Question to Schools Minister about teaching of gender ideology in schools
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 มี.ค. 2022
- In Education Select Committee I asked the Minister for Schools Robin Walker about the government's guidance on the promotion of gender ideology in schools, in light of the publication of the Interim Report of the Cass Review,.
I can absolutely assure you that the situation in schools is MUCH worse than these MPs realise. It is taken as granted that students are a new gender if they say so and to use pronouns. Also, why on earth are we teaching gender reassignment when it is illegal for kids to be mutilated?
By his same logic we should also be teaching about detransitioners.
Very true. What they are teaching in schools has no balance. They need to know ALL the facts and side effects of dangerous drugs and surgeries.
Agreed. They are an inconvenient reminder of where this ideology fails.
@@creativelady882 nothing about hormones is dangerous
No. The fight must be to have any and all 'teaching' about gender issues removed from the classroom. Fighting to have teachings about detransitioners added to an already unsuitable topic serves only to legitimize the ideologists claims and agendas.
@@SydneyScream There are lots of things about hormones that are dangerous.
Miriam I applaud you, thank you for raising this! I don't think the minister understands as much about the issue as he thinks he does.
This is the problem, no debate has made the masses ignorant of the details of how harmful this ideology is
More and more children are becoming confused about sex as a result of all this fuss. Formerly it was just a tiny percentage of unbalanced young people and there has never been any need to address the issue in the classroom unless the intention was (as I believe it was) to bring even more chaos into society. Let schools educate our young people as they used to, aiming for high academic standards where appropriate and teaching creative, technical and practical subjects so that their pupils will be fitted for the world of work when they leave.
One of the primary reasons why this ideology has been able to spread so quickly and embed itself into law and in the classroom is because these politicians simply don't know what the hell they are talking about. That would be understandable if you are just an average person because there is deliberate obfuscation of the language surrounding this issue, but if you are in a position of authority to dictate what is being taught in schools, it is unforgivable.
If kids are being taught that everyone has a gender identity (ie gendered soul) that can exist anywhere on a never ending spectrum, that is an ideology. If kids are being taught that they can be a girl stuck in a boy's body or vice versa, that is an ideology. If kids are being taught that trans is an identity and not a mental disorder (gender dysphoria), that is an ideology. These ideas have no basis in science. Without social engineering, clinically diagnosed gender dysphoria is so rare that many people would never even meet a child who has it. Ten years ago, it would have been bizarre to even tell a child about transgenderism because it was understood as a rare, psychological phenomenon
Thank you very much for standing up for children in his way. We work with the families who have been let down by those schools which have allowed gender ideology to be taught as if it were fact. Your grasp of this particular brief is excellent and we are very grateful that you choose to share it with colleagues. Hopefully, we can see better protections for vulnerable children soon. You are definitely helping that day arrive.
Thank you for all you do supporting families through this nightmare!
Thank god this is being brought to light how did we get to a point where doctors teachers are helping harm our children ....
He said people do 'transistion ' that's impossible the body is surgically and medically altered that does not equal any transition ??? Doh
Thank you Miriam. It worries me greatly that no-one is checking what schools are teaching children with regard to gender ideology. Gavin Williamson was warned about this and he did nothing.
Thank you Miriam. Brilliantly argued.
Thank you Miriam. So nice to see another MP who totally ‘gets it’. Brilliant questions and the Minister really should study this issue in detail.
150% behind you. We need to have more brave women and men who speak UP. Politicians are so terrified of this subject. We need to protect women's rights and safeguard our young people. Thank you!
They aren't terrified they just support the redefining of objective reality and this is where it starts...
At last a well informed and educated individual who's not afraid to speak the truth and speak on behalf the majority of the worlds population.
Thank you Miriam for standing up for children. Children cannot give informed consent full stop. They do not have the mental capacity to make life changing adult decisions. Children have the right to a childhood.
100 %
Miriam Cates so at 6:00 you uncovered that the Minister for Schools has a confused understanding of sex and gender!
Thank you for your commitment to safeguarding children
Followed the link from a depraved 50-60 year old man dressed as a school girl that posts selfies in women’s changing rooms calling this woman a “bigot.” I never realised how many men are desperate to access these spaces. This is going to be so harmful. I have two daughters.
AGPs are having a great time with all this
Thank you Miriam for asking this very important question.
Thank you for speaking up Ms Cates 👍🏻
Thank you, it's good to see an MP who isn't either totally under-researched and ignorant about this issue, or just a total coward, too scared of twitter mobs to state facts. It's a bit depressing that you stand out from the crowd as your level of knowledge and courage should be standard among the leaders of our institutions and our lawmakers, but it's not. Keep on keeping on, we need you.
Thank you for sticking your head above the parapet and stating biological facts
Thank you for this. Schools, when approached on this issue, say they are NOT teaching an ideology but just teaching children to "be kind".
Clever, isn't it...all thought through by those with their devious Gender Agendas, none of whom should be anywhere near children. All teachers should be speaking out against this and refusing to deliver these shocking lies to the children who are supposed to be in their care.
@@LizzieCornish If we are to stop telling children lies, we have to drop religion too. Excellent suggestion.
There's a child in my daughter's class that has said boys can be girls. I have asked her headmistress about this. She's going to talk to me and I hope she says they will not be doing that in school(primary) Thanks for stating facts. It's rare. He was obviously afraid of offending someone. Losing his job. Biology should be taught in school at an age appropriate level, nothing else. If parents want to confuse their kids unnecessarily they can. My daughter said "that's not true" and she got that message from me, or just cause it's easier to understand.
Thank you Mariam! Robin please please read the cass review, and listen to some of the detransitioners accounts, they are real and their view matters.
You are fantastic please keep speaking up
Thank you. So clear. I can share this with the leaders in my workplace.
Thankyou Miriam, well said
Thank you so much Miriam, for having the guts to address this massively important issue when everyone else is shying away from it!
The schools minister is surely aware that the protected characteristic doesn’t apply to children (under 18s), in the same way that discrimination for pregnancy/maternity doesn’t apply to a anyone not unemployment.
The GRA is inadequate in its definitions but you cannot apply the GRC to under 18s.
Yes but they don’t care a lot of these so called are not conservatives they are pretty much centre left Blairites tbh
They agree with nonsense don’t be fooled the conservatives have a 80 seat majority they have had covid and now a war they could do away with most of this transgender nonsense if they wanted to with out much notice
THEY don’t want to
Thank you!
We need more of this. Well done
This Minister needs to shut up. We're it not for Gender IDEOLOGY no one would be talking about trans people at all. It is a politicised issue 100% which is why it is so tribal.
.. it is actually anti the family and everyone knows it...you. cannot b/s me. All you can tell us women, the majority of mothers in this world, is to shut up. Well we give birth to and raise kids so you shut up and we will have our say. Delia Morris
Thank you
Thank you Miriam
Absolute shero!
In other words we are going to do nothing to clarify/get hold of this issue. Disgraceful, and the abusive medicalisation of children goes unchecked because those who believe in this ideology are exploiting those grey areas/ambiguities. They aren't waiting to find out what the guidance is. Good on Miriam for at least highlighting the issue.
How can sex be a protected characteristic, if one can simply identify in or out of whichever they like?
Thank you for standing for truth!!! And for protecting our kids! We're going to have a huge number of tragically mutilated and dysfunctional young adults in the very near future demanding to know why more people didn't stand up against these lies!
It’s amazing how MPs can say so much without saying much at all, he is completely avoiding answering whether they will clarify that this damaging ideology can not be taught in schools. He is a disgrace, stumbling all over his words and trying to slither out of doing anything, she did such a good job of not letting him get away with it so easily.
What hope is there when men like him don't grasp the basic fact that you cannot change your sex. Many of us have messed around with the face we present to the world at different times of our lives. As for lifting weights meaning you might be a bloke - where do they find these ideas ?
What needs to happen is a safe space for teachers to discuss this without fear of backlash or harassment. I’m willing to bet that if this is being taught in some schools that there are teachers who are teaching it unwillingly and that’s a problem in of itself.
While I respect you trying to support safeguarding and woman’s rights it was the conservative government who brought in mandatory sex education and the fact that the woke bloke argues that you can change sex tells you all you need to know
Their is a reason why home education is ok the rise
If sex education was not now mandatory this would not be a issue because schools would have to be moderate in their teaching or face a empty sex education
You have a 80 set majority conservatives have given us mandatory sex education
Men in woman’s jails
And mixed sex toilets bravo
But isn't the right answer.
Thank you for bringing this to Robin's attention Miriam but I still think he doesn't get it! It's also way past the time that Stonewall was stopped from influencing the education of our children. Their job was done once same sex marriage was passed into law so rather than keep representing LGB people they tagged on the T and it's been nothing but trouble since.
Does Robin realise that Stonewall now say it's transphobic for gay men to have no trans men in their dating pool and for lesbians to have to consider trans women? I think you should inform him.
Miriam Cates should be Secretary of State for Education.
If schools are going to include the concept of "transgender" in the curriculum then they MUST ensure that all lesson plans and teaching materials are in line with the latest guidance from the Department for Education. For example: "You should not reinforce harmful stereotypes, for instance by suggesting that children might be a different gender based on their personality and interests or the clothes they prefer to wear. ... Teachers should not suggest to a child that their non-compliance with gender stereotypes means that either their personality or their body is wrong and in need of changing." For more details see www.transgendertrend.com/department-for-education-rse-guidance-schools/
Care in the Community has a lot to answer for.
Can this man speak a single sentence in one try?
Thank god for this wonderful woman. This is a massive problem for young people. Why do they need to be taught anything about the concept of gender? Developing children are already having an identity crisis as they grow into adulthood and they should be left alone. Transitioning should be for adults only. A conservative government should do everything it can to promote a natural childhood with an education consisting of facts.
Truth is there is no transition!
This guy makes my blood boil. Its pure child abuse and he thinks it's ok
He is disturbingly out of touch
This guy honestly. Yeah obviously totally clueless of what is happening. It’s not about mental health, it’s about children having sex reassignment surgeries and taking hormones that cause irreparable harm and sterility.
Which begins with a Mental Health issue. If the Mental Health issues were address correctly and handled in the right way then we would not reach the stage of reassignment surgery or hormone taking.
Try and get the order of things right in your mind before you start accusing others of being clueless.
Mmm - does he actually understand that you cannot change sex. I'm not sure. And that is a major issue.
ANY teacher teaching gender is normal as with homosexuality must be sacked.
'I'm happy to look at the Cass report' He hasn't read it.
Respecting differences is very different to encouraging them. There should be no place in schools for any kind of gender spectrum.
As the minister said, schools should teach facts.
The facts are clear, there are male and female, men and women, girls and boys - no spectrum, no non-binary. There is a case that gender dysphoria is an issue and should be addressed, but in the right way. That right way is to take it out of schools and into Mental Health services so that those affected can be helped and supported.
Why are sex and gender being taught at all in the schools. When I was in school we were not taught any of this stuff and it did me no harm.
Uh uh ooooooo ooooo uh uh uh uh eh eh eh eh eh uh uh uh uh....
I don’t believe it is the schools responsibility to take on gender dysphoria in pupils , that is over each completely by the schools . If the child has such extreme mental disorders why is that anything to do with the school. Aren’t we seeing a complete abrogation of responsibility by parents for their children , and said children should be taken out of the school completely and the medical profession should be involved. If I were a teacher I wouldn’t want the responsibility of affirming or otherwise a confused child , it is total over each of that teacher’s responsibilities, and one can only make really unpleasant assumptions regarding why they are doing this …
Prison for anyone talking to other people's kids about sex..outside of reproduction a teacher has absolutely no reason at all to talk to someone else's child about any kind of sex Or sexuality..its child abuse
If children can be persuadef to consent to gender change can they be persuaded to engage in other "intetgenerational activities".,Consent is being made nuanced and more fluid,,?
He knows he is lying
Miriam Cates for Prime Minister
These entitled title holders are asleep
Teach kids in an approprite way? Who decides what is appropriate? You have to write down specifically what can and can't be taught or the teachers who have drunk the koolaid will just keep on indoctrinating.
It looks like this guy has a family member who is lgbtq that is why. Or he doesn't have kids of his own.
Why should we talk and teach about the radical ideologies of a group that make up a minuscule fraction of our population. Children need to be taught about things that will be of value to their futures not left wing ideologies. These things have no place in schools. Keep up the good fight.
Tim nice but dim, just doesnt get it.
were teaching facts..... so men can become women is a fact? LOL
Miriam is what we need in this country, before we rapidly reach American issues and standards in schools and society
Thank you Miriam
This guy makes my blood boil. Its pure child abuse and he thinks it's ok
This guy makes my blood boil. Its pure child abuse and he thinks it's ok