The thing I appreciate most about rugby players at a high level like this is that when they get a red, they don't shout or go nuts or argue like soccer or a lot of other professional athletes. They take it and walk away. Because most of the time, they already know it's going to happen because they know the rules.
As a Uruguayan, being Futbol (soccer) and Rugby my two beloved sports, I couldn't stress enough how mad it makes me watching soccer players diving, pretending and crying like big babies. My applause to the rugby referees and players who respect the rules like gentlemen.
Head clashes are generally just timing gone wrong unless forwards are recklessly charging into the breakdown.Tip tackles are another thing all together especially when players can pull out or lower the opponent safely and dont.
Yep. A lot of these could be down to bad timing. Things think bastero (or however the French 13's name is spelt) striking the opponent in the ruck, that's a different story.
How on earth can you call this a list of rugby's most deserved red cards when you omit Duncan McRae's red card after he pinned Ronan O'Gara on the floor and repeatedly punched him in the face? Also, special mention should go to manu tuilagi for the most deserved red card that wasn't a red card. After punching Chris Ashton repeatedly in the head.
Sam Cane one was definitely not a red card, 100% yellow card at most, that refs and TMO needs their eyes checked because there is mitigation but they both say no mitigation.
@@RugbyClanOfficialWould suggest if you going to try compiling this type of video again, that you just show clips where referee immediately gives red card. Those are what your video title is deserving of. But showing tackles where yellows were awarded, and then tackle being upgraded to red are simply wrong!
I think the Red should be for flagrant foul play or reckless play. About 50% of these were poor technique or bad luck. Poor technique should receive a Yellow at worst. Rugby is a contact sport. It's getting to the point where you need to field a 16th player : A Lawyer who can tuck in behind the fullback and negotiate with the Referees.
South Africa one was way more worthy of a red card than Sam Cane one was. The South African coach probably paid the English refs to cheat in the final just like they did in the Quarterfinals and Semifinal.
agree with you totally, ridiculous red card. The arm wasnt being twisted just simply being batted at which happens all the times in games , its happened to me in many games and i have dished it out in games. talking to at worst but getting carded is just ridiculous
I hate to sound like a grumpy old fart, but about 1/2 of these don't deserve reds, & 20 years ago they might not even have been penalties. When you go in for a wrapping, ball-&-all tackle, there's always a chance that your shoulder will make glancing contact above the neck, but virtually no harm is done. There's just no way that THAT "offence" is worthy of the same in-game punishment as a stiff or swinging arm across the face, or hitting a bloke in the air while's jumping to catch a bomb, or knees in the back, or a late hit on a kicker, etc ........
Maybe but it’s all about safety now, especially when there is irrefutable evidence that head and neck injuries have a direct link to Alzheimer’s and MND so I’d say the extra caution is definitely warranted. To be fair, lots of the incidents in this video were absolutely deliberate and most of the red cards were bang on
If it was american football those tackles would be legal mainly because of the helmet and shoulder pads hence why they wear them. Maybe Rugby should look into the same technology and make it compulsory before rugby is reduced to ripper rugby.
The thing I appreciate most about rugby players at a high level like this is that when they get a red, they don't shout or go nuts or argue like soccer or a lot of other professional athletes. They take it and walk away. Because most of the time, they already know it's going to happen because they know the rules.
As a Uruguayan, being Futbol (soccer) and Rugby my two beloved sports, I couldn't stress enough how mad it makes me watching soccer players diving, pretending and crying like big babies. My applause to the rugby referees and players who respect the rules like gentlemen.
Head clashes are generally just timing gone wrong unless forwards are recklessly charging into the breakdown.Tip tackles are another thing all together especially when players can pull out or lower the opponent safely and dont.
Someone should get the Barrett boys watches for Christmas then.
Timing gone wrong? They could always tackle below the waist
Yep. A lot of these could be down to bad timing.
Things think bastero (or however the French 13's name is spelt) striking the opponent in the ruck, that's a different story.
How on earth can you call this a list of rugby's most deserved red cards when you omit Duncan McRae's red card after he pinned Ronan O'Gara on the floor and repeatedly punched him in the face?
Also, special mention should go to manu tuilagi for the most deserved red card that wasn't a red card. After punching Chris Ashton repeatedly in the head.
I love this repeat it’s so cool. Keep up the good work guys❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Love the way these big men accept the red card no arguing no tantrums
It's a gentlemans game👍🏻
6:30 who is that?
The pain you feel today
will be the dementia
You enjoy
Tomorrow
they just can t argue the red. animals !!!
3:15 no red card at all
exactly, i dont play or watch much rugby, but that didn't seem like a red, not even a yellow
@@peterhowe547not even a penalty, im confused of what the refs called it for
12 headbutted 13 during the first tackle
@@martspil9848 What ? Can you be serious ? There's no contact at all between their heads.
Was that a young Dan Cole?
4:39 I don’t think this is red card worthy but yellow card is the kicker was dipping after the kick there fore the elbow collided to the kickers cheek
Like the ref said, it was never legal so mitigation. It was a shoulder charge, no arms, and got him in the head. Read all day
Refs need to start using the term, “forearm shiver” when calling those forearm hits.
Sam Cane one was definitely not a red card, 100% yellow card at most, that refs and TMO needs their eyes checked because there is mitigation but they both say no mitigation.
Most of them aren't that bad just poor timing it's the dump tackles and dirty stuff that is bad
Some of these are worse than red some are not red
bro why are you showing nz so much do you hate us or something
No hate here. Didn't know it was all NZ players🤔
I could fight twice the amount of these that are more deserving of worst red cards
You can guess where he's from 🤣
Bro, they showed more saffers.. apparently if you’re good you’re red card worthy 😂
@@RugbyClanOfficialWould suggest if you going to try compiling this type of video again, that you just show clips where referee immediately gives red card. Those are what your video title is deserving of.
But showing tackles where yellows were awarded, and then tackle being upgraded to red are simply wrong!
INSANT RED CARD!
I think the Red should be for flagrant foul play or reckless play. About 50% of these were poor technique or bad luck. Poor technique should receive a Yellow at worst. Rugby is a contact sport. It's getting to the point where you need to field a 16th player : A Lawyer who can tuck in behind the fullback and negotiate with the Referees.
Sam Cane did not deserve that red card in the rwc final
Sam Cane's red was correct as per the rules, but the rules need to be addressed as it was ridiculous for that to be any more than a penalty.
That’s true
South Africa one was way more worthy of a red card than Sam Cane one was. The South African coach probably paid the English refs to cheat in the final just like they did in the Quarterfinals and Semifinal.
That fiji card shouldn't have been. Attacking player can't hold defender.
So, you can retaliate against a minor foul against you by throwing blows?
what rule states that the attacking player can't hold the defender?
agree with you totally, ridiculous red card. The arm wasnt being twisted just simply being batted at which happens all the times in games , its happened to me in many games and i have dished it out in games. talking to at worst but getting carded is just ridiculous
I hate to sound like a grumpy old fart, but about 1/2 of these don't deserve reds, & 20 years ago they might not even have been penalties. When you go in for a wrapping, ball-&-all tackle, there's always a chance that your shoulder will make glancing contact above the neck, but virtually no harm is done. There's just no way that THAT "offence" is worthy of the same in-game punishment as a stiff or swinging arm across the face, or hitting a bloke in the air while's jumping to catch a bomb, or knees in the back, or a late hit on a kicker, etc ........
Maybe but it’s all about safety now, especially when there is irrefutable evidence that head and neck injuries have a direct link to Alzheimer’s and MND so I’d say the extra caution is definitely warranted.
To be fair, lots of the incidents in this video were absolutely deliberate and most of the red cards were bang on
Mitigation, and degree of danger. These words should never be used in the game of rugby. Save it for the judiciary and suspend players after the game.
Those words are used to determine red or yellow. What words would you like then to use?
Game's gone soft
Not the most deserving. Tiddly winks anyone? :)
If it was american football those tackles would be legal mainly because of the helmet and shoulder pads hence why they wear them. Maybe Rugby should look into the same technology and make it compulsory before rugby is reduced to ripper rugby.
So contact that should be illegal becomes legal because your opponent is wearing a helmet??
There have been studies on this exact question. They find that showing less humanity (eg the face) makes the opponents more brutal by far
Go back to the gay parade and leave American Sissy Football out of this.
This’ll just lead to more injuries and poorer form tackles. This coming from 8 years of American football and 15 years of rugby experience
rugby a borefest these days
Rugby and leauge have become so weak and soft. Would rather watch paint dry.
Most of these wouldn’t be penalties in real sports.
YOU WOULDN'T LAST A MINUITE IN "AMERICAN" N.F.L.!
Sure. Cool story bro.
what will all the tupperware crap they have on mate! i dont think so!
Americans - our sport stars have the most brain damage USA USA USA
Americans are soft and need pretty armour to play contact sports. Go back to the pride parade you fruit