Indonesians React To Their Capital City Sinking & Flooding | ASIAN BOSS
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ต.ค. 2024
- Did you know that Jakarta, the capital of Indonesia, is sinking faster than any other city in the world because of drilling for drinking water, the weight of its skyscrapers and rising sea levels? The problem has gotten so bad that the Indonesian government recently proposed to relocate the capital elsewhere, which is kind of a big deal. But how do the people of Indonesia feel about this potential move? Are they for or against this proposal? We hit the streets of Jakarta to find out.
The opinions expressed in this video are those of individual interviewees alone and do not reflect the views of ASIAN BOSS or the general Indonesian population.
Special thanks to our Asian Boss team in Jakarta, Indonesia.
Ramzy (Reporter)
Instagram ► / ramzyasmoro
Ryan (Videographer)
Instagram ► / ryanmelandie
Tina (Host)
Instagram ► / tiinamina_
Our vision is to build a lasting grassroots movement of young people from every country to report on real social and cultural issues. We believe having meaningful discussions with people with different opinions is extremely important.
For business or media inquiries, reach out to us at inquiries@asianboss.io
Reach out to our founders, Stephen and Kei, directly if you have any questions, feedback or suggestions:
Stephen on Twitter ► / theasianboss
Stephen on Instagram ► / theasianboss
Kei on Instagram ► / asianbossk
Are you curious about real people's perspectives from Asia on various cultural and social issues? Subscribe to ASIAN BOSS for more informative and thought-provoking videos ► goo.gl/TRcSbE
#Jakarta #Globalwarming #AsianBoss
You can't run a country if your desk and computer are underwater. If Indonesia does not move the capital they should rename Jakarta to Atlantis.
Lebay amat! 😁
We can if we are aquaman
haha
Then you will destroy kalimantan forest
Hahahahahaha I died, and i am Indonesian dude and I fully agree with you
Finally Asian Boss come up with other issues about Indonesia rather than religion issues. Good move Asian Boss
Yeah, I'm really interested in listening to people talk about climate change.
🤔 You and the 200 people that liked this have some very selective memories...
Look at their uploads... I stopped looking at 5 but I'm sure if I keep scrolling back through their uploads I'll eventually find a religion focused video...
@@mangomonster5296 yes it is because in Indonesia have blasphemy law. People are afraid to talk about this kind of issues. You can go to jail if some people think you blaspheme their religion. They prefer to talk safely rather than talk according to what they think.
So true, hehe
Don't listen to this guy. Please make more religious issues videos.
Even if Indonesia relocates its capital city elsewhere, Jakarta will still be overcrowded. This is due to the fact that most of Indonesia's economic wealth is concentrated in Jakarta. If Indonesia evenly spread out its economic wealth to other parts of the country, then Jakarta would no longer be overcrowded.
Yep, There will be no dramatic changes at all
At least we're trying to reducing it by move the Capital to the another land .
If not doing anything its gonna be more worse.
And we don't have anything or alternative if always in Jakarta.
And move the Capital isnt about Jakarta but for equitable development
Matt Reeves Relocating Indonesia's capital city alone will not solve Jakarta's overcrowding problem. The best solution is for every province in Indonesia to be as wealthy and developed as Jakarta.
Bandung, Surabaya and Palembang are also a better option to make new economic centers.
My life is still sinking faster than Jakarta
Well...what else did you expect with such a hideous face...???
Lol xD
sad story. i like it! (plus 1)
Can I call you moanbean
@@uttisiseppe769 can i call you brown banana?
It'd be interesting to hear the opinion of Indonesians outside of the capital city too, since this is a project that affects them differently than it affects those in Jakarta.
Agree
The funny thing is the interview is not in Jakarta
It’s in Depok, lmao. A city which neighboring Jakarta.
@@momon4868 How do you know?
@@lavidawithjoey the interview took place in university of indonesia library in depok
off topic.
being a filipino and watching this, it is really weird hearing them speak. It's like you're familiar with the sound of their words but you can't really understand what they say.
Neighbor. Austronesian.
I feel the same when I'm hearing someone speaks Tagalog. It's like, "is this an Indonesian local language that I don't even know it exists?"
@@falah5122 well, some indonesian tribes who live in small islands arround sulawesi have the same language and culture with philipino.
I think we have the same ancestor, because we used Sanskrit/sangsakerta. And tagalog are kinda use the same pattern of naming system.
But unfortunately sanskrit are forgotten by a lot of poeple, as our education system didn't teach it. And a lot of people Filipino still use devrided spanish language in their use of word, but indonesian can't speak Dutch, it's a wasted opportunity for us, it would be cool if we can. Because my grand grandparent can speak dutch well. But wr can't.
Me to bro... Im indonesian. i went to philipine when i hear tagalog it feel femiliar like im still in indonesia... I love philipine....
Ibu kota pindah pun Jakarta gak akan sepi. Malah akan semakin ramai karena Jakarta akan jadi pusat pergerakan ekonomi. Keuntungan lain adalah dengan terpusatnya ibu kota di Kalimantan mendorong daerah selain 'Jawa' ikut berkembang juga. Ya pasti banyak ngabisin uang. Tapi 10-20 tahun kedepan sih akan bagus hasilnya.
Turki mindahin ibukotanya dari istanbul ke ankara ga pernah sepi tuh istanbul
bener, karna tujuan utamanya adalah mengamankan ibu kota negara(pusat pemerintahan) dari bahaya alam yang sangat besar nantinya
Good one dude...
Sayangnya kl itu benar cuma saya gak kebagian ngerasain manisnya projek tersebut :) dam
@@CarsOliver she is not a dude.
Nice choice of place to interview people. The Library of UI attracts open-minded people
So true bro. Can't agree more with you. They're smart and open minded people
yeah, it gets a much better responses than doing it on public places which is a pretty sad truth about our country's mindset tbf
Ah biasa aja, ngga ada yg bermutu semua yg di interview cara pikirnya masih kaya orang biasa.
@@momon4868 liat vid yg soal poligami, parah itu
@@momon4868 Hhh. Gak bisa bedain. Noh lihat yg Poligami. Banyak yg masih kurang paham agama.
Yes, as a commuter the traffic in Jakarta is wasting around 3-4 hours of your life everyday, your life is wasted on these roads..
Same in manila ph man
Is Jakarta good to visit as a tourist?
@@irememberla6460 No lmao, why would you come to indo to visit jakarta.
Lol come to India then
...🤣🤣
Twitter use goes through the roof at these times.
why I'm even reading the subtitle, I'm Indonesian :/
True 🤣
Me too 😂😂😂
Same lol
If this ain’t me 😂
me too, it feels like a habit i afraid lmao
now this is better topic to talk from indonesia, good job asian boss
True true
Why is it a better topic?
@@jcv1564 it's the first time they do interview aside religion matters
N A Alright but that doesn't make either topic better or worse, they're both things that are interesting to think and hear about.
@@jcv1564 there is blasphemy law in Indonesia. People prefer to talk safely rather than talk according to what they think. You can go to jail if someone feel offended and report it to the the authority.
Unlike that capital, my capital is just fine. No overcrowding, rising sea levels, or traffic what so ever. A city of three million without traffic, great civil engineering
You can barely find anyone in Pyongyang
Congratulations to you supreme leader!
Lets invade Pyongyang :p
Is it really you??
Subhajit Pradhan Yes it is.
Finally asian boss, the topic that really “in” today in indonesia
Climate change isn't hoax. Just think at how ice age can be done. It's nature we can't stop it. But human now do is speed it up.
Maybe earth need hundred years to melt some ice in south or north pole. But human did it in a few decade.
As Indonesian I support this plan. But in really great plan. I wont to see next Jakarta. The city should have a good plan in any aspects.
There's is some misconceptions that melting polar has effect on the rising sea level, which is false. The rising level is from ice on land entering the ocean.
Or speed it up faster so we can experience another ice age with the stoppage of the exchange of warm and cold water because of the low salinity, then land will start to rise again and Europe and America would be a cold wasteland and the equator would be HOT AF forests.
@@jameschristophercirujano6650 sounds great, what is the last time in history before the gulf-stream that hits europe?
@@joemuis23 I think it was around 20-40k years ago.
@@TimeManInJail Depend, if the polar ice sit on some underwater structure it will affect the sea level. Only the floating ice won't which is mostly in the north pole. The south pole is a different thing.
I am surprised by fact that many of the interviewees (who seems to be young and well educated) don’t even get their facts right. It really shows how ignorant we are about this issue. The sea level rises around Jakarta Bay Area is not 1cm per year.. it’s 25cm or approximately 10 inches per year. The issue of relocation of The Capital has been raised up since the era of President Soekarno in 1957, not since SBY era. Other countries did their extreme in preventing global climate change. Many had switch to zero waste living. So many environmental activists (mostly expatriates) do beach cleaning in Bali and around our country but we as citizens couldn’t even do the simplest thing: throw our garbage in the garbage bin. Let’s not only talk about long terms solutions. Let’s talk about the present. I mean.. with previous Governor (Ahok) we enjoyed several years of flood-free city.. Can we at least simply copy paste and maintain that level of cleanliness. Stop talking only on macro level. Those are the duties of our government. The only thing you can do, is choose the people that are concerned about environmental issues. But what about the little thing? Less plastic usage, learn to recycle, again... throw your garbage in it’s proper place. Educate yourself. Please. It is impacting our lives in much sooner and greater than you think it is.
I agree with you, they are quite ignorant about these problem, because this is not a simple problem and they should interview people specifically who know the problem/ or people who study it, not random people.
And i agree ahok are doing a great job when he is in the government, I'm not sure about this new Governor, anies.
And
Neither do your facts about sea level rise is true. It is not true that sea level rise happening at Jakarta is 25 cm per year ( educate yourself about scientific fact from science journal and not from news portal). You have to distinguish between sea level rise and land subsidence. Sea level rise may vary each location from 0.5 - 4 cm per year. The other factor why jakarta is sinking, because significant rate of land subsidence 1 - 15 cm per year. NOTE THAT it happen in certain area, and each area get different rate of subsidence. Correct me if i am wrong.
My point is, you may/can/must tell people the truth that you know, but dont easily judge people and blame other as if they are ignorant.
Agreed. Let's start with ourselves!
I don't understand, why they build flashy PIK 1, PIK 2 in north jakarta is sinking???
@@aisyusagi189 The goverment will build Giant Sea Wall to protect Jakarta from Flooding. That's why there's still demand in North part of Jakarta. The fact is (if i'm not mistaken) the newly built reclamation island is part of the Giant Sea Wall Project.
I think Asian boss should make a lot more content of climate change.. obviously orang2 jkt (yg muda2 lg syangnya) hv no idea n don't understand how bad jkt condition is and why president want to relocate the capital city that's why they opposed it... I think about this issue Asian boss should have good resources that can explain scientifically.. so ppl will understand the background of this issue
Interviewing an expert is not Asian Boss main topics or idea 😅 watch their other videos, their main focus is to interview common people on the street
Asian boss has been focusing on the opinions of "the common people" so there is nothing wrong with that. You can watch Vice as an alternative with expert comments in it
As a resident from Borneo, I do have some issue with the relocation, what if all those business in Jakarta move along with the relocation and scummy property business will take this chance to deforest to open housing business, this is what happened in Java, and i don't want cities in Borneo crowded and polluted like Jakarta, While I agree it's recommended to relocate capital city
i do think borneo is the only option tho, sadly. geologically speaking, jakarta is located on java island, that has a potential for being impacted by natural disaster such as earthquake and volcano eruption, due to it close to the subduction zone. borneo is much further from those, which means there is much lesser risk from being impacted from such disasters. have you ever imagined if the govt center is gone due to such disasters?
Cuma perpindahan pemerintahan doang yg akan dipindah. Bukan kegiatan ekonominya.
Maybe you are right about deforestation, but Borneo are a big island, it will take forever to deforest whole island, if that's what you think about to happen.
@@DGraze I prefer the deforestation won't happen at all honestly, it won't need forever to deforest by the way, probably only like 20 years, Java used to have very cool climate, now it's a lot warmer, even in Borneo now also warmer, 20 years ago, I can see fog every morning, now there's barely of it due to current deforestation.
@@venth85 actually this kind of topic are not an easy topic to be talked for us, because even when capital are not in borneo, deforestation are happening in borneo, i don't know if it's because there are less watch control,
Or maybe when capital are relocate to borneo, people or even people from other country will see this deforestation more and a lot of people will give more voice to stop it.
and cool climate are relative, there is still a lot of place in java that has cool climate, you can't generalized java as a more warm island as a whole. i live in bandung and this city are still has cool climate, and lot's of city too has cool climate, not sure about you're place, but it can be because global warming too, or you're city has more building too not as it used to be, because in lembang, i still can see fog but of course depend on weather too.
so i hope you can see moving capital if it happen of course, in a more positive way. cheers from java.
Please do interview Myanmar citizens how they feel, after former military government moved the capital city from Yangon to Naypyitaw.
I think it would be hard to hard to interview in Myanmar because I think there's a high military presence
@@sy8112 •• i don't know where you are from but Myanmar is just like a normal country to get interviewed and to raise opinions towards government since it's democracy. Yes military is here but it's 2019, they aren't governor anymore.
@@danny_mizo Thanks for the info! I did a school project on Myanmar where I mainly focused on the military dictatorship and unfair treatment of Muslims within the country. I haven't ever been so it was unfair to assume it's still like that in the country.
@@sy8112 .. Oh, you do need to research more about it, coz the way you just said about Military is incorrect. And try to visit the country instead of paper research.
@@danny_mizo yes I agree
i love to see how they're all speaking indonesia language instead of english
Most Indonesians speak Indonesian, without any English words in the middle
@@rismadeco except jakselians
@@milkeyway7105 Nice one hahahaha
Shin samaaa, me tooooo❤❤❤❤
That guy with a glasses and batik should be our president.
fyi..
the plan to move the capital is for the center of government and not the center of the economy
Isn't it supposed to be the way around. People attracted to the economy not government why they persist on moving the capital if economy the attracting disaster.
@@fahmiibrahim3477 it's impossible to move the center of economic to another city. Jakarta has been the center of economic since Dutch Colonial
*sorry if my english so bad
@@fahmiibrahim3477 it doesnt. i live in Sydney Australia, people here avoiding living in capital city (Canberra) because not much to do there apart from government job. Main business still in Sydney~
@@PokeyExplore we're from same country man. then again if the government could they already done it during soeharto governance which is i think is the first time moving capital idea come. either jakarta need to be strict and killing or moving all the economic attraction to another cities.
@@omaraliwi4034 i don't know what will motivate someone to move beside money.
Maybe jakarta can also do the same thing like dutch do how they face raising water with their dam or something like that cause of it's lowland
Search up about sinkholes
ABSOLUTELY RIGHT,
Thank you for listening your audience on how to pick interviewee :)
A similar situation is happening to Male, the capital of the Maldives. However they can't move the capital because just like Indonesia, the Maldives is an archipelago. The islands within the Maldives, however, are very small (unlike Indonesia) and aren't suitable to house a capital. The island the city is on is the only suitable one. So they build barriers to stop the rising sea levels from flooding the entire city. Soon those barriers will be infiltrated as the sea level increases. It's a complex situation for both capitals
I've seen Male, the capital and Maldives is group of scattered islands and I think the capital is the biggest land of them all, no other place to move other than moving to the mainland Asia.
Indonesia as an archipelago country faces many earthquake and tsunami especially in Java Island (one of the city is Jakarta) and Borneo is one of the most save island in Indonesia. Did Maldives have an island that kinda 'safe' than the other?
Hey I've seen you at the China uncensored!
@@armybuddyforlive5436 no, Maldives area is small, and don't have a safe place far enough from their mainland
Jakarta is one of those places where the problem isn't that the sea is rising, but that, like in México City, the land under the city is literally sinking.
They're really intellectual and calm.
They did the interview in Universitas Indonesia, i could tell lol that would explained why the answers appeared intellectual
@@mangomonster5296 i said 'appeared'
They move the capital not because sinking so fast but they want have business city and the capital with different city like new York and Washington
Sinking is one of the reasons
In Philippines President Duterte made a new city in Clark it is almost done he made it because our traffic is very horrible he want to transfer some major companies there to less traffic in metro manila also to contrive the pollution.
The one main issues Jakarta sunk is OVERUSED OF LAND WATER, national plumbing water not really great in such Big Capital city 😌
Itu masalah utama nya, bukan perubahan iklim, nunggu ada yang bilang ini di interview, kayaknya rata-rata orang indo gak tau soal ini...
Yeah instead moving the capital city, government should start to developing seawater desalination Technology to reduce the land water usage.. yeah it's expensive, but it's less expensive than moving the capital city and it'll give the government more time to plan their project to move the capital city and it'll be useful for long-term usage..
To be honest, I agree with developing other parts of Indonesia. But, then again, if you create a new city out of nowhere and change the designation of your capital city to that new city, will people move, stay, and work there? Just look at Naypyidaw, Myanmar and Brasilia, Brazil (which only develop further years after the project is complete).
Who is supposed to move to the new city? Government officials? Executives? Or ordinary people? Will they be willing to settle in a newly developed area where the quality of education and health services are unknown? Are there any incentives for people moving to the new city?
Also, don't forget that moving the capital to another place doesn't stop the sinking and flooding from happening in Jakarta.
They just wan to save their asses 😒 And I love how you're worried about "Who will moved there" instead of "ALL WILL MOVE HERE AND OUR FOREST WILL BE GONE NOOOOO" :D Bcs I personally don't think people will be moving to where the goverment is at... it's all about the facilities and economics state
Belanda here, we are happy to help with your water management, Indonesië. It is kind of our thing for the last 1200 years.
I really hope help comes
Indons ourselves can't solve this alone
@arif mark007 Sorry about that brother, shitty habits die hard, tehee >_
please, we need belandas now than ever :(
how do you know indonesian poeple called the Netherlands is belanda😅
🙏 hope these people will be safe. Good luck Indonesians
hope is not gonna help them when they're drowning.
News: Indonesia wants to move their capital to Kalimantan.
Bruneians & East Malaysians: Road trip!
BANYAK YG SALAH KAPRAH TENTANG PEMINDAHAN IBUKOTA.....YG PINDAH ITU PUSAT PEMERINTAHAN SAJA SEMUA FASILITAS BISNIS DAN RODA EKONOMI TETAP SAMA.....
Woi ngekomen ga usah ngegas.. sante bosss
IYA BENER, NGGA SEMUANYA IKUT PINDAH PADAHAL.
BTW SAYA SUKA YANG NGEGAS NGEGAS GINI. LANJUTKAN!
Iya emang betul. Yg pindah pusat pemerintahan. Terus di kota baru entar akan berkembang juga ekonomi terus mendorong ekonomi daerah sekitar. Intinya baguslah. Apalagi Kalimantan itu strategis.
Iya mungking dikira orang - orang kek spongebob, pindahin ibu kota dari cacing alaska
Kita bisa mencontoh Korea Selatan atau Malaysia. Ibukota pindah itu perlahan.
Okay guys scrap the railroad project, we're gonna stop it
Instead let's move Jakarta somewhere else
Newby Ton I think the bigger solution is for Indonesia's economic wealth to be spread out to other parts of the country. That way, Jakarta will no longer be overcrowded.
@@ekmalsukarno2302 This is exactly my thought for a very long time! The government should have strategically develop different cities for various industries so that it's not all saturated in Jakarta. This in turn could generally improve the living conditions of its people across Indonesia.
Is this a Spongebob reference
Build a dam
Newby Ton 😂😂😂 Patrick!
Knowing that you share some words with other languages is one thing and actually hearing them is another thing. I heard many Sanskrit words while they spoke, like uttaraya (north), samudra (sea), etc.
Utara ya = North, right.
Utara = north.
Samudera/laut = sea/ocean
@@galaksikita5466 Oh. North in Sanskrit, and many other Indian languages, is called "uttar". So the words are more similar that way.
@@kdpak Absolutely. Hmmm do you know what the meaning of "Bhinneka Tunggal Ika" in ur language (Sanskrit)? It's our ideology.
@@galaksikita5466 The word bhinneka sounds like the Sanskrit word bhinna meaning various or different, and ika sounds like ek meaning one. I Googled the motto and came to know that it literally means, "out of many, one" or simply unity in diversity.
@@kdpak Yupp. Unity in diversity. Many motto in Sanskrit in Indonesia (Police, Army, medical/health, etc). U can search it.
Example the words.
"Kurnia Jaya Persada"
"Mega Buana"
Are those Sanskrit words? What's means in ur language (Sanskrit)?
It's interesting how Seoul is noisy, like a typical large city, while in Jakarta you can hear the birds chirping and the wind blowing.
10:57 Tina is so cute when she does her salute.
this interview was actually done in a campus library area, hence the lack of noise. if they actually hit the open streets of Jakarta it would be far more crowded :)
Like Parent like son.
You can take a look at Amsterdam (The capital city of the Netherlands) as an example.
huh??
As we know Amsterdam is also sinking and under the sea level but they managed to survive. What the OP means The Netherlands colonized Indonesia back in WW era so OP thinks Indonesian (son) should follow what The Netherlands (parent) do to their capital city.
Like parent like son? Pufft
What kind of "parent" dutch do to Indonesia u dumbass
At some point I want if we were colonized by russia or germany. Their hymne songs seems awesome
I'll wait for the next theme abt Indonesia...Good Job Asian Boss😍😘
This channel is so much more inciteful than mainstream news.
If this interview is done in Malaysia or Singapore, Im sure that most of them will give answer in english.. good for indonesian to speak their language
I think the climate change is not the main reason for moving our capital city. Overpopulation, traffic issue, transmigration even political issue maybe are why Jakarta getting more worst. Palangkaraya, the central city in Kalimantan Island is the best choice for me, to moving to. This plan even has been annouced from Soekarno's era and he had designed it to be capital city for sure.
Adimart Arminadi Perhaps the best solution is for every province or major island in Indonesia to be as wealthy and developed as Jakarta. The problem is, most of Indonesia's economic wealth is based in Jakarta, therefore spreading out Indonesia's economic wealth to other parts of the country will solve Jakarta's overcrowding problem.
maybe these issues are the result of your bad karma, because your goverment supported the murders of non-muslims
@@helohelooo8208 whatta hell you talking about??
@@helohelooo8208 Are you talking about terrorism?
@@L16htW4rr10r no, i meant the government supported massacres of minorities , including the "Mei 1998" incidents, could you please expain why the so called "religion of peace" were murdering non-muslims ??
Very concerning to think that this may happen in the very near future however this situation will become a lot more frequent due to the impact of climate change
if its going to borneo, need regulation about the forest.
borneo's forest one of the biggest in the world.
Unpopular opinion.. few people doesn't see this way.. if they want to move it to Borneo, they will need more land to construct the office.. to solve that they need to cut down more the threes and help the global warming.. and will make the situation in Jakarta even worse than ever... and from the other side, if they really move it to Borneo, what will happen to someone who works at MA, DPR, etc. Will they move as well? Or just stay at Jakarta and potentially lose their jobs and become jobless?? If they move as well, they will need a house or an apartment, and it'll need more land..
Nonton video jokowi pas di Kalimantan mas... Itu daerah yg mau ditempatin bukan hutan
@@rismadeco iya saya tau kok mas, saya pun baca berita. palangkaraya itu lahan kosongnya sangat luas. tapi yang namanya ibu kota itu, pasti butuh resource yang banyak maupun sdm / sda. dapat dipastikan nanti akan menjadi kawasan urban. karena kawasan urban, otomatis lahan untuk kependudukan disekitar palangkaraya dibutuhkan. bisa dilihat saja di Jakarta, jabodetabek jadi wilayah yang padat penduduk.
(1) You can relate the sinking phenomena of Jakarta to the scientific term "relative sea level rise". On the one side the sea level is rising due to climate change, and on the other side the land surface sinks due to the heavy load of hardly regulated construction projects across the last decades and the depletion of ground water. There are a couple of scientific studies made the last years that show that there are even parts in Jakarta that sink up to 10cm/year.
(2) If I'm not wrong, the plan by moving the capital was primary to relocate the government institutions. As examples of Germany or Brazil show, relocating a capital doesn't mean to relocate a whole economic/financial district. It takes many years. But the relocation could be at least an intervention to stop the nearly endless growth of the city.
I was In jakarta for 14 days.
Even after my morning bath, i still sweating a lot because its so hot right there.
What climate are you from?
Because jakarta are not an easy climate to get used to, a lot of people fail to adjust their body and leave jakarta again.
Well you should try Surabaya, it's hotter than Jakarta
Mindah ibukota baik utk jangka panjang di bidang ekonomi scr keseluruhan. Indonesia bkn cm jkrt dan jawa.
palm oil is also considered as biofuel (9:20). I think biofuel is not a great solution, as it also has a big impact in the biodiversity. Alternative energy such as solar lights, wind, and water would be cleaner and safer for our environment and ecosystem.
Yup, and dont forget, Indonesia is located on ring of fire. We have big geothermal energy potential
It's about money guys
I'M CRYING WATCHING THIS
Really appreciate Asian Boss for bring out this topic.
The issue about moving the government center actually since a long time ago, but the government themself not making any progress to make them come true. I think it'll finish maybe the next 10-15 years.
Saya pro, kalo belom kejadian pada belom nyadar bakal tenggelam dan pemerintah bakal disalahkan buang buang duit, tapi nanti pas udah tenggelam kalian jangan salahkan pemerintah.
0:47 hidup gua ngapa begini amat yak wkwkw
Kayak sedang menyesali sesuatu wkwk
SAYA CINTA INDONESIA HEHE
-FROM PH
Mahal ko kayo. Maraming salamat.
aku cinta filipina juga hehe
@@Kanal7Indonesia thanks xD
Gue kira cuma orang amerika aja yg bilang climate change itu hoax. Ternyata orang indo juga, hedeh 4:30
ada teori kalo sebenernya perubahan iklim itu karena setiap 2000 taun sekali bumi bergeser kutub perputarannya, jadi posisi kutub utara dan selatan jg bergeser, es d kutub mencair karena posisinya jadi lebih sering kena matahari, semua wilayah pun ikut bergeser posisinya, makanya bbrapa taun ini banyak cuaca aneh
My first thought (as a Mindanaoan) on moving the capital to Borneo is that it would actually trigger international sea trade in Mindanao, which is a big mystery to me considering that they could have built ports directly facing Malaysia and Indonesia long ago. It would benefit trade of agricultural products between countries and allow development for both Borneo and Mindanao -- or directly even Malaysia's two states in Borneo. HOWEVER if the reason was climate change and it might result to further deforestation, that's just defeating the purpose.
However, it is beneficial if at least the central government itself relocates somewhere with less population density and no heavy traffic. It's only the capital that will change and it's not like Jakarta will be abandoned by its residents. Although yes, there will be residents who will have to relocate due to work.
Saying no to the move is just like postponing it until the time the problem is already worse. But hey, it costs too much and we consider one interviewee's words, it should be done slowly.
Oh one more thing: They should also try to learn from Malaysia's moving its federal government.
Untill this one, Video bout Indonesia reaches 3 video. Please makes “Indonesia Topic” Playlist hehe
Asian boss Indonesia 🤗🤗🤗
3 video in 2019... thanks thankss...
Nice interview. greetings from indonesian.
Ngga ada yg peduli lu darimana, komen ngga mutu, anjing.
@@momon4868 wow edgy
AB comes through again with actual on the street knowledge of a country thank you GREAT REPORTING
Ooh I’m going to Indonesia this summer!
I'm guessing bali?
As Korea moved it's capital city in 2007 to Sejong. Perhaps a story on the challenges of moving a capital city from Korea would compliment this story from Indonesia. Also, a poll of Asian Boss subscribers to gauge awareness of Korea's new capital would be interesting.
"Sejong was founded in 2007 as the new national capital of South Korea from territory of South Chungcheong and North Chungcheong provinces to ease congestion in South Korea's current capital and largest city..." Wikipedia
So... It's not Seoul anymore?
6:24 I think Most of the Borneo Residents strongly agree with the transfer of the capital to Borneo as a Borneo citizen. I strongly agree that the capital will be moved here because the island of Borneo also wants it as Java. Infrastructure on Borneo is still not as good as Java
And not few people disagree too..
Here in Australia we want to move our capital into the ocean.
@vishu singh stop saying that, you'll get me fired. Do you know how hard it is to get an acting job?
Good one😉
@vishu singh yes,and aussie is probably a fairy
climate changes is just small problem to relocate the capital city.. the main problem is because of political and safety... sometime jakarta is hard to control..
Your Buddies perubahan iklim masalah besar boss, ga hanya climate change aja, di pulau jawa banyak sekali lempeng yg bisa memicu gempa bumi yang besar, kita ga bisa ngelawan alam, itu alasan utama dipindahkannya ibu kota negara
climate change is a small problem??? wat??? are u sure?? are you from mars?
@@kimyeong-jun519 I said small reason for Indonesia to relocate capital city.. understand my first comments first..
@@buddies8757 i understand it. but dont ever say the climate change is just a small problem. its a very big problem in this world nowadays. that political and safety problem are just a very very little issuse in every country.the government must deal on it.
@@kimyeong-jun519 look, climate change are important. But it only play a small part in Indonesian moving their capital to another city.
Don't get so worked up when you misunderstood the first post.
*Bangkok has joined the chat*
Tommy Bridge .
*Manila has also joined the conversation*
Jakarta should increase efforts to build more canals, maintain and clean them if they are so worried about the city becoming underwater.
They were doing all of it.
The problem is sinking land ( indonesia in on "ring of fire" geologic location with 3 earth plates), and rising sea level. There's just so much human could do.
Thank you so much AsianBoss for hearing my suggestions :) I wish for a better interview topics for Indonesian team :)
Anyway I support for the capital city to move to outside java. A lot of reasons and it won't change the economy in Jakarta, instead it can improve the economy in the future capital city
You can cover the increasing and extreme heat wave that is now affecting Pakistan and Northern India.
For the indonesian interviewer : Finally, you pick the right indonesian citizen to ask, and all of them can give a great answer.
Karena yang sebelum2nya, yang ditanyain kurang tepat, jawabannya pun seadanya karena kurang pemahaman, dan gak terlalu bisa kasi pandangan yang mewakili jawaban orang indonesia pada umumnya. (menurut gue)
But, for this one, good job. Keep it up.
Moonson, summer? It should be rainy and dry season.
SUMMER =/= DRY SEASON
Ketika orang luar negeri lebih peduli terhadap isu lingkungan ketimbang rakyat Indonesia itu sendiri.
Liat rugi nya negara akibat macet,triliunan bro,in kota hrus dipindh,berani ambil resiko,ketimbang nahan ibukota di jakrta, udh go kbyng rugi nya brpa ibu kota ttp dijakarta
The main problem actually is the underground water reserve usage. The residential, mall, office, all use this unrenewable resource. If only the water filtration companies got more efficient and government put a high taxation over ground water usage, it will help to reduce the problem getting worse significantly.
I think Korea did a similar act - moving a large part of central government and its workers to Sejong from Seoul in order to lessen overcrowded beast of S. Korea ‘s capital.
It’s insane how much construction is going on in Sejong, and yet the city is mostly empty of residents. What a fascinating project.
The problem is money..
Moving the capital doesn't mean Jakarta is gone. Jakarta is just gonna be another ordinary big city
Lets love our planet, save planet, save animal, save us. Use reuseable product
too little people care...
Some people said Atlantis located in Indonesia, and now we will have Jakarta as Atlantis 2.0
Is it just me or the guy in 4.33 is actually answering the question "Do our local media cover climate change?" And he answers "hoax, I heard it was a hoax."
That doesn't really mean he thinks it is hoax, but he heard the media (somewhere) saying that it is hoax.
Yaaa, me too._.
From a longg time ago since dutch colonies era Jakarta is a water city, there are a lot of water passage and built in river with many brigdes, boats, etc. I dunno where all the water passages has gone now :v
And maybe aside from Palangkaraya Indonesia can consider selat malaka as the capital city. In Majapahit era and before that, selat malaka has been famous for being the center for traders to trade and the area is very strategic too
Can't you find "better" people for doing interview??
Jakarta is so big, so you can ask to other people that can give more interesting conversation
Yah, agree...
Most of interviewed people was on depok instead of jakarta. Maybe, if they did it on north jakarta, it'd be much better 👌
@@erfianhernandez8593 yes North jakarta please, I've lived here since I was born and I have a lot to say about the climate change 😭
I live in Houston, Texas and I feel the effects of climate change. It floods almost every time it rains! The rain here is more heavy and severe. And the wind has been very strong, I never use to be scared of the wind during storms, but now it terrifies me.
Seeing as it's literally sinking into the ocean I don't think so
Yeah.. it'll takes many years.. most likely a century or so...
It's amazing to see the level of trust they have in the government
I was surprised no one gave as a good reason to move the Capital the fact that Jakarta (under the name Batavia) was also the capital when Indonesia was a Dutch colony. Indonesians really don't seem to hold much of a grudge against the Dutch (I'm Dutch), or do they?
[edit] Funnily enough The Netherlands, tiny and low lying as it is, is also at serious risk when sea levels rise, our capital Amsterdam is as threatened as Jakarta, if not more.
I'm Indonesian, and to answer your question I think it's because we were colonized by Dutch for so long that we developed some kind of mental issue which we always glorify things that Caucasians do and to see them as superior instead of hating what Dutch did in the past 😂 I know, it's weird.. to test this theory you can try to take stroll on Indonesia's streets as a Dutch, everybody will be kind enough to greet you and you'll be followed by kids like some kind of their idol even though you said that you're Dutch 😂
That's reassuring on a personal level, because Indonesia is very beautiful and interesting and I'd like to go there one day, but it's disconcerting too of course. As a Western person I want to be just another person. Not revered or idolized, but also not blamed for the sins of my forefathers.
Thank you very much for your reply :3
@Nabilla Thank you for being passive aggressive to me for something I had no part in.
So I'm 400 years old now?
@Nabilla Fadillah Lol? So how about I blame you for the Dayak cannibals from 1999?
Tbh jakarta is sooo crowded nowdays you can feel traffic like everyday non stop even in saturday and sunday, i think move capital city is great idea, and also too many vechile on the street makes huge contribution in traffic problem
That's who says climate change HOAX, I think you must be go to Buru island.
why i must go to buru island?
@@izu___ because the islands literally lose it's 10% of land each year
If the city is truly sinking why not find a solution? Learn from the Dutch and how they were able to reclaim their land. The country can continue to build giant luxurious skyscrapers but yet they are not doing much to save the city. There's no reason to move the capital elsewhere. The business and financial district is here and it should be as close to the capital as it can be. Reclaiming land is one thing but they should also find solutions on how to get water to residences and businesses of the city. Didn't Tokyo and Taipei have the same problem back in the day? The government of Indonesia needs to understand and study these issues really well rather than just run from the problem. Indonesia is such a great country and has grown a lot over the last few years. So why not continue to grow and fix the things that need to be fixed; infrastructure, political, social, and many more. As a proud Inondeian myself, I really do love this country and I really wish the best for it and its people.
4:33 he's completely need to face Greenpeace activists 😂
Thanks for interviews people in my country to think about it.
Please interview jakarta's governor on how to fix the issue. He will probably just give you a poetry instead.
Moving capital citry from Jakarta wont affect Jakarta economy much because those business companies won't just relocate. You can see in other countries that moved their capital city, their main business city remain the same (Sydney & Canberra) (Shanghai & Beijing) (New York & Washington) - Sydneysider
It'll believe me.. many international companies that based in Jakarta right now try to develop and make plan to relocate their headquarters to their branch on the other city when they need it... they already saw what will happen to Jakarta long before our government did... do you think they'll stay and wait for Jakarta sink then start to develop their beaches? No..
Suggest for next topic,
1. Indonesian think about Japan.
2. Indonesian think about S. Korea.
3. Indonesian think about China.
4. Indonesian think about India.
No. 1 should be Indonesians think about Malaysia
Indonesia think about Wakanda
Better not. It would be pitiful if Indonesians give so much unnessecary praises to other countries. Trust me, we won't embarass ourselves.
These university students don't represent Indonesia as a whole. They are the 0.007% who managed to get themselves into one of the best universities in Indonesia.
wait is that in Universitas Indonesia's library
Good job Asian Boss you finally hear our complaint , another Indonesian topic outside religion keep it up
mas tas cokelat musti ketemu mas baju bisbol
Hahaha tas coklat nyebelin
@@coconut1586 gemessshh mau cubit ya... ehm ehm ehm.. towel juga iiiicch
Iya. Jelas beda pemikiran. Wkwk...
Asian Boss... Sering-seringlah buat konten tentang Indonesia 😉
When ur indonesian but u still see the subtitle
Btw stop global warming ppl
Meanwhile the head govt is busy on moving outside Java's island. I just remind how great Jakarta since pre-history as trading and business state. Just go to the Borneo to create governorance's state. But you still need Jakarta as the best business state. Similar like Istanbul and Ankara.
They better start building now rather than debate and waste time, slowly like the bearded dude said. Just like Abuja and Brasilia.
Another great topic from Asian Boss 👍
Kinda related to the question in the end, I'd like to see a video about plastic ban in Bali. If you guys need volunteers around Bali, maybe I could help