Maya Ali & Bilal Ashraf's Grievance Against Drama Critics | Are We Excited For Sar-e-Rah?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 ก.ค. 2024
- 00:00 Introduction
10:51 Shoaib Akhtar Biopic
17:50 Joyland
23:40 Shadi Season For Cricket Stars
28:39 Sar-e-Rah
33:11 Bilal & Maya
Something Haute is Pakistan’s leading content creating platform the most credible opinion on Pakistan’s beauty, fashion & style, movies & TV scene.
Subscribe for the latest news and reviews on beauty products and Pakistani dramas & movies and exclusive celebrity interviews.
Something Haute’s TH-cam channel is managed by Dot Republic Media. All Copyright Rights Reserved.
Subscribe to our TH-cam channel:
bit.ly/somethinghaute
Follow us on Instagram:
/ somethinghauteofficial
Hassan's Instagram: / hchoudaryy
Aamna's Instagram: / thisisaamna
Visit our website:
www.somethinghaute.com/ - บันเทิง
“I am working from 2012 and you are reviewing since 2018” was directly and clearly pointing to your reviews.
That was so dumb because she's been working as an actress not as a flippin journalist, so what the flip what she on about.
I also felt that comment was rude and unnecessary
Exactly!
That was SUCH a rude comment uff
And we the viewers are watching this lady crying in almost all of her dramas since 2012. It doesn't matter if we r in AC room or shoveling snow.
I think Maya was mostly attacking Amma tv aur main. But Amma is so good at pointing out all the mistakes and flaws which amazes me. Not everyone is book smart, some people are street smart. And we should appreciate both. Love Something Haute and Amma tv aur main both. They both are different but very entertaining in their own ways.
Best comment .. same thoughts , love both shows ❤️
Totally agree I love both the show
Also both portals are totally within their right to review ... their are always on point
agreeeed!
totally agree, amma has her own flavor, she represents our desi culture.. she does exactly what happens in a normal household... but maya's point was actually childish.
You are right amma is very experienced ❤️
Even if they were talking about amma tv aur men, they make dramas for housewives and gharailu khwateen. And amma is a gharailu khatoon and 99% of the time, her critic is on point!
But she’s very badtameez, let’s be honest.
@@nkhan8933 i will be honest she truly represents an average Pakistani woman who, when done with her chores, sits back to relax and watch dramas. Punjabi moms are like tht. I think its alright, something haute and amma tv aur men both critic, one is a very balanced and informed review and the other is a viewpoint of the majority audiences who are illiterate and don’t know much on the subject but still have an eye for flaws and places that have room for improvement. ITS FINE REALLY, there was no need to be this salty tbh. And mujhe tu ye pta hai k woh bhe SH bhe jo jo points highlight krte hen woh humesha sahi hi hote hen 😂 the silly mistakes and all. Anyhow :)
@@aziza000 she is, but she talks like an average Punjabi household woman . And her opinion is raw and pure. Galiyan etc kam ki jaskti hen but unhon ne apne show ka taste hi ye rkha h k punjabi mayen aise bolti hen shyd. Phr b reviews ache deti hen woh .
Ttly agreed👍🏻
@@rohazee8367 my mum is Punjabi and the most typical, conservative woman, but she’s not badtameez. If an younger woman spoke like how she speaks and used abusive language people would’ve been far more harsh towards her channel but since she’s older, people can’t see that. Also sometimes she says things and her own lifestyle & kids lifestyles are polar opposites of that. I also think she now just criticises for the sake of it, rather than constructive criticism, and tries to be funny. It’s not salty, I just think she can be very rude! A lot of the things she says I agree with but her way of saying them are just mean, coarse and a mockery.
I think Hasan should have held the ground for all reviewers/critics instead of feeling excited that Maya Ali is not talking about something haute (which she was) just like how she was holding it down for all actors. I personally felt in this episode that Hasan just doesn't want to upset Maya Ali even after what she does! Sometimes you gotta say what you gotta say.
Just like critics and reviewers do not have any proper training and education, all these actors don't have any training also. They learned on the go.
Lastly, please somebody start telling these actors that everyone works hard, a lot of the time, much harder than them, yet they get praises, recognition and loads of money. If you are so sensitive and your job is so hard then just quit it and do something that you find easy. The world will be fine if we don't have Maya Ali and the other dude.
💯
💯💯💯💯💯💯
It seems that Hassan has very good equation with Maya and Bilal which is the reason he doesn't want Maya to get upset.We all have our own opinion no one can take it..These actors are previliged that they take chunk of money and go for world tour after every project and that is all just because of people who are sitting at home and giving their reviews on their dramas.
Agreed
Seems like Hasan doesn’t want to offend Maya and Bilal but he stands wrong and agree with Amna - even if it wasn’t meant towards him, which Maya is not going to say to his face but he should’ve stood up to his reviewer fraternity.. He didn’t even let Amna say much although I agree with Amna being upset about it and she was trying to voice her thoughts!!!!
Hasan please try to be more genuine and not so diplomatic..
Hassan is defending Maya not saying anything bad about SH. I feel our problem was not just tis that she might be targeting SH but that her opinion was just derogatory to people reviewing or working hard in general. Even celebrities are making crappy dramas and then justifying it by saying we have to earn a living.
being an actor who is earning from people's opinion and money, she should have phrased her thoughts in a better way and been more sensitive
EXACTLY - maya spoke so harshly about the profession so I’m not sure why hassan is taking comfort in the fact that SH was not under fire ( which it clearly was )
Yes it was such a bad taste that Hassan is okay that she has not said that about somthing haute and someone else. They should stand for their whole community. Don't be so self centered
It's not that she was "rude" it was all very passive. Not only that it, but their privilege was also showing. They sounded completely out of touch with reality. It made it out like their audience are idiots. They are so easily swayed by reviewers. Let me tell you, I don't even watch most of these dramas but I watch reviewers because it's entertaining. Like amina said, it was bad taste. The whole vibe was so off putting
Absolutely.. passive aggressive
I wish Hassan could let Aamna talk and give her POV. He kept saying, "Koi esi baat nai, Koi esi baat nai". Let the lady say what she wants, coz we all agree with her! I think he was worried about their relationship with poor Miss Maya the Perfect, who works 1000 hours in the sun, getting bitter.
Disagreed with Maya. Unless reviewers are being disrespectful, she can't say that one has to spend time on a shoot to comment on the drama. You don't need to know how to cook to enjoy a good meal or know a crappy meal from a great one. So, spending time on a shoot will help appreciate the effort that goes into creating a short clip. Despite the appreciation, one would still be able to say if that clip is well made or not.
I don't understand why celebrities don't take criticism well. Okay you do hardwork but it doesn't mean if you give us crap and we will take it. People are working hard in every profession. There are so many other professions which require so much more hard work but provide much less money. I don't know what are they whining about reviews so much. And I appreciate you hassan for handling it so professionally
Exactly, like if you work hard, you are also enjoying the perks of life
Right! If audience can praise the good work, why can’t they speak up if they are disappointed?
No one likes criticism, celebrities don't take criticism neither do Amna n Hassn . Maya didn't do suger coating she didn't go 4 unfiltered opinion. V all Don't like wrong feed back n criticism Maya n Bilal clearly talked about team work thy kinda showed every 1' s hard work .
These day celebrities trying not to b in spot light for interviews coz things can go in wrong direction unintentionally or intentionally their statments opinion face bashing or liked .
Thy can b in bad mood thy r after all human like us . Thy can dislike n share how thy feel .
Agree with Aamna 100%. Hasan it felt like you were just glad she didn’t mean you. And even if she wasn’t talking about you, it was still an attack on your colleagues and members of your fraternity. And this ‘ghar pe baith ke’ comment is just uncalled for. Who exactly is maya making her dramas for?
Totally agree... Sab ghr p hi beth k dekhty he even if its Netflix, amazon prime etc whatever!
@Hassan, stop defending Maya and her behavior, doesn’t matter if she was talking about your reviews or others, her choice of words and behavior was disrespectful and after this interview, she has fallen from grace at least in my eyes
I was not a regular drama viewer until I started watching SH regularly. Now I watch dramas so I can listen to the reviews. I am sure I am not the only one. These drama reviewers have increased our interest in Pakistani entertainment industry. You guys speak what us viewers sitting in AC rooms are thinking, thank you!
Same here
Pataa nahin AC k kamron ne maya ka kya bhigaara hai hahahah
Same
Same
Same
I read through many comments on Maya's "review" of the critics. I haven't found a person yet in these comments who agreed with Maya on her comments. An actors job is to act, the reviewer's job is to review. As a viewer, I felt like both Maya and Bilal came to the interview with an agenda and just put forth what was on their minds. I am glad that Hassan felt the "warmth" from them but I felt the whole interview was "cold", especially after their comments. As human beings, they did not come across as likable people. A little humility goes a long way, especially in the entertainment industry.
Definitely an agenda…when they began criticizing, Maya turns to Bilal and asks if he wants to go first…seemed rehearsed for sure…
Maya definitely came across as a self entitled person.
Couldn't have put it better myself.
Couldn't have agreed more! Maya was definitely very cold and sarcastic when she said I have been working from 2012,and also when talking about her upcoming projects she said demaag kholein n laughed very meanly.
They think that the audience is dumb.They can't figure out when someone comes on screen and speaks with an agenda
Maya can be entitled to her opinion about letting the professionals handle the job but her opinion also translates into "I don't want random people having opinions about the content" which is what the problem is. Your dramas are being aired in every household where television is present so even a 12-year-old can like or dislike your content and also can talk abt it.
It certainly seemed that way especially her mannerism and the passive aggressive undertones in it
Aamna kudos to you for saying it spot on. Hassan, please don't defend them. It seems like you're almost to scared to offend these stars. Aamna isn't. Also, Hassan, please don't undermine reviewers who are 'sitting at home' - they (and you) are not reporting on a war or a US election. These are Pakistani dramas that are targeted towards the 'ghar ka audience' so they have every right to review.
Also, Hassan, not classy bringing up the off camera conversation so much and that Maya was talking of 'someone' else. We know who those 'someones' could be and it is really not nice to keep implying that. As reviewers, you should have their back too.
Maya and Bilaal looked like a school children whining about tests and exam results putting their hard work down . 😊 Only the insecure artists do not feel comfortable being critiqued. All around the world reviews of movies come out after the first show. It is all part of the showbiz profession. With so much love and appreciation, and popularity, a little bit of criticism on work should be accepted by them, wholeheartedly. Big stars become humble with time, ours do a couple of movies and think they have become stars. I was looking at the first show response of people for the film Pathan, and public was going absolutely berserk over Shahrukh and Depika, in the cinema halls. This is called star power, and yet they are humble. Ours should take some lessons from them.
Maya Ali smiles a lot but when she talks, you can feel the bitterness and arrogance. In her interview with Aamna she said good roles are offered to yumna or sajal etc. Girl it’s their naseeb and unlike you they don’t cry with golden eyeshadow for 50 episodes.
How much research is required to tell bad content from good content in a drama? This case is totally different vs. a car review. Even when it comes to food - if I am a customer of a restaurant and I don't like their Biryani - the Chef can't tell me 'Hey first learn what it takes to make Biryani'. In that case as well you can have experienced food critics with their say but a restaurant runs for the average consumer who chooses to spend their money there. And if they decide not to, the restaurant will go out of business. A 'Star' becomes a Star and earns their money because of the audience. So they need to respect them. Ofcourse these actors can also have their opinion and that is to be respected as well, but the way these two expressed it - it was just entitlement.
Definitely
Amna is absolutely right !! Maya’s choice of words and attitude was not appropriate.. healthy criticism will raise the craft of arts and drama .. our artist should have big heart and improve their work!!
#mayaali Hassan is trying hard to defend Maya while Aamna is telling and explaining the truth and real facts, which I really appreciate.... Aamna, you are absolutely right ✅️ 👏 🙌. HASSAN PLEASE STOP BEING SO OVERLY POSITIVE... We are going to throw up on that 🤪😜😆
Yes he looks like he want to be in good list🥲
He is always chaploos of actors
Considering "Yunhi" is Bilal Ashraf's debut in drama industry, this interview of his brought a sour taste in my mouth of actor Bilal. It's your first drama show some professionalism. His demeanor was so rude for no reason. I mean do people even know him?
Maya isn't or as far as I remember doesn't really get that much criticism, so where did the comment came from? Why was she so salty about it? Why were both of them so high on their clouds like we're listening to huge number stars here? Really dissatisfied with both of these.
These actors do a couple of movies and their think they have become stars.
Both Maya and Bilal are so unpleasant and full of themselves, just don't like both of them and I'm not going to watch their bakwas drama #yunhi👎👎👎🤮🤮
exactly!!! just compare it to fawad khan even thou he is wayyyyy bigger star than them. He was so polite & humble.
Bilal spent a big chunk of time with MK during their film-making process and post. Perhaps he could have learnt a thing or two from her. Humility earns you respect! - As for Maya - you're right she doesn't get much criticism she was often let off the hook easily even when there was inconsistencies in her performances. I think she has always been like this (passive-aggressive) and we're only getting to see it now
I agree. Bilal has no grounds to throw shade at anyone in the industry, especially because he is a weak actor. Maya wants to be treated like a star so maybe she needs to act like one too.
If I mess up a surgical procedure , I won’t expect the patient and family to give me grace for all the hard work I put up in med school 🤪
The interesting thing is that someone like Wahaj Ali actually said he learns from critiques and drama viewers comments!
and that's why in a short period of time he has reached massive success while others after spending over a decade in the industry have only 2-3 notable projects.
@@elenam4846 so true, he is a remarkable actor, and he said how people thought he wasn’t good in Mah e tamaam etc, but he had made great progress in leaps and bounds, to ehd e wafa, Dil na umeed tou nahi, and Jo bichar,and even in the comedy Ishq Jalebi!🌹
We can understand Hassan that probably while you had a chat with Maya offscreen you knew she was primarily talking about someone else, but you see thats ‘offscreen’; something that the audience would never get exposed to. So naturally on the basis of whatever we see on screen is how we reach a conclusion about someone. Because of that Maya should’ve chosen her words well, what we saw was purely bitter and tbh just pissed me off whereas i was excited for yunhi as i havent seen much of them. A sensible actor even if he/she is best friends with the said interviewer will still act responsible because that is what the audience sees right. If it wasnt about you, she should have spoken better, because you and Amna are masters at your job and no one should sit on your show and say otherwise and think oh thats okay because off camera I meant it wasnt for them. We are fond of you and it naturally upsets us but at the same time her way of talking pissed us off even if it wasnt meant for you because it was degrading. Kudos to you once again Hassan for carrying out the entire interview with utmost grace.
👍 ✔
Even if it wasn't meant for them but still saying it about other reviewers is also not good.
@@sanskrati5998 yeah thats exactly what i said, it was degrading
@@sanskrati5998 exactly
Hassan acted like a kid “it is not not us you are talking about “
You all should have each other’s back even if she was referring to other reviewer ( #Amma tv aur mein is 99% correct )
It is reviewer job to review ..
Artists should learn from Shah rukh who is sooo humble
Whatever you say, Hassan, you can not justify Maya and Bilal.
They were wrong. Period.
There are only three drama critic portals and she was dissing every portal especially Amma TV aur mein. Madam the real audience of your dramas are people like Amma and her reviews are unfiltered which makes her show amazing. Something Haute has a different critic style which I absolutely love as well but you cant keep throwing crap and ask the audience kae dhoop mein kaam kiya like it please? Let the work speak for itself. Not watching #yunhi or any other product from these two whiny babies!
Artists should not fear criticism if they are confident of their work .
Hassan you are being way too kind and we appreciate that but that interview wasn’t good in any way! Sorry to say but Maya was extremely disrespectful and disruptive. She didn’t even let Bilal finish one sentence without interrupting.
As a loyal SH viewer none of us liked it. You guys put so much effort and time. She shouldn’t have said that or May be choose better words. Besides SH it’s Amma who reviews and we equally love and respect her perspective. Our celebrities tend to get defensive rather than take the criticism and work harder.
@@Xenonni 🤭😅 just the whole comment was unnecessary and not worded right. Reviewers are doing their job. And now when Faisal Qureshi Attiqa Odho and Rubina Ashraf are doing reviews and they are being really tough 😁🤪
So right about Maya interrupting Bilal in the whole interview. I think that was so irritating.
💯
@@kukuali rubina ashraf will rip their drama apart!
I loved the intro about Aamna's visit to Hassans place, I was smiling throughout
One can counter maya and bilal with the comment that
Kisi critic k critique ko critique krnay se pehlay they should watch all the dramas that are being reviewed then they would realise how difficult it is to take in majority crappy content and continue watching it for the sake of reviewing
Hassan she was obviously talking about u guys esp that ‘I’ve been working since 2012’
And even if she wasn’t talking about SH she did belittle ur peers and that was to bad bad taste
Amina u are absolutely correct in the three points u raised - we watch these dramas ‘ ghar’ aur ‘AC’ main and we absolutely have the right to have an opinion about them - we also work hard and trust us no one gives us any latitude based on our conditions
Hassan pls understnd the offscreen bit we were not privy too and what we saw was very uncomfortable to watch - and it’s not only u whose behalf we are angry at ; it’s other reviewers too whom we have come to enjoy even more than the dramas being churned out
Absolutely 💯
Kinda disappointed in you Hassan, you kept saying she’s not talking about us. Even IF she’s not talking about you, come on why are you happy that she’s targeting someone else it’s a bit childish. I have to agree with Aamna on this , her comments were in bad taste regardless of who she was talking about.. you guys are a community, you should have each other’s back. Maya’s salty attitude was not necessary she can get her point across in a better way, again agree with Aamna that they have no media training
Agreed with the reviews. The view of maya and Bilal is unjustified.
I’m disappointed with Hassan as he was playing safe mujhay tho nai keh rahi … I wasn’t expecting this ..
From now on Hassan and Amna (especially Hassan) will be kinder to Maya when giving reviews as you can tell he doesn't like rocking the boat. Hassan in denial that they weren't talking about something haute. It's so obvious that they were!
Maya was so wrong with her opinion.Hasan u should have said something. Even if she didn’t mean u u still should have stood up for what’s wrong and what’s right like Amna did.Because U know whatever she was saying was not right.She has the right to give her opinion but not by degrading the other person. Does she know the A of being an Actress?Has she got a degree in acting?Do we not always talk about talent.If u have talent u become something without a degree.
#feedback agar apka k ilawa Maya ny kisi or k bary m bhi bat ki h maslan Amma t.v or main ki to aplogun ko us k bary m bhi bat Karni chahiye thi. Jab Amna ka issue Hoa tha to Amma ny Amna ka sath dia tha.
Amna is right about interview but Hassan v dissapointing
I feel they’re hinting towards Amma from Amma,TV aur main as she’s a layman among these highly qualified,experienced “journalists” and “critics”
Good thing about Amna is she’s not always biased and often tries to present both sides of the story and voices her disagreement strongly.
Hasan is now also part of mainstream media somehow,plays safe.His biases are visible.
You should watch my reviews of "mainstream" dramas sometime then if you think I am biased
-- Hassan
@@SomethingHaute Believe it or not but you were quite biased. You kept saying "as long as you are not talking about us" it was very uncalled for.
You also keep saying that we should tolerate Maya's opinion. This was not an opinion it felt more like an attack. Honestly if you are okay with the attack that's your choice but I feel bad for other reviewers
P.s. the way she said after your introduction "pani peelay araam seh" I could sense the cringe and awkwardness from my mobile screen. Kudos to you for closing your eyes 🙈
@@SomethingHaute Also Hasan when you meet her next time on your Talk Talk show please ask her what exactly qualifications she has on acting😁
@@SomethingHaute I promise this is the last thing. In case if you want to use an example next time. Please tell her one of our and Ama tv aur mein viewer is a Research Scientist who works on field on a single project for 365 days and when it goes for approval it gets rejected/disapproved/demand for amendments by people who have never worked in a lab but they have an expertise on judging and doing a critical analysis on peer reviewed articles.😀
No Hassan, Maya was wrong, rude and defensive and chose unreasonable words for you and Amna and we are offended! I didn't even finished watching that interview when they start whining 😡
Hassan you guys should stand for whole of your community. Ye kia baat hue ky humien nahe kaha. Hamary portal ko nahe kaha. Baki log b jo kam kr rhy han, drama dheak ky hi kaam kr rhy han. Galaxy lollywood is working since 2010. Bohat se actors ko b acting ka A nahe pata. From where Maya got acting training. Did she go to a film school.
That's a bad taste... if you think that she is talking about someone else and not us.
Maya is beautiful and good actor I'm following her since her first drama dur e shehwar..she used to be a very bubbly and positive girl but now by the time passed she changed a lot..her attitude is change...
I agree with amna totally. The audience has every right to have an opinion, and if someone has a channel and wants to review it and other ppl want to watch it - the celebrities need to accept that. There is definitely a difference between a journalistic approach vs a layman approach to the review - but again the audience can choose to like either or both!
Regarding the Maya Ali’s comments, they definitely left a bad taste. It was so surprising coz it sounded very ignorant. I mean by that logic, drama viewers should also turn off their fans and acs and then watch them 🤷♀️. Makes no sense.
Hi Amna and Hassan. I really love watching your show. It's been 3 years now that I follow your shows. I really love the way you both review. I was 17 when I started watching your show, you made me realise that I have been watching the dramas wrong way. My ability to realise wrongs and rights about social norms improved watching your videos. So please always stay the way you both are. Lots of love from France ❤️
I would recommend you to watch Drishyam and KGF (both parts), also how i met your mother. I am sure u'll like it.
I watched drishyam it's quite good
💯 agree
Bigger fan of Amna and Hassan after listening to their discussion on Maya and Bilal's interview. It's commendable that you guys always stay respectful towards the people involved regardless of how controversial the topic is. Really puts me off when celebrities come from a place of privilege and make ill-informed comments. And this argument that "critics should create content first and then critique other content" is such a bogus argument. Renowned film/drama critics around the world do not make films/dramas themselves but are well respected.
Hassan please stop defending mayaa .. amnaa has a valid point ..
My Dude Hassan I get it that you don’t want to be on bad list of these celebrities but when they are wrong you should accept it. It doesn’t matter if Maya was talking about you or not. What she said was absolutely wrong and I love how Amna Stood against that but what really bothers me is you trying to defend Maya. Absolutely Wrong
#onthespot Totally agree with Aamna about Maya and the interview. Hassan definitely needs to be commended for keeping his cool but sometimes it’s ok to get your point across in a respectful manner and stand up for your work even if it’s not you specifically that’s being targeted. I can totally see Aamna putting Maya in her place with out being offensive 😆
Aamna!! You were on fire! You’re reply was amazing! Proud of you
No one is ignoring the hard work put in by the actors, but if the content is not good then as viewers we have got the right to call it out.
Working conditions can not be used as an excuse for generating crappy content. Critique is meant to improve the content we watch, people creating the content need to understand this.
You’re right Aamna aapi that old school affection, hospitality and warmth is just the best ❤
Totally agree with Amna , very poor choice of words by Maya . Instead of being grateful she is playing victim here 🤦 very disappointing and shameful.
Guys ..Mujhey Pyar hua tha was trending in India on #2 yesterday. .(it even left Ranbir-Shraddha movie trailr behind) Woh #2! Congratulations 👏 👏
Yes i saw it i am from India 😍
Hassan, Aamna said it right the other day that you are very kind and gracious even off-screen and we can see that. And I think the objective of discussing this today was because you felt bad for Maya and wanted to address it. I understand you want to give Maya benefit of doubt and it's very gracious of you. The crux of the matter is not the lack of tolerance for differing views - it's the manner in which she put her point forth. It was salty and passive-aggressive from the moment you did Intro. Maya lacks the tact and professionalism to put her point across in a respectful manner. I wish she can google what passive-aggressive behavior entails and make amendments accordingly. After spending over a decade, she still hasn't learned what to say or how to say. As Aamna put it, she and Bilal surely need media training. I wholeheartedly agree with Aamna, and I am so glad that she expressed her disappointment. When actors like Maya cannot find a compelling argument in response to the feedback they receive they always deflect the topic and indulge in victim-mentality. SH is like our family and we feel protective about you - it was natural that any form of attack would be met with the comments we saw underneath their interview. Moreover, it wasn't just an attack on critics but also on her 'Gher Behti Huwe audience' as well. As I said in my previous comment - only an insecure actor will respond in the manner she did. In her last interview on SH, she was upset that assertive women roles go to Yumna, Sajal and Saba, well maybe she hasn't reached that mark and brought that finesse to her acting and that's why the feedback she received for Pehli Si mohabbat is actually for her own good but she seemed too entitled to see it that way
I like Maya but this was so u called for. Every profession requires hard work.
Secondly Hassan, this is your profession. Sounds so weird that all you care about is if she's talking about Something Haute. You should be able to defend what you do.
Good going, Amna!
Everyone is entitled to an opinion, be it a ‘star’ or a ‘commoner’. But the point is, that her points were absurd and made NO sense! Because she’s been working since 2012, critics should think before giving feedback. Because ‘princess’ Maya has worked a long day in the heat/ cold, no one has the right to judge?? If a labourer was building her house in the same heat/cold (for much less money) and did a rubbish job, I’m sure Maya would let him know she isn’t happy. So yes Hasan, everyone is entitled to an opinion, but it has to at least make sense. Im afraid, your understanding of her statement didn’t make sense either. I agree with Aamna, Maya’s comments were derogatory and entitled.
Imagine if you complained about a meal at a restaurant and the chef says, ‘nay, pehle aa ke pakao na zara, feyr kuj boliyo’ 😆
I 100 % agrees with all viewers who are expressing their thoughts about Maya and Bilal. I couldn't watch it further than that, felt really bad for Hassan and all the critics who were targeted 😔 my all support is with the critics and good drama makers, actors and crews.
Really liked the fact that Aamna didn’t mince words and spoke about privilege and clout . Kudos
Love Amna and how she handles Hasan and his rambling.
Seriously! Hats off to Hassan for the way he handled Maya and Bilals comments!!
@@Saamla hahaha exactlt.. he was trying sooo hard not to upset actors as he has now a show.. not right
Why can't artists take criticism positively?? This is the job of Critics to review and criticise.. we as audience n u as critics have the right to say what we think of their work!!
Disagree with Maya' statement about reviews... Hollywood ho ya Bollywood har Jaga har koi reviews deta hai ..Baat ye hai humare actors insecure ho Jate Hain..they should take criticism, reviews in positive way....
One is not displaying respect and manners when one puts up points like Maya did towards Hassan! We have critics and commentators in Cricket as well for example, do we expect them to have played cricket to be able to comment on the sport? It's not great to put someone in this positions and start lashing out when you know they won't defend themselves at that moment. As gracious as Hasan was, I agree with Amna on the points made.
I felt Maya was especially condescending to Hassan … you are judged for the end product and if this was a way to shut down any critique, it has put them under a magnifying glass now so their drama better be good . If their PR team specifically asked for an interview these two should have been a lot more humble , Bilal seemed like he didn’t want to be there so maybe it would have been better that he did not come instead of making snarky comments . I think Hassan wanted to appear as if he was fine with the remarks as to not tarnish their relationship but Maya should have given the same courtesy back . She came across as very entitled and bratty .
Maya’s choice of words were wrong ! That ac k kamray mein Beth k karna ..the viewers have every right to comment
I wasn’t a big drama viewer before I became a regular follower of SH. Actors should be grateful, our interest in their work is piqued because their work is being talked about and they are getting more exposure
Regarding Maya ali, As a character in PTv drama khawaja and sons used to say “ Tuleem dee kumee “. It doesn’t matter what was said off camera and against whom, she came across as crass, rude, vengeful, and downright ill informed
Amna it’s hard to make understand when he just doesn’t want to listen. He was star struck in this interview and did not handle too well Maya’s lashing out at the reviewers. He could have spoken up but he chose not to . Not because he doesn’t know how to reply but because he chose not to say anything. How gullible of him to say “they were not talking about us”
Hassan bhai they were talking about your reviews too !! You were included in these comments. SH was also a target for reviewing their work . Wake up and smell the coffee . Forget what was said off the camera . Lol the girl just dissed you in front of the camera and you are defending her by talking about what she said behind camera 😅😂😂😅
Sorry but Hasan needs to read the room. Both on the previous video and current video, majority of the comments do not agree with what Maya said, and Aamna is completely justified in her disappointment. I feel Hasan is letting his personal bias for Maya show. I know they are not friends etc, but it’s clear he doesn’t want to offend her. Once again, read the room Hasan.
I agree with Amna, I understand some people get so rude but commenting on the criticism as a whole was so so stupid. Maya is really a very nice actor but here she was so full of attitude in that particular part idk which cloud she was on. Also for winning the argument these actor just come with we woke 10 hours like ma'am? you are doing it because you want to do it you want to earn you love you profession! Kudos to both of you for handling situation graciously
I totally agree with Amna that Maya’s comments were offensive. I can understand that hassan is defending Maya as he has good relationship with her but the point is that even if she was not talking about SH shed comments were not valid for anyone. Amma from Amma TV and main is not trained journalist but she represent average household women who are majority of our audiences. And her raw take on dramas is also a great feedback for makers. So even if it was not about hassan and Amna it was wrong to say those things about reviewers in general. Nobody needs to be a drama maker first and then review and nobody needs to stand in sun for 10 hours to qualify to review a drama and it has nothing to do with who has been working in the field longer.
Agreed with the first opinion of Amna about whatever Maya said for drama reviews.
I felt the same .
Maya when you don’t like a dish in a restaurant then you don’t first go into the kitchen, stand with the chef in the heat to see the problems faced before that dish was served to you. So similarly you are being paid very highly for what you do, no one will stand on the field with you before reviewing.
👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
How uneducated of a statement it is when you suggest that the content you make be appreciated on the basis of how much hard work you put in. How ridiculous is that! How can any art form evolve without any discourse around it?
Hassan is being nice about it bilawaja, it doesn't matter who Maya was referring to, it's the principle of the thought that's problematic. If a performer thinks that they are above criticism because they worked omg so hard on it, how insightful are they really about their own craft, the art form itself, and the reality that surrounds them?
The best thing for an artist is to just learn from the constructive reviews and ignore the rest. Whining about it on a public platform is a bad look. Yes Maya has the right to express her opinion. Nobody is saying otherwise. But it's just ironic that her criticism for the bad reviewers is that they don't know the R of reviewing. That's like some random person saying she doesn't know the A of acting. If she has a problem with a specific style of reviewing or the kind of trashy comments people leave then she should have mentioned that instead of painting everyone with the same brush.
No hate hassan but I started watching SH after watching amma reviews. I love her desi tarka aur SH more practical point of view. Also I literally wait for mondays to watch amma TV aur ma. So please don’t defend maya. We absolutely love amma
Thanks for a thought-provoking episode. Also thank you Aamna ma'am for telling about your visit... and Hassan sir and his family's great hospitality and warmth...also Hassan sir you look super-cool in this look
#onthespot Before I make my comment i want to say that I occasionally watch your content as well as Galaxy lollywood content.
Hasan it was quite obvious that Maya was demeaning Ama tv aur mein. I am sorry if this comes out as a comparison but my intention is to remind you that when HSY and deepak took a rage out on Amna. It was Ama who spoke in Amna's favour and it was highly appreciated by Amna and yourself. From the interview of Maya and even from your Haute bite it looked like you agreed with Maya on Ama's take. You even said people should study before doing reviews.
How sad 😔
It would have been soo nice if you had actually and openly supported your critic community WITHOUT ANY FEAR.
Amna I think you are going to be a little bit more wiser and fearless, can you please once again address this properly.
Thannkkk youuu
Personally, I found Maya’s comments quite weird and hypocritical. Every job has its perks and lows. You can’t compare apples and oranges. The actors don’t do all of their work standing under the sun, it’s just a fraction of it.
Maya and Bilal are literally unaware of how much they themselves benefit from these reviews. To sit on a digital drama reviewing platform to promote their work and then asking the critiquing community to not give opinions is downright dumb.
Disagree with Maya. As someone who works in the content creation in industry, I can say from experience, even as we work on a project, you are keenly aware to know that it will, should and must be open to criticism. That includes even your own work in any project. You have to distance yourself from your work. We don’t own our work, it’s in that hands of those you create it for- the public, critics included. It’s nothing personal.
I just wanted to comment regarding the reviews…there are so many dramas produced, living far away in Canada, my insight into what to watch is coming from reviews from you guys. There are so many dramas that I haven’t seen but because you feature them and even if your review is not favourable I have watched that drama because perhaps I liked the plot. So keep the reviews coming they are much appreciated!!
Hasan you should see momin and Imaan take on Maya and Bilal interview they are so correct and your point what if they said one thing y can’t we bear it, but this was a personal attack u guys never do personal attacks you talk about the characters and 99percent of times u r all praises for actors its character u talk about. Anyways i am big fan of all reviewers and felt really bad what Maya said.
Hassan was calm and composed because he had off camera chat woth her and she insured she wasnt talking about him.. i am sorry thats a very lame excuse and her comments were very bad..:.. when reviewers are reviewing they dont talk about actors… its the character, the writing and direction…. Maya should get offended if they talk bad about her acting…..
Not good Maya….
Hassan why o why are u trying soo hard not to upset any actor... Don't do this! Ammna on the other hand is always nonbiased n i like this quality of hers 💗
Hassan didn’t let Amna speak properly on Maya’s topic . He was cutting her continuously. Anything can happen behind camera that people don’t know but here the discussion is about on camera. Maya didn’t accept that statements were not for SH. She was harsh and rude throughout the interview . It’s her right to give review on reviews but she could have use much better words to keep her point.
That's exactly I said. That she could have used better words to express her opinion. What's your point?
-- Hassan
@@SomethingHaute I just wanted say that the thing you are saying about Maya’s comments that those were not for SH is not correct because she directly compared your and her work experience. It was not a pleasant sight.
I love to watch Maya on screen as much as I look for SH reviews and eagerly waiting for her drama(Juhi)
For me it was not good experience because you guys always give genuine feedback and because of Amna’s reviews I started watching Agar.
Hassan you didn’t need to justify Maya and her stance. What you saying is that you can criticize and not others is wrong. I criticize her for her lame portrayal in PSM and I have the right to do so. Yes I watched it while sitting in aircon like they act with lots of fans and Vans where they have their own make artist for even playing a normal middle-class girl. So where is she coming from?
Hassan sounds so immature, she actually insulted sarcastically on camera and Hassan is just talking about off camera ......
It didn't make sense even if she was talking about someone else. We love you guys and we love the style of Amma too. If their dramas are beyond the understanding of a normal viewer then why not review them in the style of AAM AWAM. Maya's remarks were deteriorating.
Agreed 💯💯
I hope ap logon ne A/C band kar diya hoga aj discussion k waqt ?
🤣😆🤣
😂😂 - Best Comment!
Hi, I've been following you guys since the start, and i love you guys and say this with all the love, but Hassan even if maya wasn't talking about you guys, it doesn't take away from the fact that it was wrong, as Aamna correctly pointed out they get lacs and crores for working in extreme conditions, and as far as the review thing is concerned, the drama is made for the public, so its is our right to either like it or not and then share our opinions on it, just because it isnt what you believe or because as an actor you're "sensitive" doesn't make it wrong. Another thing is that you kept saying it wasn't about us and all, however it was very clear who she was talking about, and i must say it was extremely derogatory for the people who she was speaking about, the dramas are made for housewives as said by them themselves, she as in amma from amma tv aur mein has been watching these dramas for a very long time and their reviews make so much sense and are entirely what the masses feel themselves hence the viewership, and it would've been nice to see that instead of saying atleast you're not talking about us, u would've defended and taking your peers side, however i dont blame you as again you were trying to mediate the situation, however it would've been nice to see you atleast disagree with the statement and understand that it was wrong in todays episode.
Aamna was right these actors need proper media training before coming to give interviews.
Hope you understood what I'm trying to say, and if i said anything wrong, i apologise in advance for that, love you guys❤
absolutely 💯
I agree to amna about maya as you people are giving opinion about their characters in drama but maya was attacking reviewers personally. #onthespot
It might be Maya's opinion but there is a way to state her opinion. If she wants the reviewers to be polite, you yourself need to be polite first. Also, the point that actors work hard and so should not be critiqued too much does not make sense at all. It's like saying I have worked hard for an exam so the teacher should not deduct my marks or say not to say anything about the bad food served at a restaurant just because the chef worked hard standng and cooking in the heat. It does not work this way
i respect both of you
on maya’s point hassan aaj shadeed relieved hain ke unka naam maya nay nhn liye
aur iske elwa something haute is only lead by professionals
amna conclude this point very professionally while hassan praise their professionalism by demeaning other youtubers
literally very disappointed with hassan’s take
What Maya said it does not make any sense at all,
She works in hard circumstances,
She is working from last 10 yrs, so we need to appreciate her pathetic work???
We will only appreciate good quality work as a viewers ,
As a viewer I always agree with Hassan and Amina.
I never found them criticizing any project for no reasons.
Hassan k according agr wo nhi hain tou koi bhi kisi kabil nhi!!? Pathetic points he has to defend maya...
Hassan please let Amna talk as well. We got the point please stay away from rambling.
I agree with Amna in maya ali's case . Whatever she said is 100 percent right. I am glad she addressed it . Don't defend her (maya) hassan. Friendship aside whatever she said was not right
I am extremely fond of Aamna but on Maya and Bilal thing Hassan opinion taken me away! So mature of him. Today it felt I have seen Hassan growing like a baby to a man. Love you both!!!!