This is the first time I've seen a member having to cover the lines of another member while the member whose lines are being covered is still there, just doing something else.
can you spot the two diffrent sound effect from the guitar WITHOUT changing the guitar effect ? people tend to change the guitar effect by using a pedal on the floor as you seen on many guitarist on stage. I believe Winter could play a basic guitar, because her finger is not stiff, But to make it "safe" on live performances, they had to recorded the guitar section on live performance ( check other video, with the exact same guitar sound ). anyway i still love her performance on stage@@dapperfob6194
@@basebonkah8418 yeah for this part but for the "solo part" it's harder to tell. Must be hard to go from dancing to guitar all of a sudden even if she's capable of it.
Why do these Kpop labels have no faith in their idols ability to perform live as in actually playing an instrument live or singing live? I also don’t understand why these fans are so impressed by someone being able to play an instrument like it’s groundbreaking. Musicians have been playing instruments, singing and dancing on stage (actually live instead of backing track) since forever. How is these fans’ bar incredibly low?
that was not a backing track lol. at most there was a backing track that dampened when she played but if you look at the end when she stops playing and have ever used an electric guitar its immediately obvious that is a live and active guitar
@@bobarctor-m6s yes it is. I am a guitarist and I know what it looks like. There are vibrato notes in the sound (that's when you shake your finger) yet there is absolutely zero of it while she's playing. If you knew anything about the guitar you could spot it was fake in about 3 seconds.
@@sminchan3732 First off, yes there was. Second off, even when the vibrato cut off as she was still moving her finger, you can see that she mutes the string with an upstroke. Even if you argue that her fretting finger had a delayed reaction, there could be any number of reasons for that, such as her being too focused on that specific action. Humans gonna human. And if you argue like someone else here that you can hear palm-muting when she was strumming in the second half, hello, you can mute the strings with your left hand, too. And that's what it sounds like. Honestly, all of you guitar playing gatekeepers are so absurdly sad. It's like you feel inadequate as a guitarist, so every time the opportunity arises, you take shots at another guitarist to try and prove that you're worthy or some stupid thing like that. It's sad.
@@sminchan3732 I never said there wasn't, but either way, if you actually think that she isn't playing and think that you can't hear the live playing loud and clear, then you're just creating a stubborn illusion for yourself. I've played guitar for years. You and people like you probably played guitar for years, too. . . meaning you pretended to with the door closed. But it's cooler to leave that part out and play at being knowledgeable 🙃
As was already mentioned, there are wireless plugs. Although this was obviously pre-recorded and probably not by her. Seems like she played the correct notes though, even though the palm muting was clearly not done correctly.
she's not actually playing in this clip. for example at the end there is noise from when the fingers slide off the strings which isn't demonstrated by her hand movements. a lot of notes being played also don't correspond to the notes she's fingering and plucking.
@@sorenpachuau3244 maybe they just don't watch a bunch of performances which is super fair (and doesn't really have to do with age), but yeah the "history makers" part does sound ignorantish in a way
The guitar is actually plugged into a wireless pack, you can see the cable at the bottom of the guitar. That said, she is miming the part still because what she plays doesn't match the guitar you hear.
Yes you are corrcet, but not for the reasons you think. Getting used to new headphone's and only noticing a latency issue with the signal... oppsie My bad. Came back to say.@@PerfectSense77
Playing guitar on a big stage at high volume is totally different playing at home. If you haven't grown up gigging on guitar and learned those skills over time then it's really easy to mess it up and just make a whole lot of nasty noise and feedback.
Too bad it's fake. She's not even muting/ palm muting the parts that should've been. You're buddy doesn't actually seem to know what he's talking about.
@@VVVY777 I agree. Still, her job is not to play the instrument. Her job is to perform and put on a good show. Regardless of the trickery, I think she still did her job and I doubt anyone there cared enough to demand their ticket money back over it as they had a good show anyway
is Winter a Marty Friedman fan?? the Jackson Kelly is a guitar you don't usually see, and Marty Friedman is the most well known Jackson Kelly guitarist
I‘ve played with and recorded double guitars long enough to hear them. That girl‘s guitar was not plugged in the PA. you would have clearly heard her otherwise, especially during those crazy vibratos on the backing track, during which her fingers didn’t move at all. We would have heard 2 different notes. and worse yet, two notes half a step from one another. That is an ugly dissonant sound that would absolutely have been heard. All you heard in this video was backing track. Regardless if she played or not, her guitars are at volume 0 and not audible. You can simp all you want, but you’re in denial if you think any part of her playing was plugged in.
@@WalnutWarrior7 haha as music producer...I noticed she's just fake it for show.....unplugged no DI box and etc.... the guitar sound itself is backtrack ..nobody play guitar W/O cable due to DPC latency between hardware
Independientemente de si realmente estaba tocando la guitarra o haciendo playback, siento que hubiera estado mejor que mientras lo hacía se moviera más y transmitiera alguna clase de sentimiento.... en fin no hate
I mean I can appreciate all types of musical performances but this is so high school but if you're going for the preteen crowd I suppose its what sells 🤣
Y’all really didn’t notice that her hands don’t match the rhythm parts in between the lead guitar parts? It’s incredibly fake. This clip just makes Kpop look even worse. They don’t sing live. They don’t play their instruments live. Truly lame.
This woman can't be more perfect ❤😮
never have i been rizzed up more
that was hot! ❤
You can tell she knows how to play it, but is ashamed of having to pretend to play over the track.
I don't think she was pretending, what makes you say that?
@@Gunso790she's not really playing. It's a backing track. She's fingering the correct notes though, but it's obvious.
This is the first time I've seen a member having to cover the lines of another member while the member whose lines are being covered is still there, just doing something else.
I don't know why it sounds funny
COOOOOL !
Oh, she plays the guitar very well. I recommend that she plays it more extravagantly. That must be the reason why she picks it up on stage.
she is not actually playing the guitar ..
@@MetalGuitarTimo proof ? seemed real to me, all notes are correct and timing is good
@@dapperfob6194 Hello friend! at 0:44 there is a clear chugging rhythm (palm muting) but she is executing full strums.
can you spot the two diffrent sound effect from the guitar WITHOUT changing the guitar effect ? people tend to change the guitar effect by using a pedal on the floor as you seen on many guitarist on stage. I believe Winter could play a basic guitar, because her finger is not stiff, But to make it "safe" on live performances, they had to recorded the guitar section on live performance ( check other video, with the exact same guitar sound ). anyway i still love her performance on stage@@dapperfob6194
@@basebonkah8418 yeah for this part but for the "solo part" it's harder to tell. Must be hard to go from dancing to guitar all of a sudden even if she's capable of it.
Hell yeah! 🔥🤘🏼
She's really the coolest❤
That's fake She isn't playing it
@@ranisoft1026 she played it her self tho
This is going to be some good content for Steve T.
HAHAHAH
무선 샤워기가 생각나는 연주였어요!
블루투스 샤워기인가
Nearly flawless! You could barely tell you were listening to a backing track. 😂😂😂
The end is so obvious
she's definitly playing the right frets
@@yaboi-km2qn at least
are you retarded?
picking technique and frets were consistent with sound of guitar but I doubt she was playing live as @mitch3384 said, kpop is rarely live
Not a single one of these girls looks like they're having a good time.
That was actually pretty cool :) Unexpected, but well played!
Why do these Kpop labels have no faith in their idols ability to perform live as in actually playing an instrument live or singing live? I also don’t understand why these fans are so impressed by someone being able to play an instrument like it’s groundbreaking. Musicians have been playing instruments, singing and dancing on stage (actually live instead of backing track) since forever. How is these fans’ bar incredibly low?
They're main focus to an idol is their visuals if you look pretty/handsome then your good even if they sing like a dying goat😂😂
잭슨은 최고의 기타제작사이며 켈리는 최고의 기타임이 이로써 증명되었다.
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
mi mejor amiga dijo q le de like eee3esta re copado aguante está mina muak
Now we just need a full version of Devils Cry by Taeyeon with a solo by Winter. This would make me very happy 😁
oh she's GOATED
She probably can play the guitar to a degree, but that was a backing track.
that was not a backing track lol. at most there was a backing track that dampened when she played but if you look at the end when she stops playing and have ever used an electric guitar its immediately obvious that is a live and active guitar
@@bobarctor-m6s yes it is. I am a guitarist and I know what it looks like. There are vibrato notes in the sound (that's when you shake your finger) yet there is absolutely zero of it while she's playing. If you knew anything about the guitar you could spot it was fake in about 3 seconds.
@@sminchan3732 First off, yes there was. Second off, even when the vibrato cut off as she was still moving her finger, you can see that she mutes the string with an upstroke. Even if you argue that her fretting finger had a delayed reaction, there could be any number of reasons for that, such as her being too focused on that specific action. Humans gonna human. And if you argue like someone else here that you can hear palm-muting when she was strumming in the second half, hello, you can mute the strings with your left hand, too. And that's what it sounds like. Honestly, all of you guitar playing gatekeepers are so absurdly sad. It's like you feel inadequate as a guitarist, so every time the opportunity arises, you take shots at another guitarist to try and prove that you're worthy or some stupid thing like that. It's sad.
@@sarahnadeofpoetry there's a backing track. Anyone who plays the guitar can see that. If you disagree, you simply do not know the guitar.
@@sminchan3732 I never said there wasn't, but either way, if you actually think that she isn't playing and think that you can't hear the live playing loud and clear, then you're just creating a stubborn illusion for yourself. I've played guitar for years. You and people like you probably played guitar for years, too. . . meaning you pretended to with the door closed. But it's cooler to leave that part out and play at being knowledgeable 🙃
ON FIREEE!!!!
The girl knows what she is doing.
Really impressive without plug in 😍😍
th-cam.com/users/shortsNIYyrGO4-yE I think that's plugged
As was already mentioned, there are wireless plugs. Although this was obviously pre-recorded and probably not by her. Seems like she played the correct notes though, even though the palm muting was clearly not done correctly.
40 likes? U can see her guitar is plugged IN, what do u think is this Shining-silver-metal-thing under her guitar, u can see it the whole perfomance?
it was plugged in:>
stupid, it's wireless plug
she's not actually playing in this clip. for example at the end there is noise from when the fingers slide off the strings which isn't demonstrated by her hand movements. a lot of notes being played also don't correspond to the notes she's fingering and plucking.
her hands actually perfectly match at the end, have you ever played an electric guitar?
Que perfeitaa
I love her, she is my type girl with electric guitar is so good to me
Sweet AF😍
Okay, I'm sorry but the girl at the back continuously screaming made me laugh a lot lmao.
Though Winter looks cool affff
i couldnt hear anything cause of the screams lol
Thats a nice Jackson explorer looking guitar
She is giveing goosebumps ❤
Gasp 🤤 I'm in love
Her technique is so good that dont even need to plug in
Seriously, that guitar is like totally wifi
Considering that this is Kpop its almost safe to be playback but guitars dont need cables anymore for quite a long time now...
To be fair we haven’t been living in the Buddy Holly era of guitars needing to be physically plugged into an amp for a little while now🤣🤤
@@jfrog1979 its not even plugged into a radio pack
@@drdavidappleton1 It is dude, there's a transmitter attached to the guitar strap.
Holy shit that’s hot!!!
Winter rocking out on a Kelly, I can die now.
This randomly showed up in my feed and guys i think fell
me enamoré, 99% amor 1% fé o no era asi
SM got all that money and couldnt even get a guitar stand for Winter.....
젝슨 기타를 바닦에 쿵~ 내려놓는 용기! 대단하군
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ주인 오열
Wow!!! I didn't know she played. So awesome! ❤️
You still don't know then lol
she didn't know either ;)
AHAHAHAHA!
@@corumeach 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
사람들 참...... 저거 핸드싱크에요.. 실제 연주는 전문 기타리스트가 하는거고 윈터는 손가락 모양만 비슷하게 흉내 내는거라고요..
댓글 중에 기타치는 사람이 하나도 없나?? 저걸 모른다고???? 어???????? 진짜??????
기타치는 사람 아닌데도 대충보면 안맞는거 앎
음 잡을때 저렇게 잡는것도 그렇고
그걸 모르더라도 할 줄 알면 저런 느낌으로안하죠
엉성한데 팬분들은 심취해있느라 그걸 모르는 것 같네요..?
this is the first time i've ever seen a gg dancing, singing and playing guitar at the same time! aespa are history makers!
Wondergirls and AoA-Black had band concepts before and they also played live.
how old are you
@@sorenpachuau3244 why?
@@sorenpachuau3244 maybe they just don't watch a bunch of performances which is super fair (and doesn't really have to do with age), but yeah the "history makers" part does sound ignorantish in a way
Some metal singers have been playing drums and singing for decades. NOTHING about Kpop is history making.
Nice Kelly!! 🤘
Gotta love the no cable tone
Lead kick's in: Ahh so she's a rhythmist, bit misleading but ok.
Rhythm stops: Wait a second!
ever heard bluetooth
It could be wireless
The guitar is actually plugged into a wireless pack, you can see the cable at the bottom of the guitar. That said, she is miming the part still because what she plays doesn't match the guitar you hear.
Yes you are corrcet, but not for the reasons you think. Getting used to new headphone's and only noticing a latency issue with the signal... oppsie My bad.
Came back to say.@@PerfectSense77
i dont think in all my life ive seen someone take off a guitar like that 1:18 lmao
Loll. Me neither
Next levul guitar dismount ❤
They got her a guitar tech to hand it to after this show.
I haven't seen many guitarists wear a giant bow with a mic pack hidden in it.
Necesitamos un solo de rock de Winter ❤
Padre🛐
So they sang her parts while she's playing it
I just realized there is almost no real footage of her playing? Ugh
❤❤❤
Um, yea. Pretty sure she is air guitaring it. Look and listen closely.
Part of it is live, part of it is backing track. Just like the vocals.
❤️🔥🤟😜🤟❤️🔥
SLAY
wait omg I didn’t know she played electric guitar im gagged
she's so good at this oh my god
lol
@@Debjit0_ 😂😂🤦♂️🤣🤣🤣
PFTA
ギター弾けたの！？って思ったけど、コメ見てたらこれ違うんか、、でも指捌きはめっちゃ滑らか！
Pov: woman can't be seen sweet playing the electric guitar
Winter:🤍⚡
Wow, that looked pretty legit.
??????????????????????????? !!!
LOL casually shreds
cool
she looks like she knows how to play, why would they use a backing track
Playing guitar on a big stage at high volume is totally different playing at home. If you haven't grown up gigging on guitar and learned those skills over time then it's really easy to mess it up and just make a whole lot of nasty noise and feedback.
❤🔥❤🔥❤🔥
its so cool, i wish it was not fake.
Lol guitar miming. It was playing rythm chunks and lead all at the same time...
Then it was playing a lead arpeggio while her fingers didnt move 🤣🤣🙄
0:10
*_I didn't expect _**_#Winter_**_ to play the electric guitar so well... by the way, can someone tell me the name of this song ?_* 😍🤩🎸🎶😉🤗
It’s girls by aespa
@@Hemkopbroderi *_Thanks_* 🤗
She's handsyncing lmao
It's a hand sync guys...
Part of it is live, part of it is backing track. Just like the vocals.
@@SYMPATRIC If we bend the string like that, it doesn't sound clear... also the sounds can't be that in those left-hand position
@@SYMPATRICaespa sings well these days, but all of their performances are lipsync, you should know this
Winter are Super very cool on guitar solo and I very very like her very much more ❤
Agreed.
As a guitarist. Ill take this as an insult.
She Slayed this performance. I asked a buddy of mine who is in a band she knocked this out of the park💯💕
Too bad it's fake. She's not even muting/ palm muting the parts that should've been.
You're buddy doesn't actually seem to know what he's talking about.
@@VVVY777 I agree. Still, her job is not to play the instrument. Her job is to perform and put on a good show. Regardless of the trickery, I think she still did her job and I doubt anyone there cared enough to demand their ticket money back over it as they had a good show anyway
is Winter a Marty Friedman fan?? the Jackson Kelly is a guitar you don't usually see, and Marty Friedman is the most well known Jackson Kelly guitarist
I think she's going for that Hetfield vibe.
no she's not
@@nenehelix1549come on now. Low slung black Explorer-type guitar? She might not know it, but she is.
That's not a guitar solo. It's rhythm guitar with a few licks.
If i was there I'd bark loud
Almost thought I found a video of a K-Pop Idol being talented outside of dancing.
There are lots of videos like that out there though
Highest Powerlevel in KPop
im sure she can actually play guitar they didn't have to do her like that...
I have the same guitar now... It weighs the half Winter does 😮😮😮😮
I SEE REDY OUT THERE
0:03 오른쪽에 레디 있네ㅋㅋ
the guitar wasnt even connected to an amplifier?
I mean like, she IS really playing. But she is also being doubled by either a track or another guitarist off stage. I give it a 6 out of 10.
My goodness. A rational person.
I‘ve played with and recorded double guitars long enough to hear them. That girl‘s guitar was not plugged in the PA. you would have clearly heard her otherwise, especially during those crazy vibratos on the backing track, during which her fingers didn’t move at all. We would have heard 2 different notes. and worse yet, two notes half a step from one another. That is an ugly dissonant sound that would absolutely have been heard.
All you heard in this video was backing track. Regardless if she played or not, her guitars are at volume 0 and not audible. You can simp all you want, but you’re in denial if you think any part of her playing was plugged in.
@@WalnutWarrior7 haha as music producer...I noticed she's just fake it for show.....unplugged no DI box and etc.... the guitar sound itself is backtrack ..nobody play guitar W/O cable due to DPC latency between hardware
Winter can play. It is just frustrating that she can only play it with the backing track
WOW!! A player with talent beyond dance and pretty?
Where's the talent?
I just can't stop laughing at this sh.t !
Not enough distractions at once to keep my attention.
Where's Two Set Vioin when you need them?!
OMG, did someone finally pick up an instrument. Congratulations GenZ!
THATS EXACTLY WHAT I THOUGHT 🤣🤣🤣
Hey I picked up the drums
my computer is every instrument bitch
bro, lol
had me on the floor 🤣
Boomer humor
Definitely looks prerecorded unfortunately
캘리를 들고 나올줄이야...
This went down as one of the landmarks in kpop performance history
Imagine her on guitar + Wheein on drums collabing with Dreamcatcher doing one of their songs like Scream. I would literally scream.
@@sleepingpanda467 😮😮😮👌🏻👌🏻👌🏻
@@sleepingpanda467And if Wonder Girls too. I would want them to come back for that performance 😭😭
핸드싱크잖아 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 앰프도 없고 악보도 틀리면 빼박이지 뭐
애초에 프렛보면 음도 맞지 않음 ..
스트럼할때 핸싱인거 엄청 티나고 퍼포먼스용으로 핸싱연습만 한것 같은데... 그리고 Em펜타토닉도 아니에요
@@user-bz5lo6lt5p ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
난이도 엄청 쉬운거니까 가능하겠죠 ㅋㅋ 그리고 칠줄 알아도 저런 무대에선 음향때문에라도 핸싱해요 세션이랑 밴드가 나와서 하는것도 아니고
아니 그냥 티가 ㅈㄴ남ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
uh hello backing track
Why no guitar stand?`Why keep guitar on the floor?
Should collab with YuQi of G-Idle for a rock song
OOOMMGGG GUITAR SOLO EPIIIC I play the guitar and it’s so cool to see a kpop group playing guitar live !!
Epic? It is very strong word which totally not matched with reality. But looks fun like an idea.
You have no idea what was epic guitar solos. :D
@@ArchAngel_83 I can play, i know it is not...
@@Psychotoxic86 I didnt say to you mate I said who wrote comment is.
@@ArchAngel_83 Sorry ))))
Independientemente de si realmente estaba tocando la guitarra o haciendo playback, siento que hubiera estado mejor que mientras lo hacía se moviera más y transmitiera alguna clase de sentimiento.... en fin no hate
She's so cool that she doesnt even need cable for guitar. Yeahh...
She's using a wireless device
its 2023 brother, guitarists have been using wireless devices for 15+ years.
I mean I can appreciate all types of musical performances but this is so high school but if you're going for the preteen crowd I suppose its what sells 🤣
기타 땅에 버리는거 왤캐 빡치지;;
안던지는게 어디임 ㅋ
She got a tech to hand it to the next night.
Y’all really didn’t notice that her hands don’t match the rhythm parts in between the lead guitar parts? It’s incredibly fake.
This clip just makes Kpop look even worse. They don’t sing live. They don’t play their instruments live. Truly lame.
She's literally on the correct frets..
But yes this is not live but she does know how to play.
Yes that's backtrack, but winter can indeed play guitar and know how to play it, stop
I never said she couldn’t play. I’m saying that she’s NOT playing lol.
I’ve been playing guitar for 20 years. I would know.