Are Forcefields Possible?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 ก.ย. 2017
- Is Violet's forcefield from The Incredibles 2 possible?
Why don't they exist in real life? Are they physically possible? Come find out.
Hi! I'm Jade. I'm an Aussie with a Bachelor's degree in Applied Physics. After three years and over 100 lab sessions, I realized I'm terrible at experiments. So now I make physics and maths videos on TH-cam :) Check out my channel and subscribe if you like:
SUBSCRIBE / upandatom
Visit the Up and Atom Store
store.nebula.app/collections/...
Let's be friends :)
TWITTER: upndatom?lang=en
Other Videos You Might Like!
Math, When Are You Going to Use It? • Why Math is Important
The Physics of Free Will • The Physics of Free Will
Would Physics Be the Same in a Mirror Universe? • Charge Parity Violatio...
Big thank you to Mr. Beat for supplying the footage with the transition glasses! Check out his channel here: / iammrbeat
SOURCES
Physics of the Impossible - Michio Kaku
www.amazon.com/Physics-Imposs...
Force field movie clips:
Epic Fight Scenes: #9 - Dune (Shield Practice) • Epic Fight Scenes: #9 ...
FANTASTIC FOUR "Let's get invisible" [Invisible Woman]
• Video
Star Trek vs Star Wars: Shields
• Star Trek vs Star Wars...
The Incredibles - Violet VS Dash
• Video - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
Two atoms are looking out a plasma window. One atom says, "Hey, I just lost an electron." His friend asks, "Are you sure?" The first atom replies, "Yes, I'm positive."
😂😂😂😂😂
This deserves more likes
@@kalvincochran9505fr
Is it supposed to be funny?
@@uno2326 focus on the Yes I'm positive part... Otherwise rewatch the video to where she explains what plasma is made of.
I love how dejected Gravity was when you took his pencil.
Lol
I felt so bad for that gravity force
Why? If you look at the 4 forces described, gravity is actually quite strong.
The weak and strong nuclear forces are both extremely short ranged. So they can't influence things over great distances.
Gravity and Electromagnetism have infinite ranges using the inverse square law. And the electromagnetic force is far stronger than gravity. But ... there's a problem with electromagnetism. Namely that it has two charges that cancel each other out. And since there's an equal amount of both charges on a macro scale, electromagnetism really doesn't have a huge effect over long distances.
But gravity? It may be weak, but there's only one type and it's attractive. So add more mass and the total force increases without limit.
Truly, Gravity sure is a sad character. Last time I talked to him he was living in some slum under Bikini Bottom's trash heap of decaying pineapple tops. Truly sad! I think someone should start a gofundme to help this poor powerless guy :/ ;) :D
I did too. Gravity was all like "hey you wanna go for coffee" and she was all "nah I got my own thermos flask thanks". Bro looked beaten.
thats not how it works
Dark energy/Dark matter stole his girlfriend
Which makes me think that we could make a force field using these properties
Glad I got to show off my glasses that secretly block laser beams!
Haha must feel nice being a super hero :)
@Shanaya Kaur Australia.
The magnetosphere is a force field. It burns up things that fly through it. Although it isn't perfect it is a shield. It stops a lot of things. It repeals it protects it is spherical as well. By my definition we have a giant force field.
Correct and if we develope a emf emitter stronger than electromagnets, we could in theroy create a thin field of emf at high particle density.
My friend I cry when I see intelligent people working in the wrong paradigm, what a waste for humanity. It's like when the police came to look for my mother in law in the wrong lake, how long do you think they searched, and do you think they found the body? In order to find my mother in law they had to look in the right lake, starting with the fact that, and hold on to your braces, there is no space. Universe, space, stars, but even the atomic conception of matter it's all unproven, it's something they have been drilling into us since I was kid when I was reading Asimov, Clarke and Bradbury, I fell for it and lost 30 years on this, I am telling you with all the love in the world, look better look deeper and use your head, but you already are, just not int he right lake.
@@SavageDarknessGames Good thinking, but magnetism will be reacting to metal objects only, electrostatics would be the answer as it attracts anything and moves anything given the right voltage - in zillions volts probably; however in order to offset's earth production of electrostatics (diaelectrics), you would need a generator the size of earth, and that would be if we knew how earth created it's magnetic (dialectric) fields, because it isn't with a molten core, by definition, past the Currie point that this is ever going to happen.
@@SavageDarknessGames How is magnetism made of particles, it's big claim that we cannot prove, even light it's unproven it's made of particles - photons. (The monadic approach was an invention from Leibnitz where atoms = monades, it's a nice story, science ran with it, but again, it is unproven.)
Being linguistically proficient in identifying scientific elements doesn't means those scientific elements 1. do exist 2. are used in the right context anyway.
@@thewizardsofthezoo5376 try the double slit experiment with a charge emp burst
Dash: HEY NO FORCEFIELDS!!!!
Violet : *You started it*
i didnt get this reference😂😅😅
@@anmolsinghal484 it's from the movie The Incredibles
@@anmolsinghal484 it's from the incredibles
thanks😂
I love these animations!
Thank you! Means a lot coming from the master of animations :)
Not only the animations !
I really love the way you explain things in a calm tone and at just about the right pace. The animations really help visualize the idea. Keep making such wonderful science videos. Subscribed :)
Try Physics Girl!
Jade these videos look so high quality now. I can't watch this right this second but I am gonna come back and check it out :)
Great and interesting video- keep up the great work. Love the 12tone T shirt too!
Thank you for the support! And yes it's a very cute T-shirt n_n
Every night before I go to sleep i get my phone and learn something from this channel.
LOVE FROM BANGLADESH 🙏
Great work Jade! Really like the idea and well written. :)
Props for the clip from Dune
Step Back History Damn! You beat me to it!
I have put at least 2 Dune references in my videos. I don't mess around.
Step Back History I don't know why so many people hate the David Lynch movie. Yes, it's gritty and weird and doesn't follow the book closely, but those rough edges is what's good about it.
Gritty and weird kinda defines Dune... and David Lynch.
Thank you! Someone on my twitter recommended I use it :) Glad you liked it! It did make me realize how far special effects have come...
Since i have also read it, I can confirm that you prepared this video after reading Physics of the Impossible. Tbh, I really loved your narrating style. You doubled the fun with your excellent visuals and explanation. Keep it up!
Love this channel and the host and the animations. Thanks very much!
Your attitude, moves and expression are fabulous. You could be a great teacher for anyone or with anything :P .
love for you and for the force field as Star Trek Discovery has shown :D .
Brilliant work Jade :) I love topics like these and for sure all the science fans. Actually I requested a video to you before about physics of the impossible and I'm very happy to see it for real haha :p Thank you very much for your efforts!
Thank you! I listen to my viewers ;) and I'll be doing more videos on the physics of the impossible so make sure to stick around!
Yes, We will XD, because this is our favorite hobby, doing positive stress LOL. And it is said that : It is difficult when I have to and so easy when I want to. And we want it all :) We'll be waiting for your new physics of the impossible vids
Electrified soap bubbles (with floaty nanomaterial)
I like to believe that the electrons that race around the nucleus of my atoms act as a kind of "force field" that repels other electrons in other atoms allowing me to stand on the surface of the earth and interact with things. Is the outer shell of an atom a "thin sheet"? Pretty darn thin I would say. Seems like a natural force field already exists.
Gr8 topic...simply explained..superb video effects... And an awesome tshirt ...
U earned another subscriber now!! Gr8 going :)
Loved this! Such a fantastic explanation for layman like me. I run a tabletop superhero RPG game and Force Field is the most controversial power that a character can have. We're always having armchair-science debates about it. I'll be sure to share this with my group. Oh, and liked and subbed.
Love this channel. May the force be with you :)
which one? :O
That is a question for George Lucas :)
Good breakdown on this subject. Thank you.
also is that a 12 tone shirt? Love it!
Yes! He's a friend of mine :)
cool i watch that too
@@donaldcarothers832 I watch 12tone VERY often!!!!
Loved the video but the T-Shirt drew me down here...
12 tone’s channel is super cool I immediately noticed the shirt how neat I haven’t checked out his merch yet but I love it. I’m a biochem student and I love to nerd out about music theory and play bass as a hobby. I always think those two hobbies as very distinct but doing both of them keeps me sane and curious and I couldn’t imagine my life without the arts and science. I wish I knew the story behind his doodles I don’t know why he draws them that way. Does anyone else know?
Just found this video, the production of the video is really good. Great job 👍
I remember a scifi story from either Clarke or Asimov where they created a starship out of the strong and weak nuclear forces from a solid steel hull, but having removed the atoms and left behind the forces. Somehow.
@@ronruszczyk7935 Thank you! I knew I wasn't imagining it...
Your perpetual enthusiasm is charming... and that accent just makes listening that much easier. You make head-hurting science fun.
Kiwi
You are awesome 🥰 That answered almost all of my questions .
🎉 Thank you 😌
Excellent video. Intelligent, interesting and great delivery.
Michio Kaku is one of my absolute favorite scientists. Just discovered your channel.......Awesome. (corrected)
:)))
As opposed to one of your relative scientists?
@Toby Henderson yeah, not really a 'scientist' tho, is he... :p
Right. Have you read any of his books
He is hardly a scientist now. He has done nothing with anything science in very long time. His faculty page is basically empty for anything he has done in research
It's funny how usually people rely on animated characters who are cuter than their real person counterpart... But with Up and Atom, it's just the opposite 😂 Good video, thanks for sharing!
I know right. She is so beautiful
🤮
This is the first video of yours that I understood.. lol.. you are such a beauty with brains... great work
I just discovered this channel and I'm binge watching every video. You're amazing. ❤️
That was very interesting to watch.
If I were to guess, among all the impossible things we can see in sci fi, force field doesn't strikes me as the most difficult to make.
So, I would say they will probably be a thing in a distant future (or something similar would probably be).
There's quiet a few things that I can't buy as being possible (at least within the realm of what we have and know in this world), like a human being going through solid materials or teleportation but Force field doesn't seem too bad.
Awesome video! I wonder how the world would change of we had forcefields. They would be great at preventing disasters or just keeping the rain off :D
omg the world would change in so many ways cogito. I wanted to talk about it more in the video but I couldn't think of how to do it without diverging too far from the point. We could live in giant underwater domes because force fields could separate water and air. We could control the weather on land if we lived in giant domes. Entire building, structures and cities could be made out of force field and built much more quickly and cheaply than the way they are built now. They could completely replace concrete, brick and mortar. It would be REVOLUTIONARY!!!
@@upandatomsorry to butt in. Electromagnetic force fields could work against any object so long as you can fit a few conditions. Ionizing any incoming object then using a high grade repulsion field. Or coat any incoming object in iron and use the repulsion field to manipulate the object. Depending on output field strength you could stop any incoming projectile. Aside from turning energy into a solid object i dont think theres any conventional way to make a sci fi force field as far as your materials are concerned.
Plasma wouldnt work. Any object that emits a magnetic field could punch right threw, even temporarily. Bypassing it wouldnt be overwhelmingly hard... Most of these solutions are ridiculously high in energy requirements and bypassing them would be fairly easy.
A missile fitted with a high power magnetic penetrator tip could slip threw any plasma field. A chromatic finish would render your laser screen... Well pointless. And an armor layer could be bypassed either fast or slow.
Any laser could be countered rather easily with a water atomizer sprinkler, and chromatic finishes. Hell even a fog machine would help.
A really high powered laser, one capable of being used as a weapon, isn't going to be neutralised by atomised water. The water would be instantly boiled away. Chromatic surfaces have the same problem... whilst it might take slightly longer, you can melt any material if you can generate enough focused heat. A missile with a magnetic tip can be deflected by other magnets.
I just found your videos and there amazing! super informative
I read a paper years ago that documented an electrostatic force field. It was inadvertently created by the manufacturing of thin plastic film. The field was generated by the static charge created by the continuous transport of the thin film across a gap between the machines. Workers reported that a bird flying though the gap bounced off an invisible barrier. When studied it was found the effect depended on very narrow set of atmospheric conditions. I wish I could find the paper but it's been over 10 years since I read it.
Gravity's disappointed expression just made my day.
I probably shouldn't mention that the 'Physics of the impossible' audiobook is on youtube... :p
I loved the animations. They are good because it can help you to retain the information you have learned.
Your channel is great! Thank you for sharing these interesting topics with us.
Also, i'ts really nice to see you wearing a 12tone logo. :D
I'm really glad you enjoy them! And yes Corey from 12tone is a friend of mine and I loved the cute elephant drawing :)
I saw Violet
Yea right
You may have seen violet, by my cow mooed indigo.
Interesting! How about interference of electromagnetic waves? Or gravimetric waves, if that is possible. We can now use acoustic wave interference to lift small objects and stuff. This could be the basis of a tractor/repulsor type beam in my imagination. Which might lead to shaped forcefields?? It just seems a shame if we couldn´t do it. Excellent video, by the way!
Great video! Your channel is awesome.
Right lol
Interesting topic and the production is bloody brilliant! You go gal :)
wow this is the first time you've ever commented on one of my videos... I must have done something right!
Jade!
Same with Tractor Beams, Yes?
love
Steve Holliday
but electromagnetic force field already exists. the earth has one. it deflects the majority of sun's radiation.
Magnetic fields require too much power, and modern weapons are electrically neutral
Magnetosphere?
Discoloured Buttflaps It exists, but not the same type of force field as those of science fiction.
As described, it doesn't work as a planar structure
We need to deflect solid objects. She said something about the military using it.(pretty sure the military would not need to deflect uv rays anytime soon.
This is honestly one of the most well-communicated videos on this topic. :)
Awesome video, I am learning a lot.
What if you use the Earth's atmosphere as an example, like how meteors can disintegrate when they enter the Earth's atmosphere. make the regular air outside seem like space by changing the air inside the "Force Field" but not so much so that it's impossible to be inside. Then use plasma to hold the air inside. This way it'll be like Non-Newtonian Fluids (Oobleck) but instead of hardening when hit, this disintegrate when they enter the "Force Field" at high speeds. This means that you can walk in the "Force Field", but bullets won't be able to get through.
Great animations! they are very effective. It is an interesting topic, I wonder what would happen if two force fields collided... I guess they would deflect, so maybe the force field itself is not about stopping objects but rather changing their direction? In that sense maybe gravity points away from the person or object could act as a force field? When I say gravity points I obviously talk from a SciFi point of view, not sure if they would be even possible. Great video, thanks
maybe it would be like in dragon ball z with the kamayamaya waves?
Fantastic video!! ☺️☺️
Very good use of graphics, video presentation to explain such complex subjects
Your representation of carbon nanotubes looked alot more like graphene sheets! (I don't blame you, they share alot in common)
Also, I believe those nanomaterials are a bit overrated in term of projected properties, but it doesn't hurt to dream! :p
Haha yeah when I was reading I didn't really understand how a carbon nanotube can only be 1 atom thick if it loops back around on itself?
How long ago was that design put forward? If it was before 2004 then maybe they said carbon nanotubes because graphene hadn't been isolated yet.
wouldn't the tube surface be just one atom thick, but the material is made from those tubes? i think the material itself isn't 1 atom thick.
I'm guessing graphene wasn't yet a "household name" back in 2017
*a lot
Predictions are hard, especially when they're about the future.
Yeah, like if.... i can predict the past.
Not entirely.
We can look at patterns in models and structures 😁
I predict the day after Sunday will be Monday so not all predictions are hard. Now if all English speakers change it to something else I will be wrong.
Wonderful and simple explanation.....really loved it
Lovely channel and lovely 12tone t-shirt! Subbed!
Could we manipulate the higs field making what ever enters will just pass through you?
Wait a minute...
IS THAT A 12 TONE SHIRT!?
Dear Class, the Defense Shield technology & design(s) at mark :11 & :12 seconds is astonishing! It deals with something in/re our School Project(s) - B.P.D.S.G. technology & Application(s) we are dealing with....configuration. So far our primary model is a perfect sphere, but we are also working on partial shields too, and the illustrations and footage shown here is wonderful. The engineering & thought behind it is sound, lol, peoples with a good attitude to come up with something that funny and good.
Thank you for this awesome video!
You remind me of my science teacher from hs. I loved her personality, it made science interesting some how. Keep up the good work!!
If interstellar gas is plasma. Then why is is called interstellar gas? Shouldn't it be called interstellar plasma?
For the same reason reduction reactions in chemistry give electrons
Interstellar gas is made up of ionic, atomic and molecular gas as well as larger particles of dust. Interstellar plasma would be the ionic type. A caveat to this is if the non ionic gas is heated high enough or moving fast enough it can also be considered a plasma. (99.9 percent of the sun's mass is considered in the plasma state. That means about 0.1 percent is not a plasma)
Great video, as you started i tought about plasma being a candidat as i remambered the different tokomak fusion reactors. They alredy work in a similar way.
Informative and at the same time cute video. A rare combination in our known universe. I foresee a bright future for you
I like how you explain how and why it does or doesn’t work and why. I always like to know how things work and why. It helps me trust the effectiveness of a strategy or way of doing things working because I don’t just say oh it works but I really understand how and why they work. Thanks for making this video!!
We’ve been making force fields for thousands of years. They’re called walls.
L.A.M.E
Elliot Alderson Keep studying physics, you’ll understand why it’s literally true.
@@donwald3436 I was also wondering why she didn't discuss the electromagnetic force at the quantum scale.
It may be possible when technology grows like the aliens from Independence Day.
@SonofEyeaboveall Effoff Sadly, I haven’t. It was just a mere coincidence. I only saw the first and second movie.
I really love your videos
Excellent thumbnail. Good video. I’d never heard of plasma windows before. Thanks.
totally subbing
thank you and welcome!
An old article I read talked about it, a tape factory (accidentally)invented an electrostatic forcefield.
Shooting off high amounts of static force as the rollers moved, pushing things away from them.
So... Yes, I believe forcefields can and have existed.
Yep I read that same story. It was in I think North or South Carolina at a Scotch tape factory. Morning moisture in the air also had something to do with it as well as X-Rays being emitted at the point where the raw tape material was being pulled off the roll headed to the cutters.
In the words of Howard Stark _"I am limited by the technology of my time"_
You are the greatest!!! Able to devulge and explain the most abstruse of physics to us poor mortals. I love it!!
I want anti-gravity first. Back to the Future II promised me anti-gravity cars and they are nearly 4 years late.
ITS YOUR KIDS MARTY. SOMETHING'S GOTTA BE DONE ABOUT YOUR KIDS
*IT'S (not possessive)
EVERYONE, ITS STRICKLAND! RUN!
It aint hard to make magnetic roads that repel magnets in cars. just pop on some engine and you are good to go
Also why didn't Marty just go "thanks for the advice, doc, when I have my kids I'll remember to raise them better". Why did they have to go to the future?
Back to the future 2 is just a movie and not a prediction of the future, just a guess as to what could happen. people have made hover device but is much larger than hover board used in movie.
I’m reminded that some of the first tries at AI made scholars realize they didn’t know quite what intelligence was. When someone achieves a force field, they might find it functionally equivalent to a windowpane.
Indeed, I gather a windowpane is quite literally a force field. The bits of mass it is built around are a tiny fraction of its volume, and it can be made both transparent and practically impenetrable.
It seems to me the true goal is to conjure windowpanes from nothing and dismiss them at will. Maybe that outlook will spark an idea.
This was great and informative
Right
Your thumbnail for this video is epic! Perfect!
What about the greatest force of all?
love
Cringe.
Oh nooo! So many have been burnt that way. You could say you'd need a force field against love.
Can it stop a time fused nuke?
@@colonelstriker2519 it can stop someone from launching one.
That’s not a force. That’s just lust in disguise. More of a diluted emotion than a force.
Jade is an example of someone who probably could have also been a successful actor, but instead went into science. That's a pretty rare combination.
When you can comprehend why an electron does not just fall into the nucleus, then you can possibly construct a force field. But you have to start at the foundation of the Universe to figure this out.
I don't know why - but I really loved that short Dune clip...
It's amazing but electromagnetic fields would also be a huge weakness to the field. It would be insane to blow up a ship through its defensive systems with just the right electromagnetic field
That's why I like how in star trek the forcefields are useless if the enemy has some number. You can imagine they have a technology that almost encrypts the magnetic field so that you can't just disrupt the contained energy with your own field? And yet in sciFi they don't have to explain all that detail to us, just take artistic license and all...
I wish you were my teacher 😥
reflective (preferably in all wavelength) surfaces can't stop laser either, but are totally able to make them someone elses problem.
Really polished video! Noice!
Thanks Ben :)
Earth has force feild its called atmosphere but everybody knows that but the planet are not in the talking list 😐😐😐😞😞😞
(Edit)also thanks for sharing of your smartness 😊😊😊
Wtf you both
@MrZyliaThe earth's atmosphere protects us from most meteors, debris and the coldness from outer space.
@MrZylia Mhm, personally, it reminds me of a natural version of the forcefield from passengers.
if only humans can make something like an atmosphere, forcefield may be come true
There is no need to construct a forcefield against laser beams.
Just polish your spaceship to a mirror smooth reflecting finish and you're set.
Scientists and highly technical folks will tell you this is not possible until one fine day it arrives with a bang like the iPhone
I love you and your videos
Well isn't plasma part of the electromagnetic force?
I thought so
We have force fields everywhere.
A shield or armor is a force field, it uses the electrostatic force field
Hey scientists please just make me a lightsaber I'll be content with that
Hi jade, that was really useful. I'm in love with your voice, Thanks.
to cute to pay attention lol
Jade, you're adorable, I want to give you a hug😊
1:10 to 1:13 is my life in a nutshell.
Great video btw
Thanks for the info
Wow in your Thumbnail u look ravishing😍😃
good show i subscribed
create a magnetic field on the outside of the ship and fill it with
1 Eletrostialy charged Sand, dust
2 Cold plasma
this provide the effect of a classic force field and would work at stopping lasers and particle beams possibly even missiles and railgun rounds maybe.
I find your hotness doesn’t at all hinder my learning. Cool. I’m finally growing up.