Always such a joy to listen to Dr. Gulati speak. So much to learn from him always, whether they be his videos or articles. Can almost feel the frustration in his voice here trying to rally the same points to people for the last 20 years and it still falling on deaf ears.
One of the best discussion, I love hearing Ashok Gulati Sir. He speaks from heart and put a lot of sense. The decision for the future are never easy as it is not certain, needs planning, investment and risk. Just appeasing the current situation is symbol of weakness. Lets change for the greater good and save our future.
Dr Gulati clearly has a solid macro-economic understanding of the challenges of the Indian farmer. That said I think he has a limited perspective on the design of an MSP. This is understandable, given our Govt's history (for many decades) of bungling good ideas with flawed design and execution. What I think is that we need to diversify the PDS, state by state, to provide people with basic rations including more valuable produce such as vegetables, dairy, eggs, and meat. We shouldn't buy more than needed, the presence of PDS procurement will act as a price-setter (if MSP is provided). Private procurement can still happen, and in scarcity years prices will go up (good for farmers, and current methods can be considered if prices get too high).
बहोत ही लाजवाब संदर्शन था डॉ गुलाटी के साथ. बहोत ही कड़वी सच्चाई किसानों के सामने और देश के सामने रखी. अगर किसानोंको खुदकुशी/गरीबी से बचना है तो उसको खुद को बदलना पड़ेगा ही, उसके अलावा दूसरा चारा नहीं हैं. नही तो किसान और देश दोनों डूबेंगे इस सब्सिडी के दांव में. A NAKED TRUTH By De GULATI Both to FARMERS and COUNTRY.
🔥 1)agriland ceiling act, 2) essential commodity act,and 3)land acquisition act This three acts must abolishe primarily for strengthening the sovereignty of the people.
Poultry, dairy and other animals raised for food depend on feed raised by farmers, who as mentioned in the interview, do not get anything. This man will never mention the massive subsidy to corporates in terms of almost free land and loans which they are excused from paying back.
This year the subsidy government pays farmers in wheat should go down. In fact it will profit as today international wheat prices are higher than the MSP
गुलाटी जी सही है किसान ने पानी हवा सब जहरीला कर दिया जो प्राइवेट स्कूलों में किताब हर साल नई दी जाती है उनसे पैड कटते हैं कभी उस पर आप जैसे अर्थशास्त्री ने बात की ओर एनजीटी भी इस बात नही
Poultry cannot be given as an example to promote privatisation of trade because it is supported by technology which is imported and not from State Agricultural Universities. I feel Research and Development is the spoiler.
Increase in international wheat prices is GOOD news for India and its farmers. With Russia offering to sell us oil at 35$ discount to international prices the petrol price in India should come down.
60$ was the max estimate for crude oil in the current budget now the prices are gone up 90$-120$ even if Russia give discount of 35$ it will still very high this is simple economics but now integrate economy and international politics and then the conclusion will be that buying Russian oil will not going to benefit our nation
Why not ensuring msp for oilseeds and pulses ie to the extent it is required in India. Discourage purchase of paddy slowly like first auction of oilseeds and pulses and paddy at the last. Now we have full data about the ownership of lands and allot acreage of paddy from a farmer and similar acreage of pulses/oilseeds. This work can be done by the agri department but should be done before sowing of crops .
Gulati who has world record of attaching his name to hundreds of articles by young researchers have come to full circle. With coming to a propaganda portal like wire.
#Bhim Rao mission in the world #,channel को ज्यादा से ज्यादा Subscribe करें, "अधिकार की लड़ाई में निमंत्रण नहीं भेजे जाते,जिसका ज़मीर ज़िन्दा है वो खुद समर्थन में आ जाते हैं ",jay bhim jay संविधान 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻✊✊✊✊✊✊✊✊✊🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
A economist should be the last person to speak on farming Appointing people on CACP without any knowledge about agriculture is disastrous Inspite of him being a economist he has not talked anything about ECONOMY OF SCALE In india 85 % of the farmers are less than 2 hectares Whereas in the western Australia the average size of wheat farm is 4500 hectares in such a scenario how can the indian farmer be cost competitive
गुलाटी बात खाधान्न पर है तो निर्मला क्यों बन रहा है राजा। खेत में काम कर रहे मजदूरों किसानों का इंटरव्यू ले द वायर इस प्रधानपाखंडी के भक्त का क्या ले रहा है।
No technology work so long farmers is poor and don't surplus finance to take risks.rest discussion is futile and useless or party motivational and government favourism
लखनऊ के गरीब मुस्लिम सब्जी विक्रेता की 19 साल की बेटी ने महिला अंडर-19 हॉकी में इतिहास रच दिया थोड़ी ऐसी सकारात्मक खबरें भी चला लिया करो या सिर्फ नफरत फैलाने वाली ही खबरें क्यों चलाते हो तुम
Ye kaise kaise logon ke interview lete ho yaar. Kheti ke baare m hawa hawai baate kar reha h gulatimar. Msp p baat isliye nahi karni kyunki uske business friends ko issue hi sakta h
Gulati saab Kahan ke arth shastri hai. Gadhaeconomics ke. Another stupid misleading people against subsidy. Ghadhe se poocho agar foodgrain mehnga hota hai to inflation bhi badega.
Gulati ji aap khud kyu ni krte kheti, Krke dikhao fr kisano ko smjhana ki kaise benefits kmaya apne. Gulati ji kisan bhi tax pay krta hai kyuki hr chij pr to tax hai kisan bhi to market se hi apne ghr ka sara sman purchase krta hai jo us pr mrp hai kisan ko bhi usi rate me milta hai Biscuits se lekr oil tk sb pr to tax hai
Always such a joy to listen to Dr. Gulati speak. So much to learn from him always, whether they be his videos or articles. Can almost feel the frustration in his voice here trying to rally the same points to people for the last 20 years and it still falling on deaf ears.
One of the best discussion, I love hearing Ashok Gulati Sir. He speaks from heart and put a lot of sense. The decision for the future are never easy as it is not certain, needs planning, investment and risk. Just appeasing the current situation is symbol of weakness. Lets change for the greater good and save our future.
बहुत बढ़िया विडियो ….देश के हर गाँव के किसानों को सुनना चाहिये।
Dr Gulati clearly has a solid macro-economic understanding of the challenges of the Indian farmer. That said I think he has a limited perspective on the design of an MSP. This is understandable, given our Govt's history (for many decades) of bungling good ideas with flawed design and execution.
What I think is that we need to diversify the PDS, state by state, to provide people with basic rations including more valuable produce such as vegetables, dairy, eggs, and meat. We shouldn't buy more than needed, the presence of PDS procurement will act as a price-setter (if MSP is provided). Private procurement can still happen, and in scarcity years prices will go up (good for farmers, and current methods can be considered if prices get too high).
बहोत ही लाजवाब संदर्शन था डॉ गुलाटी के साथ.
बहोत ही कड़वी सच्चाई किसानों के सामने और देश के सामने रखी.
अगर किसानोंको खुदकुशी/गरीबी से बचना है तो उसको खुद को बदलना पड़ेगा ही, उसके अलावा दूसरा चारा नहीं हैं.
नही तो किसान और देश दोनों डूबेंगे इस सब्सिडी के दांव में.
A NAKED TRUTH
By De GULATI
Both to FARMERS and COUNTRY.
🔥
1)agriland ceiling act,
2) essential commodity act,and
3)land acquisition act
This three acts must abolishe primarily for strengthening the sovereignty of the people.
Hamare Loktantrik Desh Bharat mein Kisano ko bhi Unka HAQ aur Adhikaar Sammaan Sahit Milna Chahiye.----- Aam Jan Adhikar Manch, Buxar, Bihar.
Thanks Wire..
Nobody can change the future of agriculture of India. So much Politics.
Wonderful , GULATI SIR ALWAYS GIVE A LOT OF CLARITY.
Poultry, dairy and other animals raised for food depend on feed raised by farmers, who as mentioned in the interview, do not get anything. This man will never mention the massive subsidy to corporates in terms of almost free land and loans which they are excused from paying back.
In depth discussion. Thanks
गुलाटी जी, एक छोटी पुस्तिका लिखिये सभी क्षेत्रियों भाषाओं में अनुवाद कर सब किसानों को बँटवाने की व्यवस्था करना चाहिये।
This year the subsidy government pays farmers in wheat should go down. In fact it will profit as today international wheat prices are higher than the MSP
dude, our govt don't allow farmers to sell wheat even in different states, let alone internationally.
गुलाटी जी सही है किसान ने पानी हवा सब जहरीला कर दिया जो प्राइवेट स्कूलों में किताब हर साल नई दी जाती है उनसे पैड कटते हैं कभी उस पर आप जैसे अर्थशास्त्री ने बात की ओर एनजीटी भी इस बात नही
Great interview
पंजाब के किसान किसान आंदोलन को विफल करते हुए अडानी के वेयर हाउस में अपनी फसल बेचने के लिए मीलों लम्बी लाइन में खड़े हैं।
He is corporated favour economist
Lot of thanks sir great explaintion
Best interview ......
Govt agar paddy aur wheat ke ialava baaki cheejo pe bhi msp compulsory kre to farmers doosre crops bhi paida krege...lekin govt khud nhi chahti esa
We need to change our food basket.
The subsidies on fertilisers will be less than that government will save on wheat subsidies
gulati saab is an imressiv personality. I respect him alot.
I like gulhati sir
Poultry cannot be given as an example to promote privatisation of trade because it is supported by technology which is imported and not from State Agricultural Universities. I feel Research and Development is the spoiler.
Increase in international wheat prices is GOOD news for India and its farmers. With Russia offering to sell us oil at 35$ discount to international prices the petrol price in India should come down.
60$ was the max estimate for crude oil in the current budget now the prices are gone up 90$-120$ even if Russia give discount of 35$ it will still very high this is simple economics but now integrate economy and international politics and then the conclusion will be that buying Russian oil will not going to benefit our nation
Why not ensuring msp for oilseeds and pulses ie to the extent it is required in India. Discourage purchase of paddy slowly like first auction of oilseeds and pulses and paddy at the last. Now we have full data about the ownership of lands and allot acreage of paddy from a farmer and similar acreage of pulses/oilseeds. This work can be done by the agri department but should be done before sowing of crops .
Nice
Namaskar Masha Allah bahot hi sahi kaha aapne 💯
But if the same is being said by ruling dispensetion then, we have to protest.
Cool
Agar baaki crops pe bhi.. profitable price mile to kisaan ugaayege na...
Loss mein thodi na jayege...
best news
chalne do aise hi...jab log khud se badlaav maangenge tab sochna🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Bina maange to advice bhi nai deni chaiye India mein.
Ab to AAP ki govt hai..khareedle MSP se 10 Guna jyaada price mein...
Gulati who has world record of attaching his name to hundreds of articles by young researchers have come to full circle. With coming to a propaganda portal like wire.
Golati.ji.kya..kheti.ke.alava.aap.ke.pas.kon.sha.bjnes..ya.kese.khrcha.ghr.chlate.he.btana.tb.kishsn.ke.bare.me.malum.hoga
#Bhim Rao mission in the world #,channel को ज्यादा से ज्यादा Subscribe करें, "अधिकार की लड़ाई में निमंत्रण नहीं भेजे जाते,जिसका ज़मीर ज़िन्दा है वो खुद समर्थन में आ जाते हैं ",jay bhim jay संविधान 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻✊✊✊✊✊✊✊✊✊🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Too late now farmers supported anti farm laws made to modernise farming now let them collectively beg with middleman
Left wala hi sahi rehga the wire k liye Economist
Uncle Dal Makhni bnayi jaati hai,.. Ugayi nhi jaati.. Ugayi maanh(urad) jaati hai
MSP on telephone calls... Uncle TRAI bhi kuchh hai?
Ek hi time pe Corporates aur cooperative ka smarthan...matlab kuchh bhi
A economist should be the last person to speak on farming
Appointing people on CACP without any knowledge about agriculture is disastrous
Inspite of him being a economist he has not talked anything about
ECONOMY OF SCALE
In india 85 % of the farmers are less than 2 hectares
Whereas in the western Australia the average size of wheat farm is 4500 hectares in such a scenario how can the
indian farmer be cost competitive
😂😂 he is a agricultural economist
Gulati.ji.kishano..ki.fshl.ke.dam.fiks.hoa.chahiye.ya.nhi
गुलाटी बात खाधान्न पर है तो निर्मला क्यों बन रहा है राजा। खेत में काम कर रहे मजदूरों किसानों का इंटरव्यू ले द वायर इस प्रधानपाखंडी के भक्त का क्या ले रहा है।
Gulati.ji.mugfli.ke.ret.bides.me.kse.beche.20.klo.peda.hui.he
No technology work so long farmers is poor and don't surplus finance to take risks.rest discussion is futile and useless or party motivational and government favourism
Diversification aur water saving ki baat se sahmat hu'n.... Par baki sab galat examples dekar viewers ko mislead karne ki koshish..
Correct brother
लखनऊ के गरीब मुस्लिम सब्जी विक्रेता की 19 साल की बेटी ने महिला अंडर-19 हॉकी में इतिहास रच दिया थोड़ी ऐसी सकारात्मक खबरें भी चला लिया करो या सिर्फ नफरत फैलाने वाली ही खबरें क्यों चलाते हो तुम
जिस को फसलों के नाम नहीं पता उस से कृषि पे बात कर रहे हो। दाल मखनी😜
बकवास कर रहा है
Gulati to gulati mar bat karte he
Ye kaise kaise logon ke interview lete ho yaar. Kheti ke baare m hawa hawai baate kar reha h gulatimar. Msp p baat isliye nahi karni kyunki uske business friends ko issue hi sakta h
Msp hati to kisan barbaad hoga yeh gulati Buddha sataya gaya hai.
He's a corporate stooge
Kisan ko Kya chahiye yeh sirf Tikait decide karenge..aap chup raho...
😂 fir ३ कृषि कानून मन लेते
Gulati saab Kahan ke arth shastri hai.
Gadhaeconomics ke.
Another stupid misleading people against subsidy.
Ghadhe se poocho agar foodgrain mehnga hota hai to inflation bhi badega.
Fertilizer policy and management is for poors governance of BJP government
Gulati ji aap khud kyu ni krte kheti,
Krke dikhao fr kisano ko smjhana ki kaise benefits kmaya apne.
Gulati ji kisan bhi tax pay krta hai kyuki hr chij pr to tax hai kisan bhi to market se hi apne ghr ka sara sman purchase krta hai jo us pr mrp hai kisan ko bhi usi rate me milta hai Biscuits se lekr oil tk sb pr to tax hai
Agar baaki crops pe bhi.. profitable price mile to kisaan ugaayege na...
Loss mein thodi na jayege...
FREE MARKET ME JAAO.....