Can the word "Batao" be considered as a formal conversation anywhere Mr Raj Ji? Also, just see the person who's sitting in front of you. He's the former Corps Commander and the former IDS Chief with the rank of Lt Gen. If we just leave beside these formalities too, there's a way of talking to a person who's senior than you in terms of age also. Talking to an elder person, I Mean, an elementary school going kid also is very well aware of this thing. Though you haven't done this thing intentionally or you must be having this dialect but yeah, you can shift to "Bataiye or Batayein" at least while talking to a senior person than you. Regards. Jai Hind 🇮🇳
First reaction after seeing the Thumbnail was definitely I would like to watch this...but the way he was asking questions looks like he is talking to his fellow TH-camrs...I didn't want to watch this and saw a comment if anyone observed this. He definitely needs to get into the roots first.
Raj, PLEASE NOTE :- when a person is talking or replying to your questions that too a TOP Army Official, always make it a point to look into their eyes as a sign of respect. For Eg; - @ 46:00 and during many other time , you are simply looking elsewhere that too for more than 2 seconds, which will makes the person feel unheard. If it was someone else the interview would have ended then and there itself. I salute the army officer for his patience with you.
Sikhane a jate ho sare he has done something in his life ki usse itna bade officer ake mile who are u guys Or vaise he was writing the points in his pad that's he wasn't able to match eye contact or batao bhi respectful hi hota he and if The Satish sir didn't feel bad who you guys are guys chill and take good out of everything instead of just picking out odds.
@@MadhurAggarwal-j3s: He has done something in his life, to iska matlab ye ho gaya kya ki ye aadmi mahaan hai aur galti nhi kar sakta ?? Viewers dekh rahe h iska podcast to jaha lagega ki is bande ke actions ya wordings galat h, to log suggest & comment karenge hi .... Seekhne ki koi umar nahi hoti aur koi level nhi hota dost, mahaan wo hi hai jo hamesha seekhta rahe.
@@MadhurAggarwal-j3scut the bullshit bro., It his honor that Lt. Gen sir agreed to shoot the video , because he want to teach the youngsters especially defence aspirants. The way he asked is not acceptable. He should have corrected it, if he realised that , but he didn't that means he lacks that
में यही कमेंट करने के लिए कमेंट बॉक्स में आया था। इतने सम्मानित व्यक्ति से बेहद विनम्रतापूर्वक बात करनी चाहिए, ना की बताओ जैसी आदेशात्मक भाषा में। मिस्टर राज, इनसे सवाल पूछना कोई आपका हक नहीं है जो आप ऐसी भाषा का इस्तेमाल कर रहे हो। आपको सर बताइए जैसी विनम्र भाषा का उपयोग करना चाहिए।
Bro, he is a person who deserves upmost respect. We are because of the army. Please try to use kinder words( mujhea bato kya hota hai, try kya aap mujhea bata saktea ho, or else mujhea bataiea) Just a kind suggestion Much love
It’s really pleasure to hear Lt Gen Dua sir.. Mr Raj Shamani.. please call him respectfully.. while asking questions unlike “Batao”.. I feel Mr.Shamani not well prepared for this interview
I’m from uri born bought up here . And tht day was so horrible. Indian Army always be humble and fruitful to the people here as I schooled from Army School Uri which is in the brigade where the attack took place. I hope our pride our army live long❤
"Be a citizen worth dying for" Would never want anyone to die for me, but if they do, I should be damn well deserving of that sacrifice. The motivation we all need. Wise words!
@@prasanth5289 to his defence i would like to put this argument that when such a huge personality and respectable person is sitting in front of you, you sometimes fumble and also can't always think of the right word to speak at the time also he has to keep him engaged in the conversation and put the right type of question in a right way, continously listen to him and also think of what next question should be. I think we should cut him some slack it's not as easy at it looks. These minor mistakes can be foreshadowed by the fact that he invited a HERO on the podcast to spread awareness.
Absolutely right bro....I found him many times using this word while talking to every dignitary. This is the simple common sense in our society that even a school going kid know how to talk to their elders. This simple etiquette makes a great impact. And he should take care of it. This kind of word when comes during the conversation riuns the beauty of it. I was literally thinking of it to comment but you commented on this moral subject matter. Thanks for highlighting it...👍👍 Hope he will take care of it in his upcoming interviews.
GREAT JOB शहीद जवानोंकी विधवा पत्नी का पुनर्विवाह, सहीमे ये बहोत ही जटील समस्या है, उनकी पुरी निजी जीवन का सवाल है! आपने पहल कर उनके जीवन मे खुशियाली लायी, काबिल ए तारीफ काम है आपका! आपको शतशः नमन!
As an Army aspirant this podcast is very special for me. I'm preparing myself for army and my both elder brothers are serving in Indian army (Assam regiment and Naga regiment) and also my father was in Assam police. I watch every defence veteran podcast it's gives me goosebumps, motivation and many things to learn which can't be described in words. Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Can the word "Batao" be considered appropriate in a formal conversation, Mr. Raj? Please consider the person sitting in front of you. He is the former Corps Commander and the former IDS Chief, holding the rank of Lt. General. Beyond these formal titles, there is a proper way to speak to someone senior to you, both in rank and in age. Even an elementary school child understands the importance of speaking respectfully to elders. I understand that you may not have done this intentionally and that it might be part of your dialect. However, it is advisable to use "Bataiye" or "Batayein" when addressing someone senior. Regards.
कचरा सड़क पर फैंकने और दूसरों की सुविधा का ध्यान रखने वाली कितनी साधारण सी बात सेना के इतने बड़े अधिकारी को बोलनी पड़ी . वास्तव में ये बात बहुत ही महत्वपूर्ण है साधारण नहीं . सिर्फ उनका कहने का तरीका साधारण था . आपको हमारा प्रणाम जी
Please do some research before calling such senior officers. Calling a corps commander a commanding officer without realising the difference is ridiculous. Also it shall improve the questions you ask.
Nabi subadar chuni lal is from jammu and kashmir distt doda and i am also from their i know him very well.we all were proud from his bravery and boldness,I can't explain his word ❤❤❤
Am sure no one loves the country like him... A job superbly done for his motherland!!! Salutations to you Sir... People like you have ensured we are safe at home... Jai Hind Sir!!
Wonderful guest! Learnt a lot and kudos to your team, Raj! I'd love to see you bring on board someone who is a local leader - like a mayor of a city and explain how the local administration really works in 2023. I'm sure India has some incredible folks in this important band of leadership.
No kudos, it looks so bad and disrespectful to call such a leader ki aap Mujhe ‘batao’. I Mean what the heck…Raj Shamani thoda mumbai Vaali duniya se nikal ke learn things how to talk to people like him. You would say sir aap please yeah ‘bataye’
Can the word "Batao" be considered appropriate in a formal conversation, Mr. Raj? Please consider the person sitting in front of you. He is the former Corps Commander and the former IDS Chief, holding the rank of Lt. General. Beyond these formal titles, there is a proper way to speak to someone senior to you, both in rank and in age. Even an elementary school child understands the importance of speaking respectfully to elders. I understand that you may not have done this intentionally and that it might be part of your dialect. However, it is advisable to use "Bataiye" or "Batayein" when addressing someone senior. Regards.
Absolutely brilliant interview with Gen Sahab. I absolutely agree with Agniveer scheme Army & Govt has come out with. We need to develop confidence in Decision makers and stop doubting them All The Time. Let’s see the progress of the Agniveer scheme. If am sure the Govt will change it if it doesn’t work. 😊🙏🏽🇮🇳
Be a good citizen ; A citizen "worth dying for" Great words from a great person IDK how many people follow this thing of not spreading waste on roads but I follow it to the core Lets go ....... Incredible India 🇮🇳
Few correction- Final post of sepoy is SM Medical services for defance wards are upto age of 24 for boys and for girls until marriage. And also there are many perks for army wards like Army Welfare Education Society who runs many good schools and colleges for army wards, I am also in one of those college.
Salute u saab .. i was also in indian army before n its commando .. SFF special frontier force ...tibetan... Really feel good to see you saab jai hind saab
Bro I am commenting before seeing your podcast,but please bring Lt general Syed Ata Hasnain sir , because he has the mind blowing knowledge and what a clarity of thoughts about Military and International relations,so blease bring him.❤
Excellent session of podcast!! Very detailed interview. However Raj, it would have been highly appreciated by all if you could have denoted Lt. Gen. with "BATAIYE" instead of "BOLO". When a person of his stature is being interviewed we give supreme respect to that person and be most humble. Hitherto, please take care of it.
Regardless of the age of the army officer, it is our duty to show them the utmost respect. Before inviting an army officer to the podcast, it's essential to conduct thorough research and practice, as we feel regretful about the manner in which you are interacting with or questioning them.
Bro @Raj i loved the interview and gone thru the comments.....i am the son and grandson of Army personnel......Bro please keep that respect ki haa batao ki jagah bataiye ......when you are a "personality" who is in the public domain you must consider communication skills with each and every single personality ...agar koi actor ho alag agar koi kuchh to alag.....But the Army is in our blood.❤ But haa i can understand aap bhi dil se respect karte hain . Bas bolne ke tarike se log aapko judge karte hain .....But EOD it am blessed to listen Sir ❤😊
You are a God for the minute 20 approx.. Only for that.. And what you have achieved professionally in the Bharat Army.. God bless you always.. Jai hind.. Jai Bharat.. 🌹💐💯🕉️🙌🙏🇮🇳
Be a citizen worth dying for. I Was a soldier and when I used to come back from my field tenures, I used to see people misbehaving everywhere like throwing garbage, stealing electricity etc. I used to think, if these are the people for whom I may die, then my life is wasted.
Neither salaries nor perks, from any Offr ever ! Least, from Dy Army Cdr Lt Gen Satish Dua- renowned for his Uri OPs ! If there were 10 Qs u asked to such an Combat Operational Gen, I expected u to limit ur 8 Qs probing only d operational decision making, at Corps, Army HQ , Min of Def, PMO levels , but u switched on to newer aspects, every Q : things every aspirant kid checks from Public Domain, Army ads, missing out on Uri Ops done first time by person who seized opportunity from Sporting Def Min straightaway, during his visit there! Gen Hooda, Army Cdr d Boss in J & K couldn't have thru proper channe ls, by any Govt !😢 U wasted missing Uri OPs by switching to a new Q everytime- thus 1st & last Q OK from this matured living legend ! Any other Sr Def Offr would be cheesed off by every new topic Q - away from Uri OPs!
Yes you have to arrange these kind of podcasts which will inspire the youth jaihind vandemataram vande gou mataram jai hindu raashtra hara hara mahadev jai bhavaanee jai sri ram
Brilliant guest, the podcast had potential to be equally brilliant had the host maintained a respectful environment. Him engaging informally with such a distinguished person, was making me uncomfortable right through the screen. Or maybe we differ in a sense of showing respect idk but looking at the other comments many people felt the same . Kudos to the INDIAN ARMY, prayers for the families of the 18 jawans. Jai hind !!
An officer & a gentleman. One of India's finest. He probably did not get a first class education in terms of schooling. But he's done well in terms of remaining true to his convictions. We need people like this in all theatres of life who are gentle, but won't mince words. There is a certain kind of a diplomacy that is weak & is devoid of truth (and its associated conviction) that is seen prevalent among various sections of Indian society. Probably more among the youth. It is refreshing to see an old lion roar. A true son of India.
@15.00 will surely give you goosebumps, I thank Raj Sir to bring out such an incredible podcast which draws us close to reality… and we get an opportunity to hear about and appreciate the Real Heroes 🫡
He has commanded his Battalion as well as a Brigade in active militancy in Jammu & Kashmir on Line of Control, (LoC). As a Major General, he raised and commanded a new Counter Terrorism Division of Assam Rifles to coordinate operations in three states of the North East.
This is another great podcast. Some comments on Raj’s ‘Batao’ word shall be ignored as definitely he has utmost respect for our legendary Armed Hero. You can feel it when he talks. Sometimes we speak certain words as per our own habits/environment. Feeling of self respect is important. Surely he can correct it in next podcast. Very inspiring pod cast.
भारतीय जवान सिर्फ नेताओं और अधिकारियों के एक ऑर्डर पर हमेशा देश के लिए जान देने के लिए तैयार होते हैं और भारत का घटिया विपक्ष हमारे वीर जवानों से सबूत मांग रहे थे ।। नमन करते हैं वीर योद्धाओं को ।। जय श्री राम !! 🚩🚩
A fight against terrorism anywhere is a fight for safety and security everywhere. Global security is not a joke and countries which treat everyone else as collateral damage should not be regarded as leaders.. i for one am happy that India took a strong stand against terrorism.. bravo. Jai Hind 🙏 team is family and family is team.. this does not happen outside of the army. I trust the Indian Army and Indian leadership.. Bravo
Hi Raj bhai, This video is also amazing, and I look forward to hearing more from this podcast. Your content is great. Your guests are always so interesting. I love how you choose them. Love you 3000.
@Raj: Col Dua is such a senior person both in terms of professional seniority and age....I think he should be addressed with more respect...in place of "bataon" ,it should be "batayen"
I think you should pay Utmost respect to him while addressing him, lines like "Aap batao", "yeh batao" etc, sounds very rude and disrespect while addressing such an Honorable personality on your podcast. Apart from that, this is a Hit Podcast
An intresting interview on how to thwart by Indian Army th security threat from enemy of our country like th one happened in Uri & susquently Uri surgical strike operation by Indian Army... A brvo act on th part of our Indian Army & it's brave jawans... Hat's off... Jai Hind...
Having a legendary army officer on the podcast is a true privilege. You are doing a fantastic job, and the show keeps getting better with every episode! To question in the end ‘Do we need such guests?’ is to overlook the value they bring. They are a living legend, and their presence is a gift to the listeners. If someone chooses not to listen, that’s their prerogative, but let’s not doubt the worth of such esteemed guests. Keep up the great work!
I would like to suggest doctor as a choice of guest, because what a doctor goes through his entire life, the amount of sacrifies, pain and toughness, most people dont know about that. It would be interesting for the audiences to learn about hard work and perseverance from the experience of a doctor.
The way he corrects himself by saying correction...the way he says sorry this shows the respect which sir gave to raj but the behavior raj showed towards respect sir was very unprofessional !!
Bro my feedback as an old viewer: don’t cut people when they try to answer and 2nd thing when you ask someone to tell the answers to your questions, instead of using the word ‘batao’ kindly use ‘bataiye’ and ‘please’( with due respect)❤️
Raj, why did you delete my comment? I rightly said that you should've said "bataiye", instead of "batao".. You should acknowledge that and accept your mistake, rather than deleting my comment...
Thank u so much for calling this gentleman on your show , my brother has joined Indian army recently and we are always on the lookout for army man conversations these days ❤. Only one thing I found very ajeeb was the words put forward by u BATAO , . Kindly change it to Bataiye .. for any person whatsoever . Will definitely bring more respect amongst Indians .
I am a huge fan of Raj but I feel it's a wastage of time to invite one of the most senior Indian army official and asking him questions about salary structure in Indian army as these informations are already available in public domain, it's better to ask them questions about their rich experience in Indian army
Dear Raj , we would like to provide friendly advice to you , once you are doing broadcast don't look in down and write it's look like you are not interested in interview and his talking.
Lt. Gen. Satish Dua. Lieutenant General Satish Dua, PVSM, UYSM, SM, VSM retired as the Chief of Integrated Defence Staff. A counter-terrorism specialist, General Dua was the Corps Commander in Kashmir, who planned and executed the Surgical Strikes in response to the terror attack at Uri.
![กี่หมื่นฟ้า | Your Sky Series EP.1 [1/4]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vLGjxFL6U_I/mqdefault.jpg)
Can the word "Batao" be considered as a formal conversation anywhere Mr Raj Ji?
Also, just see the person who's sitting in front of you. He's the former Corps Commander and the former IDS Chief with the rank of Lt Gen. If we just leave beside these formalities too, there's a way of talking to a person who's senior than you in terms of age also. Talking to an elder person, I Mean, an elementary school going kid also is very well aware of this thing.
Though you haven't done this thing intentionally or you must be having this dialect but yeah, you can shift to "Bataiye or Batayein" at least while talking to a senior person than you.
Regards.
Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Ha bhai me bhi yahi soch raha tha pagal he kya ye
Yes absolutely usse time iss Shamani ne mood kharaab kar diya 😐
Ye 2 kaudike youtubers khud ko jyada bada samajhne lage hai 😡
I found btao bit dictative, better to use btaiye.
First reaction after seeing the Thumbnail was definitely I would like to watch this...but the way he was asking questions looks like he is talking to his fellow TH-camrs...I didn't want to watch this and saw a comment if anyone observed this. He definitely needs to get into the roots first.
Pehli bar comments krne walo ke liye respect badh gayi, and yes Give more respect to this Legend.
Raj, PLEASE NOTE :- when a person is talking or replying to your questions that too a TOP Army Official, always make it a point to look into their eyes as a sign of respect. For Eg; - @ 46:00 and during many other time , you are simply looking elsewhere that too for more than 2 seconds, which will makes the person feel unheard. If it was someone else the interview would have ended then and there itself. I salute the army officer for his patience with you.
I made a similar comment. Due respect should be given to guest and who is none other than a decorated General.
Obviously and asking questions in like alien manners sometimes, like ,batao, what bataiye hota h bhai
Sikhane a jate ho sare he has done something in his life ki usse itna bade officer ake mile who are u guys
Or vaise he was writing the points in his pad that's he wasn't able to match eye contact or batao bhi respectful hi hota he and if The Satish sir didn't feel bad who you guys are guys chill and take good out of everything instead of just picking out odds.
@@MadhurAggarwal-j3s: He has done something in his life, to iska matlab ye ho gaya kya ki ye aadmi mahaan hai aur galti nhi kar sakta ?? Viewers dekh rahe h iska podcast to jaha lagega ki is bande ke actions ya wordings galat h, to log suggest & comment karenge hi .... Seekhne ki koi umar nahi hoti aur koi level nhi hota dost, mahaan wo hi hai jo hamesha seekhta rahe.
@@MadhurAggarwal-j3scut the bullshit bro., It his honor that Lt. Gen sir agreed to shoot the video , because he want to teach the youngsters especially defence aspirants. The way he asked is not acceptable. He should have corrected it, if he realised that , but he didn't that means he lacks that
"Be a good citizen, a citizen worth dying for, jai hind".
This really hits me on the spot, the least we can do is be a good citizen.
🫡
में यही कमेंट करने के लिए कमेंट बॉक्स में आया था। इतने सम्मानित व्यक्ति से बेहद विनम्रतापूर्वक बात करनी चाहिए, ना की बताओ जैसी आदेशात्मक भाषा में। मिस्टर राज, इनसे सवाल पूछना कोई आपका हक नहीं है जो आप ऐसी भाषा का इस्तेमाल कर रहे हो। आपको सर बताइए जैसी विनम्र भाषा का उपयोग करना चाहिए।
Right mujhe v yeah accha nhi laga baaki overall video superb ❤❤
Mere muh ki bat chin Li apne bro
💯 sure
Wo mumbai ka hai yahi language hai waha ka😊
Bhai phir bhi tumhe army personnel ki respect karni चाहिए@@Mithubhai489
Bro, he is a person who deserves upmost respect. We are because of the army. Please try to use kinder words( mujhea bato kya hota hai, try kya aap mujhea bata saktea ho, or else mujhea bataiea)
Just a kind suggestion
Much love
right brother 👍
Completely agree
agreed 👍
Mujhe b Inka aise bolne ka tarika accha nhi lga
Agree
It’s really pleasure to hear Lt Gen Dua sir..
Mr Raj Shamani.. please call him respectfully.. while asking questions unlike “Batao”..
I feel Mr.Shamani not well prepared for this interview
+1. Great podcast channel, but Mr Raj needs to be aware of the person he is interviewing.
Yes he can use the words like 'kya aap bata sakte hai' or 'batayein' instead of batao
ये बताओ ये बताओ बोलते हो, ये “बताइए” बोलना चाहिए इतने वरिष्ठ आर्मी अफ़सर से जो इतने सम्माननीय हैं
True
exactly humee sunane mei itnaa bekar lg ra h tm ksee bol pa re ho samnee u r most experienced and u have millions subscribers
Sch me Yr kitna gnda sound kr rha h.. "बताओ"...
Isko chutiya bolne ka mann kr rha... Btaiye bolne me kya dikkat tha ek word ne video ka g maar diya
Yes he can be a better interviewer. Even questions can be better.
आज पहली बार सुनने मिला कि कोई हायर ऑफिसर अपनी सबोर्डिनेट का इतनी दिल से तारीफ किए। अच्छा लगा
मायाजाल ......
यह भक्त बनाने की टेक्नोलॉजी है जिसमे आप फँस चुके है या फसने वाले हों
I’m from uri born bought up here . And tht day was so horrible. Indian Army always be humble and fruitful to the people here as I schooled from Army School Uri which is in the brigade where the attack took place. I hope our pride our army live long❤
But Khangress and Dhurt Rathee says Surgical strike nahi hua tha 😂😂
@@ramachandra8155 they are all useless fellows. They only care about the Gandhi printed on notes not books!!
@@ramachandra8155 😂😂
"Be a citizen worth dying for"
Would never want anyone to die for me, but if they do, I should be damn well deserving of that sacrifice. The motivation we all need. Wise words!
Well said 👏
“Be a citizen worth fighting for” would it be a better way to put it ?
@@josh1harsh indeed
@@josh1harsh As he said War hai casualty hote hai
“Batao” nahi “Bataiye”, “aap bata skte hein?” . Unke “Age” aur “kaam” ka respect to do.
Yes, it is very awkward to ask batao
Complete unprofessional behaviour from Mr.Raj Shamani
Yes bro you are right
Haa sahi Mai batao nhi bataiye bolna chahiye
@@prasanth5289 to his defence i would like to put this argument that when such a huge personality and respectable person is sitting in front of you, you sometimes fumble and also can't always think of the right word to speak at the time also he has to keep him engaged in the conversation and put the right type of question in a right way, continously listen to him and also think of what next question should be. I think we should cut him some slack it's not as easy at it looks. These minor mistakes can be foreshadowed by the fact that he invited a HERO on the podcast to spread awareness.
We are proud to have such people for our country. Jai Hind❤
Absolutely right bro....I found him many times using this word while talking to every dignitary. This is the simple common sense in our society that even a school going kid know how to talk to their elders. This simple etiquette makes a great impact. And he should take care of it. This kind of word when comes during the conversation riuns the beauty of it. I was literally thinking of it to comment but you commented on this moral subject matter. Thanks for highlighting it...👍👍 Hope he will take care of it in his upcoming interviews.
GREAT JOB
शहीद जवानोंकी विधवा पत्नी का पुनर्विवाह, सहीमे ये बहोत ही जटील समस्या है, उनकी पुरी निजी जीवन का सवाल है! आपने पहल कर उनके जीवन मे खुशियाली लायी, काबिल ए तारीफ काम है आपका!
आपको शतशः नमन!
As an Army aspirant this podcast is very special for me. I'm preparing myself for army and my both elder brothers are serving in Indian army (Assam regiment and Naga regiment) and also my father was in Assam police. I watch every defence veteran podcast it's gives me goosebumps, motivation and many things to learn which can't be described in words. Jai Hind 🇮🇳
He won’t respond to this. This is exactly what I said.
Really appreciate your family services
🎉
Jai Hind🇮🇳
Last ka line dil chu gaya bhai "be a good citizen a citizen worth dying for " 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
We definitely want this type of podcasts. We love to listen brave veterans. Button --------
stay tuned for more such episodes🙌
@@rajshamani 🙌👍
@@rajshamanisir I loved your podcast but please don't say aur batao.....aur batayie sir this will suits best...!!
@@rajshamaniApni talking language thik kar
@@rajshamani Dear Novice Raj S,
Can the word "Batao" be considered appropriate in a formal conversation, Mr. Raj? Please consider the person sitting in front of you. He is the former Corps Commander and the former IDS Chief, holding the rank of Lt. General. Beyond these formal titles, there is a proper way to speak to someone senior to you, both in rank and in age. Even an elementary school child understands the importance of speaking respectfully to elders.
I understand that you may not have done this intentionally and that it might be part of your dialect. However, it is advisable to use "Bataiye" or "Batayein" when addressing someone senior.
Regards.
Brilliant message at the end...
"Be a citizen who is worth for which solider dies" ❤
कचरा सड़क पर फैंकने और दूसरों की सुविधा का ध्यान रखने वाली कितनी साधारण सी बात सेना के इतने बड़े अधिकारी को बोलनी पड़ी . वास्तव में ये बात बहुत ही महत्वपूर्ण है साधारण नहीं . सिर्फ उनका कहने का तरीका साधारण था . आपको हमारा प्रणाम जी
HI, kindly address the seniors as " bathaiye" instead of " bothao". Remember they are stalwarts. That makes this conversation lot better. Thanks
Please do some research before calling such senior officers. Calling a corps commander a commanding officer without realising the difference is ridiculous. Also it shall improve the questions you ask.
Chill atleast esne Bulaya toh sahi ... ajkal logo ko army ki padi kidhar hain.. we should appreciate usne ye initiative liya
Bilkul sahi hai itna senior offr ko aisa v puchna chahiye jab aap commanding offr the…. Like this
Sahi bola senior official se agar sab questions ke answer aye toh koi confusion nahin reheta
Truee
That was CORE COMMANDER not CORP COMMANDER
🙏”Be a Citizen that is worthy for a soldier to die for” Jai Bharat🇮🇳 Jai Sanatan.🙏😊
बहुत ही अच्छा मुलाकात थी हमारे जवनोंको कितानी मुश्किल झेलनी पडती है इसका एहेसास होता है. ऊन सभी के लिये मेरा सलाम.भारत माता की जय हो.
बहुत बेहतरीन तरीके से जर्नल सतीश दुआ साहब ने आसान शब्दों में आम नागरिकों को इस ऑपरेशन की विस्तार में बताया। धन्यवाद।
Give utmost respect to our armed forces personnels - whether a Jawan or an General.🙏SALAMI SHASTR 🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳 JAI BHARAT 🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳🙏🇮🇳
Love to hear from Army personals! Always proud of our Indian Army
Nabi subadar chuni lal is from jammu and kashmir distt doda and i am also from their i know him very well.we all were proud from his bravery and boldness,I can't explain his word ❤❤❤
I loved when dua sir said ..chunnilal mera saathi tha
im proud of myself, that the country where i live, is lead by you people.. hats off to you people sir., we all are grateful for u
Am sure no one loves the country like him... A job superbly done for his motherland!!! Salutations to you Sir... People like you have ensured we are safe at home... Jai Hind Sir!!
Wonderful guest! Learnt a lot and kudos to your team, Raj!
I'd love to see you bring on board someone who is a local leader - like a mayor of a city and explain how the local administration really works in 2023. I'm sure India has some incredible folks in this important band of leadership.
thank you bro, also suggestion noted🙌
@@rajshamaniRaj I would request U to also respond to comments which act as criticism. Thank You
No kudos, it looks so bad and disrespectful to call such a leader ki aap Mujhe ‘batao’. I
Mean what the heck…Raj Shamani thoda mumbai Vaali duniya se nikal ke learn things how to talk to people like him. You would say sir aap please yeah ‘bataye’
@@Midnight_Owl_Of_Bones yes, I also felt the same. The guest was more respectful however. hope he rectifies this issue in future episodes.
@@rajshamani Dear Novice Raj S,
Can the word "Batao" be considered appropriate in a formal conversation, Mr. Raj? Please consider the person sitting in front of you. He is the former Corps Commander and the former IDS Chief, holding the rank of Lt. General. Beyond these formal titles, there is a proper way to speak to someone senior to you, both in rank and in age. Even an elementary school child understands the importance of speaking respectfully to elders.
I understand that you may not have done this intentionally and that it might be part of your dialect. However, it is advisable to use "Bataiye" or "Batayein" when addressing someone senior.
Regards.
Absolutely brilliant interview with Gen Sahab. I absolutely agree with Agniveer scheme Army & Govt has come out with. We need to develop confidence in Decision makers and stop doubting them All The Time. Let’s see the progress of the Agniveer scheme. If am sure the Govt will change it if it doesn’t work. 😊🙏🏽🇮🇳
जयहिंद जय भारत खूप छान माहिती दिल्याबद्दल धन्यवाद सर.
❤ last few mins of this conversation. “Be a good citizen”is such a simple and a powerful message. Thank you for this podcast!!
Felt like a gaurdian giving me lessons of life.Salute you Sir and all the soldiers who gave their life and still serving . Jai Hind .
What an end to that lovely conversation.. BE a good citizen, citizen worth dying for !!♥
So nice to hear from an army officer.. proud and tears .love this
Be a good citizen ; A citizen "worth dying for"
Great words from a great person
IDK how many people follow this thing of not spreading waste on roads but I follow it to the core
Lets go ....... Incredible India 🇮🇳
Few correction- Final post of sepoy is SM
Medical services for defance wards are upto age of 24 for boys and for girls until marriage.
And also there are many perks for army wards like Army Welfare Education Society who runs many good schools and colleges for army wards, I am also in one of those college.
@Anonymous-mf3yf APS to bss thik hai but colleges bahut mstt mstt hai btw i am in best and oldest college run by AWES.
Ait pune
@@mohitparmar9288 chutiya college
Salute u saab .. i was also in indian army before n its commando .. SFF special frontier force ...tibetan... Really feel good to see you saab jai hind saab
Bro I am commenting before seeing your podcast,but please bring Lt general Syed Ata Hasnain sir , because he has the mind blowing knowledge and what a clarity of thoughts about Military and International relations,so blease bring him.❤
thanks for the guest suggestion bro, will try to bring him on the podcast🙌
Excellent session of podcast!! Very detailed interview. However Raj, it would have been highly appreciated by all if you could have denoted Lt. Gen. with "BATAIYE" instead of "BOLO". When a person of his stature is being interviewed we give supreme respect to that person and be most humble. Hitherto, please take care of it.
Wah aapkaname toh sunatha lekin dekhna aur sunnaneka bahut hi happiness generate hua .satish dua hindustan ke saput .salute to you .God bless you 🙏 ♥️
Yes good citizen is very important very discipline citizen.Super -Duper thoughts .
Yes want to see such guests .
One love INDIAN ARMY 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Regardless of the age of the army officer, it is our duty to show them the utmost respect. Before inviting an army officer to the podcast, it's essential to conduct thorough research and practice, as we feel regretful about the manner in which you are interacting with or questioning them.
Bro @Raj i loved the interview and gone thru the comments.....i am the son and grandson of Army personnel......Bro please keep that respect ki haa batao ki jagah bataiye ......when you are a "personality" who is in the public domain you must consider communication skills with each and every single personality ...agar koi actor ho alag agar koi kuchh to alag.....But the Army is in our blood.❤
But haa i can understand aap bhi dil se respect karte hain .
Bas bolne ke tarike se log aapko judge karte hain .....But EOD it am blessed to listen Sir ❤😊
You are a God for the minute 20 approx.. Only for that.. And what you have achieved professionally in the Bharat Army.. God bless you always.. Jai hind.. Jai Bharat.. 🌹💐💯🕉️🙌🙏🇮🇳
Be a citizen worth dying for. I Was a soldier and when I used to come back from my field tenures, I used to see people misbehaving everywhere like throwing garbage, stealing electricity etc. I used to think, if these are the people for whom I may die, then my life is wasted.
A suggestion Raj, please don't ask salaries. It's feels awkward.. The guests also don't look comfortable sharing the same..
Jai Hind
Absolutely. First, it's bad manners. Second, this info is available in public domain.
Neither salaries nor perks, from any Offr ever ! Least, from Dy Army Cdr Lt Gen Satish Dua- renowned for his Uri OPs !
If there were 10 Qs u asked to such an Combat Operational Gen, I expected u to limit ur 8 Qs probing only d operational decision making, at Corps, Army HQ , Min of Def, PMO levels , but u switched on to newer aspects, every Q : things every aspirant kid checks from Public Domain, Army ads, missing out on Uri Ops done first time by person who seized opportunity from Sporting Def Min straightaway, during his visit there! Gen Hooda, Army Cdr d Boss in J & K couldn't have thru proper channe ls, by any Govt !😢 U wasted missing Uri OPs by switching to a new Q everytime- thus 1st & last Q OK from this matured living legend ! Any other Sr Def Offr would be cheesed off by every new topic Q - away from Uri OPs!
I disagree . salary should be discussed .
Soldiers deshbhakti ke liye jate hai salary ke liye nahi
Ye anchor bahut jyada immature hai
Yes you have to arrange these kind of podcasts which will inspire the youth jaihind vandemataram vande gou mataram jai hindu raashtra hara hara mahadev jai bhavaanee jai sri ram
Brilliant guest, the podcast had potential to be equally brilliant had the host maintained a respectful environment. Him engaging informally with such a distinguished person, was making me uncomfortable right through the screen.
Or maybe we differ in a sense of showing respect idk but looking at the other comments many people felt the same .
Kudos to the INDIAN ARMY, prayers for the families of the 18 jawans. Jai hind !!
The last message is so powerful!!
An officer & a gentleman. One of India's finest. He probably did not get a first class education in terms of schooling. But he's done well in terms of remaining true to his convictions. We need people like this in all theatres of life who are gentle, but won't mince words. There is a certain kind of a diplomacy that is weak & is devoid of truth (and its associated conviction) that is seen prevalent among various sections of Indian society. Probably more among the youth. It is refreshing to see an old lion roar. A true son of India.
@15.00 will surely give you goosebumps, I thank Raj Sir to bring out such an incredible podcast which draws us close to reality… and we get an opportunity to hear about and appreciate the Real Heroes 🫡
"Be a citizen worth dying for" what a quote.
Really liked the choice of guest. Great podcast, keep it up. Jai hind.
thanks man🙌
He has commanded his Battalion as well as a Brigade in active militancy in Jammu & Kashmir on Line of Control, (LoC). As a Major General, he raised and commanded a new Counter Terrorism Division of Assam Rifles to coordinate operations in three states of the North East.
This is another great podcast.
Some comments on Raj’s ‘Batao’ word shall be ignored as definitely he has utmost respect for our legendary Armed Hero. You can feel it when he talks. Sometimes we speak certain words as per our own habits/environment. Feeling of self respect is important. Surely he can correct it in next podcast.
Very inspiring pod cast.
proud of MY INDIAN ARMY - WHAT AN OFFICER YOU HAVE CREATED....
Watched many videos but nobody explained the Hamas and Israel situation better than you. Thank you sir for this podcast and your services.❤
भारतीय जवान सिर्फ नेताओं और अधिकारियों के एक ऑर्डर पर हमेशा देश के लिए जान देने के लिए तैयार होते हैं और भारत का घटिया विपक्ष हमारे वीर जवानों से सबूत मांग रहे थे ।।
नमन करते हैं वीर योद्धाओं को ।।
जय श्री राम !!
🚩🚩
फार सुंदर पहिलयांदा अशा मोठ्या वयकतिची मुलाखत ऐकायला मिळाली धनयवाद 🙏🙏
the last line he said was EXTREMELY CRITICALLY IMPORTANT!!
"Be a citizen worth dying for" very deep and very crucial for all of us.
Keep bringing more such podcasts with defense personnel ❤
Really learning experience
more podcasts coming soon stay tuned🙌
@@rajshamani bhai sabko izzat chahiye tum ho ya main hu ya koi our aage se dhyan rakhna.
Feeling proud and fortunate to have such army officers 🙏💪
Jai hind bow down for indian army salute to indian army
Thank you very much for this need more
Love you and best wishes lt general Satish Dua ji
A fight against terrorism anywhere is a fight for safety and security everywhere. Global security is not a joke and countries which treat everyone else as collateral damage should not be regarded as leaders.. i for one am happy that India took a strong stand against terrorism.. bravo. Jai Hind 🙏 team is family and family is team.. this does not happen outside of the army. I trust the Indian Army and Indian leadership.. Bravo
Hi Raj bhai,
This video is also amazing, and I look forward to hearing more from this podcast. Your content is great. Your guests are always so interesting. I love how you choose them. Love you 3000.
Thank you kunal bhai🙌
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
@@rajshamanibhai do podcast with any ex R&AW agent ❤
@@rajshamanisab kuch thik tha lekin “batao"ye sahi nahi laga baki sab first class hai❤
Salute Indian Army ko. ❤ 🙏🏾
1:00:30 would make sure to be a good citizen! Jai Hind sir
Yes please lots and lots of these guest. Sir said the best thing that be a good citizen and be patriotic ❤️
@Raj: Col Dua is such a senior person both in terms of professional seniority and age....I think he should be addressed with more respect...in place of "bataon" ,it should be "batayen"
han yr, itne podcast kar liye ab tak yeh nahi pata inko
I think you should pay Utmost respect to him while addressing him, lines like "Aap batao", "yeh batao" etc, sounds very rude and disrespect while addressing such an Honorable personality on your podcast. Apart from that, this is a Hit Podcast
This is an amazingggggg conversation! Huge respect 🫡
An intresting interview on how to thwart by Indian Army th security threat from enemy of our country like th one happened in Uri & susquently Uri surgical strike operation by Indian Army...
A brvo act on th part of our Indian Army & it's brave jawans...
Hat's off...
Jai Hind...
Having a legendary army officer on the podcast is a true privilege.
You are doing a fantastic job, and the show keeps getting better with every episode!
To question in the end ‘Do we need such guests?’ is to overlook the value they bring. They are a living legend, and their presence is a gift to the listeners.
If someone chooses not to listen, that’s their prerogative, but let’s not doubt the worth of such esteemed guests.
Keep up the great work!
Thank you for bringing out the best personality to share his views 👍
yes this episode is very helpful for me and we definately need more such guest 🙂❤
stay tuned for more such episodes🙌
I would like to suggest doctor as a choice of guest, because what a doctor goes through his entire life, the amount of sacrifies, pain and toughness, most people dont know about that. It would be interesting for the audiences to learn about hard work and perseverance from the experience of a doctor.
The way he corrects himself by saying correction...the way he says sorry this shows the respect which sir gave to raj but the behavior raj showed towards respect sir was very unprofessional !!
Wahhhh... What an achievement....... Awesome.... Hat's off..... Indian army is best....
Bro my feedback as an old viewer: don’t cut people when they try to answer and 2nd thing when you ask someone to tell the answers to your questions, instead of using the word ‘batao’ kindly use ‘bataiye’ and ‘please’( with due respect)❤️
Absolutely reiterate same !
Agree totally.
Citizen worth deing for....what a statement 😢😢 total eye opener everyone should start being a good citizen...
Raj, why did you delete my comment?
I rightly said that you should've said "bataiye", instead of "batao"..
You should acknowledge that and accept your mistake, rather than deleting my comment...
Fat gayi rahegi ye tatti youtuber ki 😂
Jai hind, good morning. Excellent conversation buddy, whole nation needs to learn from our real heros. Jai hind
Thank u so much for calling this gentleman on your show , my brother has joined Indian army recently and we are always on the lookout for army man conversations these days ❤.
Only one thing I found very ajeeb was the words put forward by u BATAO , . Kindly change it to Bataiye .. for any person whatsoever . Will definitely bring more respect amongst Indians .
@Raj do use the world Bataiye instead of batao as the guest is a reapected person and senior... that just a good suggestion from my end.....thanx
"Be a citizen worth dying for" gave me goosebumps 🫡
I am a huge fan of Raj but I feel it's a wastage of time to invite one of the most senior Indian army official and asking him questions about salary structure in Indian army as these informations are already available in public domain, it's better to ask them questions about their rich experience in Indian army
Absolutely 💯 agreed
And they are also not comfortable to share salary and all that things... ask genuine question
Salary related questions should be avoided... But hierarchy in army and how long they usually serve in a position these things are good queries.
Agreed brother!! Give him pass he is uneducated!! 😂
Dear Raj , we would like to provide friendly advice to you , once you are doing broadcast don't look in down and write it's look like you are not interested in interview and his talking.
Lt. Gen. Satish Dua. Lieutenant General Satish Dua, PVSM, UYSM, SM, VSM retired as the Chief of Integrated Defence Staff. A counter-terrorism specialist, General Dua was the Corps Commander in Kashmir, who planned and executed the Surgical Strikes in response to the terror attack at Uri.
Insightful session for many students and working professional out there
With all due respect to LT GEN SATISH DUA JI, yet INDIA doesnot recognise Hamas as terrorist organisation.
Love your content, you bring for us raj.
thank you bro🙌
Raj Bhai A Positive Suggestion for You
Please don't Use This 'Batao' word especially for these legends like Satish Sir
Tatti Insaan hai ye youtuber
इतने बड़े अधिकारी है, सम्मान सूचक शब्द का उपयोग करना चाहिए, जैसे बताओ - बताईए सर हो सकता है,
Sach me behad hi acha tha episode and unki bate bahot kuch sikhne mila and soldier ke bare me aur bhi imp badi