people has been hating this group just because the members are from different countries and didn't have any Korean member. but they still being Kpop, they are from a kpop company, they speak korean, they has training for it, people are so mad i'm so happy that now they are being recognize, they are on trending this days, this girls are so good
Yes these girls are on trending! They deserve this so much. The talent in them is amazing and they all shine. The MV is well shot and shows the beauty of India. This is cultural appreciation done perfect and you can tell they have so much love and respect. This is how diversity ❤ I’ve been a fan from the start and i do miss the old members but Gabbi NVee and Sriya do so well and work so well together as a group with fatou. I send love and hope y’all get the recognition you deserve blackswan!❤👏👏
Hi, thank you for reacting to BLACKSWAN KARMA MV! They went to India back in January thanks to the Indian prime minister who invited them to perform on several stages there (the biggest was Hockey World Cup). They worked with a korean mv director and an Indian producer and his team for this comeback. Even tho they had a small budget they were able to learn about Indian culture, traditions, etc... to share it to the fans as cultural appreciation of Indian culture (one of the member is Indian (Sriya), they filmed in her town, Odisha) and I think this is wholesome, this Comeback is serving ✨✨
not prime minister but the chief minister of Odisha(a state in India, not a city) who sponsored the Hockey World Cup-2023 and Shriya is from Odisha too The MV was shot in Bhubaneswar(Capital city of Odisha)...I belong here too.
Fatou actually isn‘t the first black K-pop idol. In fact this same group had an African American member called Alex when they were known as Rania. They only recently rebranded as Blackswan, but the group has been around since 2011. ❤
This is truly the best Black Swan has been so far. There last song was pretty good, but this one is on another level! The channel Ploopy678 did a 2-part history of this group featuring interviews with past members, because it's long and messy, but despite the shadiness of the company, the girls themselves always give their all.
they should n't have shown the usual stereotypical image of cow on street (it doesn't happen in whole of india), otherwise rest of the video was breathtaking really showing beauty of indian culture..
They did great in this one tho. People been hating on this group because of mix of foreigners. Their music wasnt that good before. But this one i gotta be honest the did their best in this one
@@ayoayo1044 just like the Korean comment said please stop putting that on them now we get it. But now let's celebrate this awesome comeback and move forward please 😢 it would be best for the girls
@@ayoayo1044 you telling me close to me, over and over and tonight are bad music. You just want to say something bad about them just say it. They have no skip discography. Dance and vocals. Have you ever listened to tonight ?
They worked hard to learn how to dance, speak korean, sing properly and film this MV in India. The result is stunning for my opinion ✨🙏❤️ The storyline of the MV is not cringe at all. Beautiful culture of India. I'm from south east asia and I grew up in France. I appreciate to see people who love kpop and non asian (except Syria who is Indian part of Asia) reaching their dream in South Korea. Let's support them.
PURPLE-her name is FATOU(FA-TWO) she is the leader and main rapper also she is sengalese and raised in belgium PINK-her name GABI(ga-bee) she is the sub vocalist and is brazialian-german RED-her name is SHIRYA(SHRI-YA I BELIEVE SO SORRY) she is the main dancer and maknae(youngest) BLUE-her name is NVEE(envy)the main vocalist and she is american and former actress
members: Fatou - main rapper (she is from Senegal) Gabi - visual (she is half Brazilian and German) Sriya - main dancer (she is from India) Nvee - main vocalist (she is American) it has another brazilian half japanese member call "Leia" (she was my bias) but apparently she's not in the group anymore
@@yggirlgroups she literally groped and harassed the other members on live and made them uncomfortable/pushed their boundaries and there’s literal proof of her trashing Fatou and liking comments and tweets of racist fans. That’s not exactly someone you should be standing.
@@Oujibug She has mental health problems, so she may not be fully aware of her actions. Also, her and Fatou got into an argument once, which EVERYONE overreacted over. Leia was just upset and felt safe knowing that people cared about her, even if they went about it in the wrong way. Leia is ignorant, not racist. I'm Autistic, so sometimes I say things that I don't mean, Leia is the same. Based off the way people online act, it seems you guys think Neurodivergent people shouldn't be allowed to be K-pop Idols. P.S Leia is talented, which is all that matters.
All members of this group are foreign, they get a lot of hate as theyve had many different members and changes, they used to have korean members but they graduated, this is a comeback and only one of the members was in the last m/v or group lineup, that was fatou she has the rap parts, the rest of the girls this is their debut, the girl in the dance break was sriya she is indian, fatou is the rapper and she is senegalise, the blonde one is gabi and shes brazillian/german, and the girl who did the highnote is nvee and shes mix race american and black, the old members where judy youngheun fatou and leia, fatou and leia had some disagreements and leia was racist and s4d the members so they didnt have a comeback for a while and judy and youngheun were korean and they graduated from the group
Leia is still a member of the group, you know that right-? Also, it was all just a misunderstanding, the only people at fault are the fans and Leia's Mother who was overprotective. Leia is working on her mental health, so she knows she ain't a perfect person. Spreading lies isn't gonna help. There is a difference between ignorance and racism.
She isnt the first black kpop idol. Also theres a Brazilian member in this group. Alex was 1st, she was actually a member of this group then left and completely disappeared tbh and then they changed the name of the group and added Fatou
Si los coreanos siguen con la idea de ya no tener hijos lo más probable es que así serán los grupos de kpop dentro de 80 años, ya que no habrá coreano suficientes para hacer más grupos de kpop
Actually The word 'Karma'...has came from the Holy book of 'Gita'...from India....and the meaning that foreigners know about Karma is wrong as hell.....and btw they dis this video in India....from where the whole world began.....✌️✌️🙏🧡🤍💚
Kpop is a genre, not a racial classification. They work and live in Korea under a Korean company, as well as promote and sing in Korean. That’s literally all that’s required to make them a Kpop group. Besides that, most Kpop groups use western choreographers, producers and songwriters as well as concepts and pop culture. The very backbone of Kpop has been accredited to black American culture by the same people that started it. By your logic, the genre shouldn’t exist in the first place.
Cultural appropriation max by Blackswan Why are Fatou Gabi Nvee allowed to exploit Sriya culture? Only Sriya has a right to dress in traditional Indian dresses nobody else.
they have a indian member they filmed in india the film crew is an indian film crew. if sriya had a problem she would say something. they’re highlighting the culture you see all the indian people in the mv don’t act dumb
@@Doyoungismyfave just see how Sriya was treated after the dreads scandal. She was made to apologise for 1 hairstyle while the whole group cosplays as Indian. Don't tell me how to feel
![THEY'RE BACK & THE HATERS IS PRESSED!!! 😂😈 | [BLACKSWAN] ‘Karma’ Official M/V REACTION](/img/n.gif)
people has been hating this group just because the members are from different countries and didn't have any Korean member. but they still being Kpop, they are from a kpop company, they speak korean, they has training for it, people are so mad
i'm so happy that now they are being recognize, they are on trending this days, this girls are so good
We did have korean members but people still hated
한국인 멤버 없다고 싫어하지는 않아요.
@@piixelll I see people hating on them because of nationality, so yes, it's because of that too
they are mad bc they are living their dream
@@yggirlgroups 전 한국인입니다 한국인들은 다른 국적의 케이팝 아이돌을 미워하지 않습니다. 你这是什么意思？ 你上次不是说你不会忘记天安门而且必定找回民主。
Yes these girls are on trending! They deserve this so much. The talent in them is amazing and they all shine. The MV is well shot and shows the beauty of India. This is cultural appreciation done perfect and you can tell they have so much love and respect. This is how diversity ❤ I’ve been a fan from the start and i do miss the old members but Gabbi NVee and Sriya do so well and work so well together as a group with fatou. I send love and hope y’all get the recognition you deserve blackswan!❤👏👏
So many people spread hate and negativity about this group thank you for being positive ❤
They filmed this in India btw 😊
I haven't read many negative comments so far
@@andyandys5356Yeah because Black Swan proved the haters wrong. But before the MV came out haters were hating on them for no reason.
그룹에 대한 부정과 혐오 퍼트리지 않아요 그런말 함부로 하지마세요
당신이 문제랍니다
@@느림보라이더 ? what do you mean
@@느림보라이더 they weren’t talking about Korean citizens hating it was mostly international K-pop fans hating on them
That's our indian culture ❤🇮🇳🙏 so proud of our girls for showing it so beautifully ❤
Your culture is being exploited for views. Don't support every trash out there
Their B-Side „ cat and mouse“ is also amazing, you should give it a try
Ty for reacting to them, hopefully BLACKSWAN will continue to be successful✨
Hi, thank you for reacting to BLACKSWAN KARMA MV! They went to India back in January thanks to the Indian prime minister who invited them to perform on several stages there (the biggest was Hockey World Cup). They worked with a korean mv director and an Indian producer and his team for this comeback. Even tho they had a small budget they were able to learn about Indian culture, traditions, etc... to share it to the fans as cultural appreciation of Indian culture (one of the member is Indian (Sriya), they filmed in her town, Odisha) and I think this is wholesome, this Comeback is serving ✨✨
not prime minister but the chief minister of Odisha(a state in India, not a city) who sponsored the Hockey World Cup-2023 and Shriya is from Odisha too
The MV was shot in Bhubaneswar(Capital city of Odisha)...I belong here too.
Fatou actually isn‘t the first black K-pop idol. In fact this same group had an African American member called Alex when they were known as Rania. They only recently rebranded as Blackswan, but the group has been around since 2011. ❤
Though she is the first African idol in the whole industry, the only one if i'm not mistaken, her being from Senegal
Alex is a mixed African American. Fatou is from mono racially African and from Belgium and Senegal
Wasn't Alex just a featuring artist?
@@oluwashinaomisanya7487 she was not she was a member but the company did not know what to do with her in the group
0:04 yeah he pointed that out in the text on screen
A diverse group ❤ and they don’t GAF. We need some more Black Swan 🖤🤎🤍💖
This is truly the best Black Swan has been so far. There last song was pretty good, but this one is on another level! The channel Ploopy678 did a 2-part history of this group featuring interviews with past members, because it's long and messy, but despite the shadiness of the company, the girls themselves always give their all.
I would also like mention that this is the first k-pop MV ever to shoot in India 😊
@@lakshmanmanoj3911 woaahh, talking dirty about own country?!! 👏🏼👏🏼
@@lakshmanmanoj3911funny people complain but if this was any other K-pop group they wouldn't bat an eye 🙄
they should n't have shown the usual stereotypical image of cow on street (it doesn't happen in whole of india), otherwise rest of the video was breathtaking really showing beauty of indian culture..
그래서 더 좋음. 새로우니까..
They did great in this one tho. People been hating on this group because of mix of foreigners. Their music wasnt that good before. But this one i gotta be honest the did their best in this one
심한 편견과 부정적인 말은 삼가해주세요 결코 블렉스완 에 도움되지않아요
Blackswan never did bad music, this is just different
@@Fabi_lumina they had bad music and production but they've stepped up their budget
@@ayoayo1044 just like the Korean comment said please stop putting that on them now we get it. But now let's celebrate this awesome comeback and move forward please 😢 it would be best for the girls
@@ayoayo1044 you telling me close to me, over and over and tonight are bad music. You just want to say something bad about them just say it. They have no skip discography. Dance and vocals. Have you ever listened to tonight ?
와우... 뮤비는 처음 보네. 너무 이쁘게 잘 찍었다.
응원해요, 블랙스완~!
I will definitely be supporting them.Very,fresh,talented group❤
Fatou is beautiful please support them blackswan we have to make 50 million fatou rap is awesome
I wish this group be continue because they change the members so many times and this is the best song and mv for them
이번 노래 좋네.!
For real fatuo freestyle rapper so good and the group so talented I love them ❤❤❤❤❤❤
Fatou's mixtape is 🔥
They're in India, shocking that you didn't realize that
he is from America so...
@@Yoshi-fg8om Right that makes sense lol
@@Yoshi-fg8om facts lmao
@@Yoshi-fg8om please don’t generalize us Americans like that…
Y’all do realize a lot of Americans know geography right…
블래스완은 케이팝을 대표하는 걸그룹이 될 실력이 있어요 ^^
Thank you for reacting to them🙏
Here is more songs
Close to me
Tonight (debut)
Get up
Over and over (bside)
Cat and mouse (bside)
they are in India and they have a Indian in their group too and her name is Sriya.
Thank you Sebastian for reacting to blackswan thank u soooooo much they deserve it
Thats for spreading some positivity, Blackswan get so much hate for nothing and are underrated.
Location is from my state ODISHA, INDIA 🇮🇳 how beautiful my state is😍❤
It really is, never heard of Odisha before this mv but now I want to visit. ❤
@@ashantijordane1862 always Welcome
I’m really happy for this group and I hope they grow more. Also Fatou’s name is pronounced like Fa-too.
Can’t wait for SEPT 6th NEW MV FOR cat and mouse for BLACKSWAN 🖤🦢🦢🦢🦢
OMG Cat and Mouse too is really good!
Love all the members they're so talented! ✨🖤🦢
People ARE MISSING OUT on these girlsssss
Thanks for reacting them❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
WONDERFULL
Blackswan currently consists of 5 members:
Fatou- Leader & Main Rapper (African)
NVee- Main Vocalist (American)
Leia- Dancer, Vocalist, Rapper, Visual (currently on hiatus for mental health reasons, Brazilian)
Gabi- Dancer, Vocalist, Visual (Brazilian)
Sriya- Main Dancer, Vocalist, Rapper(?), Maknae (Indian)
Leia is not a part of a group no more.
@@mrpiggy4031 No, she is on hiatus and is inactive, she is still a member of the group.
I've been waiting to long for this😂
Thanks Sabestine for reacting to Blackswan ✌️
From a Lumina with Love🖤❤️
한국인 멤버가 있어도, 없어도 응원합니다. 재능이 뛰어난 사람들이니까요
I love the song
And the mv show Indian culture. And colours
The blonde is from Brazil ❤️🇧🇷❤️
I know this group since.... yes maybe one year. And this group have to get more positive attention.
Yassssssss so this is in India n that is the first Indian k-pop idol Shreya
This mv depicts her cultural assets being an odishi
멤버들 한국발음 진짜좋음
They worked hard to learn how to dance, speak korean, sing properly and film this MV in India. The result is stunning for my opinion ✨🙏❤️ The storyline of the MV is not cringe at all. Beautiful culture of India. I'm from south east asia and I grew up in France. I appreciate to see people who love kpop and non asian (except Syria who is Indian part of Asia) reaching their dream in South Korea. Let's support them.
If you can, you should watch some of their music show performances!!! When I tell you no crumbs were left in sight 😭😭😭
PURPLE-her name is FATOU(FA-TWO) she is the leader and main rapper also she is sengalese and raised in belgium
PINK-her name GABI(ga-bee) she is the sub vocalist and is brazialian-german
RED-her name is SHIRYA(SHRI-YA I BELIEVE SO SORRY) she is the main dancer and maknae(youngest)
BLUE-her name is NVEE(envy)the main vocalist and she is american and former actress
members:
Fatou - main rapper (she is from Senegal)
Gabi - visual (she is half Brazilian and German)
Sriya - main dancer (she is from India)
Nvee - main vocalist (she is American)
it has another brazilian half japanese member call "Leia" (she was my bias) but apparently she's not in the group anymore
Leia was your bias?!?!?💀
Fatou is Belgian Senegalese... That matters..and NVEE is mixed ( white and black) American
@@Pequenaerra yes, why?
@@yggirlgroups she literally groped and harassed the other members on live and made them uncomfortable/pushed their boundaries and there’s literal proof of her trashing Fatou and liking comments and tweets of racist fans. That’s not exactly someone you should be standing.
@@Oujibug She has mental health problems, so she may not be fully aware of her actions. Also, her and Fatou got into an argument once, which EVERYONE overreacted over. Leia was just upset and felt safe knowing that people cared about her, even if they went about it in the wrong way. Leia is ignorant, not racist. I'm Autistic, so sometimes I say things that I don't mean, Leia is the same.
Based off the way people online act, it seems you guys think Neurodivergent people shouldn't be allowed to be K-pop Idols.
P.S Leia is talented, which is all that matters.
Estou tão feliz de ter uma ídol brasileira em um grupo que está indo com tudo , estou realmente me sentindo representada pela Gabi 🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
All members of this group are foreign, they get a lot of hate as theyve had many different members and changes, they used to have korean members but they graduated, this is a comeback and only one of the members was in the last m/v or group lineup, that was fatou she has the rap parts, the rest of the girls this is their debut, the girl in the dance break was sriya she is indian, fatou is the rapper and she is senegalise, the blonde one is gabi and shes brazillian/german, and the girl who did the highnote is nvee and shes mix race american and black, the old members where judy youngheun fatou and leia, fatou and leia had some disagreements and leia was racist and s4d the members so they didnt have a comeback for a while and judy and youngheun were korean and they graduated from the group
Leia is still a member of the group, you know that right-? Also, it was all just a misunderstanding, the only people at fault are the fans and Leia's Mother who was overprotective. Leia is working on her mental health, so she knows she ain't a perfect person. Spreading lies isn't gonna help. There is a difference between ignorance and racism.
@@tjsquibbofficial she legit s4d the members and also shes been kicked out hasnt she
@@DWHKSU Nope, Leia is currently on hiatus.
@@tjsquibbofficial hope she never comes back ♥️
Gabi is of German descent but was born in Brazil and you didn't make that clear !!!
:Roll up' mv is out
Black swan india 🇮🇳
The black member in the group, her name is pronounced as fa-to
There are two black members babe. Fatou AND NVee
that's just how it is pronounced in hangul tho
@@ihavenohometown no that’s just how it’s pronounced
Let's make it to 10 million soon guys on the karma mv , we can do it guys ❤❤❤
Come here cz BlackSwan slay comeback they deserve to be a global worldwide girlgrop
Amei video música 🎉🎉🎉❤❤😂😂
❤
Ta incrível a músicas
You should listen to their song cat and mouse it's my favorite song by them !
check their b-side cat & mouse as well! its good too!
She isnt the first black kpop idol. Also theres a Brazilian member in this group. Alex was 1st, she was actually a member of this group then left and completely disappeared tbh and then they changed the name of the group and added Fatou
💜💜💜
their fifth member leia who is japnese/brazilain is currently on hiatus
Now this is cultural appreciation
Check Roll up their new comeback
I think they also performed on Inkigayo
YOU HAVE TO LISTEN TO CAT AND MOUSE
🎉🎉🎉
Creo que la mayoría venimos por Fatou pero la chica india nos dejo enamorados
“Ms. Fatowel😂”
Si los coreanos siguen con la idea de ya no tener hijos lo más probable es que así serán los grupos de kpop dentro de 80 años, ya que no habrá coreano suficientes para hacer más grupos de kpop
Eu já fui Lumina, na primeira formação...
Pelo visto estou voltando a ser kkkkkkk
Actually The word 'Karma'...has came from the Holy book of 'Gita'...from India....and the meaning that foreigners know about Karma is wrong as hell.....and btw they dis this video in India....from where the whole world began.....✌️✌️🙏🧡🤍💚
wait the credits : aespa - illusions hahahah
Not fatau lmaooo😂
LkoolL
Fatou is not the first black idol by the way :)
Really ? Then who is first ?
Can you stop stop say God blank my brother thankyou peace 🕊️
girl shut up
She’s not the first black kpop idol
The song isn't bad, but I still don't understand what it's like to be a kpop group without a single Korean member... it doesn't make sense
Kpop is a genre, not a racial classification. They work and live in Korea under a Korean company, as well as promote and sing in Korean. That’s literally all that’s required to make them a Kpop group. Besides that, most Kpop groups use western choreographers, producers and songwriters as well as concepts and pop culture. The very backbone of Kpop has been accredited to black American culture by the same people that started it. By your logic, the genre shouldn’t exist in the first place.
Well they still sing and rap in Korean and promote in Korea and they’re under a Korean agency so it is K-pop even if there are no Korean members
you’re actually so stupid
Cultural appropriation max by Blackswan
Why are Fatou Gabi Nvee allowed to exploit Sriya culture? Only Sriya has a right to dress in traditional Indian dresses nobody else.
they have a indian member they filmed in india the film crew is an indian film crew. if sriya had a problem she would say something. they’re highlighting the culture you see all the indian people in the mv don’t act dumb
@@neodxlso No. They can dance wherever they want BUT not wear what only Sriya has a right to wear
You are throwing that word around. You need to learn the difference between appropriation and appreciation
@@Doyoungismyfave just see how Sriya was treated after the dreads scandal. She was made to apologise for 1 hairstyle while the whole group cosplays as Indian. Don't tell me how to feel
@@tyuiop67996how old are u? 7?
This they best song