I'm 58 years old and a die hard Floyd fan since the beginning. Miley makes this song her own with more style and simplicity than any other artist who has covered It . This tune Is older than her and she owns It. Bravo girl.
I watched this prepared to hate it. She did damn good, I got NO complaints. One of the best covers of this song I've heard, this song was great when it came out and still is.
@@ehnonymouseshe goes out of tune knowing it to deliver more emotion depends on the artist in the past no one would sing pitch perfect. Artistic expression ❤
I lost my dad on New Years day January 1st 2020.. Pink Floyd was his all time favorite band and hearing you do a cover is just beautiful.. no matter who sings this song , it still makes me very emotional. So thank you Miley for having such a beautiful voice and singing this song. R.I.P dad, you are never forgotten, i love and miss you so very much. xoxo, from your one and only daughter Merci.
Your father should be so proud of you as you have those beautiful feelings in your hearth...Hes with you in every cell of your body...Rip your Lovely father
I lost my dad at 16 . In 1971. It has been tough without a dad all these years , but my memories of him are still strong. I can still hold them and feel loved.
This was the very 1st song I learned on my guitar when I was 17. I play by ear & now that my Dad passed away totally unexpected on August 15, 2021, this song has taken on a totally different meaning for me. I have always loved it & I always will. I miss you so much, Daddy! R.I.P. Cajun!! I love you even more than even I realized. Wish you were here. 🥺😢😭
WOW.... Same here Tabby, I've been playing guitar for 20+ years self taught. I also play by ear and this was one of the very first songs I learned. I'm a very big Pink Floyd fan and have learned several of there albums completely now. My last name is also Johnson. :-) My condolences to you and much respect to your father.
I feel you. My father died 2 months ago, I play guitar since I was 11, and I also learnt this son a long time ago, but now that my daddy dies, it took a whole new meaning. In the beginning I couldn't help crying. Now I don't, but it's still sad. I miss him so much. I hope he knows how much I love him, wherever he is. A big hug to you!
Sorry for your loss. Mine passed in 2017 and he wanted me to make sure Pink Floyd was played at his funeral. He was always the life of the party..he loved to sing and play guitar..was so animated and made everyone he met laugh. He had such a good heart and would help anyone if he could.. "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" is what was played at his service. Man I miss my dad. RiP to our dads and thanks to Pink Floyd for their music decades later.
It's songs like this that make me really like Miley even more. The simplicity of the video keeps the focus on the song itself. It reminds me that she is in it for the music more than the glam. Three thumbs up!
I’m just so shocked at how much she does. So many genres. She’s good at absolutely everything. Nothing she can’t do. All these classic rock covers. No one else like her.
If they valued her talent more and less her personal life then she would be the number one artist of these times, her versatility, charisma, humanity and incredible voice are a gift.
It seems to be her that values the drama more than her talent. It's all orchestrated. Sad too, as this isn't too bad. There's a grit in her voice I haven't noticed before.
As an old fellow, & an appreciator of great music , I heard and enjoyed so many great talents & each time been amazed & entertained by by them & without taking away from amazing work, This young lady just takes it to a whole new level, Please appreciate what you hear and see because I think she will be rated as one of the best if not already 🙏🙏🤩
The precision and artistry of Miley's vocal phrasing is compelling and astonishing at the same time. She is an incredibly disciplined performer, a true genius and a natural talent.
Well I'm 57 Miley. This a beautiful cover. A confident delivery start to finish. A well thought out arrangement staying true to every chord change. Other than some muting and a few throw away notes you delivered the songs message very well. A trademark feature within so many Pink Floyd songs is the intro attention grab. Your distinct voicing delivered just enough rasp and vulnerability. Great job Miley. Seems your sweet spots in life have been found.
Get over here hubby, on you knees...NOW! I'm just imagining being married to this women's libber. Some guys mike think it's fun...until the usual divorce comes with these types.
There’s never been a doubt about her talent. But her pop music and her whole stage presence isn’t really for our age groups. Perhaps she’s past all that and we can all just enjoy her talent. If you liked this, might I suggest Pink’s cover of Me and Bobbie McGee.
I'm just watching this and 2024, I'm the big Pink Floyd fan. I have been ever since I was a kid seen them in concerts multiple times. She did an excellent job. Very talented woman.🥰💞💖😍😘
Me agrada ver a ésta Miley, tan fuerte y decidida a ocupar el lugar que le corresponde en el ámbito de la música, sin dudas lo tiene todo para ser la mejor.
Wow. Just wow. I’m 62 in a couple of weeks and heard so many covers of this song down the years, but this is the best. Every time I hear her sing she impresses me more and more. What a voice.
I generally disdain Miley out of a; lovely voice, lousy image and image transition take. In my opinion I have seen her corruption over the years . Meh, I'm a boomer and who cares? Lol. Not me.
Your covers have been fantastic! It doesn't feel like you're performing them. It feels like they envelop your soul and you have to express them. Massive respect!
This was so moving, especially during covid. Have listened and relistened numerous times, just to re-expeperience how on point and incredibly performed this cover was
Heard this version today for the first time. Miley makes this PF classic sound like a flower power song with a voice that reminds me of Melanie Safka. Well done again, she never stops to ammaze me.
Her vocal quality is just perfect for this song, the natural vibrato and mournful tone is something that David Gilmour, as good as his performance is, simply doesn't have. Well done Miley. 😊 ❤
My first child oldest son passed away going on 5 yrs now and this is my song. Was one of his faves.. I didn't think anyone outside of Pink Floyd could ever sound as good. Thank you well sung
I agree, she has developed an amazing voice over the past, but she won't get far covering classics. I think she didn't manage to convey the true essence of "Wish You Were Here", but I would love for her to explore this trail more and maybe pop out some original, "classic-rock-feeling" tracks on her own. She definitely got potential.
I always like her covers. She doesn't change the arrangements much, if at all, She just sings the hell out of 'em. I really love her voice more and more as she gets older. I definitely think she's in her element when she does rock songs.
She's Growing beautifully. This is a prayer in my opinion, and I am so happy I got to hear in her voice. May God keep her safe and fiercely living to learn more about herself and her internal power
She's been covering classic rock songs in her tours since she was 15. She was always like this but her label didn't want her to move in this direction. I'm so glad she finally got rid of them :)))
Real music is subjective no need for the passive shade for other genres. But ya Miley is amazing like that she's a versatile singer who cannot be boxed in a single genre.
I´m immediately in love when she does such wonderful things. She makes it to her own song in a magical way. I wish she would make a record with these crazy cover songs like Jolene, sweet Jane and wish you were here.
Check out her cover of Blondie’s Heart of Glass, she kills it!! Miley is so underrated. No matter what people think of that girl, she’s oozing with talent. I love her! Her voice is INSANE!!!!!
Hard to cover such an iconic song by such a massive band but she is brilliant and brings her own to it. Agreed an album of her rock covers would be brilliant
I’ll never forget this time period. In the middle of the Covid Pandemic. She was going through the separation. The guitar player had just got over a hard hit from Covid. This was so heartfelt. I’ll never forget. It still makes me want to cry. (Scratch that, it actually does). We had lost so many. Not to mention she had had her vocal surgery. A mesmerizing performance from Miley on Saturday Night Live.
Hey!! Me too!! I was in another room, heard her singing “Help” and it was so powerful I had to come see who it was!! Now just found this and she’s finally growing into the class woman she’s meant to be.
Some people like her covers some don't (I like most of them) but either way is nice seeing her introducing a new generation to these cool classics. Probably some Millennials and Gen-Y will take the time to listen to the originals and expand their musical appreciation.
Strange to think that people born around my year (1987) never heard of Pink Floyd. But the small area that I live in happens to have only a handful of radio stations, and luckily I grew up listening to two of them which were pop oldies and a rock station that still plays the same rock and roll day in and day out when it comes to the oldies. So to me it was just the norm.
It's funny, brother. I remember being at a barbecue and I was sat playing Sabbath, Thin Lizzy, and Blue Oyster Cult. My friend's (new) step-dad comes up and sits beside me and him. First thing he says is: 'I bet you don't even know who these guys are, do you?' I wave my phone, which is hooked up to the aux, and say: 'Thin Lizzy. Jailbreak. 1976.' Be careful with this attitude you have. Some of us grew up with the right parents. And sometimes, even though we're 'millennials,' we've had the internet a hell've a lot more time than you: and plenty of time to do our research.
@@Zooptopus27 well, mostly because, they were from the 60's, originally. They weren't nearly as popular in the 80's, with the teens, as they were in the 60's. They are more in the psychedelic era of music, than that of heavy metal and glam rock. Which, the 80's, were more of the heavy metal and glam rock, than the psychedelic stuff. Even though, they were able to intermesh with each other on the radio stations and all. But, they were around the time that Lynyrd Skynyrd, Deep Purple, Janis Joplin, Jimmy Hendrix, Led Zeppelin and the other bands were writing song's about getting high on acid, instead of mostly weed. But, like I said, they still kept going through the 70's, 80's and early 90's. At least until the grunge rock music and the rap music took over the lead of the music world. They obviously stuck around with us diehard fans, of course. But, they weren't at the top of the billboards anymore, though...
@@Moll7399 I KNOW! I CANT WAIT WHEN SHE DROPS THEM!!! I have been repeating Edge of Midnight and Prisoner!! 😭 I was not rlly a rock fan but she made me one. And now I listen to Nirvana and so. Its crazy she makes you like something you never did. ❤️
I am older.I have a daughter Mileys age .She has an old soul.I think some of the younger generations need to listen to Pink Floyd and older artist.Stevie Nicks..Miley was doing a concert,She started singing Pink Floyd's song.She could tell that you get crowd really didn't know it so she stopped the song and sang something else.Miley is VERY talented. I think she is turning into a Queen!!!! Her spirt is Golden. I know Doc Magee that manged Motley Crew and Bon Jovi .ect. So the industry is tuff.Miley grew up in the industry. Her voice is amazing. Hugs from Chicago!
I doubt Miley ever reads these with 99.99999% certainty, but if she did, I'd like her to know I apologize for my misjudgment of her early career which I understand now was orchestrated by Disney and commend her absolute and indispensable talent as an artist. If my vocals are a 1000th yours, Ms. Cyrus, I'm blessed truly and totally.
I think the challenge now is to find a song Miley CAN’T sing. I’m not sure one exists. I have heard this lady sing pretty much every genre, and make signature songs her own. I don’t care what the haters say - this lady is pure talent and gold.
Her cover of Psycho Killer just dropped for the coming Talking Heads tribute album. Afraid she missed it on that one. But you're right, she can cover ALMOST anything and make it sound good, not just copying the original.
So so so good. I'm a die hard Pink Floyd fan. Love this cover so much. I was blown away by her rendition of 'No Tears Left To Cry'. Unique and amazing voice.....
@@theroostmandyvixengastationckn Yeah, fame and wealth make nepotism easy. You can look around the feeds to see the paid for promotions of offspring. Dolly Parton is a treasure, nothing sordid about her. Miley? Not so much. Then again, the era was another.
my dad was in the British army very young..he died of cancer..he loved Floyd..this floors me every time..this is for all the ex vets...great job miley..this is not about having a bad day...if you ever loved a ex get ..they are. forever chained in their miners in a metal cage of pain all alone.. it's so sad.
Miley is so talented, she can sing any cover, and she does a superb job! I just heard her sing "Landslide", and I was completely bowled over! Hope she someday does a covers album.
Completely agree. She reminds me of Stevie Nicks, she has such an amazing voice. I never took any notice of her until I came across some of the covers she had done on here.
i've seen multiple comments from older people, i'm 17 and i love when she covers this type of music. her original stuff is good too but i wish she'd release a rock album, suits her voice so well
I feel the same way. I'm 20 now knew her since I was 10 and I am so glad that she introduces our generation and me to so much good old music. 🌟 She is different than the other disney stars, her talent shows the most when she sings raw like this
I started to like Miley ,due to my daughter liking some of her songs as Hannah Montana and really appreciated her more when hearing ( get the party started ) when visiting Disney world with my daughter but I am really liking her newest song Midnight sky. And now after hearing her cover of my personal favourite band ( Pink Floyd ) Wish you were here. I am officially a fan. You rock Miley. Your voice is quite unique and very soothing in a raunchy way that I love. You have turned me into a fan of your unique style and creative expression. Keep rocking covers like heart of glass and zombie. You go girl. Luv ya.
Very nice. Sung with true feeling......well done dear. I'm 63 and saw PF live in the 70s, 80s, and lastly in 94. You did the song justice Miley. Very respectfully.
She can't sing this genre or at least she shouldn't be allowed to. There's a difference between missing notes and interpreting a song. She's incredibly bad.
I remember watching this when it first aired. It’s haunting, especially with the visuals. And we were all really feeling that whole “wish you were here” vibe at the time. Miley’s good at poking all my feels.
LOVE her voice and her version of this incredible song. It’s blows me away how much she sounds like Stevie Nicks from Fleetwood Mac! I love them both so freak’n much!
As a Floyd fan since before I can remember, and even more so as this is one of my favorite Floyd songs, I rabbit-holed myself to this video fully expecting to be neutral on it at best (to be fully honest, I'm neutral on Miley, and am very particular about covers of songs that I like - I thought I would hate this and click away after the first couple of verses). It's been a while since I've been this wrong - This is AMAZING!!!
I too ventuied into this with some trepidation - for the integrity of the song - I have recently watched a few of Miley's perfomances of covers and appreciate very much she is way more talented than pop culture shows - that said - I was in until the na-na-na - maybe Iam just being protective of this song and the memories.
@@theloniouscoltrane3778 Don't worry! We'll be saying the same thing in 60 years from now for Miley's music. The body gets old but the soul never does!
Never heard this cover by her until now abd gotta give her props ,,, was never a Miley fan but been watching her do a few covers and she's killing it , especially say hello 2 heaven , she killed that song ,
Really they keep focusing on her life too much you know fans of hers we're not sitting here focusing on her life like all these daily news channels on TH-cam are doing we recognized her Talent we see it and yes she's more than pop culture she's tough Rock country a little bit of everything you know
I'm 58 years old and a die hard Floyd fan since the beginning. Miley makes this song her own with more style and simplicity than any other artist who has covered It . This tune Is older than her and she owns It. Bravo girl.
I watched this prepared to hate it.
She did damn good, I got NO complaints.
One of the best covers of this song I've heard, this song was great when it came out and still is.
@@kazutams ...I thought exactly the same thing, I was like no way, but man was I surprised...
P Cz I just read a similar comment from an Irishman about her cover of Zombie. She's singing with soul.🔥
Check out her Heart of Glass (Blondie) and Landslide (Fleetwood Mac) covers also. I'm sold.
Listen to Alpha blondi's cover of this song, Very good also, but yes i like this too
I'm 300 yrs old, I really love when she does this kind of music. bless you.
Damn, you are old as hell. Glad you like it
Love
Man...
No one is immune to ageing my friend. It part of life in this world. 🤔🌍🌎🌏. Arnold Bourbon Amaral
Lol, I had to laugh.
So I've been wanting to go to bed for over an hour now and I just can't stop listening to all of Miley's covers. Amazing love it.
i listen to some of the songs over and over! She is soulful!
yeaaaah, me too
Same
Same lollll
Current situation for me at 317 am lol
She has a really uncanny knack for emotion and accent of her own style in whatever genre she sings. This woman is a super talent !!
this is so real, for this reason when Miley sings she connects emotionally and mentally with the lyrics, she transmits emotions through her voice
She goes out of tune. For instance; when she sings "from a cold steel rail". How does anyone think this is a good version?
It Really Got to me~
@@ehnonymouseshe goes out of tune knowing it to deliver more emotion depends on the artist in the past no one would sing pitch perfect. Artistic expression ❤
Miley is the left over real deal! She is country royalty!
Miley Cyrus is so much more than her pop culture persona. Her Backyard Sessions are great.
Couldn’t agree more. Her talent is unreal.
I feel she is her authentic self in these backyard sessions. No pretenses, no pressures, pure soul
I'd like her to drop the cocky B's and play some good music
why ??? i think all her pop culture is FUNDAMETAL
"Happy Hippie" pretty much says it all.
I lost my dad on New Years day January 1st 2020.. Pink Floyd was his all time favorite band and hearing you do a cover is just beautiful.. no matter who sings this song , it still makes me very emotional. So thank you Miley for having such a beautiful voice and singing this song.
R.I.P dad, you are never forgotten, i love and miss you so very much. xoxo, from your one and only daughter Merci.
Merci..your dad lives on forever in your heart and your memories..you take him everywhere with you...
May his memory be a blessing ❤
Lost my dad in 2019, also a big pink Floyd/Roger waters fan. Was shocked at how well she did this song
Your father should be so proud of you as you have those beautiful feelings in your hearth...Hes with you in every cell of your body...Rip your Lovely father
I lost my dad at 16 . In 1971. It has been tough without a dad all these years , but my memories of him are still strong. I can still hold them and feel loved.
have you ever been so stoned you started watching miley cyrus cover all your favorite bands? this was very good.
Me right now 🤣
😂 literally me right now
Yes! High as fuck looking through all her stuff (:
Yes 👍😂
Same lol
My God her phrasing in this is so good. The emotional impact of this is staggering. I've always liked her covers, but this is another tier.
We need a full album of these covers of classics. She’s nailing so many of them! ❤️
She is a bloody good singer, she can sing any damn songs. And good at make us keep guessing.
She is 27 Age now , just wonder at 40 what she will be.
🤣
Roger that. You can't get to the bottom of her talent. But I can hardly listen to her cover of "Zombie" without crying.
Make a play list lol
Yeah, she nails this classic, in the sense that she's crucifying it.
I'm hear to listen to all of her rock covers. Her nothing else matter cover jammed and so does her voice in this classic.
Music runs in her veins...she is the ultimate jack of all trades when it comes to singing..country pop rock...she just adapts and crush
Late at night I love to listen to Miley do these great covers. What a voice.
I have a new found respect for Miley Cyrus. She’s such a performer. All about the music!
This was the very 1st song I learned on my guitar when I was 17. I play by ear & now that my Dad passed away totally unexpected on August 15, 2021, this song has taken on a totally different meaning for me. I have always loved it & I always will. I miss you so much, Daddy! R.I.P. Cajun!! I love you even more than even I realized. Wish you were here. 🥺😢😭
WOW.... Same here Tabby, I've been playing guitar for 20+ years self taught. I also play by ear and this was one of the very first songs I learned. I'm a very big Pink Floyd fan and have learned several of there albums completely now. My last name is also Johnson. :-) My condolences to you and much respect to your father.
I feel you. My father died 2 months ago, I play guitar since I was 11, and I also learnt this son a long time ago, but now that my daddy dies, it took a whole new meaning. In the beginning I couldn't help crying. Now I don't, but it's still sad. I miss him so much. I hope he knows how much I love him, wherever he is. A big hug to you!
Sorry for your loss. Mine passed in 2017 and he wanted me to make sure Pink Floyd was played at his funeral. He was always the life of the party..he loved to sing and play guitar..was so animated and made everyone he met laugh. He had such a good heart and would help anyone if he could.. "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" is what was played at his service. Man I miss my dad. RiP to our dads and thanks to Pink Floyd for their music decades later.
She is so beautiful. Her voice is all raspy and real. She really connects. I think she is great and I hate pop culture.
It's songs like this that make me really like Miley even more. The simplicity of the video keeps the focus on the song itself. It reminds me that she is in it for the music more than the glam. Three thumbs up!
❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉 bravo !!!💫💫💫🎄
Well said - I couldn't agree more! Miley is a TRUE talent and she's not afraid not to 'function' according to anyone's expectations.
I’m just so shocked at how much she does. So many genres. She’s good at absolutely everything. Nothing she can’t do. All these classic rock covers. No one else like her.
Lets see her cover Porcupine Tree
@@MrGreenTiger lets see her cover cannibal corpse
And that gorgeous raspy voice, in a good way. Incredibly talented. 💕
@Better Call Sol I'd love to hear her cover Sleep Together or Trains. Gravity Eyelids or piano lessons. Freaking hell man
It traceycallk me
If they valued her talent more and less her personal life then she would be the number one artist of these times, her versatility, charisma, humanity and incredible voice are a gift.
Indeed she has a Goodheart and kind..despite the flaws of her life.
Many top artists have done way worse that her in their personal lives. Miley Cyrus is a top star
She is Miley Cyrus is because of that personality
The personal life is part of her
It seems to be her that values the drama more than her talent. It's all orchestrated. Sad too, as this isn't too bad. There's a grit in her voice I haven't noticed before.
Brutal cover
she's extremely versatile, and has great taste in her cover choices. I would love to hear her do more of this type of music, her voice is superb👍
As an old fellow, & an appreciator of great music , I heard and enjoyed so many great talents & each time been amazed & entertained by by them & without taking away from amazing work, This young lady just takes it to a whole new level, Please appreciate what you hear and see because I think she will be rated as one of the best if not already 🙏🙏🤩
The precision and artistry of Miley's vocal phrasing is compelling and astonishing at the same time. She is an incredibly disciplined performer, a true genius and a natural talent.
Well I'm 57 Miley. This a beautiful cover. A confident delivery start to finish. A well thought out arrangement staying true to every chord change. Other than some muting and a few throw away notes you delivered the songs message very well. A trademark feature within so many Pink Floyd songs is the intro attention grab. Your distinct voicing delivered just enough rasp and vulnerability. Great job Miley. Seems your sweet spots in life have been found.
This young woman has such a strong and compelling voice... Beautiful and haunting
Get over here hubby, on you knees...NOW!
I'm just imagining being married to this women's libber.
Some guys mike think it's fun...until the usual divorce comes with these types.
I'm not really a fan of any artists the past decades... but just became a Miley fan. Her rock covers seems like her original song. It suits her.
Would you like to marry her? Her women's libbing over you and likely divorce would be your bonus.
This is one of my favorite songs; I'm so glad this artist is singing it now!
Love the acoustic setting, just a guitar and a beautiful voice.
I'm 59yo and use to see Pink Floyd live before Mylie was born. Personally I loved this. Her voice and style choice was pretty awesome.
I'm going to have to go see you in concert one-day Miley you really did a tribute to Pink Floyd
Stai scherzando vero ? Questa versione è una merda !!! Lontana anni luce dai Pink Floyd ma anche dall' essere una cover decente ! Uno schifo
Its my dream to see david live
There’s never been a doubt about her talent. But her pop music and her whole stage presence isn’t really for our age groups. Perhaps she’s past all that and we can all just enjoy her talent. If you liked this, might I suggest Pink’s cover of Me and Bobbie McGee.
Ash also have those credentials and agree she was awesome
I'm just watching this and 2024, I'm the big Pink Floyd fan. I have been ever since I was a kid seen them in concerts multiple times. She did an excellent job. Very talented woman.🥰💞💖😍😘
Me agrada ver a ésta Miley, tan fuerte y decidida a ocupar el lugar que le corresponde en el ámbito de la música, sin dudas lo tiene todo para ser la mejor.
Wow. Just wow.
I’m 62 in a couple of weeks and heard so many covers of this song down the years, but this is the best. Every time I hear her sing she impresses me more and more.
What a voice.
I'll be 63 in a month and I agree.
Tampoco exageres
you have your opinion. I have mine.@@juangajardo4371
Check out Irish band Aslan. Live version at vicar street. Sadly lead singer Christy Dignam died last year.
Well... Miley has officially won me over these past few months. I really like the direction she's going in lately.
As someone who is a huge Pink Floyd fan and loves Miley’s covers, this is like heaven to me ❤❤❤❤
It is good . Very good.
She’s the real deal .. not faking anything ..a real live performer
I’m 350 years old. I really enjoy it when she covers tracks from those kids from 40 years ago.
Wait, your a robot?
I generally disdain Miley out of a; lovely voice, lousy image and image transition take. In my opinion I have seen her corruption over the years . Meh, I'm a boomer and who cares? Lol. Not me.
Im 490 years old and i love the young crowd at enlightenment
So you've been around since crazy Joe became a Senator?
So wait what?
This song takes me back to the first lockdown. So much has changed since then. Brings tears to my eyes.
DAMN! This is now my favorite cover of “Wish You Were Here.” Her talent has no limit.
I’ve heard this song sang over the years but until now never heard it sang so well .x
She's killing it with these covers. Especially this.....oh my goodness 😮
Love u miley
Gave me chills. I’ve always loved this song, her voice with it is beautiful.
Your covers have been fantastic! It doesn't feel like you're performing them. It feels like they envelop your soul and you have to express them. Massive respect!
Love her voice and her passion when she sings
This was so moving, especially during covid. Have listened and relistened numerous times, just to re-expeperience how on point and incredibly performed this cover was
This girl feels it with all her soul and you can’t ask anymore than that. Just beautiful!
❤
Please Miley, we need an Album of all the classics covers you did these last months. And please please on Vinyl 2. Would cross mountains to buy one!!
Heard this version today for the first time. Miley makes this PF classic sound like a flower power song with a voice that reminds me of Melanie Safka. Well done again, she never stops to ammaze me.
Her vocal quality is just perfect for this song, the natural vibrato and mournful tone is something that David Gilmour, as good as his performance is, simply doesn't have. Well done Miley. 😊 ❤
My first child oldest son passed away going on 5 yrs now and this is my song. Was one of his faves.. I didn't think anyone outside of Pink Floyd could ever sound as good. Thank you well sung
Sorry to hear that, Deana. My feelings to you
I'm so sorry to hear that.. I can't imagine the pain you feel. Sending love to you ❤️
God bless
I can see how this song would remind you how we must all play the hand we are given. Blessed be.
My condolences. It's too short
Miley is really underrated for the musician she is. She’s a legend. She will go down in history. And I’ll live a life of letting people know.
Her rock covers are amazing! I love when she credits her Dad for making her listen to great music!
Legend? LMAOOOO
Why? Because she’s covering amazing music? She’s pathetic
@@Nico-px2hg be quiet
I agree, she has developed an amazing voice over the past, but she won't get far covering classics. I think she didn't manage to convey the true essence of "Wish You Were Here", but I would love for her to explore this trail more and maybe pop out some original, "classic-rock-feeling" tracks on her own. She definitely got potential.
@@jessicatheodore1921 or?
I always like her covers. She doesn't change the arrangements much, if at all, She just sings the hell out of 'em. I really love her voice more and more as she gets older. I definitely think she's in her element when she does rock songs.
Wow, she excels at any type of music genre. Simply an amazing talent.
Amo la canción y me encanta la voz de esta mujer. Qué excelente combinación la he repetido varias y no me canso.
She's Growing beautifully. This is a prayer in my opinion, and I am so happy I got to hear in her voice. May God keep her safe and fiercely living to learn more about herself and her internal power
Why she took the longest path to the real music?! She is born to rock!
She's been covering classic rock songs in her tours since she was 15. She was always like this but her label didn't want her to move in this direction. I'm so glad she finally got rid of them :)))
It's her path, the right path, hers to call...whatever the desire...
I DVD don't it was choice, remember Disney tried to own her completly
Real music is subjective no need for the passive shade for other genres. But ya Miley is amazing like that she's a versatile singer who cannot be boxed in a single genre.
long path but better than no path. glad to see her where she is
I´m immediately in love when she does such wonderful things. She makes it to her own song in a magical way. I wish she would make a record with these crazy cover songs like Jolene, sweet Jane and wish you were here.
Surprising to say the least.
This sounds like Stevie Nicks doing Pink Floyd and it suits her.
Changes my opinion of Miley Cyrus completely.
Check out her cover of Blondie’s Heart of Glass, she kills it!! Miley is so underrated. No matter what people think of that girl, she’s oozing with talent. I love her! Her voice is INSANE!!!!!
@@kariesmith5313 her cover of The Cranberries's Zombie is better in my opinion
@@alvarodc1798 all here covers are Brillant my favourites tom petty chris Cornell and lana del Rey
she has her own amazing stuff tho. listen to her live performances with midnight sky - stevie nicks even joined on a remix of this song!
You're easily convinced
Quando eu descobrir o que eu vim fazer nessa vida, vai ser que nem a Miley escolhendo o rock. PERFEIÇÃO!!
Hard to cover such an iconic song by such a massive band but she is brilliant and brings her own to it. Agreed an album of her rock covers would be brilliant
I’ll never forget this time period. In the middle of the Covid Pandemic. She was going through the separation. The guitar player had just got over a hard hit from Covid.
This was so heartfelt. I’ll never forget. It still makes me want to cry. (Scratch that, it actually does). We
had lost so many.
Not to mention she had had her vocal surgery. A mesmerizing performance from Miley on Saturday Night Live.
This song has been rolling around in my head recently. Great job covering it ya brought me to tears
Why will it be? ... Deben haber cosas guardadas en los corazones
Im 66 yrs old. Her original stuff im just so so on. But when she does covers I'm a fan.
Hey!! Me too!! I was in another room, heard her singing “Help” and it was so powerful I had to come see who it was!! Now just found this and she’s finally growing into the class woman she’s meant to be.
Agree, I always thought she this wild child, but when she isn't pondering to the masses u actually see her talent.
I love her cover of Jolene
loving her new cover Help! by The Beatles th-cam.com/video/cFJWYsoxmvo/w-d-xo.html
@@PlantGiveawayPH Her Dylan covers excellent too.....
Some people like her covers some don't (I like most of them) but either way is nice seeing her introducing a new generation to these cool classics. Probably some Millennials and Gen-Y will take the time to listen to the originals and expand their musical appreciation.
I found pink Floyd through her, it's so good.
You got a point.
Strange to think that people born around my year (1987) never heard of Pink Floyd. But the small area that I live in happens to have only a handful of radio stations, and luckily I grew up listening to two of them which were pop oldies and a rock station that still plays the same rock and roll day in and day out when it comes to the oldies. So to me it was just the norm.
It's funny, brother. I remember being at a barbecue and I was sat playing Sabbath, Thin Lizzy, and Blue Oyster Cult. My friend's (new) step-dad comes up and sits beside me and him. First thing he says is: 'I bet you don't even know who these guys are, do you?'
I wave my phone, which is hooked up to the aux, and say: 'Thin Lizzy. Jailbreak. 1976.'
Be careful with this attitude you have. Some of us grew up with the right parents. And sometimes, even though we're 'millennials,' we've had the internet a hell've a lot more time than you: and plenty of time to do our research.
@@Zooptopus27 well, mostly because, they were from the 60's, originally. They weren't nearly as popular in the 80's, with the teens, as they were in the 60's. They are more in the psychedelic era of music, than that of heavy metal and glam rock. Which, the 80's, were more of the heavy metal and glam rock, than the psychedelic stuff. Even though, they were able to intermesh with each other on the radio stations and all. But, they were around the time that Lynyrd Skynyrd, Deep Purple, Janis Joplin, Jimmy Hendrix, Led Zeppelin and the other bands were writing song's about getting high on acid, instead of mostly weed. But, like I said, they still kept going through the 70's, 80's and early 90's. At least until the grunge rock music and the rap music took over the lead of the music world. They obviously stuck around with us diehard fans, of course. But, they weren't at the top of the billboards anymore, though...
I keep coming back to this cover. No one nails it like Miley does.....
She covers this classic amazingly well, beyond belief just how fantastic her version actually is, absolutely fantastic vocals.
How good is the guy playing the guitar. Great work by both of them.
If only he could play it somewhat like the original.
Que buenas versiones ha sacado de estos clásicos Miley Cyrus, se nota su madurez como artista. Voz rasposa, profunda y fuerte. Todo un aporte.
glad att ni tycker om henne i latinamerika. vet inte hur stor hon är i sverige. jag älskar henne i alla fall. greetings from botkyrka / hogslaby
Wow, Miley is the real deal,gutsy ,brave ,adventurous will take on a challenge, out of her comfort zone,go for it and give it 110% 👍
she was made to ROCK. just it.
@@Moll7399 I KNOW! I CANT WAIT WHEN SHE DROPS THEM!!! I have been repeating Edge of Midnight and Prisoner!! 😭 I was not rlly a rock fan but she made me one. And now I listen to Nirvana and so. Its crazy she makes you like something you never did. ❤️
**AGREED, SHE'S NOT BAD TO LOOK AT EITHER LOL 😆**
I am older.I have a daughter Mileys age .She has an old soul.I think some of the younger generations need to listen to Pink Floyd and older artist.Stevie Nicks..Miley was doing a concert,She started singing Pink Floyd's song.She could tell that you get crowd really didn't know it so she stopped the song and sang something else.Miley is VERY talented. I think she is turning into a Queen!!!! Her spirt is Golden. I know Doc Magee that manged Motley Crew and Bon Jovi .ect. So the industry is tuff.Miley grew up in the industry. Her voice is amazing. Hugs from Chicago!
Way2go Miley
she has no voice and no feeling, even Fiona Aplle is better...think about Aguileras voice or Oconnors come on
She did not stop band start play her hits and she say I hear your shit what you play ok
I doubt Miley ever reads these with 99.99999% certainty, but if she did, I'd like her to know I apologize for my misjudgment of her early career which I understand now was orchestrated by Disney and commend her absolute and indispensable talent as an artist. If my vocals are a 1000th yours, Ms. Cyrus, I'm blessed truly and totally.
Check her cover of blonde heart of glass as above never judge a book as the old saying goes
I think the challenge now is to find a song Miley CAN’T sing. I’m not sure one exists. I have heard this lady sing pretty much every genre, and make signature songs her own. I don’t care what the haters say - this lady is pure talent and gold.
Her cover of Psycho Killer just dropped for the coming Talking Heads tribute album. Afraid she missed it on that one. But you're right, she can cover ALMOST anything and make it sound good, not just copying the original.
So so so good. I'm a die hard Pink Floyd fan. Love this cover so much. I was blown away by her rendition of 'No Tears Left To Cry'. Unique and amazing voice.....
Trained by dolly Parton she knows all music all era's she doesn't disappoint
She is her God mother. Can't go wrong lol
Nice
@@theroostmandyvixengastationckn Yeah, fame and wealth make nepotism easy. You can look around the feeds to see the paid for promotions of offspring.
Dolly Parton is a treasure, nothing sordid about her. Miley? Not so much. Then again, the era was another.
She was trained by her dad and Dolly
my dad was in the British army very young..he died of cancer..he loved Floyd..this floors me every time..this is for all the ex vets...great job miley..this is not about having a bad day...if you ever loved a ex get ..they are. forever chained in their miners in a metal cage of pain all alone.. it's so sad.
Miley is so talented, she can sing any cover, and she does a superb job! I just heard her sing "Landslide", and I was completely bowled over! Hope she someday does a covers album.
Good rendition. She should do Fleetwood Mac songs like The Chain and Dreams
Totally agree
YES
Completely agree. She reminds me of Stevie Nicks, she has such an amazing voice. I never took any notice of her until I came across some of the covers she had done on here.
sellcyanidecracksdfsdfosdifswrtretertoiertio
Talking about her doing Fleetwood Mac I found this for you.
m.th-cam.com/video/QfXG7pR-24Q/w-d-xo.html
Damn., this woman can sing anything and make it sound great.!
Yes she’s so talented, her rock album out now
sellcyanidecracksdewrpowerweprwepr
What makes Miley such a great artist is that she emphasizes every word and you hear the meaning and intent of the lyrics !
Just loving Miley and her talent recently. Her covers are fabulous and she has such a powerful voice. Jolene such a classic.
i've seen multiple comments from older people, i'm 17 and i love when she covers this type of music. her original stuff is good too but i wish she'd release a rock album, suits her voice so well
She just did! Check out "Plastic Hearts", her newest album.
I feel the same way. I'm 20 now knew her since I was 10 and I am so glad that she introduces our generation and me to so much good old music. 🌟 She is different than the other disney stars, her talent shows the most when she sings raw like this
I started to like Miley ,due to my daughter liking some of her songs as Hannah Montana and really appreciated her more when hearing ( get the party started ) when visiting Disney world with my daughter but I am really liking her newest song Midnight sky. And now after hearing her cover of my personal favourite band ( Pink Floyd ) Wish you were here. I am officially a fan. You rock Miley. Your voice is quite unique and very soothing in a raunchy way that I love. You have turned me into a fan of your unique style and creative expression. Keep rocking covers like heart of glass and zombie. You go girl. Luv ya.
Very nice. Sung with true feeling......well done dear. I'm 63 and saw PF live in the 70s, 80s, and lastly in 94. You did the song justice Miley. Very respectfully.
I’m 45 n loved Floyd since I was about 13 this actually gave me goosebumps!
Not a fan of Miley and the pop industry at large, but props on this cover. A beautiful voice and rendition.
She’s definitely one of the best rock female cover singers
Wow what a cover of a classic song 🎵 she nails the song and puts her own signature on it
- __-WORD-__-
I wish Miley would do “The great Gig in the sky”. Everything she touches turns to gold! 🐈
wouldn't that be something?
That'd be absolutely epic.
Is there any genre that Miley Cyrus can't do? She's incredibly talented.
I agree she is talented, but she gets a bad rap
Robin Alexander her rap was good in don’t call me angel wasn’t it
check feelin myself with william, french montana, and snoop dogg
NA NA NA NA
She can't sing this genre or at least she shouldn't be allowed to. There's a difference between missing notes and interpreting a song. She's incredibly bad.
I remember watching this when it first aired. It’s haunting, especially with the visuals. And we were all really feeling that whole “wish you were here” vibe at the time. Miley’s good at poking all my feels.
Beautiful. I really like Miley's voice.
LOVE her voice and her version of this incredible song. It’s blows me away how much she sounds like Stevie Nicks from Fleetwood Mac! I love them both so freak’n much!
As a Floyd fan since before I can remember, and even more so as this is one of my favorite Floyd songs, I rabbit-holed myself to this video fully expecting to be neutral on it at best (to be fully honest, I'm neutral on Miley, and am very particular about covers of songs that I like - I thought I would hate this and click away after the first couple of verses). It's been a while since I've been this wrong - This is AMAZING!!!
I too ventuied into this with some trepidation - for the integrity of the song - I have recently watched a few of Miley's perfomances of covers and appreciate very much she is way more talented than pop culture shows - that said - I was in until the na-na-na - maybe Iam just being protective of this song and the memories.
To each his own...been listening to this song since 75..and most of its pop covers..the original emotion can't be replicated..we're getting old
@@theloniouscoltrane3778 Don't worry! We'll be saying the same thing in 60 years from now for Miley's music. The body gets old but the soul never does!
Check out her Bob Dylan!
@@thomast378 thanks!
This woman is a gift!!
Great job Miley 👏 She should do a whole album covering rock classics.
I love Floyd, i love this track, reminds me of my Dad, "wish you where here " pops
Amazing version, I'm becoming a big fan Miley. Just wow.
People forget that she's actually a very good singer
Your 💯 % right because I didn't realise how good she can sing until recently and her voice blew my mind.
To busy getting her tits out
No they don't, it's patently obvious every time she opens her mouth, she's incredibly talented
People don't care. And she's not...
@@Ingens_Scherz pees on the surfbroad
Never heard this cover by her until now abd gotta give her props ,,, was never a Miley fan but been watching her do a few covers and she's killing it , especially say hello 2 heaven , she killed that song ,
She's just great in almost every kind of music! What an incredible voice!
She sounds like Bonnie Tyler. I feel like she would kill a cover of it’s a heartache
Yes yes
no she sounds like Joan jett.
She would kill a cover of anything
Bonnie Tyler's voice is raspier.. I love them both
He has covered nothing but a heartache
miley is so talented. people should stop sleeping on her.
Really they keep focusing on her life too much you know fans of hers we're not sitting here focusing on her life like all these daily news channels on TH-cam are doing we recognized her Talent we see it and yes she's more than pop culture she's tough Rock country a little bit of everything you know
🤣🤣🤣
Sleeping on her - meaning??
@@Nina5144 Not paying attention to her
I never really liked her originals but wow these are perfect for her voice.
Major Pink Floyd fan here
Love this version , Love ya Miley 🎸🌹💕