These videos are so epic, I am so grateful, even with you with so little who view you, you put great effort in these videos, having valuable information and spending any resources, like time or money, to have this quality. thankyou so much
I pray that Allah swt revives true\original protects and preserves it and make its massage be witnessed by all people but at the right moment place, time best regards from a Muslim [ line of ismail ]
Where can I read a copy of the exact excommunication document that was propounded upon the Greek church. And also the responding excommunication document that was per pound it up on the Roman church? I’d like to read the original document. I was in English of course!
Believe that Jesus Christ is Lord, and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, and you will be saved..Be baptized and repent of your sins. Repent simply means to turn away from your sins. God loves you and so do I.
There's only one problem with this....even the Devil believes and knows Jesus Christ is Lord, knows the Holy Bible by heart...doest get you anywhere....that's why Our Lord established his Church on St Peter, the Church exists till date, and all the Apostles have brought theirs fruits of labour as well....Sorry none of this new age....man made with a manufacturing date from the Protestant movement or later
@@fannyissac7398 the devil does know... That is why people need to repent after they know Jesus is LORD... repentance is knowing one is in the wrong and choosing to do the will of God... choosing to do the right thing...and that is something that differentiates true believers and the Devil.
@@TeachMeLordGod I wouldn't say you aren't saved but only that you're not growing efficiently in Christ... Our environment does affect our walk with Christ... One could either leave that church and find a Holy Spirit filled one or remain in that church and be the praying catalyst that Bring Biblical correctness to that Church....but these are only my words..they should absolutely truly seek God to instruct them on what to do....God bless
@@fannyissac7398I think u were referencing James 2:19, which was talking about how demons know that Jesus is the son of God. This is not groundbreaking, they even called Jesus the son of God in the gospels. There is a difference between knowing Jesus is the God in the flesh, and that God raised him from the dead(or believing that that happened) and actually believing that those events are able to save you from hell. That is the destruction between those 2 verses, Roman’s is referencing salvation if you believe, but James is just referencing simply believing that something happened(this is consistent with the rest of the chapter of James 2: faith and works is the theme)
Il trying to find out which church to join(I was raised a catholic but was born again about a year ago) I’m trying to find the right church-either stick with Catholicism, switch to orthodox, or join a non-denominational church-this video was very educational and well done but the more I learn about church history the more I get confused about which church to join. Any suggestions?✝️
I'm struggling with the same thing, though I was raised Pentacostal. I'd probably be a Catholic but I just don't think I can ever accept Immaculate Conception, and I know the Orthodox Church doesn't believe that. But at the same time I recognize the importance of apostolic succession and I also feel a sense of peace when I think about becoming a Catholic that I don't entirely feel when I think about becoming an Orthodox. I also struggle with the fact that I feel deeply called to some form of ministry but I know Catholic priests cannot marry(excepting some exceptions in the Eastern Catholic Church) whereas Orthodox priests can. And I know I need to be married in order to stay away from sin.
For what it's worth, I'd say try out a Protestant church that preaches the Bible and treats the Bible as the final authority. I love my Catholic and Orthodox brothers but they can be so wrapped up in traditions and dogma that they lose focus on Jesus Christ. This schism seems to be focused on how important The Pope actually was when his importance shouldn't even be in the same stratosphere as Jesus Christ. See what real Bible believing Protestants are talking about when they say Sola Scriptura and Sola Fida (I know a lot of denominations are trash) and make a decision, but don't forget it's ALL about Jesus Christ and what he did for us. Acts 2:38 Ephesians 2:8-9 2 Timothy 3:16-17
@@euthyphro8935 But Jesus says that the Apostles had the authority of Heaven. First individually to Peter when he confesses Jesus as The Christ in Matthew 16 and then to the rest of the 70 in Matthew 18. And they all said to trust the bishops. Paul, one of the Apostles though not the 70, even appeals to his authority as an apostle in one of his letters. And Ignatius(a disciple of Polycarp who was a disciple of John the Apostle) said to trust the bishops as where they are so is Christ. And, if the Apostles passed on their authority all the way down to present day, then the bishops of the Catholic Church, Orthodox and Roman, would then also have that same authority: the authority of Heaven. So to deny them, unless properly excommunicated, would be to deny the Apostles and so deny Christ as well. And Sola Fide is unbiblical. Jesus says what we must do to inherit eternal life. He says to keep the commands. And He even lists several sins that if you commit, without repentance, you would go to Hell. And, again, if the Apostles have the keys to the Kingdom, as Jesus said they do, then if they or their successors say something forfeits eternal life, then they have forfeited eternal life. Likewise with Sola Scriptura, if the Apostles grant authority to their successors, then the successors' words must also be taken as scripture. I agree many have lost sight of Christ but that does not make their commands or decrees necessarily without authority, unless that authority has been taken away like in the case of excommunication or abrogation by a future successor. As Jesus said about the Jews, do what they say but do not do their works.
@@IsaiahINRI we agree more than you think. The Apostles absolutely had authority to dictate and teach scripture which they did. The Bible even says in Thessalonians 2:15 to respect the Tradition given by word or epistle... from the apostles, who have all died. Where we're going to run into an issue is apostolic succession, which I've never been convinced of. The church doesn't have more authority than scripture, The Bible says in both deuteronomy 4:2 and Revelation 22:18-19 not to add or take away from his word. Finally I've given chapter and verse for why I believe as I do. Should we believe councils and dogma carry more weight than scripture? Do our works that are filthy rags (Isaiah 64:6) compare at all to Jesus's sacrifice?
@@euthyphro8935 Jesus gave them this authority, though. Jesus humbled Himself to agree with whatever they declare.If they then declare that apostolic succession is the way, then Jesus agrees. There is even a scriptural basis for these things, so it isn't solely rested upon Ignatius
This article ignores the fact that the church was divided long before the so-called "Great Schism." There was the division between Trinitarians and Unitarians. And the division between Chalcedonian and non-Chalcedonian churches in the East.
i think it's irrelevant in regards to the topic. the great schism describes eastern orthodox and catholics no longer being in union. arianism, nestorianism, and unitarianism are all other conflicts which occur at different times throughout the centuries. nestorianism and arianism were both discussed at ecumenical councils if you're interested.
I hate being stuck between denominations. It just leads me into a path of more fear and confusion. I go to a church that calls themselves non-denominational but they come off as Baptist/southern Baptist to my husband and I. Not that I see anything wrong with Baptists, it is just the one who runs the church (my FIL) says he has this church set up because of the others being hypocrites. He is friendly to all but I feel like I'm being misguided a bit and some of the theology doesn't make sense. I try to listen/watch videos online and read Wikipedia for history of the church to try to understand which church had it wrong and where it all went wrong. Some claim that Jesus left a church, not a Bible but the Bible was also written by His apostles and/or disciples so it is very weird to think that the Bible holds little authority even it is said to be God-breathed and His word. I too want us to get along but there are things that confuse me so much. I am partially glad/blessed that I am even concerned with this because it shows that I am indeed working my salvation with both fear and trembling. Part of me also thinks that a lot of this is a huge misunderstanding. Like the Holy spirit either coming from the Father or from the Father and Christ. I wish that was the only issue I have to deal with with the other denominations around me. I can definitely simp for the catholics a bit when they say that us protestants can't even fully agree on things. I've been told by my church that if we all believe in Christ and His sacerfice for mankind and that we love God with our everything and love others as ourselves, we are good but unfortunately I have come to understand that things are way more nuanced than that.
I'm catholic, I pray that one day we can be united once more! However, both sides have a lot of problems that need fixing before the miracle of unity can be realized. Please pray for us, as we will pray for y'all :') God love you!
The gospel of St. John states it begins with logos and Logos was with God. Logos is God. This is the Trinity. The Trinity is God revealing himself to us. Pythagorus prepared us for the Trinity. He believed number was the order of the universe. ( 1+2=3) 1 is unity. 2 is diversity. 3 is the Trinity (unity and diversity at the same time) Another characteristic of God is beauty. “The true, the good, the beautiful” Because of 20th century, beauty gets lost as a result of the decline of art. Beauty is a manifestation of God. There is evidence of this Trinity throughout creation.
It makes me wonder about why this happened. God caused the language confusion at Babel to prevent them from building it. Did God cause this same type of confusion in the Great Schism, or did He simply allow it to happen? Or did Satan cause it? 🤔
@@TheologyAcademy One question in this video you make it sound like that there was never a time when the church was in complete unity because you make it sound like that there is no hope for the christian faith and saying that as a muslim
@bubbag8895 I went to Catholoc school. This is fake news. They absolutely teach world history. And the early Pope's were doing a good job keeping Islamic terrorists at bay. Shame we lost that strength.
The more I learn about the Catholics, the most I become aware that they are a source of so many conflicts and controversies in the global Christianity. They have a mottled history and even today, I have rarely met ordinary lay Catholics who are are properly discipled and strengthened by their being part of the Catholic church.
Well then you’re misinformed. Catholics are the only true Christians and have done their best to put down heresy and spread the gospel to the world. The Catholic Church is the reason just about everyone in earth can claim to be a Christian even if they call themselves some other form of Christianity. But without the universal church there would be no Christianity. What this video doesn’t say is the sack of Constantinople wasnt until the 4th crusade. There were 3 crusades that were sent to help the Byzantines deal with Muslims by the Pope after the schism. And the Byzantines were quite treacherous. Read about how they left Byzantines during the siege of Antioch during the first crusade. Yes the fourth crusade went horribly off script as Constantinople was not the original target. However to cry for the Byzantines who conquered and pillaged so many peoples when they get conquered is pretty rich. They were at an all-time low point with horribly incompetent or outright malevolent emperors when the fourth crusade arrived. The only reason you would say the Catholic Church is a cause of controversy is because you want to believe some form of heresy which is a mortal sin and evil.
Strange conclusion you came to. While the behaviour of the crusaders was inexcusable the division that happened was mostly political and not theological. The entire church was under the popes rule and everyone recognised it, unfortunately secular ruler of Constantinople decided to replace a bishop with another because he refused to give communion to someone who openly had incest, Rome wanted to restore the proper bishop but they rebelled and were a significant factor in the schism. Read about Photius and Coerularius, the schism was mostly personal and political not actually theological.
Well I have never met a normal Protestant, lol. The reason why the world runs with no problem is because of the influence of the church. 2. Church acted as a governing body. Saying catholic Church is evil just shows you are ignorant
Remember, the Filioque was never mentioned in the Gospels. Rather, the Gospel alludes to the Holy Spirit proceeding from the Father and being sent from the Son. The terms were often used interchangeably in certain regions in defence of the Son's divinity, which gave rise to the schism afterwards.
There isn't a Biblical one. I've read that Toledo bishops were actually trying to deal with 1. Muslim influence and 2. Belief that Holy Spirit is not actually God. (An old, old heresy that is still around, Oneness Pentecostal or JW.)
@@TheologyAcademy where do the Gospels allude to it? At Jesus' baptism the Spirit descended like a Dove upon the Son. So here the Fillioque theory makes no sense.
Excellent summary of the Great Schism and its underlying roots. I understand your toning down your descriptions of the Crusades as being "misbehavior" but it was dramatically more than that. When the Muslims took over Constantinople they didn't kill many people. When the "Christian" Crusaders came they left no one alive. It was a massacre -- mass murder, plundering, raping, you name it they did it. But overall, this video is a very thorough overview of the history that provides a lot of detail other descriptions of the Schism don't go into. Thanks, you have a new subscriber with alerts!
@@corym8358 to the contrary, it's putting words in peoples' mouths that they didn't say that *is* bad behavior. It's definitely worth clearing that up 😉 because I said no such thing. Peace.
Even if it is, which I agree bloodshed even in the name of Christ is a sin, it isn't really the point of this video. So it would just be a derailment of the subject which could easily get people lost trying to keep up.
I have to make a correvtion to author sentences about crusades behaviour. Hard behaviour of crusades was only a response of the previous massacre of latin people perpetrated by bizantine people. In costantinople there was a latin quarter filked with venetian and genoese people, catholic, that were killed in hundreds, even the catholic bishop was slaughtered. Crusaders vindicated this massacre. This part of the story is aleays neglected by orthodox folk. The first stone was launched by them
I submit that the west actually "split off" as there were 5 ancient patriarchates; Rome went their own way, the other 4 are still in communion, (along with a bunch of newer ones).
@@sdnlawrence5640 Just like biblical and historical evidence proves that jesus pbuh and his apostles were vegatarians biblical and historical evidence also proves that the trinity, atonement, original sin and hell are very late misinterpretations and are not supported by the early creed hence its not a part of Christianity I pray that Allah swt revives Christianity both inside and out preserves and protects it and makes its massage be witnessed by all people but at the right moment, place and time The secret text of the Bible says ye shall know them by their fruits So too that I say to my christian brothers and sisters be fruitful and multiply Best regards from a Muslim [ line of ismail ]
Baptizing a baby while using sprinkling is very funny for they can’t repent yet. Acts 2:38 And Peter said to them, “Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.”
Dear @TheEmsrea. The instruction to sprinkle was given in the Didache when there was no flowing water around. It is an exception but no the standard. It would be great if you could support our channel to keep us producing videos and legit content! Unfortunately, we are reaching a point where we cannot sustain the costs of producing these videos. Can you make a $5, $10, $20, $50, or $100 donation now or every month to keep this channel going? You can make a direct donation @ fundly.com/let-there-be-light-4 or a tax-deductible donation @ www.theology-academy.org/ (Under “SUPPORT US”). You can also become a patron @ www.patreon.com/user?u=28861271.
These videos are so epic, I am so grateful, even with you with so little who view you, you put great effort in these videos, having valuable information and spending any resources, like time or money, to have this quality. thankyou so much
You should do a video about the crusades, this was a fantastic video, nice research my dude!
This schism, would have to upset God so much. A separation of the Church that shouldn't have happened, once again Man has failed God.
Well, failing God is kind of what we do best at this point.
This video is incredibly well produced. Congrats 😊
I honestly think this video is the only source that finally explained to me the difference between orthodox and catholic:)) great video
Thank you for making a rather messy subject clear :)
Very balanced!
I pray that Allah swt revives true\original protects and preserves it and make its massage be witnessed by all people but at the right moment place, time
best regards from a Muslim [ line of ismail ]
Excellent use of graphics with the narration
Where can I read a copy of the exact excommunication document that was propounded upon the Greek church. And also the responding excommunication document that was per pound it up on the Roman church? I’d like to read the original document. I was in English of course!
Please check out our scripts with full references and citations on theology-academy.org
Definitely interesting. Gonna have rewatch this again.
Believe that Jesus Christ is Lord, and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, and you will be saved..Be baptized and repent of your sins. Repent simply means to turn away from your sins. God loves you and so do I.
But if we go to the wrong church, we aren't saved according to some. :(
There's only one problem with this....even the Devil believes and knows Jesus Christ is Lord, knows the Holy Bible by heart...doest get you anywhere....that's why Our Lord established his Church on St Peter, the Church exists till date, and all the Apostles have brought theirs fruits of labour as well....Sorry none of this new age....man made with a manufacturing date from the Protestant movement or later
@@fannyissac7398 the devil does know... That is why people need to repent after they know Jesus is LORD... repentance is knowing one is in the wrong and choosing to do the will of God... choosing to do the right thing...and that is something that differentiates true believers and the Devil.
@@TeachMeLordGod I wouldn't say you aren't saved but only that you're not growing efficiently in Christ... Our environment does affect our walk with Christ... One could either leave that church and find a Holy Spirit filled one or remain in that church and be the praying catalyst that Bring Biblical correctness to that Church....but these are only my words..they should absolutely truly seek God to instruct them on what to do....God bless
@@fannyissac7398I think u were referencing James 2:19, which was talking about how demons know that Jesus is the son of God. This is not groundbreaking, they even called Jesus the son of God in the gospels. There is a difference between knowing Jesus is the God in the flesh, and that God raised him from the dead(or believing that that happened) and actually believing that those events are able to save you from hell. That is the destruction between those 2 verses, Roman’s is referencing salvation if you believe, but James is just referencing simply believing that something happened(this is consistent with the rest of the chapter of James 2: faith and works is the theme)
Il trying to find out which church to join(I was raised a catholic but was born again about a year ago) I’m trying to find the right church-either stick with Catholicism, switch to orthodox, or join a non-denominational church-this video was very educational and well done but the more I learn about church history the more I get confused about which church to join. Any suggestions?✝️
I'm struggling with the same thing, though I was raised Pentacostal. I'd probably be a Catholic but I just don't think I can ever accept Immaculate Conception, and I know the Orthodox Church doesn't believe that. But at the same time I recognize the importance of apostolic succession and I also feel a sense of peace when I think about becoming a Catholic that I don't entirely feel when I think about becoming an Orthodox. I also struggle with the fact that I feel deeply called to some form of ministry but I know Catholic priests cannot marry(excepting some exceptions in the Eastern Catholic Church) whereas Orthodox priests can. And I know I need to be married in order to stay away from sin.
For what it's worth, I'd say try out a Protestant church that preaches the Bible and treats the Bible as the final authority. I love my Catholic and Orthodox brothers but they can be so wrapped up in traditions and dogma that they lose focus on Jesus Christ. This schism seems to be focused on how important The Pope actually was when his importance shouldn't even be in the same stratosphere as Jesus Christ. See what real Bible believing Protestants are talking about when they say Sola Scriptura and Sola Fida (I know a lot of denominations are trash) and make a decision, but don't forget it's ALL about Jesus Christ and what he did for us.
Acts 2:38
Ephesians 2:8-9
2 Timothy 3:16-17
@@euthyphro8935 But Jesus says that the Apostles had the authority of Heaven. First individually to Peter when he confesses Jesus as The Christ in Matthew 16 and then to the rest of the 70 in Matthew 18. And they all said to trust the bishops. Paul, one of the Apostles though not the 70, even appeals to his authority as an apostle in one of his letters. And Ignatius(a disciple of Polycarp who was a disciple of John the Apostle) said to trust the bishops as where they are so is Christ. And, if the Apostles passed on their authority all the way down to present day, then the bishops of the Catholic Church, Orthodox and Roman, would then also have that same authority: the authority of Heaven. So to deny them, unless properly excommunicated, would be to deny the Apostles and so deny Christ as well.
And Sola Fide is unbiblical. Jesus says what we must do to inherit eternal life. He says to keep the commands. And He even lists several sins that if you commit, without repentance, you would go to Hell. And, again, if the Apostles have the keys to the Kingdom, as Jesus said they do, then if they or their successors say something forfeits eternal life, then they have forfeited eternal life.
Likewise with Sola Scriptura, if the Apostles grant authority to their successors, then the successors' words must also be taken as scripture. I agree many have lost sight of Christ but that does not make their commands or decrees necessarily without authority, unless that authority has been taken away like in the case of excommunication or abrogation by a future successor. As Jesus said about the Jews, do what they say but do not do their works.
@@IsaiahINRI we agree more than you think. The Apostles absolutely had authority to dictate and teach scripture which they did. The Bible even says in Thessalonians 2:15 to respect the Tradition given by word or epistle... from the apostles, who have all died. Where we're going to run into an issue is apostolic succession, which I've never been convinced of. The church doesn't have more authority than scripture, The Bible says in both deuteronomy 4:2 and Revelation 22:18-19 not to add or take away from his word.
Finally I've given chapter and verse for why I believe as I do. Should we believe councils and dogma carry more weight than scripture? Do our works that are filthy rags (Isaiah 64:6) compare at all to Jesus's sacrifice?
@@euthyphro8935 Jesus gave them this authority, though. Jesus humbled Himself to agree with whatever they declare.If they then declare that apostolic succession is the way, then Jesus agrees. There is even a scriptural basis for these things, so it isn't solely rested upon Ignatius
This article ignores the fact that the church was divided long before the so-called "Great Schism." There was the division between Trinitarians and Unitarians. And the division between Chalcedonian and non-Chalcedonian churches in the East.
i think it's irrelevant in regards to the topic. the great schism describes eastern orthodox and catholics no longer being in union. arianism, nestorianism, and unitarianism are all other conflicts which occur at different times throughout the centuries. nestorianism and arianism were both discussed at ecumenical councils if you're interested.
I believe the correct words run like, 'Love one another.'
I’m orthodox but we need to come together and unite as one! I’m okay to adopt some of the disagreements we have with Catholicism
I hate being stuck between denominations. It just leads me into a path of more fear and confusion. I go to a church that calls themselves non-denominational but they come off as Baptist/southern Baptist to my husband and I. Not that I see anything wrong with Baptists, it is just the one who runs the church (my FIL) says he has this church set up because of the others being hypocrites. He is friendly to all but I feel like I'm being misguided a bit and some of the theology doesn't make sense. I try to listen/watch videos online and read Wikipedia for history of the church to try to understand which church had it wrong and where it all went wrong. Some claim that Jesus left a church, not a Bible but the Bible was also written by His apostles and/or disciples so it is very weird to think that the Bible holds little authority even it is said to be God-breathed and His word. I too want us to get along but there are things that confuse me so much. I am partially glad/blessed that I am even concerned with this because it shows that I am indeed working my salvation with both fear and trembling. Part of me also thinks that a lot of this is a huge misunderstanding. Like the Holy spirit either coming from the Father or from the Father and Christ. I wish that was the only issue I have to deal with with the other denominations around me. I can definitely simp for the catholics a bit when they say that us protestants can't even fully agree on things. I've been told by my church that if we all believe in Christ and His sacerfice for mankind and that we love God with our everything and love others as ourselves, we are good but unfortunately I have come to understand that things are way more nuanced than that.
I'm catholic, I pray that one day we can be united once more! However, both sides have a lot of problems that need fixing before the miracle of unity can be realized. Please pray for us, as we will pray for y'all :') God love you!
Unification is coming. See Our Lady of Fatima
What unity does truth have with falsehood?
The gospel of St. John states it begins with logos and Logos was with God. Logos is God. This is the Trinity. The Trinity is God revealing himself to us. Pythagorus prepared us for the Trinity. He believed number was the order of the universe. ( 1+2=3) 1 is unity. 2 is diversity. 3 is the Trinity (unity and diversity at the same time) Another characteristic of God is beauty. “The true, the good, the beautiful” Because of 20th century, beauty gets lost as a result of the decline of art. Beauty is a manifestation of God. There is evidence of this Trinity throughout creation.
please make video history chapter and verse
We will have videos specifically on biblical exegesis at some point.
Reminds me a bit of the OT story of the confusing of languages at the Tower of Babel.
Indeed. Unfortunate events in the church!!
It makes me wonder about why this happened. God caused the language confusion at Babel to prevent them from building it. Did God cause this same type of confusion in the Great Schism, or did He simply allow it to happen? Or did Satan cause it? 🤔
@@PockASqueeno the ego of men is the only barrier between heaven and earth
@@TheologyAcademy One question in this video you make it sound like that there was never a time when the church was in complete unity because you make it sound like that there is no hope for the christian faith
and saying that as a muslim
Wow great job
Thank you 🙏
I think if i had access to an Orthodox church, id consider switching from the Roman Catholic church.
I'm 31 and grew up catholic. I'm just now teaching myself of other religions. I have no faith. But I love the history of religion.
Turn back to Christ. He can save you from hell and offers you the gift of Salvation. Amen
Pope made himself king of the world and most Catholic schools never teach study of the Word itself
@bubbag8895 I went to Catholoc school. This is fake news. They absolutely teach world history. And the early Pope's were doing a good job keeping Islamic terrorists at bay. Shame we lost that strength.
4:19 and 5:21 and 6:29
Upsetting
Catholicism must recognize teachings of Eastern Orthodoxy.
One Christ and one body (Church) of Christ.
WHO ELSE IS HERE BECAUSE THEIR TEACHER MADE THEM???
also: 2:50 "Pepin the *Short* "
😭💀☠
The more I learn about the Catholics, the most I become aware that they are a source of so many conflicts and controversies in the global Christianity. They have a mottled history and even today, I have rarely met ordinary lay Catholics who are are properly discipled and strengthened by their being part of the Catholic church.
Well then you’re misinformed. Catholics are the only true Christians and have done their best to put down heresy and spread the gospel to the world. The Catholic Church is the reason just about everyone in earth can claim to be a Christian even if they call themselves some other form of Christianity. But without the universal church there would be no Christianity. What this video doesn’t say is the sack of Constantinople wasnt until the 4th crusade. There were 3 crusades that were sent to help the Byzantines deal with Muslims by the Pope after the schism. And the Byzantines were quite treacherous. Read about how they left Byzantines during the siege of Antioch during the first crusade. Yes the fourth crusade went horribly off script as Constantinople was not the original target. However to cry for the Byzantines who conquered and pillaged so many peoples when they get conquered is pretty rich. They were at an all-time low point with horribly incompetent or outright malevolent emperors when the fourth crusade arrived. The only reason you would say the Catholic Church is a cause of controversy is because you want to believe some form of heresy which is a mortal sin and evil.
Strange conclusion you came to. While the behaviour of the crusaders was inexcusable the division that happened was mostly political and not theological. The entire church was under the popes rule and everyone recognised it, unfortunately secular ruler of Constantinople decided to replace a bishop with another because he refused to give communion to someone who openly had incest, Rome wanted to restore the proper bishop but they rebelled and were a significant factor in the schism. Read about Photius and Coerularius, the schism was mostly personal and political not actually theological.
@@vinnyv949 🎯
Well I have never met a normal Protestant, lol. The reason why the world runs with no problem is because of the influence of the church. 2. Church acted as a governing body. Saying catholic Church is evil just shows you are ignorant
I always wondered what the biblical rationale behind the filioque clause. Any suggestions?
Remember, the Filioque was never mentioned in the Gospels. Rather, the Gospel alludes to the Holy Spirit proceeding from the Father and being sent from the Son. The terms were often used interchangeably in certain regions in defence of the Son's divinity, which gave rise to the schism afterwards.
There isn't a Biblical one. I've read that Toledo bishops were actually trying to deal with 1. Muslim influence and 2. Belief that Holy Spirit is not actually God. (An old, old heresy that is still around, Oneness Pentecostal or JW.)
@@sdnlawrence5640id add Mormon aswell
I think the best one to reconcile is : Revelation 22:1-5 . Both correctly can be understood by Latin and Greek .
@@TheologyAcademy where do the Gospels allude to it? At Jesus' baptism the Spirit descended like a Dove upon the Son. So here the Fillioque theory makes no sense.
The Kingdom of God versus humanity struggling to get their way with evth
I’m not convinced that all that been said it’s actual.
Excellent summary of the Great Schism and its underlying roots. I understand your toning down your descriptions of the Crusades as being "misbehavior" but it was dramatically more than that. When the Muslims took over Constantinople they didn't kill many people. When the "Christian" Crusaders came they left no one alive. It was a massacre -- mass murder, plundering, raping, you name it they did it. But overall, this video is a very thorough overview of the history that provides a lot of detail other descriptions of the Schism don't go into. Thanks, you have a new subscriber with alerts!
Constantinople never fully recovered from that sad and demoralizing episode
@@fredball4894 very sad to hear that, thanks for sharing.
So taking Christian lands and subjugating them to Muslim rule was not bad behavior. Thanks for clearing that up for us.
@@corym8358 to the contrary, it's putting words in peoples' mouths that they didn't say that *is* bad behavior. It's definitely worth clearing that up 😉 because I said no such thing. Peace.
Even if it is, which I agree bloodshed even in the name of Christ is a sin, it isn't really the point of this video. So it would just be a derailment of the subject which could easily get people lost trying to keep up.
Is no one else watching this because they're doing this in religion at school
Maybe it's just Christian Australian schools that make us do this
Be grateful you're not in a secular public school in Australia. They are feeding kids bugs and foisting sodomy 🏳️🌈 on them.
One Bible and a schism?
Different perspectives
I have to make a correvtion to author sentences about crusades behaviour. Hard behaviour of crusades was only a response of the previous massacre of latin people perpetrated by bizantine people. In costantinople there was a latin quarter filked with venetian and genoese people, catholic, that were killed in hundreds, even the catholic bishop was slaughtered. Crusaders vindicated this massacre. This part of the story is aleays neglected by orthodox folk. The first stone was launched by them
✝️🕉️
The information is this video is not accurate.
BBBIW. Prove it!
Filioque is pronounced "Fee-lee-OH-kay" or "Fee-lee-OH-kway"
The Orthodox had to split off and get rid of the sickness in the West from the true Church of Christ.
Their were definitely disputes
What are you tring to say
I submit that the west actually "split off" as there were 5 ancient patriarchates; Rome went their own way, the other 4 are still in communion, (along with a bunch of newer ones).
@@sdnlawrence5640 Just like biblical and historical evidence proves that jesus pbuh and his apostles were vegatarians biblical and historical evidence also proves that the trinity, atonement, original sin and hell are very late misinterpretations and are not supported by the early creed hence its not a part of Christianity I pray that Allah swt revives Christianity both inside and out preserves and protects it and makes its massage be witnessed by all people but at the right moment, place and time
The secret text of the Bible says ye shall know them by their fruits
So too that I say to my christian brothers and sisters be fruitful and multiply
Best regards from a Muslim [ line of ismail ]
A study of the pre-Nicaean fathers leave no doubt that the Church has always been Catholic, in union with the Petrine Primacy.
Baptizing a baby while using sprinkling is very funny for they can’t repent yet.
Acts 2:38
And Peter said to them, “Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.”
Dear @TheEmsrea. The instruction to sprinkle was given in the Didache when there was no flowing water around. It is an exception but no the standard. It would be great if you could support our channel to keep us producing videos and legit content! Unfortunately, we are reaching a point where we cannot sustain the costs of producing these videos. Can you make a $5, $10, $20, $50, or $100 donation now or every month to keep this channel going? You can make a direct donation @ fundly.com/let-there-be-light-4 or a tax-deductible donation @ www.theology-academy.org/ (Under “SUPPORT US”). You can also become a patron @ www.patreon.com/user?u=28861271.
The early baptism isn’t against sins they have yet committed but the inheritance of the original sin of Adam.