Welcome everyone! Please remember to LIKE this video and SUBSCRIBE to our channel because it'll help grow our channel! We do our best to give our genuine, honest and respectful reactions. May peace be upon you all! 🙂
FUN FACT: Malcolm X disavowed many of his more black nationalist views after his Hajj trip in 1965, where he saw Muslims of different races worshiping Allah with no discord.
29:54 Meditation is not that modern though. Ancient india used to practise meditation and yoga. Therefore you will see older religions like buddhism, hinduism etc already have meditation mentioned. Its getting popular nowadays cuz people are realizing its benefits today in this stressful world.
The rise of Christianity and the rise of Islam kind of mirror each other in many ways. -Both religions became popular with the oppressed of society (women, slaves, prisoners). -Both religions were persecuted when they first arose and were horribly mistreated in captivity causing multiple martyrs. -Both of the founders were deeply religious in their faith. -Ali is kind of like Peter (not in the sense of being hand selected by the founder) in the way that they were the closest to the founder during the founder's life. -The Sunni-Shia split is kind of like the Gentile-Jewish split. -The Gentile- Jewish split happened at the first ecumenical council at Jerusalem in the 30s CE (a few tears after Christ died). -The main issue in the council was whether or not Christianity should stay a sect of Judaism or outwardly proselytize among to the Gentiles. -In the council there was a fierce debate between Peter and Simon (both in the proselytizer camp) whether or not the converted Gentiles should follow the dietary laws of Judaism outlined in Deutoronemy. - Peter's view of Gentiles being allowed to not follow the dietary laws won out in that debate.
Corrections *the sunni-shia split is very different than the Jewish law debate *the council happened at 50AD * It wasn't a debate about whether to proselytize to gentiles but whether gentiles had to keep the jewish law to be Christian, or even if Jews had to continue to keep the law. This debate continued throughout Christian history over how much of the law should be followed. The council agreed that the only laws gentiles must keep are not eating blood, no idolatry, no fornication, no eating strangled meat or meat sacrifed to other gods *The debate was between Peter/James and Paul/Barnabas *Paul won the debate after Peter had a vision
2:45 - well said, no Muslim paints a broad brush over other religions when it comes to this, so others doing it to our religion does not make sense either. Good reaction brothers. Keep it up!
36:17 I think he is referring to Turkey here, where their state's founder Atatürk wanted a strict separation between state and religion which is why since the 80s headscarves are banned in all public buildings and schools there. It seems to be a hot topic at the moment as Erdogan wants to overturn that law but many who oppose him and think he has become too conservative with age see it as a betrayal of the founding father and the ideals of their country.
@@zomberkay I am German, so don't really have a horse in the race. Turkey just has some relevance to me due to the amount of migrants coming from there. Imo he is similar to Putin a once effective and good leader that has grown old and doesn't want to relinquish power and thereby turning more and more into an autocrat doing incredible damage to the political and societal structure of their nation by persecuting opposition and pushing a religious ultra nationalism with leader cult. Granted Erdogan is still far from Putin's level of madness but that's the direction I see him going
@hmvollbanane1259 the problem I have with the migrants in Germany is that the original workers were okay bunch not too good not too bad. But their grandchildren are arrogant and uneducated bunch they try to flaunt their bmw or audi cars here in turkey. And %90 of them support Erdogan. There's a big rise of hate against these people in turkey especially among the young. That aside, erdogan and his team were doing good for the first 10 years. Last 12 years are a big disaster. This also marks his 22 year rule if you noticed.
Cogito is not wrong tho: in 20th century Turkey and Iran, during Ataturk's and Reza Shah's reign respectively, veils and headcoverings for women were officialy banned, especially in state institutions and public places. Also, regarding the succession after Muhammad and beginnings of the Sunni-Shia split (it's going to be a text wall but bear with me): there are some historians who say that one of the original fault lines was the difference in early Muslim society between the North Arabian nomadic Beduin tradition and South Arabian sedentary tradition of Himyarite Yemen. In Beduin tradition clan councils had the ultimate authority and chose clan leaders, so power was elected, while in great cities of the south tradition dictated hereditaty rule passed through the bloodline, as they have been monarchies for hundreds of years. Yemen, much more populous than northern Arabia, was conquered by Muslims around 930, so 2 years before the prophet's death. Muhammad rebelled against so many traditional aspects of Meccan society that it wasn't really obvious if the power of clan councils would be kept intact and he indeed never directly stated who should become his successor so there was a vaccume and uncertainty of sorts. After Yemen's conquest the northern and southern traditions were likely competing with each other and after the death of Islam's prophet those who subscribed to the southern Yemenite tradition saw Ali and his children as obvious successors (inheritance through bloodline), becoming the foundation of "the Party of Ali". Beduin clan leaders meanwhile obviously believed that succession should be decided by the council, as they have always done in the north (power through elections). Northern Beduin tradition won out and Rashidun caliphs would be decided by clan councils. But the southern Yemenite tradition would become fixed aspect of Shia political and later religious doctrine, in later centuries only strenghtened by the influence of Iranian monarchical tradition, as after the conquest of Sasanian Iran many Iranians joined the Shiites, seing in them political allies against caliphate's establishment
I have been to a mosque before many times The community i grew up in is very mixed I have been invited by friends during prayers They thought me how to do the Wudu helped me do it And whe we Got in the respectfully ask me to stand at the far back While the do thier Sallah So everytime i i accompany them i know what i have to do And i dont distract them they finish thier prayers I greet everyone one and we leave Am African by the Way
sorry to say this but never to harm animal's. is a bit ironic, since sheeps and cows are eaten during eid. ? pls correct me if I'm wrong. just trying to understand.
Harming animals unnecessarily or purposefully torturing them is prohibited. According to the stipulations of Islam the animal that is being slaughtered must be: In a calm state Have the neck cut with a razor sharp blade as fast as possible Through the jugular vein The purpose must be for consumption or distribution of the meat to the poor -Rohaib
slaughtering animals is harming them. taking a life is sinful isn't it. on top of that, earlier due to shortages of food i accept it might have been necessary at times. But a good Muslim in todays world doesn't need to slaughter animal's. they are rich as well that slaughter for the gain. Main point being is harming any animals is sinful? right? I'm trying to understand this. not getting it sorry for the trouble sir
@@sumitpatil870The specific way that Muslims slaughter an animal is designed to limit the amount of suffering for an animal, it is very specific. If one sacrifices an animal in an improper way that caused pain to the animal, it is not accepted. Along with this, the food is used for feeding the poor and families, and other good causes, it is not used for wasteful causes.
Muslims believe that we have the right to eat certain animals as made permissible by God. It doesn’t matter if other food sources are available. We believe these animals are a blessing for mankind to use and benefit from. But they have rights in the sense where we cannot torture them or harm them. The only exception is obviously when we kill them to consume. However, this has many rules attached to it. So I’m any time or context is a Muslim kills and animal properly to consume it, this is never sinful. Just like how murder is wrong, but to defend yourself, at times it is permissible. -Rohaib
@@MuslimMindsUS killing a unharming animal is not the same as murder or defending yourself. how is that the same. 😅 as the animal has no way to defend it's self. i wonder what god would think. Btw is it written down in Qur'an that it's permissible to eat animals?
Once you look at the world with the view that "my holy book is the ultimate truth"why are you even bothering looking at other religions? You've already shut your Muslim mind to other ideas.
I want more muslims to react of this video pls ... , some scholars as well , to check the videos credibility & is it ok to share the video with some non-muslim to introduce them to islam
Hello Againt Dear Friends, Assalamualaikum, How was your day i wanted to explained about Why The art in Persian The holy Prohpet and poius on fire? It's simply a Persian/Arabic version of Halo in chrisitiany they use halo a circle light but in our religion many Arts use fire to mean glory And Great
There isn’t a difference when you die if you’re Muslim or anything else. We will all be judged by Allah/God. It’s that simple, even Muslims can be punished. It’s all based on our actions and intentions. Hope this clarifies! Appreciate your comment and question! -Hamza
@@MuslimMindsUS So in Islam, a devout Jew or Christian who lives a good life and serves God would go to Heaven? How about an Atheist or Hindu who believes in no God or many gods respectively?
Up to God to judge, Muslims have a more secure idea of salvation. But for those who don’t have a proper understanding or were sincere, have a chance of being saved if God decides -Rohaib
God is an intelligent and merciful being, you really cannot say all non muslims will go to hell. He might make an exception on some non Muslims since he too has free will. This is mentioned in the Qur'an as well by the way.
Assalamualaikum brother, that is amazing to hear alhamdulilah. I would start by reading the Quran, look up the clear Quran, it is a good English translation. Go to your local masjid and inform the imam that you a new Muslim and they will assist you. Please reach out to us on instagram and we will talk with you further and send you some resources @muslim.minds.us
What kind of god allow slavery, if Muhammed was the messenger of god, he should abolish bad things, instead he approves it except with their wives or those ˹bondwomen˺ in their possession,1 for then they are free from blame, إِلَّا عَلَىٰٓ أَزْوَٰجِهِمْ أَوْ مَا مَلَكَتْ أَيْمَـٰنُهُمْ فَإِنَّهُمْ 10:36 غَيْرُ مَلُومِينَ ٦
Dudes , Indonatian Muslims have some hinduistic practices . Their currency has lord Ganesha picture on it . Please look at Indonesian history , culture and some practices by them a little deeper. It is Hinduism influence ,makes the typical Indonesian muslims more peaceful .
The currency with that picture is not produced for the last 15 years... Also, I dont see your point? They are still the largest Muslim majority country, what do they do that is unislamic?
@@MuslimMindsUS yes Indonesia has lord Ganesha in their currency.....they play ramayan.as cultural drama.... they have Hindu god statue like goddess saraswati they named their building, flight inspired by hindus.....and also they believe their ancestors were hindu.................
@@navyashrivastava393 i also agreed with you, left guy is also brainwashed, @MuslimMindsUS bro have you ever think why every terriost group is a muslim jihadi group and is shariya laws good for a muslim women???? Although no hate for islam all religions are Just a way of living,
Welcome everyone! Please remember to LIKE this video and SUBSCRIBE to our channel because it'll help grow our channel! We do our best to give our genuine, honest and respectful reactions.
May peace be upon you all! 🙂
I’m liked and subscribed
FUN FACT: Malcolm X disavowed many of his more black nationalist views after his Hajj trip in 1965, where he saw Muslims of different races worshiping Allah with no discord.
In Hinduism there is a book called bhavishya purana that is older than Islam itself it mentions about Mecca before Islam. Please read it.
I do t think they will find the description of their prophet to be really good there... given he is called a mlechha there...😅
Macca once belongs to a different relegion and Muhammad killed poor people who lived there and maade slaves and threatened to convert to islam....
29:54 Meditation is not that modern though. Ancient india used to practise meditation and yoga. Therefore you will see older religions like buddhism, hinduism etc already have meditation mentioned. Its getting popular nowadays cuz people are realizing its benefits today in this stressful world.
The rise of Christianity and the rise of Islam kind of mirror each other in many ways.
-Both religions became popular with the oppressed of society (women, slaves, prisoners).
-Both religions were persecuted when they first arose and were horribly mistreated in captivity causing multiple martyrs.
-Both of the founders were deeply religious in their faith.
-Ali is kind of like Peter (not in the sense of being hand selected by the founder) in the way that they were the closest to the founder during the founder's life.
-The Sunni-Shia split is kind of like the Gentile-Jewish split.
-The Gentile- Jewish split happened at the first ecumenical council at Jerusalem in the 30s CE (a few tears after Christ died).
-The main issue in the council was whether or not Christianity should stay a sect of Judaism or outwardly proselytize among to the Gentiles.
-In the council there was a fierce debate between Peter and Simon (both in the proselytizer camp) whether or not the converted Gentiles should follow the dietary laws of Judaism outlined in Deutoronemy.
- Peter's view of Gentiles being allowed to not follow the dietary laws won out in that debate.
Corrections
*the sunni-shia split is very different than the Jewish law debate
*the council happened at 50AD
* It wasn't a debate about whether to proselytize to gentiles but whether gentiles had to keep the jewish law to be Christian, or even if Jews had to continue to keep the law. This debate continued throughout Christian history over how much of the law should be followed. The council agreed that the only laws gentiles must keep are not eating blood, no idolatry, no fornication, no eating strangled meat or meat sacrifed to other gods
*The debate was between Peter/James and Paul/Barnabas
*Paul won the debate after Peter had a vision
2:45 - well said, no Muslim paints a broad brush over other religions when it comes to this, so others doing it to our religion does not make sense either.
Good reaction brothers. Keep it up!
Salaam bro, exactly! Appreciate the support, jazakAllah khair! 😁
-Hamza
@@MuslimMindsUS Wa'Salam and wa iyyak bro, no worries.
36:17 I think he is referring to Turkey here, where their state's founder Atatürk wanted a strict separation between state and religion which is why since the 80s headscarves are banned in all public buildings and schools there. It seems to be a hot topic at the moment as Erdogan wants to overturn that law but many who oppose him and think he has become too conservative with age see it as a betrayal of the founding father and the ideals of their country.
Are you against him ?
@@zomberkay I am German, so don't really have a horse in the race. Turkey just has some relevance to me due to the amount of migrants coming from there.
Imo he is similar to Putin a once effective and good leader that has grown old and doesn't want to relinquish power and thereby turning more and more into an autocrat doing incredible damage to the political and societal structure of their nation by persecuting opposition and pushing a religious ultra nationalism with leader cult. Granted Erdogan is still far from Putin's level of madness but that's the direction I see him going
@hmvollbanane1259 the problem I have with the migrants in Germany is that the original workers were okay bunch not too good not too bad.
But their grandchildren are arrogant and uneducated bunch they try to flaunt their bmw or audi cars here in turkey. And %90 of them support Erdogan.
There's a big rise of hate against these people in turkey especially among the young.
That aside, erdogan and his team were doing good for the first 10 years.
Last 12 years are a big disaster.
This also marks his 22 year rule if you noticed.
Cogito is not wrong tho: in 20th century Turkey and Iran, during Ataturk's and Reza Shah's reign respectively, veils and headcoverings for women were officialy banned, especially in state institutions and public places.
Also, regarding the succession after Muhammad and beginnings of the Sunni-Shia split (it's going to be a text wall but bear with me): there are some historians who say that one of the original fault lines was the difference in early Muslim society between the North Arabian nomadic Beduin tradition and South Arabian sedentary tradition of Himyarite Yemen. In Beduin tradition clan councils had the ultimate authority and chose clan leaders, so power was elected, while in great cities of the south tradition dictated hereditaty rule passed through the bloodline, as they have been monarchies for hundreds of years. Yemen, much more populous than northern Arabia, was conquered by Muslims around 930, so 2 years before the prophet's death. Muhammad rebelled against so many traditional aspects of Meccan society that it wasn't really obvious if the power of clan councils would be kept intact and he indeed never directly stated who should become his successor so there was a vaccume and uncertainty of sorts. After Yemen's conquest the northern and southern traditions were likely competing with each other and after the death of Islam's prophet those who subscribed to the southern Yemenite tradition saw Ali and his children as obvious successors (inheritance through bloodline), becoming the foundation of "the Party of Ali". Beduin clan leaders meanwhile obviously believed that succession should be decided by the council, as they have always done in the north (power through elections). Northern Beduin tradition won out and Rashidun caliphs would be decided by clan councils. But the southern Yemenite tradition would become fixed aspect of Shia political and later religious doctrine, in later centuries only strenghtened by the influence of Iranian monarchical tradition, as after the conquest of Sasanian Iran many Iranians joined the Shiites, seing in them political allies against caliphate's establishment
No
I have been to a mosque before many times
The community i grew up in is very mixed
I have been invited by friends during prayers
They thought me how to do the Wudu helped me do it
And whe we Got in the respectfully ask me to stand at the far back
While the do thier Sallah
So everytime i i accompany them i know what i have to do
And i dont distract them they finish thier prayers
I greet everyone one and we leave
Am African by the Way
sorry to say this but never to harm animal's. is a bit ironic, since sheeps and cows are eaten during eid. ? pls correct me if I'm wrong. just trying to understand.
Harming animals unnecessarily or purposefully torturing them is prohibited.
According to the stipulations of Islam the animal that is being slaughtered must be:
In a calm state
Have the neck cut with a razor sharp blade as fast as possible
Through the jugular vein
The purpose must be for consumption or distribution of the meat to the poor
-Rohaib
slaughtering animals is harming them. taking a life is sinful isn't it. on top of that, earlier due to shortages of food i accept it might have been necessary at times. But a good Muslim in todays world doesn't need to slaughter animal's. they are rich as well that slaughter for the gain. Main point being is harming any animals is sinful? right? I'm trying to understand this. not getting it sorry for the trouble sir
@@sumitpatil870The specific way that Muslims slaughter an animal is designed to limit the amount of suffering for an animal, it is very specific. If one sacrifices an animal in an improper way that caused pain to the animal, it is not accepted. Along with this, the food is used for feeding the poor and families, and other good causes, it is not used for wasteful causes.
Muslims believe that we have the right to eat certain animals as made permissible by God. It doesn’t matter if other food sources are available. We believe these animals are a blessing for mankind to use and benefit from. But they have rights in the sense where we cannot torture them or harm them. The only exception is obviously when we kill them to consume. However, this has many rules attached to it.
So I’m any time or context is a Muslim kills and animal properly to consume it, this is never sinful.
Just like how murder is wrong, but to defend yourself, at times it is permissible.
-Rohaib
@@MuslimMindsUS killing a unharming animal is not the same as murder or defending yourself. how is that the same. 😅 as the animal has no way to defend it's self. i wonder what god would think. Btw is it written down in Qur'an that it's permissible to eat animals?
Once you look at the world with the view that "my holy book is the ultimate truth"why are you even bothering looking at other religions? You've already shut your Muslim mind to other ideas.
I want more muslims to react of this video pls ... , some scholars as well , to check the videos credibility & is it ok to share the video with some non-muslim to introduce them to islam
Hello Againt Dear Friends, Assalamualaikum, How was your day i wanted to explained about Why The art in Persian The holy Prohpet and poius on fire? It's simply a Persian/Arabic version of Halo in chrisitiany they use halo a circle light but in our religion many Arts use fire to mean glory And Great
Wait so the sentences within a story are sorted by length within each surra or are also the stories themselves mixed with eachother?
Nice video
Thank you!!!
-Hamza
In Islam, what happens to Christians and Jews when they die?
There isn’t a difference when you die if you’re Muslim or anything else. We will all be judged by Allah/God. It’s that simple, even Muslims can be punished. It’s all based on our actions and intentions. Hope this clarifies! Appreciate your comment and question!
-Hamza
@@MuslimMindsUS So in Islam, a devout Jew or Christian who lives a good life and serves God would go to Heaven? How about an Atheist or Hindu who believes in no God or many gods respectively?
Up to God to judge, Muslims have a more secure idea of salvation. But for those who don’t have a proper understanding or were sincere, have a chance of being saved if God decides
-Rohaib
God is an intelligent and merciful being, you really cannot say all non muslims will go to hell.
He might make an exception on some non Muslims since he too has free will.
This is mentioned in the Qur'an as well by the way.
@@MuslimMindsUS Are the people of the book more secure than pantheists or atheists?
Why did Pakistan harbour bin la den? Answer this.
Why are you asking us, are we the Pakistani government lol? Go ask Pakistan
-Rohaib
So you think all Pakistanis knew he was hiding there?
I don't like Pakistan too but atleast ask a logical question.
Why indians have problem with bin laden? Even usa didn't have problem with bin laden when he was fighting against soviet lol
There was no bin laden it's a cover up for United States to act freely in the Arabian peninsula
i am a revert any tips?
Assalamualaikum brother, that is amazing to hear alhamdulilah. I would start by reading the Quran, look up the clear Quran, it is a good English translation. Go to your local masjid and inform the imam that you a new Muslim and they will assist you.
Please reach out to us on instagram and we will talk with you further and send you some resources
@muslim.minds.us
@@MuslimMindsUS🤣🤣🤣🤣
What kind of god allow slavery, if Muhammed was the messenger of god, he should abolish bad things, instead he approves it
except with their wives or those ˹bondwomen˺ in their possession,1 for then they are free from blame,
إِلَّا عَلَىٰٓ أَزْوَٰجِهِمْ أَوْ مَا مَلَكَتْ أَيْمَـٰنُهُمْ فَإِنَّهُمْ
10:36 غَيْرُ مَلُومِينَ ٦
I'd like to see a vid about Ahmadiyas
Dudes , Indonatian Muslims have some hinduistic practices . Their currency has lord Ganesha picture on it . Please look at Indonesian history , culture and some practices by them a little deeper. It is Hinduism influence ,makes the typical Indonesian muslims more peaceful .
The currency with that picture is not produced for the last 15 years... Also, I dont see your point? They are still the largest Muslim majority country, what do they do that is unislamic?
I agree !!! Do video on indonatian Muslims and their culture too , everything will be cleared .
@@MuslimMindsUSyou have no knowledge of history.
@@MuslimMindsUS yes Indonesia has lord Ganesha in their currency.....they play ramayan.as cultural drama.... they have Hindu god statue like goddess saraswati they named their building, flight inspired by hindus.....and also they believe their ancestors were hindu.................
@@navyashrivastava393 i also agreed with you, left guy is also brainwashed, @MuslimMindsUS bro have you ever think why every terriost group is a muslim jihadi group and is shariya laws good for a muslim women???? Although no hate for islam all religions are Just a way of living,
ok show me where its written you cant attack women and children pls
You guys trying your best to polish islam....
brother u study indonesien history this country before hindius then 1800century they conversation islam now they fallow culture sanatan
Search ex Muslim sahil and Adam seeker
They will show them the reality of islam in the same book which is with them. They just need to pick it up and search for the verse😂😂😂😂.
stop interrupting again and agian
It’s a reaction, you can watch the original yourself if you want
Lol
the devil's in the detail🤣
What is sex slave bro