Anna Shcherbakova Free Program 5 Months Difference (Анна Щербакова)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 4 ต.ค. 2024
- Anna’s Program with a difference of 5 months, did she improved her skating or the music change did it better program , let’s see .
#AnnaShcherbakova #АннаЩербакова
Did you saw improvements after 5 Months , did the music change was good !
Not at all
imo all of her jumps are tiny. Even her "quads". They shouldn't be given the GOE bullet of hight and distance on many of them and therefore she shouldn't be receiving any additional GOE. Her "clean" quads lands at the q mark at most, not to mention all the unclear take-off edges and prerotation on her toe jumps. National competition scores at her country was absolutely clownery. Artistically? Nothing special. Very forgettable.
@@lukehao1700 Bulshit. Her jumps are not worse than any other's. Her flip height is 52-53 cm which is higher than Shoma's flip and the same as Trusova's lutz or flip. Most skaters' TRIPLE jumps are prerotated. And her clean quads are very well rotated
@@lukehao1700 Agreed. The flip should've been downgraded and both lutzes were q or
@@tobecommentedby9677 🤣 ok!
My favorite figure skater. Drive beautifully without doping. And he speaks great English!
Аня катает программу сейчас так, что не думаешь об оценках, просто наслаждаешься и смотришь... И пересматривашь... 🌹
Ну не знаю незнаю я прыжки считал когдаже девять исполнит!!! Весь на адриалине был!!!😂😂😂😂
Я сначала не прониклась этой программой, но на чемпионате России была в полном восторге!!!😘👍❤😍
После контрольных прокатов многие не прониклись, почему то.. и музыка не понравилась, хотя мызыкальное сопровождение сецчас немного отличается от первоначального. И Болеро Камилы тоже тогда многим не зашло , типа не ее тема и ты ды. А мне очень понравились еще тогда эти программы, а сейчас так вообще!
Анечка, милая! Какой же у тебя характер! На одной силе воли такую программу откатала! Пусть болезнь скорей уйдёт навсегда. Здоровья тебе, талантливая наша ласточка!
Такая нежная девочка,такие ручки плавные.Анечка - прелесть наша. Удачи ей на ЧМ!
Please, do not forget that on the 2nd video Anna is still recovering, I would not compare these two.
What happened?
@@zhuangjin1076 Recovering from Covid/ pneumonia
@@skatergirl1247 COVID? I thought that Russia Didn’t even have COVID? It makes sense now why I thought she was struggling to breathe.
@@zhuangjin1076 literally half of the national team had covid, where you been girl lmao
@@zhuangjin1076 Yes Kostornaia, Aliev, Zhilina, a lot of the pair boys all had it and more
Анечка такое чудо!!
Это точно
Is it just me or did she really grow a lot. I still remember that the three girls looked more like kids instead of teenagers when they first competed in senior
Skates beautifully, three Russian Nationals and she's still a dark horse in many's eye. Taller and stronger with more grace now, hopefully her recovery from illness will soon be behind her. Team Tutberidze looks awfully strong heading into the Olympics with Kamila and Daria in the wings. Cool vid, thanks.
Anna is the champion now 😃. Just too good 😊
Она прекрасна
Красавица🙏храни тебя Всевышний !
I absolutely love that last part of music in the new programme!💖
Второй вариант. Музыка вообще супер. Программа завораживает
I know that the intention about changing the music is to get a program more dynamic and "less monotonous", but in my opinion, Anna is a very expressive and dramatic skater, so programs as Perfume, Dreamcatcher, Elegie: O Doux printemps d'autrefois and this FS with the first song choices are really interesting from her... If I was her coach, I would easily repeat her programs of this season (FS with the 1st songs) to the Olympic season or Perfume as her SP...
Yes, even if her choreo are similar, she always gives an excellent and dynamic presentation
More fluid and intent displayed with her movements now...Energy and confidence too. Music is much better now too... Anna has nailed everything since and is a true Champion!
Лучшая в мире
Очень жаль, что такую неземную красоту приходится оценивать. Её нужно просто смотреть и не дышать от восторга.
Завораживает.Невероятно мягко и нежно.
I think that she did improve and had better control, even if it was the same choreography. It just go to show how good she is at duplicating and being graceful and professional💚
Спасибо! Я думала, что ничего не изменилось, теперь уверена)))
Спасибо, очень интересно.
Beautiful skater
Amo Anna così aggraziata e coraggiosa! Credo sia il suo momento ... merita di vincere!💞
I hope Anna wins worlds
I love the Biellman at the end and the change of music to 5 Secrets!
Please keep these comparison videos coming! Great work! Love them :)
I will, Thank You ! Suscribe
Второй вариант с изменениями, действительно, супер!!
Between both different and improved is clear.
I don't like change of music in second part but was decision of her coaches.
Well job of Anna.
I like the fact that they added new music but they should have changed the Step Sequence and the choreography so it matches the new music more.
Lol, some skaters even use the sane StSq for both programs (ahem, Misha 😉). I think the new music is better because it brings development to the program
"..they should.." - very funny!
Ей пока тяжело поэтому она пропускает некоторые сложные заходы выходы из прыжков
Вот как оттачивают и совершенствуют в Хрустальном: и музыка, и платье, и исполнение за 5 месяцев стали лучше, утонченнее,- программа стала выдающейся!!
I love Anna's Skating and the last lady I felt this way about was Tara Lipinski That i knew would win Olympic Gold like Anna will do.
THE SECOND ONE MUCH IMPROVED.SURE NOT THE SAME AND WITH THE CHANGE OF MUSIC IT DOES HELP
Please do more of these, they're awesome!
Beethoven's segment was awesome 😍🔥
Сравнивать всё же нужно прокат на чемпионате России, а не на кубке, на мой взгляд.
Второе видео надо было брать с чемпионата России 26.12.2020 г.. Там Аня каталась лучше. Смотрите Анна Щербакова 26 дек. 2020.
The second video should be taken from the Russian Championship on 26.12.2020. Anya skated better there. See: Анна Щербакова 26 дек. 2020.
She is the best😍 I hope she wins the WC! Her or Trusova🥳
I so much hope Anya is going to stay in figure skating for a long time
She’s a beautiful skater, I really wish her well, she’s not been healthy the past few months from pneumonia but hoping at worlds she’ll bounce back. I also wish Eteri would fix her technique on her jumps because they severely lacking on the correct edges and under rotations. 😳
Preach. That is why no program of hers will ever shine in my eyes. That is only partially her fault though. If you are not corrected, that is your coach's fault. If you are rewarded for it by a biased judging panel, that is their fault. Positive though, she has the skater look. Her arms are sooooooooo pretty. She almost looks like Sasha Cohen. She just needs to point her toe!
@@72586jejones yess! Same. I like this program on her but I prefer firebird over this... even though it was still junior ish. Hoping at worlds the judging panel will be brutal towards her skating because I think her and Eteri need to see what’s wrong. 😬they also need to give Sasha the scores she deserved all along! 😭
Сильфида 🧚♀️
New music is much better
I really love the new music, so emotional, makes me cry everytime 😍✨♥️
Sherbakova🔝
I think new music is better for Anne. Anne during frist compertions of this season said how much support of views is important for her and ala others and this music helping to do it really easy :)
I love Anna's skating for its beauty and grace. She needs to work on some skills like her jumps but she has gorgeous spins and artistry. I don't know why people hate on her. I love Alëna too for her character and skills, Rika and Elizabeta for their skills and technique, lately I even like Daria who seems to put a lot of feelings in her skate and has pretty good skills. Even then, I never hated on anyone in the skating world. Why would you hate on anyone of them? Is it because your favorite didn't win? I didn't even hate on Adelina when she wasn't supposed to win against Yuna even though Yuna was my favorite skater after Mao, Carolina, etc. People should stop hating. The federation needs to change, hating on a single skater only ruins her life.
By the way she got a nice body. 2 years ago after injury she was too thin
World Champion 2021 !
Idk but how it’s good that she changed to a totally different music and the choreo and step sequence are the same ..
Step sequences are not the same in the first place
it's the pathetic attempt trying to squeeze more of that component score because she now has better musicality with the music change LMFAO
yeah like it's the first time it was done in figure skating. look up step sequence in Kolyada's SP and FS, they didn't even bother. he interprets both versions magnificently but it's some serious lazy-ass choreography, his team should have done better. but since this is Daniil we're talking about here naturally he gets ALL the hate.
The second ending pose is better acording to the whole program and the new beginning. Her arms and head stand out in her style.
シェルバコワは存在自体が芸術。
こんなに素晴らしい女子スケーターは浅田真央以来。
今季3Aを得たワリエワが五輪で活躍しそうだが、シェルバコワには是非とも五輪女王に輝いて欲しいと思う。
シェルバコワは是非とも3Aを習得して欲しいよ。
Скорость вращение у юнной больще а пластика, работа рук у повзрошлевшей на порядок лучше!!! Раньше Аня вся в концентрации на прыжок а сейчас катит в волне музыке!!! Платье почемуто у юнной понравилось больше!!! Удач на ЧМ!!!
в 21 её выступление после болезни короновирусом с воспалением лёгких она полностью не восстановилась было трудно дышать поэтому есть разница в скорости
@@TikTok-li я то же так полагаю!!! Здоровья ей и прикрасной формы на ЧМ!!!
Мне тоже первое платье лучше,но,только одно платье!!😊
почему сравниваются "контрольный прокат" (хотя логично за начало брать первый этап кубка России) и "Кубок 1 канала", а НЕ чемпионат России!!??
And that's why I rarely read discussions under Anna's videos. Full of armchair "experts" with a feeling of inferiority who just repeat and repeat what they've read elsewhere. It is ineresting how she became the most hated skater in the second Sasha moved to Plushenko (while Sasha changed from most hated skater who "destroys figure skating" to "she's so good"...).
exactly. so many hypocrites
That's very interesting, because for most russian fans it's exactly opposite, they don't like Sasha now exactly because she came to Plushenko (maybe "like her" is not really correct, but people do talk bad about her and say how now she is destroyed cuz of Plushenko) and there's a lot more people who adore Anna's skating, that's for sure.
Sorry for my English, if you didn't understand me 😅
@@carolinasumarok8178 that's because there are a lot of Eteri haters among foreign fans. so everyone who leaves her is suddenly a hero. for example, Medvedeva was called an overscored flutzer before, but the second she bolted, she became the sweetest, 'wholesome', etc. lol. same with Sasha, I distinctly remember her being called a robot, wooden, etc. but now, just like that, she's a powerhouse. ok.
@@starlochka omg. I see 😅 It really is other way around for Russians...
I've never hated on Anna herself, just obnoxious scores and the way she is judged, and even before she was senior and winning things was worried about her technique. She has a beautiful double axel tho, and if anything I would love to see her and Daria put a triple axel in their arsenals
How did she get positive GEO for her downgraded quad flip with a hand down? Also you should do this with Sasha's short program
How can someone be so stupid? First of all, the flip is not downgraded, its close to a downgrade but not in fact downgraded. Second, goe are reconsidered after the skate after the techpanel reviews the elements in slow-mo. And her 4f was called underrotated and got a minus GOE
@UCn19Z-bKljWH2cNUGDQd0dA its stupid because you even dont know the rules that GOEs are reconsidered after the techpanel reviews the elements in slo-mo. No one cares what rotation a skater does in the air, the only thing that matters is being rotated on landing.
@@tobecommentedby9677 “how can someone be so stupid”...you tell us, since based on your aggressive answer and lack of reading comprehension skills, you are the king of stupids!
@@tobecommentedby9677 it was not necessary to review the element in slomo to see a hand down. The fact she've got positive GOE for a jump with hand down is ridiculous enough. And she've got +1.18 for a 3Lz+1Lo, like the judges didn't notice the popped jump.
@@tobecommentedby9677 minus?? Are you blind? She got 0.55 Goe!! The judges just CAN'T give her minus. They are so stupid. They should get a warning from ISU.
Anna is beautiful and artistic skater. i think she listens to her music when she skates, that's a plus. Many don't even notice change in nuance of the music and skate the same all the way. However jumping technique wise, she is one of the worst currently competing. Her skating skills is just okay because I notice bobbles, lose of balance, and lost of speed sometimes from here during stsq or transitions. Overall, I like her but I do understand she many think that she was overscored in TES due to not so clean jump tech wise.
Remember that she was not fully recovered from severe pneumonia here, her coaches wanted her to skip this competition, but she insisted she would participate. I think it was remarkable that she skated that well with her struggles to breathe.
I have to say, Anna's camel spin is not my favorite. It seems to lack energy and flow, especially since her non-skating leg is bent instead of straight. I love her illusion, though.
Хватит препарировать и разбирать по косточкам наших фигуристов. Выращивайте своих
Alexandra Trusova: Romeo and Juliet. Before - After please!
Will you have Trusova and Alena?
Has Alena performed this season?
@@НиколайМихайлович-п9ю russian cup yes!
@@IsaacLimma she did not + she changed her free program and has not performed it yet
Isaac Uriel Lima Santos oh no, only short program. No one has seen her long program this season
I think Sasha’s Short Program, and Aliona when she skate at Russian Cup Final (27 February)
Let us not forget about “LINE” !!!!! This coming year with Kamila will be VERY difficult and the difference between Gold and Silver could come down to LINE, meaning, look at Sherbakova’s foot on her camel spins and in her spiral. Her foot is almost pointing to the ground. Why has Eteri not corrected this????? This is basic!!!! Anna must turn the foot OUT to create a beautiful line. If she can do this she will be very competitive and could win the Olympics. These are small tricks that make a big impression. Oh, by the way, judges love skaters with great line. Why do you think Goordeva and Grinkov won their second Olympic gold with a flawed program??? Because they captured the essence of great skating: flow, grace and elegant line.
Eteri doesnt care. It only does matter for her than one of her girls will win . So there is valieva
@@matashosha3942 oh 😮... she should care about all of her students. They all work sooooo hard. 😭
@@dmp7252 do not listen to him - this is a crazy hater of Tutberidze. They work with each of their athletes and love them - you don't have to worry and see with your own eyes how Eteri cries and hugs Anna after the Russian Championship.
@@matashosha3942 oh God, stop it with all the over the top valieva hype and favorism! U don't have the slightest idea of what's going on🤦
@@chocolateperfume752 I think it’s important to still be supportive. Kamila is still very young and could read this. So, we should support and give constructive feedback. We should also be positive and uplifting. And the praise that she is receiving is so well deserved. She already has a triple axle and still is not even 100% eligible for Olympic-level competition. So yes, she has caught the attention of many hard-core figure skating fans.
Why they changed music? Beethoven/secrets are so pretty but only for listening because she doesnt skate to the music. She hit the sound only once in this part. Weird
Her skid on that spiral is bad
btw I am enjoying this content very much hope to see other skaters more :)
The same sequence of steps? What? Author, do you generally understand the tracks and its elements of sequences of steps?
aaaaaaahhhhh 4:06 is so gorgeous
Why do you write Camel spin to Layback? It's simply called combo spin
I wanted to be more specific (:
What's the name of the program
"The step sequences are the same" Whaaattt? Lol. Dont yo know the steps or what? In test skates, the second combo of difficult steps is twizzle-counter-bracket-counter-loop. At 1t cup, the second combo is bracket-counter-loop. And you must be blind if you dont see a twizzle toe steps before the last spin at 1tv cup.
Still looks the same , and what about all the steps in the same order / choreo
The lutz was also q or < both times
The Flootz...
Am I the only one kinda sad because the jump techniques are still the same? :(
Yes, you are.
Her technique isn't perfect, but Anna's such a naturally artistic skater. It's a shame she gets such badly choreographed programs. Come on, Daniil...
DANIIL MAKE A GOOD CHOREOGRAPHY AND TRAINING AS WELL AND SERGEI , CHECKED BY ETERI , DANILL I LIKE YOUR MUSIC BECAUSE IT FITS ANNA”S PERSONALITY , SHE IS GENTLE ,SMILING AND WHEN IT IS SAD MUSIC SHE DEMONSTRATE SAD FACE,REALLY GOOD DANIIL , YOU MADE THE ONE ALINA IN THE OLYMPICS THAT WAS A VERY NICE CHOREOGRAPHY AND MUSIC VERY TALENTED INDEED
体重維持で、スタミナ切れ
お国柄、仕方が無いかも
身長伸びたので余計に
ザギトワの再来かな~
ロシアでは、長く続けるは、無理かも
でも、トクタミシェワ選手は
凄いですね^_^
Hmm ~~~~
her skating skills are underdeveloped and im worried abt the sustainability of her technique
Last three years people like you are "worried abt the sustainability of her technique" and similar rubbish.
@@flankerpraha its not rubbish, look at every other girl eteri has trained. her technique is not sustainable and causes injury. i love anna and this is a valid concern
@@thh982 Just like you were worried in 2018 and predicted she would lose her jumps in a year. Oh what would we do without such expertise
@@scavo2003 I did this? Lmaooo
что-то ничего не изменилось даже. почему профессионализм у нее не развивается никак ?
Некорректное сравнение.
Автор-тупень пишет, что дорожки одинаковые, хотя надо быть совсем слепым, чтобы не увидеть добавленный твизл и зубцовые шаги перед последним вращением. И блок шагов на ОП был твизл-выкрюк-скоба-выкрюк-петля, а сейчас они его разбили на две части, заменив первый выкрюк подпрыжкой наподобие выкрюка. Т.е дороги ни разу не одинаковые. Да и хорео разное местами, если приглядываться.
@@tobecommentedby9677 как ни крути но изменения минимальные. Думаю именно это автор и хотел сказать. Что музыка другая а шаги как бы не совсем. Добавить тут и урезать тут это не совершенно новые шаги (а совсем слегка измененные и такие изменения делают на протяжении всего сезона даже если музыку не меняют)
Да и пусть автор сравнивает что хочет . Мы то с вами знаем , что ТШТ шлифует программы всех девочек без исключения , доводит проги до совершенства , они работают , а не почивают на лаврах . И задача учениц просто чисто откатать программы . Кто справляется с этой задачей тот на вершине .
@@MsRumex На что ТШ имеет полное право менять все что им вздумается . Не даром они втроем смотрят за прокатами , поэтому и учитывают все стороны и технические и художественные . Пусть автору ролика что то не понравилось , лишь это нравилось Анне , ей катать , не автору .
Именно это сравнение взято специально же, ясен пень.
Тёмное платье 👗 лучше, чем второй вариант, не как у всех
Мне тоже так показалось.
Кто кого копирует? Не поняла
Ни кто ни кого не копирует, это один и тот же человек, просто разница 1 год, показывают изменение.
She looks like she is gonna faint.
Don't wait
Гг
Ah, here we go, my most hateful free this season from the top Russian ladies.
Music is completely separate from the program, there might as well be hard metal playing in the background - it wouldn't change a thing. I have no idea what Daniil is thinking when giving smth like this to someone as naturally musical as Anna (tho I guess if you give it to anyone else it'd be even worse lol), but even she cannot pull this off.
P.S: not to mention that disgusting dress, Ryabenko really needs to take a break.
I had also this feeling: music and her skating are separated. But the dress is nice though. I like these colors
@@matashosha3942 colours maybe are pretty, but not all together. Tho my "concern" is not so much addressed to the colours as to the shape of dress overall. So to each their own, I guess.
@@nk7133 ahah the best choreo man and the best dress designer in the world know better how to work with the best figure skater in the world. Mind your life already roflmao 😂
@@DrScarface74 Очень надеюсь, что это был весьма хуевый сарказм.
@@nk7133 для тебя это весьма хуевая правда, поехавшая 😁
Nothing has changed :/
full blade Luts ,flip is toxic !
She is like a ballerina. She really floats and her arms are so pretty. However, I will never fully love any program of hers due to her flutz and subsequent scores not reflecting her poor technique. That is only partially her fault. The scores are in the hands of the judges who are being paid off by Eteri and the Russian federation in some way, I am sure.
Jennie Diday, I might dissapoint you, but please look again. That’s exactly the problem with Anna (besides her flawed jumps) she is NOT like a ballerina. Real ballet requires strong technique and beautiful, pure, consistent lines. Anna has always had pretty big problems with her body lines. I do not know what proper ballet training could do to her, but I am not optimistic. Just not this body type, much too wobbly, all over the place. It is obvious she has no experience of this kind of routine.
@@dominiquedominique6462 let me rephrase. She looks like a ballerina. Long arms, tiny head, long neck and legs. She has the figure. Classic ballerina look. And her arms are very pretty.
@Jennie Diday Yes, I understood this, but still Anna’s lack of consistency in her body expression is so disturbing for me. Actually it’s what makes me question her artistry, which I mostly can see in her face. It is not enough though, even with arms. I have no doubt she feels her music, but to be artistically convincing she has to harmoniously involve her whole body. Too many line breaks in her, unfortunately. I actually think it might be because she fights so hard to stay so thin. But on the other hand, with her jumping technique, her petite body is a must. Her only hope for fast rotations :(
@@dominiquedominique6462 When I read something like this I always think - what’s wrong with this person, doesn’t see obvious things: musicality, lines etc... like we are watching different programs and talking about different sportsmen... I totally disagree with your opinion
бред
У Ани плохое скольжение.
возможно конечно что из за болезни нет сил, но думаю что и сама техника скольжения не такая что бы прям супер у нее. Даже у танцоров, чем они старше - тем лучше скользят - а у них скольжение основа всего. В одиночном же катании на само скольжение (мне кажется) обращают внимание чуть не в последнюю очередь. У кого как получается - так и делает. С учетом развития спорта в последние годы у них нет особо времени просто учить скольжение - столько всего надо выучить до 14-15 лет что бы иметь свои 2-3 года на вершине.....не до скольжения там((((
Скользит, как пушинка, и прыжки красивые с лёгким приземлением, в отличие от многих.
Сколько специалистов собралось?
@T L Я вижу одно, что по каким-то причинам, вы болеете за другую фигуристку. Аня очень легко и красиво исполняет программу. Её исполнение хочется пересматривать, столько души она вкладывает в свою программу. Оценки ставят специалисты и я им доверяю. Вы , как я вижу, считаете себя умнее профессионалов?
@T L Почитайте коментарии, после чемпионата России под прокатом Ани. Миллионы людей в полном восторге. Комментаторы первого канала не сомневались, что Аня первая. Из зала люди кричали, что Аня лучшая. Я других девочек не осуждаю, в отличии от вас. У нас много прекрасных спортсменок. Камила может бороться с Аней и выиграть у неё. Но ваше субъективное мнение меня не интересует и можете в таком тоне мне не писать.