This song is such a raw exploration of the duality of mourning. How you can rage against the unfairness while still reeling from the misery of loss. Such an underrated song that anyone who has lost a loved one can relate to.
I lost my dad a few years ago and every time I hear this song I sing it angry because "Pulled walked away before your time. I can't stand it, it's very unfair," but then I feel better. These songs are the ones that help you show your emotions a little and when it's over, you return to normal.
I LOVE seeing someone rediscover an old song and see it and hear it differently. Great reaction! Subscribed! I think this song is like a way to grieve giving a primal scream and pure energy.
On of my favorite bands from when I was in high school and university. Will actually be seeing them live soon. My inner 20-year-old is really excited. 😁
I am so excited that I finally get to see The Offspring play live in January next year. Smash was a frequently played album during my high school years. The band still kicks ass and writes amazing and relevant songs.
5FDP version was so great and it helped me to find this original version what is also great! So thank you 5FDP, they did cover to honor and respect Offspring. Both are so awesome! Maybe like bit more Ivan Moodys voice with these lyrics but Dexter also awesome
I can never listen to this song without tearing up, this song always makes me think of my niece that passed away in 2014 from a drug overdose. She was so young and had so much life ahead of her, I miss her so much
Love this song, such deep meaning. I have heard this song before and absolutely love it. Every word he sings is so true in different ways to different people. Didn't know who did this song so thank you for showing me this beautiful song that I can now put a title to the group who performs this song. Now I must get their CD!!! Loved your reaction. ❤😊❤😊❤😊
nah its not, i saw a video couple time ago where they explain it, its about somethings hapenned when they was in ''vacation'' with his wife, ....they where in a store when someon starting shooting rounds everywhere, after that he wriht that song, like if him or his wife died in that tromatic experience ( sorry for my bad english ) ....................... if you whant to se that video search for '' The Offspring: Why 'Gone Away' Is So Misunderstood About Dexter Holland's Personal Life '' ( its the title of that video )
Marc is right everyone gets it wrong nobody died it’s him thinking what it would have been like if his wife was taken that day baskin robbins was shot up by young idiots
@michaelserrano3689 You're correct, he wrote this after his girlfriend was killed in a car accident. I don't know what (marc5384152) is talking about, but it has nothing to do with this song if it happened at all. 》Edit/Addition《 I checked out the video and channel (marc5384152) referenced and found that channel has a long history of posting videos with false information about subjects that have a polarizing aspect just to get views and comments on his channel. There's even a disclaimer at the beginning of his videos stating that he holds no accountability for the accuracy of the information in his videos
Please, please do the summary at the end :) Otherwise one of my favorite songs. Five finger death punch does a nice cover of this ! And again, your sister has epic music taste!
@@davidward9737 define “younger” lol. I’m 26 and grew up with FFDP but most of us are well aware that offspring did it first and better for what it’s worth. FFDP is known for different songs
Stand mic gives more movement, but the mic they used is like a pendulum, which plays more for the atmosphere the video is creating. And I was a college freshman when this tune came out and had dealt with a friend’s death, so to me, the song hit the right beats.
About 7 years ago my mom was in the hospital for the last time. The rest of the family wanted to pull the plug but me and my sister wanted to take a day to talk about it because we knew our mom would want at least that. So we did and decided that it would be best to let her go. So we got in the car and this was the first song that came on. I immediately hit skip and was like, nah not today. Took like 5 years before I finally said ok and didn't skip the song when it came up.
I understand Ive probably forgotten more songs and bands then i remember, and the only way to trigger those memories is to see someone elses reaction or mention
People use "iconic" way too often these days, to describe things that are just good, not emblematic of something. This song is truly iconic, it captures the essence of The Offspring, and even the whole rock movement at that point in time.
Time for Missioned Souls version….family band from Philippines….you will get a kick out of it….then check-out their cover of Journey’s Separate Ways, and then all their other amazing covers!
This is so much better then the Five Finger Death Punch cover, to me anyways. I know people like the meaning of the FFDP video, but I remember when this version came out, so maybe that is why I like it better.
This song was covered by Five Finger Death Punch with very minor changes to the lyrics and a reaction done by you that you had posted here on TH-cam about 10 months ago.
This is one of my favorite OFFSPRING songs, FIVE FINGER DEATH PUNCH covered it, NOTHING LIKE THIS, this is a great song, Dex is a great singer also has a PHD
@@CoreyWickramasekeraI think the 5 finger version is a song that we have heard the sad depressed loss done better. This hits an emotion not hit as often. A band that did that well back in the Day was Stabbing Westward
Hmm, my musical taste hasn't really changed much since my teens a bit over 50 years ago. Finding newer stuff that satisfies it isn't that easy, though.
All right then I have a request for you please. There is a group called rainbow. The song would be called stargazer. It is the lead guitar player from an old band called deep purple with their front man. Ronnie James Dio. dio went on to have a solo career and also was the second lead singer for a band you might have heard of called Black Sabbath
I just don't know how you could remember this unless your sister listened to the Greatest Hits album for years after its release. Then, why would she know this song? She would have to be a lot older than you, or your parents were into The Offspring and your sister liked it from a very young age.
You reacted to 5 finger death punch 's video of this song about a year ago. They sound very different.....but still recognizable as the same song. You picked up on the lyrics but didn't connect them
my favorite song of theirs, gotta get away being their second and pay the man being excellent. their IXNAY ON THE HOMBRE is an amazing album much better when they're serious than the goofy songs, but those get them money tho
@rayactions Indeed, FFDP did a version of this song, to which you already reacted. But nothing to do with one interpretation with the other. The version by FFDP (a band that I like a lot, although not exactly that version) is simply a normal song, with respect to which the virtues it has are not from the version itself, but from the beautiful composition of lyrics and music from the original song, which Dexter Holland composed after having endangered his life and that of his wife in a shooting in which they were accidentally involved (although there is an erroneous legend that Holland composed it in honor of a deceased girlfriend). However, the original Offspring song is a marvel, far, far superior to the FFDP version, not least because Ivan Moody's voice is a very good voice, but Dexter Holland is simply one of the 40s or 50s (I would say i) best vocalists in rock history.
The only Offspring song that is true and heartfelt…. They nail this song to the wall and envelope all the emotions, beautifully….. Their one true masterpiece of pop/rock.
In The Offspring version you strongly feel the anger and frustration that you can't change what happened, but Five Finger Death Punch conveys the sadness better. 2 brilliant versions of the same song
This song is such a raw exploration of the duality of mourning. How you can rage against the unfairness while still reeling from the misery of loss. Such an underrated song that anyone who has lost a loved one can relate to.
I lost my dad a few years ago and every time I hear this song I sing it angry because "Pulled walked away before your time. I can't stand it, it's very unfair," but then I feel better. These songs are the ones that help you show your emotions a little and when it's over, you return to normal.
Offspring are such a great band
I LOVE seeing someone rediscover an old song and see it and hear it differently. Great reaction! Subscribed! I think this song is like a way to grieve giving a primal scream and pure energy.
MY dear sister just passed. she loved this (as i do)... will always think of her. Gonna miss you Tonya!
Hugs to you and to heaven!
On of my favorite bands from when I was in high school and university. Will actually be seeing them live soon. My inner 20-year-old is really excited. 😁
I am so excited that I finally get to see The Offspring play live in January next year. Smash was a frequently played album during my high school years. The band still kicks ass and writes amazing and relevant songs.
Saw Offspring live at Lolapallooza São Paulo, awesome perfomance!
The original.. Yes!! This needs to get more love over 5FDP since alot of people think they originally did it and it was a remake.
5fdp butchered this song IMO.
@@vizion311 I'm not a fan of their version and turning it into a war song.
5FDP version was so great and it helped me to find this original version what is also great! So thank you 5FDP, they did cover to honor and respect Offspring. Both are so awesome!
Maybe like bit more Ivan Moodys voice with these lyrics but Dexter also awesome
@@davidward9737
With these lyrics, topic can be many things
5FDP butchered this totally. This version was perfection from the offspring. Should never have been touched
I'm 34 years old, I'm so glad I grew up with the music I did. My mate really loved the offspring! Brings back great memories.
Great song, great singer and frontman! Credits for the choice also...❤🎉
Finally someone reacting to the Original!
I can never listen to this song without tearing up, this song always makes me think of my niece that passed away in 2014 from a drug overdose. She was so young and had so much life ahead of her, I miss her so much
Love this song, such deep meaning. I have heard this song before and absolutely love it. Every word he sings is so true in different ways to different people. Didn't know who did this song so thank you for showing me this beautiful song that I can now put a title to the group who performs this song. Now I must get their CD!!! Loved your reaction. ❤😊❤😊❤😊
This came on the radio in 2015 as I was driving home from my father's funeral. Still hits me today.
Chevelle - send the pain below reaction
If remember correctly Dexter wrote this in memory of his girlfriend who passed away. It's a beautiful song
nah its not, i saw a video couple time ago where they explain it, its about somethings hapenned when they was in ''vacation'' with his wife, ....they where in a store when someon starting shooting rounds everywhere, after that he wriht that song, like if him or his wife died in that tromatic experience ( sorry for my bad english ) ....................... if you whant to se that video search for '' The Offspring: Why 'Gone Away' Is So Misunderstood About Dexter Holland's Personal Life '' ( its the title of that video )
Marc is right everyone gets it wrong nobody died it’s him thinking what it would have been like if his wife was taken that day baskin robbins was shot up by young idiots
@michaelserrano3689 You're correct, he wrote this after his girlfriend was killed in a car accident. I don't know what (marc5384152) is talking about, but it has nothing to do with this song if it happened at all.
》Edit/Addition《
I checked out the video and channel (marc5384152) referenced and found that channel has a long history of posting videos with false information about subjects that have a polarizing aspect just to get views and comments on his channel. There's even a disclaimer at the beginning of his videos stating that he holds no accountability for the accuracy of the information in his videos
@@marc5384152that is true
His sister
I couldn't listen to this song for a long time after my mom passed in 2017. It'd break my heart any time it came on the radio.
Please, please do the summary at the end :) Otherwise one of my favorite songs. Five finger death punch does a nice cover of this ! And again, your sister has epic music taste!
Much better then the five finger death punch version
With rare exceptions, originals (like this one) tend to the better
Totally agree, what is upsetting is younger people tend to think 5FDP originally did this.
Way way better than that shameful remake
It's what my older brother use to hear all the time. I miss him...
@@davidward9737 define “younger” lol. I’m 26 and grew up with FFDP but most of us are well aware that offspring did it first and better for what it’s worth. FFDP is known for different songs
this was my middle school music!!! i miss this!!
Stand mic gives more movement, but the mic they used is like a pendulum, which plays more for the atmosphere the video is creating. And I was a college freshman when this tune came out and had dealt with a friend’s death, so to me, the song hit the right beats.
Theyre a wonderful band.
Also, obligatory mention that Dexter, the singer, has a phd.
In molecular biology!!
@@paulfadeley3496 Ok, but that's...like...the easiest biology....
Still more motivated than most, obligatory, where is your phd comment
About 7 years ago my mom was in the hospital for the last time. The rest of the family wanted to pull the plug but me and my sister wanted to take a day to talk about it because we knew our mom would want at least that. So we did and decided that it would be best to let her go. So we got in the car and this was the first song that came on. I immediately hit skip and was like, nah not today. Took like 5 years before I finally said ok and didn't skip the song when it came up.
You have a beautiful voice!
Can't wait to see them again and again in concert
I've seen them twice live, such a great show each time
Funny that you mention Avenge Sevenfold's song, because I have both that and this song to remind me of my best friend who is no longer here.
I used to listen to this song for hours a day after my mom died from cancer. This song is actually how I felt at the time. 😢
:(
I understand Ive probably forgotten more songs and bands then i remember, and the only way to trigger those memories is to see someone elses reaction or mention
I love your reactions your face expressions you are extremely beautiful and charming Raychel❤
I feel you. my sister used to listen to guns n roses in her teens, while I listened to trash. and now its vice versa.
People use "iconic" way too often these days, to describe things that are just good, not emblematic of something. This song is truly iconic, it captures the essence of The Offspring, and even the whole rock movement at that point in time.
Time for Missioned Souls version….family band from Philippines….you will get a kick out of it….then check-out their cover of Journey’s Separate Ways, and then all their other amazing covers!
I covered this song on my channel. Always liked this band. Smash with Dookie is, for me, the best punk rock album.
My favorite song of theirs; more Pop/Rock than Punk but a great song none the less.
This is so much better then the Five Finger Death Punch cover, to me anyways. I know people like the meaning of the FFDP video, but I remember when this version came out, so maybe that is why I like it better.
Sounds like your sister has great taste in music. You should do a reaction with her in the future.
This song was covered by Five Finger Death Punch with very minor changes to the lyrics and a reaction done by you that you had posted here on TH-cam about 10 months ago.
I want this played at my funeral.
Offspring doesnt get enough credit
I read the inspiration for this song was someone close to him passing away from Cancer
I love how you ad-libbed a Starkid musical song when you realized your copy-paste error.
You should react to Billy Howerdel's recent solo album - song called Free and Weightless. He is the second vocalist in A Perfect Circle.
Offspring kicks ass!
Sloan, I would gladly trade places. You were by far a better person. I miss you and I love you, wherever you are.
noctura does a great cover of this classic
I didn't recognize the title and artist, but I remember the song.
Shinedown - Through the Ghost
Pretty sure Dexter is an actual rocket scientist or something very similar.
Phd in molecular biology, and has done a fair amount of research into HIV, even got a paper on it published in 2013
The original is much rawer than five finger death punch's iteration. It's not made for money but for what it means to Dexter.
Several months ago you reacted to the Five Finger Death Punch cover of this song.
This is one of my favorite OFFSPRING songs, FIVE FINGER DEATH PUNCH covered it, NOTHING LIKE THIS, this is a great song, Dex is a great singer also has a PHD
Think Five Finger Death Punch version lost the desperation that is so obvious in the way the offspring does it
@@unwokeatheist EXACTLY, FIVE FINGER DEATH PUNCH tries to keep it slow and dark, I'm not a fan of them.
@unwokeatheist they covered BAD COMPANY too, and the kids today, HAVE NO CLUE about the original
@@CoreyWickramasekeraI think the 5 finger version is a song that we have heard the sad depressed loss done better. This hits an emotion not hit as often. A band that did that well back in the Day was Stabbing Westward
@@unwokeatheist I remember them, only remember one song, can't remember the name
Sometimes when they play it live he plays on a piano
Hmm, my musical taste hasn't really changed much since my teens a bit over 50 years ago. Finding newer stuff that satisfies it isn't that easy, though.
They do a slow piano version of this as well
Have you done a reaction for - A Perfect circle- The Packsge
You’re adorable 😊
You should do a reaction of the cover this song by Noctura.
next Avenged Sevenfold The Stage please
All right then I have a request for you please. There is a group called rainbow. The song would be called stargazer. It is the lead guitar player from an old band called deep purple with their front man. Ronnie James Dio. dio went on to have a solo career and also was the second lead singer for a band you might have heard of called Black Sabbath
I just don't know how you could remember this unless your sister listened to the Greatest Hits album for years after its release. Then, why would she know this song? She would have to be a lot older than you, or your parents were into The Offspring and your sister liked it from a very young age.
Can you do Lost or G by Avenged Sevenfold next?
Im always sang this song in videoke
The Offspring
* Bad Habit
* Genocide
* Smash
Adam's song by Blink 182
You reacted to 5 finger death punch 's video of this song about a year ago. They sound very different.....but still recognizable as the same song. You picked up on the lyrics but didn't connect them
Is it just me, or.. I just thought…. With so much crap going on in the world today, rock would make a big resurgence.
Peak Offspring.
my favorite song of theirs, gotta get away being their second and pay the man being excellent.
their IXNAY ON THE HOMBRE is an amazing album much better when they're serious than the goofy
songs, but those get them money tho
Noctura does a cover of this song that is really nice.
@rayactions Indeed, FFDP did a version of this song, to which you already reacted. But nothing to do with one interpretation with the other. The version by FFDP (a band that I like a lot, although not exactly that version) is simply a normal song, with respect to which the virtues it has are not from the version itself, but from the beautiful composition of lyrics and music from the original song, which Dexter Holland composed after having endangered his life and that of his wife in a shooting in which they were accidentally involved (although there is an erroneous legend that Holland composed it in honor of a deceased girlfriend). However, the original Offspring song is a marvel, far, far superior to the FFDP version, not least because Ivan Moody's voice is a very good voice, but Dexter Holland is simply one of the 40s or 50s (I would say i) best vocalists in rock history.
Please react to The Offspring
The Kids Aren't Alright Music Video
Please react swallowed by bush. Maybe this song stuck to your mind also or im very sure. You get a surprise.
I dont know if you take requests but End of Heartache by Killswitch Engage please
Pls listen Silverchair - emotional sickness
One ok rock - stand out fit in
I can't finish it.... reminder of losing my parents
Thank God it's not the ffdp version
Since you like deep singer voices, try Saviour Machine: Carnival of Souls, Legion, or Jesus Christ (all can be found live)
THIS VERSION IS SUPERIOR
woooww One My Fav Band in teeanger.. Hai raya, Pleas React Dimash New Song I've Got You... i Think you will like it.
The only Offspring song that is true and heartfelt…. They nail this song to the wall and envelope all the emotions, beautifully….. Their one true masterpiece of pop/rock.
Honored to be the 293rd view of this vid 😂
Please reaction.. The offspring hammerhead live t mobile playground 2008.... ☺☺☺
Requested songs in ur link. Hope you'll check it.
React to Soda Stereo - Profugos
Anyone else want to see her do snuff by slipknot?
I think she has already
In The Offspring version you strongly feel the anger and frustration that you can't change what happened, but Five Finger Death Punch conveys the sadness better. 2 brilliant versions of the same song
My wife died over a year ago now. I still can't listen to this song anymore. I liked your vid, but forgive me for not watching 😢
Now react to Watain
Send them with guns n' roses Metallica
Yep. I am sure when you were younger, you were no doubt a Taylor Swift fan girly.
That version is a Original
Can you please react to forest nella fantasia
Great reaction to a great song. Five Finger Death Punch does a great cover of this also.
Not great. Pop cover
As much as I love the original, I think the piano version they released a few years ago hits me more.
No
The original is the best, not that crappy rendition 5fdp tried to do
I'm not really a fan of ffdp
if you Wanna learn about wireless microphones watch Garth Brooks videos from the 90's
This chick
FFDP cover of this song is excellent!!! Harder feel to a heavy topic
Five finger death punch covered this song… that one is hard to handle.
Bmth mom