Hello Rabbi, hello all. I just wanted to complement you on your excellent content. I really enjoy watching all of it including your discussions. I have a huge interest in ancient history and religion, especially in the near East and you are always accurate and unbiased. I found your videos via my interest in watching the lectures on this channel by Professor Israel Finkelstein, having read several of his books. I wish I could join in your discussions, but I fear the time difference between you in U.S and me in the U.K would be a major issue. I wanted to suggest a TH-cam channel that would compliment your videos. You often touch on other historical events going on in the near East that have had a huge effect on Jewish religion and history. You usually describe these events as best you can within the time limits you have. This content can add more depth and context. They produce accurate and unbiased educational videos in a straightforward and easy to understand format. The channel I recommend is 'History with Cy'. The channel specialises in the ancient history of the Near East. Take a look it's a great channel especially if your new to the subject. Keep up the good work and I look forward to watching all your future content.
this sooo civilised! White men who do NOT speak with forked tongue. Nice! THIS is what makes contemporary USA 'great'. Thanks, guys. - a message from Sri Lanka. Rabbi, I love your intellect.
Dr. Amanda Podany cites earlier "the gods allowed our defeat because they were displeased" narrative from Sumerian and Akkadian writings. It is not necessarily unique to Judean (but I will have to go back to find specific examples). I think it shows up in the Neo-Sumerian period.
If you go to this playlist and start with the one you are watching, it should play the next in the series. Thanks for watching! th-cam.com/play/PLyHcweASuE6_PI19EOGi0wqoAF8dbfV1C.html
Ezra (at 8:03) seems to place the Name in the mouth of Cyrus. And yet the famous Cylinder says Nabonidus was thrown down for blasphemy against Marduk and Cyrus was raised by Marduk. Begging the question, What is the relationship between the concept of Yahweh and Marduk the son of Enki? And what is the relation to the one "broken in pieces" according to Jeremiah 50:2?
Have you done, or are you planning on doing, a video covering the triad of the Ten Commandments? I thought it was curious that of the three passages which depict the story (Deut 5, Exodus 20, Exodus 34) the first two accounts are nearly identical only differing in the reason given for observing the Sabbath if I recall. But the Ex 34 passage gives a wildly different list of commandments that no one that I know of would recognize as being the "Ten Commandments", despite it being the only passage of the three that actually refers to them using that phrase within the text itself. I don't read Hebrew, so I am forced to rely on English translations of the text. Is there some context in the original language that I am missing? Or is this possibly just that the Ex 34 passage is so focused on Jewish festivals and dietary requirements that the Christians sort of overlooked it and emphasized the Ex 20 passage with its more generalized moral/ethical rules so it became the one that many people were familiar with?
This adult education curriculum, "An Introduction to Secular Humanistic Judaism," does explore the 10 Commandments in more detail in its Biblical Literature section of the Jewish Culture part of the program - this year is Introduction to Jewish History. It remains to be seen if we will still be doing video programming in 2021-2022!
I like this. But what happened to the priests of the other gods at the Deuteronomic purge? And what happened to those farmers that were allowed to remain in Juda while the upper class was deported to Babylon? And I doubt the story about the Assyrian total deportation of the entire Israelite people -- the Tanakh is ambiguous about that, and there were (are) the Samarians ...
There are extra-Biblical records attesting to Assyrian deportation policies. You are correct that the peasantry stayed - they may well be the "intermarried" people that Babylonian returnees complain about in Ezra-Nehemiah, or the ancestors of the Samaritans. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resettlement_policy_of_the_Neo-Assyrian_Empire#:~:text=After%20the%20fall%20of%20Samaria,(modern%2Dday%20Iran).
The Zohar as in general Kabbala holds Diviniy as an unified heterosexual couple, which female part, Ashera, had its place within the ohel as in each of the two temples. Todays (modern) Feminism ignores those sources of tradition.
I am enjoying these talks. Thank you!
I love listening to your vlogs.
Why does this channel have so few subs? Its been very informative and deserves to be up there.
Hello Rabbi, hello all. I just wanted to complement you on your excellent content. I really enjoy watching all of it including your discussions. I have a huge interest in ancient history and religion, especially in the near East and you are always accurate and unbiased. I found your videos via my interest in watching the lectures on this channel by Professor Israel Finkelstein, having read several of his books. I wish I could join in your discussions, but I fear the time difference between you in U.S and me in the U.K would be a major issue.
I wanted to suggest a TH-cam channel that would compliment your videos. You often touch on other historical events going on in the near East that have had a huge effect on Jewish religion and history. You usually describe these events as best you can within the time limits you have. This content can add more depth and context. They produce accurate and unbiased educational videos in a straightforward and easy to understand format. The channel I recommend is 'History with Cy'. The channel specialises in the ancient history of the Near East. Take a look it's a great channel especially if your new to the subject. Keep up the good work and I look forward to watching all your future content.
this sooo civilised! White men who do NOT speak with forked tongue. Nice! THIS is what makes contemporary USA 'great'. Thanks, guys. - a message from Sri Lanka. Rabbi, I love your intellect.
Dr. Amanda Podany cites earlier "the gods allowed our defeat because they were displeased" narrative from Sumerian and Akkadian writings. It is not necessarily unique to Judean (but I will have to go back to find specific examples). I think it shows up in the Neo-Sumerian period.
Thank you - interesting to know. It certainly would not be the first time that Judean culture, mythology and religion borrowed from Mesopotamia!
Amazing talks on Jewish history. Is it possible to arrange the series plays in order one after the other?
If you go to this playlist and start with the one you are watching, it should play the next in the series. Thanks for watching! th-cam.com/play/PLyHcweASuE6_PI19EOGi0wqoAF8dbfV1C.html
Hey great work! can I get that pdf? Torah Creation
Ezra (at 8:03) seems to place the Name in the mouth of Cyrus. And yet the famous Cylinder says Nabonidus was thrown down for blasphemy against Marduk and Cyrus was raised by Marduk. Begging the question, What is the relationship between the concept of Yahweh and Marduk the son of Enki? And what is the relation to the one "broken in pieces" according to Jeremiah 50:2?
Have you done, or are you planning on doing, a video covering the triad of the Ten Commandments? I thought it was curious that of the three passages which depict the story (Deut 5, Exodus 20, Exodus 34) the first two accounts are nearly identical only differing in the reason given for observing the Sabbath if I recall. But the Ex 34 passage gives a wildly different list of commandments that no one that I know of would recognize as being the "Ten Commandments", despite it being the only passage of the three that actually refers to them using that phrase within the text itself.
I don't read Hebrew, so I am forced to rely on English translations of the text. Is there some context in the original language that I am missing? Or is this possibly just that the Ex 34 passage is so focused on Jewish festivals and dietary requirements that the Christians sort of overlooked it and emphasized the Ex 20 passage with its more generalized moral/ethical rules so it became the one that many people were familiar with?
This adult education curriculum, "An Introduction to Secular Humanistic Judaism," does explore the 10 Commandments in more detail in its Biblical Literature section of the Jewish Culture part of the program - this year is Introduction to Jewish History. It remains to be seen if we will still be doing video programming in 2021-2022!
I like this. But what happened to the priests of the other gods at the Deuteronomic purge? And what happened to those farmers that were allowed to remain in Juda while the upper class was deported to Babylon? And I doubt the story about the Assyrian total deportation of the entire Israelite people -- the Tanakh is ambiguous about that, and there were (are) the Samarians ...
There are extra-Biblical records attesting to Assyrian deportation policies. You are correct that the peasantry stayed - they may well be the "intermarried" people that Babylonian returnees complain about in Ezra-Nehemiah, or the ancestors of the Samaritans. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resettlement_policy_of_the_Neo-Assyrian_Empire#:~:text=After%20the%20fall%20of%20Samaria,(modern%2Dday%20Iran).
De-rib-ative 🤣🤣
The Zohar as in general Kabbala holds Diviniy as an unified heterosexual couple, which female part, Ashera, had its place within the ohel as in each of the two temples. Todays (modern) Feminism ignores those sources of tradition.
Lemme tell ya-- some Christians also do not like admitting that the Torah didn't come straight from the mouth of God lol