guy's voice most suited for this song..no wonder he won.. if shannon won having this version it will never be a hit at all...he sounded like he's being squeezed or something...
I know they would have had this song ready before the competition had even started, but with no disrespect to Guy, I’d love to see him sing a song in Shannon’s preferred genre. For example, What About Me will never be sung and performed as well as Shannon Noll has.
The song was chosen before top 3 (or even top 4). Unfortunately, Shannon got the bad luck of this. ABMH fit other top 4 (It fit Rob Mills too). Grad that they change the winner single to different songs in later seasons.
This is the format of the Idol show, two remaining contestants will sing the same song, and the wimner of the show will own the song, even the song A MOMENT LIKE THIS in AMERICAN IDOL was performed both by Kelly Clarkson and Jusitn Guardini, then when Kelly was declared the Winner of AMERICAN IDOL, the song became hers
He's not a good singer. If they'd wanted him to succeed, they would have made it happen. Look at One Direction. None of them passed individual auditions and they came about fourth as a group, because it was painful to listen to them sing out of tune
"iTs ObViOuS tHiS sOnG wAs WrItTeN fOr GuY." Yes, a song they wrote before the competition started, was written specifically for a person they didn't know prior to auditions. Okay then.
@AJB3I think after getting voted against the winner then asked to perform the same song that could have been his number 1 plus thinking oh no I got voted out by Australia would give you a bit of performance anxiety. He should have won hands down instead of fried hair who couldn’t hit a hard note if he was writing home from war. Now he is sadly judging people on TV 🤭
Oi! Don't talk about Guy like that! Guy is a fantastic singer and one amazing person. Guy and Shannon are both fantastic performers in their own right! I'm a fan of both. I just hate it when people disrespect Guy!@@Pebs_dandysworld_781
forgety life storry . What music way S.N. Is to G.S. ..G.S. was and still is only judge and member of the jury to say who is good or not. . Nothing else!!
System requirements for GTA V- www.systemrequirementslab.com/cyr... Your i3-4170 is around 47% better than the minimum Q6600- www.game-debate.com/cpu/index.php... But your 8400GS is around 570% worse than the minimum 9800GT- www.game-debate.com/gpu/index.php... Recommend graphics upgrade to a GTX 750 Ti for about $100 USD. It's around 139% more powerful than the 9800GT, and most will work with any 300W or greater power supply- www.game-debate.com/gpu/index.php?gid=3151&gid2=883&compare=geforce-9800-gt-1gb-vs-geforce-gtx-750-ti
Aussies made a right decisions when voting Guy as a winner... coz this guy right now not even close to Guy Sebastian. He made himself stupid by singing Guy's song. and i keep wondering why people keep saying "He's been robbed"..
He didn't sing 'Guy's song' you dick, this was the song written for the winner which subsequently was Guy. They both sang it then Australia voted, which was completely rigged because the song suited Guy to a tee and obviously didn't suit Shannon's voice at all.
Freddy Floyd that winner song don t forget their both sang it to find out who going to sing that song on that album shannon is a runner up got the sang from moving pictures what about me he did make a good song out of it
Personally I thought Shannon noll sang it better no hate on guy. I liked Shannon noll version better I thought his version had more emotion and he sang it better
Oof, okay I haven't seen this in 20 years and uh...it's not good. They really should have given him a song in his preferred genre because this song is all Guy
This is my Opinion - I Believe that Australia Idol got rigid letting Guy Sebastian win. I think Shannon Noll Had it won. What made Guy Sebastian win is that his own followers Voted him to win
John Keogh I will always wonder if Cosima or Shannon would have made it to the final. They conveniently announced Guy had made it to the final BEFORE Cosima announced she was withdrawing
@@gerardmcc1 You don't have ears ? This sounds terrible.. This cover is terrible. I'm not saying he's a bad singer but he completely destroyed this song. He's out of tune. You want to hear a great cover ? Listen to Garett's one 💆♂️
at the time I agreed with you, Shannon was an Australian sound and his raspy voice was awesome for me Guy also had a great voice but that warbling vocal gymnastics put me off. but as with any reality TV show the producers manipulate things to suit themselves and wrote a song for guy. Poor Shannon sounds terrible singing this but he has had a good career. Guy has evolved more and is truly world class now so in the end the stronger contender did win.
Shannon is the only first Idol contestant that singing with his deep heart and his style so humble from the first audition i saw... Proud to him! 🎉
I actually loved it his version
What a beautiful version 🥰💖💖💖
You must be deaf
guy's voice most suited for this song..no wonder he won.. if shannon won having this version it will never be a hit at all...he sounded like he's being squeezed or something...
Guy has a vocal range and Shannon doesn't. I think what you're trying to say
I know they would have had this song ready before the competition had even started, but with no disrespect to Guy, I’d love to see him sing a song in Shannon’s preferred genre.
For example, What About Me will never be sung and performed as well as Shannon Noll has.
The song was ready I remember they said we have a song ready for the winner. Sorry still bitter Lol
Looking back at this , a different song could have had a different result. Country pop would have worked here.
The song was chosen before top 3 (or even top 4). Unfortunately, Shannon got the bad luck of this. ABMH fit other top 4 (It fit Rob Mills too).
Grad that they change the winner single to different songs in later seasons.
The winner won,Say no more
I feel like guy is more suited to this song but I absolutely love Shannon's voice for most songs
I’m Sorry Guy’s Version Was So Much Better! I’m Glad Guy Won!
PKingHeroics Screw You Bro And Bye Felicia! My Opinion Not Yours! 😠😡😤🤯🙄😒😑🤦🏾♂️
It’s so obvious this song was written for Guy lol
On ya Shannon
It’s so obvious this song was written for Guy lol
Came here to say this
@@aarenmyatt4509 ¹1g
I seriously agree
Shannon was not a pop singer, they should've written a different song for him
Shannon was not a pop singer they should've written a different song for him
This is the format of the Idol show, two remaining contestants will sing the same song, and the wimner of the show will own the song, even the song A MOMENT LIKE THIS in AMERICAN IDOL was performed both by Kelly Clarkson and Jusitn Guardini, then when Kelly was declared the Winner of AMERICAN IDOL, the song became hers
The organization obviously rigged the competition for Guy to win
He's not a good singer. If they'd wanted him to succeed, they would have made it happen. Look at One Direction. None of them passed individual auditions and they came about fourth as a group, because it was painful to listen to them sing out of tune
You do realise this show is literally the Australian version of a British show called Pop Idol. Pop is literally in the name.
in australia only ... on chanels wich made him
YOU ❤ ARE AMAZING 👏
you are the best in that conttttest
Those collars on the shirts......
"iTs ObViOuS tHiS sOnG wAs WrItTeN fOr GuY."
Yes, a song they wrote before the competition started, was written specifically for a person they didn't know prior to auditions. Okay then.
They could have changed the key for his version to be a bit lower and it would have worked better. It was rigged, they wanted Guy to win
As a "stupid American" merely watching clips, Guy was leagues better than this dude. It's not fair. But life isn't fair.
@AJB3I think after getting voted against the winner then asked to perform the same song that could have been his number 1 plus thinking oh no I got voted out by Australia would give you a bit of performance anxiety. He should have won hands down instead of fried hair who couldn’t hit a hard note if he was writing home from war. Now he is sadly judging people on TV 🤭
Oi! Don't talk about Guy like that! Guy is a fantastic singer and one amazing person. Guy and Shannon are both fantastic performers in their own right! I'm a fan of both. I just hate it when people disrespect Guy!@@Pebs_dandysworld_781
""connnntessstt" was /had to be false. No way you could loose
He's not one them for that song music like gay Sebastian he just sing Angels bought me here
that choice of key absolutely ruined him.
he held it though
Jeff Cone held the mic ???
No.
Jeff Cone Oh so he didn’t hold the mic ?
@@arigold9448 k
Shannon was a better entertainer on stage imo
Absolutely without a doubt and I will say this again 20 years later
forgety life storry . What music way S.N. Is to G.S. ..G.S. was and still is only judge and member of the jury to say who is good or not. . Nothing else!!
System requirements for GTA V-
www.systemrequirementslab.com/cyr...
Your i3-4170 is around 47% better than the minimum Q6600-
www.game-debate.com/cpu/index.php...
But your 8400GS is around 570% worse than the minimum 9800GT-
www.game-debate.com/gpu/index.php...
Recommend graphics upgrade to a GTX 750 Ti for about $100 USD. It's around 139% more powerful than the 9800GT, and most will work with any 300W or greater power supply-
www.game-debate.com/gpu/index.php?gid=3151&gid2=883&compare=geforce-9800-gt-1gb-vs-geforce-gtx-750-ti
Oh my god this is terrible. Guy's version (the proper real version) is so much better and authentic. Shannon's is like karaoke
i feel it, shannon sings like he is in karaoke ✌️😁
Aussies made a right decisions when voting Guy as a winner... coz this guy right now not even close to Guy Sebastian. He made himself stupid by singing Guy's song. and i keep wondering why people keep saying "He's been robbed"..
He didn't sing 'Guy's song' you dick, this was the song written for the winner which subsequently was Guy. They both sang it then Australia voted, which was completely rigged because the song suited Guy to a tee and obviously didn't suit Shannon's voice at all.
Freddy Floyd that winner song don t forget their both sang it to find out who going to sing that song on that album shannon is a runner up got the sang from moving pictures what about me he did make a good song out of it
Richard Hannaford it’s obvious it was written for Guy but at the end of the day Guy had the better voice anyway 🤷♀️
because he WASSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS
oh 😲🙁
That song wasn’t fit to him in the first place
i also notice that. he sing like he is only at home ✌️😁
Personally I thought Shannon noll sang it better no hate on guy. I liked Shannon noll version better I thought his version had more emotion and he sang it better
This was horrible...
Oof, okay I haven't seen this in 20 years and uh...it's not good. They really should have given him a song in his preferred genre because this song is all Guy
This is my Opinion - I Believe that Australia Idol got rigid letting Guy Sebastian win. I think Shannon Noll Had it won.
What made Guy Sebastian win is that his own followers Voted him to win
Guy was the better singer by far
@@joniedwards4215 read my opinion again.
Example soap opera fans will vote for soap opera idols to win.
No argument please it's only my opinion.
So you're saying that Guy only won because more people votes for him? Well, fuck me dead.
He sounds horrible. I couldn't believe he made it to top 2. :p
Kisha Mae Generalao the reason he got top 2 because the cosima de vito withdraw the comptition because of her illness
John Keogh I will always wonder if Cosima or Shannon would have made it to the final. They conveniently announced Guy had made it to the final BEFORE Cosima announced she was withdrawing
RachelXKnight666 ~ I think this just isn’t the type of song for him, he’s better at rock stuff
Not to offend but so boring version
terrible terrible cover
Where’s your cover of this?
@@gerardmcc1 You don't have ears ?🤣🤣
Loïc Syed obviously I do 🙄
@@gerardmcc1 Okay good !! Do you have musical ears ? Do you really think that this guy is singing the right notes or singing well ?
Loïc Syed I never said he sounds good
Butchered the song.
Terrible
You could do better?
@@gerardmcc1 can u
Nadine Carlos I couldn’t but I’m not the one saying he’s terrible
@@gerardmcc1 You don't have ears ? This sounds terrible.. This cover is terrible. I'm not saying he's a bad singer but he completely destroyed this song. He's out of tune. You want to hear a great cover ? Listen to Garett's one 💆♂️
Not a patch on the talent of Guy. Also, not as humble.
Shannon was Robbed of Australia Idol
Janet Smith Rubbish! There’s no comparison between Shannon and Guy! Shannons a great singer,but Guy sings so much better!
Totally agree. Guy Sebastian is wonderful.
You’re deaf
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😔😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😅😅😅😅☺️😔😔😔😔😔😔😔😂😂😂 he did well but nope he did not get robbed
at the time I agreed with you, Shannon was an Australian sound and his raspy voice was awesome for me Guy also had a great voice but that warbling vocal gymnastics put me off. but as with any reality TV show the producers manipulate things to suit themselves and wrote a song for guy. Poor Shannon sounds terrible singing this but he has had a good career. Guy has evolved more and is truly world class now so in the end the stronger contender did win.