What video doorbell are you using? Also if you want to check out the full comparison article, here’s the link: smarthomesolver.com/reviews/best-smart-video-doorbells-2021-update/
I have a Dream Machine Pro so I can go with the Unifi doorbell easy enough but I feel like I need to commit to their cameras as well then which are massively expensive.
Nice touch to quote Harvey Dent from one of my favorite movie trilogies! 👍 I have not yet switched to a video doorbell (and that's inspite of having several free ones sent over by companies that wanted to partner and integrate their products into our smart research platform). But that could be because I am picky about latency, no subscription fees, no being tied into any manufacturer's ecosystem etc.....and because I am able to replicate most of the features (except the chime) built into video doorbells with regular cameras from Reolink with Blue Iris or even Raspberry Pi with motioneye (and few Twillio and/or Sendgrid routines for notifications) . 🙂 Completely agree with your assessment though (especially for non-geeks like me) about Eufy for budget conscious consumers and the newer Ring Pro for people with extra budget (even though many of my friends are sick of the increasing latency with their older models - planned obsolescence in older models?). Question: What is your thought about any theft deterrent features built into the doorbells you reviewed here? I know there was concern previously about some doorbells getting built in SD card storage to solve the missing 24/7 recording problem but that was defeated if the doorbell could be stolen relatively easily.
Agreed. Excellent production, clips, sound, explaining and easy to understand. Here have 500.000 goldstars for a job well done 👍 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️✖️100.000 Thank you 😊
This is the second home in which th-cam.com/users/postUgkx0jZ_lGlDVJhDnmagEU8gn47cmfPNlLQU we've replaced our "regular" doorbell with a Ring video doorbell and we really enjoy it. It is very easy to install and it works very well, with a clear picture through the app and good in-home use (we added the chime, which is also easy to install and doesn't require another thought to use).
Coming back 3 years later, I have still yet to see a better review + comparison. Showing the app and how it looks side by side against competition is extremely useful if not essential.
I appreciate your mention of the audio quality. For those of us with hearing impairments, even with hearing aids we sometimes cannot understand tiny tinny-sounding audio. It’s especially useful that you play the audio so we can judge it for ourselves. Thank you!
I've had nothing but issues with mine. The UDMPRO consistently resets itself and loading into the live feed on my Pixel 4XL is unbearably slow. The other issue I have is that you cannot set a custom "doorbell" notification when the doorbell is pressed.
I have the ring pro 2 and the small picture on the echo show can be fixed simply by telling the echo show to zoom in,a feature I've not seen advertised anywhere(I found it by accident).The echo show remembers this setting until you power cycle it or tell it to zoom out.
Have been using Eufy for 2 years now and love their system. Also have 2 of their cameras, all connected to their base station. Notifications are fast and reliable. Video quality is very high. Batteries last approx 6-7 months ( I live in Seattle. Gets cold in winter, but usually not freezing). Nice not to have to pay monthly fees and you can store a ton of video on their base station system.
We have a Wyze cam and your review is spot on. My notifications do show up quickly, though. An SD card option would be awesome. Still happy with it for the price.
I am literally returning both my Eufy tomorrow because there is times I get notifications and then I go to see recording and nothing or there is times it goes hours without recording. Ever since the system update I have been having this problem. I updated it like about a couple weeks ago before the update it was great. I even got a replacement and same thing, so that lemme know it was something to do with the update.
I just purchased the Wyze doorbell for 2 reasons. 1: I like having multiple chimes in the home and I can choose a different sound for each doorbell. 2: I already have Wyze cams, Wyze plugs, Wyze thermostat, and Wyze lights. So it just made sense to stay with that ecosystem. I don’t mind the delay because right now I have no delay and I have a second cam on my front porch anyway.
Wyze products are inexpensive and there is a reason. Wyze has gone downhill as a company. Their customer service is an exercise in frustration. The constant updates risk deteriorating the image quality and function of your older Wyze cameras. They don't support previous versions making all your original Wyze systems obsolete and virtually useless. AND $1.99 per camera per month adds up real fast/ plus a $60. annual fee for their home security Kit.
I’ve been using a UniFi setup for years for my home network and security cameras, so all I had to add was the doorbell since I had all the other necessary equipment. Only been using the doorbell for a month, but I have no complaints.
Terrific video for people to start looking into the different video doorbells available in today’s market. Easy to understand and comprehensive. Thank you!
I've watched several of these comparison videos and this is by far the most comprehensive when it comes to practical usage. Thank you - I've decided to blow my cash on the Ring P2, that is if they ever come back in stock.
Great video, Reed. I've been thinking about getting a video doorbell for a few months now and this video guide has led me in the right direction. When there are a few top options, that's when the hard part comes in. I'm considering Eufy, Nest, or Ring - but I'll also have to get Hoobs up and running to get it working within myHomeKit setup.
The wired Ring doorbells (as well as wired Nest Hello doorbells) are great products. HOWEVER, they don't tell you upfront that these wired doorbells all have an internal non-user-serviceable battery. IF you will be using the doorbell with a mechanical chime, just be aware that at some point, the battery inside will fail. The internal battery on these units are used to provide temporary voltage to the doorbell unit when a mechanical chime is used. When someone presses the doorbell button, power is temporarily routed away from the doorbell to the chime inside the house. The battery keeps the doorbell powered for the 1-2 seconds while this happens. Over time, this small battery will be unable to deal with the voltage drop and your doorbell will lose power and reboot itself. If you don't rely on a mechanical chime or if you use the Ring wireless chime, than it won't be an issue. If you do use a mechanical chime, depending on your environment (which includes usage rate, weather, temperature, etc.), the doorbell will stop function properly at some point in time. For most users, it seems to be somewhere between 1-3 years.
@@ilyas_khan I'm not sure if Ring has any battery powered products that can be wired to a mechanical door chime. The ones I'm aware of can be charged by the doorbell wiring but do not have the ability to ring a physical chime besides the wireless electronic chime that Ring sells (and this chime is powered by a standard indoor outlet). But in general, you won't have that issue as any supplemental power for a mechanical chime would come from the replaceable and rechargeable battery which is not present in the Ring Pro / Pro2.
Glad you liked the video. I normally wouldn’t walk looking at the camera but I’m doing it so you can compare video quality of the doorbells. Getting footage of myself standing or walking in front of the doorbells is my least favorite thing.
I have the Wyze Doorbell on my side Door where it's a step up to get in so it's a narrow area and it works perfectly for my needs. I agree that I wish it had a SD card reader but for what I use it for, it's great. On my front door I use the new Ring Wired doorbell and it can see my entire yard, I'm very impressed with the viewing angle and picture quality. The only thing I don't like is the monthly fees for the full functions for both devices. That leaves my back deck and back door with a wireless doorbell/flood lamp to install and you've given some great suggestions.
You missed one critical test. Stick the doorbell in the freezer for 2 hours and see if it still works. My Ring 3 is useless for 3 months of the year as i live in Norway.
Place a heat pad behind the ring setup if wired. It will be a makeshift build but a solution nevertheless. If you want to get fancy you can get an Arduino (or some type of IFTTT trigger) to program it to only kick off at certain low temps. I have a heat pad warm up my lithium batteries at a certain temp automagically.
I really like all your video's. You try and put humor in them, which I can appreciate. I hoped you would have done the Amcrest doorbell. I have the Ring Elite in my brand new house and love it. When you pair it with the alarm the $100.00 a year alarm monitoring and unlimited camera subscription it is a good value!
I was hoping to see the Amcrest as well to see how it compared. I have one that I installed last year. At the time it was the only one that produced an ONVIF video stream so I could view the camera with BlueIris. Not sure why it was overlooked in this review.
Really good and insightful overview of what is on offer, thanks. However, as a tech novice regarding these devices I was also eager to understand what products required hard wiring or batteries or could handle both options. Thanks again for a great research tool!
Ultimate doorbell features but still not found. NO Cloud Poe Good camera no stretched fisheye crap. Aimable camera Onvif and good app for notification or HA integration. Electric relay for garage or door
It's not "Ultimate" without Arlo, which many reviewers select as the best video doorbell available. And it's the only doorbell that will work seamlessly with existing mechanical doorbell chimes.
Great Video! I have had the Nest Hello for about 3 years tied into my Google Home. I’ve really enjoyed it. When I’m at work I get instant notifications if someone’s at my front door or even if they’re dropping of packages. I was torn between Ring and Nest Hello when I was trying to decide. However it’s probably splitting hairs between your top 3.
The 115 degree heat last week plus the bell is west facing killed my third video doorbell in two years. Time to look for something that plastic pcp board will not warp from the heat.
monthly fees suck. Plus I don't want my camera footage leaving my house.. That's why I went with Unifi.. everything stays with me and the cameras and notifications are great. The doorbell does seem to get pretty warm though, but other than that, no complaints.
Correction at 6:05. "3D Motion Detection" uses radar from the doorbell to determine a person's position, then overlay their position & path on a satellite image. They don't use satellite imagery to locate people.
We had the eufy wired doorbell for a long while and the notifications weren’t showing up on our phones, so we decided to switch to the ring pro. The reason that we got the eufy doorbell is the free cloud storage, but we have a ring spotlight camera right above our ring pro that we bought the ring protect basic plan for
Got the Ring Pro on ebay for 100 bucks this last christmas season. It was as pain in the butt after initial set up. It crashed, it refused to work and it was constantly rebooting. it did this for about a week. Well, whatever it was doing, it's now stable and works fine. It looks good as far as the video goes, never tried to talk over it.
Wow, I just love this! Finally a video comparing kind of all of the video doorbells on the market. Sadly it’s clear to me that it’s not the time for me to get a video doorbell yet. I’m to picky so there was something I missed with every doorbell that made me think ’no not that one because…’
Very infomative video. The one that's missing IMHO is the DoorBird. It's pricey but well built hardware, and the nice thing is that it can be used without their (free) cloud service: you can pull the video feed with RTSP, and have the doorbell part work through a SIP telephone exchange like Asterisk. We're using a few of these in our properties, and we have fully integrated it into our home automation solution.
Just installed the Eufy Wired Doorbell today. Have 3 of the Eufy S40 Solar Cams on the way. So far I love the app and the quality of the doorbell cam. the fact i do not need to pay for a subscription is great to. If anyone is reading this I would highly recommend Eufy's newer products.
Debating on ordering the cordless eufy 2k doorbell. How do you like the doorbell? I'm also considering 2 of the S40 cameras. However, if snow, ice or shade block charger panel likely fucked. 🤔 Like to mount under gutter on soffit, no sun.
@@shanew7361 I love both of them. The S40 is top notch technology if you ask me. Trying to find a spot with full sun all day is not possible for me. Even with sun half of the day it does greatly reduce the amount of times I would have to charge plugging it in. I would guess I will have to charge by hand maybe 2-3 times a year. Regardless of snow and what ever else might block sun rays, I don't think you can go wrong getting this camera. I would not recommend hanging under the gutter instead hang it on the gutter. That's what I did
If you want a 24/7 surveillance video go with the Nest. If you want just surveillance of a certain area, go with the Ring. There was a shooting outside of my house where my Ring Pro managed to catch the vehicle through the 30-second camera snapshots but couldn't make out the license or the model of the car because it was at night. If I had gone with the Nest, it probably would've helped with the 24/7 video recording.
Very nice comparison. One thing that is probably lower-level consideration is mechanical/digital existing doorbells. Support for them and speed at which they ring is important for those of us that have them (I have one that plays music/whatever clips outside). Ring Pro 1 supports them but had a 2-3 second delay before the chime sounded but the Pro 2 is instant.
Great thorough video, I really appreciate the great detail you provided for each doorbell, some of which I have never heard of. I wish more gave the option to upload to an FTP server of an external hard drive.
Bought Nest doorbell 1 year ago and worked great for about 10 months, to include the capturing of approaching individuals from about 20-25 feet; however, it no longer can detect motion unless 5-7 feet away and I contacted tech support; we want through changes in the app and reset the unit; then they sent me replacement unit since within year warranty and the same thing; have to be about 5-7 feet or closer to trigger motion, and they now claim it can be my wifi, which there was no issues during first 10 mos; I saw online others experiencing same thing, and I’m thoroughly disappointed!!! Never again, and will switch to Ring Pro 2 Which I should have bought instead of fecal Nest doorbell
I got the wyze. I like it. But like you said the notifications are horrible. Notified 3 min later the person has already left. Wyze serves a purpose to allow entry level users. To push bigger companies to innovate and bring prices down.
couple years with the Nest Hello and it's still going strong... grandfathered the 24/7 recording plan as i prefer this to event-based recording (always a hit and miss)
Face recognition will be dope when they hook up with social media platforms and your smart phone tells you who the hell is that stranger doing the delivery or stealing a package at your door 😂😂
I purchased the Wyze doorbell and I am seriously considering replacing it. By the time you get the notification that someone is at your door, they're already gone. 50% - 60% of the times I try to check the live feed, it won't connect to my wi-fi. I have to restart it to get it to function. Worst of all, every day from 2pm until about 5pm, the sun shines directly on the doorbell, it overheats, and doesn't work at all. Wyze, as a company, needs to find a direction. One month they announce that they are coming out with outdoor wireless cameras, next month they've moved on to robot vacuums and the cameras are forgotten. The month after that they move on to fitness watches and the vacuums are forgotten. They need to find one thing that they are really good at and then get really great at it. Don't just half-ass a project then move on.
@@IgorAntarov seems that in the world, doesn't exist a SERIOUS device that do that. All s*** with battery and / or impossible integration with Home assistant
I have a Eufy 2k Batt doorbell and set the Alexa routine to play live feed on my Echo Show 5 when some one press the door bell.. it works when testing out on the Preview but when actual press on door bell doesn't. Not sure anyone faced the same issue
The unifi cameras (and doorbell) send motion snapshots to both your phone and apple watch if you have one of those. Edit: I just got my G4 pro doorbell and it's nice. 30fps playback is so much smoother than my Ring Pro was and image quality in day/night is close enough that I can't really tell much difference. Glad to save $50/year though with no subscription.
I think you need to check your connections in your house for your doorbell and get a more powerful amp because the G4 doorbell that I put in has none of those problems as in no audio delay none of that stuff I went above and beyond the power that it said it's required and it works flawlessly audio quality is very crisp and clear through talking I was so shocked how good it was none of that rattly stuff that you had
Great comparison review, but for me I would like to see how these work as a doorbell with chime options/costs and also can they automatically pop up on google home or Alexa displays and what features available on the displays. I know its odd and very 'old school', but I don't walk around with my phone in my hand all the time.
Hi Reed, thanks for the video! It's awesome as always. But do you mind adding Arlo and Blink as well? Seems those two brands are also worth to be rated.
Isn't it clear that best all-round doorbell here (and by best I'm referring to image quality both day and night, given that this seems to be the most crucial aspect) was the Ring Pro 2?
@@Mr.Torres831 I haven't bought yet actually, so let's go through it as we all have different interpretations. Two things first though: none of them are good enough quality really, given what you can achieve with even a cheap £150 Sansco 1080p 4-cam CCTV system from Amazon. But also, I was basing my opinion on the night-time quality mainly, because that's when I'm more likely to have someone come to the door who's not known, not easily-identifiable later (like a delivery driver would be, even from scant detail), or someone who's up to something dubious. *Wyze* - Daytime = Hardly any real detail on face, Night = About the same *Unify* - Daytime = Not enough contrast on face, Night = Next-to-no detail *Ring Pro 2* - Daytime = Not fantastic but definitely better detail/ contrast when subject comes close to cam, Night = Slightly speccly image but definitely more detail *Netatmo* - Daytime = Face too dark again, so although plenty of colour, not much detail, and overall not as crisp an image as the Ring, Night = Similar to the first two *Nest* - Daytime = not enough light/ detail on face, Night - Next to no detail on face. *Eufy* - Aha. I was judging by the brief clip shown here, but having just gone back and watched his dedicated review of that particular doorbell, I have to admit that it's pretty good. Better or worse than the Ring? Probably about even. Frankly, I would have like to have seen the same test done at a location which isn't enclosed like that, and where more natural light during the daytime or light from streetlamps might have helped. In the meantime I shall probably wait for something better to come to the market, as I'm slightly baffled as-to why mobile phones (with similar sized sensors) can give near-professional quality images/ video, yet dedicated security devices such as these can't get anywhere near.
Ive done a lot of research and ended up just going with a $20 kangaroo doorbell and then supplement it by adding a Reolink Argus PT wireless solar powered 1028 HD two way audio and night vision camera. Pan and Tilt, Motion security alerts, alarms etc. Great product for $140. Wireless WiFi connection and powered by a solar panel.
My Google nest doorbell camera constantly rings our physical chime in the house when the temperature outdoors gets lower than 35 degrees. We have to cut the power for a few months of the year so we can get some sleep. On the bright side my dog doesn't Care when the indoor bell chimes anymore, since it was a constant noise for several days before we finally cut the power.
This was a good review but my issue with all these youtube reviews is they do a great job covering the features but if you read through the reviews from online stores (ie: Amazon or BestBuy) features is not the major issue people have with these doorbells. 1) difficulty of installation (App simply won't connect to bell, or app won't work on certain OS) 2) Network connections (ie: won't connect to wifi if router has both 2.4 & 5.0 Ghz transmission) 3) Poor customer service (they don't stand by their product even if it is clearly their fault) 4) Not working as advertised (ie: does not always detect motion, doorbell does not always ring or notify when pressed) I've owned a half dozen of these over the years and my honest opinion, they ALL eventually fail either partially or completely within 1 or 2 years. So in short, caveat emptor: they are all about as reliable as a 1980s Fiat.
I’m using the Unifi G4 doorbell with Home Assistant. It integrates well and you can install it using HACS for the Unifi Protect. I have motion/doorbell alerts, you can get image previews in the notifications and live video feed in the dashboard using RTSP.
Thanks for the video. I love these thorough comparison videos that you and rob do. Would like to know how many of the doorbells support face recognition and Apple TV notifications. Face detection is the only missing piece of the puzzle in my setup, but I don’t even know if it’s worth it.
I know this is an older video but on the UniFi doorbell under the settings is distortion correction and if you turn that off you get a bigger view range but it will make the image fish eye.
I bought a couple of Amazon Echo show's for my mum and mother-in-law which work great. I paid a bit extra for a Ring Doorbell wired. As of writing this, it doesn't integrate with google home so google alerts when it's pressed. Also if you use an existing doorbell it disables the chime. The camera looks good, bummer it doesn't integrate with Google and disables the existing chime.
What video doorbell are you using? Also if you want to check out the full comparison article, here’s the link: smarthomesolver.com/reviews/best-smart-video-doorbells-2021-update/
I use a ring 3
I am glad you did an update. i was curious to see what you thought about the Unifi G4 door bell camera.
I have a Dream Machine Pro so I can go with the Unifi doorbell easy enough but I feel like I need to commit to their cameras as well then which are massively expensive.
Nice touch to quote Harvey Dent from one of my favorite movie trilogies! 👍
I have not yet switched to a video doorbell (and that's inspite of having several free ones sent over by companies that wanted to partner and integrate their products into our smart research platform). But that could be because I am picky about latency, no subscription fees, no being tied into any manufacturer's ecosystem etc.....and because I am able to replicate most of the features (except the chime) built into video doorbells with regular cameras from Reolink with Blue Iris or even Raspberry Pi with motioneye (and few Twillio and/or Sendgrid routines for notifications) . 🙂
Completely agree with your assessment though (especially for non-geeks like me) about Eufy for budget conscious consumers and the newer Ring Pro for people with extra budget (even though many of my friends are sick of the increasing latency with their older models - planned obsolescence in older models?).
Question: What is your thought about any theft deterrent features built into the doorbells you reviewed here? I know there was concern previously about some doorbells getting built in SD card storage to solve the missing 24/7 recording problem but that was defeated if the doorbell could be stolen relatively easily.
Great video but I am left wondering how the Arlo would have compared. Recently got a Ring Pro 2 and was in doubt between it and the Arlo.
Wow, this is the most comprehensive video doorbell comparison on TH-cam for sure. It’s obvious a huge amount of work went into it. Thanks you Reed!
Thanks Guy! It was a lot of work and I appreciate the nice comment!
Agreed. Excellent production, clips, sound, explaining and easy to understand. Here have 500.000 goldstars for a job well done 👍
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️✖️100.000
Thank you 😊
I bought the Eufy off of this and I can agree with every point
A comprehensive review indeed. This is how reviews should be done. Thank you!
Where’s the Vivint camera at though?
This is the second home in which th-cam.com/users/postUgkx0jZ_lGlDVJhDnmagEU8gn47cmfPNlLQU we've replaced our "regular" doorbell with a Ring video doorbell and we really enjoy it. It is very easy to install and it works very well, with a clear picture through the app and good in-home use (we added the chime, which is also easy to install and doesn't require another thought to use).
Coming back 3 years later, I have still yet to see a better review + comparison.
Showing the app and how it looks side by side against competition is extremely useful if not essential.
I appreciate your mention of the audio quality. For those of us with hearing impairments, even with hearing aids we sometimes cannot understand tiny tinny-sounding audio. It’s especially useful that you play the audio so we can judge it for ourselves. Thank you!
I have the UniFi Doorbell and I love it. The only con to me is lack of POE
I've had nothing but issues with mine. The UDMPRO consistently resets itself and loading into the live feed on my Pixel 4XL is unbearably slow. The other issue I have is that you cannot set a custom "doorbell" notification when the doorbell is pressed.
Hardly anyone has PoE ability at their doorbell haha
I have the ring pro 2 and the small picture on the echo show can be fixed simply by telling the echo show to zoom in,a feature I've not seen advertised anywhere(I found it by accident).The echo show remembers this setting until you power cycle it or tell it to zoom out.
Oh that's a good tip! Thanks Tom!
Have been using Eufy for 2 years now and love their system. Also have 2 of their cameras, all connected to their base station. Notifications are fast and reliable. Video quality is very high. Batteries last approx 6-7 months ( I live in Seattle. Gets cold in winter, but usually not freezing). Nice not to have to pay monthly fees and you can store a ton of video on their base station system.
Best security device. Ask your nosy neighbor They always know what’s going on
Facts lol 😂 And that would be my mother 🙄 yes she’s my neighbor so annoying.
@@marisolrivas777 well good thing is your mother can easily scare the robber and talk to him to death and he would run away from her.
We have a Wyze cam and your review is spot on. My notifications do show up quickly, though. An SD card option would be awesome. Still happy with it for the price.
All of the options are overwhelming!! Trying to find the right choice for my older parents. One that’s easy to operate
I have the Eufy and it’s great. Clear pics and you can even hear the wind blowing. Worth the money.
Awesome job Reed, such a detailed and helpful video! Eufy definitely does seem the best option at the more budget end of the market.
I am literally returning both my Eufy tomorrow because there is times I get notifications and then I go to see recording and nothing or there is times it goes hours without recording. Ever since the system update I have been having this problem. I updated it like about a couple weeks ago before the update it was great. I even got a replacement and same thing, so that lemme know it was something to do with the update.
You are not going to miss a knock on the door with all of those doorbells 😀
I've had ring doorbell for 6 months. I've missed 5 rings and motion so far.
I just purchased the Wyze doorbell for 2 reasons.
1: I like having multiple chimes in the home and I can choose a different sound for each doorbell.
2: I already have Wyze cams, Wyze plugs, Wyze thermostat, and Wyze lights. So it just made sense to stay with that ecosystem.
I don’t mind the delay because right now I have no delay and I have a second cam on my front porch anyway.
Wyze products are inexpensive and there is a reason. Wyze has gone downhill as a company. Their customer service is an exercise in frustration. The constant updates risk deteriorating the image quality and function of your older Wyze cameras. They don't support previous versions making all your original Wyze systems obsolete and virtually useless. AND $1.99 per camera per month adds up real fast/ plus a $60. annual fee for their home security Kit.
I’ve been using a UniFi setup for years for my home network and security cameras, so all I had to add was the doorbell since I had all the other necessary equipment. Only been using the doorbell for a month, but I have no complaints.
Terrific video for people to start looking into the different video doorbells available in today’s market. Easy to understand and comprehensive. Thank you!
I've watched several of these comparison videos and this is by far the most comprehensive when it comes to practical usage. Thank you - I've decided to blow my cash on the Ring P2, that is if they ever come back in stock.
Great video, Reed. I've been thinking about getting a video doorbell for a few months now and this video guide has led me in the right direction. When there are a few top options, that's when the hard part comes in. I'm considering Eufy, Nest, or Ring - but I'll also have to get Hoobs up and running to get it working within myHomeKit setup.
Did you ever get hoobs to work with your Homekit setup?
Would have loved to have seen the Logi Circle doorbell
Me too
I have it and it's fantastic.
Reed - you’re a good man! Love the comparison videos 👍🏻
Thanks Dan! Glad to hear you like them!
(Baby Yoda gets rejected as a person)
*Burglar: I have an idea (Proceed to order a Yoda mask for Halloween)*
The wired Ring doorbells (as well as wired Nest Hello doorbells) are great products. HOWEVER, they don't tell you upfront that these wired doorbells all have an internal non-user-serviceable battery. IF you will be using the doorbell with a mechanical chime, just be aware that at some point, the battery inside will fail.
The internal battery on these units are used to provide temporary voltage to the doorbell unit when a mechanical chime is used. When someone presses the doorbell button, power is temporarily routed away from the doorbell to the chime inside the house. The battery keeps the doorbell powered for the 1-2 seconds while this happens. Over time, this small battery will be unable to deal with the voltage drop and your doorbell will lose power and reboot itself. If you don't rely on a mechanical chime or if you use the Ring wireless chime, than it won't be an issue. If you do use a mechanical chime, depending on your environment (which includes usage rate, weather, temperature, etc.), the doorbell will stop function properly at some point in time. For most users, it seems to be somewhere between 1-3 years.
If you use a battery powered ring that can also be wired up to provide a trickle charge, would you have this same issue?
@@ilyas_khan I'm not sure if Ring has any battery powered products that can be wired to a mechanical door chime. The ones I'm aware of can be charged by the doorbell wiring but do not have the ability to ring a physical chime besides the wireless electronic chime that Ring sells (and this chime is powered by a standard indoor outlet). But in general, you won't have that issue as any supplemental power for a mechanical chime would come from the replaceable and rechargeable battery which is not present in the Ring Pro / Pro2.
Got it... If I want to rob a house wear a Yoda mask.
Reed, you have a VERY distinct walk. I don't need to see your face to know you're walking to the door. :)
Thank you for this awesome comparison video!
Glad you liked the video. I normally wouldn’t walk looking at the camera but I’m doing it so you can compare video quality of the doorbells. Getting footage of myself standing or walking in front of the doorbells is my least favorite thing.
I have the Wyze Doorbell on my side Door where it's a step up to get in so it's a narrow area and it works perfectly for my needs. I agree that I wish it had a SD card reader but for what I use it for, it's great.
On my front door I use the new Ring Wired doorbell and it can see my entire yard, I'm very impressed with the viewing angle and picture quality. The only thing I don't like is the monthly fees for the full functions for both devices.
That leaves my back deck and back door with a wireless doorbell/flood lamp to install and you've given some great suggestions.
You missed one critical test. Stick the doorbell in the freezer for 2 hours and see if it still works. My Ring 3 is useless for 3 months of the year as i live in Norway.
Ring 3 blir det vell ikke da😂😂
Are you using your Ring 3 hardwired or by battery?
Bru, I laughed when I read this!! LOL!!😂😂
Place a heat pad behind the ring setup if wired. It will be a makeshift build but a solution nevertheless. If you want to get fancy you can get an Arduino (or some type of IFTTT trigger) to program it to only kick off at certain low temps.
I have a heat pad warm up my lithium batteries at a certain temp automagically.
That is actually a brilliant idea.
I really like all your video's. You try and put humor in them, which I can appreciate. I hoped you would have done the Amcrest doorbell. I have the Ring Elite in my brand new house and love it. When you pair it with the alarm the $100.00 a year alarm monitoring and unlimited camera subscription it is a good value!
I was hoping to see the Amcrest as well to see how it compared. I have one that I installed last year. At the time it was the only one that produced an ONVIF video stream so I could view the camera with BlueIris. Not sure why it was overlooked in this review.
Really good and insightful overview of what is on offer, thanks. However, as a tech novice regarding these devices I was also eager to understand what products required hard wiring or batteries or could handle both options. Thanks again for a great research tool!
So what you are saying is aliens can break Into my house without my doorbell telling me
Ultimate doorbell features but still not found.
NO Cloud
Poe
Good camera no stretched fisheye crap.
Aimable camera
Onvif
and good app for notification or HA integration.
Electric relay for garage or door
It's not "Ultimate" without Arlo, which many reviewers select as the best video doorbell available. And it's the only doorbell that will work seamlessly with existing mechanical doorbell chimes.
Got the Eufy doorbell replaced with Ring. Eufy is way better. Even working in -29 temperature.
Yessss I literally just rewatched the 2020 video yesterday 😂😂 thanks for making a new one
Dang I was hoping for the Logitech doorbell review too
It confused me more than it helped me pick the right one lol
I don't believe you talked about storage and 24/7 footage support on the nest hello but all in all excellent review, thanks for putting this together!
Great Video! I have had the Nest Hello for about 3 years tied into my Google Home. I’ve really enjoyed it. When I’m at work I get instant notifications if someone’s at my front door or even if they’re dropping of packages. I was torn between Ring and Nest Hello when I was trying to decide. However it’s probably splitting hairs between your top 3.
The 115 degree heat last week plus the bell is west facing killed my third video doorbell in two years. Time to look for something that plastic pcp board will not warp from the heat.
My ring has lasted the az heat wave for the last 2 years
monthly fees suck. Plus I don't want my camera footage leaving my house.. That's why I went with Unifi.. everything stays with me and the cameras and notifications are great. The doorbell does seem to get pretty warm though, but other than that, no complaints.
You Either Die A Hero, Or You Live Long Enough To See Yourself Become The Villain. 😂😂
Correction at 6:05. "3D Motion Detection" uses radar from the doorbell to determine a person's position, then overlay their position & path on a satellite image. They don't use satellite imagery to locate people.
Oh okay I really thought they used live tracking satellites to monitor my home, with NORAD subscription fees.
We had the eufy wired doorbell for a long while and the notifications weren’t showing up on our phones, so we decided to switch to the ring pro. The reason that we got the eufy doorbell is the free cloud storage, but we have a ring spotlight camera right above our ring pro that we bought the ring protect basic plan for
Got the Ring Pro on ebay for 100 bucks this last christmas season. It was as pain in the butt after initial set up.
It crashed, it refused to work and it was constantly rebooting. it did this for about a week.
Well, whatever it was doing, it's now stable and works fine.
It looks good as far as the video goes, never tried to talk over it.
Wow, I just love this! Finally a video comparing kind of all of the video doorbells on the market.
Sadly it’s clear to me that it’s not the time for me to get a video doorbell yet. I’m to picky so there was something I missed with every doorbell that made me think ’no not that one because…’
Same. Blink drops a new one this month so interested in this one
Great video this helps out soo much!
Best part. “You either die a hero or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain” 🦇
Thanks for this video! Already in the UniFi ecosystem, so went with the G4 and it's been working great. Definitely worth the extra money
Great job comparing options! Ring Pro 2 has been doing a great job since it arrived on the scene this past April. Thanks!
I think you have a unique entrance with blown out lighting behind the pillars.
Very infomative video. The one that's missing IMHO is the DoorBird. It's pricey but well built hardware, and the nice thing is that it can be used without their (free) cloud service: you can pull the video feed with RTSP, and have the doorbell part work through a SIP telephone exchange like Asterisk. We're using a few of these in our properties, and we have fully integrated it into our home automation solution.
Just installed the Eufy Wired Doorbell today. Have 3 of the Eufy S40 Solar Cams on the way. So far I love the app and the quality of the doorbell cam. the fact i do not need to pay for a subscription is great to. If anyone is reading this I would highly recommend Eufy's newer products.
Debating on ordering the cordless eufy 2k doorbell. How do you like the doorbell? I'm also considering 2 of the S40 cameras. However, if snow, ice or shade block charger panel likely fucked. 🤔 Like to mount under gutter on soffit, no sun.
@@shanew7361 I love both of them. The S40 is top notch technology if you ask me. Trying to find a spot with full sun all day is not possible for me. Even with sun half of the day it does greatly reduce the amount of times I would have to charge plugging it in. I would guess I will have to charge by hand maybe 2-3 times a year. Regardless of snow and what ever else might block sun rays, I don't think you can go wrong getting this camera. I would not recommend hanging under the gutter instead hang it on the gutter. That's what I did
@@nateitscake88 Good to know! Thanks for the info!
If you want a 24/7 surveillance video go with the Nest. If you want just surveillance of a certain area, go with the Ring. There was a shooting outside of my house where my Ring Pro managed to catch the vehicle through the 30-second camera snapshots but couldn't make out the license or the model of the car because it was at night. If I had gone with the Nest, it probably would've helped with the 24/7 video recording.
I'm yoda... everyone felt that cuteness
Very nice comparison. One thing that is probably lower-level consideration is mechanical/digital existing doorbells. Support for them and speed at which they ring is important for those of us that have them (I have one that plays music/whatever clips outside).
Ring Pro 1 supports them but had a 2-3 second delay before the chime sounded but the Pro 2 is instant.
Great thorough video, I really appreciate the great detail you provided for each doorbell, some of which I have never heard of. I wish more gave the option to upload to an FTP server of an external hard drive.
I got the Ring about 6 months ago and a big fan
Bought Nest doorbell 1 year ago and worked great for about 10 months, to include the capturing of approaching individuals from about 20-25 feet; however, it no longer can detect motion unless 5-7 feet away and I contacted tech support; we want through changes in the app and reset the unit; then they sent me replacement unit since within year warranty and the same thing; have to be about 5-7 feet or closer to trigger motion, and they now claim it can be my wifi, which there was no issues during first 10 mos; I saw online others experiencing same thing, and I’m thoroughly disappointed!!! Never again, and will switch to Ring Pro 2
Which I should have bought instead of fecal Nest doorbell
Honestly vivint outshines all of these
Surprised to see their new doorbell camera pro not on the list
I got the wyze. I like it. But like you said the notifications are horrible. Notified 3 min later the person has already left.
Wyze serves a purpose to allow entry level users. To push bigger companies to innovate and bring prices down.
Lots of useful information. Well worth a sub.
couple years with the Nest Hello and it's still going strong... grandfathered the 24/7 recording plan as i prefer this to event-based recording (always a hit and miss)
I love the Vivint doorbell.
Face recognition will be dope when they hook up with social media platforms and your smart phone tells you who the hell is that stranger doing the delivery or stealing a package at your door 😂😂
Any thoughts on Arlo doorbell?
I purchased the Wyze doorbell and I am seriously considering replacing it. By the time you get the notification that someone is at your door, they're already gone. 50% - 60% of the times I try to check the live feed, it won't connect to my wi-fi. I have to restart it to get it to function. Worst of all, every day from 2pm until about 5pm, the sun shines directly on the doorbell, it overheats, and doesn't work at all. Wyze, as a company, needs to find a direction. One month they announce that they are coming out with outdoor wireless cameras, next month they've moved on to robot vacuums and the cameras are forgotten. The month after that they move on to fitness watches and the vacuums are forgotten. They need to find one thing that they are really good at and then get really great at it. Don't just half-ass a project then move on.
a doorbell without battery, with the best integration with home assistant, that save video when someone ring at door in the nvr or ftp, exist?
I have the same question
@@IgorAntarov seems that in the world, doesn't exist a SERIOUS device that do that. All s*** with battery and / or impossible integration with Home assistant
On your recommendation bought the eufy wireless doorbell and still going strong
Had the Arlo (junk) and went with the Nest Hello recently and have been satisfied to the point that I got the Nest Cam for the backyard
I have the UniFi G4 and several other cameras, as well as several WiFi APs.
Life savior for someone whom got left behind , VERY behind!
I have a Eufy 2k Batt doorbell and set the Alexa routine to play live feed on my Echo Show 5 when some one press the door bell.. it works when testing out on the Preview but when actual press on door bell doesn't. Not sure anyone faced the same issue
How do you like the doorbell?
The unifi cameras (and doorbell) send motion snapshots to both your phone and apple watch if you have one of those.
Edit: I just got my G4 pro doorbell and it's nice. 30fps playback is so much smoother than my Ring Pro was and image quality in day/night is close enough that I can't really tell much difference. Glad to save $50/year though with no subscription.
I think you need to check your connections in your house for your doorbell and get a more powerful amp because the G4 doorbell that I put in has none of those problems as in no audio delay none of that stuff I went above and beyond the power that it said it's required and it works flawlessly audio quality is very crisp and clear through talking I was so shocked how good it was none of that rattly stuff that you had
Nice video was about to make my own till I found your videos. Great work
This Is My Favorite Quote Of All Time: You Either Die A Hero Or Live Long Enough To See Yourself Become The Villain. 🦸♂️ or 🦹♂️
Great comparison review, but for me I would like to see how these work as a doorbell with chime options/costs and also can they automatically pop up on google home or Alexa displays and what features available on the displays. I know its odd and very 'old school', but I don't walk around with my phone in my hand all the time.
Great job, thanks for including the Unifi G4. Looks like that's what I'll be getting.
you totally rock! thanks for the comparisons!!
we got the Eufy battery with the chime plug in. We really like it for our needs, maybe eventually we may go with the wired one
Hi Reed, thanks for the video! It's awesome as always. But do you mind adding Arlo and Blink as well? Seems those two brands are also worth to be rated.
great video! very informative and your voice is very soothing
Wish you would have thrown an arlo in there as well. Other than that one thing this video is amazing, super in depth, detailed, and informative!
Isn't it clear that best all-round doorbell here (and by best I'm referring to image quality both day and night, given that this seems to be the most crucial aspect) was the Ring Pro 2?
@@Mr.Torres831 I haven't bought yet actually, so let's go through it as we all have different interpretations. Two things first though: none of them are good enough quality really, given what you can achieve with even a cheap £150 Sansco 1080p 4-cam CCTV system from Amazon. But also, I was basing my opinion on the night-time quality mainly, because that's when I'm more likely to have someone come to the door who's not known, not easily-identifiable later (like a delivery driver would be, even from scant detail), or someone who's up to something dubious.
*Wyze* - Daytime = Hardly any real detail on face, Night = About the same
*Unify* - Daytime = Not enough contrast on face, Night = Next-to-no detail
*Ring Pro 2* - Daytime = Not fantastic but definitely better detail/ contrast when subject comes close to cam, Night = Slightly speccly image but definitely more detail
*Netatmo* - Daytime = Face too dark again, so although plenty of colour, not much detail, and overall not as crisp an image as the Ring, Night = Similar to the first two
*Nest* - Daytime = not enough light/ detail on face, Night - Next to no detail on face.
*Eufy* - Aha. I was judging by the brief clip shown here, but having just gone back and watched his dedicated review of that particular doorbell, I have to admit that it's pretty good. Better or worse than the Ring? Probably about even.
Frankly, I would have like to have seen the same test done at a location which isn't enclosed like that, and where more natural light during the daytime or light from streetlamps might have helped. In the meantime I shall probably wait for something better to come to the market, as I'm slightly baffled as-to why mobile phones (with similar sized sensors) can give near-professional quality images/ video, yet dedicated security devices such as these can't get anywhere near.
Very good video thanks. It would have been nice to see the zoom and pause feature as well as picture quality during the day and night.
This was very informative thank you! And I especially enjoyed the funny bit at the end ☺️
No Arlo Video Doorbell? Don't hate on Arlo!
Ive done a lot of research and ended up just going with a $20 kangaroo doorbell and then supplement it by adding a Reolink Argus PT wireless solar powered 1028 HD two way audio and night vision camera. Pan and Tilt, Motion security alerts, alarms etc. Great product for $140. Wireless WiFi connection and powered by a solar panel.
My Google nest doorbell camera constantly rings our physical chime in the house when the temperature outdoors gets lower than 35 degrees. We have to cut the power for a few months of the year so we can get some sleep. On the bright side my dog doesn't Care when the indoor bell chimes anymore, since it was a constant noise for several days before we finally cut the power.
This was a good review but my issue with all these youtube reviews is they do a great job covering the features but if you read through the reviews from online stores (ie: Amazon or BestBuy) features is not the major issue people have with these doorbells.
1) difficulty of installation (App simply won't connect to bell, or app won't work on certain OS)
2) Network connections (ie: won't connect to wifi if router has both 2.4 & 5.0 Ghz transmission)
3) Poor customer service (they don't stand by their product even if it is clearly their fault)
4) Not working as advertised (ie: does not always detect motion, doorbell does not always ring or notify when pressed)
I've owned a half dozen of these over the years and my honest opinion, they ALL eventually fail either partially or completely within 1 or 2 years. So in short, caveat emptor: they are all about as reliable as a 1980s Fiat.
I wonder if the notification problem could've been better on a newer phone.
Which doorbell integrates best with Home Assistant, if any?
I’m using the Unifi G4 doorbell with Home Assistant. It integrates well and you can install it using HACS for the Unifi Protect. I have motion/doorbell alerts, you can get image previews in the notifications and live video feed in the dashboard using RTSP.
Nice job. Would have liked to have seen the new Lorex doorbell.
Great reviews. Wish it included all video doorbells at the time!
Thanks for the video. I love these thorough comparison videos that you and rob do. Would like to know how many of the doorbells support face recognition and Apple TV notifications.
Face detection is the only missing piece of the puzzle in my setup, but I don’t even know if it’s worth it.
Iii
Great video!
You need to have an ease of installation rating as well.
I know this is an older video but on the UniFi doorbell under the settings is distortion correction and if you turn that off you get a bigger view range but it will make the image fish eye.
I would like you to add the Lorex 2k doorbell.
What about Amcrest?
One of the few which allows RTSP and doesn't need subscription
Great comparison! I like the overall results of the Ring Pro 2. These days I tend to prefer the convenience of cloud-based solutions.
Thanks Nigel! I agree cloud-based solution are really convenient.
I bought a couple of Amazon Echo show's for my mum and mother-in-law which work great. I paid a bit extra for a Ring Doorbell wired. As of writing this, it doesn't integrate with google home so google alerts when it's pressed. Also if you use an existing doorbell it disables the chime. The camera looks good, bummer it doesn't integrate with Google and disables the existing chime.
Do any of these run entirely locally (ie zero cloud) and integrate with Home Assistant?