Water Change or Not to Water Change? That is the Question I Have the Answers

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 ต.ค. 2024
  • Hope you all enjoy! If you love clean Homebred top quality aquatics and rarities check out the site below. Thanks for watching! :D
    Website/Online Store: lrbaquatics.com/
    OS Supported Membership Link: / @lrbaquatics
    Want to support or represent, snag up a LRB Aquatics Mad Scientist Shirt here is the link: teespring.com/...
    LRB

ความคิดเห็น • 305

  • @AQUAPROS
    @AQUAPROS ปีที่แล้ว +18

    FISH JESUS! 😇

    • @animablo
      @animablo 10 หลายเดือนก่อน

      ❤❤❤

  • @htpclivingroom8785
    @htpclivingroom8785 ปีที่แล้ว +20

    I followed Father Fish's way. Now pretty much first year over, no water changes. All good.

  • @James_Hande
    @James_Hande ปีที่แล้ว +14

    What people either don't know or forgot is that people used to keep fish without filters, heaters and artificial lights not so long ago. During my 58+ years in the hobby I have successfully kept aquariums setup and functioning in many different ways. One thing I noticed was there's more to aquarium water than we have test kits for. Example: I had a 55G tank setup and occupied for about a year with just topping off all going great. I monitored the water parameters regularly. I bought some new fish and quarantined them for two months. No problems raised it's ugly head so I introduced them to the 55G. In less than a month the fish were exhibiting bad strange behavior. I talked with my favorite old timer at my LFS. He suggested quick somewhat large water changes for a few days. Sure enough they pulled through and lived a long and healthy life. I have always relied on the tank itself to house the beneficial bacteria; glass, substrate, rocks, driftwood, plants, etc... I only added either box filters, sponge filters or HOB's to polish the water and keep it crystal clear. I always cleaned such filters under my chlorinated tap water. My fry/grow out tanks were always bare with a box or sponge filter and heater. I kept the viewing panel clean but let the other sides form algae. I would siphon the uneaten food and debris from the bottom every two days with a 20-25% water change. I found that gave me best results in having larger survival rates and quicker growing. For three plus decades I kept a large community display tank utilizing an UGF, HOB and at the time the best plant growing lights. The plants and fish all did just fine with no issues or tank break downs.
    I started in the hobby as a wee-lad and followed the advice from my favorite old timer. As I caught that MTS disease as I grew older I started experimenting with different ways of keeping aquariums. There are "many" ways to keep them successfully. I can not follow TH-camr's that preach "my way is the only way to be successful". Sorry Father Fish but your 6" deep substrate method may work but it is NOT the only way. And not feeding your fish, really??
    The internet started as a good thing. But over the decades it went down hill. There are too many self proclaimed experts and bashers.
    Lucas, you do you! I love what you do for the hobby bro. Call out the haters and don't let them get to you. 😉
    Sorry for the essay.

  • @josephdonnelly3169
    @josephdonnelly3169 ปีที่แล้ว +29

    When you broke down the ‘cichlid guys’ and the ‘natural guys’ you said it all; so simple. I have a planted tank and an mbuna tank among others, but treat them so differently.
    Second, when you said aggression with sugar coat bothered you; I felt the same and responded to all three channels. KG was the best example of this. I still enjoy Ben O’s videos, but it was hard for me to take Caveman too serious with his 90% water changes with pushing of sea hem products. Don’t get me wrong, his fish do look great.
    Thanks for your video, it’s the voice of reason here. Keep doing what you do…

    • @SensorySeekerStories
      @SensorySeekerStories ปีที่แล้ว +12

      KG said nothing wrong, never thought looking after fish could turn into drama ffs

    • @geekroomlife5850
      @geekroomlife5850 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Watch everyone and enjoy everyone. Had 5 gallon tanks to my 310 planted, and 740 SA/CA. I keep YT on during game nights and cookouts sometime and FF video was on, talking that method. My friends start asking why I do WC. So I can see how his video could hurt average people. Ohwell. Drama sells whether it’s a video like this or a 105 minutes rant. It’s all good

    • @LRBaquatics
      @LRBaquatics  ปีที่แล้ว +7

      @@SensorySeekerStories To me it’s not about the drama but the message. Yes the guys are all right on some things but many things are missing on all fronts. I’m just trying to share my perspectives on the various perspectives and possibilities which will open the door for more types of people to enjoy the hobby in the style they like and how to make it easier and not so complicated. That’s the biggest hurdle in this hobby is to try and get over overcomplicating things.

    • @SensorySeekerStories
      @SensorySeekerStories ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @LRB Aquatics -King of DIY 's Favorite that's fair enough, everyone does things different, and wants different things from this hobby. The entire thing has been blown out of proportion, just enjoy the hobby for what it is. It sounds miserable, but we'll all be gone one day. Just enjoy life and support each other.

    • @billschwarz1157
      @billschwarz1157 วันที่ผ่านมา

      a 90% water change really often is just as consistent as no water changes in a balanced tank. It's how a lot of peeps keep goldfish for no particular reason. Seen a goldfish in a bare bottom tank in a polluted working garage before, it was huge, they never change the water.

  • @andrewderksen3342
    @andrewderksen3342 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    Father fish & secret history got me started 🙌🐟
    And as soon as you said
    "All natural "
    I subscribed ✅

  • @blacksailsinthesun
    @blacksailsinthesun ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Shrimp jesus your a natural world legend 😊 kg dont seem the friendliest to me apart from yourself i only watch father fish and aquarium coop.your most definitely the most compassionate chilled out fish/shrimp jesus dude keep it up

    • @LRBaquatics
      @LRBaquatics  ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Thanks, I appreciate that! 💕

  • @TMAquatics
    @TMAquatics ปีที่แล้ว +16

    LRB always chill and grounded. Love it.

  • @top_mf_n_here1806
    @top_mf_n_here1806 4 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I have both styles of tanks setup(planted and large cichlid s)
    My 125 is a Frontosa colony(6 large/medium) and 2 large Angels. Use to do water changes weekly but now i grow house plants on top with roots in tank (pothos, monstera, peace lily, lucky bamboo). Doing this i change water once every 2 months or longer now.

  • @rowenamattingley5677
    @rowenamattingley5677 ปีที่แล้ว +36

    Hi guys, I only started aquarium keeping 3 months ago when I was diagnosed with an illness and am home bound. I found it very stressful when doing my research and nearly gave up because of all of the different and contradictory do's and don't. I live in tropical Queensland Australia and I have to cool my tanks and not heat them which is a pain but you guys and LRB have made me happy to have aquariums (I started with one and now I have 4 x 20 litre nano tanks.❤❤

    • @WildGrowthChannel
      @WildGrowthChannel ปีที่แล้ว +3

      Hey thats awesome! Love seeing stories like this one. Very cool!

    • @TheDISSHonoredOne
      @TheDISSHonoredOne ปีที่แล้ว +4

      @rowenanmattingley5677 wish you well with your illness and new beginnings in hobby again

    • @LRBaquatics
      @LRBaquatics  ปีที่แล้ว +4

      Glad I could help you enjoy nature more! May god and breath give you strength! Yeah not easy keeping them cool and those chillers are expensive. If kept cool though they hold the cold more and more for the room if you get more tanks. Kind of like a radiators cooler or heater. On 30c/86f degree days I don’t even have to run the ac on my fish room because by night fall the tanks have kept it cooler in the barn then cool back down on night and morning. With massing more aquariums I’m able to self substation the temps to a suitable range.

    • @neutronshiva2498
      @neutronshiva2498 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      How do u cool them? I need some efficient method that dont cost a million bucks.

    • @rowenamattingley5677
      @rowenamattingley5677 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @@neutronshiva2498 I have to keep the air conditioner on all day every day and it does cost a fortune. My son floats refrigerated bottles of water in his tanks to cool them but he has to change them often. Sorry I could not help more.

  • @BenOchart
    @BenOchart ปีที่แล้ว +19

    Hi Lucas, I wasn’t aware you had chimed in on this until John mentioned you in his live stream. Great stream. I too get “therapy”from water changes and general aquarium care. So true about fish keepers being vital to certain species, like the Paratilapia polleni which has disappeared in the wild. I’ve expanded into a variety of fish but still a big Cichlid keeper. If you’d ever like to discuss these different worlds in a collab, I’m game 😉😀👍🏻

    • @LRBaquatics
      @LRBaquatics  ปีที่แล้ว +7

      I would love too

    • @Scionmalth
      @Scionmalth ปีที่แล้ว +2

      I would love to watch a conversation on the different styles of aquariums...

  • @brianhobbs772
    @brianhobbs772 ปีที่แล้ว +14

    100% LRB I was one of the lucky ones that got the last 5 mascara Barb’s and those fish came so healthy they didn’t give me one problem they were swimming around like they were born in my tank and never went through the mail, so heathy and happy I adopted your no filter method a year ago on all my 11 tanks and my plants and fish grow better than ever with rare water changes thank you for all the great things you have done in the hobby

    • @LRBaquatics
      @LRBaquatics  ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Thanks for the support and sharing your experience!

  • @whydoyoucare
    @whydoyoucare ปีที่แล้ว +4

    i have four tanks. two weeks ago, i broke one down and built it father fish style. then i went to phillips fish works and bought four bags of bugs. put three in tanks and one in a gallon pickle jar to watch it grow. think i'm going to put together a jar for my grandson. i think this is a great kid project. i don't do water changes on my tanks anymore. they are so stable. i was always going for the natural style, heavy planted w/o knowing about natural tanks. wish i was introduced to this when i started, sure would have saved me hella money! thank you for the awesome video! ☮️

    • @LRBaquatics
      @LRBaquatics  ปีที่แล้ว +2

      This is why I try to teach what I teach. To save people money and to give them the perspective that you don;t need alot of money to enjoy the hobby and nature it brings.

  • @thesolaraquarium
    @thesolaraquarium ปีที่แล้ว +9

    That is so true about water changes killing fish. It all depends on the quality of your source water. People in our hobby obsess about their tank water. Source water is critical. I am blessed with natural source water - it is almost impossible to kill a fish with it. I also use rain water but that can be deadly if not used right.
    Bad source water can be improved gradually over time (best not to change it too much) imo, depending on how many fish you have of course.

  • @sunsetjen2398
    @sunsetjen2398 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    Thanks Lucas 👍 4 All Your Wisdom 😘 Following your ways & recommendations (including 2 watch FF) enabled me to LOVE & Thrive in this hobby 💋🐟🦐🌿

  • @ReneesZooTube
    @ReneesZooTube ปีที่แล้ว +7

    I breed Guppies for a hobby, not for show. I'm also disabled. Weekly/frequent water changes are literally not physically possible for me. I also feel like they're complete drudgery. I do top offs as necessary and do big volume water changes quarterly (4 times a year). That meets my needs for maintaining my fish. My tanks aren't sparkling spotless clean. They have mulm and algae and occasionally green water and I'm ok with all that. It's beneficial for my growing babies. I keep floating plants. I feed moderately and don't push for huge growth because I don't need it. I breed for color and hardiness. So less frequent water changes works just fine for me.

  • @ryanoakes4629
    @ryanoakes4629 ปีที่แล้ว +8

    Good for you bud.. I started fish tanks many years ago doing water changes and chemo treatment…lol now I enjoy my all natural dirted tanks with my substrates from my river and lake i live on..a natural biodiversity living in them with smaller fish..and ya thanks for sticking up for fatherfish❤..I noticed after his video on NO WATER CHANGES. I AGREE! Everyone came out and we’re debating it,,lol they don’t get it..’keep fish great again’ loving your tanks..😊 peace brother🎉..

  • @davidshultz4654
    @davidshultz4654 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    Thanks Lucas. Your insight and your honesty is more appreciated than you realize. Thank you!

  • @DougRobins
    @DougRobins 8 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Good video & well said. I’ve converted 3 of my 5 tanks to deep substrate & cut my maintenance by 75%.

  • @plantlifeproject
    @plantlifeproject ปีที่แล้ว +3

    I appreciate the video. When people argue about their way of aquarium keeping being the “right way”, it’s like arguing that an apple is better than an orange.

  • @fishandfloral
    @fishandfloral ปีที่แล้ว +8

    I’m in both worlds, I have a large tank with cichlids and can’t have plants in it, so water changes are a must intermittently. My others are small nano planted tanks. I do maintenance on them differently.

  • @DeanoSupremo1
    @DeanoSupremo1 ปีที่แล้ว +7

    I never do water changes. Just top ups.
    My fish are fine and plants too.
    And saves me a lot of time

  • @antw23uk
    @antw23uk ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Doing a bit of maintenance on my big tank whilst watching this and found a baby chilli rasbora in the sump. Its mega 'dirty' so cant see much but he's now in the main tank looking a little bewildered. Super chuffed ... long live 'dirty' tanks :)

    • @LRBaquatics
      @LRBaquatics  ปีที่แล้ว

      Thats awesome, congrats!

  • @Jacksprat265
    @Jacksprat265 ปีที่แล้ว +11

    I’m finding that lighting is crucial for plant growth to enable the natural balance. I love the deep substrate low maintenance method now 😍

    • @tylerblues2246
      @tylerblues2246 ปีที่แล้ว

      So true it has always worked for me. Great for plants and fish.

  • @chrisjones2569
    @chrisjones2569 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    I have multiple tanks and a 10 gallon. The filter stopped, and I didn't notice, so I just never fixed it now it's doing fine it has 10 of your blue rice fish in it, and it's heavily planted

  • @tylerblues2246
    @tylerblues2246 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Great video mate.
    I’ve kept tanks for years now and unknown to me always have used the walstead method. I just wanted to make my tanks as natural as possible trying to see the fish as wild as they could be. I thought it would be a happier place for the fish to live.
    I tell anyone new to the game who comes round and sees my tanks to use dirt and have more plants then fish. Always worked for me.
    My personal opinion was a few years ago that kg Tropicals was the most patronising fish videos on TH-cam.
    Keep up the great work dude and soon I will have the courage to set up a tank with no filter.
    Peas out bro.

  • @CATfishTONY
    @CATfishTONY ปีที่แล้ว +1

    100% AGREE 👍
    we all need to get along.we have mason jars to 275 gallon tank with a 55 gallon filter.
    Scuds-to 35 sunfish

  • @vampgaia
    @vampgaia ปีที่แล้ว +8

    My water changes are based on the tank. Some tanks get a water change once a month, some could go months without a water change. My tanks have mulm and algae. I work a lot. I am happy to have algae and floating plants. They help keep my tanks balanced. My oscars' tank and my axolotl's tank need more frequent water changes than my planted community tanks. There is no 100% right way to keep fish. Lordy, people need to chill. Do what is best for your fish and the environment you are keeping them in.

  • @colorguppies
    @colorguppies ปีที่แล้ว +10

    We all have our ways. Your way cuts out profit for some. Keep being you!!!!

  • @TixPham
    @TixPham ปีที่แล้ว +9

    Thank you shrimp jebus. Everyone has their own version of truth. it's all about the beneficial bacterial. It's like the fight against good and evil. Asking as we keep neutral like our PH everything would be balanced. I noticed being too much of one thing is human growth regress.
    Edit: PS don't make shrimp jebus angry. Or his going to come at you with all his receipts. + His 1000's of fish videos. I think I know who I would listen too.

  • @WildGrowthChannel
    @WildGrowthChannel ปีที่แล้ว +3

    I watch all your stuff, and youre the only channel I really never ever disagree with! Especially on this topic

  • @Fish-Addict
    @Fish-Addict ปีที่แล้ว +6

    I agree 100%. Unfortunately father fish got mad at me when I tried to remind him that the "filterless" advice is not for beginners but more for a semi experienced aquarist

    • @Hawaiianshirtoperator
      @Hawaiianshirtoperator ปีที่แล้ว

      I’m semi experienced and I worry about no filter

    • @ebenoid6643
      @ebenoid6643 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      75% plants rule all day… LOADS OF PLANTS and no issues.

    • @evergreenpsyche
      @evergreenpsyche 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

      FatherFish doesnt recommend filterless though? He does advocate deep substrate, minimal water changes, and lots of plants. But in the few videos I seen of him, usually he recommends a sponge filter and he does mostly tropical fish. His advice mostly works for beginners, aside from the advice of collecting wild pond cultures to seed your tank with. That one can potentially go very wrong
      Yea he can be a bit eccentric and temperamental lol

  • @vikkirountoit497
    @vikkirountoit497 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    Go all FishJesus - love that image:) You have a great message for everyone. Do what works for you to have healthy fish and enjoy the hobby. I've got a mix of hands off and hands on with 6 tanks and 15 nanos. The more plants and tiny critters I have, the better the water seems to be and better water means better fish for me.

  • @GloryBe007
    @GloryBe007 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Thank you, LRB. I’m glad you took care of that 🙏✌

  • @dylanneff
    @dylanneff ปีที่แล้ว +6

    Thanks for doing this video. I agree with the vast majority of what you said, and I love that you focus on the natural systems. I do want to say that Bulk Reef Supply is a relatively large company I really respect. They do their own experiments that they document. Not everything they do is amazing, but I do think they’re generally helpful and thoughtful.

    • @LRBaquatics
      @LRBaquatics  ปีที่แล้ว +3

      I have been to Bulk Reef Supply and it is a great company, dont get me wrong. But a freshwater guy like me that knows what I know and from what was said, knows better. As far as salt goes its neat they all have their own lil reef tanks in offices plus like you said they do their own experiments. I have seen a few, which is respectable.

  • @vamosaltemacongabrielmende3965
    @vamosaltemacongabrielmende3965 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    I have 4 nano, no filters/water change on them after killing all my fish during a water change. So lesson learned, no water changes for me only topping off what’s evaporated. The only thing is that I clean the glass of them. What I have inside is a lot of plants and snails in them.

  • @howardvantassel7557
    @howardvantassel7557 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    For my tanks with the fish I keep I do the natural method. Never do water changes except when I take some water from the established tank and jump start the new natural tank. No chemicals other then dechlorinator when I top off my tanks.

  • @markfranklin8831
    @markfranklin8831 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Your a 💯 percent correct ( there is no right or wrong way ) it depends on what your keeping imo💗👍✌️💯

  • @MrsBJPalmer
    @MrsBJPalmer ปีที่แล้ว +3

    "Ya filthy animal! Grrrrgh!!" 😂😅🤣😂😄😁😅😊🤣😂😅🙃😇🤣

    • @LRBaquatics
      @LRBaquatics  ปีที่แล้ว +3

      😄

    • @ladylrbnaturelife
      @ladylrbnaturelife ปีที่แล้ว +1

      😂 right?! That one made me laugh even the second time around

  • @pyleaquatics
    @pyleaquatics ปีที่แล้ว +4

    I have found that I need to change water often on my killifish growout tanks. If I don't, they don't grow. It must be a hormone thing. Most of my other tanks, I don't need to change the water very often. It usually changed because I just don't like the way it's starting to look. I just use a bare airline and no filtration on almost all my tanks. Lots of plants are the key for me.

  • @GeneralA6
    @GeneralA6 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    spot on. need to spread more of these videos

  • @TheDISSHonoredOne
    @TheDISSHonoredOne ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Lucas, does Not surprise me that Kaveman or neither of them took you up on your co live stream to discuss the 'differences' in the styles of fish keeping of the two 'different kinds of fish that we are keeping. Like you Lucas, Father Fish and Alexander/Alex say, there are many tank set ups and different methods that you can you use to keep healthy fish.. Having said that, I have 1 cichlid tank set up out of my current running 14 tanks, that is set up the natural way and it does and looks awesome! Why does my cichlid tank succeed this 'natural way' because it is not OVERSTOCKED & NOT OVERFED and planted, I've created a food web etc. Natural way!

  • @calebduke2832
    @calebduke2832 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I just built a father fish tank 2 months ago and so far the tank is doing wonderfully and fish are reproducing. I’ve done no water changes. I just use some giant tweezers to arrange stuff aesthetically to my pleasing and scrub algae off the walls and it looks fine IMO.

  • @stephancardoos1782
    @stephancardoos1782 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Always so level headed, appreciate your knowledge.

  • @briangriffith4574
    @briangriffith4574 ปีที่แล้ว +9

    Can you put together a pond tank with all water plus animals and organisms from your ponds out on your property? I would love to see that.

    • @LRBaquatics
      @LRBaquatics  ปีที่แล้ว +7

      One day I plan on it. I would like to have a bigger tank for it 125 or bigger and maybe do a 40 and 20 with the different types of fish and fauna.

  • @michaelmitchell5909
    @michaelmitchell5909 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    You have awesome beautiful tanks man. You and father fish have inspired me to start doing natural tanks....

  • @AHGAQUATICS
    @AHGAQUATICS ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Totally agree I’ve tank I keep crystal clear like aquascape that I change water weekly and I’ve another tank I almost never change great video ❤👏👏👏👏👏

  • @edwardspade6122
    @edwardspade6122 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Thanks To you for keeping it friendly and noting it all depends, I’m an in the middle. Air driven filters some power, greenwater tanks

  • @RVA_Aus
    @RVA_Aus ปีที่แล้ว +3

    100% mate, there is many ways to get the same outcome. Lace man is throwing rocks at glass windows.
    Love your work , from Australia 🇦🇺

  • @DamianBloodstone
    @DamianBloodstone ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I've had tanks forever. I've been listening to you for a long while now. I don't do water changes and just top off now because salt is sometimes in my tap water. I live on the East Coast and this place is surrounded by fresh and salt water. I try to continue a natural balance. To each their own though. Take Care and Stay Safe.🖖

  • @caewalker9276
    @caewalker9276 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Thank you Lucas. I'm starting a cichlid tank and I can't do it like I normally do ( lots of plants and no vac). I realise there is a place for everything and everything in its place. Thank you for your time and advice. It's been valuable to me.

  • @ericwilson4553
    @ericwilson4553 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Havent listened in a while but keep up the good work and the MTS brother!

  • @abubbleoff1742
    @abubbleoff1742 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Best explanation yet! Thanks LRB.

  • @WOW_AQUATICS
    @WOW_AQUATICS ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Love it! I keep a ton of plecos..all that natural alge and mulm is fantastic. I do have an automatic change system but it's now rare that I use it. Once Every couple weeks.

  • @trill000
    @trill000 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Made me realize I have 6 tanks: 55 gal planted w/goldfsh and guppies, 10 gal "foodweb," 5 gal planted betta, 2.5 gal aquatic turtle deep substrate "tank" in his habitat, 1 gal "resurrection jar," 0.5 gal glass cylinder planted w/guppy.

  • @rotten2209
    @rotten2209 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I dont do them nearly as much as I was told but all my tanks are crystal clear, inhabitants are healthy and the plants thrive. I've lost more fish and shrimp after 75% water changes than anything else including a cat peeing in the HOB.

  • @DeltaKiloExotics
    @DeltaKiloExotics ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Im in the no change, lots of plants, have done so for years, everyone should just do what they like and enjoy the aquarium....

  • @dustycoward7615
    @dustycoward7615 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    You said it right, I think it depends a ton on what fish you are keeping

  • @jmommy991
    @jmommy991 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Have you watched all of KG Tropicals video? I didnt see him throwing shade at anyone. I could see how it was misleading if you didnt watch all of it. He even says Father Fish is correct!!!

  • @lisahowe8951
    @lisahowe8951 ปีที่แล้ว

    By far the best video I've seen from you. I have a green algae water 20 gallon tall tank with shrimp and ramshorn snails and live plants and just an air stone and my fish have been breeding a lot and I've never had to change my water and I rarely ever feed my shrimp but yet they are happily breeding.

    • @LRBaquatics
      @LRBaquatics  ปีที่แล้ว

      Have you seen my full talk? th-cam.com/video/4tneYawvQuI/w-d-xo.html

  • @mrWonderphilly
    @mrWonderphilly ปีที่แล้ว +2

    My thing now is nano fish in a big planted tank. I was 100% chasing big fish for my big tanks when I was newer in the hobby. These tanks are way cooler and more interesting now that they are filled with plants and shrimp and some fish... There is a ton of action!!

  • @SquiresAquatics
    @SquiresAquatics ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Keep up the great work, I personally have tanks that are crystal clear, others, not so much.
    I believe each one does well or different reasons. I have happy shrimps, I have happy fishes, that's what is important to mee!
    Thanks for your educational vid's!

  • @richcastro8990
    @richcastro8990 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    There’s a reason I’ve been watching you channel for so long…

  • @thehairywoodsman5644
    @thehairywoodsman5644 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    so, I do water changes, I also have at least a sponge filter in every tank, and all of my tanks except one 29 gallon have deep darted substrate that are heavily planted. the 29 gallon has a little sand and a bunch of leaves in the bottom, it has an incredibly large peace Lilly growing out of the top and a real big pothos plant rooted in the hang on back, it also is almost entirely covered in pennywort and pearl weed. it is the only tank that gets frequent water changes , I do a 1/4 change on it weekly Because its the tank my bristle nose plecos breed in so I feed it a lot of green beans , zucchini etc. it also house 10 or so Cory cats.
    I like doing water changes, but all my other tanks get them about once a month I don't really have a set schedule.
    no matter what anybody says I have learned more from you, Father fish, and Alexander Williamson in the last few years , than I learned on my own in the last 40 !
    I got my first tank in 1984 , but long before that I was catching gambusia and crawdads out the local creeks and keeping them in any container that would hold water !

  • @OceanLife6977
    @OceanLife6977 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I was exchanging comments with Patty’s Aquatics since I am doing my research before I start my first dirtied filterless aquarium, and in between comments he mentioned your channel. I also commented that before finding his channel, and other channels like FF, I truly didn’t know much about dirtied filterless aquariums. This is such an important time in the hobby for me since I find this practice absolutely amazing and incredibly addictive! I love your comments on this video about the hobby, and I truly didn’t know there was quite some drama going on. This is so unfortunate. I’ve always experienced nothing but respect from this community, and when time of need came in the sense of information, this community has always been there to assist. Hope we all find a common ground and come to an agreement that we ALL need each other for the sake of the hobby. Subbed.

    • @LRBaquatics
      @LRBaquatics  8 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

      We do all get a long. Just some differences thats all. World would be boring if we were all the same. Glad that we have been helpful in your aquarium journey!

    • @OceanLife6977
      @OceanLife6977 8 หลายเดือนก่อน

      @@LRBaquatics
      Indeed! I agree 100%! 😄😄
      Thanks for your reply.

  • @terrygorsch386
    @terrygorsch386 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    I'm on your side 😜 I like your natural style 🐠🎸

  • @cherryshrimp420
    @cherryshrimp420 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    I think the cichlid people are incorrectly concluding that this is a cichlid vs nano fish/planted tank issue. It's not. Cichlid tanks and monster fish tanks benefit all the same from microbial communities growing on surface area like deep substrates. Newcomers may not know that Father Fish kept many cichlids and monster fish in his shop which can be found in his earlier videos.
    Personally, I've kept tilapia-sized fish and small fish, and I fail to see how there is a divide in fishkeeping "principles" between them. Theyre all the same. A larger fish may eat bigger food, but it eats less often (which hobbyists tend to overfeed). So the water quality is not unmanageable for it's size.

  • @animablo
    @animablo 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    I found this channel after watching Father Fish earlier and it turned out to be very good, friend. You want to reunite with this hobby.

  • @SininStyle
    @SininStyle ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Nano Vs. Cichlid
    Neolamprologus Multifasciatus, when worlds collide!
    Healthy debates bring better solutions. As long as there is no serious outrage, nothing but good things can come from conversations.

  • @reneesmith1900
    @reneesmith1900 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Thank you!!!!! For the (keeping it fun) and real!!!!

  • @kdr1048
    @kdr1048 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Appreciate you Lucas 👍 Those "dirty" tanks are far more impressive than any crystal clear co2 tank. Dirted tanks for life over here. Nothing better than good ol dirt. Mother Nature is undefeated

    • @Voyvoda1903
      @Voyvoda1903 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Your tanks are great. Father Fish always showcases your tanks.

    • @kdr1048
      @kdr1048 ปีที่แล้ว +3

      @@Voyvoda1903 thank you!

  • @theweirdplantguy4873
    @theweirdplantguy4873 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    You are my Fish Jesus and I appreciate it so much! You are my Marsh.

  • @aheimsvensson1573
    @aheimsvensson1573 17 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Im all with you brother A dirty tank can be so extermely interesting and all the things going on in that enviroment.

  • @Sean-yr2rl
    @Sean-yr2rl ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I'm working on growing more plants dialing in my aquarium lighting. Years ago my tank was near my window but i moved. now i have one of the 'fancy' led's and another tank just has fluorescent lighting. Both are doing well. My long term plan is to do very few water changes but my water is very soft so i need to do a water change every now and then or i lose fish slowly one by one.
    I love how your plants are doing LRB! I'm planning on buying some of your plants soon to add and start up summer tubbing season soon.

  • @krabbykhris
    @krabbykhris ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Very well put. Keep doin ya thang !!!

  • @dragonforce2247
    @dragonforce2247 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

    No matter what I experiment on I always go back to a more natural way! It always seems easier plus they look more interesting and more of the natural way takes care of itself

  • @jackiestubbs6964
    @jackiestubbs6964 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Thanks for the info. Being considerate of others opinions. 2 of my 3 tanks don’t need water changes.

  • @angelikakurowicka7182
    @angelikakurowicka7182 ปีที่แล้ว

    Its true, i keep fish for almost 15 years. At start i had dozen of filters on 1 tank at the time for the best water quality and did every 2 weeks 50% waterchange. I always had trouble with my water.
    Now i have a normal filter in my aquarium. Like 3-4 times the water volume per hour and thats it. I top my water off with new water just to fill it back up. I hold lots of Angelfish. BUT i do have good planted tanks. Never have problems with the water quality.

  • @dougdame6706
    @dougdame6706 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Really interesting talk. "Many different methods" is a huge insight ... each person has to find/understand what works for his/her specifics .... big fish/small fish/planted/bare/breeding for profit/etc.
    Q: With limited water changes, how do you manage/avoid TDS creep?

    • @LRBaquatics
      @LRBaquatics  ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Plants and fish can uptake excessive mineralization and usually naturally you get evaporation, well in open tanks then have to top off. In lid tanks they stable a bit more with evaporation but then you need atmospheric exchange which best to use airline. You should check your hardness time to time if your always adding and not sure, especially if you have soft or hard water specific fish. Mineralization build up will also show itself in your aquarium as well either on the walls or plant leaves. But beware you can still get this build up sometime even in low tds condition due to the type of mineral so always good to check if you dont know but once you go through some time you find what you need to know with how your specifics cycle about and why.

  • @FinsbyProductions
    @FinsbyProductions ปีที่แล้ว +3

    I'm with ya lrb ❤thanks for this ❤️

  • @marisacortes7044
    @marisacortes7044 7 หลายเดือนก่อน

    I love your method. I’m using it for years. Do not worry about caveman or anybody else you do you❤

  • @raisinggoldfishonabudget7058
    @raisinggoldfishonabudget7058 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    The bacopa tank looks AWESOME, you asked how the
    camera vision was doing & it was a little blury in spots
    but if you moved too fast it'd mess up.

    • @TheDISSHonoredOne
      @TheDISSHonoredOne ปีที่แล้ว +1

      @raisinggoldfishonabudget7058 Ikr that bacopa! I totally want bacopa now, right now, get in my tanks 😁

  • @jaredgollnitz5258
    @jaredgollnitz5258 10 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Heck I keep hornwort in with a 175 gallon tank with sand bottom, 50 koi, fed twice daily, and I STILL don’t do water changes.

  • @manubustaraiglesias6788
    @manubustaraiglesias6788 11 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Do you have any video about goldfish filterless tanks?
    Also how do you keep the temperature in the filterless tanks? Do they still have heaters? As a heater is the most expensive bit to run in a tank....

    • @LRBaquatics
      @LRBaquatics  11 หลายเดือนก่อน +2

      I do have filterless goldfish aquariums if you youtube search my name and the other keywords they should pop up. I dont have heaters and keep the house around 72-78. Depending of the time of year.

  • @QueAquatics
    @QueAquatics ปีที่แล้ว +2

    I never really thought of it. Cichlid between nano interesting. I have both kinds of fish 45 tanks and I do water changes and I do not do water changes.

  • @aapassion5135
    @aapassion5135 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    That the point 100%, also watch those videos. You need to do water change when in your tank only background and fish;) just wondering how long his fish ok with 80% water change.

  • @jayblomquist3339
    @jayblomquist3339 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I like rivers better than lakes constant water changes. Plants do the same thing clean lakes up here in Minnesota . they both work same in your aquarium .

  • @kayhalliday2676
    @kayhalliday2676 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    ❤ nature for the win!

  • @Firebird894
    @Firebird894 ปีที่แล้ว

    I keep nanos and cichlids smaller ones but oh and catfish and shrimp plus live cultures. I do occasional small water changes here and there I have some tanks that get none at all. They do well. I noticed the angelfish get cranky and start fighting after a water change even a small one and I play them some bach and vivaldi and they calm right down. I also don't feed much I used to but I am switching over to mostly live food that lasts in the tank so thats a good distraction for them they don't get bored and start picking fights so much. You have to develop a feel for the water and it takes some time. I am converting the entire downstairs of my house to a fishroom laundry is no longer a laundry, the garage is full of tanks the yard is full of ponds. I turned an old canoe into a ricefish pond. I am working on a real big pond in the front yard with rocks and lotus and lillies that will be my koi pond I might put some bigger native aussie fish in too. But I am doing a shallow area sheiled by rocks for small fish to get through and escape into aswell and a swamp to the side like a bog garden that connects to it. Have a plan for a stream and a bridge linking some ponds and to act as a sump for another project. Also in the future a greenhouse passive heating for more growout space.

    • @LRBaquatics
      @LRBaquatics  ปีที่แล้ว

      That sounds awesome! Especially the Ricefish canoe pond! I did alot of that sort of thing at my old house with reterraforming and turning all the rooms into fish rooms. Now I’m trying to do it all again with a bigger canvas this time before I get too old lol.

  • @marymendez4178
    @marymendez4178 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    KG Tropicals is John & Lisa. Prime Time Tropical is Jason & Joanna also with The small scape. Father Fish says don't use gravel or plastic plants, don't do water changes. I love these channel and your not far from them. Glass House Aquartics was in Florida this pass week, it would of been nice if you had met her.

  • @CarolynnMc01
    @CarolynnMc01 ปีที่แล้ว

    I've been working a lot and have missed your live streams for quite some time. I'm soooo glad I ran across the recap of this one. It's just great! I only have 2 five year-0ld tanks right now. I rarely change water. I top them off. . I do check the water, it's always satisfactory. The only thing that's changed over the past year is that I have minimal algae growth compared to in the past. I turn my lighting up to maximum and run them eight hours a day. Oh well! Everything seems fine and I put algae tabs into both aquariums almost daily. Your videos are UBER helpful! bunches of thanks.

  • @lakeshiamills1454
    @lakeshiamills1454 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Lucas it's all water in the end and I love that you have basically that same philosophy. At the end of the day we all keep fish differently, we all do what works for us and try new things to see if it WILL work for us. I'm currently up to over 30 aquariums and counting in my little corner of fishness and just recently got into larger cichlids again after years of avoiding big fish. There's an aesthetic and a draw to every aspect of the hobby for sure, and the guys you mentioned are all in different aspects of the hobby. I think what pushes the "drama" is so called fans that instigate things that don't need to be instigated. A lot of the videos in resposne to father fish in my opinion are just like the other side of the debate so to speak. I personally don't subscribe to kave man aquatics but that's only bc his videos are not my style not because he doesn't have good content. I've followed you and KGTropicals for years, and I felt that Johns video was spot on. He made a great point and I felt he gave props where props were due without compromising his own conviction. I also love that you always tend to become the mediator 😅. I've started changing some of my tanks over to filter less, some to matten and sponge filters only, and I have my biggest tank with a canister bc I feed heavily and allows me time between water changes. I have several tanks that I haven't done a water change on in months, some I do water changes on every week. It all depends on where you are in the hobby.

  • @anthonysanchez8304
    @anthonysanchez8304 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Where are the salt water guys to put this dilemma to an end! Lol😂

  • @TheDISSHonoredOne
    @TheDISSHonoredOne ปีที่แล้ว +1

    @lrbaquatics Lucas your tanks are beautiful clean and healthy. You never have to defend their clear & clean healthy water they all have. I was excited to meet both of them, the 3 of them in Aquashella Dallas next month but now I will just walk past them unless I decide to tell them how I feel about their dumb attacks on our natural tanks.

  • @decosherry69
    @decosherry69 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Preach!!!💕

  • @ronlafond5288
    @ronlafond5288 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    It's off topic, but I'm curious about the kind of lights you're using in your racks over the tanks? Thanks!

    • @TheDISSHonoredOne
      @TheDISSHonoredOne ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Lucas told us in a recent video but I cannot remember what he said because I did not need lights but if u watch recent videos you'll catch it :)

    • @ronlafond5288
      @ronlafond5288 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      @@TheDISSHonoredOne Thanks for that. I will.

  • @llorakbretz
    @llorakbretz ปีที่แล้ว +4

    tanks are dirty? in our eyes only, if your fish is breeding its not dirty but a profitable tank

  • @christinamorris2823
    @christinamorris2823 หลายเดือนก่อน

    'dirty' to me is something that is detrimental to the inhabitants health...like high ammonia or high nitrites or nitrates. Other than that you don't have to worry! You also have to take into consideration how stable your system is...and how heavily stocked.

  • @manubustaraiglesias6788
    @manubustaraiglesias6788 11 หลายเดือนก่อน

    Ok il have a look. Imposible to keep for discus at those temperatures then as they need it much higher. Many thanks for your reply. I'm looking for cheaper// easier alternatives ;)

  • @tonyp8762
    @tonyp8762 ปีที่แล้ว +5

    Lucas, I am so glad that you touched on this. Over the past 4 years I have seen everytime a certain man syas something, the whole ACO affiliate team jumps to debunk him. All I know is that, if anyone knows this man, he is speaking from years of experience and if he is wrong, I think it's more on the aquarist part to research their particular set up.
    This is like the 6th time they got at him over his experience but I can say KGTropocals actually did an amazing job contrasting the information that was presented by the first youtuber's video.
    When I started having trouble with my 40g B., fish dying all the time. I wrote to FatherFish, Michael's Fishroom and MD Fish Tanks and they all said stop feeding the fish for a day every once and awhile. I followed their advice and found that lower amounts of food throughout the day solved it. Less deaths, less water changes and beautiful plant life. So, I don't know why all these people jump (actually I do) when he speaks...money, money, money.

    • @globalist1990
      @globalist1990 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      I agree with you 100%. And even if father fish also has a shop, the difference is, his videos explain how to do stuff without having to buy anything from him and to spend as little as possible in any shop. It's like, if you want more convenience you can spend some more on his stuff other's. If you can't or don't want to, you can still do fine with his advice.

    • @WildGrowthChannel
      @WildGrowthChannel ปีที่แล้ว +4

      You can read about roping a bull and know everything there is to know about it, but until you rope one, you arent an expert. Same goes with aquariums. Ill take LRBs years of knowledge as reference from his actual application and what he shows us, not theories
      .

  • @Hawaiianshirtoperator
    @Hawaiianshirtoperator ปีที่แล้ว

    I put leaf matter from the creek in my 20 gallon and I’ve been monitoring the fish closely and so far the only thing that’s happened is the dead plants disappear. I do worry about parasites down the road