Thanks again for this flight that you sent me, Bill. I finally got to sit down and try these and they are all good. I do like Bruichladdich and found these to be strong representatives of their DNA. My preferences matched you exactly. I loved the 2011 as my first dram, quickly realized 2012 didn't live up, and then knew 2013 was the winner on first sip. 2013 first, 2011 second, and 2012 a distant third. However, it wasn't the "heaviness" but I just found 2012 a bit flat or one dimensional because the fruit wasn't there to balance with the malt. This was super fun.
I've only had one, I think the 2011, but was amazed how much of a jump in quality it was over the Classic Laddie for only about $10 more. If it were sold in my state, I'd stock it. I give the Laddie a buy it, and I still get it here and there as an occasional stock it lol. Cheers and Merry Christmas!
I enjoyed this review thoroughly. I don't know that I have actually seen any of these myself. Since I am more of a peated fanboy, my eyes immediately locked on to their Port Charlotte Heavily Peated 2013 expression when I found it this fall. As could be expected, the barley was sourced at the same seven Islay farms and also comes in at 50% ABV. I love it! How about a mirror image comparison of the 2011-2013 Port Charlotte Heavily Peated Islay Barley bottles?
What a great comparison! I was blown away by the 2013! Thanks for the solid , detailed review!
Thanks again for this flight that you sent me, Bill. I finally got to sit down and try these and they are all good. I do like Bruichladdich and found these to be strong representatives of their DNA. My preferences matched you exactly. I loved the 2011 as my first dram, quickly realized 2012 didn't live up, and then knew 2013 was the winner on first sip. 2013 first, 2011 second, and 2012 a distant third. However, it wasn't the "heaviness" but I just found 2012 a bit flat or one dimensional because the fruit wasn't there to balance with the malt. This was super fun.
Local Total wine had the 2013 for only 48 dollars today, I couldn't pass it up, and it's like a more heavy, less salty Classic Laddie and it's so good
i am so glad you did this comparison; nice job.
Great comparison!
Cheers 🥃
Thank you :)
I’ve only had 2013, it’s excellent!
I've only had one, I think the 2011, but was amazed how much of a jump in quality it was over the Classic Laddie for only about $10 more. If it were sold in my state, I'd stock it. I give the Laddie a buy it, and I still get it here and there as an occasional stock it lol. Cheers and Merry Christmas!
I enjoyed this review thoroughly. I don't know that I have actually seen any of these myself. Since I am more of a peated fanboy, my eyes immediately locked on to their Port Charlotte Heavily Peated 2013 expression when I found it this fall. As could be expected, the barley was sourced at the same seven Islay farms and also comes in at 50% ABV. I love it! How about a mirror image comparison of the 2011-2013 Port Charlotte Heavily Peated Islay Barley bottles?
Those are much harder to find in my area. Not sure I could get my hands on them. I'd love to though!
Definitely compare with the 2014! Excellent video. Thank you! I was disappointed I have the 2012 after this.
Wish you the best for this Christmas 🎄
well i was considering having my 2011 and 2012 today - guess this confirms i need to do that
Absolutely it does
Great breakdown, and much appreciated (sadly, I missed the 11, and can't compare to the subsequent versions).
Enjoyed that review Good job !and wish you happy holidays Bill
My favorite “oily” whisky is Laphroig 18, but I haven’t seen it at a reasonable price for 15 years 😢
Easy the 2013 you should all buy.
love the video Bill!
Merry Christmas and Happy, Healthy New Year !!!
You as well!
Review 14
Get into cigars. Change your whisky life