I know it depends on the luck of the draw and the silicon lottery, but what about manual overclocking capability difference between these two specific cards, did you try getting the max clocks out of them, if so could you please share the number here with us, thanks.
Got the same card here, I think it's great for the price. using vsync fan stop is on most if not all most all of the time, max 64 degrees. No coil whine, only when I play say CS:GO vsync off and it's doing crazy FPS.
Would be more interesting to see the overclocking results, you should try it without unlocking the voltage if you are worried about damaging the cards. I heard somewhere the 10 series gigabyte cards have bad mosfets in them but it doesn't seem to hurt their scores. I'm looking at a asus dc 1070 vs an asus strix 1070 personally.
In UK this gtx 1080 g1 gaming was 619gbp and gtx 1080 xtreme gaming was 679 but i still bought gtx 1080 xtreme gaming because of bigger cooler much bigger fans 2 power connectors and more oc headroom, i have r9 290x winforce oc and i know how loud can be 3 x 80mm fans, ofc tdp is 300w not 180w but they could done like 90mm fans instead of small ones like 80mm
Any Nvidia GPU featuring GPU Boost will go higher than the advertised boost speeds, they have been doing it for a while since we are up to GPU Boost 3.0 now 8-]
Nice vid, do you think when the 1080 TI hits next year we will able to have ultra setting and game at 4k? Or still 2 years away (1180 TI 60fps 4k ready?? lol). I'm going to stay on my cheaper 1070 for now, since I only run 1440p.
what i'm more interested is cf and sli values.. most expected tests are 1060 1070 1080 470 and 480 solo and dual comparisons for me... thx and good luck man..
Have you experienced any fan defects or bending? I plan on purchasing this card but gotta get some feedback I heard there were a few problems ... would you recommend to buy xtreme or g1?
Was going to get a new 1070 or 1080, but then saw a used Aorus 1080 xtreme for A$675 and grabbed it. Not bad considering they are around $1000 or more when new. And until you actually hold it, you don't realise how big and heavy they are. But love the fan stop function for normal use, all that copper weight and size really helps, even in light gaming, you see the fans stop. Thanks to those huge fans and heatsink, I haven't seen it get over 60 degrees yet (haven't done any major overclocking, so haven't really pushed it yet). For a nonwater-cooled GPU, that is pretty good. Thanks for the Gigabyte comparison (the only one I could easily find), it helped validate my purchase.
G1 used to mean something. nicely binned, .. custom pcb, now all the 10 series cards pretty much perform the same. wtf is the point of buying aftermarket, and why does gigabyte need 3 different versions of cards that perform identically anyway?
Goes to show its not really worth paying $400 extra for the Extreme edition, I seen that G1 Gaming card on special round a bit for about $1000. All of the 1080's perform fairly similarly. Even if you threw in a reference gtx1080 without an overclock you would have a small % of FPS difference.
G1 Gaming 1080 is a great card. Got one as a warranty replacement when my Founders Edition failed. Though other than the factory overclock, the Founders performed just as well with manual OC, also breaking the 2ghz barrier comfortably. The G1 wins for being cooler and quieter but the Founders cards look nicer with their angles and quality finish....
Not worth the extra $50. The cooler is more premium (metal vs. plastic) and obviously does a better job cooling, but a 1080 Windforce has no problems cooling the 1080 even OC'ed -- you'll hit the silicon's limit before you hit the temp limit in most cases. Also, I don't want a 2 1/2 slot fatty in my case; a 2-slot cooler is just right. This is Pascal, not Hawaii.
+Tech Showdown First of all: Nice video, I really enjoyed watching it ! :) But here are 2 Things you might improve in the future: Before taking B-Roll / Photos of your cards you should clean them from dust and fingerprints! Once you notice them, its really annoying and looks kinda unprofessional :x And you should use the Points for Heaven Benchmark, not the Avg FPS! The Points are way more accurate :)
All my benchmarks are accurate, I always test them twice to make sure the results are consistent and within like 0.2fps of eachother, that's why I don't use the GTA 5 benchmark as it isn't accurate at all.
I really don't care which one is faster. It will give you 3-5 frames more,but the look of Extreme version is really sexy.And i really appreciate the better cooling with lower noise!I will buy the Extreme version for 1080p.I know you will say it is overkill,but i don't want heater next to me while i am gaming.I want my PC to run quite and stable while i am enjoying my games at Ultra settings!I don't care how stupid you will find this. :D
ah ok no need i have the g1 as well , to tell you the truth the biggest gain you can see are when you oc the memory cause all gtx 1080 suffer from serious lack of bandwidth ,i have calculated that you need to oc the memory to 6384 mhz for optimal performance wich is impossible so we are stuck at 5500mhz losing around 10 percent possible performance , the coolest video you can make is comparing 960 vs 980 and 1060 vs 1080 demonstrating the scalability of cuda cores in larger gpu's
***** if you overclock 1080 to 5500 mhz memory and downclock 1060 to 3666 mhz memory in theory 1060 should be exactly on half of the performance of 1080 ,after that when you overclock 1060 to 4700 mhz seeing the performance rise showing how much we are loosing cause of lack of memory bandwidth on a 1080
What about overclocking who will spend so much money on a card an will not overclock it?!? Overclocking is the only thing I watch these reviews and no overclock... so yeah...
NOW THAT'S WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT! TECH PORN! LMAO! BACK TO YOUR ROOTS! LMAO! I THOUGHT YOU WERE GOING TO START MAKING TOP TEN VIDEOS! LMAO! I LAUGH, BUT YOU WOULD PROBABLY GET MORE SUBS IF YOU DID SOME GENERIC STUFF! LMAO!
I know it depends on the luck of the draw and the silicon lottery, but what about manual overclocking capability difference between these two specific cards, did you try getting the max clocks out of them, if so could you please share the number here with us, thanks.
I have gtx 1070 g1 gaming, it has a little of coil whine, but it never surpass 67 degrees celcius at full load, and its pretty silent . I love it.
Fedee +1 with a gtx 1070 g1 gaming
1070 g1 gaming, no coil whine max temp 72c oc'ed to 2100/8500
Got the same card here, I think it's great for the price. using vsync fan stop is on most if not all most all of the time, max 64 degrees. No coil whine, only when I play say CS:GO vsync off and it's doing crazy FPS.
Hi, I have the two cards and was wondering if these could be used together with the sli bridge?
Would be more interesting to see the overclocking results, you should try it without unlocking the voltage if you are worried about damaging the cards. I heard somewhere the 10 series gigabyte cards have bad mosfets in them but it doesn't seem to hurt their scores. I'm looking at a asus dc 1070 vs an asus strix 1070 personally.
Find out which rx 480 is the best. XFX GTR vs MSI gaming?
hi my friend. could you answer me if the xtreme one is sagging on the motherboard?
Spoiler alert. 2fps is the difference.
In UK this gtx 1080 g1 gaming was 619gbp and gtx 1080 xtreme gaming was 679 but i still bought gtx 1080 xtreme gaming because of bigger cooler much bigger fans 2 power connectors and more oc headroom, i have r9 290x winforce oc and i know how loud can be 3 x 80mm fans, ofc tdp is 300w not 180w but they could done like 90mm fans instead of small ones like 80mm
290x vs a 1060 how about that?
So the new pascal GPU's will boost higher than their advertised boost speeds?
Any Nvidia GPU featuring GPU Boost will go higher than the advertised boost speeds, they have been doing it for a while since we are up to GPU Boost 3.0 now 8-]
***** Why don't aftermarket card distributors use this higher boost speed in their ad's for an advantage over competitors?
i have a question, since they both have the same GPU and Vid RAM, can you SLI a xtreme and normal 1080?
fdjw88 yes
Hey, what case is that?
Why dont you have temperatures listed if you benchmark them?
Try watching at 9:15
hey there could you tell me how much you could get a 1080 card now? (since it dropped in price) oh and love from New Zealand
Nice vid, do you think when the 1080 TI hits next year we will able to have ultra setting and game at 4k? Or still 2 years away (1180 TI 60fps 4k ready?? lol). I'm going to stay on my cheaper 1070 for now, since I only run 1440p.
Yeah I would say so, the 1080 Ti is going to be a slightly cut down version of the Titan XP so it should have similar performance to that
Can i sli them G1 and xtreme together?
yes
what i'm more interested is cf and sli values.. most expected tests are 1060 1070 1080 470 and 480 solo and dual comparisons for me... thx and good luck man..
extra 8pin for 2 - 7fps more?
Kindly Pls..review AORUS GTX 1080 Ti XTREME (1746Mhz) vs MSI 1080 Ti Gaming X (1683Mhz) vs Asus Strix 1080 Ti (1708Mhz) asap.. Thks...!
Here from Tech Lounge! nice video :)
could you do reviews for 1070 cards made by gainward, palit, galax, or colorful? Nice video :)
Have you experienced any fan defects or bending? I plan on purchasing this card but gotta get some feedback I heard there were a few problems ... would you recommend to buy xtreme or g1?
Was going to get a new 1070 or 1080, but then saw a used Aorus 1080 xtreme for A$675 and grabbed it. Not bad considering they are around $1000 or more when new. And until you actually hold it, you don't realise how big and heavy they are. But love the fan stop function for normal use, all that copper weight and size really helps, even in light gaming, you see the fans stop. Thanks to those huge fans and heatsink, I haven't seen it get over 60 degrees yet (haven't done any major overclocking, so haven't really pushed it yet). For a nonwater-cooled GPU, that is pretty good. Thanks for the Gigabyte comparison (the only one I could easily find), it helped validate my purchase.
G1 used to mean something.
nicely binned, .. custom pcb,
now all the 10 series cards pretty much perform the same.
wtf is the point of buying aftermarket,
and why does gigabyte need 3 different versions of cards that perform identically anyway?
Question: What case is tech showdown using ?? its look so awesome
- Anthony
My Rig Specs: bit.ly/2buaaaj
thanks a lot kevin =)
From NZ?
Goes to show its not really worth paying $400 extra for the Extreme edition, I seen that G1 Gaming card on special round a bit for about $1000. All of the 1080's perform fairly similarly. Even if you threw in a reference gtx1080 without an overclock you would have a small % of FPS difference.
G1 Gaming 1080 is a great card. Got one as a warranty replacement when my Founders Edition failed. Though other than the factory overclock, the Founders performed just as well with manual OC, also breaking the 2ghz barrier comfortably.
The G1 wins for being cooler and quieter but the Founders cards look nicer with their angles and quality finish....
Liked and subscribed. Just ordered the G1 gaming from playtech cheers
Miss watching you!
Hey nice vid, I am tossing up between these two cards so this was very helpful for me.
Awesome! Glad to have helped!
My G1 runs at a stable 2050 mhz with plus 500mhz on the memory, it reaches max 80 C under long and heavy load :)
Not worth the extra $50. The cooler is more premium (metal vs. plastic) and obviously does a better job cooling, but a 1080 Windforce has no problems cooling the 1080 even OC'ed -- you'll hit the silicon's limit before you hit the temp limit in most cases. Also, I don't want a 2 1/2 slot fatty in my case; a 2-slot cooler is just right. This is Pascal, not Hawaii.
They're both pretty loud. Also dayum and I thought Canadian prices were bad.
Just picked one of these up for 475USD after tax and shipping
The G1
Murrrrica
g1 gaming is 1300 leva in Bulgaria so
+Tech Showdown
First of all: Nice video, I really enjoyed watching it ! :)
But here are 2 Things you might improve in the future:
Before taking B-Roll / Photos of your cards you should clean them from dust and fingerprints!
Once you notice them, its really annoying and looks kinda unprofessional :x
And you should use the Points for Heaven Benchmark, not the Avg FPS!
The Points are way more accurate :)
All my benchmarks are accurate, I always test them twice to make sure the results are consistent and within like 0.2fps of eachother, that's why I don't use the GTA 5 benchmark as it isn't accurate at all.
My g1 gets up to 2500mhz and it sits around 80f
I really don't care which one is faster. It will give you 3-5 frames more,but the look of Extreme version is really sexy.And i really appreciate the better cooling with lower noise!I will buy the Extreme version for 1080p.I know you will say it is overkill,but i don't want heater next to me while i am gaming.I want my PC to run quite and stable while i am enjoying my games at Ultra settings!I don't care how stupid you will find this. :D
finally i come across someone from New Zealand!!! and great showdown tho!!
got my xtreme gaming today for $1199. From my old gigabyte 960 to a xtreme gaming 1080. The difference is unreal.
James Toumazis 1200 dollars? Wtf?
AnimalzyNL In Australia dude
damn rip australians
the difference i saw in fps from both doesnt worth the difference of extra bucks
there is no reason to buy the extreme version for 300 dollar more
I'm using the G1 at 1080p 75hz
I am too :)
Just bought a G1 used for $300
@@TheRedstonePlayerMC I got it brand new for 500, how do i overclock? There are two softwares, aorus engine and extreme engine
been around since the declaration of independence was signed i cant with this guy omg i laughed so hard i went to sleep 😂
Hello brother give me graphic card please bro please give me 🙏
3-6 fps gain on the Extreme..
Tech Showdown+ thats what i wanted to see , just yesterday i bought 1080 g1 and thought i fucked up , now i know i didn't
can you do an overclocked video for g1 and xtreeme gaming
best clocks for g1 gaming are +120 core +500 memory
I can do one for the G1 since that's my personal GPU but not for the Xtreme Gaming since that was only borrowed
ah ok no need i have the g1 as well , to tell you the truth the biggest gain you can see are when you oc the memory cause all gtx 1080 suffer from serious lack of bandwidth ,i have calculated that you need to oc the memory to 6384 mhz for optimal performance wich is impossible so we are stuck at 5500mhz losing around 10 percent possible performance , the coolest video you can make is comparing 960 vs 980 and 1060 vs 1080 demonstrating the scalability of cuda cores in larger gpu's
***** if you overclock 1080 to 5500 mhz memory and downclock 1060 to 3666 mhz memory in theory 1060 should be exactly on half of the performance of 1080 ,after that when you overclock 1060 to 4700 mhz seeing the performance rise showing how much we are loosing cause of lack of memory bandwidth on a 1080
i'd do the video myself but i dont have a 1060
What about overclocking who will spend so much money on a card an will not overclock it?!? Overclocking is the only thing I watch these reviews and no overclock... so yeah...
What is that strange Aussie/Kiwi/Yankee accent there man ? what are you ?
A human being
290 SLI vs 1070
SLI is nVidia. Crossfire X is AMD. Nice.
Derek Swanson Whoops always mix them up..
never do Crossfire its stupid, better invest in a single much faster card.
I got my 1080 g1 gaming up to 2140mhz easily.
The Xreme looks better
0.2-2 fps for about $30...yikes
NOW THAT'S WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT! TECH PORN! LMAO! BACK TO YOUR ROOTS! LMAO! I THOUGHT YOU WERE GOING TO START MAKING TOP TEN VIDEOS! LMAO! I LAUGH, BUT YOU WOULD PROBABLY GET MORE SUBS IF YOU DID SOME GENERIC STUFF! LMAO!
Caps lock is cruise control for cool aye bro
***** YEAH! I PUT THE LOCK IN CAPS LOCK! I'M NEVER OFF ALWAYS ON! LMAO! DIDN'T MEAN TO HURT YOUR EYES! LMAO! THANKS FOR THE GREAT CONTENT!
I,m Tooth
lol
Money talk :)
Vidcards are like apple products, Complete waste of money.
Is that right?
first