tokyo ghoul victims
Thanks + Tokyo Ghoul is spectacular
-izers
@@ihavenoideaonanything “victim”
Naw I’ll say it more aot level then usogui or punpun
@@something3251 💀
w edit
Thanks
Usogui take conclusion + extreme diff[-]
Valid opinion
Song?
Crystal Castles Crimewave
w
Thanks
Whats goodnight punpun actually about can you tell me pls?
Goodnight Punpun is about a boy named Punpun Punyama. The whole manga follows the relationships Punpun has with his friends, family, and lovers. I would say the manga is worth going in as blind as possible, but that's just me.
Usogui negs
Yep, Usogui is just too peak
Punpun >
Fair. Out of curiosity, how would you change the category distribution?
Deuteragonist to punpun???
I was confused about this comment, because I could've sworn it went to Usogui, and then I watched the short and realized that I gave it to Goodnight Punpun by accident. So yeah, Usogui takes. Here's the rough (very rough) category distribution:
Introduction: Aiko
Conclusion: Aiko
Development: Kaji
Journey: Kaji
Depth of thought: Aiko
Character Depth: Kaji
Depth of themes: Aiko
Overall depth: Aiko
Complexity: Kaji
Themes: Aiko
Symbolism: Aiko
Philosophies: Kaji
Ideologies: Kaji
Parallels: Kaji
Psychological Accuracy: Kaji
Psychological Portrait: Kaji
Mentality: Kaji
Overall Psychology: Kaji
Narrative Impact: Kaji
Emotional Impact: Aiko
Overall Impact: Kaji
Backstory: Aiko
Emotions: Aiko
Motivation: Kaji
Goals: Kaji
Building: Kaji
Number of Peaks: Kaji
Highest Peak: Aiko
Overall Peaks: Kaji
Quotes: Kaji
Monologues: Kaji
Dialogues: Kaji
Interactions: Kaji
Side Dynamics: Kaji
Main Dynamic: Aiko
Overall Dynamics: Aiko
Consistency: Aiko
Three dimensionality: Kaji
Execution: Aiko
Characterization: Kaji
Compelling: Kaji
Overall Writing: Kaji
@@Zolaris-mx8lm thanks
@@dante_2831 No problem
Nah Pun Pun wins
High diff
W opinion. Would you change any of the category distribution?
Baku and souichi >>>>>>>>> god of writing fax : kratos is souichi victim
I haven't finished God of War, but for some reason I doubt Kratos is surpassing Souichi or Baku.
Kratos negs both
@@amtulsaboor3831 kiruma souichi solo beyond negative
@@amtulsaboor3831Souichi mid diffs
@@Toannguyen-lr6fk no he doesn't