Salamun alykum brother. We are living in a time when this book ( Al Quran ) is revealing its secrets Alhamdullilah and Jazakallah. I am learning from Marvelous Quran channel and we will learn togather.Alhamdullilah.
This is a very slippery slope to be on... _"We are living in a time when this book ( Al Quran ) is revealing its secrets"_ Have you ever come across a verse that says plainly that the Quran is a book of secrets? Most definitely NOT! On the contrary, there are verses that says... such as this one: 15:1 Alif Lam Ra, these are the signs of the Book and a clear Qur'an. So, do you think a *clear book* contains secrets? Beware of the Satan impersonating a wannabee scholar. salam.
70.23: (اَلَّذٖينَ هُمْ عَلٰى صَلَاتِهِمْ دَائِمُونَ۔) Salat is 24/7 process (دَائِمُونَ) till death we can't break it, we can't stand up 24/7 in Salat.
Fun fact: Prostrating to the Black Building thats situated in Mecca and then commiting shirk by treating Muhammad like the son of God like moat traditionalists makes you no different then thosr call Jesus the "son of God" and Hindu who worships idols. God said the people where "Ummiyan" before Muhammad i.e. they didn't receive a scripture and/or messenger. This means Abraham didn't built the Black building in Mecca. The traditionalist would say they don't commit idol worshipping when they prostating to the Black Building and thats just a direction they pray at. Well, thats the same logic that idol worshippers use. They don't think that the fake entity they are worshipping is in the idol but thats just the direction they pray.
Sir verse 41:37 ke baare mein kya kahenge? Usme الشمس and القمر ke lie sajad ka use ho rha hai? Kya wha pe physical prostration hai matlab sajdah ka? Samjhaie...😢
What about the ayah 4:102...and ayah 17:107...where the words sujood and chins have been used....n they say these words are musculine plural...thtswhy they are physical actions....hope u answer..
Interesting observation brother. What he said makes sense though with these particular ayats. 4:102 when they are carrying weapons I get your point. But 17:107 you could replace the bottom they fall in total submission when they hear it. As remember in an earlier video face didn't actually mean face. But don't take my word for it as I haven't done my due diligence. I think we have to start translating the Qur'an ourselves and actually understand it, and we should come to the same conclusions. I'm not sure how, but we need to ask Allah, how we can do it because also brother I'm also questioning so many things now that the Qur'an is right, but it's been translated incorrectly in some areas. Like the thing about when you have sex with women wash yourselves on 5:6 his point made sense as if a woman read that it would mean when a woman has sex with a woman? I really think certain things have been incorrectly translated. The question is, how has this consistently happened as multiple people have done there own translations, why would they all collectively make the same mistake as each other? Unless that's the issue, they relied on others suggestions rather than what god put in front of them and maybe peer pressure made them go with what's easiest? I have no clue, but it's all crazy isn't it? That we could be following Qur'an in the wrong way in some parts when it clearly makes things much simpler than we thought. May Allah guide us to the straight path and reveal the truth (maybe this is Allah's way of showing us, need to study Arabic I think and do our own due diligence but yeah not sure how yet).
@@Zeridium Thanks to have an opinion on my question....yeah we don't know much about Qur'an...n we try our best to understand...still we think n question....same happened with me ...I heard Moses and found that logical...but I came to these verses and got stuck again....hope in future confusion regarding this video gets cleared...
@@user-cd2jl4is4k I think his interpretations are cool, but need to think a bit our selves for examples the 3 prayer times, if they were more to do with duty why would Allah tell us the times to uphold it? And establish prayer/duty at the two ends of the day and at the approach of the night. Indeed, good deeds do away with misdeeds. That is a reminder for those who remember. Only Allah can truly guide. I think best way is to pray and be patient and ask Allah for guidance and do the best/ask for forgiveness. Maybe we need to study the Qur'an ourselves somehow and see if we come to the same conclusions.
@@user-cd2jl4is4k Honestly brother, the more I think about it, Qur'an is about a way of life, not rituals, but building Allah's system. Heaven is where everything is perfect, nice, a final destination with Allah where everything is just how it is meant to be, happy place with no badness in it. This life, the Qur'an and these translations I think Allah is telling us to follow this so we can prove to him we want a good, non corrupt place, and his way is trying to do it best way we can in life. Salat is the duty, and constantly thinking about him in everything we do is the prayer/the straight path. Even now I am thinking of him, when I was advising my friend on what garage to go through, I was thinking (how best can I explain this to them, and is this the right place for them Allah?) and then I explained the place and what they did for me. This is it man, that is the service to Allah, the straight path. I am also scared, very scared of all that I learnt may Allah/mostly be wrong the constant pointing to one way and praying but the real salat is doing that all the time in anything we do from fajr, throughout the day until nightfall and then night is our rest. Some get up at night some watches of the night to do his deeds (like parents waking up to deal with a crying baby, that's a duty/salat if we go by there translation) and some at dawn, before their day starts, read Qur'an as a REMINDER. Now I understand why Allah says the angels witness it at dawn, they're recording/checking us and there to see us as witnesses that we are reminding ourselves everyday to follow Allah's way and then we go out and do it for the day. The duty. And the birds, cats all the animals, Allah says the birds do Salah? And they made a point I never see a bird praying or lining up in rows to pray, but they fly, they sing in the morning when getting up to start their day, do there things and at nice they go quiet, rince and repeat. Allah wants to use our skills and brains to see what we do with our time. The martyrs are the ones doing whatever they did and dying in cause of Allah I think, living in his way. Like a doctor who may have died volunteering to help others in war, or say a mother trying to stop their child running on to a road then hit by a car to protect. She was living in the cause of Allah (we think, or I think it doesn't only pertains to soldiers) and they are alive with their lord as said in the Qur'an. We I think in order to clarify things have to go out of our way to understand and double check this what they've said to confirm. But see the difference, these people like Sam and everyone invite to use logic and evidence and correct them as they want the TRUTH. What do the traditionists, they call us mad/blasphemous. What did the polytheists and others do who were from Torah/injeel do? Same thing. They could not let go, and check it they just were so against it. Look at how our ummah reacts, when we say we should only go Qur'an and try to read and understand it, they get infuriated and then shun, rather than reason, and check what we said. It's all crazy but there is a reason we have been brought here by Allah. Now we got to make the next step and use our reasoning and evidence to check these facts, or we can just trust it and hope, but again, that's what maybe caused the original deviation in the first place (if this is what has happened and this is not all wrong translation) But brother, I think this is the real way, and that's the test. The forerunners in the Qur'an, few in the future, many in the past, why? They were the ones who went against the grain, and went with Allah's way even if they got ridiculed for it by family/ friends. I was born into islam and thought I had it easy, but our test is just as hard as those not born into it, in a way, as we may have been born into a religion that doesn't follow Allah's rules properly, hard for us to unlearn, Vs those who go from atheist to islam start with plate and then have to decide to follow this traditionalist way or the REAL WAY. ASSALAMU ALAIKUM and may Allah forgive us for our mistakes man and guide to his path, not man's not some scholars who think, or believe this is right but the Qur'an literally has it all, and I think it's simpler than we have been made to believe. I think we need a discord where we can all study and share findings, online "masjid" in the name of god. I think this would be good. Can you believe, that by the grace of god and his all mightiness- the all wise is inviting us perhaps to be of those who fight against the status quo, and to be of those closest to him insha'Allah if this is all true and the traditional translation are all messed up.
Salaamu Alaykum Brother Moses, when giving us the English translations are they what was giving to us by earlier interpreters or are they your translations according to the Arabic English language or are the from the organic Quranic locution.
No sects in islam QURAN: As for those who divide their religion and break up into sects, thou hast no part in them in the least: their affair is with Allah: He will in the end tell them the truth of all that they did. (En’âm 6:159)
Allah did not forget everything. This Qur-an is for people wd reason. Allah does not need to specify how many unit is salat but, just understand the Qur-an, not to twist the meaning. You know how to shorten salat. The prophet led the prayer from that verse u can understand that there are only 2rakaat in each salat.
Assalamu alaikum brother, I am searching the root word of Rukoo and its meaning. I could not find the meaning and root. would you please share me where did you find this root and its meaning.
When we say ‘Rakoh’ and ‘Sajood’ as per Quran it means respecting and accepting Allah’s Authority with humility, humbleness, willingness and submitting with one’s whole being, and then obeying and following the rules, regulations and commandments of Allah as ordained in Quran. -Quran Thinkers web site
@@AlMosesPhD Hello brother, Assalamu alaikum I've been praying Allah to reveal the truth as more and more people who I see translating Qur'an are seeing these inconsistencies (not in the Qur'an but in how the translations have been made) How has every translation been wrong though is what I'm curious about, we have so many different institutions with the same translations did they just accept it without delving deeper? Peer pressure maybe. This version of Salah makes more sense and the translation but what would you're explanation be on 4:102 and 7:107, might be worth looking into.
تمام احکمات جو 2.40 سے 2.42 میں بیان کئے گئے ہیں ان سب کو (وَاَقٖيمُوا) نافذ کرو (الصَّلٰوةَ) انکے پیچھے پیچھے چلو اور (وَاٰتُوا الزَّكٰوةَ) ادا کرو (وَارْكَعُوا مَعَ الرَّاكِعٖينَ۔) اور ان احکامات کے سامنے جھکنے تسلیم عمل کرنے والوں کے ساتھ تم بھی جھکو عملا تسلیم کرو۔
Salam ,PHD Al Moses, i'm very very much confused now on w/c to follow & w/c one s correct, all of u r using Qur-an as d bases. I knew u have d points. My question, s how do we do salat f not ritual ,in our niyat only or jst intend to do in our heart, ? pls. explain. May d All Mighty reward u for ur efforts f ur research found to b correct. More power & may Allah(swt) increase ur knowledge.
salam,you wrote "My question, s how do we do salat" ? response : *Who are الْمُصَلِّينَ the Musalleen ?* Is it those who perform the ritual prayers ? Lets find out. 70:19 Verily, man is created with an anxious disposition. 70:20 When they are afflicted, they complain, 70:21 And when good touches him, withholding [of it], 70:22 Except الْمُصَلِّينَ the MUSALLEEN. 70:23 *Those who are CONSTANT in their SALAT صَلَاتِهِمْ.* 70:24 *And They (Al Musalleen) are those who assign a certain share of their property* 70:25 *for the needy and the deprived,* 70:26 *And (Al Musalleen are those) who acknowledge the Day of Judgment,* 70:27 *And (Al Musalleen are the ones) who are afraid of the torment of their Lord,* 70:28 the punishment of their Lord is not something for them to feel secure of, 70:29 *And (Al Musalleen are the ones) who guard their carnal desires* 70:30 Except from their spouses or what they possess rightfully then indeed, they (are) not blameworthy, 70:31 but whoever goes beyond this is a transgressor; 70:32 *And (Al Musalleen are those) who honor their trust and promises,* 70:33 *And (Al Musalleen are those) who testify to what they have witnessed,* 70:34 *And (Al Musalleen are) those who, on their SALAT صَلَاتِهِمْ keep a guard,* 70:35 such people will receive due honor in Paradise. 70:36 What is wrong with the disbelievers who roam around you, 70:37 On the right and on the left, (in) separate groups? 70:38 Does every one of them desire to enter the bountiful Paradise? 70:39 By no means! Indeed, We have created them from what they know. 70:40 No! I swear by the Lord of the Easts and Wests that We have the power 70:41 to replace them by a better people and none can challenge Our power. 70:42 leave them alone to dispute and play until they face the Day with which they have been threatened: 70:43 the Day when they rush out of their graves as if racing towards a signpost, 70:44 with their eyes cast down and covered by disgrace; the day about which they were promised. 70:20 جب اسے مصیبت (یا مالی نقصان) پہنچے تو گھبرا جاتا ہے، 70:21 اور جب اسے بھلائی (یا مالی فراخی) حاصل ہو تو بخل کرتا ہے، 70:22 مگر وہ صَّلاَةَ ادا کرنے والے، 70:23 جو اپنی صَّلاَةَ پر ہمیشگی قائم رکھنے والے ہیں، 70:24 اور وہ (ایثار کیش) لوگ جن کے اَموال میں حصہ مقرر ہے، 70:25 مانگنے والے اور نہ مانگنے والے محتاج کا، 70:26 اور وہ لوگ جو روزِ جزا کی تصدیق کرتے ہیں، 70:27 اور وہ لوگ جو اپنے رب کے عذاب سے ڈرنے والے ہیں، 70:28 بے شک ان کے رب کا عذاب ایسا نہیں جس سے بے خوف ہوا جائے، 70:29 اور وہ لوگ جو اپنی شرم گاہوں کی حفاظت کرتے ہیں، 70:30 سوائے اپنی منکوحہ بیویوں کے یا اپنی مملوکہ کنیزوں کے، سو (اِس میں) اُن پر کوئی ملامت نہیں، 70:31 سو جو ان کے علاوہ طلب کرے تو وہی لوگ حد سے گزرنے والے ہیں، 70:32 اور وہ لوگ جو اپنی امانتوں اور اپنے وعدوں کی نگہداشت کرتے ہیں، 70:33 اور وہ لوگ جو اپنی گواہیوں پر قائم رہتے ہیں، 70:34 اور وہ لوگ جو اپنی صَّلاَةَوں کی حفاظت کرتے ہیں، 70:35 یہی لوگ ہیں جو جنتوں میں معزّز و مکرّم ہوں گے، 70:36 تو کافروں کو کیا ہو گیا ہے کہ آپ کی طرف دوڑے چلے آرہے ہیں، 70:37 دائیں جانب سے (بھی) اور بائیں جانب سے (بھی) گروہ در گروہ، 70:38 کیا ان میں سے ہر شخص یہ توقع رکھتا ہے کہ وہ (بغیر ایمان و عمل کے) نعمتوں والی جنت میں داخل کر دیا جائے گا؟، 70:39 ہرگز نہیں، بے شک ہم نے انہیں اس چیز سے پیدا کیا ہے جسے وہ (بھی) جانتے ہیں، 70:40 سو میں مشارق اور مغارب کے رب کی قَسم کھاتا ہوں کہ بے شک ہم پوری قدرت رکھتے ہیں peace
@@jaweedpatel Salam, very good question, i like it, bt d problem s, none of his sahabas were alive or jst even sons or daughters of his sahabas, we can get sahi info r enough to justify, d prophet was using ritual or not ritual, bt since Qur-an is d confirmation of d pass, d prophet was instructed by Allah to follow millata Ibrahin s enough to prove, salat s ritual.
SAJDA (اسْجُدُو) & MASJID (الْمَسْجِدِ) - The word Sajd, Sajood or Sajda as per Quran means submitted with one’s whole being, to follow with complete and utter conviction of heart and mind. Another word used in Quran to refer to the meanings of submission is Rackoh, but there is a difference between Sajda and Rakoh. The word Rakoh means to bend or bow to something or someone in a manner which shows initial acceptance, submission, humility and respect with complete willingness. The word Rakoh although one hand, means acceptance submission and obedience, the full, utter and deep conviction of something or someone but the impact and the benefits of that thing or that one is yet to be experienced and acknowledged, which is then reflected by the word Sajda, meanings submission with one’s whole being in complete and utter conviction of heart and mind, which comes from the witnessing and being convinced of the benefits of such submission. When we say ‘Rakoh’ and ‘Sajood’ as per Quran it means respecting and accepting Allah’s Authority with humility, humbleness, willingness and submitting with one’s whole being, and then obeying and following the rules, regulations and commandments of Allah as ordained in Quran with utter and deep conviction of its benefits. The word Masjid or Masaajid (plural of Masjid) is used in Quran in the meanings of a place, an area of a community, a city, a land where Sajda is being done, that is everyone is establishing and submitted to the law’s rules and regulations of Deen e Islam. X-Reference - 2:58 , 7:11-12 , 9:107-110 , 15:31-32 , 16:48 , 17:61 , 18:50 , 20:70 , 25:60 , 38:72 , 41:37 , 48:29 , 68:43 , 96:19. (تَسْجُدَ;اسْجُدُوا;السَّاجِدِينَ;فَسَجَدُوا;مَسَاجِدَ;سُجَّدًا;سَجَدُو;الْمَسَاجِدِ;الْمَسْجِدِ;اسْجُدِي;السُّجُودِ;يَسْجُدُونَ;سَجَدُوا;سُجَّدًا;الْمَسْجِد;مَسْجِدٍ;مَسْجِدٍ; سَاجِدِينَ ; سُجَّدًا ; يَسْجُدُونَ)
But isnt there another word for Submission/to submit in the quran? If yes, then how does it comes that allah uses 2 different word for the same things.I refer to aslama or aslamtu , Q2:112 or Q3:20
SAJDA (اسْجُدُو) & MASJID (الْمَسْجِدِ) - The word Sajd, Sajood or Sajda as per Quran means submitted with one’s whole being, to follow with complete and utter conviction of heart and mind. Another word used in Quran to refer to the meanings of submission is Rackoh, but there is a difference between Sajda and Rakoh. The word Rakoh means to bend or bow to something or someone in a manner which shows initial acceptance, submission, humility and respect with complete willingness. The word Rakoh although one hand, means acceptance submission and obedience, the full, utter and deep conviction of something or someone but the impact and the benefits of that thing or that one is yet to be experienced and acknowledged, which is then reflected by the word Sajda, meanings submission with one’s whole being in complete and utter conviction of heart and mind, which comes from the witnessing and being convinced of the benefits of such submission. When we say ‘Rakoh’ and ‘Sajood’ as per Quran it means respecting and accepting Allah’s Authority with humility, humbleness, willingness and submitting with one’s whole being, and then obeying and following the rules, regulations and commandments of Allah as ordained in Quran with utter and deep conviction of its benefits. The word Masjid or Masaajid (plural of Masjid) is used in Quran in the meanings of a place, an area of a community, a city, a land where Sajda is being done, that is everyone is establishing and submitted to the law’s rules and regulations of Deen e Islam. X-Reference - 2:58 , 7:11-12 , 9:107-110 , 15:31-32 , 16:48 , 17:61 , 18:50 , 20:70 , 25:60 , 38:72 , 41:37 , 48:29 , 68:43 , 96:19. (تَسْجُدَ;اسْجُدُوا;السَّاجِدِينَ;فَسَجَدُوا;مَسَاجِدَ;سُجَّدًا;سَجَدُو;الْمَسَاجِدِ;الْمَسْجِدِ;اسْجُدِي;السُّجُودِ;يَسْجُدُونَ;سَجَدُوا;سُجَّدًا;الْمَسْجِد;مَسْجِدٍ;مَسْجِدٍ; سَاجِدِينَ ; سُجَّدًا ; يَسْجُدُونَ)
What s the difference between rukoo and sajood? And if we are all automatically doing sajood then why are we being told to do it? Or is it that in all Ayats Allah is informing us that everything does sajood and that we have to rakoo?
@@AlMosesPhD we can choose to humble or not be humble. I agree. But what's the difference between these two actions. Rukoo and sajood. As the general understanding goes that there are no synonyms in Quran then there must be a difference between these two verbs.
@@AlMosesPhD i think your proposition would be more compelling if you prove it through a linguistic analysis and not just spout out what it means , it's a good video , but for extra defence you'll need this.
brother can u discuss the topic from Quran for overpopulation?I mean does Allah really says that people have to give birth to more kids and can we control overpopulation?pls bro help me in this may God bless you with love and respect ameen🙏🙏🙏
So you think that if you don't understand a verse you just have to change the meanings of the words to make the verse make sense to you? LOL The Quran has never been a dictionary of words, nor does it intend to be. In fact, there are words in the Quran that are only used once in the entire Quran. With such words, how can one ever begin to understand the meaning of the words without an appreciation of the general Arabic language which has reached us? And even if you say that you interpret the meanings of the words based on their roots, you can only find the root meanings in external dictionaries too. As I am sure you will appreciate, the Quran was revealed to a people who understood the language. Therefore, the language of the Arabs as it has reached us today and any sources which transmit an understanding of a word in that particular context, is implicit to understand the Quran. Yes indeed, the Quran can be used as a reference or criterion, but the Quran also expects that the audience is familiar with the language for them to be able to grasp its message. Otherwise, the Quranic language (and its message) will end up becoming nothing more than Egyptian Hieroglyphics without the Rosetta stone to assist. The word "rukoo" is well known and it´s primary meaning is bowing in a physical way. Also the word "Sujud". Surah 48 Verse 29: " *Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah, and (the ones) who are with him are strict against the disbelievers, merciful among themselves. You see them bowing themselves, prostrating...* " You can only SEE something is physical. Surah 13 Vers 15: " *Whatever is in the heavens and the earth do prostrate before Allah Alone willingly or unwillingly, and so do their shadows in the mornings and evenings.* " Even the shadows do prostrate which proofs that Sujud must be something physical. You're not seriously telling me that there isn't a single mention of "bowing" in the entire Qur'an? LOL The reason why in sura 2 verse 43 bowing is mentioned in addition to prayer is (probably) because this verse addresses the children of Israel. The form of the ritual prayers ordained for the Israelites and others included prostrating oneself (Sajdah سجدہ), but not bowing down. This particular way of bowing down called Ruku رکوع ` is peculiar to the Islamic Salah نماز alone. Hence, Raki` in راکعین or those who bow down (in worship) are, obviously enough, the members of the Islamic Ummah, and the verse, in effect, asks the Israelites to accept Islam, and to offer their prayers along with the Muslims. And the reason why it says in Surah 3 verse 43: "You Mary, obey humbly to your Lord, and prostrate, and bow with the bowing ." is because the Sujud can also be made outside of the prayer, but the Rukoo is only done in the made prayer. These are two different things and not like you say that it is supposedly wrong order because in Islamic prayer you do rukoo first and then sujud. The reason why rukoo is usually mentioned alone next to the prayer is because it is a kind of synonym not of any prayer, but of the specific Islamic prayer. That might not be the best explanation, but it's definitely a better explanation than yours by just spouting nonsense that the word rukoo just doesn't mean bowing and the entire world would have had that completely wrong since day one. lol C'mon... I am also a "Quranite" but you are one of the reasons why no one could ever take Quranism seriously. Please delete your video!
Judging by the tone of your message, you don't seem one that could be engaged in an academic discussion. My brief and final comment to you: - I am neither a Quranite nor Quranist. Just a muslim - Words that only appear once are clarified through context of known words/patterns-it’s not rocket science - Quranic Arabic Lisan is NOT that of the Arabs of 9th century nor does it need dictionaries - 48:29 is not a group of people doing a ritual prayer, nor is the ayah talking about ‘foreheads’ stained with physical prostrations - shadows do NOT prostrate. They obey/follow the laws set by Allah - the salah has never changed from one people / race / country to the other. All messengers followed islam and they all did salah what had no movements You can have the last word. Good luck with your studies
@@Wud-Wud Whether I agree with you in part or whole or not, WHY the odious tone and condescension? The impudent LOLs? Why should anyone whom perhaps is on the fence, take anything from someone who speaks like you do? I would assume you're an indifferent atheist by the way you speak. Total lack of ihsan. We are called to speak only with proper grace if the one whom you speak with is not a manifest criminal. Not like you don't already know this, of course. You _relished_ the opportunity to speak in that manner, and the self gratification is perceptible despite your thin veil of self-righteousness. Very common sight on the internet, unfortunately. There is no reason for a thoughtful muslim to take a single thing from you if you refuse to mind your manners as you have here.
@AlMosesPhD You are no Muslim. That much we do know. People like you, follow your whims and desires, and haven't got a clue about Islam, Quran, and Arabic. You don't pray, fast, pay zakat, or perform Hajj. So what is there left? Nothing. Go hijack another religion and leave Islam to Muslims.
First and foremost one we should be looking at is the content inside the namaz why must we present back to Allah,after Allah sent down to us,like those ayat we recite while doing namaz? Such a bad presentation to show to Allah.
I converted to Muslim and live with husband family in Lahore. 😮I am surprised that women here cover themselves but they demand a lot make up things, expensive and luxurious clothes as Sapphire,Nishat Linen, cosmetics,...and sometimes superstitious . Now I understand why. Because most of Muslim community'system nowadays misinterpreter TRUE MEANINGS OF ISLAM THROUGH AL QURAN. 😢😢. My husband sometimes headache when his sisters put a lot make up on their faces. And worse than that, they teach my children to become princess. Everytime I tried to say, they stop me. Tell me guys , please marry sisters,let them go out of home for me. THANK YOU. 😂😂😂😂
The Qur'an does not mention in detail how to perform prayers and how to perform Hajj. It means Muslims have to rely on the teachings and the way Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) prayed and did Hajj. It also shows Qur'an is not sufficient and Muslims needed the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) for practical guidance. The account in Sahih al-Bukhari states that Muhammad's companion Umar protested, "The illness has overwhelmed the prophet. We have the book of God [Quran] and that is enough for us."
@@AlMosesPhD It is based on how the Qur'an is being interpreted and the importance of the Prophet (PBUH) and his progeny. The mess we find is because Abu Bakr, Umar and Othman, who were not well versed in the religion usurped the right of Imam Ali (as) and became Khalifa. It resulted in Islam being divided into 73 sects and the killing of the Prophet's grandson Imam Hussain (as) in the plains of Karbala I find your video boring, I do not listen to them as you are not an expert. PhD in Philosophy, God knows from which university.
@@baqirhemraj7639 If Ali (ra) was supposed to be the first khalifaa, prophet (pbuh) would have appointed him. He didn’t! There is a divine wisdom that non of his own sons survived either. So get your head out of your behind and look at the larger picture! Also Ali was a very reluctant khalifaa. Peace
@@AlMosesPhD Yes Allah said: وَمَآ ءَاتَىٰكُمُ ٱلرَّسُولُ فَخُذُوهُ وَمَا نَهَىٰكُمْ عَنْهُ فَٱنتَهُوا۟ ۚ And whatever the Messenger gives you take it and whatever he forbids abstain from it 59:7 So many narrations of the messenger but many refuse to accept them insisting on polemics and false arguments
@@kuratulqadam8511 Please don't quote half a verse out of its context. Regardless, this is my last comment to you as these convos go nowhere with those for whom the Quran is not enough
@@kuratulqadam8511 Sir Salamoon Alaikum. I'm very new to understanding Quran, but the verse you mention is related to war booty. SO @ Al Moses PhD is correct when he says, its out of context. Jazak Allah Khair
I have grown up with the same teachings of quran as you are giving.
May Allah bless you.
Salamun aleyikum brother. Please show us how to perform salat practically, please that make it simple to understand 🙏
Salamun alykum brother. We are living in a time when this book ( Al Quran ) is revealing its secrets Alhamdullilah and Jazakallah. I am learning from Marvelous Quran channel and we will learn togather.Alhamdullilah.
SA, the Quran has always been talking to those who wish to listen :)
This is a very slippery slope to be on... _"We are living in a time when this book ( Al Quran ) is revealing its secrets"_
Have you ever come across a verse that says plainly that the Quran is a book of secrets?
Most definitely NOT!
On the contrary, there are verses that says... such as this one:
15:1 Alif Lam Ra, these are the signs of the Book and a clear Qur'an.
So, do you think a *clear book* contains secrets?
Beware of the Satan impersonating a wannabee scholar.
salam.
Such sane and humble approach to God message... 🕊
Great observation and analysis.
سَلَامٌ عَلَيْكُمْ
An excellent video.
Much appreciated by myself, and I am sure by many others. Thank you so much. God bless you.
Rukoo also means to humble oneself, to lower oneself in humility, to accept something, to bow to divine commandments
yeah, that's the overall mafhoom
70.23: (اَلَّذٖينَ هُمْ عَلٰى صَلَاتِهِمْ دَائِمُونَ۔)
Salat is 24/7 process (دَائِمُونَ) till death we can't break it, we can't stand up 24/7 in Salat.
Considerable
22.77: يَا اَيُّهَا الَّذٖينَ اٰمَنُوا
* ارْكَعُوا (first step)
* وَاسْجُدُوا (second)
* وَاعْبُدُوا رَبَّكُمْ (third)
* وَافْعَلُوا الْخَيْرَ (fourth)
لَعَلَّكُمْ تُفْلِحُونَ. (outcome of steps)
Great education channel. Thanks a lot
We're all students. Thank you for your comment
Genuine efforts made here to better understand the holly Quran 🎉
Thanks for being so clear
👍
Fun fact: Prostrating to the Black Building thats situated in Mecca and then commiting shirk by treating Muhammad like the son of God like moat traditionalists makes you no different then thosr call Jesus the "son of God" and Hindu who worships idols.
God said the people where "Ummiyan" before Muhammad i.e. they didn't receive a scripture and/or messenger. This means Abraham didn't built the Black building in Mecca.
The traditionalist would say they don't commit idol worshipping when they prostating to the Black Building and thats just a direction they pray at. Well, thats the same logic that idol worshippers use. They don't think that the fake entity they are worshipping is in the idol but thats just the direction they pray.
Walekum Salam janab
Sir verse 41:37 ke baare mein kya kahenge? Usme الشمس and القمر ke lie sajad ka use ho rha hai? Kya wha pe physical prostration hai matlab sajdah ka? Samjhaie...😢
What about the ayah 4:102...and ayah 17:107...where the words sujood and chins have been used....n they say these words are musculine plural...thtswhy they are physical actions....hope u answer..
Interesting observation brother. What he said makes sense though with these particular ayats.
4:102 when they are carrying weapons I get your point. But 17:107 you could replace the bottom they fall in total submission when they hear it.
As remember in an earlier video face didn't actually mean face. But don't take my word for it as I haven't done my due diligence.
I think we have to start translating the Qur'an ourselves and actually understand it, and we should come to the same conclusions.
I'm not sure how, but we need to ask Allah, how we can do it because also brother I'm also questioning so many things now that the Qur'an is right, but it's been translated incorrectly in some areas.
Like the thing about when you have sex with women wash yourselves on 5:6 his point made sense as if a woman read that it would mean when a woman has sex with a woman? I really think certain things have been incorrectly translated.
The question is, how has this consistently happened as multiple people have done there own translations, why would they all collectively make the same mistake as each other? Unless that's the issue, they relied on others suggestions rather than what god put in front of them and maybe peer pressure made them go with what's easiest?
I have no clue, but it's all crazy isn't it? That we could be following Qur'an in the wrong way in some parts when it clearly makes things much simpler than we thought.
May Allah guide us to the straight path and reveal the truth (maybe this is Allah's way of showing us, need to study Arabic I think and do our own due diligence but yeah not sure how yet).
@@Zeridium Thanks to have an opinion on my question....yeah we don't know much about Qur'an...n we try our best to understand...still we think n question....same happened with me ...I heard Moses and found that logical...but I came to these verses and got stuck again....hope in future confusion regarding this video gets cleared...
@@user-cd2jl4is4k I think his interpretations are cool, but need to think a bit our selves for examples the 3 prayer times, if they were more to do with duty why would Allah tell us the times to uphold it?
And establish prayer/duty at the two ends of the day and at the approach of the night. Indeed, good deeds do away with misdeeds. That is a reminder for those who remember.
Only Allah can truly guide. I think best way is to pray and be patient and ask Allah for guidance and do the best/ask for forgiveness. Maybe we need to study the Qur'an ourselves somehow and see if we come to the same conclusions.
@@user-cd2jl4is4k Honestly brother, the more I think about it, Qur'an is about a way of life, not rituals, but building Allah's system.
Heaven is where everything is perfect, nice, a final destination with Allah where everything is just how it is meant to be, happy place with no badness in it.
This life, the Qur'an and these translations I think Allah is telling us to follow this so we can prove to him we want a good, non corrupt place, and his way is trying to do it best way we can in life.
Salat is the duty, and constantly thinking about him in everything we do is the prayer/the straight path.
Even now I am thinking of him, when I was advising my friend on what garage to go through, I was thinking (how best can I explain this to them, and is this the right place for them Allah?) and then I explained the place and what they did for me.
This is it man, that is the service to Allah, the straight path.
I am also scared, very scared of all that I learnt may Allah/mostly be wrong the constant pointing to one way and praying but the real salat is doing that all the time in anything we do from fajr, throughout the day until nightfall and then night is our rest. Some get up at night some watches of the night to do his deeds (like parents waking up to deal with a crying baby, that's a duty/salat if we go by there translation) and some at dawn, before their day starts, read Qur'an as a REMINDER. Now I understand why Allah says the angels witness it at dawn, they're recording/checking us and there to see us as witnesses that we are reminding ourselves everyday to follow Allah's way and then we go out and do it for the day. The duty.
And the birds, cats all the animals, Allah says the birds do Salah? And they made a point I never see a bird praying or lining up in rows to pray, but they fly, they sing in the morning when getting up to start their day, do there things and at nice they go quiet, rince and repeat.
Allah wants to use our skills and brains to see what we do with our time.
The martyrs are the ones doing whatever they did and dying in cause of Allah I think, living in his way. Like a doctor who may have died volunteering to help others in war, or say a mother trying to stop their child running on to a road then hit by a car to protect.
She was living in the cause of Allah (we think, or I think it doesn't only pertains to soldiers) and they are alive with their lord as said in the Qur'an. We I think in order to clarify things have to go out of our way to understand and double check this what they've said to confirm.
But see the difference, these people like Sam and everyone invite to use logic and evidence and correct them as they want the TRUTH. What do the traditionists, they call us mad/blasphemous.
What did the polytheists and others do who were from Torah/injeel do? Same thing.
They could not let go, and check it they just were so against it. Look at how our ummah reacts, when we say we should only go Qur'an and try to read and understand it, they get infuriated and then shun, rather than reason, and check what we said.
It's all crazy but there is a reason we have been brought here by Allah. Now we got to make the next step and use our reasoning and evidence to check these facts, or we can just trust it and hope, but again, that's what maybe caused the original deviation in the first place (if this is what has happened and this is not all wrong translation)
But brother, I think this is the real way, and that's the test. The forerunners in the Qur'an, few in the future, many in the past, why?
They were the ones who went against the grain, and went with Allah's way even if they got ridiculed for it by family/ friends.
I was born into islam and thought I had it easy, but our test is just as hard as those not born into it, in a way, as we may have been born into a religion that doesn't follow Allah's rules properly, hard for us to unlearn, Vs those who go from atheist to islam start with plate and then have to decide to follow this traditionalist way or the REAL WAY.
ASSALAMU ALAIKUM and may Allah forgive us for our mistakes man and guide to his path, not man's not some scholars who think, or believe this is right but the Qur'an literally has it all, and I think it's simpler than we have been made to believe.
I think we need a discord where we can all study and share findings, online "masjid" in the name of god. I think this would be good.
Can you believe, that by the grace of god and his all mightiness- the all wise is inviting us perhaps to be of those who fight against the status quo, and to be of those closest to him insha'Allah if this is all true and the traditional translation are all messed up.
Ref: Surah 76 : 25 n 26@@Zeridium
_"Who does that?"_ 🤣
Thank you for that... I've not laughed out loud for quite some time now!
salam to you, brother.
:)
Salaamu Alaykum Brother Moses, when giving us the English translations are they what was giving to us by earlier interpreters or are they your translations according to the Arabic English language or are the from the organic Quranic locution.
SA, based on a Quran-centric understanding of how these terms are used within
@@AlMosesPhD Shukran for your reply. Appreciate the work you are bringing forth to us
Please send me about lallatul qdr
SA, how to 'purify/cleanse'? what is the procedure of becoming purified/cleansed?
Sunnis won't understand this.
No sects in islam
QURAN:
As for those who divide their religion and break up into sects, thou hast no part in them in the least: their affair is with Allah: He will in the end tell them the truth of all that they did. (En’âm 6:159)
@@nakinaki7991 who is sect? Anyone who doesn't follow al the Quran is indeed among the sect. Sunni or Shia all sects
Important topic, informative thanks
👍
Allah did not forget everything. This Qur-an is for people wd reason. Allah does not need to specify how many unit is salat but, just understand the Qur-an, not to twist the meaning. You know how to shorten salat. The prophet led the prayer from that verse u can understand that there are only 2rakaat in each salat.
Great analysis brother
Thank you.
We should speak some day :)
Would love to see a collaboration between you two!
Is there an English translation of the Quran that you believe is accurate in translating?
Search Quran Thinkers. Contains dictionary of concepts. Read Quran As It Explains Itself . Better than most current translations.
Assalamu alaikum brother, I am searching the root word of Rukoo and its meaning. I could not find the meaning and root. would you please share me where did you find this root and its meaning.
SA, you'll find it in all dictionaries under r k e.
But dictionaries are NOT the judge over their Quranic meaning
When we say ‘Rakoh’ and ‘Sajood’ as per Quran it means respecting and accepting Allah’s Authority with humility, humbleness, willingness and submitting with one’s whole being, and then obeying and following the rules, regulations and commandments of Allah as ordained in Quran. -Quran Thinkers web site
@@AlMosesPhD Hello brother, Assalamu alaikum I've been praying Allah to reveal the truth as more and more people who I see translating Qur'an are seeing these inconsistencies (not in the Qur'an but in how the translations have been made)
How has every translation been wrong though is what I'm curious about, we have so many different institutions with the same translations did they just accept it without delving deeper? Peer pressure maybe.
This version of Salah makes more sense and the translation but what would you're explanation be on 4:102 and 7:107, might be worth looking into.
تمام احکمات جو 2.40 سے 2.42 میں بیان کئے گئے ہیں ان سب کو (وَاَقٖيمُوا) نافذ کرو (الصَّلٰوةَ) انکے پیچھے پیچھے چلو اور (وَاٰتُوا الزَّكٰوةَ) ادا کرو (وَارْكَعُوا مَعَ الرَّاكِعٖينَ۔) اور ان احکامات کے سامنے جھکنے تسلیم عمل کرنے والوں کے ساتھ تم بھی جھکو عملا تسلیم کرو۔
Refer to the SUNNAH of RasoolAllah sallallahu alaihi wa sallam,
Authentic is Sahi Al Buqahri.
Salam ,PHD Al Moses, i'm very very much confused now on w/c to follow & w/c one s correct, all of u r using Qur-an as d bases. I knew u have d points. My question, s how do we do salat f not ritual ,in our niyat only or jst intend to do in our heart, ? pls. explain. May d All Mighty reward u for ur efforts f ur research found to b correct. More power & may Allah(swt) increase ur knowledge.
salam,you wrote "My question, s how do we do salat" ?
response :
*Who are الْمُصَلِّينَ the Musalleen ?*
Is it those who perform the ritual prayers ?
Lets find out.
70:19 Verily, man is created with an anxious disposition.
70:20 When they are afflicted, they complain,
70:21 And when good touches him, withholding [of it],
70:22 Except الْمُصَلِّينَ the MUSALLEEN.
70:23 *Those who are CONSTANT in their SALAT صَلَاتِهِمْ.*
70:24 *And They (Al Musalleen) are those who assign a certain share of their property*
70:25 *for the needy and the deprived,*
70:26 *And (Al Musalleen are those) who acknowledge the Day of Judgment,*
70:27 *And (Al Musalleen are the ones) who are afraid of the torment of their Lord,*
70:28 the punishment of their Lord is not something for them to feel secure of,
70:29 *And (Al Musalleen are the ones) who guard their carnal desires*
70:30 Except from their spouses or what they possess rightfully then indeed, they (are) not blameworthy,
70:31 but whoever goes beyond this is a transgressor;
70:32 *And (Al Musalleen are those) who honor their trust and promises,*
70:33 *And (Al Musalleen are those) who testify to what they have witnessed,*
70:34 *And (Al Musalleen are) those who, on their SALAT صَلَاتِهِمْ keep a guard,*
70:35 such people will receive due honor in Paradise.
70:36 What is wrong with the disbelievers who roam around you,
70:37 On the right and on the left, (in) separate groups?
70:38 Does every one of them desire to enter the bountiful Paradise?
70:39 By no means! Indeed, We have created them from what they know.
70:40 No! I swear by the Lord of the Easts and Wests that We have the power
70:41 to replace them by a better people and none can challenge Our power.
70:42 leave them alone to dispute and play until they face the Day with which they have been threatened:
70:43 the Day when they rush out of their graves as if racing towards a signpost,
70:44 with their eyes cast down and covered by disgrace; the day about which they were promised.
70:20 جب اسے مصیبت (یا مالی نقصان) پہنچے تو گھبرا جاتا ہے،
70:21 اور جب اسے بھلائی (یا مالی فراخی) حاصل ہو تو بخل کرتا ہے،
70:22 مگر وہ صَّلاَةَ ادا کرنے والے،
70:23 جو اپنی صَّلاَةَ پر ہمیشگی قائم رکھنے والے ہیں،
70:24 اور وہ (ایثار کیش) لوگ جن کے اَموال میں حصہ مقرر ہے،
70:25 مانگنے والے اور نہ مانگنے والے محتاج کا،
70:26 اور وہ لوگ جو روزِ جزا کی تصدیق کرتے ہیں،
70:27 اور وہ لوگ جو اپنے رب کے عذاب سے ڈرنے والے ہیں،
70:28 بے شک ان کے رب کا عذاب ایسا نہیں جس سے بے خوف ہوا جائے،
70:29 اور وہ لوگ جو اپنی شرم گاہوں کی حفاظت کرتے ہیں،
70:30 سوائے اپنی منکوحہ بیویوں کے یا اپنی مملوکہ کنیزوں کے، سو (اِس میں) اُن پر کوئی ملامت نہیں،
70:31 سو جو ان کے علاوہ طلب کرے تو وہی لوگ حد سے گزرنے والے ہیں،
70:32 اور وہ لوگ جو اپنی امانتوں اور اپنے وعدوں کی نگہداشت کرتے ہیں،
70:33 اور وہ لوگ جو اپنی گواہیوں پر قائم رہتے ہیں،
70:34 اور وہ لوگ جو اپنی صَّلاَةَوں کی حفاظت کرتے ہیں،
70:35 یہی لوگ ہیں جو جنتوں میں معزّز و مکرّم ہوں گے،
70:36 تو کافروں کو کیا ہو گیا ہے کہ آپ کی طرف دوڑے چلے آرہے ہیں،
70:37 دائیں جانب سے (بھی) اور بائیں جانب سے (بھی) گروہ در گروہ،
70:38 کیا ان میں سے ہر شخص یہ توقع رکھتا ہے کہ وہ (بغیر ایمان و عمل کے) نعمتوں والی جنت میں داخل کر دیا جائے گا؟،
70:39 ہرگز نہیں، بے شک ہم نے انہیں اس چیز سے پیدا کیا ہے جسے وہ (بھی) جانتے ہیں،
70:40 سو میں مشارق اور مغارب کے رب کی قَسم کھاتا ہوں کہ بے شک ہم پوری قدرت رکھتے ہیں
peace
Salamun alaikum
I'll cover this off in the 'How to do Salat - aqeemo al-salat' video
@@jaweedpatel Salam, very good question, i like it, bt d problem s, none of his sahabas were alive or jst even sons or daughters of his sahabas, we can get sahi info r enough to justify, d prophet was using ritual or not ritual, bt since Qur-an is d confirmation of d pass, d prophet was instructed by Allah to follow millata Ibrahin s enough to prove, salat s ritual.
@@jaweedpatel I'll come to it in the last video of the series
Don't confuse
Just research
We r not bound
SAJDA (اسْجُدُو) & MASJID (الْمَسْجِدِ) - The word Sajd, Sajood or Sajda as per Quran means submitted with one’s whole being, to follow with complete and utter conviction of heart and mind. Another word used in Quran to refer to the meanings of submission is Rackoh, but there is a difference between Sajda and Rakoh. The word Rakoh means to bend or bow to something or someone in a manner which shows initial acceptance, submission, humility and respect with complete willingness. The word Rakoh although one hand, means acceptance submission and obedience, the full, utter and deep conviction of something or someone but the impact and the benefits of that thing or that one is yet to be experienced and acknowledged, which is then reflected by the word Sajda, meanings submission with one’s whole being in complete and utter conviction of heart and mind, which comes from the witnessing and being convinced of the benefits of such submission. When we say ‘Rakoh’ and ‘Sajood’ as per Quran it means respecting and accepting Allah’s Authority with humility, humbleness, willingness and submitting with one’s whole being, and then obeying and following the rules, regulations and commandments of Allah as ordained in Quran with utter and deep conviction of its benefits. The word Masjid or Masaajid (plural of Masjid) is used in Quran in the meanings of a place, an area of a community, a city, a land where Sajda is being done, that is everyone is establishing and submitted to the law’s rules and regulations of Deen e Islam. X-Reference - 2:58 , 7:11-12 , 9:107-110 , 15:31-32 , 16:48 , 17:61 , 18:50 , 20:70 , 25:60 , 38:72 , 41:37 , 48:29 , 68:43 , 96:19. (تَسْجُدَ;اسْجُدُوا;السَّاجِدِينَ;فَسَجَدُوا;مَسَاجِدَ;سُجَّدًا;سَجَدُو;الْمَسَاجِدِ;الْمَسْجِدِ;اسْجُدِي;السُّجُودِ;يَسْجُدُونَ;سَجَدُوا;سُجَّدًا;الْمَسْجِد;مَسْجِدٍ;مَسْجِدٍ; سَاجِدِينَ ; سُجَّدًا ; يَسْجُدُونَ)
But isnt there another word for Submission/to submit in the quran? If yes, then how does it comes that allah uses 2 different word for the same things.I refer to aslama or aslamtu , Q2:112 or Q3:20
Obey me, and listen to me, seem to be the same on surface. But they are not the same.
@@AlMosesPhD alright, thanks 👍
Ruk3u means submit
so, what does Sajda and Muslim even mean?
SAJDA (اسْجُدُو) & MASJID (الْمَسْجِدِ) - The word Sajd, Sajood or Sajda as per Quran means submitted with one’s whole being, to follow with complete and utter conviction of heart and mind. Another word used in Quran to refer to the meanings of submission is Rackoh, but there is a difference between Sajda and Rakoh. The word Rakoh means to bend or bow to something or someone in a manner which shows initial acceptance, submission, humility and respect with complete willingness. The word Rakoh although one hand, means acceptance submission and obedience, the full, utter and deep conviction of something or someone but the impact and the benefits of that thing or that one is yet to be experienced and acknowledged, which is then reflected by the word Sajda, meanings submission with one’s whole being in complete and utter conviction of heart and mind, which comes from the witnessing and being convinced of the benefits of such submission. When we say ‘Rakoh’ and ‘Sajood’ as per Quran it means respecting and accepting Allah’s Authority with humility, humbleness, willingness and submitting with one’s whole being, and then obeying and following the rules, regulations and commandments of Allah as ordained in Quran with utter and deep conviction of its benefits. The word Masjid or Masaajid (plural of Masjid) is used in Quran in the meanings of a place, an area of a community, a city, a land where Sajda is being done, that is everyone is establishing and submitted to the law’s rules and regulations of Deen e Islam. X-Reference - 2:58 , 7:11-12 , 9:107-110 , 15:31-32 , 16:48 , 17:61 , 18:50 , 20:70 , 25:60 , 38:72 , 41:37 , 48:29 , 68:43 , 96:19. (تَسْجُدَ;اسْجُدُوا;السَّاجِدِينَ;فَسَجَدُوا;مَسَاجِدَ;سُجَّدًا;سَجَدُو;الْمَسَاجِدِ;الْمَسْجِدِ;اسْجُدِي;السُّجُودِ;يَسْجُدُونَ;سَجَدُوا;سُجَّدًا;الْمَسْجِد;مَسْجِدٍ;مَسْجِدٍ; سَاجِدِينَ ; سُجَّدًا ; يَسْجُدُونَ)
Zakah means justification
Is it possible that the ritual prayer was only established for the Friday prayer during the Prophet Muhammad pbuh times.
I'll talk about it in the last video of the series
What s the difference between rukoo and sajood?
And if we are all automatically doing sajood then why are we being told to do it?
Or is it that in all Ayats Allah is informing us that everything does sajood and that we have to rakoo?
We all do these actions because we can't escape the basic laws.
But we can also choose to not do rukoo / sajda per our free will
@@AlMosesPhD we can choose to humble or not be humble. I agree. But what's the difference between these two actions. Rukoo and sajood. As the general understanding goes that there are no synonyms in Quran then there must be a difference between these two verbs.
@@Parhaylikhayinsaan Rukoo = Submit / Accept.
Sajda = carry out actions.
Look out for the 'masjid' video coming soon
@@AlMosesPhD Thank you
@@AlMosesPhD i think your proposition would be more compelling if you prove it through a linguistic analysis and not just spout out what it means , it's a good video , but for extra defence you'll need this.
So wht should one do.?? Only read quran ???
why not? Is it not complete?
@@AlMosesPhD Brother, then no need ritual prayer as we do 5 times a day? But as our general understanding I'd Ruku means bowing..
@@rehman_mr I think the answer is clear in the series so far
brother can u discuss the topic from Quran for overpopulation?I mean does Allah really says that people have to give birth to more kids and can we control overpopulation?pls bro help me in this may God bless you with love and respect ameen🙏🙏🙏
I don't recall anything like that
Sa yahi video urdo me bhi
SA, Urdu mein bhi hay
So you think that if you don't understand a verse you just have to change the meanings of the words to make the verse make sense to you? LOL
The Quran has never been a dictionary of words, nor does it intend to be. In fact, there are words in the Quran that are only used once in the entire Quran. With such words, how can one ever begin to understand the meaning of the words without an appreciation of the general Arabic language which has reached us?
And even if you say that you interpret the meanings of the words based on their roots, you can only find the root meanings in external dictionaries too.
As I am sure you will appreciate, the Quran was revealed to a people who understood the language. Therefore, the language of the Arabs as it has reached us today and any sources which transmit an understanding of a word in that particular context, is implicit to understand the Quran.
Yes indeed, the Quran can be used as a reference or criterion, but the Quran also expects that the audience is familiar with the language for them to be able to grasp its message. Otherwise, the Quranic language (and its message) will end up becoming nothing more than Egyptian Hieroglyphics without the Rosetta stone to assist.
The word "rukoo" is well known and it´s primary meaning is bowing in a physical way. Also the word "Sujud".
Surah 48 Verse 29: " *Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah, and (the ones) who are with him are strict against the disbelievers, merciful among themselves. You see them bowing themselves, prostrating...* "
You can only SEE something is physical.
Surah 13 Vers 15: " *Whatever is in the heavens and the earth do prostrate before Allah Alone willingly or unwillingly, and so do their shadows in the mornings and evenings.* "
Even the shadows do prostrate which proofs that Sujud must be something physical.
You're not seriously telling me that there isn't a single mention of "bowing" in the entire Qur'an? LOL
The reason why in sura 2 verse 43 bowing is mentioned in addition to prayer is (probably) because this verse addresses the children of Israel. The form of the ritual prayers ordained for the Israelites and others included prostrating oneself (Sajdah سجدہ), but not bowing down. This particular way of bowing down called Ruku رکوع ` is peculiar to the Islamic Salah نماز alone. Hence, Raki` in راکعین or those who bow down (in worship) are, obviously enough, the members of the Islamic Ummah, and the verse, in effect, asks the Israelites to accept Islam, and to offer their prayers along with the Muslims.
And the reason why it says in Surah 3 verse 43: "You Mary, obey humbly to your Lord, and prostrate, and bow with the bowing ." is because the Sujud can also be made outside of the prayer, but the Rukoo is only done in the made prayer. These are two different things and not like you say that it is supposedly wrong order because in Islamic prayer you do rukoo first and then sujud.
The reason why rukoo is usually mentioned alone next to the prayer is because it is a kind of synonym not of any prayer, but of the specific Islamic prayer.
That might not be the best explanation, but it's definitely a better explanation than yours by just spouting nonsense that the word rukoo just doesn't mean bowing and the entire world would have had that completely wrong since day one. lol
C'mon... I am also a "Quranite" but you are one of the reasons why no one could ever take Quranism seriously.
Please delete your video!
Judging by the tone of your message, you don't seem one that could be engaged in an academic discussion.
My brief and final comment to you:
- I am neither a Quranite nor Quranist. Just a muslim
- Words that only appear once are clarified through context of known words/patterns-it’s not rocket science
- Quranic Arabic Lisan is NOT that of the Arabs of 9th century nor does it need dictionaries
- 48:29 is not a group of people doing a ritual prayer, nor is the ayah talking about ‘foreheads’ stained with physical prostrations
- shadows do NOT prostrate. They obey/follow the laws set by Allah
- the salah has never changed from one people / race / country to the other. All messengers followed islam and they all did salah what had no movements
You can have the last word. Good luck with your studies
@@AlMosesPhD 😂
@@Wud-Wud Whether I agree with you in part or whole or not, WHY the odious tone and condescension? The impudent LOLs? Why should anyone whom perhaps is on the fence, take anything from someone who speaks like you do? I would assume you're an indifferent atheist by the way you speak. Total lack of ihsan. We are called to speak only with proper grace if the one whom you speak with is not a manifest criminal. Not like you don't already know this, of course. You _relished_ the opportunity to speak in that manner, and the self gratification is perceptible despite your thin veil of self-righteousness. Very common sight on the internet, unfortunately. There is no reason for a thoughtful muslim to take a single thing from you if you refuse to mind your manners as you have here.
@AlMosesPhD You are no Muslim. That much we do know. People like you, follow your whims and desires, and haven't got a clue about Islam, Quran, and Arabic.
You don't pray, fast, pay zakat, or perform Hajj. So what is there left? Nothing.
Go hijack another religion and leave Islam to Muslims.
Very nice
Some Quran alone Muslims are still doing ritual prayers
And that's their personal choice
@@AlMosesPhD true but then they’ll argue and tell you that you’re just lazy to pray
@@missyk2984 I suggest no argument.
Those who get it will, those who don't won't
He is PHD for What
First and foremost one we should be looking at is the content inside the namaz why must we present back to Allah,after Allah sent down to us,like those ayat we recite while doing namaz? Such a bad presentation to show to Allah.
I converted to Muslim and live with husband family in Lahore. 😮I am surprised that women here cover themselves but they demand a lot make up things, expensive and luxurious clothes as Sapphire,Nishat Linen, cosmetics,...and sometimes superstitious . Now I understand why. Because most of Muslim community'system nowadays misinterpreter TRUE MEANINGS OF ISLAM THROUGH AL QURAN. 😢😢. My husband sometimes headache when his sisters put a lot make up on their faces. And worse than that, they teach my children to become princess. Everytime I tried to say, they stop me. Tell me guys , please marry sisters,let them go out of home for me. THANK YOU. 😂😂😂😂
Don't worry
Women may make up fr their husbands only
See(7:29)qibla (10:87)
INTERESTING !!! NO WADHU AYAT IN QURAN.. ???
best to watch that vid in the series
The Qur'an does not mention in detail how to perform prayers and how to perform Hajj. It means Muslims have to rely on the teachings and the way Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) prayed and did Hajj. It also shows Qur'an is not sufficient and Muslims needed the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) for practical guidance. The account in Sahih al-Bukhari states that Muhammad's companion Umar protested, "The illness has overwhelmed the prophet. We have the book of God [Quran] and that is enough for us."
Why do you keep going to 'sunni' this, 'shia' that?
Did you hear the vid? Consider the Quran?
@@AlMosesPhD It is based on how the Qur'an is being interpreted and the importance of the Prophet (PBUH) and his progeny. The mess we find is because Abu Bakr, Umar and Othman, who were not well versed in the religion usurped the right of Imam Ali (as) and became Khalifa. It resulted in Islam being divided into 73 sects and the killing of the Prophet's grandson Imam Hussain (as) in the plains of Karbala
I find your video boring, I do not listen to them as you are not an expert. PhD in Philosophy, God knows from which university.
Allah said Quran is full detailed, u just read but u dont understand it that's why u say it's not detail.
@@baqirhemraj7639 If Ali (ra) was supposed to be the first khalifaa, prophet (pbuh) would have appointed him. He didn’t! There is a divine wisdom that non of his own sons survived either. So get your head out of your behind and look at the larger picture! Also Ali was a very reluctant khalifaa. Peace
If Quran is not sufficient you just disproved all of Islam and made Allah a liar
Gumrah karne wale se bachna chahiye
Is ki theory alag hai
Isko ulmao se bat karna chahiye media se phale
Quran suna apne?
@@AlMosesPhD suna bhi hun pada bhi hun
@@jumanabud3335 Us ki ayat suni? Ya manain, ya apni dalil rakhain
Brains well spent
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Allah's kalam invites intellectual curiosity. Do try it
Beware of people who take the Quran without the Sunnah and the understanding of the pious predecessors - our religion isn’t a thesis
Did Allah ask you / me to follow 'pious' predecessors?
If you read the Quran, you'll find something v different
@@AlMosesPhD Yes Allah said:
وَمَآ ءَاتَىٰكُمُ ٱلرَّسُولُ فَخُذُوهُ وَمَا نَهَىٰكُمْ عَنْهُ فَٱنتَهُوا۟ ۚ
And whatever the Messenger gives you take it and whatever he forbids abstain from it 59:7 So many narrations of the messenger but many refuse to accept them insisting on polemics and false arguments
@@kuratulqadam8511 Please don't quote half a verse out of its context.
Regardless, this is my last comment to you as these convos go nowhere with those for whom the Quran is not enough
@@AlMosesPhD Who is it that explains the context more so than the Messenger of Allah - but people refuse to follow his guidance
@@kuratulqadam8511 Sir Salamoon Alaikum. I'm very new to understanding Quran, but the verse you mention is related to war booty. SO @ Al Moses PhD is correct when he says, its out of context. Jazak Allah Khair